MoonGolden's picture
Publish base-2026Q4.1-preview (results)
c4f750e verified
|
Raw History Blame Contribute Delete
10.2 kB
---
pretty_name: Cutaste — public baseline results (base-2026Q4.1-preview)
license: other
license_name: cc-by-4.0
license_link: LICENSE.md
task_categories:
- text-generation
language:
- en
tags:
- benchmark-results
- evaluation
- frontend
- web-design
- aesthetics
- coding-agents
size_categories:
- n<1K
dataset_info:
- config_name: default
features:
- name: task_id
dtype: string
- name: family_id
dtype: string
- name: category
dtype: string
- name: config
dtype: string
- name: model
dtype: string
- name: skills
sequence: string
- name: no_page
dtype: bool
- name: floor_pass
dtype: bool
- name: floor_failures
sequence: string
- name: flagged_for_review
sequence: string
- name: minor_findings
sequence: string
- name: requirements_met
dtype: int64
- name: requirements_violated
dtype: int64
- name: requirements_missing
dtype: int64
- name: requirements_undecided
dtype: int64
splits:
- name: test
num_bytes: 48205
num_examples: 120
download_size: 3921
dataset_size: 48205
- config_name: summary
features:
- name: config
dtype: string
- name: model
dtype: string
- name: skills
dtype: string
- name: floor_pass
dtype: string
- name: floor_pass_raw
dtype: string
- name: requirement_compliance
dtype: string
- name: requirement_compliance_raw
dtype: string
- name: judge_preferred
dtype: string
- name: judge_uncertain
dtype: string
splits:
- name: test
num_bytes: 756
num_examples: 3
download_size: 1439
dataset_size: 756
configs:
- config_name: default
data_files:
- split: test
path: data/test-*
- config_name: summary
data_files:
- split: test
path: data/summary/test-*
---
# Cutaste — public baseline results (base-2026Q4.1-preview)
**What this is.** The maintainer's results for the Cutaste public benchmark release `base-2026Q4.1-preview`: the
four-column report, one row per task × configuration, the judge admission records and the page sources the
public configurations generated. The tasks and the scoring rules are **not** here: they are in
[`Validflow/cutaste-base`](https://huggingface.co/datasets/Validflow/cutaste-base) under the same tag. These results belong to
the tasks whose `prereg.json` has hash `sha256:33e9f49571c49ff5562e66b387255e76592e72c06c5cb27942306a6fac55c9ef` (tasks publish commit `edff08e28e41`); the `cutaste` CLI
refuses results whose manifest names another prereg hash.
## Results (four separate columns — never added together)
| Config | Floor pass | Requirement compliance | Auto-judge: preferred | Auto-judge: uncertain |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| `codex-plain` | 90% (33/40 raw) | 70% (44/72 raw) | not shown | not shown |
| `codex-frontend-design` | 80% (30/40 raw) | 64% (40/72 raw) | not shown | not shown |
| `codex-impeccable` | 97% (37/40 raw) | 72% (45/72 raw) | not shown | not shown |
Percentages are weighted by the public category weights; raw counts in brackets. Intervals, sample sizes and
per-category numbers are in `report/report.json`.
- **Floor** = share of pages with no hard defect (blank page, horizontal scroll, clipped or overlapping text, broken images, unreadable main text, page errors).
- **Requirement compliance** = requirement points that could be decided automatically; points that need a vision checker are left out (`n/a`, counted per row as `requirements_undecided`).
- **Auto-judge** = pairwise preference of a model judge, *an estimate*, not human taste; disagreements between the two orders count as *uncertain*. Shown only when the judge snapshot was admitted (`judge/admission.json`).
- **External reference** (Code Arena) is not provided in this release.
## Folder structure
```text
README.md LICENSE.md NOTICE
data/test-00000-of-00001.parquet one row per task × configuration (config "default", split "test")
data/summary/test-00000-of-00001.parquet the table above (config "summary", split "test")
report/report.json the four-column report data (renders with `cutaste base report`)
report/results.json the maintainer's run results: cells (run and evaluation hashes), tallies, judge block
judge/admission.json admission of the judge snapshot: probes, intervals, admitted or not and why
judge/admission-pairs.json the probe pairs used for admission
pages/index.json one entry per configuration × task (see below)
pages/<config>/<family>/ the generated page sources (index.html, CSS, JS, images, fonts)
ledger/generated-content.json what the generated pages are and their licence
manifest.json pins the tasks' prereg hash and publish commit, plus every file's sha256
SHA256SUMS sha256 of every file
```
Versions are git tags: `base-2026Q4.1-preview` here pairs with the tag `base-2026Q4.1-preview` of `Validflow/cutaste-base`.
## Fields of `data/test-00000-of-00001.parquet`
| Field | Type | Meaning |
|---|---|---|
| `task_id` | string | Task card id (`tasks` table of `Validflow/cutaste-base`) |
| `family_id` | string | Task family id (`tasks/<family>/` in `Validflow/cutaste-base`, `pages/<config>/<family>/` here) |
| `category` | string | Page category |
| `config` | string | Configuration id (`standard/configs/<config>.json` in `Validflow/cutaste-base`) |
| `model` | string | Model of the configuration |
| `skills` | list of string | Skills of the configuration, `name@commit` |
| `no_page` | bool | The run produced no page (counts as a floor failure) |
| `floor_pass` | bool | No fatal and no severe floor-check failure |
| `floor_failures` | list of string | Ids of the fatal / severe floor checks that failed |
| `flagged_for_review` | list of string | Checks that could not decide and flagged the page |
| `minor_findings` | list of string | Minor checks that failed (recorded, not a floor failure) |
| `requirements_met` / `_violated` / `_missing` | int64 | Requirement points decided met / violated / missing |
| `requirements_undecided` | int64 | Requirement points no checker could decide here (`n/a`) |
## Fields of `data/summary/test-00000-of-00001.parquet`
| Field | Meaning |
|---|---|
| `config`, `model`, `skills` | The configuration |
| `floor_pass`, `floor_pass_raw` | Weighted floor pass share, and raw `k/n` |
| `requirement_compliance`, `requirement_compliance_raw` | Weighted share of decided points met, and raw `k/n` |
| `judge_preferred`, `judge_uncertain` | Auto-judge shares (or `not shown` when not admitted) |
## `report/report.json`
The report data the CLI renders: `configs` (harness, model, skills, sandbox), `categories` and their public
`weights`, and `sections[]` with four columns — `floor` and `compliance` (`rows[]` per config and viewport,
counts per category as `{k, n}`), `aesthetic` (`status` `admitted` with `rows[]` of preferred / uncertain
counts, or `not-admitted` with the reason) and `external`. `cutaste base report --format md|html` renders it with
intervals.
## `pages/`
`pages/index.json`: `release`, `scenario`, `perceptualHash` (`dhash-64`), `configs`, `tasks` and `cells[]`, one
per configuration × task:
| Field | Meaning |
|---|---|
| `configId`, `taskId`, `familyId`, `seed` | The cell |
| `status` | `page`, or `no-page` when the run produced none (then `files` is empty) |
| `entry` | Entry file of the page (`index.html`) |
| `files[]` | `path` (relative to `pages/<config>/<family>/`), `sha256`, `bytes` |
| `omitted[]` | Files of the run's output that are not shipped (tool state, non-page files), with the reason |
| `floor` | `pass` and the failed `fatal` / `severe` / `minor` check ids |
| `requirements[]` | `id`, `checker`, `result` (`met`, `violated`, `missing`, `n/a`) |
| `screenshots[]` | The maintainer's screenshots: `id`, `viewport`, `kind`, object `hash`, 64-bit perceptual hash `dhash` (the images themselves are not shipped) |
| `run`, `runCacheKey`, `eval`, `contractHash`, `fingerprint` | Hashes of the maintainer's run, evaluation, render contract and configuration |
Open `pages/<config>/<family>/index.html` in a browser to see a page (it needs no network). The `cutaste` CLI
re-renders these pages on your machine when you compare your own configuration (`cutaste base run`).
## How to read it
```python
from datasets import load_dataset
rows = load_dataset("Validflow/cutaste-base-results", split="test", revision="base-2026Q4.1-preview") # one row per task × config
summary = load_dataset("Validflow/cutaste-base-results", "summary", split="test", revision="base-2026Q4.1-preview")
```
```bash
huggingface-cli download Validflow/cutaste-base-results --repo-type dataset --revision base-2026Q4.1-preview --local-dir taste-base-results
cd taste-base-results && sha256sum -c SHA256SUMS
cutaste base report # with the cutaste CLI: downloads, verifies against your installed tasks, renders
```
## Licences
- Results, report, tables, judge records and the generated page sources: Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0).
- Results of other configurations are not collected here; a Hugging Face Benchmark registration (`eval.yaml`, results from model repos' `.eval_results/`) is planned.
- Font files and licence texts that an agent copied into a page folder are third-party material and keep their own licences (see `ledger/generated-content.json`).
- The tasks these results refer to: see `Validflow/cutaste-base` (WebGen-Bench, MIT).
## Limitations
Preview channel; 40 tasks; one judge family; no human labels yet; no detection of benchmark-targeted tuning.
Pages were generated without the Codex sandbox (isolated home and work directories instead); an agent could read files outside its work directory, and some copied font files from the generating machine into their pages (listed per page in `pages/index.json`, licences in `ledger/generated-content.json`).