ae0j's picture
Publish benchmark dataset v1.0.1
f7fc448 verified
|
Raw History Blame Contribute Delete
2.34 kB
# Codebook
The primary key is `product_id + criterion_id`. There is exactly one row for each product–criterion pair.
| Field | Type | Meaning |
|---|---|---|
| product_id | string | Stable product slug. |
| product | string | Product display name. |
| version | string | Application version tested for this assessment. |
| platform | string | Platform used for this assessment. |
| plan | string | Recorded plan or access state. |
| test_date | string | Month, date, or date range of the published test. |
| criterion_id | string | Stable criterion slug. |
| scenario | string | Human-readable criterion label. |
| expected_result | string | Behavior used to evaluate the criterion. |
| observed_result | string | Evidence-bounded observation. |
| coverage | enum | tested, feature_sought, or not_tested. |
| outcome_code | enum | pass, mixed, failed, not_found, or not_tested. |
| outcome | string | Human-readable outcome label. |
| evidence_url | URL/null | Primary published evidence for a tested result. |
| additional_evidence_url | URL/null | Optional second evidence item. |
| details_url | URL/null | Scoped review section used for a Not found result. |
| repeat_count | integer/null | Exact comparable count when systematically recorded; blank here means not normalized. |
| limitations | string | Assessment-specific scope and interpretation constraints. |
## Outcome definitions
- `pass` — **Passed:** The expected behavior worked in the published test.
- `mixed` — **Mixed:** The behavior worked only partly, varied across runs, or passed with an important limitation.
- `failed` — **Failed in our test:** The expected behavior did not work in the published test.
- `not_found` — **Not found:** We did not find the feature in the tested plan or flow. This does not mean it is missing from other plans or versions.
- `not_tested` — **Not tested:** We did not test this behavior strongly enough to publish a result.
## Coverage versus outcome
- `tested`: a behavioral result was published; outcome is pass, mixed, or failed.
- `feature_sought`: the feature was sought in the tested plan/flow but not found; outcome is not_found.
- `not_tested`: no normalized result is claimed; outcome is not_tested.
Do not convert `not_found` or `not_tested` to `failed`, and do not treat a blank `repeat_count` as one run.