The full dataset viewer is not available (click to read why). Only showing a preview of the rows.
Error code: DatasetGenerationError
Exception: CastError
Message: Couldn't cast
source_id: string
run_id: string
item: int64
split: string
disposition: string
transfer_check: string
verified_key_status: string
integrity_class: string
raw_key_letter: string
raw_key_meaning: string
blind_verdict: string
blind_verdict_letter: string
confidence: string
flags: list<item: string>
child 0, item: string
stem: string
options: struct<A: string, B: string, C: string>
child 0, A: string
child 1, B: string
child 2, C: string
mechanism: string
blind_derivation: string
labels: list<item: string>
child 0, item: string
scorable_on_verified_track: bool
source_index: int64
provenance: struct<run_id: string, derivation_file: string, disposition_file: string, disposition_file_sha256: s (... 6 chars omitted)
child 0, run_id: string
child 1, derivation_file: string
child 2, disposition_file: string
child 3, disposition_file_sha256: string
verified_key: struct<letter: string, meaning: string>
child 0, letter: string
child 1, meaning: string
package: string
raw_key: struct<cop_0based: int64, letter: string, meaning: string, explanation: null>
child 0, cop_0based: int64
child 1, letter: string
child 2, meaning: string
child 3, explanation: null
to
{'source_id': Value('string'), 'package': Value('string'), 'item': Value('int64'), 'source_index': Value('int64'), 'split': Value('string'), 'stem': Value('string'), 'options': {'A': Value('string'), 'B': Value('string'), 'C': Value('string')}, 'raw_key': {'cop_0based': Value('int64'), 'letter': Value('string'), 'meaning': Value('string'), 'explanation': Value('null')}, 'blind_verdict': Value('string'), 'blind_derivation': Value('string'), 'transfer_check': Value('string'), 'disposition': Value('string'), 'flags': List(Value('string')), 'verified_key': {'letter': Value('string'), 'meaning': Value('string')}, 'verified_key_status': Value('string'), 'integrity_class': Value('string'), 'scorable_on_verified_track': Value('bool'), 'provenance': {'run_id': Value('string'), 'derivation_file': Value('string'), 'disposition_file': Value('string'), 'disposition_file_sha256': Value('string')}, 'labels': List(Value('string'))}
because column names don't match
Traceback: Traceback (most recent call last):
File "/usr/local/lib/python3.14/site-packages/datasets/builder.py", line 1835, in _prepare_split_single
for key, table in generator:
^^^^^^^^^
File "/src/services/worker/src/worker/job_runners/config/parquet_and_info.py", line 621, in wrapped
for item in generator(*args, **kwargs):
~~~~~~~~~^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
File "/usr/local/lib/python3.14/site-packages/datasets/packaged_modules/json/json.py", line 373, in _generate_tables
self._cast_table(pa_table, json_field_paths=json_field_paths),
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
File "/usr/local/lib/python3.14/site-packages/datasets/packaged_modules/json/json.py", line 132, in _cast_table
pa_table = table_cast(pa_table, self.info.features.arrow_schema)
File "/usr/local/lib/python3.14/site-packages/datasets/table.py", line 2394, in table_cast
return cast_table_to_schema(table, schema)
File "/usr/local/lib/python3.14/site-packages/datasets/table.py", line 2322, in cast_table_to_schema
raise CastError(
...<3 lines>...
)
datasets.table.CastError: Couldn't cast
source_id: string
run_id: string
item: int64
split: string
disposition: string
transfer_check: string
verified_key_status: string
integrity_class: string
raw_key_letter: string
raw_key_meaning: string
blind_verdict: string
blind_verdict_letter: string
confidence: string
flags: list<item: string>
child 0, item: string
stem: string
options: struct<A: string, B: string, C: string>
child 0, A: string
child 1, B: string
child 2, C: string
mechanism: string
blind_derivation: string
labels: list<item: string>
child 0, item: string
scorable_on_verified_track: bool
source_index: int64
provenance: struct<run_id: string, derivation_file: string, disposition_file: string, disposition_file_sha256: s (... 6 chars omitted)
child 0, run_id: string
child 1, derivation_file: string
child 2, disposition_file: string
child 3, disposition_file_sha256: string
verified_key: struct<letter: string, meaning: string>
child 0, letter: string
child 1, meaning: string
package: string
raw_key: struct<cop_0based: int64, letter: string, meaning: string, explanation: null>
child 0, cop_0based: int64
child 1, letter: string
child 2, meaning: string
child 3, explanation: null
to
{'source_id': Value('string'), 'package': Value('string'), 'item': Value('int64'), 'source_index': Value('int64'), 'split': Value('string'), 'stem': Value('string'), 'options': {'A': Value('string'), 'B': Value('string'), 'C': Value('string')}, 'raw_key': {'cop_0based': Value('int64'), 'letter': Value('string'), 'meaning': Value('string'), 'explanation': Value('null')}, 'blind_verdict': Value('string'), 'blind_derivation': Value('string'), 'transfer_check': Value('string'), 'disposition': Value('string'), 'flags': List(Value('string')), 'verified_key': {'letter': Value('string'), 'meaning': Value('string')}, 'verified_key_status': Value('string'), 'integrity_class': Value('string'), 'scorable_on_verified_track': Value('bool'), 'provenance': {'run_id': Value('string'), 'derivation_file': Value('string'), 'disposition_file': Value('string'), 'disposition_file_sha256': Value('string')}, 'labels': List(Value('string'))}
because column names don't match
The above exception was the direct cause of the following exception:
Traceback (most recent call last):
File "/src/services/worker/src/worker/job_runners/config/parquet_and_info.py", line 1379, in compute_config_parquet_and_info_response
parquet_operations, partial, estimated_dataset_info = stream_convert_to_parquet(
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~^
builder, max_dataset_size_bytes=max_dataset_size_bytes
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
)
^
File "/src/services/worker/src/worker/job_runners/config/parquet_and_info.py", line 956, in stream_convert_to_parquet
builder._prepare_split(split_generator=splits_generators[split], file_format="parquet")
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
File "/usr/local/lib/python3.14/site-packages/datasets/builder.py", line 1702, in _prepare_split
for job_id, done, content in self._prepare_split_single(
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~^
gen_kwargs=gen_kwargs, job_id=job_id, **_prepare_split_args
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
):
^
File "/usr/local/lib/python3.14/site-packages/datasets/builder.py", line 1887, in _prepare_split_single
raise DatasetGenerationError("An error occurred while generating the dataset") from e
datasets.exceptions.DatasetGenerationError: An error occurred while generating the datasetNeed help to make the dataset viewer work? Make sure to review how to configure the dataset viewer, and open a discussion for direct support.
source_id string | package string | item int64 | source_index int64 | split string | stem string | options dict | raw_key dict | blind_verdict string | blind_derivation string | transfer_check string | disposition string | flags list | verified_key dict | verified_key_status string | integrity_class string | scorable_on_verified_track bool | provenance dict | labels list |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0001 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 1 | 1 | all | Do mitochondria play a role in remodelling lace plant leaves during programmed cell death?
Programmed cell death (PCD) is the regulated death of cells within an organism. The lace plant (Aponogeton madagascariensis) produces perforations in its leaves through PCD. The leaves of the plant consist of a latticework of lo... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 0,
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes",
"explanation": null
} | yes | Mitochondrial dynamics changed in a gradient across non-PCD, early-PCD and late-PCD cells alongside TUNEL fragmentation, and cyclosporine A treatment (blocking permeability transition pore formation) produced significantly fewer leaf perforations with mitochondria resembling non-PCD cells, showing mitochondria particip... | AGREE | DIRECT | [] | {
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes"
} | VERIFIED_AGREE | STANDARD | true | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0001-0050.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0002 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 2 | 2 | all | Landolt C and snellen e acuity: differences in strabismus amblyopia?
Assessment of visual acuity depends on the optotypes used for measurement. The ability to recognize different optotypes differs even if their critical details appear under the same visual angle. Since optotypes are evaluated on individuals with good ... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 1,
"letter": "B",
"meaning": "no",
"explanation": null
} | yes | Acuity differed between the charts in the strabismus amblyopia eyes: mean decimal Landolt C 0.14 vs Snellen E 0.16, a mean difference of 0.55 lines with Snellen E higher, the same 0.55-line difference as the whole group, though the differences were small. | DISAGREE | DISPUTED | [] | null | DISPUTED_UNRESOLVED | STANDARD | false | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0001-0050.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0003 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 3 | 3 | all | Syncope during bathing in infants, a pediatric form of water-induced urticaria?
Apparent life-threatening events in infants are a difficult and frequent problem in pediatric practice. The prognosis is uncertain because of risk of sudden infant death syndrome.
Eight infants aged 2 to 15 months were admitted during a p... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 0,
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes",
"explanation": null
} | maybe | The case series is only suggestive: 8 infants with bath-induced pallor and hypotonia, family dermographism, dermographism in the infants and raised blood histamine after a trial bath in the only 2 tested, with no controlled comparison, so a water-induced urticaria equivalent is plausible but not settled. | DISAGREE | DISPUTED | [] | null | DISPUTED_UNRESOLVED | STANDARD | false | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0001-0050.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0004 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 4 | 4 | all | Are the long-term results of the transanal pull-through equal to those of the transabdominal pull-through?
The transanal endorectal pull-through (TERPT) is becoming the most popular procedure in the treatment of Hirschsprung disease (HD), but overstretching of the anal sphincters remains a critical issue that may impa... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 1,
"letter": "B",
"meaning": "no",
"explanation": null
} | yes | Overall long-term outcome scores were similar between transanal (n=20) and transabdominal (n=21) pull-through, and reanalysis controlling for the age difference still showed no significant effect on long-term scoring, though continence favoured the abdominal group and stool pattern favoured the transanal group. | DISAGREE | DISPUTED | [] | null | DISPUTED_UNRESOLVED | STANDARD | false | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0001-0050.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0005 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 5 | 5 | all | Can tailored interventions increase mammography use among HMO women?
Telephone counseling and tailored print communications have emerged as promising methods for promoting mammography screening. However, there has been little research testing, within the same randomized field trial, of the efficacy of these two method... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 0,
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes",
"explanation": null
} | yes | In the randomized trial, tailored telephone counseling raised on-schedule mammography above usual care (71% vs 61%) significantly after the first year, and tailored print also exceeded usual care (67% vs 61%), with counseling most effective in women previously off-schedule. | AGREE | DIRECT | [] | {
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes"
} | VERIFIED_AGREE | STANDARD | true | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0001-0050.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0006 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 6 | 6 | all | Double balloon enteroscopy: is it efficacious and safe in a community setting?
From March 2007 to January 2011, 88 DBE procedures were performed on 66 patients. Indications included evaluation anemia/gastrointestinal bleed, small bowel IBD and dilation of strictures. Video-capsule endoscopy (VCE) was used prior to DBE... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 0,
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes",
"explanation": null
} | maybe | Community double balloon enteroscopy showed efficacy signals (therapy in 30.3% of patients, capsule findings confirmed in 74.4%), but the context reports no complication or safety outcomes at all, so safety in this setting is not settled by the evidence given. | DISAGREE | DISPUTED | [] | null | DISPUTED_UNRESOLVED | STANDARD | false | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0001-0050.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0007 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 7 | 7 | all | 30-Day and 1-year mortality in emergency general surgery laparotomies: an area of concern and need for improvement?
Emergency surgery is associated with poorer outcomes and higher mortality with recent studies suggesting the 30-day mortality to be 14-15%. The aim of this study was to analyse the 30-day mortality, age-... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 2,
"letter": "C",
"meaning": "maybe",
"explanation": null
} | yes | Mortality after emergency laparotomy was high: 30-day mortality 22% in patients over 70 vs 4% under 70 (p<0.001), and 1-year mortality 38% vs 15% (p<0.001), supporting that these outcomes are an area of concern needing improvement. | DISAGREE | DISPUTED | [] | null | DISPUTED_UNRESOLVED | STANDARD | false | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0001-0050.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0008 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 8 | 8 | all | Is adjustment for reporting heterogeneity necessary in sleep disorders?
Anchoring vignettes are brief texts describing a hypothetical character who illustrates a certain fixed level of a trait under evaluation. This research uses vignettes to elucidate factors associated with sleep disorders in adult Japanese before a... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 1,
"letter": "B",
"meaning": "no",
"explanation": null
} | yes | Adjusting for reporting heterogeneity with the CHOPIT model changed the findings: sex was no longer significantly associated with sleep problems while regular exercise became significant, showing the adjustment alters conclusions and is therefore needed. | DISAGREE | DISPUTED | [] | null | DISPUTED_UNRESOLVED | STANDARD | false | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0001-0050.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0009 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 9 | 9 | all | Do mutations causing low HDL-C promote increased carotid intima-media thickness?
Although observational data support an inverse relationship between high-density lipoprotein (HDL) cholesterol and coronary heart disease (CHD), genetic HDL deficiency states often do not correlate with premature CHD.
Carotid intima-medi... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 1,
"letter": "B",
"meaning": "no",
"explanation": null
} | no | Despite significantly lower HDL cholesterol (0.67 vs 1.58 mmol/l) and apoA-I in mutation carriers, carotid intima-media thickness was nearly identical to controls (0.66 vs 0.65), so the low-HDL mutations did not promote increased cIMT. | AGREE | DIRECT | [] | {
"letter": "B",
"meaning": "no"
} | VERIFIED_AGREE | STANDARD | true | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0001-0050.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0010 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 10 | 10 | all | A short stay or 23-hour ward in a general and academic children's hospital: are they effective?
We evaluated the usefulness of a short stay or 23-hour ward in a pediatric unit of a large teaching hospital, Westmead Hospital, and an academic Children's hospital, The New Children's Hospital, to determine if they are a u... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 0,
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes",
"explanation": null
} | yes | The short stay wards handled 10.3-14.7% of admissions with mean stays of 17.5-20.5 hours, only 4-6% needing an in-hospital bed, under 1% unscheduled return visits, no adverse events, high parental satisfaction and estimated savings of $0.5-2.3 million. | AGREE | DIRECT | [] | {
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes"
} | VERIFIED_AGREE | STANDARD | true | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0001-0050.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0011 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 11 | 11 | all | Did Chile's traffic law reform push police enforcement?
The objective of the current study is to determine to what extent the reduction of Chile's traffic fatalities and injuries during 2000-2012 was related to the police traffic enforcement increment registered after the introduction of its 2005 traffic law reform.
... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 0,
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes",
"explanation": null
} | yes | Instrumental-variable estimates showed the 2005 traffic law reform interacting with tickets per officer was significantly associated with an 8% decrease in traffic fatalities and 7% in severe injuries, and piecewise models for 2007-2012 attributed 59% fatality and 37% severe-injury reductions to police enforcement. | AGREE | DIRECT | [] | {
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes"
} | VERIFIED_AGREE | STANDARD | true | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0001-0050.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0012 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 12 | 12 | all | Therapeutic anticoagulation in the trauma patient: is it safe?
Trauma patients who require therapeutic anticoagulation pose a difficult treatment problem. The purpose of this study was to determine: (1) the incidence of complications using therapeutic anticoagulation in trauma patients, and (2) if any patient factors ... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 1,
"letter": "B",
"meaning": "no",
"explanation": null
} | no | Therapeutic anticoagulation in trauma patients carried a 21% complication rate (24/114), most commonly a sudden haemoglobin drop needing transfusion, and 5 patients died with significant haemorrhage attributed to anticoagulation in 3, which does not support it being safe. | AGREE | DIRECT | [] | {
"letter": "B",
"meaning": "no"
} | VERIFIED_AGREE | STANDARD | true | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0001-0050.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0013 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 13 | 13 | all | Differentiation of nonalcoholic from alcoholic steatohepatitis: are routine laboratory markers useful?
Specific markers for differentiation of nonalcoholic (NASH) from alcoholic steatohepatitis (ASH) are lacking. We investigated the role of routine laboratory parameters in distinguishing NASH from ASH.
Liver biopsies... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 0,
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes",
"explanation": null
} | yes | Routine markers separated NASH from ASH: MCV was elevated in 53% of ASH and normal in all NASH patients, AST/ALT ratio >1 was more common in ASH, and multivariate analysis using MCV, AST/ALT ratio and sex reached an aROC of 0.92. | AGREE | DIRECT | [] | {
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes"
} | VERIFIED_AGREE | STANDARD | true | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0001-0050.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0014 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 14 | 14 | all | Prompting Primary Care Providers about Increased Patient Risk As a Result of Family History: Does It Work?
Electronic health records have the potential to facilitate family history use by primary care physicians (PCPs) to provide personalized care. The objective of this study was to determine whether automated, at-the... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 1,
"letter": "B",
"meaning": "no",
"explanation": null
} | no | Although physicians reviewed or discussed family history at many prompted visits, there was no significant change in problem-summary documentation of risk status or in screening interventions for any of the 6 diseases, so the prompts did not change the target behaviour. | AGREE | DIRECT | [] | {
"letter": "B",
"meaning": "no"
} | VERIFIED_AGREE | STANDARD | true | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0001-0050.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0015 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 15 | 15 | all | Do emergency ultrasound fellowship programs impact emergency medicine residents' ultrasound education?
Recent years have seen a rapid proliferation of emergency ultrasound (EUS) programs in the United States. To date, there is no evidence supporting that EUS fellowships enhance residents' ultrasound (US) educational e... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 0,
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes",
"explanation": null
} | yes | Residents in programs with emergency ultrasound fellowships reported performing more scans than those without (P=.04), with significant differences in most bedside ultrasound applications and in barriers to ultrasound education (P<.05). | AGREE | DIRECT | [] | {
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes"
} | VERIFIED_AGREE | STANDARD | true | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0001-0050.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0016 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 16 | 16 | all | Patient-Controlled Therapy of Breathlessness in Palliative Care: A New Therapeutic Concept for Opioid Administration?
Breathlessness is one of the most distressing symptoms experienced by patients with advanced cancer and noncancer diagnoses alike. Often, severity of breathlessness increases quickly, calling for rapid... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 0,
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes",
"explanation": null
} | yes | In 18 inpatients with refractory breathlessness, patient-controlled intravenous opioid therapy significantly reduced breathlessness scores (median 5 at baseline to 4 on days 1 and 2, P<0.01) with stable physiology, and all 12 patients assessed on day 3 confirmed relief. | AGREE | DIRECT | [] | {
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes"
} | VERIFIED_AGREE | STANDARD | true | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0001-0050.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0017 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 17 | 17 | all | Is there still a need for living-related liver transplantation in children?
To assess and compare the value of split-liver transplantation (SLT) and living-related liver transplantation (LRT).
The concept of SLT results from the development of reduced-size transplantation. A further development of SLT, the in situ sp... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 0,
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes",
"explanation": null
} | maybe | Split-liver and living-related outcomes were close (patient survival 82% vs 88%, graft survival 76% vs 81%, liver function and complications not significantly different), yet primary nonfunction was much higher with split grafts (12% vs 2.3%), leaving whether living-related donation is still needed genuinely mixed. | DISAGREE | DISPUTED | [] | null | DISPUTED_UNRESOLVED | STANDARD | false | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0001-0050.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0018 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 18 | 18 | all | Do patterns of knowledge and attitudes exist among unvaccinated seniors?
To examine patterns of knowledge and attitudes among adults aged>65 years unvaccinated for influenza.
Surveyed Medicare beneficiaries in 5 areas; clustered unvaccinated seniors by their immunization related knowledge and attitudes.
Identified 4... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 0,
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes",
"explanation": null
} | yes | Clustering of unvaccinated seniors identified 4 distinct knowledge/attitude patterns (Potentials 45%, Fearful Uninformeds 9%, Doubters 27%, Misinformeds 19%) with differing prior vaccination rates, demonstrating that such patterns exist. | AGREE | DIRECT | [] | {
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes"
} | VERIFIED_AGREE | STANDARD | true | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0001-0050.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0019 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 19 | 19 | all | Is there a model to teach and practice retroperitoneoscopic nephrectomy?
Although the retroperitoneal approach has been the preferred choice for open urological procedures, retroperitoneoscopy is not the preferred approach for laparoscopy. This study aims to develop a training model for retroperitoneoscopy and to esta... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 0,
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes",
"explanation": null
} | yes | The porcine retroperitoneoscopic nephrectomy model simulated the whole procedure from creating the space to completing nephrectomy in 15 cases, with a statistically defined learning curve of eight cases (operative time, blood loss and peritoneal opening all improving significantly in the later group). | AGREE | DIRECT | [] | {
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes"
} | VERIFIED_AGREE | STANDARD | true | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0001-0050.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0020 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 20 | 20 | all | Cardiovascular risk in a rural adult West African population: is resting heart rate also relevant?
Elevated resting heart rate (RHR) is a neglected marker in cardiovascular risk factor studies of sub-Saharan African populations. This study aimed to determine the prevalence of elevated RHR and other risk factors for ca... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 0,
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes",
"explanation": null
} | yes | Resting heart rate was elevated (>90 bpm) in 19% of this rural Ghanaian population and was independently associated with casual high blood pressure (OR 1.94, 95% CI 1.15-3.26, p=0.013) as well as age, waist circumference and blood pressure, making it a relevant cardiovascular risk marker. | AGREE | DIRECT | [] | {
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes"
} | VERIFIED_AGREE | STANDARD | true | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0001-0050.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0021 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 21 | 21 | all | Israeli hospital preparedness for terrorism-related multiple casualty incidents: can the surge capacity and injury severity distribution be better predicted?
The incidence of large-scale urban attacks on civilian populations has significantly increased across the globe over the past decade. These incidents often resul... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 0,
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes",
"explanation": null
} | yes | Across 62 hospital multiple casualty incidents, mean arrivals were 20.8 per hospital, 95% of incidents brought 52 or fewer casualties, and 79.2% of casualties did not need immediate treatment, giving an empirical distribution that can predict surge load and severity better than the fixed 20%-of-beds assumption. | AGREE | DIRECT | [] | {
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes"
} | VERIFIED_AGREE | STANDARD | true | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0001-0050.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0022 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 22 | 22 | all | Acute respiratory distress syndrome in children with malignancy--can we predict outcome?
The purpose of this study was to delineate early respiratory predictors of mortality in children with hemato-oncology malignancy who developed acute respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS).
We conducted a retrospective chart review ... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 0,
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes",
"explanation": null
} | yes | In 17 children with malignancy and ARDS, peak inspiratory pressure, PEEP and ventilation index distinguished survivors from non-survivors by day 3, and oxygenation measures (PaO2/FIO2, P(A-a)O2) related significantly to outcome from day 8, so early respiratory variables do predict outcome, though the sample is small. | AGREE | DIRECT | [] | {
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes"
} | VERIFIED_AGREE | STANDARD | true | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0001-0050.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0023 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 23 | 23 | all | Secondhand smoke risk in infants discharged from an NICU: potential for significant health disparities?
Secondhand smoke exposure (SHSe) threatens fragile infants discharged from a neonatal intensive care unit (NICU). Smoking practices were examined in families with a high respiratory risk infant (born at very low bir... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 0,
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes",
"explanation": null
} | yes | Smoking-ban rates differed sharply by socioeconomic group: only 27.8% of families earning under $25,000 had total home and car bans vs almost 60% of higher-income families (p<.01), with significant differences by race/ethnicity and maternal depression, indicating disparity potential. | AGREE | DIRECT | [] | {
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes"
} | VERIFIED_AGREE | STANDARD | true | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0001-0050.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0024 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 24 | 24 | all | Do nomograms designed to predict biochemical recurrence (BCR) do a better job of predicting more clinically relevant prostate cancer outcomes than BCR?
To examine the ability of various postoperative nomograms to predict prostate cancer-specific mortality (PCSM) and to validate that they could predict aggressive bioch... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 0,
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes",
"explanation": null
} | yes | All four postoperative nomograms predicted prostate cancer-specific mortality and aggressive biochemical recurrence significantly, and every one predicted mortality more accurately than biochemical recurrence, with higher c-index values for the more clinically relevant outcome. | AGREE | DIRECT | [] | {
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes"
} | VERIFIED_AGREE | STANDARD | true | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0001-0050.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0025 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 25 | 25 | all | Are reports of mechanical dysfunction in chronic oro-facial pain related to somatisation?
(i) To examine the association between self-reported mechanical factors and chronic oro-facial pain. (ii) To test the hypothesis that this relationship could be explained by: (a) reporting of psychological factors, (b) common ass... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 0,
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes",
"explanation": null
} | yes | The mechanical factors associated with chronic oro-facial pain (teeth grinding OR 2.0, facial trauma OR 2.0) were also commonly associated with reporting other frequently unexplained syndromes (OR 1.8 and 2.1), linking these mechanical reports to a broader somatisation/reporting tendency. | AGREE | DIRECT | [] | {
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes"
} | VERIFIED_AGREE | STANDARD | true | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0001-0050.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0026 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 26 | 26 | all | Amblyopia: is visual loss permanent?
The records of 465 patients with an established diagnosis of age related macular degeneration who had attended a specialist macular clinic between 1990 and 1998 were scrutinised. A full clinical examination and standardised refraction had been carried out in 189 of these cases on a... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 1,
"letter": "B",
"meaning": "no",
"explanation": null
} | no | Visual loss in amblyopia was not permanent: 9 amblyopic eyes improved after the fellow eye was affected by macular degeneration, gaining a mean 3.3 lines of distance and 1.9 lines of near acuity by 12 months, and the improvement remained stable. | AGREE | DIRECT | [] | {
"letter": "B",
"meaning": "no"
} | VERIFIED_AGREE | STANDARD | true | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0001-0050.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0027 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 27 | 27 | all | Implementation of epidural analgesia for labor: is the standard of effective analgesia reachable in all women?
Social and cultural factors combined with little information may prevent the diffusion of epidural analgesia for pain relief during childbirth. The present study was launched contemporarily to the implementat... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 0,
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes",
"explanation": null
} | no | Effective analgesia was not reached in all women: a whole cluster of 226 patients only fell from VAS 8.5 to 4.1 after epidural, versus 0.76 in the larger cluster, and epidural use itself reached only 51% of labours by the final trimester, so the standard was not universally achieved. | DISAGREE | DISPUTED | [] | null | DISPUTED_UNRESOLVED | STANDARD | false | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0001-0050.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0028 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 28 | 28 | all | Does HER2 immunoreactivity provide prognostic information in locally advanced urothelial carcinoma patients receiving adjuvant M-VEC chemotherapy?
To evaluate the impact of HER2 immunoreactivity on clinical outcome in locally advanced urothelial carcinoma patients who received surgery alone, or methotrexate, vinblasti... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 2,
"letter": "C",
"meaning": "maybe",
"explanation": null
} | maybe | In patients receiving adjuvant M-VEC, HER2 immunoreactivity was significantly associated with progression-free and disease-specific survival on univariate analysis (p=0.03 and p=0.02) but not on multivariate analysis, so its prognostic value in that group is not independently established. | AGREE | DIRECT | [] | {
"letter": "C",
"meaning": "maybe"
} | VERIFIED_AGREE | STANDARD | true | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0001-0050.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0029 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 29 | 29 | all | Is halofantrine ototoxic?
Halofantrine is a newly developed antimalarial drug used for the treatment of Plasmodium falciparum malaria. The introduction of this drug has been delayed because of its possible side effects, and due to insufficient studies on adverse reactions in humans. There have been no studies investig... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 0,
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes",
"explanation": null
} | yes | Guinea pigs given a therapeutic halofantrine dose showed loss and distortion of inner hair cells and inner phalangeal cells plus loss of spiral ganglion cells, with worse inner and outer hair cell distortion at double dose and no changes in controls, demonstrating ototoxicity. | AGREE | DIRECT | [] | {
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes"
} | VERIFIED_AGREE | STANDARD | true | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0001-0050.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0030 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 30 | 30 | all | Visceral adipose tissue area measurement at a single level: can it represent visceral adipose tissue volume?
Measurement of visceral adipose tissue (VAT) needs to be accurate and sensitive to change for risk monitoring. The purpose of this study is to determine the CT slice location where VAT area can best reflect cha... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 0,
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes",
"explanation": null
} | yes | A single CT slice 3 cm above the lower margin of L3 gave the strongest correlations of visceral adipose tissue area with total VAT volume (r=0.853) and with body weight change (r=0.902), so a single-level area can represent VAT volume. | AGREE | DIRECT | [] | {
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes"
} | VERIFIED_AGREE | STANDARD | true | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0001-0050.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0031 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 31 | 31 | all | Necrotizing fasciitis: an indication for hyperbaric oxygenation therapy?
The accepted treatment protocol for necrotizing fasciitis (NF) consists of extensive surgery and wide spectrum antibiotics. Hyperbaric oxygenation (HBO) has been recommended as adjuvant therapy for NF, improving patient mortality and outcome. How... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 1,
"letter": "B",
"meaning": "no",
"explanation": null
} | no | Hyperbaric oxygenation did not help necrotizing fasciitis patients: mortality was 36% in the HBO group vs 25% without it, and the HBO group needed significantly more surgical debridements (3.3 vs 1.5 per patient), with no significant hospital-stay advantage. | AGREE | DIRECT | [] | {
"letter": "B",
"meaning": "no"
} | VERIFIED_AGREE | STANDARD | true | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0001-0050.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0032 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 32 | 32 | all | Is the Hawkins sign able to predict necrosis in fractures of the neck of the astragalus?
To assess if the Hawkins sign can predict whether or not astragalus fractures of the neck will develop avascular necrosis. It is also assessed whether the occurrence of this complication is related to the displacement of the fract... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 2,
"letter": "C",
"meaning": "maybe",
"explanation": null
} | yes | The Hawkins sign predicted avascular necrosis: none of the 12 cases with a positive sign developed necrosis while 4 cases with a negative sign did, a statistically significant association (P=.03), unlike fracture displacement, soft tissue injury or treatment delay. | DISAGREE | DISPUTED | [] | null | DISPUTED_UNRESOLVED | STANDARD | false | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0001-0050.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0033 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 33 | 33 | all | Is a mandatory general surgery rotation necessary in the surgical clerkship?
Changes in the spectrum of general surgery and the delivery of surgical care have placed the requirement for a mandatory general surgery rotation in the surgical clerkship in question.
We tested the hypothesis that equal mastery of surgical ... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 1,
"letter": "B",
"meaning": "no",
"explanation": null
} | no | Students in clerkships with and without a mandatory general surgery rotation showed no differences in written examination, OSCE, ward evaluations, self-assessment or satisfaction scores, and no concerns specific to the absence of general surgery were identified, so the rotation is not necessary for equal mastery. | AGREE | DIRECT | [] | {
"letter": "B",
"meaning": "no"
} | VERIFIED_AGREE | STANDARD | true | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0001-0050.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0034 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 34 | 34 | all | Is Acupuncture Efficacious for Treating Phonotraumatic Vocal Pathologies?
To investigate the effectiveness of acupuncture in treating phonotraumatic vocal fold lesions.STUDY DESIGN/
A total of 123 dysphonic individuals with benign vocal pathologies were recruited. They were given either genuine acupuncture (n = 40), ... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 0,
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes",
"explanation": null
} | yes | Only the genuine acupuncture group showed structural improvement, with a significant reduction in vocal fold lesion size, alongside improved maximum fundamental frequency and quality of life, supporting efficacy for phonotraumatic lesions even though sham treatment also improved function and quality of life. | AGREE | DIRECT | [] | {
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes"
} | VERIFIED_AGREE | STANDARD | true | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0001-0050.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0035 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 35 | 35 | all | Is aneurysm repair justified for the patients aged 80 or older after aneurysmal subarachnoid hemorrhage?
With the advancement of an aging society in the world, an increasing number of elderly patients have been hospitalized due to aneurysmal subarachnoid hemorrhage (aSAH). There is no study that compares the elderly c... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 0,
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes",
"explanation": null
} | yes | Patients aged 80 and older who received aneurysm repair (clipping or coiling) had significantly better clinical outcomes than those treated conservatively, despite no differences in admission WFNS grade or premorbid modified Rankin Scale, justifying repair in this age group. | AGREE | DIRECT | [] | {
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes"
} | VERIFIED_AGREE | STANDARD | true | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0001-0050.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0036 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 36 | 36 | all | Do general practice characteristics influence uptake of an information technology (IT) innovation in primary care?
Recent evaluations of IT innovations in primary care have highlighted variations between centres and practices in uptake and use. We evaluated whether structural characteristics of a general practice were... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 1,
"letter": "B",
"meaning": "no",
"explanation": null
} | yes | One general practice characteristic did influence uptake: the number of diabetes-educated staff was consistently associated with increased use of the web-based system by both nurses and GPs, even though list size, training status, GP numbers, age, sex mix and deprivation showed no association. | DISAGREE | DISPUTED | [] | null | DISPUTED_UNRESOLVED | STANDARD | false | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0001-0050.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0037 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 37 | 37 | all | Prognosis of well differentiated small hepatocellular carcinoma--is well differentiated hepatocellular carcinoma clinically early cancer?
The purpose of this study is to examine whether or not well differentiated (w-d) hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) is indeed clinically early cancer.
Seventy six patients with solitar... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 1,
"letter": "B",
"meaning": "no",
"explanation": null
} | no | Well differentiated small HCC behaved no better than less differentiated HCC: no significant differences in intrahepatic metastasis, portal vein invasion or disease-free survival, cancer cells infiltrated portal tracts, and recurrence patterns suggested minute foci were already present at surgery, so it is not clinical... | AGREE | DIRECT | [] | {
"letter": "B",
"meaning": "no"
} | VERIFIED_AGREE | STANDARD | true | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0001-0050.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0038 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 38 | 38 | all | Do follow-up recommendations for abnormal Papanicolaou smears influence patient adherence?
To compare adherence to follow-up recommendations for colposcopy or repeated Papanicolaou (Pap) smears for women with previously abnormal Pap smear results.
Retrospective cohort study.
Three northern California family planning... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 1,
"letter": "B",
"meaning": "no",
"explanation": null
} | no | Adherence did not differ significantly by the type of follow-up recommendation: adherence to colposcopy vs repeated Pap smear gave an odds ratio of 1.40 with a 95% confidence interval of 0.80-2.46 crossing 1, so the recommendation type did not influence adherence (reminders, insurance and clinic did). | AGREE | DIRECT | [] | {
"letter": "B",
"meaning": "no"
} | VERIFIED_AGREE | STANDARD | true | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0001-0050.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0039 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 39 | 39 | all | Biomolecular identification of allergenic pollen: a new perspective for aerobiological monitoring?
Accurate and updated information on airborne pollen in specific areas can help allergic patients. Current monitoring systems are based on a morphologic identification approach, a time-consuming method that may represent ... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 0,
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes",
"explanation": null
} | yes | The biomolecular approach proved feasible: modified extraction yielded good-quality pollen DNA, taxon-specific primers and TaqMan probes identified the selected allergenic taxa at the required level even from routine aerobiological tape, and preliminary quantification on grains and mixes succeeded. | AGREE | DIRECT | [] | {
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes"
} | VERIFIED_AGREE | STANDARD | true | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0001-0050.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0040 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 40 | 40 | all | Does diabetes mellitus influence the efficacy of FDG-PET in the diagnosis of cervical cancer?
Compared with computed tomography (CT) and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), positron emission tomography (PET) may have additional value in the assessment of primary and recurrent cervical cancer. However, the degree of tumo... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 1,
"letter": "B",
"meaning": "no",
"explanation": null
} | no | FDG-PET diagnostic power did not differ significantly between hyperglycaemic diabetic, euglycaemic diabetic and non-diabetic patients for either metastatic lesions (AUC 0.967/0.947/0.925, P>0.05) or primary tumours/local recurrence (AUC 0.950/0.938/0.979, P>0.05), so diabetes did not influence its efficacy. | AGREE | DIRECT | [] | {
"letter": "B",
"meaning": "no"
} | VERIFIED_AGREE | STANDARD | true | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0001-0050.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0041 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 41 | 41 | all | Biomechanical and wound healing characteristics of corneas after excimer laser keratorefractive surgery: is there a difference between advanced surface ablation and sub-Bowman's keratomileusis?
To describe the biomechanical and wound healing characteristics of corneas after excimer laser keratorefractive surgery.
His... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 0,
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes",
"explanation": null
} | yes | The two techniques differ in wound healing: advanced surface ablation cases can develop haze from a hypercellular fibrotic stromal scar, whereas sub-Bowman's keratomileusis, like LASIK, carries interface wound complication potential from a hypocellular primitive stromal scar, and their biomechanical safety ordering als... | AGREE | DIRECT | [] | {
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes"
} | VERIFIED_AGREE | STANDARD | true | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0001-0050.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0042 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 42 | 42 | all | Does radiotherapy of the primary rectal cancer affect prognosis after pelvic exenteration for recurrent rectal cancer?
Radiotherapy reduces local recurrence rates but is also capable of short- and long-term toxicity. It may also render treatment of local recurrence more challenging if it develops despite previous radi... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 0,
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes",
"explanation": null
} | yes | Prior radiotherapy for the primary rectal cancer worsened exenteration outcomes: more radical surgery (68% vs 44%), fewer clear margins (63% vs 87%), more complications per patient, and lower disease-free survival (p=0.022), with the survival difference persisting on multivariate analysis. | AGREE | DIRECT | [] | {
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes"
} | VERIFIED_AGREE | STANDARD | true | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0001-0050.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0043 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 43 | 43 | all | Can a practicing surgeon detect early lymphedema reliably?
Lymphedema may be identified by simpler circumference changes as compared with changes in limb volume.
Ninety breast cancer patients were prospectively enrolled in an academic trial, and seven upper extremity circumferences were measured quarterly for 3 years... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 2,
"letter": "C",
"meaning": "maybe",
"explanation": null
} | maybe | Detection performance depended heavily on the circumference criterion used, ranging from about half or fewer of the 39 lymphedema cases with 10% increase criteria to 91% sensitivity with a 5% increase at any site, and no specificity figures are given, so reliable surgeon detection is not settled by this context. | AGREE | DIRECT | [] | {
"letter": "C",
"meaning": "maybe"
} | VERIFIED_AGREE | STANDARD | true | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0001-0050.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0044 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 44 | 44 | all | Colorectal cancer with synchronous liver metastases: does global management at the same centre improve results?
Synchronous liver metastases (SLM) occur in 20% of colorectal cancers (CRC). Resection of SLM and CLC can be undertaken at different centres (separate management, SM) or at the same centre (global management... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 1,
"letter": "B",
"meaning": "no",
"explanation": null
} | no | Global management at one centre did not improve results: overall survival differences were non-significant (51% vs 67% at 3 years favouring separate management numerically) and 5-year disease-free survival was significantly higher with separate management (14% vs 11%, P=0.009). | AGREE | DIRECT | [] | {
"letter": "B",
"meaning": "no"
} | VERIFIED_AGREE | STANDARD | true | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0001-0050.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0045 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 45 | 45 | all | Is motion perception deficit in schizophrenia a consequence of eye-tracking abnormality?
Studies have shown that schizophrenia patients have motion perception deficit, which was thought to cause eye-tracking abnormality in schizophrenia. However, eye movement closely interacts with motion perception. The known eye-tra... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 0,
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes",
"explanation": null
} | yes | When stimulus duration was 150 msec, minimising eye tracking, patients' speed discrimination matched controls, but at 300 msec patients' thresholds were significantly higher (p=.03) and eye tracking benefited controls but not patients, indicating the motion perception deficit emerges with, and is a consequence of, abno... | AGREE | DIRECT | [] | {
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes"
} | VERIFIED_AGREE | STANDARD | true | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0001-0050.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0046 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 46 | 46 | all | Transgastric endoscopic splenectomy: is it possible?
We have previously reported the feasibility of diagnostic and therapeutic peritoneoscopy including liver biopsy, gastrojejunostomy, and tubal ligation by an oral transgastric approach. We present results of per-oral transgastric splenectomy in a porcine model. The g... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 0,
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes",
"explanation": null
} | yes | Per-oral transgastric splenectomy was completed in six pigs with no complications during gastric incision or peritoneal entry, very good visualisation, and successful ligation of the splenic vessels and mobilisation of the spleen using standard endoscopic accessories, showing it is technically possible. | AGREE | DIRECT | [] | {
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes"
} | VERIFIED_AGREE | STANDARD | true | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0001-0050.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0047 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 47 | 47 | all | It's Fournier's gangrene still dangerous?
Fournier's gangrene is known to have an impact in the morbidity and despite antibiotics and aggressive debridement, the mortality rate remains high.
To assess the morbidity and mortality in the treatment of Fournier's gangrene in our experience.
The medical records of 14 pat... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 0,
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes",
"explanation": null
} | yes | Fournier's gangrene remained dangerous in this series: 5 of 14 patients died despite antibiotics and aggressive debridement, a mortality of about 36%, with non-survivors showing markedly higher leukocyte counts. | AGREE | DIRECT | [] | {
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes"
} | VERIFIED_AGREE | STANDARD | true | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0001-0050.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0048 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 48 | 48 | all | Is it appropriate to implant kidneys from elderly donors in young recipients?
Kidneys from elderly donors tend to be implanted in recipients who are also elderly. We present the results obtained after 10 years of evolution on transplanting elderly kidneys into young recipients.
Ninety-one consecutive transplants are ... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 0,
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes",
"explanation": null
} | yes | Kidneys from donors over 60 implanted in recipients under 60 gave patient and graft survival at 1, 5 and 10 years statistically indistinguishable from matched younger-donor transplants (P=0.642 and P=0.980), supporting the practice, although creatinine values were significantly higher in the elderly-donor group. | AGREE | DIRECT | [] | {
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes"
} | VERIFIED_AGREE | STANDARD | true | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0001-0050.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0049 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 49 | 49 | all | Do provider service networks result in lower expenditures compared with HMOs or primary care case management in Florida's Medicaid program?
To determine the impact of Florida's Medicaid Demonstration 4 years post-implementation on per member per month (PMPM) Medicaid expenditures and whether receiving care through HMO... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 0,
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes",
"explanation": null
} | yes | In Florida's Medicaid Demonstration, provider service networks lowered per member per month expenditures by $7 more than HMOs among SSI enrollees, and the Demonstration overall produced much smaller expenditure growth ($40) than non-Demonstration counties ($186), with savings also seen in TANF enrollees. | AGREE | DIRECT | [] | {
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes"
} | VERIFIED_AGREE | STANDARD | true | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0001-0050.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0050 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 50 | 50 | all | Assessment of carotid artery stenosis before coronary artery bypass surgery. Is it always necessary?
Extracranial internal carotid artery stenosis is a risk factor for perioperative stroke in patients undergoing coronary artery bypass surgery (CAB). Although selective and non-selective methods of preoperative carotid ... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 1,
"letter": "B",
"meaning": "no",
"explanation": null
} | no | Assessment is not always necessary: every concomitant/staged carotid endarterectomy patient and every perioperative stroke patient was in the high-risk group (P=0.01), and significant stenosis prevalence was only 1.2% in the low-risk group vs 9.1% in the high-risk group, so selective screening of high-risk patients cap... | AGREE | DIRECT | [] | {
"letter": "B",
"meaning": "no"
} | VERIFIED_AGREE | STANDARD | true | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0001-0050.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0051 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 51 | 51 | all | Should direct mesocolon invasion be included in T4 for the staging of gastric cancer?
One of the sites most frequently invaded by gastric cancer is the mesocolon; however, the UICC does not mention this anatomical site as an adjacent structure involved in gastric cancer. The purpose of this study was to characterize a... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 2,
"letter": "C",
"meaning": "maybe",
"explanation": null
} | yes | Mesocolon invasion group had significantly worse curability, nodal metastasis, and survival than the T3 group, placing it beyond T3, while curative-resection survival was much better than incurable disease, consistent with T4 adjacent-structure invasion. | DISAGREE | DISPUTED | [] | null | DISPUTED_UNRESOLVED | STANDARD | false | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0051-0100.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0052 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 52 | 52 | all | Do Surrogates of Injury Severity Influence the Occurrence of Heterotopic Ossification in Fractures of the Acetabulum?
To determine the relationship between injury severity surrogates and other patient factors with the development and severity of heterotopic ossification (HO) following open reduction internal fixation ... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 2,
"letter": "C",
"meaning": "maybe",
"explanation": null
} | yes | ICU length of stay, non-ICU stay >10 days were significantly associated with heterotopic ossification in the multivariate model with large odds ratios (e.g. >6 days ICU OR 11.7, 95% CI 3.24-42.22), showing injury-severity surrogates influence HO occurrence. | DISAGREE | DISPUTED | [] | null | DISPUTED_UNRESOLVED | STANDARD | false | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0051-0100.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0053 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 53 | 53 | all | Does pretreatment with statins improve clinical outcome after stroke?
In primary and secondary prevention trials, statins have been shown to reduce the risk of stroke. In addition to lipid lowering, statins have a number of antiatherothrombotic and neuroprotective properties. In a preliminary observational study, we e... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 1,
"letter": "B",
"meaning": "no",
"explanation": null
} | maybe | Statin users had higher odds of early discharge home (adjusted OR 1.42) but the 95% CI 0.90-2.22 includes 1 and the effect was statistically nonsignificant, so benefit is neither proven nor excluded. | DISAGREE | DISPUTED | [] | null | DISPUTED_UNRESOLVED | STANDARD | false | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0051-0100.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0054 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 54 | 54 | all | Processing fluency effects: can the content and presentation of participant information sheets influence recruitment and participation for an antenatal intervention?
To assess the extent to which the title and font of participant information sheets (PISs) can influence pregnant women's and trainee midwives' perception... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 0,
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes",
"explanation": null
} | yes | Pregnant women rated the Double Awkward information sheet as significantly more complex than Double Fluent (p=.024) and Awkward Title-Fluent Font (p=.021), showing title/font presentation changes perceptions of the intervention. | AGREE | DIRECT | [] | {
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes"
} | VERIFIED_AGREE | STANDARD | true | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0051-0100.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0055 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 55 | 55 | all | Sternal fracture in growing children : A rare and often overlooked fracture?
Sternal fractures in childhood are rare. The aim of the study was to investigate the accident mechanism, the detection of radiological and sonographical criteria and consideration of associated injuries.
In the period from January 2010 to De... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 2,
"letter": "C",
"meaning": "maybe",
"explanation": null
} | yes | Only 4 children aged 5-14 with sternal fracture were treated over 2 years across inpatients and outpatients, confirming the fracture is rare in childhood. | DISAGREE | DISPUTED | [] | null | DISPUTED_UNRESOLVED | STANDARD | false | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0051-0100.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0056 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 56 | 56 | all | Is there a correlation between androgens and sexual desire in women?
For women, the correlation between circulating androgens and sexual desire is inconclusive. Substitution with androgens at physiological levels improves sexual function in women who experience decreased sexual desire and androgen deficiency from surg... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 0,
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes",
"explanation": null
} | yes | Sexual desire correlated overall with free testosterone and androstenedione in 560 women, with additional correlations for total testosterone and DHEAS in subgroups, demonstrating an androgen-desire correlation (though not for ADT-G). | AGREE | DIRECT | [] | {
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes"
} | VERIFIED_AGREE | STANDARD | true | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0051-0100.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0057 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 57 | 57 | all | Does immediate breast reconstruction compromise the delivery of adjuvant chemotherapy?
Immediate breast reconstruction (IBR) provides psychological benefit to many early breast cancer patients however concerns persist regarding its potential impact on chemotherapy delivery. We investigated the association between IBR,... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 1,
"letter": "B",
"meaning": "no",
"explanation": null
} | no | Complication rates were comparable (45.1% mastectomy alone vs 35.5% IBR, p=0.2) and there was no significant difference in median time to chemotherapy, so IBR did not compromise chemotherapy delivery. | AGREE | DIRECT | [] | {
"letter": "B",
"meaning": "no"
} | VERIFIED_AGREE | STANDARD | true | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0051-0100.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0058 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 58 | 58 | all | Human papillomavirus and pterygium. Is the virus a risk factor?
Pterygium is a disease of unknown origin and pathogenesis that might be vision threatening. It is characterised by a wing-like conjunctival overgrowth of the cornea. Several studies have investigated human papillomavirus (HPV) as a risk factor for the dev... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 2,
"letter": "C",
"meaning": "maybe",
"explanation": null
} | no | Only 4 of 90 analyzable pterygia harboured HPV and all four were DNA in-situ hybridisation negative, with all 20 normal conjunctival controls HPV negative, giving no support for HPV as a risk factor. | DISAGREE | DISPUTED | [] | null | DISPUTED_UNRESOLVED | STANDARD | false | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0051-0100.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0059 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 59 | 59 | all | Can PRISM predict length of PICU stay?
PRISM is claimed to score disease severity which has attributed an impact on length of PICU stay (LOS).
To determine the impact of PRISM on LOS, and evaluate an Artificial Neural Network's (ANN) performance to estimate LOS from PRISM item patterns.
Retrospectively we performed ... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 1,
"letter": "B",
"meaning": "no",
"explanation": null
} | no | Correlations between PRISM and PICU length of stay were very weak (Spearman 0.2, Pearson 0.08) and the neural network estimate correlated only 0.21-0.34 with actual stay, too weak to predict length of stay usefully despite significant p-values. | AGREE | DIRECT | [] | {
"letter": "B",
"meaning": "no"
} | VERIFIED_AGREE | STANDARD | true | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0051-0100.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0060 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 60 | 60 | all | Can predilatation in transcatheter aortic valve implantation be omitted?
The use of a balloon expandable stent valve includes balloon predilatation of the aortic stenosis before valve deployment. The aim of the study was to see whether or not balloon predilatation is necessary in transcatheter aortic valve replacement... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 0,
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes",
"explanation": null
} | yes | In 60 randomized TAVI patients there were no significant differences in early hemodynamic results or complication rates when balloon predilatation was omitted versus standard procedure, supporting omission. | AGREE | DIRECT | [] | {
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes"
} | VERIFIED_AGREE | STANDARD | true | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0051-0100.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0061 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 61 | 61 | all | Autoerotic asphyxiation: secret pleasure--lethal outcome?
Voluntary asphyxiation among children, preteens, and adolescents by hanging or other means of inducing hypoxia/anoxia to enhance sexual excitement is not uncommon and can lead to unintended death. This study addresses autoerotic asphyxiation (AEA) with the inte... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 0,
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes",
"explanation": null
} | yes | The review describes autoerotic asphyxiation as not uncommon in youth and states inept practitioners can miscalculate the peril and lose their gamble, i.e. the secret practice can end in unintended death. | AGREE | DIRECT | [] | {
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes"
} | VERIFIED_AGREE | STANDARD | true | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0051-0100.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0062 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 62 | 62 | all | Major depression and alcohol use disorder in adolescence: Does comorbidity lead to poorer outcomes of depression?
Comorbid major depression (MD) and alcohol use disorder (AUD), particularly in adolescents, have been shown to be associated with poorer subsequent MD outcomes.
Longitudinal data were used to model associ... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 1,
"letter": "B",
"meaning": "no",
"explanation": null
} | maybe | Comorbid depression/alcohol group had higher adult depression rates than alcohol-only (p<.05) and marginally higher than depression-only (p<.10), but after adjustment for gender, childhood behaviour problems and abuse the difference was no longer significant, leaving an independent effect undecided. | DISAGREE | DISPUTED | [] | null | DISPUTED_UNRESOLVED | STANDARD | false | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0051-0100.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0063 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 63 | 63 | all | Cold preparation use in young children after FDA warnings: do concerns still exist?
To characterize the use and delivery of cough and cold medicines in children younger than 6 presenting to an inner-city pediatric emergency department (PED) following 2007 FDA warnings.
A cross-sectional observational study was perfor... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 0,
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes",
"explanation": null
} | yes | After FDA warnings, 82% (53/65) of caregivers said they would still give cough/cold medicines to children under 6 and 72% of those dosed incorrectly, so safety concerns clearly persist. | AGREE | DIRECT | [] | {
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes"
} | VERIFIED_AGREE | STANDARD | true | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0051-0100.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0064 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 64 | 64 | all | Does a 4 diagram manual enable laypersons to operate the Laryngeal Mask Supreme®?
Bystander resuscitation plays an important role in lifesaving cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR). A significant reduction in the "no-flow-time", quantitatively better chest compressions and an improved quality of ventilation can be demo... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 0,
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes",
"explanation": null
} | yes | With only the 4-diagram manual, 96.7% of 150 laypersons inserted the Laryngeal Mask Supreme correctly and 79.3% achieved tidal volumes >150 ml within 2 minutes (mean 83.2s), showing the manual enables operation. | AGREE | DIRECT | [] | {
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes"
} | VERIFIED_AGREE | STANDARD | true | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0051-0100.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0065 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 65 | 65 | all | Can we measure mesopic pupil size with the cobalt blue light slit-lamp biomicroscopy method?
The aim of this work is to assess a previously described slit-lamp biomicroscopy-based method (SLBM) for measuring pupil diameter and compare it to Colvard infrared pupillometry (CIP).
Two examiners performed three repeated m... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 1,
"letter": "B",
"meaning": "no",
"explanation": null
} | no | Slit-lamp measurements were significantly smaller than Colvard pupillometry (5.81 vs 6.26 mm, p=0.01) with wide limits of agreement (~2 mm) and only 55-74% sensitivity for pupils >6 mm, so the method does not measure mesopic pupil size reliably. | AGREE | DIRECT | [] | {
"letter": "B",
"meaning": "no"
} | VERIFIED_AGREE | STANDARD | true | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0051-0100.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0066 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 66 | 66 | all | Should circumcision be performed in childhood?
To evaluate prepuce development and retractibility in a group of boys. To point out the value of circumcision and prepucial forced dilation during childhood.
Prepuce development and retractibility were evaluated in 400 boys ages between 0-16 year old.
In boys under 1 ye... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 1,
"letter": "B",
"meaning": "no",
"explanation": null
} | no | Prepuce retractibility developed naturally (type V in 5.5% under 1 year vs 82.3% of adolescents) and only 11 of 400 boys (2.7%) needed circumcision, so routine childhood circumcision is not supported. | AGREE | DIRECT | [] | {
"letter": "B",
"meaning": "no"
} | VERIFIED_AGREE | STANDARD | true | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0051-0100.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0067 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 67 | 67 | all | Does a colonoscopy after acute diverticulitis affect its management?
Medical records of 220 patients hospitalized for acute diverticulitis between June 1, 2002 and September 1, 2009 were reviewed. Acute diverticulitis was diagnosed by clinical criteria and characteristic CT findings. Fifteen patients were excluded eit... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 1,
"letter": "B",
"meaning": "no",
"explanation": null
} | no | Colonoscopy after acute diverticulitis found no malignancy and no new or different diagnosis, and survival did not differ with or without colonoscopy (P=0.62), so it did not affect management. | AGREE | DIRECT | [] | {
"letter": "B",
"meaning": "no"
} | VERIFIED_AGREE | STANDARD | true | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0051-0100.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0068 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 68 | 68 | all | Do instrumental activities of daily living predict dementia at 1- and 2-year follow-up?
To investigate whether problems in instrumental activities of daily living (IADL) can add to conventionally used clinical measurements in helping to predict a diagnosis of dementia at 1- and 2-year follow-up.
Multicenter prospecti... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 0,
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes",
"explanation": null
} | yes | Baseline IADL disability predicted dementia beyond conventional measures at 1 year (OR 2.20, 95% CI 1.51-3.13) and 2 years (OR 2.11, 95% CI 1.33-3.33), with higher conversion rates (24.4% vs 16.7%). | AGREE | DIRECT | [] | {
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes"
} | VERIFIED_AGREE | STANDARD | true | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0051-0100.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0069 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 69 | 69 | all | Does the Simultaneous Use of a Neuroendoscope Influence the Incidence of Ventriculoperitoneal Shunt Infection?
The relationship between the use of an endoscope during ventriculoperitoneal shunt (VPS) procedures and infection remains poorly defined. In this study, we sought to analyze whether the simultaneous use of an... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 1,
"letter": "B",
"meaning": "no",
"explanation": null
} | no | Shunt infection rates did not differ with versus without endoscope use overall (22.4% vs 18%, P=0.449) or in first-time (P=0.27) and revision (P=0.977) subgroups, so endoscope use does not influence infection incidence. | AGREE | DIRECT | [] | {
"letter": "B",
"meaning": "no"
} | VERIFIED_AGREE | STANDARD | true | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0051-0100.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0070 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 70 | 70 | all | Body perception: do parents, their children, and their children's physicians perceive body image differently?
To compare children's, parents' and physicians' perceptions of children's body size.
We administered a structured questionnaire of body size perception using a descriptive Likert scale keyed to body image fig... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 0,
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes",
"explanation": null
} | yes | Underestimation differed by rater: parents underestimated body size in 44-47%, children in 40-43%, while physicians had more correct estimates though still underestimating 33%, showing the three groups perceive body image differently. | AGREE | DIRECT | [] | {
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes"
} | VERIFIED_AGREE | STANDARD | true | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0051-0100.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0071 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 71 | 71 | all | Is a specialised training of phonological awareness indicated in every preschool child?
In a prospective study 218 preschool children were enrolled (stratified in 2 training programs, one specialized for phonologic awareness in order to prevent dyslexia, the other consisting in training of general perception) during t... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 2,
"letter": "C",
"meaning": "maybe",
"explanation": null
} | no | In the whole group of 218 preschool children there was only a slight writing difference between trainings; only children with hearing loss or middle-ear findings profited most in reading, so specialised phonological training is not indicated for every child. | DISAGREE | DISPUTED | [] | null | DISPUTED_UNRESOLVED | STANDARD | false | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0051-0100.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0072 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 72 | 72 | all | Is there any relationship between streptococcal infection and multiple sclerosis?
Multiple sclerosis (MS) is an immune-mediated inflammatory demyelinating disease of uncertain etiology. Although the mechanisms of inducting autoimmunity by some of the infectious agents have been investigated, there is not yet enough re... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 0,
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes",
"explanation": null
} | maybe | Anti-DNase B was significantly higher in MS patients than controls (p<0.001) but antistreptolysin O levels were similar in both small groups (n=21 each), a mixed single-marker signal that does not settle a streptococcal-MS relationship. | DISAGREE | DISPUTED | [] | null | DISPUTED_UNRESOLVED | STANDARD | false | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0051-0100.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0073 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 73 | 73 | all | Is the combination with 2-methoxyestradiol able to reduce the dosages of chemotherapeutices in the treatment of human ovarian cancer?
The endogenous estradiol metabolite, 2-methoxyestradiol (2ME), has been shown to be a potent inhibitor of cell growth and a strong anti-angiogenic substance. We investigated for the fir... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 0,
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes",
"explanation": null
} | yes | In both ovarian cancer cell lines 2-methoxyestradiol showed a significant additive inhibitory effect with epirubicin and carboplatin at lower chemotherapeutic concentrations in vitro, supporting dose reduction potential. | AGREE | DIRECT | [] | {
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes"
} | VERIFIED_AGREE | STANDARD | true | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0051-0100.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0074 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 74 | 74 | all | Assessing joint line positions by means of the contralateral knee: a new approach for planning knee revision surgery?
Reconstructing the natural joint line in knee revision surgery improves clinical and functional outcome but may be challenging when both cartilage and bone were removed during previous operations. Asse... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 0,
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes",
"explanation": null
} | yes | For the fibular head landmark the mean treated-versus-contralateral knee difference was 0.0 mm with narrow confidence limits (-1.1 to 1.1 mm) across 200 knees, supporting joint line assessment from the contralateral knee. | AGREE | DIRECT | [] | {
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes"
} | VERIFIED_AGREE | STANDARD | true | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0051-0100.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0075 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 75 | 75 | all | Does the type of tibial component affect mechanical alignment in unicompartmental knee replacement?
There are a number of factors responsible for the longevity of unicompartmental knee replacements (UKR). These include the magnitude of postoperative alignment and the type of material used. The effect of component desi... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 0,
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes",
"explanation": null
} | yes | Postoperative mechanical alignment was significantly closer to neutral with metal-backed onlay components (2.8 degrees) than all-polyethylene inlay components (3.9 degrees), P=0.003 after adjustment, so component type affects alignment. | AGREE | DIRECT | [] | {
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes"
} | VERIFIED_AGREE | STANDARD | true | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0051-0100.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0076 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 76 | 76 | all | Is tumour expression of VEGF associated with venous invasion and survival in pT3 renal cell carcinoma?
To determine whether there is a relationship between VEGF expression and renal vein and vena cava invasion in stage pT3 renal cell carcinoma and to evaluate the impact of VEGF expression on survival in pT3 renal cell... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 2,
"letter": "C",
"meaning": "maybe",
"explanation": null
} | maybe | VEGF expression independently predicted survival (OR 6.07 on multivariate analysis), but between venous-invasion groups only tumour size differed significantly, so association with invasion is unshown while the survival association is clear - a split result. | AGREE | DIRECT | [] | {
"letter": "C",
"meaning": "maybe"
} | VERIFIED_AGREE | STANDARD | true | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0051-0100.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0077 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 77 | 77 | all | Injury and poisoning mortality among young men--are there any common factors amenable to prevention?
Deaths from injury and poisoning (suicide, accidents, undetermined deaths, and homicide) are the major cause of death among young men aged 15-39 years in England and Wales and have been increasing in recent years.AIM: ... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 0,
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes",
"explanation": null
} | yes | Common characteristics recurred among 268 young male injury/poisoning deaths: drug/alcohol poisoning 29.1%, unemployment 39.4%, single status above population rate, and self-destructive behaviour in 77%, identifying shared preventable-factor patterns. | AGREE | DIRECT | [] | {
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes"
} | VERIFIED_AGREE | STANDARD | true | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0051-0100.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0078 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 78 | 78 | all | Continuation of pregnancy after antenatal corticosteroid administration: opportunity for rescue?
To determine the duration of continuing pregnancy after antenatal corticosteroid (AC) administration and to evaluate the potential opportunity for rescue AC.
Retrospective analysis of women at 24-32 weeks' gestation who r... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 2,
"letter": "C",
"meaning": "maybe",
"explanation": null
} | maybe | Only 17.9% of women remained pregnant 1 week after corticosteroids and delivered <34 weeks (the rescue-eligible group), while 46.4% delivered within 1 week and 35.7% at >=34 weeks, so any rescue opportunity is confined to a small, only partly predictable subset. | AGREE | DIRECT | [] | {
"letter": "C",
"meaning": "maybe"
} | VERIFIED_AGREE | STANDARD | true | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0051-0100.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0079 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 79 | 79 | all | Does either obesity or OSA severity influence the response of autotitrating CPAP machines in very obese subjects?
The pressures delivered by autotitrating continuous positive airways pressure (CPAP) devices not only treat obstructive sleep apnoea (OSA) effectively but also give potentially interesting physiological in... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 0,
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes",
"explanation": null
} | yes | AutoCPAP pressure showed no significant correlation with BMI, neck or waist circumference, but correlated moderately with OSA severity (AHI r=0.34, p=0.02; ODI r=0.48, p<0.001), so at least OSA severity influences the autotitrating response. | AGREE | DIRECT | [] | {
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes"
} | VERIFIED_AGREE | STANDARD | true | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0051-0100.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
pubmedqa:pqa_labeled:all:0080 | pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1 | 80 | 80 | all | Does the clinical presentation of a prior preterm birth predict risk in a subsequent pregnancy?
The objective of the study was to determine whether risk of recurrent preterm birth differs based on the clinical presentation of a prior spontaneous preterm birth (SPTB): advanced cervical dilatation (ACD), preterm prematu... | {
"A": "yes",
"B": "no",
"C": "maybe"
} | {
"cop_0based": 0,
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes",
"explanation": null
} | yes | Recurrent preterm birth was 55.2% after prior advanced cervical dilatation versus 27.2% after PPROM and 32.2% after preterm labour (P=.001), with lower delivery gestational age and shorter cervical length, so prior presentation predicts subsequent risk. | AGREE | DIRECT | [] | {
"letter": "A",
"meaning": "yes"
} | VERIFIED_AGREE | STANDARD | true | {
"run_id": "pubmedqa-pqa_labeled-all-v1",
"derivation_file": "derivations-0051-0100.jsonl",
"disposition_file": "dispositions.jsonl",
"disposition_file_sha256": "078d41ba1cca1881f31d45eb502e50c20e7060b01966be9a0fe86c26ddae6e8e"
} | [
"research material",
"not clinical guidance",
"not safe for patient care"
] |
PubMedQA — Checked Answers
A checked layer over the public PubMedQA questions: every label of the finished set re-derived blind, sealed before the label was seen, and graded as a claim — not trusted as a fact. PubMedQA (Jin et al., EMNLP-IJCNLP 2019) is the biomedical research-question benchmark in every standard evaluation suite: each item is a research question with its PubMed abstract (the conclusion removed), answered yes, no, or maybe. This census works on PQA-L, the expert-labelled set. It is run with the same discipline as our MedMCQA checked answers (agent-embassy/medmcqa-checked-answers-slice-1), our MMLU medical checked answers (agent-embassy/mmlu-medical-checked-answers-slice-1), our MedQA checked answers (agent-embassy/medqa-checked-answers-slice-1), our MedXpertQA checked answers (agent-embassy/medxpertqa-checked-answers-slice-1), our MedBullets checked answers (agent-embassy/medbullets-checked-answers-slice-1), and our HeadQA checked answers (agent-embassy/headqa-checked-answers-slice-1). The set is an evaluation set; this layer is an audit of its labels, published so scores can be read against checked labels. This card always states the running totals for everything shipped.
WHAT YOU GET
- Every question of the finished set with both answers side by side: the official label (labelled RAW) and the sealed checked verdict, plus each item's state, defect flags, and the full blind derivation.
- The dispute list: every question where the two answers part company, each printed in full with its derivation.
- The validator: rebuild every count in this card from a run's primary records. It passes with zero errors.
HOW THE BLIND WAS KEPT ON THIS BENCHMARK PubMedQA's source carries three things that would break a blind check if they reached the derivation: the abstract's conclusion (released as the long answer — the very text the label summarises), and two annotator-label fields stored inside the context record, which match the official label on 916 and 781 of the 1,000 items. All three were excluded at intake, mechanically. The blind file carried only the question, the abstract's context passages, and the three offered answers — exactly the input the benchmark's task defines — and the sealed label file's hash was recorded before any derivation existed.
RUNNING TOTALS (all shipped sets) 1,000 questions checked — the complete PQA-L expert-labelled set (500 of the 1,000 form the official test set).
- 762 verified — the sealed blind derivation and the official label agree (76.2%).
- 238 disputed — the two answers part company; each is kept in full, with its derivation, as an adjudication queue.
- 0 quarantined — no item is defective as written; all three answers are offered on every item.
THE PQA-L SET 1,000 questions: 762 verified, 238 disputed, 0 quarantined. The derivation was blind — verdicts were derived from the question and abstract context alone and sealed before any label was opened — so the 76.2% agreement is a measurement of the labels, not of a model's memory of them. It is the lowest agreement this census has measured on any set, and the shape of the disagreement is the finding:
- The dispute mass sits on the "maybe" boundary. 204 of the 238 disputes involve "maybe" on one side or the other; only 34 are direct yes/no flips. The blind reading answered "maybe" 166 times where the official labels use it 110 times, and on 74 of the 110 officially-"maybe" items the blind reading found the context did settle the question (50 yes, 24 no).
- Where the two readings take opposite definite positions, they are few and they are kept in full: 19 items labelled yes that the blind reading answers no, and 15 labelled no that it answers yes.
- Confidence tracks the split honestly: 150 of the 238 disputes rest on medium-confidence derivations and 38 on low-confidence ones; 50 rest on high-confidence derivations.
None of this declares the official labels wrong. PQA-L's labels are two expert annotators' reading of each abstract, and "maybe" is a judgement call by construction — this set measures how much of the label set a blind re-reading reproduces, and where it does not. Agreement is not proof a label is right and a dispute is not proof it is wrong; both stay on the record with evidence.
THE WIDER TRUST PROBLEM, NAMED PQA-L is the small, careful core of PubMedQA. The same benchmark ships PQA-A: 211,300 artificially labelled items whose labels come from a deterministic heuristic and run 92.8% "yes" — consumed at scale as training signal with no verification layer. This census checks the expert core; the heuristic tail's trust problem is structural, is named here in the open, and remains unowned by anyone.
CROSS-BENCHMARK TOTALS With this set, the census stands at 25,023 items checked over seven benchmark families (2,094 MMLU medical, 6,112 MedQA, 2,450 MedXpertQA, 616 MedBullets, 12,751 HeadQA, 1,000 PubMedQA, beside the MedMCQA floor in production): 22,429 verified, 2,524 disputed, 70 quarantined.
Research material only. Not clinical guidance. Not safe for patient care.
- Downloads last month
- 39