Datasets:
Download README.md from agentic-failure-study/failures-in-agentic-ai: direct link, hf CLI and curl.
- Browser
- Download file 7.26 kB
-
https://huggingface.co/datasets/agentic-failure-study/failures-in-agentic-ai/resolve/main/README.md
- Command line
-
hf download hf://datasets/agentic-failure-study/failures-in-agentic-ai/README.md
-
curl -L -o README.md https://huggingface.co/datasets/agentic-failure-study/failures-in-agentic-ai/resolve/main/README.md
language:
- en
license: cc-by-4.0
task_categories:
- text-classification
pretty_name: Failures in Agentic AI
size_categories:
- 1K<n<10K
tags:
- agentic-ai
- multi-agent-systems
- failure-analysis
- software-engineering
- llm
- taxonomy
configs:
- config_name: default
data_files:
- split: train
path: data/train-*.parquet
Failures in Agentic AI
A labelled corpus of 3,089 publicly reported failures of agentic and multi-agent applications, drawn from the issue trackers of 8 orchestration frameworks between 2023 and 2026. Each row is one failure report, coded on five independent dimensions by a deterministic, rule-based instrument, with the text span that decided the primary label kept beside it.
This release accompanies a study of how agentic systems fail, and exists so that the labels, the boundaries and the disagreements can be checked rather than taken on trust.
What is in it
| Column group | Contents |
|---|---|
| Provenance | record_id, source_url, repository, framework, issue_number, created_at |
| Report context | title, state, issue_labels, comments, reactions, body_chars |
| Dimension A - failure type | failure_type, failure_type_label, failure_type_confidence, evidence_span |
| Dimension B - cause class | cause_class, cause_label, cause_secondary, cause_confidence, cause_evidence_grade |
| Dimensions C, D, E | lifecycle_stage, severity, detection_point |
| Declared complexity | complexity_tier, complexity_multi_agent, complexity_uses_tools, complexity_uses_memory |
| Audit trail | matched_rules, taxonomy_version |
evidence_span is the sentence or traceback fragment that produced the label;
matched_rules lists the rules that fired. Together they let a reader reject any
single label without re-running the pipeline. The exact column types are listed
in codebook/schema.md.
data/exemplars.parquet holds 49 examples selected to demonstrate
each of the 10 failure types, one row per example, with its source URL.
How to load it
from datasets import load_dataset
ds = load_dataset("agentic-failure-study/failures-in-agentic-ai")
df = ds["train"].to_pandas()
df["failure_type_label"].value_counts()
exemplars = load_dataset("agentic-failure-study/failures-in-agentic-ai", data_files="data/exemplars.parquet")
Distribution of failure types
| Failure type | Records |
|---|---|
| Functionality / reasoning defect | 748 |
| Compatibility / API-contract defect | 561 |
| Data structure / output-parsing defect | 422 |
| Tool / integration defect | 374 |
| Configuration / environment defect | 355 |
| Context / memory / state defect | 253 |
| Performance / resource defect | 170 |
| Insufficient evidence | 92 |
| Agent communication / orchestration defect | 90 |
| Safety / guardrail defect | 24 |
Distribution by framework
| Framework | Records |
|---|---|
| AutoGPT | 598 |
| LangGraph | 539 |
| CrewAI | 533 |
| LlamaIndex | 436 |
| OpenAI-Agents | 337 |
| AutoGen | 300 |
| MetaGPT | 238 |
| SWE-agent | 108 |
Severity and detection
| Severity code | Records |
|---|---|
| D1_blocking | 1,811 |
| D3_degraded | 1,053 |
| D2_incorrect_output | 174 |
| D4_minor | 51 |
| Cause evidence grade | Records |
|---|---|
| hypothesised | 1,545 |
| supported | 1,170 |
| demonstrated | 374 |
Across the corpus, 31.9% of failures were never caught by the framework runtime: they reached a user as a wrong result rather than as an error.
Reproducing the labels
The labeller is rule-based and deterministic, so the same input text yields the
same label and the same evidence span. The codebook is included as
codebook/taxonomy.v1.yaml; it gives every code a definition, an inclusion rule
and an explicit exclusion clause. Agreement with a 100-record reference
annotation is 51.0% exact (macro-F1 0.54,
Cohen's kappa 0.44, moderate); the residual error sits on two codebook
boundaries, which are stated in the report rather than tuned away.
Provenance and licensing
- Each row links to its original public report. The full issue text is not
redistributed. It belongs to the reporting project, it sometimes contains
pasted credentials, and it can be re-fetched from
source_url. - The annotations, the codebook and the evidence quotations are released under CC BY 4.0. Quoted titles and spans remain attributable to their authors.
- No personal data was collected. Author handles were dropped at collection time; what remains is the public issue content needed to justify a label.
- Credential-shaped strings are masked as
[redacted: credential]before export, because people paste their own API keys into public issue reports. The stored corpus keeps the original text so it still matches the source; the release does not. - Collection used only the public GitHub API, rate limited, with every request logged.
Prior release location
This dataset was first published at:
- https://github.com/khawajasafiullah18/agentic-failure-study
- https://huggingface.co/datasets/khawajasafiullah/failures-in-agentic-ai
It has since moved to agentic-failure-study/failures-in-agentic-ai. The move preserved every
record_id: a record keeps its identifier, so a citation of the earlier location
resolves to the same rows. No row was re-fetched, relabelled or renumbered in the
move, and the earlier copy is retained as a redirect rather than deleted.
Limitations, stated up front
- This is the reporting population, not all failures. It records what people chose to file on GitHub. Silent failures fixed in-house are absent, so the proportions describe this corpus and not agentic systems in general.
- Single coder. Labels were produced by one instrument checked against one reference annotation. An independent second-coder pass is prepared but not complete; agreement is therefore reported as moderate, not as validation.
- Complexity is declared, not instrumented.
complexity_tiercounts capabilities the report mentions. It under-counts capabilities that were present but undescribed and correlates weakly with report length. - Composition drifts over time. A before/after-2025 split shows the mix of
failure types changing (Cramer's V = 0.30). Trim by
yearif you need a stationary sample. - Annual counts reflect filing volume, not only reliability change.
Citation
@misc{aldahmani2026agenticfailures,
title = {Failures in Agentic AI: a five-dimension taxonomy and corpus of
3,089 reported failures},
author = {Aldahmani, Maryam and Alhosani, Shama},
year = {2026},
note = {Dataset and codebook, CC BY 4.0},
url = {https://huggingface.co/datasets/agentic-failure-study/failures-in-agentic-ai}
}
Maintenance
Regenerated from the project repository with python -m afs.cli hf. The card,
the parquet schema and the counts above are produced by the same command, so a
relabelled corpus cannot leave a stale number in the documentation.
Generated 2026-11-15T00:50:26Z.