CoherenceBench-Agent / raw_telemetry /multi_agent_mesi_bench.json
batistado's picture
Publish CoherenceBench-Agent v1.0 multi-model & multi-agent telemetry
2c7461b verified
Raw History Blame Contribute Delete
20 kB
{
"benchmark": "MESI-KV Multi-Agent Disaggregated Coherence & Fine-Grained AST/SQLite Benchmark",
"concurrency_levels": [
1,
2,
4,
8
],
"operations_per_level": 500,
"wire_header_memory_overhead": {
"Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct (L=36, H_kv=2, D=128)": {
"header_wire_bytes": 32,
"block_tokens": 128,
"per_layer_fp16_kv_bytes": 131072,
"full_block_fp16_kv_bytes": 4718592,
"overhead_vs_per_layer_pct": 0.0244140625,
"overhead_vs_full_block_pct": 0.0006781684027777778
},
"Qwen2.5-7B-Instruct (L=28, H_kv=4, D=128)": {
"header_wire_bytes": 32,
"block_tokens": 128,
"per_layer_fp16_kv_bytes": 262144,
"full_block_fp16_kv_bytes": 7340032,
"overhead_vs_per_layer_pct": 0.01220703125,
"overhead_vs_full_block_pct": 0.0004359654017857143
},
"Qwen2.5-Coder-14B-Instruct (L=48, H_kv=8, D=128)": {
"header_wire_bytes": 32,
"block_tokens": 128,
"per_layer_fp16_kv_bytes": 524288,
"full_block_fp16_kv_bytes": 25165824,
"overhead_vs_per_layer_pct": 0.006103515625,
"overhead_vs_full_block_pct": 0.00012715657552083334
}
},
"aggregate_by_mode": {
"No-Coherence": {
"mean_stale_semantic_tool_cache_hit_rate_pct": 49.0,
"mean_stale_kv_pool_hit_rate_pct": 88.14,
"mean_silent_tainted_action_commit_rate_pct": 100.0,
"mean_false_positive_collateral_kv_eviction_rate_pct": 0.0,
"mean_false_blocked_clean_commit_rate_pct": 0.0,
"mean_read_lease_p50_us": 1.79,
"mean_read_lease_p99_us": 3.33,
"mean_write_invalidate_p50_us": 0.0,
"mean_write_invalidate_p99_us": 0.0
},
"Coarse-File-Table": {
"mean_stale_semantic_tool_cache_hit_rate_pct": 0.0,
"mean_stale_kv_pool_hit_rate_pct": 0.0,
"mean_silent_tainted_action_commit_rate_pct": 0.0,
"mean_false_positive_collateral_kv_eviction_rate_pct": 100.0,
"mean_false_blocked_clean_commit_rate_pct": 100.0,
"mean_read_lease_p50_us": 0.73,
"mean_read_lease_p99_us": 2.87,
"mean_write_invalidate_p50_us": 0.0,
"mean_write_invalidate_p99_us": 0.0
},
"MESI-KV": {
"mean_stale_semantic_tool_cache_hit_rate_pct": 0.0,
"mean_stale_kv_pool_hit_rate_pct": 0.0,
"mean_silent_tainted_action_commit_rate_pct": 0.0,
"mean_false_positive_collateral_kv_eviction_rate_pct": 0.0,
"mean_false_blocked_clean_commit_rate_pct": 0.0,
"mean_read_lease_p50_us": 0.81,
"mean_read_lease_p99_us": 2.54,
"mean_write_invalidate_p50_us": 5.68,
"mean_write_invalidate_p99_us": 20.04
}
},
"tau_act_sensitivity_p8": [
{
"tau_act": 0.005,
"satisfies_theorem2_tau_kv_le_tau_act": false,
"silent_tainted_action_commit_rate_pct": 0.0,
"false_blocked_clean_commit_rate_pct": 100.0,
"commit_validate_p99_us": 6.46
},
{
"tau_act": 0.015,
"satisfies_theorem2_tau_kv_le_tau_act": false,
"silent_tainted_action_commit_rate_pct": 0.0,
"false_blocked_clean_commit_rate_pct": 38.3,
"commit_validate_p99_us": 6.42
},
{
"tau_act": 0.08,
"satisfies_theorem2_tau_kv_le_tau_act": false,
"silent_tainted_action_commit_rate_pct": 0.0,
"false_blocked_clean_commit_rate_pct": 0.0,
"commit_validate_p99_us": 5.67
},
{
"tau_act": 0.12,
"satisfies_theorem2_tau_kv_le_tau_act": true,
"silent_tainted_action_commit_rate_pct": 0.0,
"false_blocked_clean_commit_rate_pct": 0.0,
"commit_validate_p99_us": 5.42
},
{
"tau_act": 0.2,
"satisfies_theorem2_tau_kv_le_tau_act": true,
"silent_tainted_action_commit_rate_pct": 0.0,
"false_blocked_clean_commit_rate_pct": 2.13,
"commit_validate_p99_us": 7.0
},
{
"tau_act": 0.4,
"satisfies_theorem2_tau_kv_le_tau_act": true,
"silent_tainted_action_commit_rate_pct": 100.0,
"false_blocked_clean_commit_rate_pct": 0.0,
"commit_validate_p99_us": 6.04
}
],
"results_by_concurrency": {
"P=1": {
"No-Coherence": {
"mode": "No-Coherence",
"concurrency_agents": 1,
"num_operations": 500,
"wall_time_ms": 311.53,
"throughput_ops_per_sec": 1605.0,
"stale_semantic_tool_cache_hit_rate_pct": 46.12,
"stale_kv_pool_hit_rate_pct": 87.93,
"silent_tainted_action_commit_rate_pct": 100.0,
"false_positive_collateral_kv_eviction_rate_pct": 0.0,
"false_blocked_clean_commit_rate_pct": 0.0,
"raw_counters": {
"tool_reads_total": 232,
"tool_cache_hits": 169,
"stale_tool_cache_hits": 107,
"kv_lookups_total": 232,
"stale_kv_hits": 204,
"collateral_sibling_blocks_exposed": 464,
"collateral_sibling_blocks_evicted": 0,
"tainted_commit_attempts": 34,
"silent_tainted_commits": 34,
"clean_commit_attempts": 43,
"false_blocked_clean_commits": 0
},
"directory_latency_us": {
"read_lease_p50_us": 1.25,
"read_lease_p99_us": 2.46,
"write_invalidate_p50_us": 0.0,
"write_invalidate_p99_us": 0.0,
"commit_validate_p50_us": 0.0,
"commit_validate_p99_us": 0.0,
"python_ast_scan_p50_us": 0.0,
"sqlite_trigger_update_p50_us": 1946.12
}
},
"Coarse-File-Table": {
"mode": "Coarse-File-Table",
"concurrency_agents": 1,
"num_operations": 500,
"wall_time_ms": 326.91,
"throughput_ops_per_sec": 1529.5,
"stale_semantic_tool_cache_hit_rate_pct": 0.0,
"stale_kv_pool_hit_rate_pct": 0.0,
"silent_tainted_action_commit_rate_pct": 0.0,
"false_positive_collateral_kv_eviction_rate_pct": 100.0,
"false_blocked_clean_commit_rate_pct": 100.0,
"raw_counters": {
"tool_reads_total": 232,
"tool_cache_hits": 27,
"stale_tool_cache_hits": 0,
"kv_lookups_total": 232,
"stale_kv_hits": 0,
"collateral_sibling_blocks_exposed": 109,
"collateral_sibling_blocks_evicted": 109,
"tainted_commit_attempts": 34,
"silent_tainted_commits": 0,
"clean_commit_attempts": 43,
"false_blocked_clean_commits": 43
},
"directory_latency_us": {
"read_lease_p50_us": 0.71,
"read_lease_p99_us": 2.71,
"write_invalidate_p50_us": 0.0,
"write_invalidate_p99_us": 0.0,
"commit_validate_p50_us": 0.0,
"commit_validate_p99_us": 0.0,
"python_ast_scan_p50_us": 0.0,
"sqlite_trigger_update_p50_us": 1896.58
}
},
"MESI-KV": {
"mode": "MESI-KV",
"concurrency_agents": 1,
"num_operations": 500,
"wall_time_ms": 392.68,
"throughput_ops_per_sec": 1273.3,
"stale_semantic_tool_cache_hit_rate_pct": 0.0,
"stale_kv_pool_hit_rate_pct": 0.0,
"silent_tainted_action_commit_rate_pct": 0.0,
"false_positive_collateral_kv_eviction_rate_pct": 0.0,
"false_blocked_clean_commit_rate_pct": 0.0,
"raw_counters": {
"tool_reads_total": 232,
"tool_cache_hits": 113,
"stale_tool_cache_hits": 0,
"kv_lookups_total": 232,
"stale_kv_hits": 0,
"collateral_sibling_blocks_exposed": 305,
"collateral_sibling_blocks_evicted": 0,
"tainted_commit_attempts": 34,
"silent_tainted_commits": 0,
"clean_commit_attempts": 43,
"false_blocked_clean_commits": 0
},
"directory_latency_us": {
"read_lease_p50_us": 0.75,
"read_lease_p99_us": 1.83,
"write_invalidate_p50_us": 5.21,
"write_invalidate_p99_us": 17.21,
"commit_validate_p50_us": 3.25,
"commit_validate_p99_us": 6.33,
"python_ast_scan_p50_us": 165.08,
"sqlite_trigger_update_p50_us": 1893.67
}
}
},
"P=2": {
"No-Coherence": {
"mode": "No-Coherence",
"concurrency_agents": 2,
"num_operations": 500,
"wall_time_ms": 317.2,
"throughput_ops_per_sec": 1576.3,
"stale_semantic_tool_cache_hit_rate_pct": 43.26,
"stale_kv_pool_hit_rate_pct": 89.3,
"silent_tainted_action_commit_rate_pct": 100.0,
"false_positive_collateral_kv_eviction_rate_pct": 0.0,
"false_blocked_clean_commit_rate_pct": 0.0,
"raw_counters": {
"tool_reads_total": 215,
"tool_cache_hits": 157,
"stale_tool_cache_hits": 93,
"kv_lookups_total": 215,
"stale_kv_hits": 192,
"collateral_sibling_blocks_exposed": 411,
"collateral_sibling_blocks_evicted": 0,
"tainted_commit_attempts": 37,
"silent_tainted_commits": 37,
"clean_commit_attempts": 52,
"false_blocked_clean_commits": 0
},
"directory_latency_us": {
"read_lease_p50_us": 2.04,
"read_lease_p99_us": 3.25,
"write_invalidate_p50_us": 0.0,
"write_invalidate_p99_us": 0.0,
"commit_validate_p50_us": 0.0,
"commit_validate_p99_us": 0.0,
"python_ast_scan_p50_us": 0.0,
"sqlite_trigger_update_p50_us": 1978.0
}
},
"Coarse-File-Table": {
"mode": "Coarse-File-Table",
"concurrency_agents": 2,
"num_operations": 500,
"wall_time_ms": 308.5,
"throughput_ops_per_sec": 1620.7,
"stale_semantic_tool_cache_hit_rate_pct": 0.0,
"stale_kv_pool_hit_rate_pct": 0.0,
"silent_tainted_action_commit_rate_pct": 0.0,
"false_positive_collateral_kv_eviction_rate_pct": 100.0,
"false_blocked_clean_commit_rate_pct": 100.0,
"raw_counters": {
"tool_reads_total": 215,
"tool_cache_hits": 29,
"stale_tool_cache_hits": 0,
"kv_lookups_total": 215,
"stale_kv_hits": 0,
"collateral_sibling_blocks_exposed": 79,
"collateral_sibling_blocks_evicted": 79,
"tainted_commit_attempts": 37,
"silent_tainted_commits": 0,
"clean_commit_attempts": 52,
"false_blocked_clean_commits": 52
},
"directory_latency_us": {
"read_lease_p50_us": 0.75,
"read_lease_p99_us": 2.83,
"write_invalidate_p50_us": 0.0,
"write_invalidate_p99_us": 0.0,
"commit_validate_p50_us": 0.0,
"commit_validate_p99_us": 0.0,
"python_ast_scan_p50_us": 0.0,
"sqlite_trigger_update_p50_us": 1878.33
}
},
"MESI-KV": {
"mode": "MESI-KV",
"concurrency_agents": 2,
"num_operations": 500,
"wall_time_ms": 315.43,
"throughput_ops_per_sec": 1585.1,
"stale_semantic_tool_cache_hit_rate_pct": 0.0,
"stale_kv_pool_hit_rate_pct": 0.0,
"silent_tainted_action_commit_rate_pct": 0.0,
"false_positive_collateral_kv_eviction_rate_pct": 0.0,
"false_blocked_clean_commit_rate_pct": 0.0,
"raw_counters": {
"tool_reads_total": 215,
"tool_cache_hits": 97,
"stale_tool_cache_hits": 0,
"kv_lookups_total": 215,
"stale_kv_hits": 0,
"collateral_sibling_blocks_exposed": 251,
"collateral_sibling_blocks_evicted": 0,
"tainted_commit_attempts": 37,
"silent_tainted_commits": 0,
"clean_commit_attempts": 52,
"false_blocked_clean_commits": 0
},
"directory_latency_us": {
"read_lease_p50_us": 0.83,
"read_lease_p99_us": 2.79,
"write_invalidate_p50_us": 5.88,
"write_invalidate_p99_us": 19.46,
"commit_validate_p50_us": 3.25,
"commit_validate_p99_us": 6.5,
"python_ast_scan_p50_us": 161.92,
"sqlite_trigger_update_p50_us": 1914.12
}
}
},
"P=4": {
"No-Coherence": {
"mode": "No-Coherence",
"concurrency_agents": 4,
"num_operations": 500,
"wall_time_ms": 399.8,
"throughput_ops_per_sec": 1250.6,
"stale_semantic_tool_cache_hit_rate_pct": 42.73,
"stale_kv_pool_hit_rate_pct": 84.14,
"silent_tainted_action_commit_rate_pct": 100.0,
"false_positive_collateral_kv_eviction_rate_pct": 0.0,
"false_blocked_clean_commit_rate_pct": 0.0,
"raw_counters": {
"tool_reads_total": 227,
"tool_cache_hits": 159,
"stale_tool_cache_hits": 97,
"kv_lookups_total": 227,
"stale_kv_hits": 191,
"collateral_sibling_blocks_exposed": 433,
"collateral_sibling_blocks_evicted": 0,
"tainted_commit_attempts": 38,
"silent_tainted_commits": 38,
"clean_commit_attempts": 34,
"false_blocked_clean_commits": 0
},
"directory_latency_us": {
"read_lease_p50_us": 2.08,
"read_lease_p99_us": 3.88,
"write_invalidate_p50_us": 0.0,
"write_invalidate_p99_us": 0.0,
"commit_validate_p50_us": 0.0,
"commit_validate_p99_us": 0.0,
"python_ast_scan_p50_us": 0.0,
"sqlite_trigger_update_p50_us": 2064.88
}
},
"Coarse-File-Table": {
"mode": "Coarse-File-Table",
"concurrency_agents": 4,
"num_operations": 500,
"wall_time_ms": 346.35,
"throughput_ops_per_sec": 1443.6,
"stale_semantic_tool_cache_hit_rate_pct": 0.0,
"stale_kv_pool_hit_rate_pct": 0.0,
"silent_tainted_action_commit_rate_pct": 0.0,
"false_positive_collateral_kv_eviction_rate_pct": 100.0,
"false_blocked_clean_commit_rate_pct": 100.0,
"raw_counters": {
"tool_reads_total": 227,
"tool_cache_hits": 35,
"stale_tool_cache_hits": 0,
"kv_lookups_total": 227,
"stale_kv_hits": 0,
"collateral_sibling_blocks_exposed": 100,
"collateral_sibling_blocks_evicted": 100,
"tainted_commit_attempts": 38,
"silent_tainted_commits": 0,
"clean_commit_attempts": 34,
"false_blocked_clean_commits": 34
},
"directory_latency_us": {
"read_lease_p50_us": 0.75,
"read_lease_p99_us": 2.92,
"write_invalidate_p50_us": 0.0,
"write_invalidate_p99_us": 0.0,
"commit_validate_p50_us": 0.0,
"commit_validate_p99_us": 0.0,
"python_ast_scan_p50_us": 0.0,
"sqlite_trigger_update_p50_us": 2011.92
}
},
"MESI-KV": {
"mode": "MESI-KV",
"concurrency_agents": 4,
"num_operations": 500,
"wall_time_ms": 385.9,
"throughput_ops_per_sec": 1295.7,
"stale_semantic_tool_cache_hit_rate_pct": 0.0,
"stale_kv_pool_hit_rate_pct": 0.0,
"silent_tainted_action_commit_rate_pct": 0.0,
"false_positive_collateral_kv_eviction_rate_pct": 0.0,
"false_blocked_clean_commit_rate_pct": 0.0,
"raw_counters": {
"tool_reads_total": 227,
"tool_cache_hits": 100,
"stale_tool_cache_hits": 0,
"kv_lookups_total": 227,
"stale_kv_hits": 0,
"collateral_sibling_blocks_exposed": 258,
"collateral_sibling_blocks_evicted": 0,
"tainted_commit_attempts": 38,
"silent_tainted_commits": 0,
"clean_commit_attempts": 34,
"false_blocked_clean_commits": 0
},
"directory_latency_us": {
"read_lease_p50_us": 0.92,
"read_lease_p99_us": 3.0,
"write_invalidate_p50_us": 6.5,
"write_invalidate_p99_us": 24.46,
"commit_validate_p50_us": 4.08,
"commit_validate_p99_us": 7.0,
"python_ast_scan_p50_us": 168.71,
"sqlite_trigger_update_p50_us": 1989.42
}
}
},
"P=8": {
"No-Coherence": {
"mode": "No-Coherence",
"concurrency_agents": 8,
"num_operations": 500,
"wall_time_ms": 440.91,
"throughput_ops_per_sec": 1134.0,
"stale_semantic_tool_cache_hit_rate_pct": 63.89,
"stale_kv_pool_hit_rate_pct": 91.2,
"silent_tainted_action_commit_rate_pct": 100.0,
"false_positive_collateral_kv_eviction_rate_pct": 0.0,
"false_blocked_clean_commit_rate_pct": 0.0,
"raw_counters": {
"tool_reads_total": 216,
"tool_cache_hits": 174,
"stale_tool_cache_hits": 138,
"kv_lookups_total": 216,
"stale_kv_hits": 197,
"collateral_sibling_blocks_exposed": 474,
"collateral_sibling_blocks_evicted": 0,
"tainted_commit_attempts": 36,
"silent_tainted_commits": 36,
"clean_commit_attempts": 47,
"false_blocked_clean_commits": 0
},
"directory_latency_us": {
"read_lease_p50_us": 1.79,
"read_lease_p99_us": 3.71,
"write_invalidate_p50_us": 0.0,
"write_invalidate_p99_us": 0.0,
"commit_validate_p50_us": 0.0,
"commit_validate_p99_us": 0.0,
"python_ast_scan_p50_us": 0.0,
"sqlite_trigger_update_p50_us": 2004.08
}
},
"Coarse-File-Table": {
"mode": "Coarse-File-Table",
"concurrency_agents": 8,
"num_operations": 500,
"wall_time_ms": 323.03,
"throughput_ops_per_sec": 1547.8,
"stale_semantic_tool_cache_hit_rate_pct": 0.0,
"stale_kv_pool_hit_rate_pct": 0.0,
"silent_tainted_action_commit_rate_pct": 0.0,
"false_positive_collateral_kv_eviction_rate_pct": 100.0,
"false_blocked_clean_commit_rate_pct": 100.0,
"raw_counters": {
"tool_reads_total": 216,
"tool_cache_hits": 27,
"stale_tool_cache_hits": 0,
"kv_lookups_total": 216,
"stale_kv_hits": 0,
"collateral_sibling_blocks_exposed": 104,
"collateral_sibling_blocks_evicted": 104,
"tainted_commit_attempts": 36,
"silent_tainted_commits": 0,
"clean_commit_attempts": 47,
"false_blocked_clean_commits": 47
},
"directory_latency_us": {
"read_lease_p50_us": 0.71,
"read_lease_p99_us": 3.0,
"write_invalidate_p50_us": 0.0,
"write_invalidate_p99_us": 0.0,
"commit_validate_p50_us": 0.0,
"commit_validate_p99_us": 0.0,
"python_ast_scan_p50_us": 0.0,
"sqlite_trigger_update_p50_us": 1834.83
}
},
"MESI-KV": {
"mode": "MESI-KV",
"concurrency_agents": 8,
"num_operations": 500,
"wall_time_ms": 408.07,
"throughput_ops_per_sec": 1225.3,
"stale_semantic_tool_cache_hit_rate_pct": 0.0,
"stale_kv_pool_hit_rate_pct": 0.0,
"silent_tainted_action_commit_rate_pct": 0.0,
"false_positive_collateral_kv_eviction_rate_pct": 0.0,
"false_blocked_clean_commit_rate_pct": 0.0,
"raw_counters": {
"tool_reads_total": 216,
"tool_cache_hits": 110,
"stale_tool_cache_hits": 0,
"kv_lookups_total": 216,
"stale_kv_hits": 0,
"collateral_sibling_blocks_exposed": 315,
"collateral_sibling_blocks_evicted": 0,
"tainted_commit_attempts": 36,
"silent_tainted_commits": 0,
"clean_commit_attempts": 47,
"false_blocked_clean_commits": 0
},
"directory_latency_us": {
"read_lease_p50_us": 0.75,
"read_lease_p99_us": 2.54,
"write_invalidate_p50_us": 5.12,
"write_invalidate_p99_us": 19.04,
"commit_validate_p50_us": 3.29,
"commit_validate_p99_us": 5.75,
"python_ast_scan_p50_us": 159.21,
"sqlite_trigger_update_p50_us": 2022.08
}
}
}
}
}