QuorumBench / raw_telemetry /theorem_verification.json
batistado's picture
Publish QuorumBench v1.0 multi-agent consensus & contention telemetry
75b499d verified
Raw History Blame Contribute Delete
19 kB
{
"theorem1_phase_transition": {
"parameters": {
"p0": 0.78,
"p_inf": 0.08,
"lambda": 0.55,
"mu_rate": 0.45
},
"analytical_population_mean_error_p_bar": 0.395,
"analytical_critical_quorum_ratio_phi_crit": 0.69731,
"analytical_cov_latency_accuracy": 0.385,
"n_sweep": [
{
"N": 7,
"sync_full_majority_error": 0.28395,
"quorum_curve": [
{
"k": 3,
"phi_eff": 0.4286,
"analytical_elem_error": 0.60306,
"mc_elem_error": 0.57859,
"abs_formula_diff": 0.02447,
"mc_majority_false_consensus_rate": 0.61428,
"mean_quorum_latency_s": 1.1307,
"p95_quorum_latency_s": 2.3775
},
{
"k": 3,
"phi_eff": 0.4286,
"analytical_elem_error": 0.60306,
"mc_elem_error": 0.57859,
"abs_formula_diff": 0.02447,
"mc_majority_false_consensus_rate": 0.61428,
"mean_quorum_latency_s": 1.1307,
"p95_quorum_latency_s": 2.3775
},
{
"k": 3,
"phi_eff": 0.4286,
"analytical_elem_error": 0.60306,
"mc_elem_error": 0.57859,
"abs_formula_diff": 0.02447,
"mc_majority_false_consensus_rate": 0.61428,
"mean_quorum_latency_s": 1.1307,
"p95_quorum_latency_s": 2.3775
},
{
"k": 5,
"phi_eff": 0.7143,
"analytical_elem_error": 0.49375,
"mc_elem_error": 0.48359,
"abs_formula_diff": 0.01015,
"mc_majority_false_consensus_rate": 0.46992,
"mean_quorum_latency_s": 2.4211,
"p95_quorum_latency_s": 4.5412
},
{
"k": 5,
"phi_eff": 0.7143,
"analytical_elem_error": 0.49375,
"mc_elem_error": 0.48359,
"abs_formula_diff": 0.01015,
"mc_majority_false_consensus_rate": 0.46992,
"mean_quorum_latency_s": 2.4211,
"p95_quorum_latency_s": 4.5412
},
{
"k": 5,
"phi_eff": 0.7143,
"analytical_elem_error": 0.49375,
"mc_elem_error": 0.48359,
"abs_formula_diff": 0.01015,
"mc_majority_false_consensus_rate": 0.46992,
"mean_quorum_latency_s": 2.4211,
"p95_quorum_latency_s": 4.5412
},
{
"k": 7,
"phi_eff": 1.0,
"analytical_elem_error": 0.395,
"mc_elem_error": 0.3966,
"abs_formula_diff": 0.0016,
"mc_majority_false_consensus_rate": 0.28395,
"mean_quorum_latency_s": 5.7684,
"p95_quorum_latency_s": 10.9435
},
{
"k": 7,
"phi_eff": 1.0,
"analytical_elem_error": 0.395,
"mc_elem_error": 0.3966,
"abs_formula_diff": 0.0016,
"mc_majority_false_consensus_rate": 0.28395,
"mean_quorum_latency_s": 5.7684,
"p95_quorum_latency_s": 10.9435
}
]
},
{
"N": 15,
"sync_full_majority_error": 0.2015,
"quorum_curve": [
{
"k": 5,
"phi_eff": 0.3333,
"analytical_elem_error": 0.64119,
"mc_elem_error": 0.62596,
"abs_formula_diff": 0.01523,
"mc_majority_false_consensus_rate": 0.7237,
"mean_quorum_latency_s": 0.8642,
"p95_quorum_latency_s": 1.5892
},
{
"k": 5,
"phi_eff": 0.3333,
"analytical_elem_error": 0.64119,
"mc_elem_error": 0.62596,
"abs_formula_diff": 0.01523,
"mc_majority_false_consensus_rate": 0.7237,
"mean_quorum_latency_s": 0.8642,
"p95_quorum_latency_s": 1.5892
},
{
"k": 7,
"phi_eff": 0.4667,
"analytical_elem_error": 0.58803,
"mc_elem_error": 0.5756,
"abs_formula_diff": 0.01243,
"mc_majority_false_consensus_rate": 0.65817,
"mean_quorum_latency_s": 1.3376,
"p95_quorum_latency_s": 2.2831
},
{
"k": 9,
"phi_eff": 0.6,
"analytical_elem_error": 0.53648,
"mc_elem_error": 0.52769,
"abs_formula_diff": 0.00878,
"mc_majority_false_consensus_rate": 0.56775,
"mean_quorum_latency_s": 1.929,
"p95_quorum_latency_s": 3.1401
},
{
"k": 11,
"phi_eff": 0.7333,
"analytical_elem_error": 0.48677,
"mc_elem_error": 0.48141,
"abs_formula_diff": 0.00537,
"mc_majority_false_consensus_rate": 0.45198,
"mean_quorum_latency_s": 2.7431,
"p95_quorum_latency_s": 4.3359
},
{
"k": 11,
"phi_eff": 0.7333,
"analytical_elem_error": 0.48677,
"mc_elem_error": 0.48141,
"abs_formula_diff": 0.00537,
"mc_majority_false_consensus_rate": 0.45198,
"mean_quorum_latency_s": 2.7431,
"p95_quorum_latency_s": 4.3359
},
{
"k": 13,
"phi_eff": 0.8667,
"analytical_elem_error": 0.43933,
"mc_elem_error": 0.43694,
"abs_formula_diff": 0.00239,
"mc_majority_false_consensus_rate": 0.32312,
"mean_quorum_latency_s": 4.039,
"p95_quorum_latency_s": 6.3733
},
{
"k": 15,
"phi_eff": 1.0,
"analytical_elem_error": 0.395,
"mc_elem_error": 0.39488,
"abs_formula_diff": 0.00012,
"mc_majority_false_consensus_rate": 0.2015,
"mean_quorum_latency_s": 7.3748,
"p95_quorum_latency_s": 12.6157
}
]
},
{
"N": 31,
"sync_full_majority_error": 0.11607,
"quorum_curve": [
{
"k": 9,
"phi_eff": 0.2903,
"analytical_elem_error": 0.65865,
"mc_elem_error": 0.64984,
"abs_formula_diff": 0.00881,
"mc_majority_false_consensus_rate": 0.82542,
"mean_quorum_latency_s": 0.7483,
"p95_quorum_latency_s": 1.203
},
{
"k": 11,
"phi_eff": 0.3548,
"analytical_elem_error": 0.63251,
"mc_elem_error": 0.62458,
"abs_formula_diff": 0.00793,
"mc_majority_false_consensus_rate": 0.80075,
"mean_quorum_latency_s": 0.9549,
"p95_quorum_latency_s": 1.4753
},
{
"k": 15,
"phi_eff": 0.4839,
"analytical_elem_error": 0.58128,
"mc_elem_error": 0.57458,
"abs_formula_diff": 0.00671,
"mc_majority_false_consensus_rate": 0.7175,
"mean_quorum_latency_s": 1.4394,
"p95_quorum_latency_s": 2.1136
},
{
"k": 17,
"phi_eff": 0.5484,
"analytical_elem_error": 0.55623,
"mc_elem_error": 0.55044,
"abs_formula_diff": 0.00578,
"mc_majority_false_consensus_rate": 0.6566,
"mean_quorum_latency_s": 1.7259,
"p95_quorum_latency_s": 2.4863
},
{
"k": 21,
"phi_eff": 0.6774,
"analytical_elem_error": 0.50737,
"mc_elem_error": 0.50313,
"abs_formula_diff": 0.00424,
"mc_majority_false_consensus_rate": 0.51085,
"mean_quorum_latency_s": 2.4459,
"p95_quorum_latency_s": 3.4361
},
{
"k": 23,
"phi_eff": 0.7419,
"analytical_elem_error": 0.48364,
"mc_elem_error": 0.4802,
"abs_formula_diff": 0.00344,
"mc_majority_false_consensus_rate": 0.42535,
"mean_quorum_latency_s": 2.916,
"p95_quorum_latency_s": 4.0732
},
{
"k": 27,
"phi_eff": 0.871,
"analytical_elem_error": 0.43785,
"mc_elem_error": 0.43592,
"abs_formula_diff": 0.00193,
"mc_majority_false_consensus_rate": 0.25205,
"mean_quorum_latency_s": 4.3193,
"p95_quorum_latency_s": 6.0464
},
{
"k": 31,
"phi_eff": 1.0,
"analytical_elem_error": 0.395,
"mc_elem_error": 0.39445,
"abs_formula_diff": 0.00055,
"mc_majority_false_consensus_rate": 0.11607,
"mean_quorum_latency_s": 8.9323,
"p95_quorum_latency_s": 14.2274
}
]
},
{
"N": 63,
"sync_full_majority_error": 0.04537,
"quorum_curve": [
{
"k": 17,
"phi_eff": 0.2698,
"analytical_elem_error": 0.66701,
"mc_elem_error": 0.66234,
"abs_formula_diff": 0.00467,
"mc_majority_false_consensus_rate": 0.91615,
"mean_quorum_latency_s": 0.6917,
"p95_quorum_latency_s": 0.9889
},
{
"k": 23,
"phi_eff": 0.3651,
"analytical_elem_error": 0.6284,
"mc_elem_error": 0.62487,
"abs_formula_diff": 0.00353,
"mc_majority_false_consensus_rate": 0.88302,
"mean_quorum_latency_s": 0.9989,
"p95_quorum_latency_s": 1.3671
},
{
"k": 29,
"phi_eff": 0.4603,
"analytical_elem_error": 0.59053,
"mc_elem_error": 0.58742,
"abs_formula_diff": 0.00311,
"mc_majority_false_consensus_rate": 0.82437,
"mean_quorum_latency_s": 1.3554,
"p95_quorum_latency_s": 1.8028
},
{
"k": 35,
"phi_eff": 0.5556,
"analytical_elem_error": 0.55347,
"mc_elem_error": 0.55101,
"abs_formula_diff": 0.00246,
"mc_majority_false_consensus_rate": 0.7205,
"mean_quorum_latency_s": 1.7786,
"p95_quorum_latency_s": 2.3147
},
{
"k": 41,
"phi_eff": 0.6508,
"analytical_elem_error": 0.51731,
"mc_elem_error": 0.51575,
"abs_formula_diff": 0.00156,
"mc_majority_false_consensus_rate": 0.57637,
"mean_quorum_latency_s": 2.305,
"p95_quorum_latency_s": 2.9616
},
{
"k": 47,
"phi_eff": 0.746,
"analytical_elem_error": 0.48215,
"mc_elem_error": 0.48118,
"abs_formula_diff": 0.00097,
"mc_majority_false_consensus_rate": 0.40163,
"mean_quorum_latency_s": 2.9925,
"p95_quorum_latency_s": 3.8045
},
{
"k": 55,
"phi_eff": 0.873,
"analytical_elem_error": 0.43714,
"mc_elem_error": 0.43694,
"abs_formula_diff": 0.0002,
"mc_majority_false_consensus_rate": 0.1785,
"mean_quorum_latency_s": 4.4678,
"p95_quorum_latency_s": 5.7056
},
{
"k": 63,
"phi_eff": 1.0,
"analytical_elem_error": 0.395,
"mc_elem_error": 0.39525,
"abs_formula_diff": 0.00025,
"mc_majority_false_consensus_rate": 0.04537,
"mean_quorum_latency_s": 10.5123,
"p95_quorum_latency_s": 15.85
}
]
}
],
"multi_option_plurality_verification": [
{
"num_options": 4,
"trap_concentration_theta": 0.8,
"plurality_error_threshold_1_over_1plus_theta": 0.5556,
"phi_crit_theta": 0.55013,
"N": 63,
"k": 21,
"sync_plurality_error_mc": 0.006,
"fast_plurality_false_consensus_mc": 0.72488
},
{
"num_options": 4,
"trap_concentration_theta": 0.65,
"plurality_error_threshold_1_over_1plus_theta": 0.6061,
"phi_crit_theta": 0.42102,
"N": 63,
"k": 21,
"sync_plurality_error_mc": 0.00076,
"fast_plurality_false_consensus_mc": 0.55196
}
]
},
"theorem2_cascade_amplification": {
"fast_k_of_n": {
"per_stage_error": 0.56,
"beta_herd": 0.72,
"amplification_factor_rho": 0.3168,
"asymptotic_error_floor": 0.81967,
"stages": [
{
"stage": 1,
"analytical_cascade_error": 0.56,
"mc_cascade_error": 0.55745,
"abs_diff": 0.00255,
"stage_m_output_accuracy": 0.44255,
"analytical_joint_m_stage_accuracy": 0.44,
"mc_joint_m_stage_accuracy": 0.44255
},
{
"stage": 2,
"analytical_cascade_error": 0.73741,
"mc_cascade_error": 0.7367,
"abs_diff": 0.00071,
"stage_m_output_accuracy": 0.2633,
"analytical_joint_m_stage_accuracy": 0.1936,
"mc_joint_m_stage_accuracy": 0.19423
},
{
"stage": 3,
"analytical_cascade_error": 0.79361,
"mc_cascade_error": 0.79297,
"abs_diff": 0.00064,
"stage_m_output_accuracy": 0.20703,
"analytical_joint_m_stage_accuracy": 0.08518,
"mc_joint_m_stage_accuracy": 0.08585
},
{
"stage": 4,
"analytical_cascade_error": 0.81142,
"mc_cascade_error": 0.80805,
"abs_diff": 0.00337,
"stage_m_output_accuracy": 0.19195,
"analytical_joint_m_stage_accuracy": 0.03748,
"mc_joint_m_stage_accuracy": 0.03818
},
{
"stage": 5,
"analytical_cascade_error": 0.81706,
"mc_cascade_error": 0.8154,
"abs_diff": 0.00166,
"stage_m_output_accuracy": 0.1846,
"analytical_joint_m_stage_accuracy": 0.01649,
"mc_joint_m_stage_accuracy": 0.01715
},
{
"stage": 6,
"analytical_cascade_error": 0.81884,
"mc_cascade_error": 0.8185,
"abs_diff": 0.00034,
"stage_m_output_accuracy": 0.1815,
"analytical_joint_m_stage_accuracy": 0.00726,
"mc_joint_m_stage_accuracy": 0.0078
}
]
},
"quorumguard": {
"per_stage_error": 0.055,
"beta_herd": 0.72,
"amplification_factor_rho": 0.6804,
"asymptotic_error_floor": 0.17209,
"stages": [
{
"stage": 1,
"analytical_cascade_error": 0.055,
"mc_cascade_error": 0.05362,
"abs_diff": 0.00138,
"stage_m_output_accuracy": 0.94637,
"analytical_joint_m_stage_accuracy": 0.945,
"mc_joint_m_stage_accuracy": 0.94637
},
{
"stage": 2,
"analytical_cascade_error": 0.09242,
"mc_cascade_error": 0.0931,
"abs_diff": 0.00068,
"stage_m_output_accuracy": 0.9069,
"analytical_joint_m_stage_accuracy": 0.89302,
"mc_joint_m_stage_accuracy": 0.89302
},
{
"stage": 3,
"analytical_cascade_error": 0.11788,
"mc_cascade_error": 0.11845,
"abs_diff": 0.00057,
"stage_m_output_accuracy": 0.88155,
"analytical_joint_m_stage_accuracy": 0.84391,
"mc_joint_m_stage_accuracy": 0.8432
},
{
"stage": 4,
"analytical_cascade_error": 0.13521,
"mc_cascade_error": 0.1329,
"abs_diff": 0.00231,
"stage_m_output_accuracy": 0.8671,
"analytical_joint_m_stage_accuracy": 0.79749,
"mc_joint_m_stage_accuracy": 0.79837
},
{
"stage": 5,
"analytical_cascade_error": 0.147,
"mc_cascade_error": 0.14583,
"abs_diff": 0.00117,
"stage_m_output_accuracy": 0.85418,
"analytical_joint_m_stage_accuracy": 0.75363,
"mc_joint_m_stage_accuracy": 0.75438
},
{
"stage": 6,
"analytical_cascade_error": 0.15502,
"mc_cascade_error": 0.1529,
"abs_diff": 0.00212,
"stage_m_output_accuracy": 0.8471,
"analytical_joint_m_stage_accuracy": 0.71218,
"mc_joint_m_stage_accuracy": 0.71257
}
]
}
},
"theorem3_cvar_optimality": {
"three_path_risk_verification": {
"num_options": 4,
"k_min": 3,
"zeta_blind": 0.04,
"eta_clean": 0.14,
"eta_hedge": 0.07,
"eta_sync": 0.11,
"path_probs": {
"clean": 0.42,
"hedge": 0.48,
"fallback": 0.1
},
"mc_empirical_stage_error": 0.06456,
"mc_standard_error": 0.00025,
"theorem3_1_upper_bound": 0.06486,
"bound_holds_within_mc_se": true
},
"preemptive_resume_mg1_verification": [
{
"rho": 0.58,
"rho_hi": 0.2729,
"w_fcfs_analytical_s": 4.0213,
"w_fcfs_sim_s": 3.8897,
"w_hi_quantum_analytical_s": 1.948,
"w_hi_quantum_sim_s": 1.8843,
"w_norm_pr_analytical_s": 6.2968,
"w_norm_pr_sim_s": 5.8556
},
{
"rho": 0.72,
"rho_hi": 0.3387,
"w_fcfs_analytical_s": 7.4879,
"w_fcfs_sim_s": 7.4643,
"w_hi_quantum_analytical_s": 2.6591,
"w_hi_quantum_sim_s": 2.7365,
"w_norm_pr_analytical_s": 12.3697,
"w_norm_pr_sim_s": 12.07
},
{
"rho": 0.85,
"rho_hi": 0.3999,
"w_fcfs_analytical_s": 16.5011,
"w_fcfs_sim_s": 15.995,
"w_hi_quantum_analytical_s": 3.4592,
"w_hi_quantum_sim_s": 3.4152,
"w_norm_pr_analytical_s": 28.8577,
"w_norm_pr_sim_s": 27.5526
},
{
"rho": 0.93,
"rho_hi": 0.4375,
"w_fcfs_analytical_s": 38.6874,
"w_fcfs_sim_s": 43.6709,
"w_hi_quantum_analytical_s": 4.038,
"w_hi_quantum_sim_s": 4.0453,
"w_norm_pr_analytical_s": 70.3695,
"w_norm_pr_sim_s": 79.6165
}
],
"policy_monte_carlo": {
"Fast_3_of_7": {
"accuracy": 0.503,
"false_consensus_risk": 0.497,
"mean_latency_s": 0.9904,
"p95_latency_s": 1.2614,
"cvar95_latency_s": 1.2917
},
"Sync_7_of_7": {
"accuracy": 0.7088,
"false_consensus_risk": 0.2912,
"mean_latency_s": 7.4281,
"p95_latency_s": 15.3483,
"cvar95_latency_s": 19.6111
},
"Genealogy_Sync_HPR": {
"accuracy": 0.929,
"false_consensus_risk": 0.071,
"mean_latency_s": 7.4281,
"p95_latency_s": 15.3483,
"cvar95_latency_s": 19.6111
}
}
}
}