Dataset Viewer
Auto-converted to Parquet Duplicate
arxiv
float64
2k
2.61k
architecture
stringlengths
3
15
stratum
stringclasses
5 values
category
stringclasses
2 values
claim
stringlengths
30
200
claim_page
int64
1
7
claim_quote
stringlengths
53
247
ablation_level
stringclasses
3 values
ablation_page
float64
0
47
⌀
ablation_quote
stringlengths
64
204
⌀
decided_by
stringclasses
4 values
2,007.14062
big_bird
2020-2022
ARCH
BigBird sparse attention mechanism (random + window + global tokens) whose complexity is linear in sequence length
1
To remedy this, we propose, B IG B IRD, a sparse attention mechanism that reduces this quadratic dependency to linear.
PARTIAL
4
We found that random blocks and local window were insufficient in capturing all the context necessary to compete with the performance of BERT.
third model (pair)
2,007.14062
big_bird
2020-2022
ARCH
Global tokens (ITC/ETC) attending to the entire sequence are critical for expressivity and performance
1
our theoretical analysis reveals some of the benefits of having O(1) global tokens (such as CLS), that attend to the entire sequence as part of the sparse attention mechanism.
NO
null
null
third model (pair)
2,003.10555
electra
2020-2022
TRAIN
Replaced token detection: a new, more sample-efficient pre-training task in which a discriminator predicts, for every input token, whether a small generator replaced it
1
As an alternative, we propose a more sample-efficient pre-training task called replaced token detection.
YES
6
To provide a fair comparison, we also train a BERT-Small model using the same hyperparameters.
third model (A_only)
2,003.10555
electra
2020-2022
TRAIN
Learning from all input tokens rather than the masked subset makes the task more compute-efficient than MLM
1
A key advantage of our discriminative task is that the model learns from all input tokens instead of just the small masked-out subset, making it more computationally efficient.
YES
8
First, we find that ELECTRA is greatly benefiting from having a loss defined over all input tokens rather than just a subset: ELECTRA 15% performs much worse than ELECTRA.
third model (A_only)
2,001.0821
mbart
2020-2022
TRAIN
mBART is the first method to pre-train a complete sequence-to-sequence model by denoising full texts in multiple languages
1
mBART is the first method for pre-training a complete sequence-to-sequence model by
PARTIAL
4
Table 2: Low/Medium Resource Machine Translation Pre-training consistently improves over a randomly ini-
both coders
2,206.12131
mvp
2020-2022
TRAIN
Pre-train task-specific soft (prefix) prompts per task to stimulate task capacity and mitigate multi-task neutralization
2
To mitigate this potential issue, we propose to learn
NO
null
null
third model (pair)
2,206.12131
mvp
2020-2022
TRAIN
Supervised pre-training (with labeled data) for NLG-oriented PLMs, rather than unsupervised pre-training
2
To fill this gap, we explore supervised pre-training and multi-task learning for deriving
NO
null
null
third model (A_only)
2,001.04063
prophetnet
2020-2022
TRAIN
Novel self-supervised objective: future n-gram prediction, i.e. predicting the next n tokens at once at each time step
3
For simplicity, we take bigram (n = 2) as an example to introduce ProphetNet, whose modeling target is
NO
null
null
third model (A_only)
2,001.04063
prophetnet
2020-2022
ARCH
Proposed n-stream self-attention in the decoder (extends XLNet two-stream attention), with main and predicting streams that can be switched off at inference
4
N-stream self-attention mechanism which contains a main stream self-attention and n predicting stream self-attention.
PARTIAL
7
Transformer (Raffel et al., 2019) 39.19 17.60 36.69 ProphetNetw/o pre-train 40.66 18.05 37.79
third model (A_only)
2,205.06266
xmod
2020-2022
ARCH
Language-specific modular components pre-trained from the start (X-MOD) mitigate negative interference between languages and achieve positive transfer
2
that our modular architecture not only is effective at mitigating interference between languages, but also
YES
7
Table 2: Pre-trained language results for the modular and shared model variants, pre-trained on the set of 60
third model (pair)
2,309.11419
kosmos2_5
2023
TRAIN
Two complementary pre-training tasks: document-level text recognition (spatially-aware text with bounding boxes) and image-to-markdown generation, unified via task prompts
2
KOSMOS -2.5 is a multimodal document foundation model that takes text images as input and generates spatially-aware
NO
null
null
third model (A_only)
2,312.00752
mamba
2023
ARCH
Selection mechanism: making SSM parameters (Δ, B, C) input-dependent (selective SSM / S6)
1
simply letting the SSM parameters be functions of the input addresses their weakness with discrete modalities
YES
32
Replacing any of these with a selective SSM (S6) significantly improves performance, validating the motivation of Section 3.
both coders
2,312.00752
mamba
2023
ARCH
Simplified homogeneous Mamba block architecture without attention or MLP blocks
1
We integrate these selective SSMs into a simplified end-to-end neural network architecture without attention or even MLP blocks (Mamba)
YES
33
The Mamba architecture performs similarly to the H3 architecture (and seems slightly better when using a selective layer).
both coders
2,310.06825
mistral
2023
ARCH
Uses sliding window attention (SWA) to handle sequences of arbitrary length at reduced inference cost
1
coupled with sliding window attention (SWA) to effectively handle sequences of arbitrary length with a reduced inference cost.
NO
null
null
both coders
2,310.06825
mistral
2023
ARCH
Uses grouped-query attention (GQA) for faster inference and lower decoding memory
1
GQA significantly accelerates the inference speed, and also reduces the memory requirement during decoding, allowing for higher batch sizes hence higher throughput
NO
null
null
both coders
2,410.05993
aria
2024
ARCH
First open mixture-of-experts model that is multimodal native
1
In this report, we present A RIA, the first open mixture-of-experts (MoE) model that is multimodal native.
NO
null
null
both coders
2,410.05993
aria
2024
TRAIN
4-stage training pipeline that progressively adds capabilities
2
We design a 4-stage training pipeline, including language pre-training, multimodal pre-training, multimodal long-context pre-training, and multimodal post-training.
NO
null
null
both coders
2,410.05993
aria
2024
ARCH
Lightweight 438M visual encoder handles variable-length, variable-size and variable-aspect visual input
1
Visual input of variable length, size, and aspect is encoded as visual tokens using a
NO
null
null
both coders
2,412.19437
deepseek_v3
2024
TRAIN
Multi-Token Prediction training objective improves model performance and enables speculative decoding
5
We investigate a Multi-Token Prediction (MTP) objective and prove it beneficial to model performance. It can also be used for speculative decoding for inference acceleration.
YES
26
On top of them, keeping the training data and the other architectures the same, we append a 1-depth MTP module onto them and train two models with the MTP strategy for comparison.
both coders
2,412.19437
deepseek_v3
2024
ARCH
Pioneers an auxiliary-loss-free load balancing strategy for MoE that minimizes performance degradation from load balancing
5
we pioneer an auxiliary-loss-free strategy for load balancing, which minimizes the performance degradation that arises from encouraging load balancing.
YES
27
On top of these two baseline models, keeping the training data and the other architectures the same, we remove all auxiliary losses and introduce the auxiliary-loss-free balancing strategy for comparison.
both coders
2,412.19437
deepseek_v3
2024
TRAIN
FP8 mixed-precision framework, with first validation on an extremely large-scale model.
5
We design an FP8 mixed precision training framework and, for the first time, validate the feasibility and effectiveness of FP8 training on an extremely large-scale model.
PARTIAL
47
We validate our FP8 mixed precision framework with a comparison to BF16 training on top of two baseline models across different scales.
third model (B_only)
2,409.18869
emu3
2024
ARCH
Emu3: multimodal models trained solely with next-token prediction; a single transformer trained from scratch on mixed image/text/video token sequences, without diffusion or compositional architectures
1
By tokenizing images, text, and videos into a discrete space, we train a single transformer from scratch on a mixture of multimodal sequences.
NO
null
null
both coders
2,410.05355
falcon_mamba
2024
ARCH
Falcon Mamba 7B is a new base LLM with a pure Mamba (attention-free) architecture and the first SSLM in the Falcon series, presented as the first competitive attention-free 7B model
2
We introduce Falcon Mamba 7B — a base (pre-trained) model with pure mamba architecture design, and the first State Space Language Model (SSLM) in the FalconLLM series.
NO
null
null
both coders
2,410.05355
falcon_mamba
2024
ARCH
A pure Mamba design can match or beat Transformer and hybrid designs
1
we demonstrate that even the pure Mamba design can achieve similar, even superior results compared to the Transformer and hybrid designs.
PARTIAL
0
null
third model (A_only)
2,408.00118
gemma2
2024
TRAIN
Training 2B and 9B models with knowledge distillation instead of next-token prediction
1
and 9B models with knowledge distillation (Hinton et al., 2015) instead of next token prediction.
YES
5
In Table 6, we show that distilling from a larger model improves
both coders
2,408.00118
gemma2
2024
ARCH
Interleaving local sliding-window and global attention layers (known technique applied)
1
several known technical modifications to the Transformer architecture, such as interleaving local-global attentions (Beltagy et al., 2020a)
NO
null
null
both coders
2,405.2106
mamba2
2024
ARCH
Mamba-2 architecture combining parallel block with SSD as inner SSM layer
2
The combination of the modified parallel Mamba block, together with using SSD as the inner SSM layer, results in the Mamba-2 architecture.
PARTIAL
33
Surprisingly, it is significantly better than Mamba-1 even when the state sizes are controlled (N = 16).
both coders
2,405.2106
mamba2
2024
ARCH
Introduce heads from multi-head attention to SSMs (head structure design, MVA/MIS pattern)
2
For example, we introduce the analog of heads from multi-head attention (MHA) to SSMs.
YES
35
Table 5 ablates choices of the multi-head structure for the Mamba-2 architecture.
third model (pair)
2,405.2106
mamba2
2024
ARCH
Modified Mamba block with grouped-value head structure and parallel data-dependent projections at block start
2
The main ideas include introducing grouped-value attention (GVA) head structure, and moving all data-dependent projections to occur in parallel at the beginning of the block.
PARTIAL
35
Table 4 ablates these architecture changes to the block, which occur outside of the core SSM layer.
third model (pair)
2,405.2106
mamba2
2024
ARCH
Generalize linear attention to structured masked attention.
2
tensor contractions, and then generalize it to a new family of structured masked attention (SMA) (Section 4).
NO
null
null
third model (B_only)
2,410.00037
moshi
2024
TRAIN
Inner Monologue: predicting time-aligned text tokens as prefix to audio tokens
3
we introduce Inner Monologue, a new training and inference setup for audio language models that significantly improves the factuality and linguistic quality of generated speech
YES
26
Finally, the most drastic improvement to the quality and length of generated speech comes from enabling Inner Monologue.
both coders
2,410.00037
moshi
2024
ARCH
New hierarchical streaming architecture (Helium + small Depth Transformer, RQ-Transformer) for audio tokens
3
a new architecture for audio language modeling, which combines Helium with a smaller Transformer (Vaswani et al., 2017) model to predict audio
YES
26
In that context, modeling RVQ tokens with an RQ-Transformer significantly improves perplexity over using separate classification heads.
third model (A_only)
2,410.00037
moshi
2024
ARCH
First multi-stream audio language model for full-duplex dialogue
2
We furthermore introduce the first multi-stream audio language model, i.e. a model that explicitly processes the input and output audio streams jointly into two autoregressive token streams.
NO
null
null
third model (A_only)
2,410.00037
moshi
2024
TRAIN
Introduce improved training tricks for Mimi's semantic-acoustic codec.
3
first level of acoustic tokens and introduce improved training tricks.
YES
24
This human evaluation shows a significant improve- ment from using adversarial losses only, with a MUSHRA score of 81.0 against 58.8 when using the mix of loss functions used in Encodec.
third model (B_only)
2,409.0206
olmoe
2024
ARCH
Dropless token-choice routing outperforms expert-choice routing
3
we find dropless [58] token-based routing [154] outperforms expert-based routing [219]
YES
11
Both models have an 8-expert MoE in every 2nd layer. For TC, 2 experts are activated per token
both coders
2,409.0206
olmoe
2024
ARCH
Fine-grained routing with 64 small experts, 8 active, is critical
3
One critical design decision for making MoEs performant is the use of fine-grained routing with granular experts [42]: we employ 64 small experts in each layer
YES
10
We vary the number of experts in tandem with the FFN dimension to ensure that active and total parameters and thus compute cost remain the same.
both coders
2,409.0206
olmoe
2024
ARCH
Shared experts are ineffective
3
Our findings also include those that challenge prior work, such as the ineffectiveness of shared experts
YES
10
While both settings lead to similar performance, sharing an expert performs slightly worse.
both coders
2,409.0206
olmoe
2024
TRAIN
Sparse upcycling from a dense model has limited benefits except at small compute budgets
3
challenge prior work, such as the ineffectiveness of shared experts [42] and the limited benefits of sparsely
YES
12
We find that after 500B tokens, an otherwise equivalent MoE trained from scratch already catches up with the upcycled model
third model (pair)
2,404.07839
recurrent_gemma
2024
ARCH
RecurrentGemma uses the Griffin architecture, which combines linear recurrences with local attention and has a fixed-size state
1
Griffin combines linear recurrences with local attention to achieve excellent performance on language. It has a fixed-sized state, which reduces memory use and enables efficient inference on long sequences.
PARTIAL
2
Gemma-2B was trained on 3T tokens and Gemma-7B was trained on 6T tokens, while both RecurrentGemma-2B and RecurrentGemma-9B were trained on 2T tokens.
both coders
2,411.15242
zamba2
2024
ARCH
Rotary position embeddings in the shared attention blocks improve performance
2
We apply Rotary Position Embeddings (Su et al., 2023)
NO
null
null
both coders
2,411.15242
zamba2
2024
ARCH
Two alternating shared attention blocks instead of a single shared block, which improves performance against parameter-matched baselines
2
We use two alternating shared attention blocks instead
NO
null
null
both coders
2,411.15242
zamba2
2024
ARCH
Non-shared LoRAs applied to the shared transformer blocks
2
et al., 2021) to the shared transformer blocks (Attention,
NO
null
null
both coders
2,411.15242
zamba2
2024
ARCH
Switched from a Mamba1 to a Mamba2 backbone, which allows a larger state size at the same throughput
2
for a larger state-size than is possible in Mamba1, which
NO
null
null
third model (A_only)
2,507.11407
exaone4
2025
ARCH
Hybrid global/local (sliding window) attention to reduce compute with minimal degradation
1
a hybrid architecture combining global attention and local attention is adopted. This approach minimizes performance degradation while reducing computational costs
NO
null
null
both coders
2,508.06471
glm4_moe
2025
TRAIN
Multi-stage pre-/mid-training on 23T tokens
1
Through multi-stage training on 23T tokens and comprehensive post-training with expert model iteration and reinforcement learning
NO
null
null
both coders
2,508.06471
glm4_moe
2025
ARCH
GLM-4.5 is an open-source MoE LLM with 355B total parameters and 32B activated parameters
1
We present GLM-4.5, an open-source Mixture-of-Experts (MoE) large language model with 355B total parameters and 32B activated parameters
NO
null
null
both coders
2,506.21734
hrm_text
2025
TRAIN
One-step gradient approximation removes the need for BPTT and uses O(1) memory
3
we propose a one-step gradient approximation for training HRM, which offers
NO
null
null
both coders
2,506.21734
hrm_text
2025
ARCH
Hierarchical Reasoning Model: a new recurrent architecture with two coupled modules, a slow high-level module and a fast low-level module
1
we propose the Hierarchical Reasoning Model (HRM), a novel recurrent architecture that attains significant computational depth
PARTIAL
12
retains the exact training setup of HRM but swaps in a Transformer architecture
both coders
2,506.21734
hrm_text
2025
ARCH
Hierarchical convergence avoids the premature convergence of standard recurrent models
3
avoids the rapid convergence of standard recurrent models through a process we term
PARTIAL
3
Standard architectures saturates, failing to benefit from increased depth. HRM overcomes this fundamental limitation
third model (A_only)
2,506.21734
hrm_text
2025
TRAIN
Deep supervision across segments, with the hidden state detached between segments
7
we incorporate a deep supervision mechanism into HRM, as detailed next.
NO
null
null
third model (A_only)
2,506.21734
hrm_text
2025
TRAIN
Adaptive computation time (halting learned with Q-learning), which also gives inference-time scaling
7
Inspired by the above mechanism, we incorporate an adaptive halting strategy into HRM that
PARTIAL
8
Figure 5 presents a performance comparison between two HRM variants: one incorporating ACT and another employing a fixed computational step count
third model (A_only)
2,510.26692
kimi_linear
2025
ARCH
Kimi Delta Attention (KDA): linear attention refining gated delta rule with fine-grained channel-wise gating
2
Kimi Delta Attention (KDA): a linear attention mechanism that refines the gated delta rule with improved recurrent
YES
9
hybrid Gated DeltaNet (GDN-H) baseline, all of which share the same architecture, parameter count, and training setup
both coders
2,510.26692
kimi_linear
2025
ARCH
Kimi Linear hybrid architecture with 3:1 KDA-to-global attention ratio
2
The Kimi Linear architecture: a hybrid design adopting a 3:1 KDA-to-global attention ratio, reducing memory
PARTIAL
8
All models were trained with the same FLOPs budget and hyperparameters for a fair comparison.
third model (pair)
2,509.01322
longcat_flash
2025
TRAIN
Model-growth initialization from half-scale checkpoint
4
We initialize the model using a model-growth mechanism based on a refined half-scale checkpoint, achieving improved performance compared to conventional initialization methods
PARTIAL
10
Validataion loss curve of a 6B activated MoE model in model growth experiments
both coders
2,509.01322
longcat_flash
2025
ARCH
Shortcut-connected MoE (ScMoE) to expand computation-communication overlap
4
we incorporate the Shortcut-connected MoE (ScMoE) [Cai et al., 2024] design to expand the computation-communication overlap window
PARTIAL
8
Training loss curves comparing baseline models (without ScMoE) against their ScMoE-enhanced counterparts across four different model configurations
both coders
2,509.01322
longcat_flash
2025
TRAIN
Hyperparameter transfer from smaller proxy models
4
We successfully apply a hyperparameter transfer strategy to such a large model, predicting optimal hyperparameter configurations by leveraging results from smaller proxy models
NO
null
null
both coders
2,509.01322
longcat_flash
2025
ARCH
Zero-computation experts for dynamic per-token computation budget (18.6B-31.3B active)
4
we introduce the zero-computation experts mechanism in MoE blocks to allocate a dynamic computation budget to important tokens based on their significance
PARTIAL
7
Validation loss curve comparing models with/without zero-computation experts under matched computation
both coders
2,509.01322
longcat_flash
2025
TRAIN
Multi-pronged stability suite: router-gradient balancing, hidden z-loss, optimizer configuration
4
A multi-pronged stability suite incorporates principled router-gradient balancing, a hidden z-loss to suppress massive activations, and fine-tuned optimizer configurations
PARTIAL
15
The introduction of a negligible-coefficient hidden z-loss stabilizes the norm curve without degrading training loss.
third model (pair)
2,509.01322
longcat_flash
2025
TRAIN
PID-controlled expert bias maintains the average computation budget.
4
To ensure consistent computation load, we employ expert bias adjusted by a PID-controller, maintaining an average of ∼27 billion activated parameters per token.
NO
null
null
third model (B_only)
2,509.01322
longcat_flash
2025
TRAIN
Hidden z-loss suppresses massive activations for training stability.
4
a hidden z-loss to suppress massive activations, and fine-tuned optimizer configurations.
PARTIAL
15
The introduction of a negligible-coefficient hidden z-loss stabilizes the norm curve without degrading training loss.
third model (B_only)
2,509.01322
longcat_flash
2025
TRAIN
Fine-tuned optimizer configurations improve large-scale training stability.
4
A multi-pronged stability suite incorporates principled router-gradient balancing, a hidden z-loss to suppress massive activations, and fine-tuned optimizer configurations.
PARTIAL
16
Exploring the impact of the Root Mean Square (RMS) norm of gradients and epsilon on loss across different model sizes.
third model (B_only)
2,509.01322
longcat_flash
2025
TRAIN
Deterministic computation ensures exact reproducibility and enables silent-data-corruption detection.
4
To enhance the reliability of large-scale cluster training, we introduce deterministic computation. This guarantees the exact reproducibility of experiments and enables the detection of SDC (Silent Data Corruption) during the training process.
NO
null
null
third model (B_only)
2,501.08313
minimax
2025
ARCH
Hybrid architecture: one softmax-attention block after every seven lightning-attention (transnormer) blocks
2
In the architecture, one transformer block with softmax attention follows every seven transnormer blocks (Qin et al., 2022a) with lightning attention.
YES
12
For every 8 consecutive layers in the base model, we systematically replace softmax attention with lightning attention in the first 7 layers.
both coders
2,501.08313
minimax
2025
TRAIN
Novel global router load-balancing strategy for MoE training stability
4
To ensure load balancing in the MoE blocks, we propose a novel load balancing strategy inspired by GShard (Lepikhin et al., 2021), which we refer to the global router.
NO
null
null
third model (A_only)
2,501.08313
minimax
2025
ARCH
Integrate lightning attention with MoE to maximize parameter and computational capacity.
1
To maximize computational capacity, we integrate it with Mixture of Experts (MoE), creating a model with 32 experts and 456 billion total parameters, of
PARTIAL
5
a dense model with 7 billion parameters and an MoE model with 2 billion activation parameters out of a total of 24 billion parameters.
third model (B_only)
2,503.01743
phi4_multimodal
2025
ARCH
Group query attention for more efficient long-sequence generation
1
as well as group query attention for more efficient long-sequence generation
NO
null
null
both coders
2,503.01743
phi4_multimodal
2025
ARCH
Novel mixture-of-LoRAs modality extension with modality-specific LoRAs and routers on a frozen base LM, unifying text, vision and speech in one model
1
Its novel modality extension approach leverages LoRA adapters and modality-specific routers to allow multiple inference modes combining various modalities without interference.
NO
null
null
third model (pair)
2,512.24618
youtu
2025
TRAIN
Commonsense-STEM-Agent multi-stage curriculum progressively shifting data distribution
1
By progressively shifting the pre-training data distribution from general commonsense to complex STEM and agentic tasks, we ensure the model acquires deep cognitive abilities
NO
null
null
both coders
2,512.24618
youtu
2025
ARCH
Dense Multi-Latent Attention (MLA) architecture for a lightweight 1.96B model
1
Built on a dense Multi-Latent Attention (MLA) architecture with a novel STEM-oriented vocabulary, Youtu-LLM supports a 128k context window.
YES
16
We compared GQA and MLA by pre-training 1B-parameter models from scratch on 500B tokens.
both coders
2,512.24618
youtu
2025
TRAIN
Principled agent-centric training paradigm (agentic mid-training) inducing native agentic capabilities
3
We propose a principled training paradigm that enhances native agentic capabilities through innovations in tokenizer design, data allocation, and multi-stage learning, guided by an agent-centric philosophy.
PARTIAL
29
Table 14. Performance of post-trained models with and without agentic mid-training (AMT).
both coders
2,606.19348
deepseek_v4
2026
TRAIN
Muon optimizer for faster convergence and training stability
4
we introduce the Muon (Jordan et al., 2024; Liu et al., 2025) optimizer to the training of DeepSeek-V4 series, leading to faster convergence and improved training stability.
NO
null
null
both coders
2,606.19348
deepseek_v4
2026
ARCH
Manifold-Constrained Hyper-Connections (mHC) replacing/upgrading conventional residual connections
4
To strengthen modeling capability, we incorporate Manifold-Constrained Hyper-Connections (mHC) (Xie et al., 2026) that upgrade conventional residual connections.
NO
null
null
both coders
2,606.19348
deepseek_v4
2026
ARCH
Hybrid attention architecture combining Compressed Sparse Attention (CSA) and Heavily Compressed Attention (HCA) for long-context efficiency
1
a hybrid attention architecture that combines Compressed Sparse Attention (CSA) and Heavily Compressed Attention (HCA) to improve long-context efficiency
NO
null
null
third model (A_only)

The novelty exposed: 40 coded LLM technical reports

Dataset for the paper The novelty exposed: ablation, reproducibility and transparency in 40 technical reports of open-weight large language models (LLMs) (Bahaeddin Türkoğlu, 2026).

Code, protocol and raw coder outputs: https://github.com/bturkoglu/llm-novelty-exposed (archived: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24340455)

Configurations

Config Rows Content
claims (default) 73 Architectural/training novelty claims in 40 randomly sampled reports: category, claim, page, verbatim quote, ablation level (YES = controlled with/without comparison, PARTIAL = confounded, NO), supporting quote, and whether the value came from coder agreement or the resolver
reports 40 One row per report: number of claims and their ablation levels, training runs stated, baselines rerun, scores copied, third-party evaluation, data mixture / token / compute disclosure, reporting rules met
sampling_frame 171 Causal LM architectures in Hugging Face transformers (commit 0d7a6219): date added, linked arXiv report, eligibility and reason, stratum year, sampled or not

coding/final_verified.json holds the full final coding with every quote checked against the report text by script.

from datasets import load_dataset
claims = load_dataset("bturkoglu/llm-novelty-exposed", "claims", split="train")

How it was made

40 reports were drawn at random (seed 20261114, stratified by year) from the eligible architectures. Two independent model coders from different vendors (Claude Opus 5.5, GPT-6.1 Sol) coded each report with the same pre-registered protocol; every quote was verified against the page-numbered text by script; disagreements were resolved by a third model family (Grok 4.7) under the same rule. Inter-coder agreement is reported in the paper (Table A1).

Limitations

The coding records what the reports state; it does not judge model quality, and an untested claim may still be true. Coders are language models, not human annotators. Report PDFs are not included; use the arXiv ids.

Licence

CC BY 4.0. Quotes are short excerpts from the cited reports; their copyright stays with the original authors.

Citation

@misc{turkoglu2026novelty,
  author        = {T{\"u}rko{\u{g}}lu, Bahaeddin},
  title         = {The novelty exposed: ablation, reproducibility and transparency in 40 technical reports of
                   open-weight large language models ({LLMs})},
  year          = {2026},
  eprint        = {2611.20003},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  primaryClass  = {cs.CL},
  url           = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2611.20003}
}
Downloads last month
-

Paper for bturkoglu/llm-novelty-exposed