intelligence-ladder / README.md
issaquahd's picture
Add data/leaderboard.jsonl and point the leaderboard config at it (viewer failed reading the CSV with the JSON builder)
79bfbc7 verified
|
Raw History Blame Contribute Delete
6.69 kB
---
license: cc-by-4.0
language:
- en
pretty_name: Intelligence Ladder
size_categories:
- 1K<n<10K
task_categories:
- text-generation
tags:
- code
- benchmark
- evaluation
- llm-evaluation
- edge-ai
- python
configs:
- config_name: results
data_files:
- split: train
path: data/results.jsonl
- config_name: leaderboard
data_files:
- split: train
path: data/leaderboard.jsonl
---
# Intelligence Ladder
Per-trial results and frozen task files for a seven-rung, behaviourally graded Python coding benchmark.
It measures how far up a ladder of harder task families a model climbs under one fixed protocol, and
how consistently, for hosted API models and a 4B model on an owned edge NPU node.
## Dataset summary
- **1309 trials** across 8 models: 28 tasks (7 rungs x 4) x (3 productive + 3 trap repeats) = 168 per
model; `qwen-plus` has 133 (stopped during R6, R7 not run).
- **Grading is behavioural only**: hidden asserts run under pytest, planted mutants, existing and feature
test suites. No LLM judge, no text similarity.
- **Traps**: an impossible variant of each task whose only correct answer is `UNKNOWN`. Traps are reported
separately and never rescue productive failures.
- **Solved task**: at least 2 of 3 productive repeats pass.
| Rung | Family |
|---|---|
| R1 | Simple functions |
| R2 | Edge cases / Unicode / nonmutation |
| R3 | Three-file package repairs |
| R4 | Tool-mediated debugging (simulated `read` tool, exact call accounting) |
| R5 | Bounded two-turn revisions (revised spec must reject the old behaviour) |
| R6 | Implementation plus self-authored tests that kill at least 4 of 5 planted mutants |
| R7 | Multi-file package feature (three required source files changed; existing and feature tests green) |
## Configurations
### `results` (`data/results.jsonl`)
One row per trial.
| Field | Type | Meaning |
|---|---|---|
| `id` | string | `<task>-<code|trap>-<repeat>` |
| `task`, `rung`, `repeat`, `trap` | string, int, int, bool | Task id (e.g. `R4-C`), rung 1–7, repeat 1–3, trap flag |
| `model` | string | Result label; see `data/models.json` for model ref, route and hardware class |
| `freeze_sha256` | string | sha256 of the freeze manifest the trial ran under (both shipped in `frozen/`) |
| `score.pass` | bool | Trial verdict |
| `score.*` | mixed | Structural fields by rung: `returncode`, `kind` (trap), `tool_exact`, `actual_calls`, `initial`/`final`/`obsolete_rejected` (R5), `behavior`/`tests_on_reference`/`mutants`/`mutants_killed`/`mutation_kill_rate` (R6), `existing`/`feature`/`changed_paths` (R7), `error` (harness rejection message only) |
| `wall_s` | float | Trial wall time, seconds, including transport and scoring |
| `turn_metrics[]` | list | Per model turn: `wall_s`, `ttft_s`, `tok_s`, `inference_s` (RK1), `output_tokens`, `usage.{prompt,completion,total,reasoning,cached}_tokens` where the route reports them, `metric_source` |
| `evaluation_repair` | string | Present on 3 rows re-scored from the saved answer with the frozen evaluator (no new model call) |
`score` has a rung-dependent shape; load with `json` if your tooling needs a fixed schema.
### `leaderboard` (`data/leaderboard.jsonl`, same rows as `results/leaderboard.csv`)
One row per model, generated by `reproduce.py --write` from `data/results.jsonl`: tasks solved with
cluster-bootstrap 95% CI, productive pass rate with CI, eligible families, ladder height, trap abstention,
coverage, token totals, median and p90 trial wall time, median TTFT and median tok/s (non-reasoning turns).
## Frozen files
`frozen/` holds byte-identical copies of the task files (`rungs/R1–R7.json`, which include the grading
asserts, reference solutions for R6 and package files), the prompt builder, both evaluators, the protocol
and the freeze manifests. `reproduce.py` checks every shipped file against the manifests. Reserved
held-out variants and the site-specific runner are **withheld**; their hashes stay in the manifest so a
later release can prove they were not changed (see `frozen/WITHHELD.md`).
## Models
| Label | Model ref | Route | Hardware class |
|---|---|---|---|
| `astra` | openai/gpt-6-astra | OpenRouter, streaming | hosted API |
| `deepseek-v4-flash` | deepseek/deepseek-v4-flash | OpenRouter, streaming | hosted API |
| `glm-4.7-flash` | z-ai/glm-4.7-flash | OpenRouter, streaming | hosted API |
| `gpt-5-nano` | openai/gpt-5-nano | OpenRouter, streaming | hosted API |
| `qwen3.7-flash` | qwen/qwen3.7-flash | OpenRouter, streaming | hosted API |
| `alibaba/qwen-flash` | qwen-flash | Alibaba Cloud Model Studio, buffered, thinking off | hosted API |
| `alibaba/qwen-plus` | qwen-plus | Alibaba Cloud Model Studio, buffered, thinking off | hosted API |
| `RK1-Qwen3-4B` | Qwen3-4B-Instruct-2507, RKLLM W8A8, context 2048 | local NPU via RKLLM runtime 1.3.1 | edge SoC: Turing RK1, Rockchip RK3588, 3-core NPU, 32 GB |
Output caps: 512 tokens on R1–R5 and 2048 on R6–R7 for hosted routes; RK1 kept its native 512-token output
and 2048-token context on every rung.
## Intended uses
- Compare where on the ladder different models stop under a fixed, small output cap.
- Compare an edge NPU model with hosted models on identical tasks and grading.
- Study trap abstention and reasoning-token exhaustion under a fixed cap.
- Template for adding a model with the public runner (`harness/run_model.py`).
## Limitations and biases
- 28 tasks and 3 repeats at temperature 0: intervals are wide and repeats are not independent.
- The task files are now public. Any model trained after this release may have seen them; treat new
results as contaminated unless checked against the withheld variants.
- Resource caps differ between RK1 and hosted routes on R6/R7.
- Latency comes from different instruments per route and includes transport; it is not a serving
benchmark. Hosted serving hardware is not disclosed. Power was not metered.
- `qwen-plus` coverage is incomplete. Hosted models can change behind a stable model ref; results describe
the runs made on 2026-10-27 and 2026-10-28.
- English-only prompts; Python-only tasks.
## Personal and sensitive information
None. The dataset holds synthetic programming tasks and machine-generated scores. Model answer text,
evaluator logs and all operator or infrastructure details were removed before release.
## Licence
Data, task files and documentation: CC BY 4.0. Code in the companion repository: MIT.
## Citation
```
@misc{intelligence_ladder_2026,
title = {Intelligence Ladder: a frozen, behaviourally graded coding ladder for hosted and edge models},
author = {cloudlabworks},
year = {2026},
note = {Dataset and reproduce scripts}
}
```