Datasets:

codexpublicus
/

stare-citations

Dropped, in no tier and not for review: bare-section-sign 26,835. CourtListener records' own leading citations: 1,532, 1,524 resolved to the record itself, 8 for review; the index named another decision for 574.

Tier	Citations	Share
0	33	0.0%
1	215,904	80.3%
2	205,381	76.3%
in no tier (review)	45,622	17.0%

Tier set	Citations
none	45,622
0	28
0+1	5
1	17,998
1+2	197,901
2	7,480

Tag	Citations	By tier set
`no-case-to-resolve`	14,581	1 14,576, 0+1 5
`own-citation`	1,532	1+2 1,524, none 8
`span-only`	32,924	1+2 21,972, none 8,101, 1 2,827, 2 24

Accepted tiers	Review queue	Shrink vs tier 0 alone
0	269,001	0 (0.0%)
0+1	53,102	215,899 (80.3%)
0+2	63,620	205,381 (76.3%)
0+1+2	45,622	223,379 (83.0%)

Agreement between sources

Agreement, not accuracy. Groups with cap-cites_to count full case citations in CAP decisions with a cites_to list only.

Sources	Any	All	Found	Span	Fields	Same decision
citare@0.7.3 + eyecite@2.7.8	267,909	267,620	99.9%	95.6%	99.9%	100.0%
citare@0.7.3 + cap-cites_to	139,292	105,831	76.0%	100.0%	99.6%	99.3%
eyecite@2.7.8 + cap-cites_to	139,283	105,866	76.0%	99.9%	99.7%	99.3%
citare@0.7.3 + eyecite@2.7.8 + cap-cites_to	139,292	105,820	76.0%	99.9%	99.6%	99.3%
cap: citare@0.7.3 + eyecite@2.7.8	207,192	207,070	99.9%	95.9%	99.9%	100.0%
cl: citare@0.7.3 + eyecite@2.7.8	60,717	60,550	99.7%	94.6%	99.8%	100.0%

Citation kinds

Kind	Decisions	Citations	In a tier
id	3,132	25,372	12,499
neutral	1,305	13,046	8,569
nominative	540	2,299	1,930
ocr-damage	944	0	0
pre-1850	1,241	0	0
short_case	3,017	30,061	27,435
slip	44	99	50
statute	3,855	23,735	12,842
statute:Alabama	39	106	33
statute:Alaska	75	307	281
statute:American Samoa	6	23	22
statute:Arizona	75	584	28
statute:Arkansas	75	275	263
statute:California	75	406	101
statute:Colorado	46	164	130
statute:Connecticut	75	543	19
statute:Dakota Territory	2	3	3
statute:Delaware	27	93	82
statute:District of Columbia	75	670	606
statute:Florida	10	17	13
statute:Georgia	75	728	2
statute:Guam	75	297	182
statute:Hawaii	75	1,510	32
statute:Idaho	75	272	247
statute:Illinois	18	48	45
statute:Indiana	65	292	268
statute:Iowa	53	218	170
statute:Kansas	20	92	74
statute:Kentucky	8	22	16
statute:Louisiana	6	35	28
statute:Maine	75	706	30
statute:Maryland	44	359	270
statute:Massachusetts	75	427	25
statute:Michigan	17	39	3
statute:Minnesota	75	574	469
statute:Mississippi	75	327	317
statute:Missouri	13	28	25
statute:Montana	28	108	96
statute:Navajo Nation	14	36	26
statute:Nebraska	75	337	332
statute:Nevada	18	62	44
statute:New Hampshire	29	67	57
statute:New Jersey	24	99	87
statute:New Mexico	75	289	74
statute:New York	76	199	17
statute:North Carolina	75	751	133
statute:North Dakota	75	709	81
statute:Northern Mariana Islands	75	380	150
statute:Ohio	13	17	17
statute:Oklahoma	75	641	74
statute:Oregon	12	84	75
statute:Pennsylvania	75	550	27
statute:Puerto Rico	18	61	59
statute:Rhode Island	54	102	32
statute:South Carolina	65	181	178
statute:South Dakota	24	75	57
statute:Tennessee	75	410	277
statute:Texas	64	324	94
statute:Tribal Jurisdictions	17	55	43
statute:Utah	75	336	235
statute:Vermont	75	440	13
statute:Virgin Islands	75	242	214
statute:Virginia	23	121	110
statute:Washington	22	107	72
statute:West Virginia	70	895	362
statute:Wisconsin	67	961	887
statute:Wyoming	75	386	354
statute:ca1	64	315	262
statute:ca10	61	329	315
statute:ca11	62	462	389
statute:ca2	64	408	329
statute:ca3	57	444	379
statute:ca4	69	342	292
statute:ca5	64	322	288
statute:ca6	78	408	337
statute:ca7	78	513	472
statute:ca8	67	374	313
statute:ca9	91	528	468
statute:cadc	45	397	340
statute:cafc	44	241	200
statute:federal-other	44	396	336
statute:scotus	5	66	61
supra	2,177	9,445	4,506

Statutes by jurisdiction

Decisions with a statute: by the plan's sieve, by the stricter pattern, by a full_law label from any engine, and by the planner's sieve with engines now (prefilter and label).

Jurisdiction	Decisions	Plan sieve	Pattern	Labelled	Sieve now
Alabama	130	39	62	39	39
Alaska	124	75	81	75	75
American Samoa	67	6	15	6	6
Arizona	108	75	89	75	75
Arkansas	143	75	85	75	75
California	138	75	104	75	75
Colorado	118	46	85	46	46
Connecticut	168	75	85	75	75
Dakota Territory	67	2	44	2	2
Delaware	103	27	37	27	27
District of Columbia	113	75	85	75	75
England	70	0	0	0	0
Florida	191	10	46	10	10
Georgia	158	75	50	75	75
Guam	133	75	92	75	75
Hawaii	130	75	43	75	75
Idaho	128	75	95	75	75
Illinois	141	17	81	17	17
Indiana	160	64	82	64	64
Iowa	133	53	86	53	53
Kansas	98	20	58	20	20
Kentucky	97	8	43	8	8
Louisiana	167	6	53	6	6
Maine	122	75	71	75	75
Maryland	167	44	56	44	44
Massachusetts	282	75	19	75	75
Michigan	122	17	32	17	17
Minnesota	127	75	87	75	75
Mississippi	139	75	88	75	75
Missouri	107	13	49	13	13
Montana	101	28	38	28	28
Navajo Nation	67	14	20	14	14
Nebraska	114	75	88	75	75
Nevada	84	18	46	18	18
New Hampshire	107	29	44	29	29
New Jersey	129	23	30	23	23
New Mexico	127	75	43	75	75
New York	449	75	49	75	75
North Carolina	168	75	96	75	75
North Dakota	125	75	96	75	75
Northern Mariana Islands	125	75	60	75	75
Ohio	159	13	39	13	13
Oklahoma	137	75	39	75	75
Oregon	104	12	61	12	12
Pennsylvania	225	75	64	75	75
Puerto Rico	96	18	30	18	18
Rhode Island	157	54	25	54	54
South Carolina	386	65	69	65	65
South Dakota	96	24	68	24	24
Tennessee	140	75	69	75	75
Texas	174	64	90	64	64
Tribal Jurisdictions	66	17	23	17	17
United Kingdom	2	0	0	0	0
Utah	125	75	88	75	75
Vermont	136	75	18	75	75
Virgin Islands	112	75	84	75	75
Virginia	167	23	59	23	23
Washington	119	22	56	22	22
West Virginia	129	70	98	70	70
Wisconsin	139	67	94	67	67
Wyoming	121	75	93	75	75
ca1	87	64	64	64	64
ca10	82	61	66	61	61
ca11	95	62	65	62	62
ca2	113	64	71	64	64
ca3	109	57	60	57	57
ca4	116	69	75	69	69
ca5	138	64	78	64	64
ca6	116	78	89	78	78
ca7	98	77	80	77	77
ca8	102	67	75	67	67
ca9	132	91	98	91	91
cadc	93	45	48	45	45
cafc	78	44	43	44	44
federal-other	133	44	64	44	44
scotus	171	5	8	5	5

By source

Bucket	Decisions	Citations	In a tier
cap	8,000	208,316	176,699
cl	2,000	60,718	46,713

By decade

Bucket	Decisions	Citations	In a tier
1650	3	0	0
1660	6	0	0
1670	68	0	0
1680	66	0	0
1690	2	0	0
1700	17	0	0
1710	67	2	0
1720	68	1	0
1730	67	24	0
1740	67	3	0
1750	67	3	2
1760	67	12	5
1770	67	4	1
1780	67	56	31
1790	109	47	14
1800	77	90	69
1810	87	102	62
1820	94	105	52
1830	86	114	47
1840	89	186	102
1850	103	519	305
1860	97	237	147
1870	121	474	318
1880	187	1,417	936
1890	183	973	722
1900	206	2,105	1,653
1910	274	2,752	2,243
1920	279	2,764	2,274
1930	288	3,690	3,247
1940	209	3,230	2,739
1950	310	6,108	5,367
1960	364	7,052	6,327
1970	686	15,730	13,794
1980	1,019	31,058	27,087
1990	1,268	45,310	39,143
2000	1,405	53,417	45,422
2010	1,251	60,286	48,928
2020	509	31,163	22,375

By jurisdiction

Bucket	Decisions	Citations	In a tier
Alabama	130	2,936	2,625
Alaska	124	5,690	5,052
American Samoa	67	357	279
Arizona	108	5,707	4,484
Arkansas	143	3,067	2,799
California	138	6,246	5,465
Colorado	118	4,019	3,487
Connecticut	168	5,571	4,175
Dakota Territory	67	731	467
Delaware	103	2,167	1,772
District of Columbia	113	6,316	5,269
England	70	34	6
Florida	191	978	842
Georgia	158	4,722	3,655
Guam	133	4,432	2,852
Hawaii	130	6,819	4,579
Idaho	128	7,036	6,436
Illinois	141	2,845	2,580
Indiana	160	3,992	3,499
Iowa	133	3,150	2,771
Kansas	98	2,104	1,865
Kentucky	97	834	698
Louisiana	167	1,125	936
Maine	122	3,772	2,799
Maryland	167	7,312	6,243
Massachusetts	282	2,297	1,665
Michigan	122	1,201	1,021
Minnesota	127	4,119	3,526
Mississippi	139	3,991	3,722
Missouri	107	1,515	1,351
Montana	101	2,893	2,629
Navajo Nation	67	468	344
Nebraska	114	5,838	5,146
Nevada	84	2,417	2,042
New Hampshire	107	3,165	2,772
New Jersey	129	2,642	2,305
New Mexico	127	6,854	5,249
New York	449	2,219	1,522
North Carolina	168	4,566	3,554
North Dakota	125	4,835	3,768
Northern Mariana Islands	125	4,394	3,111
Ohio	159	2,576	2,054
Oklahoma	137	6,695	4,977
Oregon	104	2,545	2,230
Pennsylvania	225	4,004	2,975
Puerto Rico	96	1,930	1,356
Rhode Island	157	2,434	2,255
South Carolina	386	2,138	1,922
South Dakota	96	3,177	2,878
Tennessee	140	3,278	2,600
Texas	174	5,172	4,330
Tribal Jurisdictions	66	1,040	759
United Kingdom	2	8	5
Utah	125	5,942	4,829
Vermont	136	3,772	2,797
Virgin Islands	112	4,243	3,753
Virginia	167	2,369	1,865
Washington	119	3,735	3,323
West Virginia	129	7,604	6,572
Wisconsin	139	6,011	5,332
Wyoming	121	6,003	5,260
ca1	87	3,032	2,612
ca10	82	3,131	2,714
ca11	95	3,638	3,189
ca2	113	4,344	3,581
ca3	109	3,492	3,059
ca4	116	3,061	2,621
ca5	138	4,425	3,914
ca6	116	4,125	3,581
ca7	98	4,455	3,967
ca8	102	2,989	2,596
ca9	132	4,547	4,018
cadc	93	3,055	2,428
cafc	78	1,237	1,033
federal-other	133	2,594	1,945
scotus	171	857	720

By level

Bucket	Decisions	Citations	In a tier
highest	4,327	127,641	105,317
intermediate	3,580	104,185	87,740
other	439	3,754	2,636
trial	1,654	33,454	27,719

Run

seconds_total: 537
seconds_labelling: 474
jobs: 8
requests: 0
resolver: {'etag_checked': 25638, 'etag_mismatch': 0, 'cl_records_read': 3919}
files: {'records.jsonl': {'rows': 10000, 'bytes': 543956784, 'sha256': '3c5d78d6ac44d8cd9f73bd25e426d27f623e64b62531e0f8a506a2a0045e9638'}, 'queue.jsonl': {'rows': 45622, 'bytes': 62536133, 'sha256': 'c406c2323588a796e566842e6386df78c569ea416726f2321a5ab5e5c5b33bcb'}}

Disagreement kinds

Kind	Citations
`missed_by:cap-cites_to:parallel`	29,439
`span`	12,095
`type`	9,972
`missed_by:cap-cites_to`	2,878
`found_only_by:cap-cites_to`	1,120
`split:eyecite@2.7.8`	1,096
`year`	783
`reporter`	733
`split:cap-cites_to`	320
`found_only_by:citare@0.7.3`	155
`found_only_by:eyecite@2.7.8`	77
`missed_by:citare@0.7.3`	46
`pin_cite`	18
`page`	17
`missed_by:eyecite@2.7.8`	11
`volume`	7
`split:citare@0.7.3`	3