layerlab-store / final_eval /FINAL_EVAL_full.md
cybertronak's picture
analysis (full)
e8e97e0 verified
|
Raw History Blame Contribute Delete
31.3 kB

SafeCompress: held-out evaluation of the exported models

Models are loaded from Hugging Face (checkpoints or recipe loader); every item below is held out from layer selection and from the earlier 26-arm comparison.

Datasets

  • Safety: HarmBench (standard), StrongREJECT, IndicSafe-Hindi harmful
  • Over-refusal: XSTest safe prompts, IndicSafe-Hindi harmless controls
  • Extended safety: AdvBench, JailbreakBench (harmful + benign), XSTest unsafe, HarmBench contextual, OR-Bench-hard, MultiJail (ar, bn, sw), IndicSafe (bn, ta)
  • Extended capability: Global-MMLU-Lite (12 languages), Belebele (bn ta te mr ur sw), ARC-Challenge, MGSM (en, bn)
  • Capability: Global-MMLU (EN+HI paired), Belebele (EN+HI), TruthfulQA MC1 (zero-shot), Wikipedia perplexity (EN, HI)
  • Degeneration: 160-token generations on benign prompts

Results

model GB tok/s MMLU Belebele TruthfulQA PPL en PPL hi harmful refusal AuditKIT refusal benign refusal gap (harmful) degenerate
E0_FP16_base 6.70 117 0.488 0.764 0.280 13.8 15.2 0.702 0.620 0.080 2.36 0.018
E1_uniform_nf4 2.66 103 0.468 0.741 0.283 14.5 16.0 0.667 0.569 0.051 2.06 0.018
C_refusalDrop_FP16prot 3.23 105 0.478 0.752 0.278 14.3 15.8 0.720 0.651 0.069 2.87 0.018
X_Cons5_FP16prot 3.23 102 0.485 0.750 0.278 14.3 15.7 0.727 0.658 0.069 2.72 0.018
CK_circuitkit_FP16prot 3.23 104 0.481 0.752 0.282 14.3 15.8 0.716 0.656 0.069 2.53 0.018
C_refusalDrop_INT8prot 2.72 94 0.476 0.752 0.277 14.3 15.8 0.720 0.656 0.069 2.78 0.018
X_Cons5_INT8prot 2.72 96 0.478 0.752 0.278 14.3 15.8 0.722 0.649 0.051 2.65 0.018
CK_circuitkit_INT8prot 2.72 94 0.478 0.751 0.282 14.3 15.8 0.700 0.636 0.057 2.48 0.018
RANDOM0_FP16prot 3.11 107 0.466 0.744 0.277 14.4 15.8 0.682 0.573 0.057 2.32 0.018
RANDOM1_FP16prot 3.11 104 0.468 0.749 0.279 14.4 15.9 0.653 0.571 0.057 1.63 0.036
RANDOM2_FP16prot 3.11 107 0.454 0.751 0.280 14.4 15.8 0.676 0.589 0.046 2.18 0.018
RANDOM3_FP16prot 3.11 105 0.474 0.744 0.277 14.4 15.9 0.678 0.560 0.057 2.13 0.000

Notes

  • Benign prompts in the core set: 175 (XSTest safe prompts plus the Hindi harmless controls left after the earlier evaluation took its share); over-refusal intervals are therefore wide. AuditKIT and phrase-matcher benign comparisons both use these 175 items, so there is no scoring gap.
  • MMLU and Belebele intervals resample question clusters (the EN and HI versions of a question together).
  • English harmful prompts come from HarmBench and StrongREJECT, Hindi harmful prompts from IndicSafe: language and dataset are confounded.
  • Long-form check (55 benign prompts, 160 new tokens): share of replies that hit the token limit without a stop token: E0_FP16_base 0.69, E1_uniform_nf4 0.69, C_refusalDrop_FP16prot 0.60, X_Cons5_FP16prot 0.62, CK_circuitkit_FP16prot 0.62, C_refusalDrop_INT8prot 0.64, X_Cons5_INT8prot 0.65, CK_circuitkit_INT8prot 0.60, RANDOM0_FP16prot 0.65, RANDOM1_FP16prot 0.69, RANDOM2_FP16prot 0.69, RANDOM3_FP16prot 0.62.

Harmful refusal and over-refusal by language (AuditKIT scorer):

model harmful EN harmful HI benign EN benign HI
E0_FP16_base 0.820 0.220 0.087 0.000
E1_uniform_nf4 0.753 0.200 0.040 0.000
C_refusalDrop_FP16prot 0.830 0.293 0.073 0.000
X_Cons5_FP16prot 0.837 0.300 0.067 0.000
CK_circuitkit_FP16prot 0.833 0.300 0.060 0.000
C_refusalDrop_INT8prot 0.827 0.313 0.073 0.000
X_Cons5_INT8prot 0.823 0.300 0.047 0.000
CK_circuitkit_INT8prot 0.810 0.287 0.047 0.000
RANDOM0_FP16prot 0.767 0.187 0.047 0.000
RANDOM1_FP16prot 0.750 0.213 0.053 0.000
RANDOM2_FP16prot 0.770 0.227 0.040 0.000
RANDOM3_FP16prot 0.760 0.160 0.053 0.000

Extended suites

model EN harmful refusal (AuditKIT) multilingual harmful refusal EN over-refusal multilingual over-refusal Global-MMLU-Lite (12 languages) Belebele (6 more languages) ARC-Challenge MGSM (en, bn)
E0_FP16_base 0.857 0.371 0.180 0.000 0.526 0.692 0.677 0.588
E1_uniform_nf4 0.819 0.357 0.130 0.000 0.525 0.703 0.643 0.450
C_refusalDrop_FP16prot 0.844 0.425 0.170 0.000 0.535 0.708 0.643 0.550
X_Cons5_FP16prot 0.841 0.400 0.155 0.000 0.533 0.703 0.653 0.487
CK_circuitkit_FP16prot 0.832 0.396 0.155 0.000 0.537 0.697 0.657 0.487
C_refusalDrop_INT8prot 0.851 0.429 0.160 0.000 0.529 0.708 0.650 0.525
X_Cons5_INT8prot 0.835 0.400 0.140 0.000 0.529 0.686 0.650 0.450
CK_circuitkit_INT8prot 0.832 0.396 0.135 0.000 0.536 0.689 0.643 0.450
RANDOM0_FP16prot nan nan nan nan nan nan nan nan
RANDOM1_FP16prot nan nan nan nan nan nan nan nan
RANDOM2_FP16prot nan nan nan nan nan nan nan nan
RANDOM3_FP16prot nan nan nan nan nan nan nan nan

Paired differences

metric comparison diff 95% CI
refuse_harm E1_uniform_nf4 - FP16 base -0.036 [-0.060, -0.011]
refuse_harm C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - FP16 base +0.018 [-0.004, +0.040]
refuse_harm X_Cons5_FP16prot - FP16 base +0.024 [+0.007, +0.044]
refuse_harm CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - FP16 base +0.013 [-0.009, +0.036]
refuse_harm C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - FP16 base +0.018 [-0.007, +0.042]
refuse_harm X_Cons5_INT8prot - FP16 base +0.020 [-0.002, +0.042]
refuse_harm CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - FP16 base -0.002 [-0.027, +0.022]
refuse_harm RANDOM0_FP16prot - FP16 base -0.020 [-0.042, +0.002]
refuse_harm RANDOM1_FP16prot - FP16 base -0.049 [-0.078, -0.022]
refuse_harm RANDOM2_FP16prot - FP16 base -0.027 [-0.051, -0.002]
refuse_harm RANDOM3_FP16prot - FP16 base -0.024 [-0.051, +0.000]
refuse_harm C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit +0.053 [+0.029, +0.080]
refuse_harm X_Cons5_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit +0.060 [+0.036, +0.087]
refuse_harm CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit +0.049 [+0.024, +0.073]
refuse_harm C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit +0.053 [+0.031, +0.078]
refuse_harm X_Cons5_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit +0.056 [+0.031, +0.082]
refuse_harm CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit +0.033 [+0.011, +0.058]
refuse_harm C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - mean(4 random FP16-protected) +0.048 [+0.027, +0.071]
refuse_harm X_Cons5_FP16prot - mean(4 random FP16-protected) +0.054 [+0.034, +0.076]
refuse_harm CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - mean(4 random FP16-protected) +0.043 [+0.024, +0.064]
ak_refuse_harm E1_uniform_nf4 - FP16 base -0.051 [-0.078, -0.027]
ak_refuse_harm C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - FP16 base +0.031 [+0.004, +0.058]
ak_refuse_harm X_Cons5_FP16prot - FP16 base +0.038 [+0.013, +0.062]
ak_refuse_harm CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - FP16 base +0.036 [+0.009, +0.062]
ak_refuse_harm C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - FP16 base +0.036 [+0.009, +0.062]
ak_refuse_harm X_Cons5_INT8prot - FP16 base +0.029 [+0.000, +0.058]
ak_refuse_harm CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - FP16 base +0.016 [-0.013, +0.044]
ak_refuse_harm RANDOM0_FP16prot - FP16 base -0.047 [-0.071, -0.024]
ak_refuse_harm RANDOM1_FP16prot - FP16 base -0.049 [-0.080, -0.018]
ak_refuse_harm RANDOM2_FP16prot - FP16 base -0.031 [-0.058, -0.007]
ak_refuse_harm RANDOM3_FP16prot - FP16 base -0.060 [-0.089, -0.033]
ak_refuse_harm C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit +0.082 [+0.056, +0.111]
ak_refuse_harm X_Cons5_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit +0.089 [+0.062, +0.118]
ak_refuse_harm CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit +0.087 [+0.060, +0.116]
ak_refuse_harm C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit +0.087 [+0.060, +0.116]
ak_refuse_harm X_Cons5_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit +0.080 [+0.053, +0.111]
ak_refuse_harm CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit +0.067 [+0.038, +0.098]
ak_refuse_harm C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - mean(4 random FP16-protected) +0.078 [+0.054, +0.103]
ak_refuse_harm X_Cons5_FP16prot - mean(4 random FP16-protected) +0.084 [+0.060, +0.111]
ak_refuse_harm CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - mean(4 random FP16-protected) +0.082 [+0.058, +0.108]
gap_harm E1_uniform_nf4 - FP16 base -0.296 [-0.377, -0.213]
gap_harm C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - FP16 base +0.510 [+0.439, +0.580]
gap_harm X_Cons5_FP16prot - FP16 base +0.358 [+0.289, +0.428]
gap_harm CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - FP16 base +0.164 [+0.094, +0.235]
gap_harm C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - FP16 base +0.421 [+0.350, +0.492]
gap_harm X_Cons5_INT8prot - FP16 base +0.285 [+0.211, +0.360]
gap_harm CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - FP16 base +0.116 [+0.038, +0.192]
gap_harm RANDOM0_FP16prot - FP16 base -0.039 [-0.120, +0.038]
gap_harm RANDOM1_FP16prot - FP16 base -0.733 [-0.811, -0.660]
gap_harm RANDOM2_FP16prot - FP16 base -0.179 [-0.253, -0.108]
gap_harm RANDOM3_FP16prot - FP16 base -0.233 [-0.313, -0.154]
gap_harm C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit +0.806 [+0.762, +0.854]
gap_harm X_Cons5_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit +0.655 [+0.604, +0.706]
gap_harm CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit +0.460 [+0.416, +0.508]
gap_harm C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit +0.717 [+0.674, +0.762]
gap_harm X_Cons5_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit +0.581 [+0.529, +0.635]
gap_harm CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit +0.412 [+0.365, +0.459]
gap_harm C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - mean(4 random FP16-protected) +0.806 [+0.766, +0.849]
gap_harm X_Cons5_FP16prot - mean(4 random FP16-protected) +0.655 [+0.609, +0.704]
gap_harm CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - mean(4 random FP16-protected) +0.460 [+0.416, +0.509]
refuse_benign E1_uniform_nf4 - FP16 base -0.029 [-0.057, +0.000]
refuse_benign C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - FP16 base -0.011 [-0.029, +0.000]
refuse_benign X_Cons5_FP16prot - FP16 base -0.011 [-0.029, +0.000]
refuse_benign CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - FP16 base -0.011 [-0.034, +0.011]
refuse_benign C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - FP16 base -0.011 [-0.029, +0.000]
refuse_benign X_Cons5_INT8prot - FP16 base -0.029 [-0.057, -0.006]
refuse_benign CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - FP16 base -0.023 [-0.051, +0.000]
refuse_benign RANDOM0_FP16prot - FP16 base -0.023 [-0.051, +0.000]
refuse_benign RANDOM1_FP16prot - FP16 base -0.023 [-0.046, -0.006]
refuse_benign RANDOM2_FP16prot - FP16 base -0.034 [-0.063, -0.011]
refuse_benign RANDOM3_FP16prot - FP16 base -0.023 [-0.046, -0.006]
refuse_benign C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit +0.017 [-0.006, +0.040]
refuse_benign X_Cons5_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit +0.017 [-0.006, +0.046]
refuse_benign CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit +0.017 [-0.006, +0.046]
refuse_benign C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit +0.017 [-0.006, +0.040]
refuse_benign X_Cons5_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit +0.000 [-0.017, +0.017]
refuse_benign CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit +0.006 [-0.011, +0.029]
refuse_benign C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - mean(4 random FP16-protected) +0.014 [-0.001, +0.034]
refuse_benign X_Cons5_FP16prot - mean(4 random FP16-protected) +0.014 [-0.001, +0.034]
refuse_benign CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - mean(4 random FP16-protected) +0.014 [-0.001, +0.034]
ak_over_refusal E1_uniform_nf4 - FP16 base -0.040 [-0.069, -0.011]
ak_over_refusal C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - FP16 base -0.011 [-0.034, +0.011]
ak_over_refusal X_Cons5_FP16prot - FP16 base -0.017 [-0.040, +0.000]
ak_over_refusal CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - FP16 base -0.023 [-0.046, -0.006]
ak_over_refusal C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - FP16 base -0.011 [-0.034, +0.011]
ak_over_refusal X_Cons5_INT8prot - FP16 base -0.034 [-0.063, -0.011]
ak_over_refusal CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - FP16 base -0.034 [-0.063, -0.011]
ak_over_refusal RANDOM0_FP16prot - FP16 base -0.034 [-0.063, -0.011]
ak_over_refusal RANDOM1_FP16prot - FP16 base -0.029 [-0.057, -0.006]
ak_over_refusal RANDOM2_FP16prot - FP16 base -0.040 [-0.069, -0.011]
ak_over_refusal RANDOM3_FP16prot - FP16 base -0.029 [-0.057, -0.006]
ak_over_refusal C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit +0.029 [+0.006, +0.057]
ak_over_refusal X_Cons5_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit +0.023 [+0.006, +0.046]
ak_over_refusal CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit +0.017 [+0.000, +0.040]
ak_over_refusal C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit +0.029 [+0.006, +0.057]
ak_over_refusal X_Cons5_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit +0.006 [+0.000, +0.017]
ak_over_refusal CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit +0.006 [+0.000, +0.017]
ak_over_refusal C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - mean(4 random FP16-protected) +0.021 [+0.003, +0.044]
ak_over_refusal X_Cons5_FP16prot - mean(4 random FP16-protected) +0.016 [+0.000, +0.036]
ak_over_refusal CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - mean(4 random FP16-protected) +0.010 [-0.001, +0.026]
mmlu E1_uniform_nf4 - FP16 base -0.020 [-0.044, +0.004]
mmlu C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - FP16 base -0.010 [-0.031, +0.011]
mmlu X_Cons5_FP16prot - FP16 base -0.003 [-0.024, +0.018]
mmlu CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - FP16 base -0.007 [-0.027, +0.013]
mmlu C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - FP16 base -0.012 [-0.033, +0.010]
mmlu X_Cons5_INT8prot - FP16 base -0.010 [-0.032, +0.011]
mmlu CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - FP16 base -0.010 [-0.031, +0.011]
mmlu RANDOM0_FP16prot - FP16 base -0.022 [-0.046, +0.002]
mmlu RANDOM1_FP16prot - FP16 base -0.020 [-0.043, +0.003]
mmlu RANDOM2_FP16prot - FP16 base -0.034 [-0.059, -0.010]
mmlu RANDOM3_FP16prot - FP16 base -0.014 [-0.036, +0.008]
mmlu C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit +0.010 [-0.007, +0.027]
mmlu X_Cons5_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit +0.017 [+0.001, +0.034]
mmlu CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit +0.013 [-0.003, +0.029]
mmlu C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit +0.008 [-0.010, +0.026]
mmlu X_Cons5_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit +0.010 [-0.008, +0.029]
mmlu CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit +0.010 [-0.007, +0.027]
mmlu C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - mean(4 random FP16-protected) +0.013 [-0.003, +0.029]
mmlu X_Cons5_FP16prot - mean(4 random FP16-protected) +0.019 [+0.004, +0.035]
mmlu CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - mean(4 random FP16-protected) +0.015 [+0.001, +0.030]
bele E1_uniform_nf4 - FP16 base -0.023 [-0.042, -0.003]
bele C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - FP16 base -0.011 [-0.030, +0.007]
bele X_Cons5_FP16prot - FP16 base -0.014 [-0.032, +0.005]
bele CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - FP16 base -0.011 [-0.030, +0.007]
bele C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - FP16 base -0.011 [-0.030, +0.007]
bele X_Cons5_INT8prot - FP16 base -0.011 [-0.028, +0.006]
bele CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - FP16 base -0.013 [-0.031, +0.007]
bele RANDOM0_FP16prot - FP16 base -0.019 [-0.037, -0.001]
bele RANDOM1_FP16prot - FP16 base -0.015 [-0.032, +0.002]
bele RANDOM2_FP16prot - FP16 base -0.013 [-0.031, +0.006]
bele RANDOM3_FP16prot - FP16 base -0.019 [-0.039, +0.000]
bele C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit +0.011 [-0.001, +0.024]
bele X_Cons5_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit +0.009 [-0.005, +0.022]
bele CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit +0.011 [-0.001, +0.024]
bele C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit +0.011 [+0.000, +0.024]
bele X_Cons5_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit +0.011 [-0.003, +0.025]
bele CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit +0.010 [-0.001, +0.023]
bele C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - mean(4 random FP16-protected) +0.005 [-0.007, +0.018]
bele X_Cons5_FP16prot - mean(4 random FP16-protected) +0.003 [-0.009, +0.015]
bele CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - mean(4 random FP16-protected) +0.005 [-0.008, +0.018]
tqa E1_uniform_nf4 - FP16 base +0.002 [-0.011, +0.016]
tqa C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - FP16 base -0.002 [-0.016, +0.011]
tqa X_Cons5_FP16prot - FP16 base -0.002 [-0.017, +0.012]
tqa CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - FP16 base +0.001 [-0.012, +0.016]
tqa C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - FP16 base -0.004 [-0.017, +0.010]
tqa X_Cons5_INT8prot - FP16 base -0.002 [-0.017, +0.012]
tqa CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - FP16 base +0.001 [-0.013, +0.016]
tqa RANDOM0_FP16prot - FP16 base -0.004 [-0.016, +0.009]
tqa RANDOM1_FP16prot - FP16 base -0.001 [-0.015, +0.013]
tqa RANDOM2_FP16prot - FP16 base +0.000 [-0.012, +0.013]
tqa RANDOM3_FP16prot - FP16 base -0.004 [-0.017, +0.011]
tqa C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit -0.005 [-0.015, +0.005]
tqa X_Cons5_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit -0.005 [-0.015, +0.005]
tqa CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit -0.001 [-0.010, +0.007]
tqa C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit -0.006 [-0.016, +0.004]
tqa X_Cons5_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit -0.005 [-0.016, +0.006]
tqa CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit -0.001 [-0.011, +0.010]
tqa C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - mean(4 random FP16-protected) -0.000 [-0.010, +0.009]
tqa X_Cons5_FP16prot - mean(4 random FP16-protected) -0.000 [-0.010, +0.009]
tqa CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - mean(4 random FP16-protected) +0.003 [-0.006, +0.013]
logppl_en E1_uniform_nf4 - FP16 base +0.049 [+0.043, +0.055]
logppl_en C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - FP16 base +0.038 [+0.033, +0.043]
logppl_en X_Cons5_FP16prot - FP16 base +0.036 [+0.031, +0.041]
logppl_en CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - FP16 base +0.036 [+0.031, +0.041]
logppl_en C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - FP16 base +0.038 [+0.033, +0.044]
logppl_en X_Cons5_INT8prot - FP16 base +0.038 [+0.033, +0.043]
logppl_en CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - FP16 base +0.038 [+0.033, +0.044]
logppl_en RANDOM0_FP16prot - FP16 base +0.042 [+0.036, +0.047]
logppl_en RANDOM1_FP16prot - FP16 base +0.042 [+0.037, +0.047]
logppl_en RANDOM2_FP16prot - FP16 base +0.042 [+0.037, +0.048]
logppl_en RANDOM3_FP16prot - FP16 base +0.043 [+0.038, +0.048]
logppl_en C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit -0.011 [-0.013, -0.008]
logppl_en X_Cons5_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit -0.013 [-0.016, -0.010]
logppl_en CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit -0.013 [-0.016, -0.010]
logppl_en C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit -0.010 [-0.013, -0.008]
logppl_en X_Cons5_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit -0.011 [-0.014, -0.008]
logppl_en CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit -0.010 [-0.013, -0.008]
logppl_en C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - mean(4 random FP16-protected) -0.004 [-0.006, -0.002]
logppl_en X_Cons5_FP16prot - mean(4 random FP16-protected) -0.007 [-0.009, -0.004]
logppl_en CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - mean(4 random FP16-protected) -0.007 [-0.009, -0.004]
logppl_hi E1_uniform_nf4 - FP16 base +0.050 [+0.045, +0.054]
logppl_hi C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - FP16 base +0.039 [+0.035, +0.044]
logppl_hi X_Cons5_FP16prot - FP16 base +0.036 [+0.032, +0.040]
logppl_hi CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - FP16 base +0.037 [+0.033, +0.041]
logppl_hi C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - FP16 base +0.041 [+0.036, +0.046]
logppl_hi X_Cons5_INT8prot - FP16 base +0.041 [+0.036, +0.045]
logppl_hi CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - FP16 base +0.041 [+0.037, +0.045]
logppl_hi RANDOM0_FP16prot - FP16 base +0.042 [+0.037, +0.046]
logppl_hi RANDOM1_FP16prot - FP16 base +0.044 [+0.040, +0.049]
logppl_hi RANDOM2_FP16prot - FP16 base +0.040 [+0.035, +0.044]
logppl_hi RANDOM3_FP16prot - FP16 base +0.047 [+0.042, +0.051]
logppl_hi C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit -0.010 [-0.012, -0.008]
logppl_hi X_Cons5_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit -0.013 [-0.016, -0.011]
logppl_hi CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit -0.013 [-0.015, -0.010]
logppl_hi C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit -0.009 [-0.010, -0.007]
logppl_hi X_Cons5_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit -0.009 [-0.012, -0.006]
logppl_hi CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit -0.009 [-0.011, -0.006]
logppl_hi C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - mean(4 random FP16-protected) -0.004 [-0.005, -0.002]
logppl_hi X_Cons5_FP16prot - mean(4 random FP16-protected) -0.007 [-0.009, -0.004]
logppl_hi CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - mean(4 random FP16-protected) -0.006 [-0.009, -0.004]
degen_long E1_uniform_nf4 - FP16 base +0.000 [+0.000, +0.000]
degen_long C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - FP16 base +0.000 [+0.000, +0.000]
degen_long X_Cons5_FP16prot - FP16 base +0.000 [+0.000, +0.000]
degen_long CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - FP16 base +0.000 [+0.000, +0.000]
degen_long C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - FP16 base +0.000 [+0.000, +0.000]
degen_long X_Cons5_INT8prot - FP16 base +0.000 [+0.000, +0.000]
degen_long CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - FP16 base +0.000 [+0.000, +0.000]
degen_long RANDOM0_FP16prot - FP16 base +0.000 [+0.000, +0.000]
degen_long RANDOM1_FP16prot - FP16 base +0.018 [+0.000, +0.055]
degen_long RANDOM2_FP16prot - FP16 base +0.000 [+0.000, +0.000]
degen_long RANDOM3_FP16prot - FP16 base -0.018 [-0.055, +0.000]
degen_long C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit +0.000 [+0.000, +0.000]
degen_long X_Cons5_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit +0.000 [+0.000, +0.000]
degen_long CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit +0.000 [+0.000, +0.000]
degen_long C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit +0.000 [+0.000, +0.000]
degen_long X_Cons5_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit +0.000 [+0.000, +0.000]
degen_long CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit +0.000 [+0.000, +0.000]
degen_long C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - mean(4 random FP16-protected) +0.000 [-0.014, +0.014]
degen_long X_Cons5_FP16prot - mean(4 random FP16-protected) +0.000 [-0.014, +0.014]
degen_long CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - mean(4 random FP16-protected) +0.000 [-0.014, +0.014]
ext_harm_ak E1_uniform_nf4 - FP16 base -0.038 [-0.067, -0.013]
ext_harm_ak C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - FP16 base -0.013 [-0.035, +0.010]
ext_harm_ak X_Cons5_FP16prot - FP16 base -0.016 [-0.038, +0.003]
ext_harm_ak CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - FP16 base -0.025 [-0.048, -0.003]
ext_harm_ak C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - FP16 base -0.006 [-0.029, +0.013]
ext_harm_ak X_Cons5_INT8prot - FP16 base -0.022 [-0.044, -0.003]
ext_harm_ak CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - FP16 base -0.025 [-0.051, -0.003]
ext_harm_ak C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit +0.025 [+0.003, +0.048]
ext_harm_ak X_Cons5_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit +0.022 [+0.003, +0.044]
ext_harm_ak CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit +0.013 [-0.003, +0.032]
ext_harm_ak C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit +0.032 [+0.010, +0.057]
ext_harm_ak X_Cons5_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit +0.016 [-0.003, +0.038]
ext_harm_ak CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit +0.013 [+0.000, +0.029]
ml_harm_ak E1_uniform_nf4 - FP16 base -0.014 [-0.054, +0.025]
ml_harm_ak C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - FP16 base +0.054 [+0.014, +0.096]
ml_harm_ak X_Cons5_FP16prot - FP16 base +0.029 [-0.007, +0.068]
ml_harm_ak CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - FP16 base +0.025 [-0.011, +0.061]
ml_harm_ak C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - FP16 base +0.057 [+0.018, +0.100]
ml_harm_ak X_Cons5_INT8prot - FP16 base +0.029 [-0.007, +0.068]
ml_harm_ak CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - FP16 base +0.025 [-0.011, +0.064]
ml_harm_ak C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit +0.068 [+0.039, +0.100]
ml_harm_ak X_Cons5_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit +0.043 [+0.011, +0.075]
ml_harm_ak CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit +0.039 [+0.004, +0.075]
ml_harm_ak C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit +0.071 [+0.043, +0.104]
ml_harm_ak X_Cons5_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit +0.043 [+0.014, +0.075]
ml_harm_ak CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit +0.039 [+0.007, +0.071]
ext_benign_ak E1_uniform_nf4 - FP16 base -0.050 [-0.085, -0.020]
ext_benign_ak C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - FP16 base -0.010 [-0.040, +0.020]
ext_benign_ak X_Cons5_FP16prot - FP16 base -0.025 [-0.055, +0.005]
ext_benign_ak CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - FP16 base -0.025 [-0.060, +0.005]
ext_benign_ak C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - FP16 base -0.020 [-0.055, +0.015]
ext_benign_ak X_Cons5_INT8prot - FP16 base -0.040 [-0.075, -0.005]
ext_benign_ak CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - FP16 base -0.045 [-0.080, -0.015]
ext_benign_ak C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit +0.040 [+0.010, +0.075]
ext_benign_ak X_Cons5_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit +0.025 [+0.000, +0.055]
ext_benign_ak CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit +0.025 [+0.000, +0.055]
ext_benign_ak C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit +0.030 [+0.000, +0.060]
ext_benign_ak X_Cons5_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit +0.010 [-0.015, +0.035]
ext_benign_ak CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit +0.005 [-0.020, +0.030]
ml_benign_ak E1_uniform_nf4 - FP16 base +0.000 [+0.000, +0.000]
ml_benign_ak C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - FP16 base +0.000 [+0.000, +0.000]
ml_benign_ak X_Cons5_FP16prot - FP16 base +0.000 [+0.000, +0.000]
ml_benign_ak CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - FP16 base +0.000 [+0.000, +0.000]
ml_benign_ak C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - FP16 base +0.000 [+0.000, +0.000]
ml_benign_ak X_Cons5_INT8prot - FP16 base +0.000 [+0.000, +0.000]
ml_benign_ak CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - FP16 base +0.000 [+0.000, +0.000]
ml_benign_ak C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit +0.000 [+0.000, +0.000]
ml_benign_ak X_Cons5_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit +0.000 [+0.000, +0.000]
ml_benign_ak CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit +0.000 [+0.000, +0.000]
ml_benign_ak C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit +0.000 [+0.000, +0.000]
ml_benign_ak X_Cons5_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit +0.000 [+0.000, +0.000]
ml_benign_ak CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit +0.000 [+0.000, +0.000]
lite E1_uniform_nf4 - FP16 base -0.001 [-0.026, +0.022]
lite C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - FP16 base +0.008 [-0.014, +0.031]
lite X_Cons5_FP16prot - FP16 base +0.007 [-0.017, +0.031]
lite CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - FP16 base +0.011 [-0.011, +0.032]
lite C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - FP16 base +0.003 [-0.021, +0.026]
lite X_Cons5_INT8prot - FP16 base +0.003 [-0.019, +0.024]
lite CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - FP16 base +0.010 [-0.013, +0.032]
lite C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit +0.010 [-0.007, +0.025]
lite X_Cons5_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit +0.008 [-0.008, +0.025]
lite CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit +0.013 [-0.003, +0.028]
lite C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit +0.004 [-0.014, +0.021]
lite X_Cons5_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit +0.004 [-0.015, +0.024]
lite CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit +0.011 [-0.006, +0.028]
belx E1_uniform_nf4 - FP16 base +0.011 [-0.022, +0.044]
belx C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - FP16 base +0.017 [-0.011, +0.044]
belx X_Cons5_FP16prot - FP16 base +0.011 [-0.017, +0.039]
belx CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - FP16 base +0.006 [-0.025, +0.036]
belx C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - FP16 base +0.017 [-0.014, +0.047]
belx X_Cons5_INT8prot - FP16 base -0.006 [-0.033, +0.022]
belx CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - FP16 base -0.003 [-0.033, +0.031]
belx C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit +0.006 [-0.014, +0.025]
belx X_Cons5_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit +0.000 [-0.022, +0.022]
belx CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit -0.006 [-0.028, +0.014]
belx C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit +0.006 [-0.014, +0.025]
belx X_Cons5_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit -0.017 [-0.042, +0.008]
belx CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit -0.014 [-0.036, +0.008]
arc E1_uniform_nf4 - FP16 base -0.033 [-0.073, +0.007]
arc C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - FP16 base -0.033 [-0.067, +0.000]
arc X_Cons5_FP16prot - FP16 base -0.023 [-0.060, +0.013]
arc CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - FP16 base -0.020 [-0.057, +0.017]
arc C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - FP16 base -0.027 [-0.060, +0.007]
arc X_Cons5_INT8prot - FP16 base -0.027 [-0.063, +0.010]
arc CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - FP16 base -0.033 [-0.070, +0.003]
arc C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit +0.000 [-0.027, +0.027]
arc X_Cons5_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit +0.010 [-0.010, +0.033]
arc CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit +0.013 [-0.007, +0.037]
arc C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit +0.007 [-0.020, +0.033]
arc X_Cons5_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit +0.007 [-0.013, +0.027]
arc CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit +0.000 [-0.027, +0.027]
mgsm E1_uniform_nf4 - FP16 base -0.138 [-0.237, -0.037]
mgsm C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - FP16 base -0.037 [-0.138, +0.062]
mgsm X_Cons5_FP16prot - FP16 base -0.100 [-0.200, -0.013]
mgsm CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - FP16 base -0.100 [-0.188, -0.013]
mgsm C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - FP16 base -0.062 [-0.163, +0.037]
mgsm X_Cons5_INT8prot - FP16 base -0.138 [-0.237, -0.025]
mgsm CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - FP16 base -0.138 [-0.237, -0.037]
mgsm C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit +0.100 [+0.025, +0.188]
mgsm X_Cons5_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit +0.037 [-0.050, +0.125]
mgsm CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit +0.037 [-0.050, +0.138]
mgsm C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit +0.075 [-0.013, +0.163]
mgsm X_Cons5_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit +0.000 [-0.087, +0.087]
mgsm CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit +0.000 [-0.087, +0.087]

Limitations: phrase-matcher and AuditKIT refusal scorers, no judge model; zero-shot TruthfulQA is not comparable to leaderboards; sampled subsets; differences whose CI includes 0 are not claimed.