|
Download rl/VALIDATION.md from d0rj/mathematics_dataset: direct link, hf CLI and curl.
- Browser
- Download file 9.03 kB
-
https://huggingface.co/datasets/d0rj/mathematics_dataset/resolve/main/rl/VALIDATION.md
- Command line
-
hf download hf://datasets/d0rj/mathematics_dataset/rl/VALIDATION.md
-
curl -L -o VALIDATION.md https://huggingface.co/datasets/d0rj/mathematics_dataset/resolve/main/rl/VALIDATION.md
9.03 kB
| # Validation evidence | |
| Implementation and checks: 2026-10-18/19. Source data revision: | |
| `d9f78d0665b3a13dad21c6830b9b358c8a25ae74`. | |
| ## Version 0.2.1: local Docker execution | |
| The Docker runner builds separate SDK images on Docker Desktop 4.89.0, | |
| Engine/CLI 29.7.2, Linux amd64, Python 3.13.14. The measured image IDs, | |
| checksums and protocol results are recorded in [DOCKER_VALIDATION.toml](DOCKER_VALIDATION.toml). | |
| Run it using [DOCKER.md](DOCKER.md). | |
| | Pinned SDK in its own container | Package tests passed | Other SDK modules skipped | | |
| | --- | ---: | ---: | | |
| | Verifiers 0.4.0 | 1,641 | 4 | | |
| | Harbor 0.24.0 | 1,500 | 4 | | |
| | OpenEnv 0.9.0 | 1,502 | 4 | | |
| | NeMo Gym 0.7.0 | 1,501 | 4 | | |
| | AgentEnv 0.9.1334 | 1,504 | 4 | | |
| Windows Python 3.13.13 separately passes 1,506 tests, with five optional SDK | |
| modules skipped; this includes the seven source-repository publication checks. | |
| The package suites include all 1,434 mathematical fixtures. | |
| OpenEnv's actual production image and native cross-container client cover | |
| 280 submissions across all 70 modules in both languages. NeMo Gym covers the | |
| same 280 submissions both through the standalone launcher and through the | |
| entrypoint receiving native supervisor configuration. AgentEnv completes 280 | |
| native episode/turn/result cycles with local stores. Verifiers covers native | |
| `Task.score` for all 140 module/language pairs and six actual `vf-eval` episodes | |
| against the local scripted endpoint. | |
| Native Harbor trials exercise artifact collection and separate agent/verifier | |
| containers, oracle reference acceptance for all 140 module/language pairs, | |
| incorrect answers covering all 12 answer kinds in each language, a source error | |
| with no model reward, and missing output earning zero. The trials assert | |
| private reference/checker paths are absent from the agent and that the verifier | |
| has no IPv4 routes. | |
| Container execution found and corrected Windows CRLF shell exports, the | |
| Docker Desktop kernel incompatibility of Harbor's egress sidecar policy, | |
| invalid-source errors leaving a misleading reward, and mixed verifier build | |
| payloads during parallel Compose/BuildKit execution. Content-addressed tar | |
| snapshots and reference checksums now bind each verifier to its task's files. | |
| The OpenEnv production image also uses the checked lockfile and pinned base. | |
| All supplied model answers are scripted or oracle answers. No model training, | |
| GPU use, hosted CI run or real-model quality benchmark is claimed. The older | |
| Docker limitation below describes version 0.2.0 and is resolved in this release. | |
| ## Scope | |
| - 1,434 generated fixtures: 717 EN and 717 RU. Each language covers all 70 modules, | |
| all five categories and all 12 grading kinds. Three examples per module/category; | |
| 56 train/interpolation modules and 15 extrapolation modules have a 70-module union. | |
| - Each fixture checks reference acceptance and rejection of a changed answer. | |
| - Additional tests cover equivalent fractions/LaTeX/decimal forms, root permutation, | |
| ordered-list changes, form shortcuts, code injection, bounded parsing, source errors, | |
| worker reuse/deadline termination/recovery, train/eval isolation and key stability. | |
| - POSIX tests use the actual installed Verifiers 0.4 plugin loader, `Trace` and | |
| `Task.score` for all 140 module/language combinations. Native Windows skips that | |
| integration module because upstream imports `fcntl`; the standalone checker is tested. | |
| - Bounded live Hub checks exercise the real streaming/filtering loader on Russian | |
| training arithmetic and English extrapolation root/factorization rows. | |
| - `scripts/smoke_rl_rollout.py` drives actual `vf-eval` through a local scripted | |
| OpenAI-compatible endpoint. It is a transport/lifecycle/reward smoke, not inference | |
| by a trained model and not a model-quality or RL-training result. | |
| Recorded complete v0.1.0 source-checkout runs (including seven card/release checks): | |
| | Platform | Result | | |
| | --- | --- | | |
| | Windows, Python 3.13.13 | 1,497 passed; one POSIX integration module skipped | | |
| | Ubuntu WSL, Python 3.12.3 | 1,639 passed, including actual v1 scoring for all 140 module/language combinations | | |
| | Actual vf-eval + local scripted endpoint | Six completed episodes, one model request each; all expected rewards matched | | |
| | Pinned public Hub loader | RU train: 3/3 accepted; EN extrapolation: 5/5 accepted | | |
| The downloadable package's `pytest tests` excludes the seven source-repository | |
| release/card checks. Release hashes are recorded in the source repository's | |
| publication report and generated release manifest. CI is configured for | |
| Ubuntu Python 3.11/3.13 and Windows Python 3.13; configuring CI is not evidence that | |
| hosted CI has executed. | |
| ## Version 0.2.0: historical SDK checks | |
| Checked on 2026-10-19 with actual installed SDKs, using the shared checker and | |
| the unchanged EN/RU regression fixtures: | |
| | Runtime | Complete suite result | | |
| | --- | --- | | |
| | Windows, Python 3.13.13 | 1,505 passed; five optional/POSIX SDK modules skipped | | |
| | Ubuntu WSL, Python 3.12.3, Verifiers extra | 1,647 passed; four other SDK modules skipped | | |
| | Ubuntu WSL, Python 3.13.14, Harbor/OpenEnv/AgentEnv/NeMo extras | 1,515 passed; Verifiers module skipped | | |
| - Harbor 0.24.0's real `Task` loader validates exported task directories for all | |
| 140 module/language pairs. Artifact checking covers correct, incorrect, missing | |
| and non-UTF-8 files. `environment_mode=separate` isolates references/checker code | |
| from the shell agent. **Version 0.2.0 had no completed Docker trial or image build**: the | |
| installed Docker Desktop daemon was unavailable (`dockerDesktopLinuxEngine` | |
| pipe missing), including after its normal start command. Run the documented | |
| `harbor run --agent oracle` once a Docker daemon is available. | |
| - OpenEnv 0.9.0's real `Environment` grades all 140 module/language pairs, rejects | |
| repeated submissions, and exposes only public state. Native WebSocket tests | |
| verify two independent sessions. The real `EnvClient` also completes reset, | |
| answer submission and state inspection through a local Uvicorn TCP server. | |
| - NeMo Gym 0.7.0's native request/response models, JSONL export and resource server | |
| grade all 140 pairs. Its real FastAPI `/verify` endpoint returns the expected | |
| reward; a policy model and training supervisor are not required for this check. | |
| - AgentEnv 0.9.1334 discovers the installed `mathematics_grade` plugin. Native | |
| task/step serialization and scoring cover all 140 pairs. A real `EpisodeSpec` | |
| run through local stores hands out the solver turn, records its supplied | |
| response, grades it, and returns the expected final score. No deployed model, | |
| A2A agent container, cloud sandbox or model training was exercised. | |
| An additional focused check passes the exported EN/RU bundle through the actual | |
| AgentEnv bundle parser (one test, separate from the complete-suite count above). | |
| - Cross-framework process tests found and fixed Windows child-process locale | |
| corruption of Russian questions by explicitly enabling UTF-8 in the grader. | |
| - Separate extras/venvs preserve Verifiers' MCP 2 pin and the other SDKs' MCP 1 | |
| dependencies. Current NeMo Gym needs Linux and Python >=3.13.14. | |
| Reproduce with `scripts/run_rl_tests.sh` and `scripts/run_framework_tests.sh` in | |
| the source checkout. The latter pins all four SDKs and runs on CPU in a separate | |
| environment. Tests do not require credentials, a model endpoint or hosted jobs. | |
| These counts are pytest cases; the module matrices each loop through 140 tasks. | |
| All fixture math remains regression/reference-acceptance evidence, not an | |
| independent full-corpus proof. Framework manifests and Docker definitions are | |
| included in the source/Hub package; configuring CI is not a hosted CI result. | |
| ## Fixture generation | |
| See [fixture provenance](tests/fixtures/provenance.toml) for hashes and versions. | |
| Russian source is the translated generator at base commit | |
| `e97cd83e190163e025dd831886f05460a11c1bc8`; English source is the original upstream | |
| commit `427f45075f84b8b9774950196ad63867ca20ffb3`. `scripts/build_rl_fixtures.py` | |
| uses per-module/category seeds derived from seed 20261018 and applies the same | |
| 160-character question / 30-character answer limits as the generator. | |
| The old English generator needs Python 3.10 and NumPy 1.26 because newer Python | |
| rejects its integer-valued float randint bounds and NumPy 2 removed `itemset`. | |
| The generator sources are not patched to create the English fixtures. Russian | |
| generation uses the existing translated checkout; neither generator was changed | |
| for RL. The environment itself uses modern dependencies pinned in `uv.lock`. | |
| ## Boundaries | |
| These fixtures are engineering regression data, not held-out model benchmarks. | |
| Accepting an official generator's answer does not independently validate its math. | |
| The full 125,409,832-row corpus has not been audited, deduplicated or used for an | |
| RL experiment here. Release preparation changes only the card and `rl/`; | |
| it neither rewrites Parquet nor uploads files itself. The source repository's | |
| publication report records the actual Hub commit and post-upload verification. | |