TRACE / NOTICE.md
d4x1's picture taoist's picture
Duplicate from taoist/TRACE
fefcb3a
|
Raw History Blame Contribute Delete
4.89 kB
# Notice: Yelp Open Dataset & License Boundaries
The TRACE benchmark builds on the **Yelp Open Dataset**. We do **not** redistribute Yelp-owned content. This file documents what is and isn't included, and why.
## What is included in this release
| Component | Origin | License |
|---|---|---|
| Dialogue **structure** (turns, actions, scenarios, personas, persona-grounded preferences) | Generated by us | CC BY 4.0 |
| Dialogue **text outside quotes** | Generated by us using LLMs | CC BY 4.0 |
| Per-turn grounding annotations (`referenced_poi_ids`, `referenced_review_ids`, `acceptable_alternative_poi_ids`, `discovered_review_ids`) | Generated by us | CC BY 4.0 |
| `quote_spans` metadata (review IDs, integer offsets, edit operations) | Generated by us | CC BY 4.0 |
| Difficulty labels, candidate pools, open-set pools | Generated by us | CC BY 4.0 |
| Code (`trace_kit/`, `scripts/`, `examples/`) | Written by us | CC BY 4.0 |
| **Yelp `business_id` / `review_id` values** | Yelp Open Dataset | Bare identifiers — factual reference, not subject to copyright |
| POI metadata (name, address, stars, categories, lat/lon, price range, attributes) | Yelp Open Dataset | Distributed under the academic-fair-use carve-out of §4.E (academic publication) — see below |
| Per-review metadata (stars, date) — IDs only | Yelp Open Dataset | Same as above |
## What is **not** included
| Component | Why |
|---|---|
| **Verbatim review text** | Yelp ToS §4.A: cannot publicly display reviews. |
| **LLM-generated quotations of reviews** | Even paraphrased quotes ≥90 fuzzy similarity are arguably derivative works of Yelp content (§5 Ownership). We replace them with `[Q:N]` placeholders backed by positional metadata. |
| Tip text, user account data | Yelp ToS §4.A. |
| Bulk POI listings without provenance | Would constitute "creating a competing local-listings DB" (§4.A). |
To obtain review text, see `scripts/reconstruct_kb.py` — it pulls text from your own copy of `yelp_academic_dataset_review.json` (you must download it after accepting the Yelp ToS) and rebuilds both the KB and the dialogue text.
## Quote-masking design
The `quote_spans` metadata is purposefully designed to contain **no Yelp word content**:
- **Exact verbatim** quotes (≈86% of cases): stored as `(review_id, [start, end])` — three integers + an ID.
- **Near-verbatim** quotes (≈11% of cases): stored as `(review_id, [start, end], edits)`. The `edits` list contains:
- `ins_p`/`rep_p`: insert/replace using whitelisted punctuation only (`. , ; : ! ? ' " - / ( ) [ ] { } whitespace`). No alphanumeric content.
- `ins_r`/`rep_r`: insert/replace by referencing another review span (`rid, c, d`). The actual word content is fetched from the user's hydrated Yelp data, never from our metadata.
Concretely, for any LLM-substituted alphanumeric content, the metadata stores **only positional pointers** into the corpus. A reader of our distribution who has not also accepted the Yelp ToS cannot reconstruct any Yelp word. This mirrors the "ship the IDs, hydrate locally" pattern used by every Yelp-derived academic benchmark.
The remaining ≈3% of LLM-quoted content (substantive paraphrase or non-quote regex artifacts) is left as plain text — these are demonstrably original LLM output that does not retrieve back to a single review span at ≥90 fuzzy similarity.
## Yelp Dataset Terms of Use — key clauses (Feb 2021)
Authoritative source: <https://www.yelp.com/dataset>. The clauses below are summarized; the full agreement controls.
- **§3 License grant**: royalty-free, non-exclusive, **non-sublicensable**, **non-transferable**, **revocable**, for **non-commercial use only**.
- **§3 Publication**: prior to public presentation involving the Data and the Yelp brand name, results must be submitted to Yelp for review (5 business days).
- **§4.A**: cannot publicly display the Data, **especially reviews and other user generated content**.
- **§4.B**: no commercial use.
- **§4.E**: cannot redistribute summaries or metrics — *except* disclosures necessary for academic publication.
- **§4.H**: cannot rent, lease, sell, transfer, assign, or sublicense any part of the Data.
- **§10 Term**: 12 months, terminable at any time; on termination must delete all copies.
## How to comply when using TRACE
By downloading and using TRACE, you acknowledge that:
1. You will obtain your own copy of the Yelp Open Dataset (and accept Yelp's ToS) before hydrating review text.
2. You will use the resulting hydrated KB for **non-commercial academic research only**.
3. You will not redistribute review text.
4. If your institution has commercial interests, you will obtain a separate authorization from Yelp before using the data in production.
## Reporting issues
- Yelp ToS questions: `dataset@yelp.com`
- TRACE issues: see the repository linked in `dataset_info.json`.