text stringlengths 0 166 |
|---|
f979705293849de48e4b40aa8988c046fa5871da |
8fdc369223509baee3422914efb3053adbd27b6391073644599a3a9ca1519cb3 experiments/LDE2G_PREREG.md |
b02983dbd22674c5b234aaada26e5003133f6a70464859e831267089c24d0137 experiments/lde2g_generator.py |
496e31ab7740c1f6264b94811f2d49b3a1f359a22be7df4ada78507620518638 experiments/lde2g_information_priority_confirmatory.py |
0d37b5c676c7fa1f6248db6fc62b82bf64a98d60c7e0025bd387a0f63c834367 lde/swarm/protocol.py |
d1e3c827a1811094ba93cf03ca9d26a1155a7f7f9883cf33608fe88062f43c2a lde/swarm/priority.py |
5f2ba5f1c60718dce95bdefc86b3e77a1799934843f535388a89b58321f3524f lde/swarm/selection.py |
cb004d9136656f1843dcf22b9b9a4fc5bd612962de04160781ad9c4c1e3d12f8 lde/swarm/discrimination.py |
fa72322e0152f269abc67929ee17abe713206ebc0bfd07588d9d5912f32c2c38 tests/test_lde2g_confirmatory.py |
=== LDE-2G S25 PRE-EXPERIMENT ENVIRONMENT === |
Captured UTC: |
2026-10-07T16:05:38Z |
=== REPOSITORY === |
commit: f979705293849de48e4b40aa8988c046fa5871da |
working_tree_status: |
=== PYTHON === |
Python 3.14.6 |
machine: aarch64 |
platform: Android-16-aarch64-64bit-ELF |
implementation: CPython |
python: 3.14.6 (main, Jul 5 2026, 10:35:55) [Clang 21.0.0 (https://android.googlesource.com/toolchain/llvm-project 5e96669f0 |
=== BUILD === |
compiler: aarch64-linux-android-clang |
SOABI: cpython-314-aarch64-linux-android |
=== HOST === |
Linux localhost 6.6.98-android15-8-pd6ff1cd-abogkiS938USQSCCZF9-4k #1 SMP PREEMPT Tue Aug 11 06:32:03 UTC 2026 aarch64 Android |
arch: aarch64 |
=== ANDROID === |
model: SM-S938U |
abi: arm64-v8a |
android: 16 |
build: S938USQSCCZF9 |
=== STORAGE === |
Filesystem Size Used Avail Use% Mounted on |
/dev/block/dm-72 459G 197G 261G 44% /data/user/0 |
=== LDE-2G SOURCE HASHES === |
8fdc369223509baee3422914efb3053adbd27b6391073644599a3a9ca1519cb3 experiments/LDE2G_PREREG.md |
b02983dbd22674c5b234aaada26e5003133f6a70464859e831267089c24d0137 experiments/lde2g_generator.py |
496e31ab7740c1f6264b94811f2d49b3a1f359a22be7df4ada78507620518638 experiments/lde2g_information_priority_confirmatory.py |
0d37b5c676c7fa1f6248db6fc62b82bf64a98d60c7e0025bd387a0f63c834367 lde/swarm/protocol.py |
d1e3c827a1811094ba93cf03ca9d26a1155a7f7f9883cf33608fe88062f43c2a lde/swarm/priority.py |
5f2ba5f1c60718dce95bdefc86b3e77a1799934843f535388a89b58321f3524f lde/swarm/selection.py |
cb004d9136656f1843dcf22b9b9a4fc5bd612962de04160781ad9c4c1e3d12f8 lde/swarm/discrimination.py |
fa72322e0152f269abc67929ee17abe713206ebc0bfd07588d9d5912f32c2c38 tests/test_lde2g_confirmatory.py |
e5a9d5e372e69061e2db8d9a820121637a67d61fd800bc5f8403586cab983c39 evidence/05_exploratory/generator_independence/azure/README.md |
0569445b9d77d7cc21cb9d4d67499f0d5782382f2cf8a1d6b0294c54fbf03989 evidence/05_exploratory/generator_independence/azure/command.txt |
95374d9ce31783a1756f5e196fe9fe90745627bba4725aeb157dbf6a0fb793a3 evidence/05_exploratory/generator_independence/azure/environment.txt |
4a8ba5ad855c89dcd2746eb2e4e4cd2ce243fb2e88fcc85dedb4cec2dd4bb33f evidence/05_exploratory/generator_independence/azure/summary.json |
e42987d1cf52ac827ef5039c902fb9f87a2e51371c09c2de5bbcd6b019f338d9 evidence/05_exploratory/generator_independence/azure/stdout.txt |
e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855 evidence/05_exploratory/generator_independence/azure/stderr.txt |
9a271f2a916b0b6ee6cecb2426f0b3206ef074578be55d9bc94f6f3fe3ab86aa evidence/05_exploratory/generator_independence/azure/exit_code.txt |
PYTHONPATH="$PWD" python3 - <<'PY' |
from experiments.lde2g_generator import generate_case |
from experiments.exploratory.lde2g_generator_independence import generate_case_independent |
from lde.swarm.blackboard import ResearchBlackboard |
from lde.swarm.discrimination import candidate_discrimination |
from lde.swarm.priority import priority_score |
from lde.swarm.selection import select_next_experiment |
def evaluate(case): |
board = ResearchBlackboard() |
for hypothesis in case.hypotheses: |
board.add_hypothesis(hypothesis) |
for request in case.requests: |
board.add_experiment_request(request) |
selected = select_next_experiment(board) |
if selected is None: |
raise AssertionError("case produced no selectable request") |
hypothesis_records = tuple( |
{ |
"hypothesis_id": h.hypothesis_id, |
"author": h.author, |
"statement": h.statement, |
"predictions": h.predictions, |
} |
for h in case.hypotheses |
) |
scores = { |
request.request_id: candidate_discrimination( |
hypothesis_records, |
request.input_value, |
) |
for request in case.requests |
} |
LDE-2G cross-substrate research record
Raw records of one preregistered experiment, LDE-2G, run on the Local Discovery Engine at source commit
f979705293849de48e4b40aa8988c046fa5871da
(codeberg.org/badatchess/local-discovery-engine).
This card was added on 2026-11-07. It describes the files as they are; no data, protocol or historical output was
changed.
Result first: the primary hypothesis was not supported
The preregistered hypothesis (01_preregistration/LDE2G_PREREG.md) was that the engine's existing priority
selector picks the candidate experiment with maximal measured discrimination in every trial. It did not.
From the root result_summary.json (Azure confirmatory run):
| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| cases | 60 (seeds 0–59) |
| selected_maximal | 49 |
| non_maximal | 11 |
| selection_rate | 0.816667 |
| mean_selected_discrimination | 3.8 |
| mean_maximum_discrimination | 4.0 |
| primary_hypothesis_supported | false |
The preregistration's falsification rule is that any trial selecting a strictly lower-discrimination candidate refutes the hypothesis; 11 of 60 did.
What "discrimination" means here. For a candidate experiment, it is the number of distinct outputs predicted by the competing hypotheses (a deterministic count). The preregistration says explicitly that it is not Shannon information gain, and that agreement or disagreement with it says nothing about AI intelligence, reasoning, optimal experiment design or generalization.
What did reproduce: the same output on two machines
releases/2026-10-11/lde-cross-substrate-evidence/04_confirmatory/ records the same confirmatory run on:
- Azure: x86_64, Ubuntu Server 24.04.4 LTS, CPython 3.12.3;
- a Samsung Galaxy S25 Ultra: aarch64, Android 16, CPython 3.14.6.
Both gave 49/60 (0.816667). cross_substrate_comparison.json records byte-identical stdout (sha256
966108ec…934b), identical empty stderr and exit code 0, and 0 per-seed differences:
EXACT_MATCH_FOR_RECORDED_CONFIRMATORY_OUTPUT.
This shows that the recorded behaviour reproduced on these two machines. It does not show portability to other platforms, independent replication by another party, or that the hypothesis is true. The same failed result reproduced.
Preserved separately: an invalid attempt
The root stderr.txt and exit_code.txt (1) are from a first, invalid attempt that failed before any
experiment ran (ModuleNotFoundError: No module named 'lde'), as stated in failed_attempt_status.txt. The
confirmatory run's own files are confirmatory_stdout.txt, confirmatory_stderr.txt (empty) and
confirmatory_exit_code.txt (0).
Exploratory, not preregistered
05_exploratory/generator_independence/ changes how the case generator draws random numbers (one stream vs
split streams). With split streams, 46/60 were maximal (0.766667), against 49/60 for the original. Its own
summary says this changed the observed behaviour in one 60-seed run and does not establish causality or
statistical independence. It is not part of the confirmatory result.
Layout
| Path | Contents |
|---|---|
01_preregistration/ |
the original LDE-2G preregistration |
02_source/ |
source commit and source-file hashes |
03_substrates/s25/ |
the S25's environment fingerprint |
05_exploratory/ |
the generator-independence perturbation (exploratory) |
06_historical_lineage/2026-10-07/ |
earlier LDE baselines and experiments (LDE0–LDE2F) |
07_azure_archive/2026-10-07/ |
the Azure archive: preregistration, Amendments 1 and 2, source, environment |
99_provenance/ |
the pre-confirmatory manifest (recorded with the outcome not yet known), timeline and hashes |
releases/2026-10-11/ |
the cross-substrate release bundle |
education/ |
a research curriculum document (not evidence) |
| root files | the Azure confirmatory outputs, plus the invalid attempt described above |
Amendment 1 reclassifies the first implementation as a pilot / nondiagnostic and keeps it. Amendment 2 freezes the confirmatory procedure (seeds 0–59, four hypotheses and six candidates per case). The original preregistration is kept unchanged.
Limits
- Synthetic, generator-dependent workload; results are conditional on that generator.
- Two computational substrates, both run by the same owner. No independent replication.
- No licence has been declared for this dataset. Ask the owner before reuse.
Provenance
Dataset owner: Chad Holland (Hugging Face: holland202). The files listed above do not record which AI systems, if any, helped design or run the experiment, so this card does not say. This card was drafted by Claude (Anthropic, Opus 5.5) from the files listed above, on 2026-11-06 → human validation: not performed → human responsibility: Chad Holland.
- Downloads last month
- 126