Datasets:

imaadd05
/

painted-metal-defects-web

label stringclasses 2 values	human_label stringclasses 2 values	original_model_label stringclasses 2 values	fresh_model_label stringclasses 4 values	reason stringlengths 70 236	model_evidence dict	flags listlengths 0 4	primary_reviewed bool 2 classes	human_rejudge_label stringclasses 2 values	source stringclasses 7 values	page stringlengths 22 221	url stringlengths 31 297	license stringclasses 3 values	source_sha256 stringlengths 64 64	stored_sha256 stringlengths 64 64	group int64 807 75.8k
defect	defect	good	good	Human rejudge of original defect candidate: defect. (earlier: Enlarged image shows continuous glossy red coating; edge joins and highlights are not clear coating loss.)	{ "image_index": 4, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Glossy red powder-coated perforated box; coating uniform and continuous with no visible chips, runs, or gaps.", "location": "", "flags": [] }	[ "visual_adjudication" ]	true	defect	reddit-archive	https://reddit.com/r/Machinists/comments/10qanih/kept_running_out_of_room_for_my_cat40_tooling_so/	https://i.redd.it/l4v92zvdkhfa1.jpg	reddit-user-content	9288423dd95567ca6ddd7826b5ad16fec85a802cd85530da6684be4319c97197	9288423dd95567ca6ddd7826b5ad16fec85a802cd85530da6684be4319c97197	44,819
defect	defect	defect	exclude	Human rejudge of original defect candidate: defect. (earlier: Moulded bin has plastic construction and rim damage, outside painted-metal inspection scope.)	{ "image_index": 5, "decision": "exclude", "evidence": "Molded gray bin liner with plastic-like seams and flexed rim; appears nonmetal, not a painted metal object.", "location": "", "flags": [ "material likely plastic" ] }	[ "material likely plastic", "visual_adjudication" ]	true	defect	reddit-archive	https://reddit.com/r/fixit/comments/1urmku6/kitchen_pullout_waste_bin_bucketcracked_and/	https://i.redd.it/gczftyvln6ch1.jpeg	reddit-user-content	f6e0da493dc85100cf56f7e0228b811bb3503704542a1943bd90511baeba4306	f6e0da493dc85100cf56f7e0228b811bb3503704542a1943bd90511baeba4306	48,683
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Motorcycle frame with uniform metallic orange coating; continuous glossy finish, no visible chips or coverage gaps.	{ "image_index": 6, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Motorcycle frame with uniform metallic orange coating; continuous glossy finish, no visible chips or coverage gaps.", "location": "", "flags": [] }	[]	false	null	reddit-archive	https://reddit.com/r/Powdercoating/comments/gmscb9/honda_cb750_frame/	https://i.redd.it/jhh3v1ao4rz41.jpg	reddit-user-content	c676035a6faaf07a6e6d37c6a24b7ca445aff2e30ede702223e56e914a2782f4	c676035a6faaf07a6e6d37c6a24b7ca445aff2e30ede702223e56e914a2782f4	1,104
defect	defect	good	good	Human rejudge of original defect candidate: defect. (earlier: Orange coated panel has no clearly visible coating damage; fine uniform texture alone is insufficient.)	{ "image_index": 8, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Rectangular orange-coated metal test coupon; uniform continuous coating, no chips, scratches, or runs.", "location": "", "flags": [] }	[ "visual_adjudication" ]	true	defect	reddit-archive	https://reddit.com/r/Powdercoating/comments/1djefou/powdercoating_problem/	https://i.redd.it/tbmu5q38sh7d1.jpeg	reddit-user-content	72ed4517b9128798320341eb3cb5d769614e00a49d1810eca50e10da184a5cca	72ed4517b9128798320341eb3cb5d769614e00a49d1810eca50e10da184a5cca	1,388
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Uniform textured silver powder-coat on the ring; no chips, scratches, peeling, runs or coverage gaps visible.	{ "image_index": 1, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Uniform textured silver powder-coat on the ring; no chips, scratches, peeling, runs or coverage gaps visible.", "location": "", "flags": [ "Textured/hammered finish appears intentional and uniform" ] }	[ "Textured/hammered finish appears intentional and uniform" ]	false	null	reddit-archive	https://reddit.com/r/Powdercoating/comments/1gdr7gv/price_check/	https://i.redd.it/roor4wrilexd1.jpeg	reddit-user-content	ef49d739d41c5b1d5d8c074af9882abced9f69998e3db57257a1e918c216f8e3	ef49d739d41c5b1d5d8c074af9882abced9f69998e3db57257a1e918c216f8e3	1,434
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Flat metal coupon with uniform copper textured coating; no visible chips, scratches, peeling or runs.	{ "image_index": 2, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Flat metal coupon with uniform copper textured coating; no visible chips, scratches, peeling or runs.", "location": "", "flags": [ "Coupon-style test plate; uniform finish" ] }	[ "Coupon-style test plate; uniform finish" ]	false	null	reddit-archive	https://reddit.com/r/Powdercoating/comments/1jpx3k3/had_any_one_used_this_cardinal_og91_we_just_got/	https://i.redd.it/1mlbxy981hse1.jpeg	reddit-user-content	f00c0340c5170def03ec40df3547253339088a062f75998fa5635b2761e50a84	f00c0340c5170def03ec40df3547253339088a062f75998fa5635b2761e50a84	3,237
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Uniform matte black coating on perforated plate; edges and hole rims show no chips, scratches or peeling.	{ "image_index": 3, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Uniform matte black coating on perforated plate; edges and hole rims show no chips, scratches or peeling.", "location": "", "flags": [ "Glove background clutter acceptable" ] }	[ "Glove background clutter acceptable" ]	false	null	reddit-archive	https://reddit.com/r/Powdercoating/comments/1lrkxbs/anyone_want_to_try_our_coatings/	https://i.redd.it/roo9n3m6hvaf1.jpeg	reddit-user-content	293ea5d339195daf1ff2ab63aea6616c95efc3e7428cb352c8e3cc97fad3264c	293ea5d339195daf1ff2ab63aea6616c95efc3e7428cb352c8e3cc97fad3264c	3,257
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Uniform glossy light-blue coating on the box; interior, edges and hole rims show no damage or coverage gaps.	{ "image_index": 5, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Uniform glossy light-blue coating on the box; interior, edges and hole rims show no damage or coverage gaps.", "location": "", "flags": [] }	[]	false	null	reddit-archive	https://reddit.com/r/metalworking/comments/ao4wbt/makeup_brush_box_i_made_from_sheet/	https://i.redd.it/jcpc2mdt06f21.jpg	reddit-user-content	7c17be2d308ee7de46fab99970bfad93bc0c3b4e9bb7c291cd4745be6bc8e496	7c17be2d308ee7de46fab99970bfad93bc0c3b4e9bb7c291cd4745be6bc8e496	3,569
defect	defect	defect	defect	Human rejudge of original defect candidate: defect. (earlier: Enlarged photo shows multiple pale scratches and scuffs across left rectangular raised block and its front edge; weld beads alone are not the defect.)	{ "image_index": 6, "decision": "defect", "evidence": "Black coating shows a raised glossy drip/run blob on the right block top and fine scratch marks on the left block top surface.", "location": "Right rectangular block top (drip/run); left block top (scratches)", "flags": [ "Thick glossy coating may exa...	[ "Thick glossy coating may exaggerate runs; scratches could be handling wear", "visual_adjudication" ]	true	defect	reddit-archive	https://reddit.com/r/Welding/comments/dtt2mf/barn_door_latch_finished_project/	https://i.redd.it/yqrme5ku9mx31.jpg	reddit-user-content	e56062c702b90cee368edda6738b3f2b2d4cfa532e3a211fccfbac09d67c2e23	e56062c702b90cee368edda6738b3f2b2d4cfa532e3a211fccfbac09d67c2e23	4,899
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Uniform glossy maroon coating on cylindrical part; reflections and grooves are normal, no chips, scratches or peeling.	{ "image_index": 7, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Uniform glossy maroon coating on cylindrical part; reflections and grooves are normal, no chips, scratches or peeling.", "location": "", "flags": [ "Background sign text is not an overlay on the object" ] }	[ "Background sign text is not an overlay on the object" ]	false	null	serper-google	https://www.reddit.com/r/drums/comments/y4rrfv/got_a_nasty_old_kit_and_painted_the_metal_snare/	https://i.redd.it/g74pytd9uzt91.jpg	unknown	3dcfa43b9eb883fec540a52cc8fae014b05ccbe5e90b3f98cabf0791348db687	3dcfa43b9eb883fec540a52cc8fae014b05ccbe5e90b3f98cabf0791348db687	7,429
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Glossy orange painted metal part on hanger wires; coating uniform and continuous with no chips, scratches, peeling, or runs visible.	{ "image_index": 1, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Glossy orange painted metal part on hanger wires; coating uniform and continuous with no chips, scratches, peeling, or runs visible.", "location": "", "flags": [ "background clutter (boots, feet) acceptable" ] }	[ "background clutter (boots, feet) acceptable" ]	false	null	reddit-archive	https://reddit.com/r/paint/comments/zler1j/just_painted_my_car/	https://i.redd.it/29c80dobxr5a1.jpg	reddit-user-content	f3382e1b1b6c0253682f317aa0a1ec48c954b3be0f01d14e8c2cd254d72682f9	f3382e1b1b6c0253682f317aa0a1ec48c954b3be0f01d14e8c2cd254d72682f9	11,780
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; White painted metal cabinet/housing; coating uniform across panels with no visible chips, scratches, peeling, or coverage gaps.	{ "image_index": 2, "decision": "good", "evidence": "White painted metal cabinet/housing; coating uniform across panels with no visible chips, scratches, peeling, or coverage gaps.", "location": "", "flags": [ "strong sunlight shadow, not a coating fault" ] }	[ "strong sunlight shadow, not a coating fault" ]	false	null	reddit-archive	https://reddit.com/r/fabrication/comments/hc0c1o/just_finishing_up_some_downdraft_worktables/	https://i.redd.it/aipjns6p6v551.jpg	reddit-user-content	a250cf3d445c7f52e1774f665b02e6dc0676392f9e546de57600e1767738dab7	a250cf3d445c7f52e1774f665b02e6dc0676392f9e546de57600e1767738dab7	15,891
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Glossy blue painted metal bicycle frame on hanger; coating continuous and uniform with no chips, scratches, or runs.	{ "image_index": 4, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Glossy blue painted metal bicycle frame on hanger; coating continuous and uniform with no chips, scratches, or runs.", "location": "", "flags": [] }	[]	false	null	brave	https://prismaticpowders.com/gallery/10297/powder-coated-bmx-bicycle-frame	https://images.nicindust…4209973&size=450	unknown	a05626ef8c52bdca01b69bd8559e4c275f083ba75086e25760a3b5410df2e6fa	a05626ef8c52bdca01b69bd8559e4c275f083ba75086e25760a3b5410df2e6fa	20,025
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Metallic blue painted motorcycle frame on carpet; coating uniform and glossy with no visible chips, scratches, or peeling.	{ "image_index": 5, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Metallic blue painted motorcycle frame on carpet; coating uniform and glossy with no visible chips, scratches, or peeling.", "location": "", "flags": [] }	[]	false	null	brave	https://prismaticpowders.com/gallery/9761/powder-coated-blue-quad-bike-frame	https://images.nicindust…1174349&size=450	unknown	c6505039de0274b6cd501cf05beb1a8b77406d7c0c44597f4f58d38a4f3880ae	c6505039de0274b6cd501cf05beb1a8b77406d7c0c44597f4f58d38a4f3880ae	20,028
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; White painted cast-iron radiator; coating uniform and glossy across sections with no chips, scratches, or coverage gaps.	{ "image_index": 6, "decision": "good", "evidence": "White painted cast-iron radiator; coating uniform and glossy across sections with no chips, scratches, or coverage gaps.", "location": "", "flags": [] }	[]	false	null	brave	https://reddit.com/r/DIYUK/comments/1k5zuye/painting_new_column_radiators	https://i.redd.it/885ldkq1clwe1.jpeg	unknown	680a9d352a3ec369aa2cebcdbe61e0d014407a7e5d1944d347153658af0930b4	680a9d352a3ec369aa2cebcdbe61e0d014407a7e5d1944d347153658af0930b4	20,469
defect	defect	good	good	Human rejudge of original defect candidate: defect. (earlier: Enlarged photo shows subtle edge irregularity but cannot separate chipped coating from substrate damage and shadow.)	{ "image_index": 7, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Matte dark-gray painted metal panel leaning on wall; coating uniform with no visible chips, scratches, peeling, or runs.", "location": "", "flags": [ "material authenticity slightly ambiguous (could be non-metal panel)" ] }	[ "material authenticity slightly ambiguous (could be non-metal panel)", "visual_adjudication", "excluded_from_default_release_unresolved" ]	true	defect	reddit-archive	https://reddit.com/r/DIY/comments/l9en8r/got_this_big_headboard_to_fix_up_its_got_a_wooden/	https://i.redd.it/x2btmt3ntoe61.jpg	reddit-user-content	ab056d7a794c518769ebb48468aa7e8e1c65677fd4f8ddd0bf5bb8d838d46201	ab056d7a794c518769ebb48468aa7e8e1c65677fd4f8ddd0bf5bb8d838d46201	23,668
defect	defect	good	good	Human rejudge of original defect candidate: defect. (earlier: Black bracket coating appears continuous; normal mounting tabs and hole edges are not defects.)	{ "image_index": 8, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Matte black painted metal bracket on wood floor; coating uniform with no visible chips, scratches, peeling, or runs.", "location": "", "flags": [] }	[ "visual_adjudication" ]	true	defect	reddit-archive	https://reddit.com/r/fixit/comments/1fvz310/can_someone_please_help_me_with_pointing_me_in/	https://i.redd.it/fd3ou97vqqsd1.jpeg	reddit-user-content	b080b5e90f36b187867a0dd6cecb811c79abdc3fffd1393cc3f17cef1a2f6a0f	b080b5e90f36b187867a0dd6cecb811c79abdc3fffd1393cc3f17cef1a2f6a0f	47,794
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Green painted metal panel with uniform smooth coating; no chips, scratches, peeling, runs, or coverage gaps visible on the face or edges.	{ "image_index": 1, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Green painted metal panel with uniform smooth coating; no chips, scratches, peeling, runs, or coverage gaps visible on the face or edges.", "location": "", "flags": [ "background cardboard clutter acceptable" ] }	[ "background cardboard clutter acceptable" ]	false	null	reddit-archive	https://reddit.com/r/paint/comments/16hee8u/best_thing_to_use_for_a_protective_coat/	https://i.redd.it/p53sa3mskynb1.jpg	reddit-user-content	9555ed681d095e0441c05f7132bd1c41216acbb03f4ab189f3c928cfa52aeab0	9555ed681d095e0441c05f7132bd1c41216acbb03f4ab189f3c928cfa52aeab0	12,052
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Olive green painted metal case with handle; coating uniform across body and lid; no visible chips, scratches, or coverage gaps.	{ "image_index": 3, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Olive green painted metal case with handle; coating uniform across body and lid; no visible chips, scratches, or coverage gaps.", "location": "", "flags": [] }	[]	false	null	serper-google	https://huckberry.com/store/bull-metal/category/p/1000628-hand-painted-steel-tool-box-removable-tray?srsltid=AYCX9vI8JLKqgJC9XsemXlp3DUSGr3e3igOi7GI8V0RXHPKZb-419dbC	https://huckberry.imgix.…xlib=react-9.8.1	unknown	17177fee6698b15b29b2d55f26076d0b947f7381648ff2e1ed522a15adf02ee8	17177fee6698b15b29b2d55f26076d0b947f7381648ff2e1ed522a15adf02ee8	7,824
defect	defect	good	good	Human rejudge of original defect candidate: defect. (earlier: Grey coated enclosure has uniform visible finish; panel seams and knockouts are normal geometry.)	{ "image_index": 4, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Gray painted metal electrical box; coating uniform on all faces; no chips, scratches, peeling, or runs visible.", "location": "", "flags": [] }	[ "visual_adjudication" ]	true	defect	serper-google	https://www.lowes.com/pd/WIEGMANN-SC-Gray-Metal-Weatherproof-New-Work-Standard-Enclosure-Wall-Electrical-Box/50311355	https://mobileimages.low…bb3/65866302.jpg	unknown	2a6bd2feac118d0798c88b5a92636441902922043c04ef51f892fb51025ed055	2a6bd2feac118d0798c88b5a92636441902922043c04ef51f892fb51025ed055	73,029
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Teal painted metal filing cabinet; coating uniform on body and drawer fronts; no visible chips, scratches, or peeling.	{ "image_index": 5, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Teal painted metal filing cabinet; coating uniform on body and drawer fronts; no visible chips, scratches, or peeling.", "location": "", "flags": [ "real product photo, acceptable" ] }	[ "real product photo, acceptable" ]	false	null	serper-google	https://www.reddit.com/r/upcycling/comments/o6lp37/gave_this_old_filing_cabinet_from_the_thrift/	https://i.redd.it/zl6pwn4rv2771.jpg	unknown	47e30639ab0e4ddb324757f6305e6dac42313691b1d7379239a7737c7f04ff20	47e30639ab0e4ddb324757f6305e6dac42313691b1d7379239a7737c7f04ff20	72,535
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Matte black painted metal side table; coating uniform on tray top and legs; no visible chips, scratches, or coverage gaps.	{ "image_index": 6, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Matte black painted metal side table; coating uniform on tray top and legs; no visible chips, scratches, or coverage gaps.", "location": "", "flags": [] }	[]	false	null	brave	https://www2.hm.com/fi_fi/home/osta-tuotteen-mukaan/huonekalut/poydat.html?colorWithNames=musta_000000	https://image.hm.com/ass…ae465c3885bb.jpg	unknown	355f4987149d4e5c92fafb71bf91d956e839c27367139e19ca9d09ce4e1bce94	355f4987149d4e5c92fafb71bf91d956e839c27367139e19ca9d09ce4e1bce94	42,509
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Glossy black painted metal part; coating intact and uniform; dark central rectangle is a reflection, not a chip; no peeling or runs visible.	{ "image_index": 7, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Glossy black painted metal part; coating intact and uniform; dark central rectangle is a reflection, not a chip; no peeling or runs visible.", "location": "", "flags": [ "strong outdoor reflections may obscure fine detail" ] }	[ "strong outdoor reflections may obscure fine detail" ]	false	null	reddit-archive	https://reddit.com/r/Powdercoating/comments/cfl67h/problem_fixed/	https://i.redd.it/056snc1x9gb31.jpg	reddit-user-content	54b334367c61886ff23661f438987e9d745ef6d7338c3e5c662dab3ddffca95b	54b334367c61886ff23661f438987e9d745ef6d7338c3e5c662dab3ddffca95b	1,029
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; White painted metal lateral file cabinet; coating uniform on body and drawer fronts; no visible chips, scratches, or peeling.	{ "image_index": 8, "decision": "good", "evidence": "White painted metal lateral file cabinet; coating uniform on body and drawer fronts; no visible chips, scratches, or peeling.", "location": "", "flags": [] }	[]	false	null	serper-google	https://www.overstock.com/Home-Garden/Hirsh-36-W-2-Drawer-Metal-Lateral-File-Cabinet-for-Home-Office-with-Premium-Matte-Texture-Finish/40382964/product.html?srsltid=AYCX9vIVU7nKZNyU0k7QMMBY0YznBJFeABYuF_sW3sY_gtv02GXxTz-t	https://ak1.ostkcdn.com/…xture-Finish.jpg	unknown	aa3a241bf9f9ff2f7d7874518007816ad6a0a51fc31b0cf8cef97d1db1462c43	aa3a241bf9f9ff2f7d7874518007816ad6a0a51fc31b0cf8cef97d1db1462c43	8,284
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Glossy black square post with base plate; surface shows uniform hammered/textured coating, no discrete chips, scratches or peeling.	{ "image_index": 2, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Glossy black square post with base plate; surface shows uniform hammered/textured coating, no discrete chips, scratches or peeling.", "location": "", "flags": [ "textured finish may be intentional; not called a fault" ] }	[ "textured finish may be intentional; not called a fault" ]	false	null	serper-google	https://www.lowes.com/pd/OUTDECO-52-in-Above-Ground-Galvanized-Steel-Fence-Post-with-Welded-Base-Plate-For-Privacy-Panels-and-Slat-Fence-Installs/5016276975	https://mobileimages.low…fd9/05383454.jpg	unknown	c5f58785c7c4a5e3caf685c6debdabc89b6b0f96b1cbf222803f69592305f2bb	c5f58785c7c4a5e3caf685c6debdabc89b6b0f96b1cbf222803f69592305f2bb	59,941
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Red triangular bracket with glossy powder-coat; slight orange-peel texture uniform across surfaces, no chips, runs or bare spots.	{ "image_index": 3, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Red triangular bracket with glossy powder-coat; slight orange-peel texture uniform across surfaces, no chips, runs or bare spots.", "location": "", "flags": [ "orange-peel texture likely intentional powder coat" ] }	[ "orange-peel texture likely intentional powder coat" ]	false	null	serper-google	https://www.etsy.com/listing/907047061/handmade-modern-shelf-bracket-color	https://i.etsystatic.com…1768542_fas3.jpg	unknown	deba4d238f85f880b60909b2303ed809098929336d95bb5bab496f5c4dafcfcf	deba4d238f85f880b60909b2303ed809098929336d95bb5bab496f5c4dafcfcf	71,720
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Green triangular bracket with uniform glossy coating; minor surface texture consistent, no visible chips, scratches or coverage gaps.	{ "image_index": 4, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Green triangular bracket with uniform glossy coating; minor surface texture consistent, no visible chips, scratches or coverage gaps.", "location": "", "flags": [ "powder-coat texture normal" ] }	[ "powder-coat texture normal" ]	false	null	serper-google	https://www.etsy.com/listing/1457268957/free-shipping-hanging-shelf-bracket-dark	https://i.etsystatic.com…0509344_1kb9.jpg	unknown	03fe10ec4c5dd4f7597964ddc70de1a01d75373201d5b1e493c0c9dca61bec09	03fe10ec4c5dd4f7597964ddc70de1a01d75373201d5b1e493c0c9dca61bec09	72,680
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; White bracket with hook; smooth uniform white coating across all members, no chips, scratches, peeling or runs visible.	{ "image_index": 5, "decision": "good", "evidence": "White bracket with hook; smooth uniform white coating across all members, no chips, scratches, peeling or runs visible.", "location": "", "flags": [] }	[]	false	null	serper-google	https://www.stoneharborhardware.com/products/round-bar-shelf-and-pole-bracket-powder-coated-3-drop-white-by-stone-harbor-hardware?srsltid=AYCX9vJtH21NIM6EHk1q87l6T6M2v4T6KKJl2OjDxrDw1y1eMpKQQ0Uw	https://www.stoneharborh…76535&width=2400	unknown	5b017925f5c998def8c1d1a54ca32f49eee7b61a1aa0da877bca7305dc0d15cf	5b017925f5c998def8c1d1a54ca32f49eee7b61a1aa0da877bca7305dc0d15cf	29,921
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Black painted metal stand; coating uniform on post, base and cradle; welds at base normal, no discrete paint damage.	{ "image_index": 6, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Black painted metal stand; coating uniform on post, base and cradle; welds at base normal, no discrete paint damage.", "location": "", "flags": [ "outdoor lighting; weld marks normal" ] }	[ "outdoor lighting; weld marks normal" ]	false	null	reddit-archive	https://reddit.com/r/Welding/comments/bz90jo/made_this_out_of_odds_and_ends_around_the_shop/	https://i.redd.it/zen2rhnf9o331.jpg	reddit-user-content	2bc8d7dd0cfb90b29b903ad3e43afc1428afc8977312c79159558e775a03fe79	2bc8d7dd0cfb90b29b903ad3e43afc1428afc8977312c79159558e775a03fe79	4,759
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Brown mailbox with smooth uniform coating and embossed decorative pattern; no chips, scratches, peeling or coverage gaps.	{ "image_index": 7, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Brown mailbox with smooth uniform coating and embossed decorative pattern; no chips, scratches, peeling or coverage gaps.", "location": "", "flags": [ "embossed pattern is design, not defect" ] }	[ "embossed pattern is design, not defect" ]	false	null	brave	https://www.amazon.com/Vertical-Mailbox-Smooth-Polished-Finish/dp/B00BB40ZTU	https://images-na.ssl-im…/71yiSDdVDhL.jpg	unknown	ee4fb7e17785e0e58cc1499b3759b56a116538d4bb65cfc242855d67c6235b7e	ee4fb7e17785e0e58cc1499b3759b56a116538d4bb65cfc242855d67c6235b7e	44,153
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Cream filing cabinet with smooth uniform painted metal body; no visible chips, scratches, peeling or runs.	{ "image_index": 8, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Cream filing cabinet with smooth uniform painted metal body; no visible chips, scratches, peeling or runs.", "location": "", "flags": [] }	[]	false	null	brave	https://amazon.com/In-Home-Recycling-Bins-Metal-Trash-Containers/s?page=3&rh=n%3A695485011%2Cp_n_material_two_browse-bin%3A11618330011	https://m.media-amazon.c…/51LRnz87IQL.jpg	unknown	ee8eb6f7ca2a22a171a3813ab886d807230fade936c8a644ca338938dd0585e3	ee8eb6f7ca2a22a171a3813ab886d807230fade936c8a644ca338938dd0585e3	59,941
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Maroon painted metal trim profile with uniform glossy coating; no chips, scratches, peeling or runs visible. Bare metal at cut cross-section edges is normal, not a coating fault.	{ "image_index": 1, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Maroon painted metal trim profile with uniform glossy coating; no chips, scratches, peeling or runs visible. Bare metal at cut cross-section edges is normal, not a coating fault.", "location": "", "flags": [ "Cut edges expose bare substrate by design" ...	[ "Cut edges expose bare substrate by design" ]	false	null	brave	https://framing4yourself.com/product/vivid-red-metal-custom-cut-picture-frame-21-227/	https://framing4yourself…227-scaled-2.jpg	unknown	462ac92ad1b81c4de1c4450d74371b2e9d7ecf7c9a62a1037d22107b8eb2ae69	462ac92ad1b81c4de1c4450d74371b2e9d7ecf7c9a62a1037d22107b8eb2ae69	29,825
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Black painted I-beam with continuous uniform coating across faces; no chips, blisters, peeling or coverage gaps. Bare metal at sheared ends is normal for structural stock.	{ "image_index": 2, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Black painted I-beam with continuous uniform coating across faces; no chips, blisters, peeling or coverage gaps. Bare metal at sheared ends is normal for structural stock.", "location": "", "flags": [ "Sheared beam ends show bare metal, expected" ] }	[ "Sheared beam ends show bare metal, expected" ]	false	null	serper-google	https://volterraproducts.com/product/faux-steel-i-beam/	https://volterraproducts…beam-cropped.jpg	unknown	f89dcd2cccb23f265dbf80695e6d46541f36a3fb6d1c8c964767f1e0a8857b5c	f89dcd2cccb23f265dbf80695e6d46541f36a3fb6d1c8c964767f1e0a8857b5c	7,751
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Light-blue painted perforated metal bench with even coating on legs and seat; no visible chips, scratches, peeling or runs. Perforations are intentional design.	{ "image_index": 3, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Light-blue painted perforated metal bench with even coating on legs and seat; no visible chips, scratches, peeling or runs. Perforations are intentional design.", "location": "", "flags": [ "Perforation pattern is intentional" ] }	[ "Perforation pattern is intentional" ]	false	null	serper-google	https://nola.se/produkter/areal-bank/	https://nola.se/site/ass…/arealbench1.jpg	unknown	c8c8ed0ba3deef4992445606cb0f1ca736c32687bee5db22ec6bb92714c68eaf	c8c8ed0ba3deef4992445606cb0f1ca736c32687bee5db22ec6bb92714c68eaf	20,964
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Green painted metal enclosure with uniform glossy coating on interior and exterior; no chips, peeling, blistering or coverage gaps. Knockouts and holes are intentional.	{ "image_index": 4, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Green painted metal enclosure with uniform glossy coating on interior and exterior; no chips, peeling, blistering or coverage gaps. Knockouts and holes are intentional.", "location": "", "flags": [ "Pre-punched knockouts are design features" ] }	[ "Pre-punched knockouts are design features" ]	false	null	serper-google	https://www.elo1.com/metal-fabrication-services-paint	https://images.squarespa…/127_D6A2075.jpg	unknown	995080e1992099ed2556fd1909657eea17e29316c5bc38e964755e1e88058523	750f3862e200ec7e6e6e9fd083b0e81e036a7e69024f85efe30c289d97896102	75,707
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Black painted metal lamp post with continuous uniform coating along shaft and base; no visible chips, scratches, peeling or runs.	{ "image_index": 5, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Black painted metal lamp post with continuous uniform coating along shaft and base; no visible chips, scratches, peeling or runs.", "location": "", "flags": [] }	[]	false	null	brave	https://www.amazon.com/lamp-post/s?k=lamp+post	https://m.media-amazon.c…/41CU31Ly+3L.jpg	unknown	a17582fa6b0676cc9d416c2c399827e0df9868420de9b5f5269e9e9ecea4fe1d	a17582fa6b0676cc9d416c2c399827e0df9868420de9b5f5269e9e9ecea4fe1d	59,941
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Black painted steel bike hoop rack with uniform coating on tube and mounting plates; no chips, peeling, blistering or coverage gaps visible.	{ "image_index": 6, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Black painted steel bike hoop rack with uniform coating on tube and mounting plates; no chips, peeling, blistering or coverage gaps visible.", "location": "", "flags": [ "Outdoor context; shadows are not defects" ] }	[ "Outdoor context; shadows are not defects" ]	false	null	brave	https://www.amazon.com/commercial-bike-rack/s?k=commercial+bike+rack	https://m.media-amazon.c…/81h+zPItmbL.jpg	unknown	2d91144cc5fb7af475ede816619a92110ab37e448796ecd3fae6c5685d973559	2d91144cc5fb7af475ede816619a92110ab37e448796ecd3fae6c5685d973559	6,356
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Black painted metal shelf/bracket with even coating on all faces; no chips, scratches, peeling or runs. Perforations and hooks are intentional.	{ "image_index": 7, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Black painted metal shelf/bracket with even coating on all faces; no chips, scratches, peeling or runs. Perforations and hooks are intentional.", "location": "", "flags": [ "Perforation pattern is design" ] }	[ "Perforation pattern is design" ]	false	null	brave	https://www.laatukaluste.com/collections/hyllyt/metallihylly	https://www.laatukaluste…jpg?v=1746300912	unknown	b0ece8c5915244110c0e2b655c64ecf8071485792e0695446e9309424c63f6b1	b0ece8c5915244110c0e2b655c64ecf8071485792e0695446e9309424c63f6b1	6,623
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Black painted metal shelf with uniform coating across surface and edges; no visible chips, scratches, peeling or coverage gaps. Perforations are intentional.	{ "image_index": 8, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Black painted metal shelf with uniform coating across surface and edges; no visible chips, scratches, peeling or coverage gaps. Perforations are intentional.", "location": "", "flags": [ "Perforation pattern is design" ] }	[ "Perforation pattern is design" ]	false	null	brave	https://www.laatukaluste.com/collections/hyllyt/metallihylly	https://www.laatukaluste…jpg?v=1746300940	unknown	4523b64297bdb78ff68806fea7d4a476175970a327b7ceaa71b035d149c4fafd	4523b64297bdb78ff68806fea7d4a476175970a327b7ceaa71b035d149c4fafd	59,941
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Black painted perforated metal cable tray; uniform coating across flanges and base with no chips, scratches, peeling or coverage gaps visible.	{ "image_index": 1, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Black painted perforated metal cable tray; uniform coating across flanges and base with no chips, scratches, peeling or coverage gaps visible.", "location": "", "flags": [] }	[]	false	null	brave	https://www.laatukaluste.com/collections/hyllyt/metallihylly	https://www.laatukaluste…jpg?v=1746300926	unknown	692b3fe70aba8aa98a3a3f01e2573f11688b5cf7625daa584092bba584a188dc	692b3fe70aba8aa98a3a3f01e2573f11688b5cf7625daa584092bba584a188dc	7,019
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Black painted corner bracket with mounting holes; coating uniform on all faces, no visible chips, scratches, runs or bare spots.	{ "image_index": 2, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Black painted corner bracket with mounting holes; coating uniform on all faces, no visible chips, scratches, runs or bare spots.", "location": "", "flags": [] }	[]	false	null	serper-google	https://www.lowes.com/pd/Etokfoks-4-pack-black-U-shaped-4x4-post-base-bracket-kit-with-12-gauge-steel-construction-and-weather-resistant-powder-coating-for-outdoor/105588802	https://mobileimages.low…d5/97849709.jpeg	unknown	62845ba2911f7956fa018b1a8416c6101d46044a55a40785b31830e1342a43ea	62845ba2911f7956fa018b1a8416c6101d46044a55a40785b31830e1342a43ea	7,493
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Black painted filing cabinet with extended drawers; smooth uniform coating on body and drawer fronts, no visible coating damage.	{ "image_index": 3, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Black painted filing cabinet with extended drawers; smooth uniform coating on body and drawer fronts, no visible coating damage.", "location": "", "flags": [] }	[]	false	null	brave	https://www.amazon.com/Solutions-Drawer-Cabinet-Letter-Assembled/dp/B08SJCKDGT	https://m.media-amazon.c…/6132EWEvZ+L.jpg	unknown	de8ad0a17bf468ff1a829d9276ea68060625f5f429f3a16ea23424c8da2737f2	de8ad0a17bf468ff1a829d9276ea68060625f5f429f3a16ea23424c8da2737f2	59,941
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Black painted metal garden bench; consistent coating on slats, backrest and legs with no chips, scratches or coverage gaps.	{ "image_index": 4, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Black painted metal garden bench; consistent coating on slats, backrest and legs with no chips, scratches or coverage gaps.", "location": "", "flags": [] }	[]	false	null	brave	https://amazon.com/Evergreen-Garden-Red-Metal-Bench/dp/B007AKCKBA	https://m.media-amazon.c…/61Ykz5-eHAL.jpg	unknown	6a78024afac72ec7d9cbb7ae01c0fe472161c194208af5ff16959093bda641f7	6a78024afac72ec7d9cbb7ae01c0fe472161c194208af5ff16959093bda641f7	26,735
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; White painted metal shelf bracket on black background; uniform white coating, no chips, scratches, peeling or bare metal visible.	{ "image_index": 5, "decision": "good", "evidence": "White painted metal shelf bracket on black background; uniform white coating, no chips, scratches, peeling or bare metal visible.", "location": "", "flags": [] }	[]	false	null	serper-google	https://ironsupports.com/products/hd-front-mount-granite-countertop-support-bracket?variant=39364660134079&srsltid=AYCX9vI90_h7hMUx_UobYln5m_rme8Q9C4WYMapGuzvHL1nW63nyBR_l	https://ironsupports.com…png?v=1774626729	unknown	7192562a5af6e87922edb3e3cb039b49f79c1e21fab84fcb26b0a310c5715cdf	7192562a5af6e87922edb3e3cb039b49f79c1e21fab84fcb26b0a310c5715cdf	27,537
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Dark brown painted metal cable tray; uniform coating on flanges and base, no visible chips, scratches or coverage gaps.	{ "image_index": 6, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Dark brown painted metal cable tray; uniform coating on flanges and base, no visible chips, scratches or coverage gaps.", "location": "", "flags": [] }	[]	false	null	brave	https://laatukaluste.com/en/collections/ale-sallittu/metallihylly	https://www.laatukaluste…jpg?v=1782576120	unknown	d77e0d16fcfc09e05182787e013c9bd38640d506dd04e182553f39389dffd011	d77e0d16fcfc09e05182787e013c9bd38640d506dd04e182553f39389dffd011	59,941
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Blue painted metal cabinet with open doors; consistent coating on interior, shelves and door faces, no visible coating damage.	{ "image_index": 7, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Blue painted metal cabinet with open doors; consistent coating on interior, shelves and door faces, no visible coating damage.", "location": "", "flags": [] }	[]	false	null	serper-google	https://jannowak.com/nl/metalen-kast-witold-modern-donkerblauw?srsltid=AYCX9vIPotPQwJoBfwxAmHMZk_u4MKPk59AokjTbCtjSfOnJ66IAkFLc	https://jannowak.com/med…image-type=image	unknown	acbaa701852210c3c80f0289d27ad77fd3aac76235c42a49196637f0875f5b4b	acbaa701852210c3c80f0289d27ad77fd3aac76235c42a49196637f0875f5b4b	17,300
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Glossy yellow painted metal garden chair; coating continuous on back, seat and tubular frame with no chips, scratches, peeling or coverage gaps visible.	{ "image_index": 1, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Glossy yellow painted metal garden chair; coating continuous on back, seat and tubular frame with no chips, scratches, peeling or coverage gaps visible.", "location": "", "flags": [ "Clean studio product photo; small white dots are fastener heads, not c...	[ "Clean studio product photo; small white dots are fastener heads, not coating damage." ]	false	null	serper-google	https://www.walmart.com/ip/Northlight-Outdoor-Retro-Metal-Tulip-Glider-Patio-Chair-Yellow/334322774	https://i5.walmartimages…a7878ad9970.jpeg	unknown	49a6e1ff9e5cc2975b73660953c3117709092c4f18983451a0385e2d7cbeb618	49a6e1ff9e5cc2975b73660953c3117709092c4f18983451a0385e2d7cbeb618	71,068
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Black painted metal pipe flange; uniform textured coating across face, bore and bolt holes with no chips, scratches or peeling visible.	{ "image_index": 2, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Black painted metal pipe flange; uniform textured coating across face, bore and bolt holes with no chips, scratches or peeling visible.", "location": "", "flags": [ "Surface texture is intentional painted finish, not a fault." ] }	[ "Surface texture is intentional painted finish, not a fault." ]	false	null	serper-google	https://www.northerntool.com/products/pipe-flange-black-coated-steel-class-300-socket-weld-1-1-2-pipe-size-7560588?srsltid=AYCX9vKGXdvwemiIdLAfAKwBnLIqndJIRxv3KYV2su4-pbfdyrujQaK5	https://assets.northernt…ages/7560588.jpg	unknown	bdfc7c7fb4a706ded33b53efc1b24ca76dea86b266338cd53e5413d93bd38725	bdfc7c7fb4a706ded33b53efc1b24ca76dea86b266338cd53e5413d93bd38725	72,270
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Glossy yellow painted metal sliding-door cabinet; coating intact on doors, frame and interior shelves with no visible chips, runs or coverage gaps.	{ "image_index": 3, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Glossy yellow painted metal sliding-door cabinet; coating intact on doors, frame and interior shelves with no visible chips, runs or coverage gaps.", "location": "", "flags": [ "Studio product photo; reflections are glare, not defects." ] }	[ "Studio product photo; reflections are glare, not defects." ]	false	null	serper-google	https://storemorestore.com/industrial-storage-cabinets/36-sliding-door-steel-storage-cabinet/?srsltid=AYCX9vJqcuXxc2CkfMwd0QwrxOGTMXIkLahDkH-rkYRC79YAbu6zJoJ9	https://cdn11.bigcommerc…e_1743773004.jpg	unknown	9be2a91684ef9aaf23e36eba44e0c9379b0526b1892151df66f30d5298275c88	9be2a91684ef9aaf23e36eba44e0c9379b0526b1892151df66f30d5298275c88	72,380
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Black painted metal wall rack with pegs; coating continuous on bar and pegs with no chips, scratches or peeling visible against concrete background.	{ "image_index": 4, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Black painted metal wall rack with pegs; coating continuous on bar and pegs with no chips, scratches or peeling visible against concrete background.", "location": "", "flags": [ "Background clutter acceptable; object clearly inspectable." ] }	[ "Background clutter acceptable; object clearly inspectable." ]	false	null	serper-google	https://www.urbandi.com/products/powder-coated-floating-shelf-brackets?srsltid=AYCX9vLLYG27Z_ryA07rAMDN2wzi956Qvl7oYEhVQ-ugxvDaIGm56XXT	https://www.urbandi.com/…43177&width=3840	unknown	68c5e5f2a86e499a1d10521ea5e5000e46fbc7a8c3c99d10b64dffddb11d5f99	68c5e5f2a86e499a1d10521ea5e5000e46fbc7a8c3c99d10b64dffddb11d5f99	73,347
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Black painted metal toolbox with open lid; coating intact on body, lid interior and edges with no chips, scratches or coverage gaps visible.	{ "image_index": 5, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Black painted metal toolbox with open lid; coating intact on body, lid interior and edges with no chips, scratches or coverage gaps visible.", "location": "", "flags": [ "Studio product photo." ] }	[ "Studio product photo." ]	false	null	serper-google	https://www.garvee.com/products/garvee-truck-bed-tool-box-48x15x15-black-powder-coated-storage-pickup-truck-bed-pae_33b6yncp?srsltid=AYCX9vL8XlMwOhzFjhS6sBx5c9z8OpgkUCOiO7enA4_bICkwjcamg2hc	https://cdn.shopify.com/…jpg?v=1772102044	unknown	2545b182363d1f6edc398a2282c29492efaad93b25a8742bc00f2486c0ee6e3a	2545b182363d1f6edc398a2282c29492efaad93b25a8742bc00f2486c0ee6e3a	5,373
defect	defect	good	good	Human rejudge of original defect candidate: defect. (earlier: Black curved hook shows continuous coating; highlights and brushed-looking surface do not establish paint damage.)	{ "image_index": 6, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Black painted metal curved bracket/hook; coating continuous on arm and mounting plates with no chips, scratches or peeling visible.", "location": "", "flags": [ "Slight surface texture on top plate is casting/paint texture, not a fault." ] }	[ "Slight surface texture on top plate is casting/paint texture, not a fault.", "visual_adjudication" ]	true	defect	serper-google	https://www.rinkit.com/products/75mm-x-85mm-black-wrought-iron-handrail-bracket-by-hammer-tongs?srsltid=AYCX9vLImq0Y6ph6pDkhH1R4q4qyXG3gtwioOMUbv9R09vsxFI2Ho5eh	http://www.rinkit.com/cdn/shop/products/HT-IM213025_WS_001.jpg?v=1746194872	unknown	ff54ecc4139c629935ef5dac80a36eb6d7625c4501919e7872be0d6ebd62a750	ff54ecc4139c629935ef5dac80a36eb6d7625c4501919e7872be0d6ebd62a750	74,292
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Black painted metal toolbox with open lid; coating intact on body, lid and edges with no chips, scratches or coverage gaps visible.	{ "image_index": 7, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Black painted metal toolbox with open lid; coating intact on body, lid and edges with no chips, scratches or coverage gaps visible.", "location": "", "flags": [ "Studio product photo." ] }	[ "Studio product photo." ]	false	null	serper-google	https://www.garvee.com/products/garvee-truck-bed-tool-box-48x15x15-black-powder-coated-storage-pickup-truck-bed-pae_33b6yncp?srsltid=AYCX9vIM-978ag3_VFLinqD-m-kgdXBpnxTeQr97N4-aAgzaksz58-d2	https://cdn.shopify.com/…jpg?v=1760695427	unknown	1a436cca59e84a096897814b8f9c4e6bf79d96a3f5c0fbf23f550308f071ab38	1a436cca59e84a096897814b8f9c4e6bf79d96a3f5c0fbf23f550308f071ab38	5,373
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Yellow painted metal bench with perforated backrest; coating continuous on frame, slats and back panel with no chips, scratches or peeling visible.	{ "image_index": 8, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Yellow painted metal bench with perforated backrest; coating continuous on frame, slats and back panel with no chips, scratches or peeling visible.", "location": "", "flags": [ "Perforations are intentional design, not coverage gaps." ] }	[ "Perforations are intentional design, not coverage gaps." ]	false	null	serper-google	https://www.walmart.com/ip/KOOL-High-Back-Outdoor-Metal-Garden-Bench-Steel-Slat-Patio-Loveseat-Park-Bench-for-Porch-Yard-Lawn-Patio-Bench-Yellow/6972968020	https://i5.walmartimages…dfb7eb43dea.jpeg	unknown	bf21f6092891bad89428d3b3a9b54bf7a89975d1410c0696fb0d17d10210b513	bf21f6092891bad89428d3b3a9b54bf7a89975d1410c0696fb0d17d10210b513	75,048
defect	defect	good	defect	Human rejudge of original defect candidate: defect. (earlier: Enlarged image shows multiple missing blue-coating patches on shelf faces and front edges, exposing brown substrate; wear-related example, not confirmed manufacturing fault.)	{ "image_index": 1, "decision": "defect", "evidence": "Blue shelf coating shows brown bare-metal/rust patches and chips on shelf surfaces and front edges, exposing substrate.", "location": "Shelf surfaces and front edges (middle shelf front edge, bottom shelf right, top shelf right corner)", "flags": [ "O...	[ "Outdoor wear; rust alone not counted but here paint is chipped off exposing metal", "visual_adjudication" ]	true	defect	brave	https://meillakotona.fi/artikkelit/vanhan-metallihyllyn-tuunaus	https://assets.meillakot….jpg?w=3840&q=75	unknown	906e502373b4e22acb6b7eaab521cedd7ca41f1b80ba22bc6134c62ada004d52	906e502373b4e22acb6b7eaab521cedd7ca41f1b80ba22bc6134c62ada004d52	40,594
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Uniform blue powder-coat on locker cabinet; no chips, scratches, runs or coverage gaps visible.	{ "image_index": 2, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Uniform blue powder-coat on locker cabinet; no chips, scratches, runs or coverage gaps visible.", "location": "", "flags": [] }	[]	false	null	serper-google	https://esmaeandrose.com/products/industrial-metal-locker-storage-bedside-navy-blue-cupboard	https://esmaeandrose.com…60734&width=1946	unknown	e954d5e59abbf903a20653f619d423c3ab6fda8d44710fd58b6ce01f9eb16d3b	e954d5e59abbf903a20653f619d423c3ab6fda8d44710fd58b6ce01f9eb16d3b	72,337
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Black bracket coating uniform and intact; no visible chips, scratches or peeling.	{ "image_index": 3, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Black bracket coating uniform and intact; no visible chips, scratches or peeling.", "location": "", "flags": [] }	[]	false	null	serper-google	https://www.boldmfg.com/products/farmhouse-handrail-bracket?srsltid=AYCX9vK7jRjNbOBiOj-0nUl3o0pXq9Gi-vIOTX21_H6QJ-u_zl_laj1U	https://www.boldmfg.com/…93148&width=1946	unknown	58e9d7d6e44f66e5cb110b6f7dac8c48eaa7856be07b0099090da578c422ff6e	58e9d7d6e44f66e5cb110b6f7dac8c48eaa7856be07b0099090da578c422ff6e	74,285
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Black bracket coating uniform; no visible coating damage on faces or edges.	{ "image_index": 4, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Black bracket coating uniform; no visible coating damage on faces or edges.", "location": "", "flags": [] }	[]	false	null	serper-google	https://www.boldmfg.com/products/linear-handrail-bracket?srsltid=AYCX9vKrNXBx3e4WLaImrLQ80sGb0H8tlVGwaHB89cx5DPmCFlRCh5ZP	https://www.boldmfg.com/…93181&width=1946	unknown	360404ceef5026a889df70e7507d72ff8c25d84b99ae19dfb66f5bdad8e32bb2	360404ceef5026a889df70e7507d72ff8c25d84b99ae19dfb66f5bdad8e32bb2	74,299
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Textured black coating on housing uniform; no chips, runs or coverage gaps visible.	{ "image_index": 5, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Textured black coating on housing uniform; no chips, runs or coverage gaps visible.", "location": "", "flags": [ "Textured finish is intentional" ] }	[ "Textured finish is intentional" ]	false	null	serper-google	https://www.approvedsheetmetal.com/blog/engineers-guide-fabricated-enclosures	https://b2910390.assetcd…2&strip=1&webp=1	unknown	73ea2b36726a868e7f08a141eb97b3530934e82935a59904b2981f5c50f82475	73ea2b36726a868e7f08a141eb97b3530934e82935a59904b2981f5c50f82475	17,974
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Black bracket coating uniform and intact; no visible chips, scratches or peeling.	{ "image_index": 6, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Black bracket coating uniform and intact; no visible chips, scratches or peeling.", "location": "", "flags": [] }	[]	false	null	serper-google	https://www.stoneharborhardware.com/products/round-bar-shelf-and-pole-bracket-powder-coated-3-drop-white-by-stone-harbor-hardware?srsltid=AYCX9vJ5fhQafBXbeIhpXW0dkQRBs3V7SPSd0LXKRrHaEeZKYGidBJmL	https://www.stoneharborh…53961&width=1920	unknown	b62f1c9de1876c0c0c5702825abab419c3977ac34494f648372d27b7623fa560	b62f1c9de1876c0c0c5702825abab419c3977ac34494f648372d27b7623fa560	72,306
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Bronze bench coating uniform across slats and frame; no visible coating damage.	{ "image_index": 7, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Bronze bench coating uniform across slats and frame; no visible coating damage.", "location": "", "flags": [] }	[]	false	null	serper-google	https://willygoat.com/products/madison-bench-with-back-powder-coated-steel?srsltid=AYCX9vKR2Ng8nIawaIknWfeaBqjtG-KBZ01vIGAjS8GTzd8CS4Whu_bV	http://willygoat.com/cdn/shop/products/71-S6.jpg?v=1607466317	unknown	1b126b483acb05fe17c7ff982ab1b0cdc9f221319eb045375c199d5cb4976bd1	1b126b483acb05fe17c7ff982ab1b0cdc9f221319eb045375c199d5cb4976bd1	5,336
defect	defect	defect	defect	Human rejudge of original defect candidate: defect. (earlier: Enlarged image shows a wavy ridge around front holes but cannot establish coating run versus formed substrate geometry.)	{ "image_index": 8, "decision": "defect", "evidence": "Glossy orange coating shows a wavy paint run/drip ridge on the right face near the holes and thick uneven edge buildup.", "location": "Right face near the large hole (wavy run ridge)", "flags": [ "Glossy wet-look; run vs thick edge somewhat ambiguous ...	[ "Glossy wet-look; run vs thick edge somewhat ambiguous but ridge reads as a run", "visual_adjudication", "excluded_from_default_release_unresolved" ]	true	defect	serper-google	https://www.reddit.com/r/diypedals/comments/vf9gut/when_you_spray_paint_an_enclosure_how_do_you/	https://i.redd.it/kfx0cvukme691.jpg	unknown	661dc7bd5be131b95d1c8f53c81c6af545c218513b8cc61d7c442d9e00e59f6b	661dc7bd5be131b95d1c8f53c81c6af545c218513b8cc61d7c442d9e00e59f6b	807
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Olive painted metal toolbox with uniform glossy coating; no chips, scratches, peeling or coverage gaps visible on lid, body or latch.	{ "image_index": 1, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Olive painted metal toolbox with uniform glossy coating; no chips, scratches, peeling or coverage gaps visible on lid, body or latch.", "location": "", "flags": [] }	[]	false	null	serper-google	https://ameico.com/products/t-320-steel-toolbox?srsltid=AYCX9vIfxrexCMBt2NbFe1naMrqtsyU2cE7k_IR-O_ZRTEpHVpm146nG	https://ameico.com/cdn/s…jpg?v=1766436539	unknown	72d47f90c1509b8b3f4a348f6aca39868f6aa4c927a02e0a8feed67e91e849f5	72d47f90c1509b8b3f4a348f6aca39868f6aa4c927a02e0a8feed67e91e849f5	17,450
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Blue painted metal toolbox, open; interior and exterior coating uniform and glossy with no visible chips, runs or scratches.	{ "image_index": 2, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Blue painted metal toolbox, open; interior and exterior coating uniform and glossy with no visible chips, runs or scratches.", "location": "", "flags": [] }	[]	false	null	serper-google	https://ameico.com/products/t-320-steel-toolbox?srsltid=AYCX9vKv2fk85IoP-sNqod5vOAre4rW5k2InqS_ajd0wWp4_IK2xAKuG	https://ameico.com/cdn/s…jpg?v=1756918609	unknown	39aea17a96c7edc00f174758bdb630c764088b76cd9000d94fdf9b199f71883b	39aea17a96c7edc00f174758bdb630c764088b76cd9000d94fdf9b199f71883b	72,384
defect	defect	good	good	Human rejudge of original defect candidate: defect. (earlier: Enlarged glossy black cover has bright patches near circular opening, but reflection versus actual paint loss is unresolved.)	{ "image_index": 3, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Glossy black painted metal housing; coating continuous over bosses and recesses, bright areas are reflections not damage.", "location": "", "flags": [ "strong specular glare may mask fine detail" ] }	[ "strong specular glare may mask fine detail", "visual_adjudication", "excluded_from_default_release_unresolved" ]	true	defect	reddit-archive	https://reddit.com/r/Powdercoating/comments/hlghmj/audi_valve_cover_in_midnight_blue_metallic_really/	https://i.redd.it/w04b934gry851.jpg	reddit-user-content	162fb727736bbcd2914a4101656ce92c7922f790a7bf999aba61d7c3765e4cd0	162fb727736bbcd2914a4101656ce92c7922f790a7bf999aba61d7c3765e4cd0	1,139
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Red painted steel table frame; coating uniform across tubes and welds with no visible chips, scratches or bare spots.	{ "image_index": 4, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Red painted steel table frame; coating uniform across tubes and welds with no visible chips, scratches or bare spots.", "location": "", "flags": [] }	[]	false	null	reddit-archive	https://reddit.com/r/metalworking/comments/1tc4byz/i_tried_something_different_with_the_frame_of/	https://i.redd.it/r4poihbahx0h1.jpeg	reddit-user-content	7070fb6f8c8fb6e754bf18f9f2a85a30b9b3f075c47447c45020aead704bd311	7070fb6f8c8fb6e754bf18f9f2a85a30b9b3f075c47447c45020aead704bd311	4,545
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Dark green painted metal bin with sloped lid; glossy uniform coating, no chips, peeling or coverage gaps on panels or handle.	{ "image_index": 5, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Dark green painted metal bin with sloped lid; glossy uniform coating, no chips, peeling or coverage gaps on panels or handle.", "location": "", "flags": [] }	[]	false	null	brave	https://resitransgroup.com/portal/producto/contenedores-metalicos	https://resitransgroup.c…r-metalico-1.jpg	unknown	6a0a033d3d6b3102e6ab7bb3dd5755c2a6069fc741d924e91098dd5cca0fc6f9	6a0a033d3d6b3102e6ab7bb3dd5755c2a6069fc741d924e91098dd5cca0fc6f9	7,044
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Matte black painted metal hook rack; coating uniform across bar and hooks with no visible chips, scratches or runs.	{ "image_index": 6, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Matte black painted metal hook rack; coating uniform across bar and hooks with no visible chips, scratches or runs.", "location": "", "flags": [ "clean studio image, possible render but coating inspectable" ] }	[ "clean studio image, possible render but coating inspectable" ]	false	null	brave	https://amazon.com/Matte-Black-Coat-Rack-Mount/dp/B0H1L26ZHH	https://images-na.ssl-im…/41Huwhq+BOL.jpg	unknown	22ba158845d69dee3cb1ef18e480a25dcaa1ed0966b7d002e6392a6f13669b1f	22ba158845d69dee3cb1ef18e480a25dcaa1ed0966b7d002e6392a6f13669b1f	59,941
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Pink painted tubular metal frame; coating continuous over tubes and tabs with no visible chips, scratches or bare metal.	{ "image_index": 7, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Pink painted tubular metal frame; coating continuous over tubes and tabs with no visible chips, scratches or bare metal.", "location": "", "flags": [] }	[]	false	null	reddit-archive+crop	https://reddit.com/r/Powdercoating/comments/1bebkg9/fun_job_time/	https://i.redd.it/plxsaajey7oc1.jpeg	reddit-user-content	6b7ad556dbff28806f089015017bbfb3a67ff9633d4366bf5e95e40f0eaa1fc4	6b7ad556dbff28806f089015017bbfb3a67ff9633d4366bf5e95e40f0eaa1fc4	59,941
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Teal painted panel radiator; coating uniform across face and fins with no visible chips, scratches or coverage gaps.	{ "image_index": 8, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Teal painted panel radiator; coating uniform across face and fins with no visible chips, scratches or coverage gaps.", "location": "", "flags": [] }	[]	false	null	serper-google	https://www.creationdecorators.co.uk/2024/05/21/radiator-painting/	https://www.creationdeco…atured-image.jpg	unknown	9a4160b14c76bcccf4967109ad76c0c9adbc689540477fbb596f8e2b003bbc5b	9a4160b14c76bcccf4967109ad76c0c9adbc689540477fbb596f8e2b003bbc5b	2,834
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Ribbed coated metal can with uniform glossy dark finish; vertical seam and reflections are normal, no chips, scratches, or coverage gaps visible.	{ "image_index": 1, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Ribbed coated metal can with uniform glossy dark finish; vertical seam and reflections are normal, no chips, scratches, or coverage gaps visible.", "location": "", "flags": [ "coating type (paint vs lacquer) ambiguous but intact" ] }	[ "coating type (paint vs lacquer) ambiguous but intact" ]	false	null	reddit-archive	https://reddit.com/r/metalworking/comments/14max5c/have_you_guys_tried_heating_up_steel_to_give_it/	https://i.redd.it/nyrfuiiqrz8b1.jpg	reddit-user-content	8c3c8dc2872852b5e112961eddfa5d3e88d943f466cf3f27c3e234d4c622bdcf	8c3c8dc2872852b5e112961eddfa5d3e88d943f466cf3f27c3e234d4c622bdcf	59,941
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Black painted metal bench with continuous glossy coating across slats and frame; no chips, peeling, or bare metal visible.	{ "image_index": 2, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Black painted metal bench with continuous glossy coating across slats and frame; no chips, peeling, or bare metal visible.", "location": "", "flags": [] }	[]	false	null	serper-google	https://victorstanley.com/benches/	https://cdn11.bigcommerc…66005589.jpg?c=1	unknown	cccd29a170827653b0a2b8a1f81ddbbaac0a560d00ef8aad424b9cafe2f07d43	8e734d941202e4658217dc0c571611a312f5ee9da41a6cddff26be0229eed3f4	62,286
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Glossy black painted metal bollard with uniform coating; highlights are reflections, no visible damage or coverage gaps.	{ "image_index": 3, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Glossy black painted metal bollard with uniform coating; highlights are reflections, no visible damage or coverage gaps.", "location": "", "flags": [] }	[]	false	null	serper-google	https://www.reliance-foundry.com/shop/bollard/decorative/r-7691-bollard?srsltid=AYCX9vLFyudj0kHZxVceGoMte4XYbDWjfbyFzveQ1RApS8d0KFo-oYyX	https://www.reliance-fou…lard-11.jpg.webp	unknown	e0f361f4190820258d33a1e947a39dccf3f1003c699e82e49f60fdb380b5cec7	9bed0c0aaf1b1e67e27f8d8ea3fda8e2d7037ad3efc96ba9f276e46dc66b90f4	73,252
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Black painted metal bollard in street setting; coating uniform and glossy, no chips, scratches, or peeling observed.	{ "image_index": 4, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Black painted metal bollard in street setting; coating uniform and glossy, no chips, scratches, or peeling observed.", "location": "", "flags": [] }	[]	false	null	serper-google	https://www.reliance-foundry.com/shop/bollard/decorative/r-7591-bollard-al?srsltid=AYCX9vKq-bs7YfgCQgILlQJFhnkbHI6d8MVvH64R1KEKBrMROiThv1s8	https://www.reliance-fou…lard-11.jpg.webp	unknown	c0697e435b2faac25bf7809b5fc68c2496b18239cafc47b448adee4c412d9147	db70ecc3406ee20fcc697ea439f3829ad9c738da2c6a6bbd161ee412e9abcc37	62,713
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Glossy black painted metal frame on towel; coating continuous over tubes and tabs, no chips, runs, or bare spots.	{ "image_index": 5, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Glossy black painted metal frame on towel; coating continuous over tubes and tabs, no chips, runs, or bare spots.", "location": "", "flags": [] }	[]	false	null	brave	https://www.sick-minis.com/products/powder-coat-swingarm	https://www.sick-minis.c…59994&width=1445	unknown	23add1723ddf1d2c2f79232e425e41994e3164c6d01a0b964e9dc8490e5cd215	23add1723ddf1d2c2f79232e425e41994e3164c6d01a0b964e9dc8490e5cd215	43,455
defect	defect	good	uncertain	Human rejudge of original defect candidate: defect. (earlier: Small pale marks on red bollard remain indistinct at available resolution; cannot establish coating damage.)	{ "image_index": 6, "decision": "uncertain", "evidence": "Smooth matte red post; material ambiguous (painted metal vs plastic/polyurethane bollard), cannot confirm painted metal coating to inspect.", "location": "", "flags": [ "material authenticity ambiguous", "possible plastic bollard" ] }	[ "material authenticity ambiguous", "possible plastic bollard", "visual_adjudication", "excluded_from_default_release_unresolved" ]	true	defect	serper-google	https://eagle.justrite.com/bollard-post-cover-smooth-6-x-56-red-1736r?srsltid=AYCX9vJjmeru4pXom9XXDmOxez26_pIZ9ATOdCFBedpUtgtqw8L3P8EO	https://eagle.justrite.c…image-type=image	unknown	669758e741fae6d34e3ecfeda378ead23cf8dd8dcb92b1e7697c17b53fcdbd8d	669758e741fae6d34e3ecfeda378ead23cf8dd8dcb92b1e7697c17b53fcdbd8d	59,941
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; White painted metal garden bench with uniform coating across lattice, seat, and legs; no chips, peeling, or coverage gaps.	{ "image_index": 8, "decision": "good", "evidence": "White painted metal garden bench with uniform coating across lattice, seat, and legs; no chips, peeling, or coverage gaps.", "location": "", "flags": [] }	[]	false	null	brave	https://www.amazon.com.mx/MFSTUDIO-asiento-estructura-respaldo-reposabrazos/dp/B08FB44MG7	https://m.media-amazon.c…/81rYq19XzKL.jpg	unknown	9b080a73744e7f628ae39da230e6097dfab6102e9fd9fc8a2b587f33af5b23da	9b080a73744e7f628ae39da230e6097dfab6102e9fd9fc8a2b587f33af5b23da	43,242
defect	defect	good	good	Human rejudge of original defect candidate: defect. (earlier: Grey coated sheet-metal toolbox has continuous visible finish; folds, hinges and handle are normal features.)	{ "image_index": 1, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Gray painted metal caddy with handle; coating uniform and intact. A small reddish spot near an interior screw reads as rust, not a coating fault.", "location": "", "flags": [ "tiny interior mark ambiguous but rust alone is not a paint defect" ] }	[ "tiny interior mark ambiguous but rust alone is not a paint defect", "visual_adjudication" ]	true	defect	brave	https://ebay.com/itm/197487977224	https://i.ebayimg.com/im…HhrY/s-l1600.jpg	unknown	67476e6f45e322f481afcef106beffde8c0d691b205c1604425eae2c0dc64ae8	67476e6f45e322f481afcef106beffde8c0d691b205c1604425eae2c0dc64ae8	5,856
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Black painted steel bench with slats; glossy coating uniform across slats and legs with no chips, scratches, or coverage gaps.	{ "image_index": 2, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Black painted steel bench with slats; glossy coating uniform across slats and legs with no chips, scratches, or coverage gaps.", "location": "", "flags": [] }	[]	false	null	brave	https://amazon.com/Outdoor-Garden-Weatherproof-Sturdy-Furniture/dp/B0B4C13RX6	https://m.media-amazon.c…/61WoMwJd+qL.jpg	unknown	2c37a6c98dffbed997ad25be8cc58c6ef28ac2ad20365ba9c6d4fddcdcaba30d	2c37a6c98dffbed997ad25be8cc58c6ef28ac2ad20365ba9c6d4fddcdcaba30d	20,624
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Red painted metal bench; glossy coating continuous over curved ends and slats, no visible chips, peeling, or runs.	{ "image_index": 3, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Red painted metal bench; glossy coating continuous over curved ends and slats, no visible chips, peeling, or runs.", "location": "", "flags": [] }	[]	false	null	serper-google	https://www.amazon.se/Tr%C3%A4dg%C3%A5rdsb%C3%A4nk-st%C3%A5lram-uteplatsen-metallb%C3%A4nk-tr%C3%A4dg%C3%A5rd/dp/B0GNRLJJZN	https://m.media-amazon.c…/81aRnSUeeyL.jpg	unknown	43590a06f9983c7e5b9e24c980dc9b7339e8305bdc7c5decfafedb608537ad6e	43590a06f9983c7e5b9e24c980dc9b7339e8305bdc7c5decfafedb608537ad6e	20,963
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Matte black painted metal bench with X-pattern back; coating uniform on frame, arms, and slats with no visible damage.	{ "image_index": 4, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Matte black painted metal bench with X-pattern back; coating uniform on frame, arms, and slats with no visible damage.", "location": "", "flags": [] }	[]	false	null	brave	https://amazon.com/Evergreen-Garden-Red-Metal-Bench/dp/B007AKCKBA	https://m.media-amazon.c…/61KeDwT+5dL.jpg	unknown	860f8eadf9ff627a0ad665389684c46652e827743f7e9a116c7333149d67af11	860f8eadf9ff627a0ad665389684c46652e827743f7e9a116c7333149d67af11	26,733
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Matte black painted metal handle bracket; coating uniform on bent bar and mounting plates, no chips or scratches visible.	{ "image_index": 5, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Matte black painted metal handle bracket; coating uniform on bent bar and mounting plates, no chips or scratches visible.", "location": "", "flags": [] }	[]	false	null	brave	https://amazon.com/Metal-Speaker-Grille-Guard-Subwoofer/dp/B0H7SXQKSY	https://m.media-amazon.c…/41L3lLyxOCL.jpg	unknown	0ae2866cab98823b551236a37ae42e7cecc4dacd3a3136a121404308c7d414ee	0ae2866cab98823b551236a37ae42e7cecc4dacd3a3136a121404308c7d414ee	39,416
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Red painted metal utility cart; glossy coating uniform on shelves, posts, and rails with no chips, runs, or gaps.	{ "image_index": 6, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Red painted metal utility cart; glossy coating uniform on shelves, posts, and rails with no chips, runs, or gaps.", "location": "", "flags": [] }	[]	false	null	brave	https://amazon.com/clp/B0DY1JYHRG	https://m.media-amazon.c…/61zHikV34wL.jpg	unknown	35f835885d07268969d3103344ac7cd232edfc044232ce907fff920ee82620d2	35f835885d07268969d3103344ac7cd232edfc044232ce907fff920ee82620d2	40,773
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Matte black painted metal bench with X-pattern back; coating continuous on frame, arms, and slats, no visible damage.	{ "image_index": 7, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Matte black painted metal bench with X-pattern back; coating continuous on frame, arms, and slats, no visible damage.", "location": "", "flags": [] }	[]	false	null	brave	https://www.amazon.com/Roudebush-Company-Bench-Frames-Free-Standing/dp/B07N7T3NRY	https://m.media-amazon.c…/61vdQZPhSnL.jpg	unknown	b5ebdc93768418a5c6ce21ec1315f5f5255301288a021755b9459da8136932ff	b5ebdc93768418a5c6ce21ec1315f5f5255301288a021755b9459da8136932ff	41,128
defect	defect	good	good	Human rejudge of original defect candidate: defect. (earlier: Silver duct fitting appears unpainted metallic sheet, outside identifiable painted-coating scope.)	{ "image_index": 8, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Gray painted metal duct collar; coating uniform on flange and collar. Faint inner line reads as a seam, not a coating fault.", "location": "", "flags": [ "inner line ambiguous but consistent with normal seam" ] }	[ "inner line ambiguous but consistent with normal seam", "visual_adjudication" ]	true	defect	brave	https://amazon.com/Transition-Polished-Burr-free-Optimization-Orientation/dp/B0HLW56KRY	https://m.media-amazon.c…/61MDGhEVSdL.jpg	unknown	d846f0dc78e631c1a734fd3da770659010b4abe52576d95fdd3b1307c12b765b	d846f0dc78e631c1a734fd3da770659010b4abe52576d95fdd3b1307c12b765b	59,941
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Black painted metal garden bench; uniform matte-black coating across frame, slats and backrest with no visible chips, scratches, peeling or coverage gaps.	{ "image_index": 1, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Black painted metal garden bench; uniform matte-black coating across frame, slats and backrest with no visible chips, scratches, peeling or coverage gaps.", "location": "", "flags": [ "studio product photo on white background" ] }	[ "studio product photo on white background" ]	false	null	brave	https://www.amazon.com/Metal-Park-Bench/s?k=Metal+Park+Bench	https://m.media-amazon.c…/61bXYL7LqHL.jpg	unknown	8a8dc0ce13772b3feb68bbe613ada60a02c7da7f03756922090484390a7aeedd	8a8dc0ce13772b3feb68bbe613ada60a02c7da7f03756922090484390a7aeedd	43,427
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Gray painted metal electrical enclosure door; smooth uniform coating over panel and recessed door, no chips, runs, peeling or bare-metal gaps visible.	{ "image_index": 2, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Gray painted metal electrical enclosure door; smooth uniform coating over panel and recessed door, no chips, runs, peeling or bare-metal gaps visible.", "location": "", "flags": [] }	[]	false	null	serper-google+crop	https://www.reddit.com/r/Home/comments/1i8wavv/how_to_repair_this_cabinet_over_electric_panel/	https://i.redd.it/voynqegi9yee1.jpg	unknown	55b7007ac1edb256710936e6b0dbe0d5d75a560064ef78ee3ca5948ffa6065da	55b7007ac1edb256710936e6b0dbe0d5d75a560064ef78ee3ca5948ffa6065da	69,272
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Glossy green painted metal bollard with sphere top; continuous coating on shaft, flutes and base, no chips, scratches or peeling evident.	{ "image_index": 3, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Glossy green painted metal bollard with sphere top; continuous coating on shaft, flutes and base, no chips, scratches or peeling evident.", "location": "", "flags": [ "strong specular highlights are reflections, not defects" ] }	[ "strong specular highlights are reflections, not defects" ]	false	null	brave	https://reliance-foundry.com/shop/bollard/decorative/r-7589-bollard	https://www.reliance-fou…9-bollard-14.jpg	unknown	d0b09153202082cef883b7b7f39b38fd84d5fc174a2aeae97c4c003a985f3c5b	d0b09153202082cef883b7b7f39b38fd84d5fc174a2aeae97c4c003a985f3c5b	40,799
defect	defect	good	good	Human rejudge of original defect candidate: defect. (earlier: Enlarged hydrant has base discoloration and minor marks but no unambiguous coating damage separable from rust or dirt.)	{ "image_index": 4, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Red painted metal fire hydrant on grass; uniform red coating on bonnet, barrel and outlets, no visible chips, scratches or coverage gaps.", "location": "", "flags": [ "shallow depth of field blurs background only; subject inspectable" ] }	[ "shallow depth of field blurs background only; subject inspectable", "visual_adjudication", "excluded_from_default_release_unresolved" ]	true	defect	brave	https://clipart-library.com/picture-of-fire-hydrant.html	https://clipart-library.…re-hydrant-7.jpg	unknown	45d44b22bccf5b039b9d50df3920af572feec4b03a2b098c11f8c3d1bc501f90	45d44b22bccf5b039b9d50df3920af572feec4b03a2b098c11f8c3d1bc501f90	10,762
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Red painted metal fire hydrant cutout on white; continuous glossy red coating across body and nozzles, no chips, peeling or runs visible.	{ "image_index": 5, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Red painted metal fire hydrant cutout on white; continuous glossy red coating across body and nozzles, no chips, peeling or runs visible.", "location": "", "flags": [ "isolated cutout product image" ] }	[ "isolated cutout product image" ]	false	null	serper-google	https://willygoat.com/products/dog-park-fire-hydrant?srsltid=AYCX9vJAUPRC6ALpIlnTRUmY9tWMvUN-GOz-NrgwK_Dr8uQtbi4YQTBg	http://willygoat.com/cdn/shop/products/DogParkFireHydrant.jpg?v=1649267036	unknown	885571f368b908f8659c0e624eb71f1e9c8de321c4d7c12f962c6ad08ac51c3a	885571f368b908f8659c0e624eb71f1e9c8de321c4d7c12f962c6ad08ac51c3a	59,941
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Teal painted metal cylindrical collar with holes; uniform coating on outer and inner surfaces, no chips, scratches or bare-metal gaps evident.	{ "image_index": 6, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Teal painted metal cylindrical collar with holes; uniform coating on outer and inner surfaces, no chips, scratches or bare-metal gaps evident.", "location": "", "flags": [ "dark holes are machined openings, not coating damage" ] }	[ "dark holes are machined openings, not coating damage" ]	false	null	reddit-archive+crop	https://reddit.com/r/Machinists/comments/zq11mn/these_are_the_tightest_cutoff_chips_ive_ever/	https://i.imgur.com/IiazEef.jpg	reddit-user-content	558295b9ac3d4a40699a7962d7bed2a955402c5ba6915ea6b8e73da54ce85cb5	558295b9ac3d4a40699a7962d7bed2a955402c5ba6915ea6b8e73da54ce85cb5	69,304
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Taupe painted metal folding table; even coating on top and curved legs, no visible chips, scratches, peeling or coverage gaps.	{ "image_index": 7, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Taupe painted metal folding table; even coating on top and curved legs, no visible chips, scratches, peeling or coverage gaps.", "location": "", "flags": [ "perforations in tabletop are design features" ] }	[ "perforations in tabletop are design features" ]	false	null	brave	https://www.amazon.de/pulverbeschichtet-Gartentische-Gartenm%C3%B6bel-Zubeh%C3%B6r/s?k=pulverbeschichtet&rh=n%3A12964011&page=3	https://m.media-amazon.c…/613y9R7ItyL.jpg	unknown	425bc8acb223eed2dbf635cd66ef2337d34d3bd5867ba212c86a9a680b57a010	425bc8acb223eed2dbf635cd66ef2337d34d3bd5867ba212c86a9a680b57a010	43,226
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; White painted metal radiator cover with louvers; smooth uniform coating on face and sides, no chips, runs, peeling or bare-metal gaps visible.	{ "image_index": 8, "decision": "good", "evidence": "White painted metal radiator cover with louvers; smooth uniform coating on face and sides, no chips, runs, peeling or bare-metal gaps visible.", "location": "", "flags": [] }	[]	false	null	serper-google	http://www.mvhvac.com/radiator-covers	https://images.squarespa…image-asset.jpeg	unknown	31c90a20fdc4de84d480dcfb1e47ec45a80f52e88099189d4869d3ea556d79b7	31c90a20fdc4de84d480dcfb1e47ec45a80f52e88099189d4869d3ea556d79b7	5,487
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Gray painted metal wardrobe with doors open; coating uniform on interior and exterior panels, no chips, scratches, peeling or runs visible.	{ "image_index": 1, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Gray painted metal wardrobe with doors open; coating uniform on interior and exterior panels, no chips, scratches, peeling or runs visible.", "location": "", "flags": [] }	[]	false	null	serper-google	https://www.republicstorage.com/product/1200-series-metal-wardrobe-cabinet/	https://www.republicstor…rage-cabinet.jpg	unknown	ba67378981afff518bae3958f15692ba6a195fabb1eef81377d481eea5aaad10	ba67378981afff518bae3958f15692ba6a195fabb1eef81377d481eea5aaad10	59,941
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Glossy blue painted metal filing cabinet; smooth continuous coating on body and drawers, reflections only, no coating damage.	{ "image_index": 2, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Glossy blue painted metal filing cabinet; smooth continuous coating on body and drawers, reflections only, no coating damage.", "location": "", "flags": [] }	[]	false	null	brave	https://www.aptdeco.com/product/cb2-metal-3-drawer-filing-cabinet-in-teal	https://d6qwfb5pdou4u.cl…1500-frame-0.jpg	unknown	14205c1af1b04448427d916013c4eb6e8f77f02e5304e61c1bc7509f22484dcd	14205c1af1b04448427d916013c4eb6e8f77f02e5304e61c1bc7509f22484dcd	59,941
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Front view of glossy blue painted metal cabinet; uniform coating across drawers and frame, no chips, scratches or coverage gaps.	{ "image_index": 3, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Front view of glossy blue painted metal cabinet; uniform coating across drawers and frame, no chips, scratches or coverage gaps.", "location": "", "flags": [] }	[]	false	null	brave	https://www.aptdeco.com/product/cb2-metal-3-drawer-filing-cabinet-in-teal	https://d6qwfb5pdou4u.cl…1500-frame-0.jpg	unknown	6ad60277b6c26a74662d5d92d2c2501ec640f30fcdeb7437337dceac3396c16a	6ad60277b6c26a74662d5d92d2c2501ec640f30fcdeb7437337dceac3396c16a	59,941
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Teal painted metal cabinet on plain background; matte coating uniform on all faces, no visible chips, scratches or peeling.	{ "image_index": 4, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Teal painted metal cabinet on plain background; matte coating uniform on all faces, no visible chips, scratches or peeling.", "location": "", "flags": [ "clean catalog-style image" ] }	[ "clean catalog-style image" ]	false	null	brave	https://www.aptdeco.com/product/cb2-metal-3-drawer-filing-cabinet-in-teal	https://d6qwfb5pdou4u.cl…1500-frame-0.jpg	unknown	28885a25c839de7fdd2de53f935f268b9ebaa65fc057291facf482202bc927d6	28885a25c839de7fdd2de53f935f268b9ebaa65fc057291facf482202bc927d6	59,941
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Teal painted metal cabinet against textured wall; matte coating continuous and even, no coating damage on visible surfaces.	{ "image_index": 5, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Teal painted metal cabinet against textured wall; matte coating continuous and even, no coating damage on visible surfaces.", "location": "", "flags": [] }	[]	false	null	brave	https://www.aptdeco.com/product/cb2-metal-3-drawer-filing-cabinet-in-teal	https://d6qwfb5pdou4u.cl…1500-frame-0.jpg	unknown	b270253f0ce7cf69faa19af80b27f5e7df50231447e3cc94283e4ccc98dacedb	b270253f0ce7cf69faa19af80b27f5e7df50231447e3cc94283e4ccc98dacedb	59,941
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Side view of glossy blue painted metal cabinet; smooth uniform coating, reflections only, no chips, scratches or runs.	{ "image_index": 6, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Side view of glossy blue painted metal cabinet; smooth uniform coating, reflections only, no chips, scratches or runs.", "location": "", "flags": [] }	[]	false	null	brave	https://www.aptdeco.com/product/cb2-metal-3-drawer-filing-cabinet-in-teal	https://d6qwfb5pdou4u.cl…1500-frame-0.jpg	unknown	1a518d19fdf24594676c5818783c5b7781891870aea3ac2b49dc909c58a0a0e7	1a518d19fdf24594676c5818783c5b7781891870aea3ac2b49dc909c58a0a0e7	59,941
good	good	good	good	Human first pass and blind local review agree; Cream painted metal enclosure cabinet; smooth uniform coating on door and sides, no visible chips, scratches or peeling.	{ "image_index": 7, "decision": "good", "evidence": "Cream painted metal enclosure cabinet; smooth uniform coating on door and sides, no visible chips, scratches or peeling.", "location": "", "flags": [] }	[]	false	null	serper-google	https://shop.prmfiltration.com/products/technomatic-control-panel-enclosure-48-x-40-x-12-dead-front-and-back-plate-powder-coated	https://shop.prmfiltrati…77302&width=1500	unknown	038c9fb59d4ec4e321b86e4be278046fe3579a733c8dc8d39326813e41372570	038c9fb59d4ec4e321b86e4be278046fe3579a733c8dc8d39326813e41372570	59,941

End of preview. Expand in Data Studio

Painted Metal Defects (Web)

Web photographs of painted-metal objects labelled good or defect (visible paint or coating damage: chips, scratches, peeling, wear). Built for paint-defect detection research at CoRe / Turku UAS. A development resource, not a benchmark: no held-out test set, no accuracy or production claim.

Release human-corrected-v4: 400 images from 836 reviewed.

decision	images
good	333
defect	67
exclude	332
uncertain	104

Classes are imbalanced; no balancing applied. Images that did not meet the project standard (not clearly painted metal, unclear, unusable) are excluded; every decision is in audit/decisions.jsonl.

Usage

from datasets import load_dataset
ds = load_dataset("imaadd05/painted-metal-defects-web", split="train")

train is a loader convention, not a recommendation. Hold out by source before tuning or evaluating.

Layout

data/images/, data/metadata.jsonl: retained images and labels
audit/decisions.jsonl: all decisions with reasons and model evidence
summary.json: counts

file_name is relative to data/; the released path is data/ + file_name.

Previous versions

main carries only this release. Earlier releases remain reachable by revision.

revision	contents
`9a79d866`	original model-labelled collection, `train/` `val/` `test/`
`2aab13a1`	`adjudicated-v1`
`f5d4fedf`	`human-corrected-v3`
`4ab839b5`	this release, `human-corrected-v4`
`3f4520`	card update

Fields

label: final good | defect. human_label: reviewer's first pass. human_rejudge_label: reviewer's second pass on early defect candidates, else null. original_model_label, fresh_model_label, reason, model_evidence, flags, primary_reviewed: model and review provenance. source, page, url, license: origin and rights. source_sha256, stored_sha256: file hashes. group: near-duplicate grouping (single-linkage on image hashes), not part identity. It can chain loosely similar images: one group holds 46 of the 400 images, so check group sizes before using it for splits.

Labels and limits

Labels are one reviewer's judgments, informed by a local vision model and visual checks; where they disagree the reviewer's judgment decides. They are provisional, not expert ground truth. good means no damage visible in the photo. Defects include wear; manufacturing origin is not established. Sources are heterogeneous (object, finish, background), few images show defects, and there is no part identity. Not suitable for factory validation.

Rights

Images come from public web pages; availability does not grant redistribution rights, which stay with their owners. Licence text is kept as recorded and unknown stays unknown. Check page and url before reuse. Request removal via the dataset discussions.

Downloads last month: 314