Defer the prospective graph-annotation schema

#91
Files changed (3) hide show
  1. README.md +1 -2
  2. SCHEMA.md +0 -14
  3. TOPOLOGICAL_SCHEMA_EXTENSION.md +0 -67
README.md CHANGED
@@ -1908,8 +1908,7 @@ or make private visual review independently reproducible.
1908
  A same-artifact relationship does not by itself establish the state shown at the
1909
  end of an individual recording, complete process coverage, geometric
1910
  registration, or verification of an inscription. Those are separate claims
1911
- requiring separate evidence. Prospective discrete structural and topological
1912
- annotations are documented separately in [`TOPOLOGICAL_SCHEMA_EXTENSION.md`](TOPOLOGICAL_SCHEMA_EXTENSION.md).
1913
 
1914
  A separate [Pre-Standard record-to-physical reference table](Physical_References/Pre_Standard_Record_References/record_physical_links.csv)
1915
  records 128 creator-supplied, scope-limited links at its pinned source revision.
 
1908
  A same-artifact relationship does not by itself establish the state shown at the
1909
  end of an individual recording, complete process coverage, geometric
1910
  registration, or verification of an inscription. Those are separate claims
1911
+ requiring separate evidence.
 
1912
 
1913
  A separate [Pre-Standard record-to-physical reference table](Physical_References/Pre_Standard_Record_References/record_physical_links.csv)
1914
  records 128 creator-supplied, scope-limited links at its pinned source revision.
SCHEMA.md CHANGED
@@ -510,17 +510,6 @@ revision, allowed relationship values, explicit owner-confirmation state, and
510
  valid SHA-256 syntax whenever a hash is present. The complete contract is in
511
  [`Physical_References/SCHEMA.md`](Physical_References/SCHEMA.md).
512
 
513
- ## Prospective Discrete Structural & Topological Schema Extension
514
-
515
- Optional prospective fields for discrete graph topology and network structure
516
- (`topological_family`, `terminal_node_count`, `terminal_edge_count`,
517
- `graph_invariants`, `recurrence_relation_id`, `derivation_manifest_ref`) are specified in
518
- [`TOPOLOGICAL_SCHEMA_EXTENSION.md`](TOPOLOGICAL_SCHEMA_EXTENSION.md).
519
- These fields associate verified physical drawings (`work_id`) and recording
520
- clips with discrete graph-theoretic invariants without modifying core video
521
- schema or existing row indices. Per core rules, all style and aesthetic classifications
522
- are excluded.
523
-
524
  ## Missing-Value Rules
525
 
526
  - Blank means unknown, not documented, or not applicable according to the field
@@ -531,9 +520,6 @@ are excluded.
531
  - Pre-Standard descriptive/provenance metadata may be less complete, but every
532
  published record must carry a collection-tier distinction, stable ID, exact
533
  content identity, and complete core encoded-video metadata.
534
- - For prospective discrete structural and topological annotations (see `TOPOLOGICAL_SCHEMA_EXTENSION.md`),
535
- terminal node and edge counts for multi-clip groups are populated strictly on `Rec01`;
536
- all intermediate and in-progress clips (`Rec02`..`RecNN`) remain strictly blank.
537
 
538
  ## Required Validation
539
 
 
510
  valid SHA-256 syntax whenever a hash is present. The complete contract is in
511
  [`Physical_References/SCHEMA.md`](Physical_References/SCHEMA.md).
512
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
513
  ## Missing-Value Rules
514
 
515
  - Blank means unknown, not documented, or not applicable according to the field
 
520
  - Pre-Standard descriptive/provenance metadata may be less complete, but every
521
  published record must carry a collection-tier distinction, stable ID, exact
522
  content identity, and complete core encoded-video metadata.
 
 
 
523
 
524
  ## Required Validation
525
 
TOPOLOGICAL_SCHEMA_EXTENSION.md DELETED
@@ -1,67 +0,0 @@
1
- # Discrete Structural & Topological Schema Extension
2
- ### *Formal Contract for Discrete Graph-Theoretic Ground Truth in Time-Lapse Artifacts*
3
-
4
- This specification defines the formal discrete mathematical and topological extension to the canonical time-lapse repository schema. It associates physical drawing recordings (`record_id: tla-...`) and physical artworks (`work_id: tlaw-...`) with verified graph-theoretic ground truth.
5
-
6
- Per `SCHEMA.md`, all style and aesthetic classifications are excluded; these fields record only objective discrete graph topology (incidence, vertices, edges).
7
-
8
- ---
9
-
10
- ## 1. Schema Fields & Types
11
-
12
- | Field Name | Type | Value Domain | Meaning |
13
- |:---|:---:|:---|:---|
14
- | `topological_family` | string / enum | `planar_network`, `chordal_ring`, `triangulated_lattice`, `bipartite_partition`, `extremal_configuration`, `hypercube_projection`, `unclassified` | The formal topological classification of the discrete network structure inscribed. |
15
- | `terminal_node_count` | integer (or blank) | $\mathbb{Z}_{\ge 0}$ | Exact ground-truth count of discrete vertices/intersections in the completed work. |
16
- | `terminal_edge_count` | integer (or blank) | $\mathbb{Z}_{\ge 0}$ | Exact ground-truth count of connecting line segments in the completed work. |
17
- | `graph_invariants` | semicolon list (or blank) | Key-value pairs (e.g., `is_planar=true; chromatic_number=4; is_connected=true; diameter=3`) | Formal structural invariants verified on the completed terminal graph. |
18
- | `recurrence_relation_id` | string (or blank) | e.g., `MANTEL-T2-FL4`, `ANDRASFAI-5T2` | Formal identifier linking the network sequence to a symbolic recurrence relation. |
19
- | `derivation_manifest_ref` | string (or blank) | e.g., `tlad-graph-v1-...` | Reference identifier linking the work to a verified derivation manifest in `time-lapse-artifacts-derived`. |
20
-
21
- ---
22
-
23
- ## 2. Missing-Value & "Rec01" Scope Rules (Strict Integrity)
24
-
25
- To prevent models or researchers from falsely interpreting an in-progress intermediate clip as a finished drawing, the following rules are strictly enforced per `SCHEMA.md` (§ Missing-Value Rules):
26
-
27
- 1. **Single-Recording Drawings (No `RecNN` Suffix):**
28
- * The fields describe the completed work and are populated directly on that row.
29
- 2. **Multi-Clip Recordings (`Rec01`, `Rec02`, ..., `RecNN`):**
30
- * **Only `Rec01` (the primary reference clip)** carries the terminal ground-truth values (`topological_family`, `terminal_node_count`, `terminal_edge_count`, `graph_invariants`).
31
- * **All intermediate and non-terminal clips (`Rec02` through `RecNN`) must remain BLANK.**
32
- * As defined in `SCHEMA.md`: *"Blank numeric values must remain blank; they are not zero."* An intermediate clip is an incomplete drawing state, not a graph with 0 nodes.
33
- 3. **Pre-Standard / Fragment Holdings Without Terminal Verification:**
34
- * Fields remain **blank** until an explicit human-verified ground-truth audit is performed. Blank values must never be promoted to inferred zero.
35
- 4. **Physical Work Identity (`Work_Identity/works.csv`):**
36
- * These fields also attach to `works.csv` at the `work_id` (`tlaw-...`) level, ensuring that each of the 425 physical artworks retains exactly one authoritative structural ground-truth definition.
37
-
38
- ---
39
-
40
- ## 3. Concrete Example in `metadata.csv`
41
-
42
- ### Case A: Single-Recording Drawing (Full Terminal Counts Populated)
43
- ```csv
44
- file_name,record_id,work_id,...,topological_family,terminal_node_count,terminal_edge_count,graph_invariants,recurrence_relation_id
45
- Standard_Time_Lapses/2026-08-24.0157.BallpointPen.Ink.Paper.9x12.mp4,tla-8f92...,tlaw-5c97...,...,triangulated_lattice,18,36,is_planar=true;chromatic_number=3,ANDRASFAI-5T2
46
- ```
47
-
48
- ### Case B: Multi-Clip Drawing (Populated on Rec01, Blank on Rec02–Rec03)
49
- ```csv
50
- # Rec01 carries the verified terminal ground truth:
51
- Standard_Time_Lapses/2026-08-22.0124.BallpointPen.Ink.Paper.14x17.Rec01.mp4,tla-1a2b...,tlaw-a43a...,...,chordal_ring,24,48,is_planar=false;chromatic_number=4,CHORDAL-C24
52
-
53
- # Rec02 is in-progress; fields remain BLANK (not zero, not null):
54
- Standard_Time_Lapses/2026-08-22.1613.BallpointPen.Ink.Paper.14x17.Rec02.mp4,tla-3c4d...,tlaw-a43a...,...,,,,,
55
-
56
- # Rec03 is in-progress; fields remain BLANK:
57
- Standard_Time_Lapses/2026-08-23.1932.BallpointPen.Ink.Paper.14x17.Rec03.mp4,tla-5e6f...,tlaw-a43a...,...,,,,,
58
- ```
59
-
60
- ---
61
-
62
- ## 4. Validation Integration
63
-
64
- During ingestion:
65
- 1. `tools/validate_metadata.py` verifies that `terminal_node_count` and `terminal_edge_count` are valid positive integers whenever present.
66
- 2. The validator asserts that for any multi-clip sequence, only `Rec01` has non-blank values; if `Rec02` carries values, validation emits an error to prevent duplicate counting.
67
- 3. Automated offline validators confirm that any `derivation_manifest_ref` resolves to a valid derivation record in `time-lapse-artifacts-derived`.