mec-is's picture
Add CVE caches and ArrowSpace test fixture
bd8f3ff verified
|
Raw History Blame Contribute Delete
4.68 kB

CALIBRATION — synthetic dataset for the tests/test_0_*.py scripts

Empirical findings from calibrating a shared controlled dataset against arrowspace==0.27.2 (pyarrowspace build, CPython 3.13, macOS arm64).

Final dataset: eigenmaps_controlled.parquet — 1000 items x 128 dims, 3 orthonormal clusters of increasing sparsity, with a cluster label column. Regenerate with uv run python tests/data/make_datasets.py (seed 11).

1. Why the old tests failed

Test Failure Root cause
test_0_0, test_0_5 assert(hits[0][0] == 4) at tau<=0.9 5×24 dataset of near-identical rows → lambda spread is numerical noise, so the spectral term never reorders results. Expectations encoded 0.26-era lambdas; file last touched at v0.26.0.
test_0_9 assert(len(hits) == 3) Contradicted build params topk: 5; 0.27.x correctly returns 5 hits.

All three failed identically on 0.27.0 and 0.27.2 — pre-existing staleness, not a regression from the version bump. The CI suite (pytest-tests/) passes 66/66 on 0.27.2.

2. 0.27.x scoring semantics (measured)

  • search(q, gl, tau) score = tau·cos(q, item) + (1−tau)·spec(item) (blend model confirmed exactly: predicted vs actual orders matched on every probed config).
  • spec is not λi directly: the query is placed into the graph and gets its own lambda λq (prepare_query_item); spec measures spectral closeness between λq and the item's λi. The shape is nonlinear — do not model it, measure it: search(q, gl, 0.0, k=n) (tau=0 ⇒ score IS spec).
  • q = items[j] * scale is cosine-invariant (cos(q, items[j]) = 1.0 for any scale > 0), but λq moves with scale — the only query-side tuning knob.
  • q = items[j] exactly (scale 1.0) raises ValueError: degenerate lambda (raw=0.000000). Always scale the query (e.g. 1.05–1.2).
  • aspace.lambdas() are min-max normalized: exactly one item shows 0.0 (the floor). Harmless — the degenerate gate only fires for a query's own lambda. Quality gate: count(λ < 1e-12) <= 1 for these datasets.
  • eps=0.05 (the old tests' value) leaves high-dim unit-norm data near-disconnected. These datasets use eps=0.5, sigma=0.5.
  • Dense noise σ drives λ per item, roughly quadratically; sparse 2-dim spikes give far less λ per L² (L²=0.078 → λ=0.032 vs dense σ=0.02 curve).
  • Lifting an item past a cos-1.0 self-anchor at tau=0.9 needs 0.1·Δspec > 0.9·(1−cos) — a 9× barrier; naive twin-item designs sit right on it (see sweep log). Cluster-level invariants are far more robust.

3. Final dataset design (1000 x 128, seed 11)

3 clusters with orthonormal centroids (QR of random Gaussian), unit-norm rows:

cluster items noise σ mean λ (build_and_store)
0 (dense) 400 0.02 0.0451
1 (medium) 350 0.05 0.1109
2 (sparse) 250 0.12 0.1372

Graph params for all variants: eps=0.5, k=12, p=2.0, sigma=0.5; topk=3 (tests 0_0, 0_5) / topk=5 (test 0_9).

Query: items[0] * 1.2 (dense-cluster member, scaled — never exact).

Verified invariants (all three builder variants)

  • build_and_store and build_full produce identical results.
  • Sampled builder must use with_sampling("simple", 1.0) for a small dataset (0.6 changes the graph; 1.0 keeps all items).
  • Cluster containment: every hit at every tau ∈ {1.0, 0.9, 0.6, 0.55} is from the query's own cluster.
  • Self item ranks first at every tau.
  • Mean λ increases with cluster sparsity: λ̄₀ < λ̄₁ < λ̄₂ (the spectral statistic tracks structural density).
  • Exactly one min-max zero λ.
  • Bonus: within the dense cluster, tau ≤ 0.6 reorders the runner-ups (spectral blending active) — observed, not asserted (brittle).

4. Sweep log (calibration journey, kept for reference)

Stage Dataset Outcome
probe (d=24) 5 handcrafted rows spec ≈ λ-closeness to query's λ discovered; exact-self query is degenerate
v2–v7 (d=60) 5 twin/filler rows 9× cosine-economics barrier; min-max λ floor; fillers hijack at scale ≥ 1.6; linear spec model insufficient at large offsets
measurement d=60 twins blend model tau·cos + (1−tau)·spec CONFIRMED via tau=0 spec extraction; winner found for [2,1,4]→[1,2,4]
final 1000×128 clusters cluster-level invariants: robust on every builder variant; adopted

5. File inventory

  • eigenmaps_controlled.parquet — the shared dataset (features f0..f127 + cluster).
  • make_datasets.py — deterministic generator.
  • CALIBRATION.md — this document.