instruction
stringlengths
57
20.2k
completion
stringlengths
4
5.16k
conversations
listlengths
2
2
A little background: I have a library project which I put under the LGPL v2.1. However, I have two applications inside the project tree using the library. It would be somewhat inconvenient to make these two small applications have their own license, so I figured I could just use the LGPL for all the code in the tree, i...
Yes, it does make sense to have an application licensed under the LGPL (Lesser General Public License), although it's more commonly used for libraries. Here are some key points to consider regarding licensing your applications under the LGPL versus the GPL: ### Differences between LGPL and GPL 1. **Linking and Distri...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "A little background: I have a library project which I put under the LGPL v2.1. However, I have two applications inside the project tree using the library. It would be somewhat inconvenient to make these two small applications have their own license, so I figured I could just use...
At work, we use a version of GCC provided by a vendor of a proprietary OS. The vendor has modified gcc so that it will only run if it successfully acquires one of a limited number of licenses we've purchased from our license server. This seems very much not in the spirit of free software, and it's very annoying, but is...
Yes, the situation you’re describing is indeed permitted under the GPL, but it raises a few nuanced legal and practical considerations. ### GPL Compliance 1. **Modified Source Code**: If the vendor has modified GCC, they are required to make the modified source code available under the terms of the GPL. This includes...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "At work, we use a version of GCC provided by a vendor of a proprietary OS. The vendor has modified gcc so that it will only run if it successfully acquires one of a limited number of licenses we've purchased from our license server. This seems very much not in the spirit of free...
I have a question about the NOTICE and CHANGELOG files in Apache 2.0 license. Here is the situation: I based my work on an Apache 2.0 licensed project. I did some minor changes (compared to the original work). It seems that I have two problems: According to the Apache 2.0 license, I have to include NOTICE file if it w...
When working with Apache 2.0 licensed projects and addressing your specific questions regarding the NOTICE and CHANGELOG files, here’s a breakdown of how to proceed: ### 1. **NOTICE File** According to the Apache License 2.0, if the original project has a NOTICE file, you are required to include it with your modificat...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I have a question about the NOTICE and CHANGELOG files in Apache 2.0 license.\nHere is the situation: I based my work on an Apache 2.0 licensed project. I did some minor changes (compared to the original work). It seems that I have two problems:\n\nAccording to the Apache 2.0 li...
Given the case of a closed source project that has been developed for some time: What are the main things that should be done in order to ease its transition to a open source development? What I've thought of so far is good documentation (at least good comments in the code) and an attractive purpose of that project f...
Transitioning a closed-source project to an open-source model is a significant undertaking that requires careful planning and execution. Here are some key steps to facilitate a smooth transition: ### 1. **Assess the Project's Readiness** - **Evaluate Legal Concerns**: Ensure that there are no legal issues or intell...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "Given the case of a closed source project that has been developed for some time:\n\nWhat are the main things that should be done in order to ease its transition to a open source development?\n\nWhat I've thought of so far is good documentation (at least good comments in the code...
This originally sprang out of this Meta question, and then a quick discussion in chat. This question is designed to test the underlying assumption behind the Meta question. It seems to some that open hardware is developing slower than open software is, though there are a non-negligible amount of projects. Going back in...
The comparison between the development rates of open hardware and open source software, especially in their early days, brings to light several factors that influence contributions and growth in both fields. 1. **Historical Context**: Open source software began to gain traction in the 1980s with the emergence of the G...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "This originally sprang out of this Meta question, and then a quick discussion in chat. This question is designed to test the underlying assumption behind the Meta question.\nIt seems to some that open hardware is developing slower than open software is, though there are a non-ne...
I was looking at the GPLv3 License. It states that when I modify the Program and distribute it, I need to meet the condition of: a) The work must carry prominent notices stating that you modified it, and giving a relevant date. Now let's say I found a GPLv3 source code on the web and want to put it on the GitHub and s...
When you modify a program licensed under GPLv3 and then distribute it, you have specific obligations to ensure compliance with the license terms. Here’s what you need to do in your scenario: 1. **Prominent Notice of Modifications**: You must include a prominent notice in the source code that states that you have modif...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I was looking at the GPLv3 License.\nIt states that when I modify the Program and distribute it, I need to meet the condition of:\na) The work must carry prominent notices stating that you modified\nit, and giving a relevant date.\n\nNow let's say I found a GPLv3 source code on ...
The copyright-owner can choose any license they wish to. But if they decide to choose an open source license (lets say Apache 2), how much do they have to conform to the license? Especially, do they have to release the source code somehow (or make it accessible for whoever got the binaries that claim to be Apache-licen...
When a copyright owner decides to release their work under an open source license like the Apache License 2.0, they are legally bound to adhere to the terms of that license. Here are the key points regarding compliance and the release of source code: 1. **Open Source Definition**: For software to be considered "open s...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "The copyright-owner can choose any license they wish to. But if they decide to choose an open source license (lets say Apache 2), how much do they have to conform to the license? Especially, do they have to release the source code somehow (or make it accessible for whoever got t...
Specifically the Symfony PHP framework, which is MIT licensed. I've read that the two are compatible, but I want to make sure that a system I develop can be released complete under the GPL.
Yes, the Symfony PHP framework, which is released under the MIT license, is indeed compatible with the GPL (General Public License). The MIT license is a permissive open-source license, meaning you can freely use, modify, and redistribute the code with very few restrictions. Since the MIT license allows for such flexib...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "Specifically the Symfony PHP framework, which is MIT licensed. I've read that the two are compatible, but I want to make sure that a system I develop can be released complete under the GPL.\n" }, { "from": "gpt", "value": "Yes, the Symfony PHP framework, which is rel...
I'm writing an installer for some softwares, and wish to make the installer stand-alone, i.e. everything baked into a single executable. One of the softwares that are installed has GPL 3, built from un-modified sources. The other softwares have a different license which allows them to be redistributed like this, withou...
Your understanding is generally correct, but there are some important nuances and details to consider regarding licenses and the specific requirements that each of them imposes. 1. **GPL 3 Software**: Since you are distributing software licensed under GPL 3, you must comply with its terms. This includes providing acce...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I'm writing an installer for some softwares, and wish to make the installer stand-alone, i.e. everything baked into a single executable.\nOne of the softwares that are installed has GPL 3, built from un-modified sources. The other softwares have a different license which allows ...
If a user contributes under pseudonym or even anonymously, how does this affect CLAs? Does it help anything if he signs a CLA with that pseudonym?
When it comes to Contributor License Agreements (CLAs), the key issue is the legal recognition of the contributor's identity and their rights to their contributions. Here are some important points to consider: 1. **Legal Identity**: CLAs are legal documents that typically require contributors to sign under their legal...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "If a user contributes under pseudonym or even anonymously, how does this affect CLAs? Does it help anything if he signs a CLA with that pseudonym?\n" }, { "from": "gpt", "value": "When it comes to Contributor License Agreements (CLAs), the key issue is the legal reco...
I wish to develop a computer game and the engine I have chosen is ioquake3. This engine is licensed under GPLv2. Needless to say the game's source code will itself will, in turn, be licensed under GPLv2. The game data/assets on the other hand will be proprietary. I intend to release this game as a free-to-play app acro...
When developing a game using the ioquake3 engine, which is licensed under the GPLv2, the code you create for your game (the game's source code) must be licensed under the same GPLv2 license if you distribute it. This means that others can use, modify, and distribute your game's source code under the same terms. Regard...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I wish to develop a computer game and the engine I have chosen is ioquake3. This engine is licensed under GPLv2. Needless to say the game's source code will itself will, in turn, be licensed under GPLv2. The game data/assets on the other hand will be proprietary. I intend to rel...
I'm working on porting a very old program (1994) that was released under the GPL. However, the only reference to that license is this text in the header of the C files: This program is free software; you can redistribute it and/or modify it under the terms of the GNU General Public License as published by the Free Sof...
The text you've provided is typical of programs released under the GNU General Public License (GPL), but it does not specify a particular version of the GPL. In situations where a specific version of the GPL is not mentioned, you generally have the following options: 1. **Assume GPL v1**: Since the program was release...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I'm working on porting a very old program (1994) that was released under the GPL. However, the only reference to that license is this text in the header of the C files:\n\nThis program is free software; you can redistribute it and/or modify it under the terms of the GNU General ...
As manager of several free software projects, I am familiar with feature requests that users of my project submit to its public issue queue. Many of the suggestions are good, but having limited resources available, there is often no way I can assign a feature request to a member of our core development team. Core team...
Encouraging contributions from users who may not be developers can be challenging, but there are several strategies you can employ to stimulate engagement and increase the likelihood that feature requests lead to user-generated pull requests. Here are some specific strategies, along with examples from successful open-s...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "As manager of several free software projects, I am familiar with feature requests that users of my project submit to its public issue queue.\nMany of the suggestions are good, but having limited resources available, there is often no way I can assign a feature request to a membe...
At the company I work for we are developing an app for use within the company. The company consists of numerous branches across the world, all other legal entities. For testing we would like to send a tablet with pre-installed software from the Dutch branch office to the Chinese branch office. Does the software has to ...
When sending a tablet with pre-installed software that includes open source components from one branch of a company to another, it is essential to consider compliance with open source licenses. Here are a few key points to guide your decision: 1. **Open Source Compliance**: Each open source license has its own require...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "At the company I work for we are developing an app for use within the company. The company consists of numerous branches across the world, all other legal entities. For testing we would like to send a tablet with pre-installed software from the Dutch branch office to the Chinese...
For example, a C repository built upon the ideas from a (say) JavaScript project - is it a derivative work based on the latter? To clear things up little bit, i'd give a more detailed example; Imagine an open source compiler written in JavaScript implements in its code base a high quality code optimization algorithm it...
Determining whether a new work is a derivative of an existing work, particularly in the context of software, involves several legal and conceptual considerations. Here’s a breakdown based on your scenario: ### Derivative Work Definition A **derivative work** is typically defined as a new, original product that includ...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "For example, a C repository built upon the ideas from a (say) JavaScript project - is it a derivative work based on the latter?\nTo clear things up little bit, i'd give a more detailed example;\nImagine an open source compiler written in JavaScript implements in its code base a ...
General description: Can I create Python software that will dynamically link against a closed-source library that has a C API (the Python interpreter is not copyleft) and will also utilize a GPL licensed Python library? It's not clear to me how exactly the GPL applies here given that calling a GPL'd Python library is ...
The question of how the GPL interacts with other software, especially in a scenario involving both GPL-licensed code and closed-source proprietary software, is nuanced and can depend on several factors. Here's a breakdown of the considerations in your situation: ### Key Considerations 1. **GPL Licensing Fundamentals*...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "General description:\nCan I create Python software that will dynamically link against a closed-source library that has a C API (the Python interpreter is not copyleft) and will also utilize a GPL licensed Python library? It's not clear to me how exactly the GPL applies here giv...
I'm about to launch my current project as Open Source. People should feel free to do with the code whatever they want and luckily there are quite a few licensing options to choose from. So I'm looking for something very permissive. I've heard of the WTFPL and that sounds about right. There are other variants around as ...
It's great to hear that you're launching your project as Open Source! When it comes to choosing a license for your code, there are a few important points to consider: ### 1. **What the WTFPL Is** The "Do What The F*** You Want To Public License" (WTFPL) is indeed a very permissive license. Its essence is that it allow...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I'm about to launch my current project as Open Source. People should feel free to do with the code whatever they want and luckily there are quite a few licensing options to choose from.\nSo I'm looking for something very permissive. I've heard of the WTFPL and that sounds about ...
I've read that the BSD-2 or "Simplified BSD" software license removes from the BSD-3 "some language that is no longer necessary". Looking at the difference between these two licenses, it appears that this refers to Neither the name of [project] nor the names of its contributors may be used to endorse or promote produ...
The removal of the clause regarding endorsement and promotion in the BSD-2 License compared to the BSD-3 License can be understood in terms of licensing philosophy and the evolution of open-source practices. 1. **Philosophical Shift**: The BSD-2 License aims to be more permissive and less restrictive than the BSD-3 Li...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I've read that the BSD-2 or \"Simplified BSD\" software license removes from the BSD-3 \"some language that is no longer necessary\". Looking at the difference between these two licenses, it appears that this refers to \n\nNeither the name of [project] nor the names of its contr...
A fellow Drupal developer is suggesting that we use themes from a collection of "Premium" paid Drupal themes downloaded from a torrent site on a shared project. It appears that most or all of these themes are derived from GPL-licensed Drupal themes such as Zen and Framework. Since these 'pirated' themes are derived fro...
Using themes that are downloaded from a torrent site, even if they are derived from GPL-licensed Drupal themes, raises significant legal and ethical concerns. 1. **GPL License**: The GNU General Public License (GPL) allows users to freely use, modify, and distribute software, but it also imposes certain conditions. Wh...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "A fellow Drupal developer is suggesting that we use themes from a collection of \"Premium\" paid Drupal themes downloaded from a torrent site on a shared project. It appears that most or all of these themes are derived from GPL-licensed Drupal themes such as Zen and Framework.\n...
For one of my products I plan to move from a commercial-only to a dual licensed license model: GNU Affero General Public License (AGPL) or a "non-free" license. I can imagine two options for the license headers in the source files: two sets of source code files with different headers: the AGPL header for the open sou...
When choosing between the two options for license headers in your dual-licensed product, it's essential to weigh the advantages and disadvantages of each approach while considering clarity, maintainability, and user experience. Here’s a breakdown of both options, along with some recommendations. ### Option #1: Two Set...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "For one of my products I plan to move from a commercial-only to a dual licensed license model: GNU Affero General Public License (AGPL) or a \"non-free\" license. \nI can imagine two options for the license headers in the source files:\n\ntwo sets of source code files with diffe...
Are there any good sites offering open-source tracks for use in applications or games? I've seen many, but seem to be any good... giving links to last.fm and other sites.
Yes, there are several platforms that offer high-quality open-source or royalty-free music tracks that can be used in applications or games. Here are some reputable sites where you can find such tracks: 1. **Free Music Archive (FMA)**: [freemusicarchive.org](https://freemusicarchive.org/) - A large archive of high-...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "Are there any good sites offering open-source tracks for use in applications or games? I've seen many, but seem to be any good... giving links to last.fm and other sites.\n" }, { "from": "gpt", "value": "Yes, there are several platforms that offer high-quality open-s...
I want to release a pre-alpha software for preview. I do not want to put the code in an open repository like GitHub yet because it is just a prototype and I intend to re-design parts. The package I am releasing contains the HTML/JS source which is bundled in a single file and is not uglified/minified. However, I defin...
Given the information you've provided about your project and your goals for its licensing, here are some considerations and recommendations for licensing your pre-alpha software: ### Licensing Options 1. **MPL (Mozilla Public License)**: - **Advantages**: MPL is a file-level copyleft license. This means that modif...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I want to release a pre-alpha software for preview. I do not want to put the code in an open repository like GitHub yet because it is just a prototype and I intend to re-design parts. The package I am releasing contains the HTML/JS source which is bundled in a single file and is...
There is an application A. It uses the GPL license. There is another application B that takes all of A's code and improvises it. In its repo, both GPL and LGPL license can be found. We are building an application C, which is open source and uses all of application A's code, much like B did. However, we take the enhance...
When dealing with open source licenses, particularly the GPL (GNU General Public License) and LGPL (GNU Lesser General Public License), it's important to understand how they apply to your situation. 1. **Application A is under the GPL**: This means that any derivative works (like application C, which uses A's code) mu...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "There is an application A. It uses the GPL license.\nThere is another application B that takes all of A's code and improvises it. In its repo, both GPL and LGPL license can be found.\nWe are building an application C, which is open source and uses all of application A's code, mu...
Free software evangelists often advertise free and open source software to be more secure than proprietary alternatives. Is this true, and why? Are there security reasons not to use free and open source software?
The assertion that free and open source software (FOSS) is more secure than proprietary software is a topic of considerable debate and can depend on various factors. Here’s a breakdown of the arguments for and against this claim: ### Arguments for FOSS Security: 1. **Transparency**: The source code for open source so...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "Free software evangelists often advertise free and open source software to be more secure than proprietary alternatives.\n\nIs this true, and why?\nAre there security reasons not to use free and open source software?\n\n" }, { "from": "gpt", "value": "The assertion t...
Suppose you have an open source piece of software. You decide you want to publish the software under an open source license. You spend time researching licenses online and finally you find the perfect one. My question: Are there any (better) alternatives to simply adding a link to the chosen license? If yes, what are ...
When publishing open source software, simply adding a link to the chosen license is a common practice, but there are better alternatives that ensure clarity, accessibility, and compliance. Here are some alternatives: ### Better Alternatives to Simply Adding a Link: 1. **Include the Full License Text:** - Instead o...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "Suppose you have an open source piece of software. You decide you want to publish the software under an open source license. You spend time researching licenses online and finally you find the perfect one. \nMy question:\nAre there any (better) alternatives to simply adding a li...
We are using Qt(5.3.2 - opensource) for one of our applications that we are going to be distributing (closed-source). We dynamically link to Qt and have made no modifications to Qt. At Qt's Legal FAQ, they list the necessary obligations for using Qt under the LGPL. We understand and agree with their interpretation of ...
Your understanding of the LGPL (Lesser General Public License) in the context of using Qt is mostly accurate, but let's clarify a few key points regarding your concerns: 1. **Source Code Provision**: Under LGPLv3, if you dynamically link to a library like Qt and make no modifications, you are still obligated to provid...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "We are using Qt(5.3.2 - opensource) for one of our applications that we are going to be distributing (closed-source). We dynamically link to Qt and have made no modifications to Qt. \nAt Qt's Legal FAQ, they list the necessary obligations for using Qt under the LGPL. We understa...
It's something I want to get started on and be able to contribute but I don't even know how or where to start. Many employers and recruiters ask if I have any experience with them, I just don't know where to start
It sounds like you're looking to gain experience in a specific field or skill set but aren't sure how to begin. Here are some steps you can take to get started, regardless of the area you're interested in: 1. **Identify Your Interest Area**: Narrow down the specific field or skill you want to focus on. This could be a...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "It's something I want to get started on and be able to contribute but I don't even know how or where to start. Many employers and recruiters ask if I have any experience with them, I just don't know where to start\n" }, { "from": "gpt", "value": "It sounds like you'r...
How can I create my own educational license for my scholar books? I'm thinking in a fork of CC BY-SA-NC + educational use. What should I have in mind before write the license? These is our draft for the human-readable summary of the license: You are free to: Share – copy and redistribute the material in any medium or...
Creating your own educational license, especially one that builds upon existing licenses like CC BY-SA-NC, is a complex process. Here are some key factors and considerations to keep in mind before finalizing your license: ### 1. **Clarity and Simplicity**: - Ensure that the language in your license is clear and eas...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "How can I create my own educational license for my scholar books?\nI'm thinking in a fork of CC BY-SA-NC + educational use. What should I have in mind before write the license?\nThese is our draft for the human-readable summary of the license:\n\nYou are free to:\n\nShare – copy...
While this question says what to do if someone is breaking the terms of a license, I am asking what do I do if I breaking the terms of an open source license? I was using a piece of software and misread one of the terms of the agreement. I reread the license recently and noticed I am breaking one of the terms. My quest...
If you find that you are inadvertently violating the terms of an open-source license, here are some steps you can take to address the situation: 1. **Understand the Violation**: First, make sure you fully understand which terms you are violating. Different licenses have different requirements (e.g., attribution, redis...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "While this question says what to do if someone is breaking the terms of a license, I am asking what do I do if I breaking the terms of an open source license?\nI was using a piece of software and misread one of the terms of the agreement. I reread the license recently and notice...
Can Wikipedia written content and images be used on my website, without a direct recognition on the page it is used. Perhaps place any thanks/recognition in the terms and conditions of my page.
Using content and images from Wikipedia on your website requires adherence to specific licensing terms. Wikipedia content is typically licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-Share-Alike License (CC BY-SA) and its text is also in the public domain under the GNU Free Documentation License (GFDL). Here are the ke...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "Can Wikipedia written content and images be used on my website, without a direct recognition on the page it is used. Perhaps place any thanks/recognition in the terms and conditions of my page.\n" }, { "from": "gpt", "value": "Using content and images from Wikipedia ...
I have recently been looking for open source dating software to build upon and I keep seeing things like this: www.skadate.com/open-source.php www.a-dater.com www.abk-soft.com ph7cms.com Which all clearly state that they are "Open-source", yet I cannot redistribute or resell anything, and I cannot have access to the so...
Your understanding of open source seems to be correct in principle, but it appears that the offerings you've encountered may not align with traditional open-source definitions. Let's break this down: ### Definition of Open Source 1. **Source Code Access**: Open-source software must provide access to its source code. ...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I have recently been looking for open source dating software to build upon and I keep seeing things like this:\nwww.skadate.com/open-source.php\nwww.a-dater.com\nwww.abk-soft.com\nph7cms.com\nWhich all clearly state that they are \"Open-source\", yet I cannot redistribute or res...
I've been playing around with my own router and found DD-WRT as an open source firmware alternative for this kind of device but I can't find something equivalent for modems. Can you recommend something?
While there are several open-source firmware options available for routers, the options for modems are more limited. Unlike routers, which often have more customizable firmware, modems typically have less support for open-source alternatives due to the complexity of the modem's functions and the proprietary nature of m...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I've been playing around with my own router and found DD-WRT as an open source firmware alternative for this kind of device but I can't find something equivalent for modems. Can you recommend something?\n" }, { "from": "gpt", "value": "While there are several open-so...
Does the Python Software Foundation License permit relicensing to the GNU GPLv3 (or v2)?
Yes, the Python Software Foundation License (PSFL) does permit relicensing under the GNU General Public License (GPL) v2 or v3. The PSFL is generally considered a permissive license, which allows for the software to be redistributed and modified under different terms, including the GPL. However, it's important to note...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "Does the Python Software Foundation License permit relicensing to the GNU GPLv3 (or v2)?\n" }, { "from": "gpt", "value": "Yes, the Python Software Foundation License (PSFL) does permit relicensing under the GNU General Public License (GPL) v2 or v3. The PSFL is gener...
I want to use open source software for my business, and it is dual licensed. If I choose the paid license which provides support for any changes we require, will this mean that we are unable to change to a different support provider in future? In this article I was concerned by the following suggestion: Some vendors o...
The concern raised in the article you referenced highlights some of the complexities and potential drawbacks associated with dual-licensed software. While the landscape of open-source software and licensing has evolved since 2010, some principles still apply today. ### Understanding Dual Licensing In a dual-licensing...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I want to use open source software for my business, and it is dual licensed. If I choose the paid license which provides support for any changes we require, will this mean that we are unable to change to a different support provider in future?\nIn this article I was concerned by...
How do I prevent the misuse of my applications and/or their source codes? Maybe something along these lines: You are NOT allowed to bundle this application with anything that may count as: Malware, Adware, Spyware or an otherwise undesirable application. Also, the way I see it I cannot just say 'illegal uses are forb...
Preventing the misuse of your applications and their source code is a multifaceted challenge that involves both legal and technical measures. Here are some strategies you can consider: ### Legal Measures 1. **Licensing**: Use a well-crafted license that clearly outlines what is and isn't allowed. You can create a cus...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "How do I prevent the misuse of my applications and/or their source codes?\nMaybe something along these lines:\n\nYou are NOT allowed to bundle this application with anything that may count as: Malware, Adware, Spyware or an otherwise undesirable application.\n\nAlso, the way I s...
If I find a security issue in a Github project should I raise it in the project's issue tracker (where it's open to public scrutiny) or try to find private means to contact the repo's maintainer so that action can be taken before the issue is exposed to public scrutiny?
If you discover a security issue in a GitHub project, it is generally best practice to report it privately to the repository maintainer before making it public. Here are the steps you should consider: 1. **Check for Security Policy**: Look for a security policy in the repository, which may outline how to report vulner...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "If I find a security issue in a Github project should I raise it in the project's issue tracker (where it's open to public scrutiny) or try to find private means to contact the repo's maintainer so that action can be taken before the issue is exposed to public scrutiny?\n" }, ...
I'm a little confused by copyright notices on open source projects. Let's say that a particular project is covered by a very permissive license, such as MIT or BSD. A copyright notice appears from the company that originated the source code. But let's say that the project leader leaves the company, but continues to co...
Copyright in the context of open source projects can indeed be complex, especially when multiple contributors are involved. Here are some key points to consider regarding copyright notices and contributions: ### 1. Original Copyright and Licensing When a project is created, the original author (or authors) holds the c...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I'm a little confused by copyright notices on open source projects.\nLet's say that a particular project is covered by a very permissive license, such as MIT or BSD. A copyright notice appears from the company that originated the source code.\nBut let's say that the project lea...
I am looking at some highy geometric flags used by the the extended LGBT community. Many of these are not able to be copyrighted (according to wikimedia) Because the consist only of: Choice of Color Geometric Shapes and these factors do not contribute to the creation of an original work. Several of the flags I am loo...
The question of whether a work is copyrightable involves considering various factors, including originality and creativity. In the case of flags that consist solely of color choices and geometric shapes, it is true that many jurisdictions would not recognize these as original works eligible for copyright protection due...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I am looking at some highy geometric flags used by the the extended LGBT community.\nMany of these are not able to be copyrighted (according to wikimedia)\nBecause the consist only of:\n\nChoice of Color\nGeometric Shapes\n\nand these factors do not contribute to the creation of...
Since 2015-10-08, GPLv3 is listed as one-way compatible license for CC BY-SA 4.0: […] you may license your contributions to adaptations of BY-SA 4.0 materials under GPLv3, but you may not license your contributions to adaptations of GPLv3 projects under BY-SA 4.0 That means I may take source code licensed under CC ...
The distinction between what constitutes an "adaptation" of a work and what does not can be nuanced, and the legal implications can depend on the jurisdiction and specific circumstances. However, based on the definitions provided in the CC BY-SA 4.0 license and general copyright principles, we can analyze your scenario...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "Since 2015-10-08, GPLv3 is listed as one-way compatible license for CC BY-SA 4.0:\n\n[…] you may license your contributions to adaptations of BY-SA 4.0 materials under GPLv3, but you may not license your contributions to adaptations of GPLv3 projects under BY-SA 4.0\n\nThat mean...
I have build an open source audiobook player which is licensed under gpl v3. Yesterday someone sent me a mail with the topic 'Violation of source code license' including a link to an app that seems an exact copy of my app. Does that violate the license? How do open source projects normally react to situations like this...
The GPL v3 (GNU General Public License version 3) requires that any derivative works of a GPL-licensed project also be released under the same license. This means that if someone has created an app that is an exact copy of your audiobook player, they are indeed likely violating the terms of the GPL v3 unless they have ...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I have build an open source audiobook player which is licensed under gpl v3.\nYesterday someone sent me a mail with the topic 'Violation of source code license' including a link to an app that seems an exact copy of my app.\nDoes that violate the license? How do open source proj...
I have created a license for my apps: This computer program is licensed under Illuze License v1.0.0 or later. Illuze License v1.0.0 [3rdDec2015] -Rahul2001.com It's simple: -You are free to use this application in any manner as long as you aren't, in any way (directly or indirectly), hurting a living being. -You...
Creating a custom software license like the Illuze License you have drafted is certainly possible, and many developers have done similar things. However, there are a few considerations to keep in mind regarding the validity and enforceability of your license: ### 1. **Publication and Registration:** - **Publication...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I have created a license for my apps:\n\nThis computer program is licensed under Illuze License v1.0.0 or later.\nIlluze License\n v1.0.0 [3rdDec2015]\n -Rahul2001.com\n It's simple:\n-You are free to use this application in any manner as long as you aren't, in any way (direc...
Most of us know open-source and open-source concepts from software. Code is easily distributable. We have various licences that help us legalize and regulate how people use our code, and we have various services that help us reach out and show-off. How (and how well) do these concepts apply to hardware? How do I open-s...
Open-sourcing hardware is an emerging area that shares many principles with open-source software but comes with its own set of challenges and considerations. Below, I’ll outline key aspects of open-source hardware and provide a guide on how to open-source a hardware product effectively. ### Understanding Open-Source H...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "Most of us know open-source and open-source concepts from software. Code is easily distributable. We have various licences that help us legalize and regulate how people use our code, and we have various services that help us reach out and show-off.\nHow (and how well) do these c...
As a follow up from GPL V3 with OpenSSL Exception, I'm curious about linking an LGPLv3 project with a GPLv3 project that has a special exception for OpenSSL. In the answer to the aforementioned question, it was stated: Note, however, that you can only add exceptions to work for which you have copyright control. If y...
Linking an LGPLv3 project with a GPLv3 project that includes an OpenSSL Exception raises several important points regarding compatibility and licensing. ### Understanding the Licenses 1. **LGPLv3 (Lesser General Public License v3)**: This license allows you to link to proprietary or other free software without requir...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "As a follow up from GPL V3 with OpenSSL Exception, I'm curious about linking an LGPLv3 project with a GPLv3 project that has a special exception for OpenSSL. In the answer to the aforementioned question, it was stated:\n\nNote, however, that you can only add exceptions to work f...
One of the hallmarks of the FLOSS philosophy is its reliance upon open standards. The OSI has the one definition of an open standard. The FSF has its own There are many bodies which produce official standards: OSI, ITU, ETSI, IEEE, and so on. The standards most software developers will be familiar with are those whic...
The question of what constitutes an "open standard" is a nuanced and important one in the context of Free/Libre and Open Source Software (FLOSS). An open standard ideally should be publicly available, implementable without restriction, and devoid of encumbrances like patents and proprietary licenses. However, as you po...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "One of the hallmarks of the FLOSS philosophy is its reliance upon open standards.\nThe OSI has the one definition of an open standard. The FSF has its own\nThere are many bodies which produce official standards: OSI, ITU, ETSI, IEEE, and so on.\nThe standards most software dev...
I have an open-source project that I originally wanted to license under MIT, but since I'm using a GPLv3 component that I can't quite get rid of (namely, the .g4 ANTLR grammar file that I'm using to generate a lexer/parser), I've been sort-of forced to distribute my project under GPLv3 as I understand anything that tou...
You’re right in your understanding of the implications of using GPLv3 components in your project. When you incorporate GPLv3 code (like the ANTLR-generated lexer/parser), your entire project must also be distributed under the GPLv3 because of the copyleft nature of that license. This is true even if parts of your proje...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I have an open-source project that I originally wanted to license under MIT, but since I'm using a GPLv3 component that I can't quite get rid of (namely, the .g4 ANTLR grammar file that I'm using to generate a lexer/parser), I've been sort-of forced to distribute my project unde...
I want to move from MIT license to a new one, with this goals to reach: Leave the project free to use for individuals and small open source companies Let commercial companies pay some money for using my software And I have some questions about this plan: What license type should I choose? What kind of monetization s...
Transitioning from the MIT license to a new licensing model can be a strategic way to achieve your goals of allowing free use for individuals and small open-source companies while also enabling monetization from commercial entities. Here’s a breakdown addressing your questions: ### 1. License Type Given your goals, y...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I want to move from MIT license to a new one, with this goals to reach:\n\nLeave the project free to use for individuals and small open source companies\nLet commercial companies pay some money for using my software\n\nAnd I have some questions about this plan:\n\nWhat license t...
On GitHub issue page, there doesn't seem to be a place to show that I also share this problem (e.g. upvote, +1) to let the developers prioritize this issue. Is there a way to do this? If know, how do developers know which issues affect most people?
On GitHub, there isn't a built-in "upvote" or "+1" feature specifically for issues like you might find on other platforms. However, there are a few ways that users can indicate their interest in an issue or show that they are affected by it: 1. **Commenting**: You can comment on the issue to express that you are exper...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "On GitHub issue page, there doesn't seem to be a place to show that I also share this problem (e.g. upvote, +1) to let the developers prioritize this issue.\nIs there a way to do this? If know, how do developers know which issues affect most people?\n" }, { "from": "gpt"...
Sorry if anything I say is a bit stupid or out of context, I'm really new to Open Source licensing, so please don't be too mean ;) I have wrote a software framework which I want to distribute as open source but restricting it's commercial use a bit. First restriction is, if you're an individual developer or the usage i...
It's great that you're diving into open source licensing! Your requirements indicate a desire for a fairly restrictive license, and while there are many existing open source licenses, none of the well-known ones (like MIT, Apache, GPL, etc.) align perfectly with your specified restrictions. Open source licenses typical...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "Sorry if anything I say is a bit stupid or out of context, I'm really new to Open Source licensing, so please don't be too mean ;)\nI have wrote a software framework which I want to distribute as open source but restricting it's commercial use a bit.\nFirst restriction is, if yo...
Other than having someone manually reading all of the code, how can you demonstrate an open-source project's reputability? i.e. it is not a virus/malware/whatever. I'm not concerned with the efficiency of the program. I just need to be able to demonstrate that the program is exactly what it says it is and is thus not ...
Demonstrating the reputability of an open-source project without manual code review can be challenging, but there are several strategies you can use to establish trustworthiness: 1. **Community Trust and Popularity**: - **Stars, Forks, and Contributors**: Check the number of stars, forks, and active contributors on...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "Other than having someone manually reading all of the code, how can you demonstrate an open-source project's reputability? i.e. it is not a virus/malware/whatever.\nI'm not concerned with the efficiency of the program. I just need to be able to demonstrate that the program is e...
What is the good way to change the license of an opensource project? I guess it depends of the agreements of the contributors Do i need 100% approval? What if one contributor disagree or one contributor didn't answer? What about versions? If change happens at version X, does it apply for previous versions? Where...
Changing the license of an open-source project is an important decision and involves several considerations. Here's a structured approach to navigate this process: ### 1. Assess Contributor Agreements - **Check Contributor Agreements**: If you have formal contributor agreements (like Contributor License Agreements, CL...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "What is the good way to change the license of an opensource project?\n\nI guess it depends of the agreements of the contributors\n\n\nDo i need 100% approval?\nWhat if one contributor disagree or one contributor didn't answer?\n\nWhat about versions?\n\n\nIf change happens at ve...
Suppose I want to modify a license. Say I choose the MIT license: ..to deal in the Software without restriction, including without limitation the rights to use, copy, modify, merge, publish, distribute, sublicense, and/or sell copies of the Software,... and I would like to remove publish and add some restrictio...
When modifying an established license like the MIT License or terms of service such as Google's, there are several important considerations to keep in mind: ### Modifying a License 1. **Identify Your Goals**: Clearly define what you want to achieve with the modifications. For example, if you want to remove the "publi...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "Suppose I want to modify a license. Say I choose the MIT license:\n\n..to deal\n in the Software without restriction, including without limitation the rights\n to use, copy, modify, merge, publish, distribute, sublicense, and/or sell\n copies of the Software,...\n\nand I woul...
Is there any legal constraint saying that a commercial software must quote the open source libraries and public domain libraries regardless of the open source license type? For example, let's say I develop a web application based on java servlet and I include (and use without modifications) a library licensed under Apa...
When using open source libraries, the obligations to provide attribution and adhere to licensing terms depend on the specific license under which those libraries are released. In your example, the library is licensed under the **Apache License 2.0**. Here are the key points regarding your obligations when using this li...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "Is there any legal constraint saying that a commercial software must quote the open source libraries and public domain libraries regardless of the open source license type?\nFor example, let's say I develop a web application based on java servlet and I include (and use without m...
I'm looking for a good license-model. I am developing a framework. These key points should be considered: Can: modify distribute commercial and private use sell it in modified/extended state Cannot: hold Liable sell it in original state sublicense Must: include Copyright include License Should: send fixes/chan...
Creating a custom license can be complex and is often not recommended unless there are very specific needs that existing licenses do not meet. The key points you've outlined contain elements that are somewhat common in open-source licenses, but also have some unique requirements that might not align perfectly with esta...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I'm looking for a good license-model. I am developing a framework.\nThese key points should be considered:\nCan:\n\nmodify\ndistribute\ncommercial and private use\nsell it in modified/extended state \n\nCannot:\n\nhold Liable\nsell it in original state\nsublicense\n\nMust:\n\nin...
I've been looking at the web articles, and following statement seems to be true: When there is an application source code which just uses some GPL library, but does not contain any part of the library within the codebase, the developer of the application still needs to publish the application in GPL (if he/she is to p...
Your question touches on a nuanced and often debated area of software licensing, particularly concerning the GNU General Public License (GPL). To address your question, it's essential to clarify how the GPL works and where the obligations arise. ### Understanding GPL Obligations 1. **Definition of Derived Works**: Th...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I've been looking at the web articles, and following statement seems to be true:\n\nWhen there is an application source code which just uses some GPL library, but does not contain any part of the library within the codebase, the developer of the application still needs to publis...
Open sourcing doesn't necessarily mean that you give away your source code for free. I am wondering about the business model where your code is made public, free for personal/hobby use, but with a mandatory fee for commercial/company use. Is this possible, and is there any existing license (or licenses) that are made f...
Yes, it is indeed possible to have a business model where your code is open-sourced and available for free for personal or hobby use, but requires a fee for commercial or company use. This approach allows you to maintain some control over how your software is used in a commercial context while still promoting openness ...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "Open sourcing doesn't necessarily mean that you give away your source code for free.\nI am wondering about the business model where your code is made public, free for personal/hobby use, but with a mandatory fee for commercial/company use.\nIs this possible, and is there any exi...
After reading these lines: make a new github project (not a fork). merge in the original repository. In this Answer, I was wondering if there are any rules or guidelines when to fork a project and when to create a new one. If this turns out to be just a matter of personal taste: what are the advantages and disadv...
When deciding whether to fork an open-source project or create a new GitHub project and merge in the original repository, it's important to understand the implications of both approaches. Here are some guidelines, advantages, and disadvantages of each method: ### Forking a Project #### When to Fork: 1. **Contributing...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "After reading these lines:\n\n\nmake a new github project (not a fork). \nmerge in the original repository.\n\n\nIn this Answer, I was wondering if there are any rules or guidelines when to fork a project and when to create a new one. If this turns out to be just a matter of pe...
I often hear about GPL variants, MIT, BSD and many other license options. A general Internet search reveals sites like "Top 20 licenses" or pages some licenses going out of fashion and others coming in. With so many licenses to choose from, a major stumbling block for beginners in open sourcing is deciding what license...
Choosing an open-source license can indeed be daunting, especially with the variety of options available. Here's a breakdown of some of the most commonly adopted open-source licenses, their stats, and key differences among them. ### Popular Open Source Licenses 1. **MIT License** - **Usage**: One of the most widel...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I often hear about GPL variants, MIT, BSD and many other license options. A general Internet search reveals sites like \"Top 20 licenses\" or pages some licenses going out of fashion and others coming in.\nWith so many licenses to choose from, a major stumbling block for beginne...
So what I'm planning to do is to create a script which one part calls (via Python's subprocess) external open source script licensed under GPL-2. To make it easier for users I'd like to distribute the GPL-2'ed script with with my own so that call could be easily done on the correct version of software. (I want to use ...
When dealing with licenses like the GPL-2, it's important to understand how the license applies to your own code and distribution practices. Here's a breakdown of your scenario: 1. **Calling an External GPL-2 Script**: Simply invoking or calling an external script that is licensed under GPL-2 does not in itself cause ...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "So what I'm planning to do is to create a script which one part calls (via Python's subprocess) external open source script licensed under GPL-2. To make it easier for users I'd like to distribute the GPL-2'ed script with with my own so that call could be easily done on the cor...
I released a project under GPLv2 license on GitHub. But this project is not distributed as binary by itself. It is only available in a packaged offer along other components. As original licence owner I understand that I can also distribute my work using non Free Licenses. The result is that the GPLed project is publicl...
Your situation raises important questions about the implications of the GPL license, particularly the differences between GPLv2 and GPLv3, and the responsibilities that come with using GPL-licensed code. Let's break down your concerns: 1. **License Violation**: According to the GPLv2 (and also the GPLv3), if a third p...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I released a project under GPLv2 license on GitHub. But this project is not distributed as binary by itself. It is only available in a packaged offer along other components. As original licence owner I understand that I can also distribute my work using non Free Licenses.\nThe r...
According to the Open Definition: “Open means anyone can freely access, use, modify, and share for any purpose (subject, at most, to requirements that preserve provenance and openness).” Open Data is hence, any data that is open, according to this definition. So, then this leads me to the question: What is Open Knowl...
Open Knowledge refers to the body of knowledge that is available to anyone to access, use, modify, and share, much like Open Data. However, it encompasses a broader scope than just data. While Open Data primarily focuses on datasets that are made available in a way that allows for free use and sharing, Open Knowledge i...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "According to the Open Definition:\n\n“Open means anyone can freely access, use, modify, and share for any purpose (subject, at most, to requirements that preserve provenance and openness).”\n\nOpen Data is hence, any data that is open, according to this definition. So, then this...
This website: https://html5up.net/ offers lots of HTML 5 themes using CC BY licenses. Can I create my own Wordpress theme based on these HTML 5 templates and sell on a theme market like https://themeforest.net/ ?
You can use HTML5 templates from websites like HTML5 UP, which are offered under Creative Commons licenses, but you must adhere to the specific terms of the license, in this case, CC BY (Attribution). Here are the general points to consider: 1. **Attribution**: You must provide proper credit to the original authors of...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "This website: https://html5up.net/ offers lots of HTML 5 themes using CC BY licenses. Can I create my own Wordpress theme based on these HTML 5 templates and sell on a theme market like https://themeforest.net/ ?\n" }, { "from": "gpt", "value": "You can use HTML5 tem...
As a creator of a FLOSS project, what do I need to know about the Digital Millennium Copyright Act? As an example, Github is often forced to remove sites based on DMCA requests. The requests are posted at https://github.com/github/dmca and make for some interesting reading. Many of the take-down requests are based pure...
As a creator of a Free/Libre and Open Source Software (FLOSS) project, it's important to understand the implications of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA) and how it can affect your work. Here are some key points and lessons to consider: ### Key Sections of the DMCA 1. **Anti-Circumvention Provisions (Sectio...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "As a creator of a FLOSS project, what do I need to know about the Digital Millennium Copyright Act?\nAs an example, Github is often forced to remove sites based on DMCA requests. The requests are posted at https://github.com/github/dmca and make for some interesting reading.\nMa...
There are two libraries under MIT, that do the same thing, each with some pros and cons. I'd like to merge them, effectively reworking the public API, but keeping the underlying logic (code). The resulting library should be part of my framework that is currently licensed under apache 2.0. Can I license the resulting l...
When merging two libraries that are both licensed under the MIT license into a new library that is part of your framework licensed under the Apache 2.0 license, here are some considerations to keep in mind: ### Licensing 1. **Licensing the Resulting Library**: - You can license the resulting library under Apache ...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "There are two libraries under MIT, that do the same thing, each with some pros and cons. I'd like to merge them, effectively reworking the public API, but keeping the underlying logic (code). The resulting library should be part of my framework that is currently licensed under a...
A common misunderstanding is that free software (replace the terms with "open source software" as you wish) will never involve costs. While this might be indeed true regarding you don't need to pay for licenses, they often don't understand you might have to pay for actually getting access the learning curve might be s...
Explaining the true nature of open-source software (OSS) and the costs associated with it can be challenging, especially when many people associate "free" with "no cost." Here are some strategies to help customers understand the broader implications and benefits of open-source software, beyond just licensing: ### 1. *...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "A common misunderstanding is that free software (replace the terms with \"open source software\" as you wish) will never involve costs. While this might be indeed true regarding you don't need to pay for licenses, they often don't understand\n\nyou might have to pay for actually...
I want to use this library in my project. Author says it is under the LGPL license, but one of its dependencies is under the EUPL license. EUPL license isn't clear about if a closed-source application that uses the libraries inherits the EUPL license. What I understood so far is the following: LGPL licence is compatib...
Using a library under the EUPL (European Union Public License) in a closed-source commercial product can be complex, and it ultimately depends on several factors. Here's a breakdown based on your understanding and the licenses involved: 1. **Understanding EUPL**: The EUPL is a copyleft license, which means that it req...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I want to use this library in my project. Author says it is under the LGPL license, but one of its dependencies is under the EUPL license.\nEUPL license isn't clear about if a closed-source application that uses the libraries inherits the EUPL license. What I understood so far i...
As I said in the title I have created a software that contains a library that has FOSS license.. 1) can I distribute my project with proprietary license (either sell it or give it for free) ? 2) If not, what should I do? This is the software license.
To provide a clear and accurate answer, it would be helpful to know the specific FOSS (Free and Open Source Software) license your library is under, as the rules governing distribution can vary significantly between different licenses. However, I can provide a general overview based on common FOSS licenses: 1. **Can y...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "As I said in the title I have created a software that contains a library that has FOSS license..\n1) can I distribute my project with proprietary license (either sell it or give it for free) ?\n2) If not, what should I do?\nThis is the software license.\n" }, { "from": "...
I found a GPL v3 licensed library, that I can compile for various architectures and use in the code for a BSD licensed project. This means that I probably have to distribute the binaries with it. Does this violate the GPL terms of use?
Using a GPL v3 licensed library in a BSD licensed project involves some important considerations regarding the licenses' compatibility and requirements, especially when it comes to distribution. 1. **GPL v3 License**: The GPL v3 license is a copyleft license. This means that if you use a GPL v3 licensed library in you...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I found a GPL v3 licensed library, that I can compile for various architectures and use in the code for a BSD licensed project. This means that I probably have to distribute the binaries with it.\nDoes this violate the GPL terms of use?\n" }, { "from": "gpt", "value"...
What is the copyright status of the source code of “Adventure” (also known as Colossal Cave Adventure)? There is a good record today of the history of Adventure. Specifically: The 1975–1976 Crowther and Woods “350-point version” for PDP-10 Fortran is available. What is the copyright status of this work? Not just who ho...
"Adventure," also known as "Colossal Cave Adventure," was originally developed in the mid-1970s by Will Crowther and later modified by Don Woods. The copyright status of the original source code is important for understanding how you can use or distribute derivatives of it. As of now, the original source code for "Adv...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "What is the copyright status of the source code of “Adventure” (also known as Colossal Cave Adventure)?\nThere is a good record today of the history of Adventure. Specifically: The 1975–1976 Crowther and Woods “350-point version” for PDP-10 Fortran is available.\nWhat is the cop...
I work at a small company in a small IT department. We use Visual Studio Online (the Team Foundation Server flavor of VSO) to store our source code. We're interested in deploying an open source (GPL v3) project for use here. The project is hosted on GitHub. There are some bugs in the project however that we will need t...
Creating a fork of an open-source project is a common scenario when you need to make modifications while also wanting to contribute back to the original project. Given your situation, here are some considerations regarding both approaches: ### 1. **Forking on GitHub** - **Pros:** - **Seamless Integration with ...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I work at a small company in a small IT department. We use Visual Studio Online (the Team Foundation Server flavor of VSO) to store our source code. We're interested in deploying an open source (GPL v3) project for use here. The project is hosted on GitHub.\nThere are some bugs ...
Straight up: I've never heard of the term 'copyleft' before. The fact that I get that little red squiggle under it tells me it's not really a word. Concisely, my question is, what does it mean to you? I saw it tagged on a few questions so I read the tag description: For questions about the copyleft concept (also kno...
Copyleft is a concept that emerged as a way to ensure that the freedoms associated with certain works, particularly in software and creative content, are preserved for all users. The term is a play on the word "copyright," flipping it to emphasize the idea of freedom rather than restriction. Here’s a concise breakdow...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "Straight up: I've never heard of the term 'copyleft' before. The fact that I get that little red squiggle under it tells me it's not really a word. Concisely, my question is, what does it mean to you? \n\nI saw it tagged on a few questions so I read the tag description:\n\nFor q...
I've got a number of software projects, licensed under varying licenses. For simplicity, let's take one of them, licensed under the GPL. Obviously, the GPL requires various things, and there may be occasions where people don't do all those things. If I notice those, I see two choices: Contact the relevant person with ...
When you are the copyright holder of software licensed under the GPL (GNU General Public License), you have certain rights and responsibilities regarding the enforcement of the license. The GPL is designed to ensure that the freedoms granted by the license are upheld. Here’s how the involvement of a third party changes...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I've got a number of software projects, licensed under varying licenses. For simplicity, let's take one of them, licensed under the GPL.\nObviously, the GPL requires various things, and there may be occasions where people don't do all those things. If I notice those, I see two c...
MIT license states The above copyright notice and this permission notice shall be included in all copies or substantial portions of the Software. If I make a modified version of an MIT-covered code and publish it, does it have to be under an MIT license because the notice is copied?
No, you are not required to publish a modified version of an MIT-licensed code under the MIT license. The MIT license is permissive, which means that you can modify the code and choose to license your modified version under a different license if you wish. However, you are required to include the original copyright n...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "MIT license states\n\nThe above copyright notice and this permission notice shall be\n included in all copies or substantial portions of the Software.\n\nIf I make a modified version of an MIT-covered code and publish it, does it have to be under an MIT license because the noti...
Is it possible to use free software libraries or parts of a free software system in proprietary software without violating the licenses? In other words, can I build a system that uses some parts of a free software and release just the source code of the already free parts as free software? For instance, let's say I'm w...
The ability to use free software libraries or components in proprietary software depends on the specific licenses of the software you are considering. Here’s a general overview: 1. **Permissive Licenses (e.g., MIT, BSD, Apache)**: These licenses are generally permissive and allow you to use, modify, and distribute the...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "Is it possible to use free software libraries or parts of a free software system in proprietary software without violating the licenses?\nIn other words, can I build a system that uses some parts of a free software and release just the source code of the already free parts as fr...
I want to write a plugin for an open-source software which is not GPL, but has a GPL-compatible license (MIT/BSD). I would like the plugin to use a GPL library. Can I do this? My rationale: Since the plugin links with a GPL library, the plugin is of course also GPL, which is fine. In order to comply with GPL, all the ...
Your reasoning is mostly correct, but there are some important nuances to consider regarding the licensing of your plugin, the host application, and the GPL library you intend to use. 1. **GPL and Linking**: The GPL license is quite strict about linking. If your plugin links with a GPL-licensed library, then your plug...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I want to write a plugin for an open-source software which is not GPL, but has a GPL-compatible license (MIT/BSD). I would like the plugin to use a GPL library.\nCan I do this?\nMy rationale:\n\nSince the plugin links with a GPL library, the plugin is of course also GPL, which i...
I am using the Volley library, provided by Google, to do some http requests on android app. The Volley library is under the "Creative Commons Attribution 2.5". If I want to publish my app later on the Play Store, do i have something special to do to be able to use this library ? I read the license but i don't really un...
The Creative Commons Attribution 2.5 license allows you to use, modify, and distribute the work as long as you provide appropriate credit to the original creator. When it comes to using the Volley library in your Android app and publishing it on the Play Store, here's what you need to consider: 1. **Attribution**: You...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I am using the Volley library, provided by Google, to do some http requests on android app. The Volley library is under the \"Creative Commons Attribution 2.5\".\nIf I want to publish my app later on the Play Store, do i have something special to do to be able to use this librar...
Like many other people I read this meta post. Since I don't really understand what is at stake I became confused and worried. Does this mean that I can legally force any organization to let me see the source code of any application touched by a questioner when I give an answer to their question? Does this mean that I o...
It seems like you’re referring to a concern about intellectual property rights and licensing related to contributions made on platforms like Stack Overflow (SO) or the Stack Exchange network. This can be a complex and nuanced topic, so let's break down your questions and concerns. 1. **Access to Source Code**: In gene...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "Like many other people I read this meta post. Since I don't really understand what is at stake I became confused and worried.\nDoes this mean that I can legally force any organization to let me see the source code of any application touched by a questioner when I give an answer ...
I'm new to licenses and don't really understand the difference between the license choices on GitHub. If you license your own work under the GNU General Public License, does this mean you wouldn't be able to use the code again in a closed source commercial product you own?
Yes, that's correct. The GNU General Public License (GPL) is a copyleft license, which means that if you distribute the code or a derivative work based on that code, you must do so under the same license (GPL). This requires that any modifications or derivative works you create also be open source and made available to...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I'm new to licenses and don't really understand the difference between the license choices on GitHub.\nIf you license your own work under the GNU General Public License, does this mean you wouldn't be able to use the code again in a closed source commercial product you own?\n" ...
Using a text format utility, (e.g. par) I would like to know if either/both of the following are permitted: Adjust paragraph width or center/justify text. Distribute as a .md Markdown file so as to highlight # headers and/or add bullet lists to individual articles/clauses.
Yes, you can definitely use text format utilities like `par` to adjust paragraph width, center or justify text, and also format your content as a Markdown file to include headers and bullet lists. ### Adjusting Paragraph Width and Justification The `par` utility allows you to control the formatting of text, including...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "Using a text format utility, (e.g. par) I would like to know if either/both of the following are permitted:\n\nAdjust paragraph width or center/justify text.\nDistribute as a .md Markdown file so as to highlight # headers and/or add bullet lists to individual articles/clauses.\n...
Here's the scenario. Alice crafted a compression library and published it under GPL. Bob crafted a font processing library which uses pieces of code from Alice's library and ... let's call it overly optimistically ... published his combined work under MIT license. This is a problem for people who want to use Bob's libr...
Yes, if Carol rewrites Bob's library such that it no longer contains any pieces of Alice's GPL-licensed code, her new version can indeed be published under the MIT license without being subject to the GPL's requirements. Here's a breakdown of the situation: 1. **Bob's Library**: Originally published under MIT but con...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "Here's the scenario. Alice crafted a compression library and published it under GPL. Bob crafted a font processing library which uses pieces of code from Alice's library and ... let's call it overly optimistically ... published his combined work under MIT license. This is a prob...
The source for the Linux kernel v0.01 can easily be found online, however it does not seem to contain a license or any redistribution rules. Is it, therefore, safe to assume that this code is in the public domain? Or have I missed something, and in fact it is licensed under some kind of license?
The Linux kernel version 0.01 was released by Linus Torvalds in 1991, and while it may not have an explicit license included in the source code, it is not in the public domain. The development of the Linux kernel quickly adopted the GNU General Public License (GPL), starting from version 0.99, which became the formal l...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "The source for the Linux kernel v0.01 can easily be found online, however it does not seem to contain a license or any redistribution rules. Is it, therefore, safe to assume that this code is in the public domain? Or have I missed something, and in fact it is licensed under some...
I was looking for a .ttf font, where almost all of the unicode characters are created. Then I've found the GNU Unifont It is licensed under GNU GENERAL PUBLIC LICENSE Version 2 The application I am working on cannot be open sourced (not my choise). It is not just closed-source, but commercial also. Am I allowed to use ...
The GNU Unifont is licensed under the GNU General Public License (GPL) Version 2. The key aspects of this license are that it allows you to use, modify, and distribute the font, but any derivative work or any software that incorporates the font must also be licensed under the GPL if distributed. Given your situation—w...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I was looking for a .ttf font, where almost all of the unicode characters are created. Then I've found the GNU Unifont\nIt is licensed under GNU GENERAL PUBLIC LICENSE Version 2\nThe application I am working on cannot be open sourced (not my choise). It is not just closed-source...
I've been developing an API internally with a few friends, and hope to expand it and make it open to the broader public. I've highlighted a lot of background in this question, but to recap, it's a smaller project that has mostly been intended for educational use. We're going fairly well, found a name for it (Spoiler! I...
It's great to hear about your project, Snowdrop, and your enthusiasm for expanding it! When it comes to managing contributions and licensing for an open-source project, there are a few key considerations to keep in mind: ### 1. Importance of Licensing Having a clear license for your project is crucial because it defi...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I've been developing an API internally with a few friends, and hope to expand it and make it open to the broader public. I've highlighted a lot of background in this question, but to recap, it's a smaller project that has mostly been intended for educational use.\nWe're going fa...
It has always bothered me that the MIT license uses the word “conditions” but only seems to list one condition: Permission is hereby granted […] to any person obtaining a copy of this software […] to deal in the Software without restriction […] subject to the following conditions: The above copyright notice and this p...
The language in the MIT License can indeed be a bit confusing, particularly regarding the use of the word "conditions." The license states: 1. The "condition" for using the software is that the copyright notice and permission notice must be included in all copies or substantial portions of the software. 2. The subsequ...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "It has always bothered me that the MIT license uses the word “conditions” but only seems to list one condition:\n\nPermission is hereby granted […] to any person obtaining a copy of this software […] to deal in the Software without restriction […] subject to the following condit...
I understand that, generally speaking, you may not issue a license on a copyrighted work if you do not own the copyright to that work. Licensing is an exclusive right of the copyright holder. Instead, you may prepare a derivative your other people's work, and license your own changes under some license. Recipients of y...
The MIT License does allow for sublicensing, but it is essential to clarify what that means in practice. When you receive a work licensed under the MIT License, you are granted permission to use, copy, modify, merge, publish, distribute, sublicense, and sell copies of the work. This means you can redistribute the origi...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I understand that, generally speaking, you may not issue a license on a copyrighted work if you do not own the copyright to that work. Licensing is an exclusive right of the copyright holder. Instead, you may prepare a derivative your other people's work, and license your own ch...
Apache License, Version 2.0 is not compatible with GPL version 2, according to GNU and Apache websites. I worry is it possible to make Android projects under GPLv2 license, because, Android SDK, support libraries and most of android libraries are under Apache v2.0. I have found a lot of popular GPLv2 Android projects...
You are correct that the Apache License, Version 2.0 (Apache 2.0) is not compatible with the GNU General Public License (GPL) version 2 (GPLv2). This means that if you create a project that links to or incorporates code licensed under Apache 2.0, that project cannot be licensed under GPLv2 without potentially violating...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "Apache License, Version 2.0 is not compatible with GPL version 2, according to GNU and Apache websites. \nI worry is it possible to make Android projects under GPLv2 license, \nbecause, Android SDK, support libraries and most of android libraries are under Apache v2.0.\nI have f...
I like the jQuery Isotope plugin and I want to use it on my website. I was wondering if it was OK to use it without a licence. It's licensed under either GPLv3 as an open-source license, or there's a commercial license available if you want to keep your code proprietary. I am not gonna sell the plugin or claim its mine...
Yes, you can use the jQuery Isotope plugin on your website without needing to purchase a commercial license, as long as you adhere to the terms of the GPLv3 license. Here’s a brief overview of what that means: 1. **GPLv3 License**: Since Isotope is available under the GNU General Public License version 3 (GPLv3), you ...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I like the jQuery Isotope plugin and I want to use it on my website. I was wondering if it was OK to use it without a licence.\nIt's licensed under either GPLv3 as an open-source license, or there's a commercial license available if you want to keep your code proprietary.\nI am ...
How do Open Source projects audit code to ensure it comes from ethical sources. For example, if a hacker hacks into IBM, steals some code and contributes it to the kernel, how does the kernel team ensure that it doesn't get into the kernel?
Auditing code in open source projects to ensure that it comes from ethical sources is a complex process, especially given the openness and collaborative nature of such projects. Here are some methods that are commonly employed to ensure code integrity and ethical sourcing: 1. **Code Review Processes**: Open source pro...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "How do Open Source projects audit code to ensure it comes from ethical sources. For example, if a hacker hacks into IBM, steals some code and contributes it to the kernel, how does the kernel team ensure that it doesn't get into the kernel?\n" }, { "from": "gpt", "va...
From Wikipedia, it states that EULA is different from OSSL Unlike EULAs, free software licenses do not work as contractual extensions to existing legislation. No agreement between parties is ever held, because a copyright license is simply a declaration of permissions on something that otherwise would be disallowed by...
You are correct in your understanding of the fundamental differences between Open Source Software Licenses (OSSL) like the MIT License and End User License Agreements (EULAs). ### Key Differences 1. **Nature of Agreement**: - **EULA**: A EULA is a contract between the software developer or publisher and the end us...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "From Wikipedia, it states that EULA is different from OSSL\n\nUnlike EULAs, free software licenses do not work as contractual extensions to existing legislation. No agreement between parties is ever held, because a copyright license is simply a declaration of permissions on some...
Music can be shared under open source principles that allow remixing, for instance under matching Creative Commons licenses and on platforms like Soundcloud. It is common sense, that a release as open source makes the piece more attractive, it can gain through word-of-mouth advertising and can become more popular than ...
The idea of sharing music under open-source principles or Creative Commons licenses has indeed gained traction, and there is some evidence to suggest that this approach can positively affect a piece's popularity. Here are a few points to consider regarding the impact of open licensing on music and other creative works:...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "Music can be shared under open source principles that allow remixing, for instance under matching Creative Commons licenses and on platforms like Soundcloud. It is common sense, that a release as open source makes the piece more attractive, it can gain through word-of-mouth adve...
I have noticed that some groups or organizations convey the GPL software without the source code. Such examples are: https://sourceforge.net/projects/serbian2014/files/Download/ as Serbian GNU/Linux https://gitlab.com/trios-linux/trios/tree/master (pure, if any source), again as some kind of Serbian GNU based on Linu...
You are correct in your understanding of the GNU General Public License (GPL). The GPL is designed to ensure that software licensed under it remains free and that users have the right to access the source code. Specifically, the GPL (both version 2 and version 3) requires that if you distribute binary versions of softw...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I have noticed that some groups or organizations convey the GPL software without the source code. Such examples are:\n\nhttps://sourceforge.net/projects/serbian2014/files/Download/ as Serbian GNU/Linux \nhttps://gitlab.com/trios-linux/trios/tree/master (pure, if any source), aga...
Dalvik was licensed under the ASL on the premise that it was reverse engineered: Licensing and patents Main article: Oracle v. Google Dalvik is published under the terms of the Apache License 2.0.[18] Google says that Dalvik is a clean-room implementation rather than a development on top of a standard Java runtime...
ART (Android Runtime) is also part of the Android operating system, similar to Dalvik, but it was introduced as a replacement for Dalvik in Android 5.0 (Lollipop). ART is designed to improve performance and provide better memory management. As for the licensing, ART is part of the Android Open Source Project (AOSP), w...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "Dalvik was licensed under the ASL on the premise that it was reverse engineered:\n\nLicensing and patents Main article: Oracle v. Google\nDalvik is published under the terms of the Apache License 2.0.[18]\n Google says that Dalvik is a clean-room implementation rather than a\n ...
I recently modified software code licensed under EPL v1.0. Can I remove the original copyright and add my own copyright ?
No, you cannot remove the original copyright notice from software licensed under the Eclipse Public License (EPL) v1.0. The EPL allows you to modify the code and distribute your modifications, but it requires that you retain the original copyright notice and the license terms. Here are a few key points to consider: ...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I recently modified software code licensed under EPL v1.0. Can I remove the original copyright and add my own copyright ?\n" }, { "from": "gpt", "value": "No, you cannot remove the original copyright notice from software licensed under the Eclipse Public License (EPL...
In its anatomy browser BioDigital has a feature where the website displays text that it doesn't license under CC BY-SA. At the end of that text the user can click on "Read more". If he does an inline popup appears showing information from Wikipedia mobile. This popup refers at it's end to being licensed CC-BY-SA. Is it...
To determine whether BioDigital's approach complies with the CC BY-SA license, we need to look at a few key points about the CC BY-SA license and how it works. 1. **CC BY-SA License Overview**: The Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike (CC BY-SA) license allows users to share, remix, and adapt the work, as long as t...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "In its anatomy browser BioDigital has a feature where the website displays text that it doesn't license under CC BY-SA. At the end of that text the user can click on \"Read more\". If he does an inline popup appears showing information from Wikipedia mobile. This popup refers at...
I am currently working on an EPUB project in which I'll embed a font licensed under OFL. According to the second point in the PERMISSION & CONDITIONS section, the font "may be bundled (...) provided that each copy contains the above copyright notice and this license". There is no problem to include the "copyright notic...
In an EPUB project, including a license file, such as the OFL (Open Font License), is important for ensuring that you comply with the license requirements. Here’s how you can effectively include the license file in your EPUB structure: 1. **Create a License File:** Make sure you have the OFL .txt file that contains th...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I am currently working on an EPUB project in which I'll embed a font licensed under OFL.\nAccording to the second point in the PERMISSION & CONDITIONS section, the font \"may be bundled (...) provided that each copy contains the above copyright notice and this license\".\nThere ...
I've a proprietary program which is using OOP classes which I want to publish as FOSS (only the classes). Which FOSS compatible license I can choose for the classes which will work with my proprietary program which I'm selling? I was thinking about GNU GPL, but if I understand correctly, I've to distribute my entire pr...
If you want to publish your object-oriented classes as free and open-source software (FOSS) while still being able to use them within a proprietary program, you should consider licenses that allow for both open-source distribution and proprietary usage. Here are some options you might consider: 1. **MIT License**: Thi...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I've a proprietary program which is using OOP classes which I want to publish as FOSS (only the classes).\nWhich FOSS compatible license I can choose for the classes which will work with my proprietary program which I'm selling?\nI was thinking about GNU GPL, but if I understand...
Our app's icon dates back to when shiny gradients were cool, so we asked users to design a new one, and about 20 different designs have been submitted. A particular user submitted a very nice design, and several people asked her to make slight variations, so now she has 3 very similar variations of the same icon. If we...
In situations like this where multiple similar designs are submitted and the "independence of clones" issue arises, traditional voting methods such as simple plurality voting can lead to suboptimal results, as you've noted. Instead, methods that account for voters' preferences and can effectively aggregate similar opti...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "Our app's icon dates back to when shiny gradients were cool, so we asked users to design a new one, and about 20 different designs have been submitted.\nA particular user submitted a very nice design, and several people asked her to make slight variations, so now she has 3 very ...
This question is about selling FLOSS and its source-code. According to Selling Free Software and commercial purpose, Free Software can be distributed with or without charge. My friend asked me two questions which I didn’t answer exactly, so I would like to ask one here, in order to know absolutely and explain. Consider...
Selling Free/Libre Open Source Software (FLOSS) can indeed be a viable business strategy, even without dual licensing or added services. The key to understanding this business model lies in recognizing the value that companies can offer beyond just the software itself. Here are several ways this can work: ### 1. **Val...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "This question is about selling FLOSS and its source-code. According to Selling Free Software and commercial purpose, Free Software can be distributed with or without charge.\nMy friend asked me two questions which I didn’t answer exactly, so I would like to ask one here, in orde...
I am using the Telegram API (licensed under GNU GPL) to integrate chat services within my own application. The developer of Telegram asks to - "Please remember to publish your code too in order to comply with the licences." So in a nutshell, my question is: Do I need to open-source my entire application or whether ...
When using software that is licensed under the GNU General Public License (GPL), you are generally required to comply with the terms of that license if you distribute your application. Here are a few key points to consider: 1. **Use of GPL Code**: If your application incorporates or links against GPL-licensed code (li...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I am using the Telegram API (licensed under GNU GPL) to integrate chat services within my own application. The developer of Telegram asks to -\n\n\"Please remember to publish your code too in order to comply with the\n licences.\"\n\nSo in a nutshell, my question is: Do I need ...
Is it possible to distribute binary files using any open source or Creative Commons license? In particular, I have several Flash videos (.swf files) whose sources (.fla files) are not available/lost. These videos need to be shipped with an open source project. I am looking for possible ways to address this situation. A...
Yes, it is possible to distribute binary files like Flash videos (.swf files) under an open source or Creative Commons license. However, there are a few considerations to keep in mind regarding licensing, legal implications, and the intent of open-source principles. ### Licensing Options 1. **Creative Commons (CC)**:...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "Is it possible to distribute binary files using any open source or Creative Commons license? In particular, I have several Flash videos (.swf files) whose sources (.fla files) are not available/lost. These videos need to be shipped with an open source project. I am looking for p...
I am working on open source tool for which I want users to not remove or change product logo. Is this possible? I had originally asked my question here at Stack Overflow but it was recommended that I ask here as well.
When it comes to open source projects, there are certain conventions and principles that typically govern how projects are used and distributed. Here are a few considerations for maintaining your product logo while allowing for open source usage: 1. **License Choice**: Select an appropriate open source license that al...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I am working on open source tool for which I want users to not remove or change product logo. Is this possible?\nI had originally asked my question here at Stack Overflow but it was recommended that I ask here as well.\n" }, { "from": "gpt", "value": "When it comes ...