instruction
stringlengths
57
20.2k
completion
stringlengths
4
5.16k
conversations
listlengths
2
2
I have implemented an RSYNC library based on the technical report by Andrew Tridgell and Paul Mackerras. The library implementation does not borrow code from the official RSYNC library and does not conform to the official API. I would like to release my library as free software on GitHub. The RSYNC library itself is...
When developing your own implementation of an algorithm or protocol, such as the one described in the RSYNC technical report by Andrew Tridgell and Paul Mackerras, you are generally free to license your work independently of the original RSYNC library, provided you have not copied any of the original source code or oth...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I have implemented an RSYNC library based on the \ntechnical report by Andrew Tridgell and Paul Mackerras. The library implementation does not borrow code from the official RSYNC library and does not conform to the official API. I would like to release my library as free softw...
Wikipedia seems to imply that Turbolinux bundles proprietary codecs. More generally, under what conditions is it OK to mix proprietary and GNU-GPLv3 software into an operating system, and distribute it on a DVD?
Mixing proprietary software with GNU GPLv3-licensed software can be a complex issue, primarily revolving around the terms of the licenses involved. Here’s a general overview of the conditions under which it is permissible to combine these types of software and distribute them together, particularly in the context of an...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "Wikipedia seems to imply that Turbolinux bundles proprietary codecs.\nMore generally, under what conditions is it OK to mix proprietary and GNU-GPLv3 software into an operating system, and distribute it on a DVD?\n" }, { "from": "gpt", "value": "Mixing proprietary so...
Context: I'm making a YouTube commercial, which includes some music that's licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0. Would an audio-visual work constitute a derivative work of the music used in it, and (given the music's license) would you have to license the whole commercial as CC BY-SA 3.0?
Yes, an audio-visual work that incorporates music licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0 would indeed be considered a derivative work of that music. The CC BY-SA 3.0 license requires that any derivative works must also be licensed under the same terms, meaning that your entire commercial would need to be licensed under CC BY-SA 3...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "Context: I'm making a YouTube commercial, which includes some music that's licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.\nWould an audio-visual work constitute a derivative work of the music used in it, and (given the music's license) would you have to license the whole commercial as CC BY-SA 3....
During development of ParrotBot, I've ran into many issues in terms of debugging, design and integration. In the chat room, I've received lots of support that has helped me greatly, so that I could continue the project, with ease. However, I've started wondering whether I could possibly be charged for this "support." H...
In general, using and modifying open source software comes with specific rights and responsibilities that are outlined in the software's license. Here are some key points to consider regarding your situation with ParrotBot: 1. **Open Source Licensing**: Open source projects are usually released under specific licenses...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "During development of ParrotBot, I've ran into many issues in terms of debugging, design and integration. In the chat room, I've received lots of support that has helped me greatly, so that I could continue the project, with ease.\nHowever, I've started wondering whether I could...
If software is licenced under a GPL license, can it be used without restriction in a corporate/commercial environment? The software that I am refering to is QGIS which provides this description: QGIS is a user friendly Open Source Geographic Information System (GIS) licensed under the GNU General Public License. QGIS ...
The confusion surrounding the use of GPL-licensed software like QGIS in a corporate or commercial environment is quite common, so it’s understandable that there are differing opinions. Let's clarify the key aspects of the GNU General Public License (GPL) and how it applies to commercial use. 1. **Freedom to Use**: The...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "If software is licenced under a GPL license, can it be used without restriction in a corporate/commercial environment? The software that I am refering to is QGIS which provides this description:\n\nQGIS is a user friendly Open Source Geographic Information System (GIS) licensed ...
I want to copy a file from a project licensed under a New BSD license. My own project is licensed under an MIT license. The file is simple batch script for locating build tools and starting the build. The file itself does not contain copyright notices. How can copy the file without breaking the license? Should I includ...
When using a file from a project licensed under the New BSD license in your own project that is licensed under the MIT license, you can certainly do so, but you need to adhere to the terms of the New BSD license. Here’s how to properly proceed: 1. **Include the License**: Yes, you should include the New BSD license in...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I want to copy a file from a project licensed under a New BSD license. My own project is licensed under an MIT license. The file is simple batch script for locating build tools and starting the build. The file itself does not contain copyright notices.\nHow can copy the file wit...
I'm giving myself a headache just thinking about this, so would appreciate anyone else with an opinion. First, off, a note: I'm absolutely aware that my current code is a 'derivative work' - That's not in question. The implications of this are giving me a headache though. The situation is as follows: I wanted to parse ...
This is a nuanced issue and involves understanding both copyright law and software licensing principles. Here are several points to consider that might help clarify your situation: 1. **Derivative Works and Code Licensing**: Since you have derived your code from an existing implementation, it is indeed a derivative wo...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I'm giving myself a headache just thinking about this, so would appreciate anyone else with an opinion.\nFirst, off, a note:\nI'm absolutely aware that my current code is a 'derivative work' - That's not in question. The implications of this are giving me a headache though.\nThe...
Chromium development is still very much active on Google Code, which will turn read-only on August 25th 2015. What are the plans to move Chromium development?
Chromium development transitioned from Google Code to GitHub in 2016. This move was part of a broader trend in the software development community to use Git and GitHub for version control and collaboration. The Chromium team planned and executed the migration to ensure that the development process remained smooth and e...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "Chromium development is still very much active on Google Code, which will turn read-only on August 25th 2015.\n\nWhat are the plans to move Chromium development?\n" }, { "from": "gpt", "value": "Chromium development transitioned from Google Code to GitHub in 2016. Th...
Cooking recipes are often used to explain novice programmers about the concept of algorithms. There are some basic similarities to these two. So I ask myself, if there are open source programs, are there open source recipes? And if not, why not?
The idea of "open source recipes" is indeed a fascinating concept that can draw parallels with open source software. Let's break down the idea and explore whether it exists, and if not, why that might be the case. ### Open Source Recipes: The Concept 1. **Definition**: Just as open source software is made available f...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "Cooking recipes are often used to explain novice programmers about the concept of algorithms. There are some basic similarities to these two. So I ask myself, if there are open source programs, are there open source recipes? And if not, why not?\n" }, { "from": "gpt", ...
I have some source code for which I am the copyright holder. I want to release it under the GPL, but when it was closed source, I copied a bunch of a stuff from Wikipedia for a couple of classes and used it strictly for comments. This was just a matter of convenience, I have classes that allow you to manipulate HTTP he...
When you incorporate material from a source that is licensed under a Creative Commons license, you must adhere to the terms of that license, regardless of whether that material is used as comments or as part of the functional code. In your case, the comments derived from Wikipedia are governed by the Creative Commons A...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I have some source code for which I am the copyright holder. I want to release it under the GPL, but when it was closed source, I copied a bunch of a stuff from Wikipedia for a couple of classes and used it strictly for comments. This was just a matter of convenience, I have cla...
I think the inverse of What do I need to share if I include CC-BY-SA artwork in my software?. Some webpages, such as Code for America are licensed under CC-BY-SA. If I want to adapt the code for this web page to host copyrighted content which cannot be redistributed, can I? Is it possible to retain the CC license for t...
Yes, you can use CC-BY-SA licensed material (like a webpage template) while having separate copyright clauses for the content you add to it, as long as you adhere to the terms of the CC-BY-SA license for the original material. Here's a breakdown of how it works: 1. **Using CC-BY-SA Licensed Material**: The CC-BY-SA l...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I think the inverse of What do I need to share if I include CC-BY-SA artwork in my software?.\nSome webpages, such as Code for America are licensed under CC-BY-SA. If I want to adapt the code for this web page to host copyrighted content which cannot be redistributed, can I? Is ...
We're trying to raise some fund for our Open Source project. There's a lot of companies out there selling t-shirts and stickers with Open Source projects, but they don't give a share of the profits to those projects. I was wondering if there was any initiative out there selling merchandise who're giving a part of the p...
Yes, there are several initiatives and platforms that focus on selling merchandise for open source projects while ensuring that a portion of the profits goes back to those projects. Here are a few options you can explore: 1. **OpenCollective**: OpenCollective allows open source projects to raise funds through contribu...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "We're trying to raise some fund for our Open Source project.\nThere's a lot of companies out there selling t-shirts and stickers with Open Source projects, but they don't give a share of the profits to those projects.\nI was wondering if there was any initiative out there sellin...
While driving in the car recently I noticed a Google Streetview car go by outside. Once I got home I went onto Google Streetview and looked around for a bit. This is when I noticed the copyright notice: My question: How is Google able to take photos of already possibly copyrighted/licensed objects, and how is it that...
Google's ability to take photographs of objects and then display those images on Google Street View, despite the presence of potentially copyrighted or licensed objects, is based on several legal principles and practices: 1. **Public Space Photography**: Google Street View cars capture images from public roads and spa...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "While driving in the car recently I noticed a Google Streetview car go by outside. Once I got home I went onto Google Streetview and looked around for a bit. \nThis is when I noticed the copyright notice:\n\nMy question:\nHow is Google able to take photos of already possibly cop...
I run a moderately successful open source project on GitHub (it is a privacy enhancing tool for public websites, based upon some PETs I developed for my thesis). I am getting quite a few feature requests, and some of them are accompanied with pull-requests from people unknown to me. I think it is great that users want...
It's fantastic to hear that your open-source project is gaining traction and that users are eager to contribute! Managing contributions, especially when you're a one-person team, can be challenging but also rewarding. Here are some options and tools that can help you handle contributions more effectively while ensuring...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I run a moderately successful open source project on GitHub (it is a privacy enhancing tool for public websites, based upon some PETs I developed for my thesis).\nI am getting quite a few feature requests, and some of them are accompanied with pull-requests from people unknown t...
I have a graduation project based on an open source system. As my university is more leaned towards the market instead of the academia, I wanted to know who else (if ever) is going to take my project from the campus library to read or create new work based on it. Is it possible to attach some type of creative-commons-...
While you can't enforce a requirement for readers to contact you based on a Creative Commons license, you can encourage them to do so through the terms of the license or by including a specific clause in your project documentation. Here’s how you can approach this: 1. **Choose a Creative Commons License**: First, sele...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I have a graduation project based on an open source system. As my university is more leaned towards the market instead of the academia, I wanted to know who else (if ever) is going to take my project from the campus library to read or create new work based on it. \nIs it possibl...
As the title suggests I'm a bit confused when it comes to licencing in the middle of development. Say the following situation (for the sake of argument I'm the only contributor): I make a project opensource without a license I continue contributing to it and at some point I commit a license doc and license text in the...
Your situation highlights some important nuances regarding licensing for open-source projects. Here’s a breakdown of your questions and assumptions: 1. **Initial Project Without a License**: - When you start a project without a license, all rights are reserved by default. This means that no one else has the legal ...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "As the title suggests I'm a bit confused when it comes to licencing in the middle of development.\nSay the following situation (for the sake of argument I'm the only contributor):\n\nI make a project opensource without a license\nI continue contributing to it and at some point I...
Many IP cores especially from Xilinx have an AXI interface from ARM. The AXI interface standard is free for download (after registration), but I don't think it's free for implementation. So I assume Xilinx has bought an AMBA license to equip its IP cores with AXI interfaces. I don't have such license. Can I offer AXI i...
The question of whether you can offer AXI interfaces for your open-source IP cores written in VHDL or Verilog depends on several factors, primarily centered around licensing and intellectual property rights. 1. **AXI Specification**: While the AXI interface specification itself is available for free download after reg...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "Many IP cores especially from Xilinx have an AXI interface from ARM.\nThe AXI interface standard is free for download (after registration), but I don't think it's free for implementation. So I assume Xilinx has bought an AMBA license to equip its IP cores with AXI interfaces.\nI...
I have an commercial embedded device which uses linux as OS and I would like to add remote support to my commercial application on the device. I would like to use a dynamically linked library with GPL V2 license for adding the remote support. Can I create an application under GPL, which uses the library and acts as se...
When dealing with GPL (GNU General Public License) licenses, particularly GPL v2, it's essential to understand how the license affects your application and how you can structure your project. 1. **Using a GPL v2 Library**: If you link your application (the server in this case) with a library licensed under GPL v2, you...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I have an commercial embedded device which uses linux as OS and I would like to add remote support to my commercial application on the device.\nI would like to use a dynamically linked library with GPL V2 license for adding the remote support. \nCan I create an application under...
I'm working on an open source Python project and we have plans to use GPLv2-licensed library python3-xlib, but we will not distribute it with our library. So user can install it by pip install our-lib and the pip tool will install python3-xlib automatically. Or user can manually install python3-xlib. I've read that 3-c...
Your questions raise important points about software licensing, especially when dealing with different license types such as the GNU General Public License (GPL) and permissive licenses like the BSD license. I'll address your questions in detail: ### Using GPL Libraries as Dependencies 1. **Using a GPLv2 Library (lik...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I'm working on an open source Python project and we have plans to use GPLv2-licensed library python3-xlib, but we will not distribute it with our library. So user can install it by pip install our-lib and the pip tool will install python3-xlib automatically. Or user can manually...
I am developing a software for commercial release which is developed ahead on a sample code provided by MSDN This is mentioned in the beginning // THIS CODE AND INFORMATION IS PROVIDED "AS IS" WITHOUT WARRANTY OF // ANY KIND, EITHER EXPRESSED OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO // THE IMPLIED WARRANTIES OF MERC...
You are allowed to use the sample code provided by Microsoft under the terms of the Microsoft Limited Public License (MLPL) version 1.1, which you outlined. However, there are specific conditions and limitations that you must follow to ensure compliance with the license. Here are the key points: 1. **Non-Exclusive Lic...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I am developing a software for commercial release which is developed ahead on a sample code provided by MSDN \nThis is mentioned in the beginning\n// THIS CODE AND INFORMATION IS PROVIDED \"AS IS\" WITHOUT WARRANTY OF \n// ANY KIND, EITHER EXPRESSED OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT...
I created an open source user management system for PHP which is (admittedly) directed towards novice programmers. The idea is to help familiarize "Cowboys from Code Canyon" with the tools and design techniques used by the professional PHP community, while providing a useful piece of software. The problem is that my t...
Dealing with a user base that may not be inclined to read documentation can be frustrating, especially when your goal is to help novice programmers improve their skills. Here are some strategies you can consider to alleviate the burden of repetitive questions and improve the overall experience for both you and your use...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I created an open source user management system for PHP which is (admittedly) directed towards novice programmers. The idea is to help familiarize \"Cowboys from Code Canyon\" with the tools and design techniques used by the professional PHP community, while providing a useful ...
Currently, all user submitted content is licensed under "cc by-sa 3.0 with attribution required". This shows up at the bottom of each page: user contributions licensed under cc by-sa 3.0 with attribution required Is material that is submitted to Stack Exchange under this license compatible with the GPL? The reason t...
To determine if content licensed under "CC BY-SA 3.0" is compatible with the GNU General Public License (GPL), we should analyze the licenses in question. 1. **CC BY-SA 3.0 License**: - This license allows users to share (copy, distribute and transmit) and adapt (remix, transform, and build upon) the work, but req...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "Currently, all user submitted content is licensed under \"cc by-sa 3.0 with attribution required\". This shows up at the bottom of each page:\n\nuser contributions licensed under cc by-sa 3.0 with attribution required\n\nIs material that is submitted to Stack Exchange under thi...
Is Open Source Software a subset of free software? I was recently asked this and realized I was unsure the exact answer. I understand that free software is not a type of open source software, but I am unsure if the reverse is true or not.
To clarify the relationship between open source software and free software, it's essential to understand how both terms are defined and their philosophies. **Free Software**: This term is primarily associated with the Free Software Foundation (FSF), founded by Richard Stallman. The key aspect of free software is the e...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "Is Open Source Software a subset of free software?\nI was recently asked this and realized I was unsure the exact answer. I understand that free software is not a type of open source software, but I am unsure if the reverse is true or not.\n" }, { "from": "gpt", "val...
If I'm using a library that is licensed under GPL v3 in my project, can I license my project under the MIT license? I tried to read the GPL v3 text but I cannot understand it without your assistance.
Using a library licensed under the GPL v3 in your project imposes certain obligations due to the nature of the GPL licensing. The GNU General Public License (GPL) v3 is a copyleft license, which means that any derivative work you create that incorporates GPL-licensed code must also be distributed under the same GPL lic...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "If I'm using a library that is licensed under GPL v3 in my project, can I license my project under the MIT license? I tried to read the GPL v3 text but I cannot understand it without your assistance.\n" }, { "from": "gpt", "value": "Using a library licensed under the...
Can you fork a MIT licensed project, discard the code, and keep only the name? Say I wanted to piggyback on top of a popular MIT licensed project name for marketing purposes, but not use any of its code. Is this possible?
Using the name of a project that is under the MIT License can be a legal gray area. The MIT License itself primarily governs the use, copying, modification, and distribution of the software code, but it does not provide explicit rights or restrictions regarding the name or branding associated with that software. Here ...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "Can you fork a MIT licensed project, discard the code, and keep only the name?\nSay I wanted to piggyback on top of a popular MIT licensed project name for marketing purposes, but not use any of its code. Is this possible?\n" }, { "from": "gpt", "value": "Using the n...
I am interested in contributing to some open source projects in order to learn git and Python better. A lot of the projects I have looked at are fully mature, and the updates are pretty complex, requiring an understanding of large parts of the project. How do I find some low hanging fruit or moderately challenging prob...
Contributing to open source projects is a great way to learn Git and Python, as well as to improve your programming skills. Here are some strategies to find low-hanging fruit or moderately challenging problems to work on: ### 1. **Beginner-Friendly Labels** Many projects tag issues that are suitable for beginners. Loo...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I am interested in contributing to some open source projects in order to learn git and Python better. A lot of the projects I have looked at are fully mature, and the updates are pretty complex, requiring an understanding of large parts of the project.\nHow do I find some low ha...
CC BY-ND (Creative Commons Attribution No Derivatives) is a fairly restrictive license. It does not allow derivative works. The Wikipedia article on Creative Commons licenses says that it is not a free/libre license: Description Acronym Free/Libre ==================================================...
You raise an interesting point about the classification of the CC BY-ND license and its acceptance by various organizations, including the Free Software Foundation (FSF). The discussion around Creative Commons licenses often highlights the distinctions between "free" and "libre," especially when it comes to what is per...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "CC BY-ND (Creative Commons Attribution No Derivatives) is a fairly restrictive license. It does not allow derivative works.\nThe Wikipedia article on Creative Commons licenses says that it is not a free/libre license:\nDescription Acronym Free/Libre\n======...
This question is a follow-up on a number of questions that all mention some sort of software architecture X for creating software composites, and then goes on to ask: "Will using X to create a composite result in a derivative work?". For example: What are the arguments for considering dynamic links to constitute deri...
The question of how proprietary software can functionally utilize free software without resulting in derivative works often hinges on the way the software components interact, their licenses, and legal interpretations. Below are some concrete examples of proprietary software that depend on free software components whil...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "This question is a follow-up on a number of questions that all mention some sort of software architecture X for creating software composites, and then goes on to ask: \"Will using X to create a composite result in a derivative work?\". For example:\n\nWhat are the arguments for...
I want to contribute to a C# project on GitHub, but the repository is missing a CONTRIBUTING.md file. I've already noticed a few code style inconsistencies, but I don't want to assume the project is using the MSDN code conventions. What is the best way to bring up this issue with the maintainer?
Bringing up the issue of code style inconsistencies in a respectful and constructive manner is crucial when contributing to an open-source project. Here are some steps you can follow to communicate your observations effectively to the maintainer: 1. **Check Existing Issues and Discussions**: Before reaching out, revie...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I want to contribute to a C# project on GitHub, but the repository is missing a CONTRIBUTING.md file. I've already noticed a few code style inconsistencies, but I don't want to assume the project is using the MSDN code conventions. What is the best way to bring up this issue wit...
Recently some non-technical managers where I work found out that GitHub has a repository with code from "Hidden Tear" which is a ransomware application. The immediate reaction was to ban GitHub, which is something that we use extensively to get open source code. The only way to access GitHub again is by proving that th...
Creating a comprehensive open-source usage policy is an important step in ensuring that your organization can safely and effectively leverage resources from platforms like GitHub. Below, I’ll outline a suggested framework for your policy document, along with some guidelines to show the safety of using GitHub and open-s...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "Recently some non-technical managers where I work found out that GitHub has a repository with code from \"Hidden Tear\" which is a ransomware application. The immediate reaction was to ban GitHub, which is something that we use extensively to get open source code. The only way t...
I have some code which I would like to open source it (as part of the private repository), however the access should be limited only to the memberships who paid the access fee. Is it going to work? Which license can I use? Then can I protect from the unauthorised publishing of my code? Should all the people who have ac...
Open sourcing your code while limiting access to paying members involves a few considerations. Here’s how to approach it: ### 1. License Selection: If you want to open source your code but limit access to certain individuals (like paying members), a traditional open source license might not fit your needs. Most open s...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I have some code which I would like to open source it (as part of the private repository), however the access should be limited only to the memberships who paid the access fee. Is it going to work? Which license can I use?\nThen can I protect from the unauthorised publishing of ...
There are two libraries under MIT, that do the same thing, each with some pros and cons. I'd like to merge them, effectively reworking the public API, but keeping the underlying logic (code). The resulting library should be part of my framework that is currently licensed under apache 2.0. Can I license the resulting l...
When merging two MIT-licensed libraries and reworking the public API, here are the key considerations regarding licensing, rebranding, and attribution: ### Licensing 1. **Can you license the resulting library under Apache 2.0?** - Yes, you can license your resulting library under Apache 2.0. MIT is a permissive li...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "There are two libraries under MIT, that do the same thing, each with some pros and cons. I'd like to merge them, effectively reworking the public API, but keeping the underlying logic (code). The resulting library should be part of my framework that is currently licensed under a...
As far as I understand, the GPL is a license with an incredibly strong copyleft trait. That is, anything that even links to it, let alone modify it, needs to be released under the GPL. Due to this 'viral' nature of the license, some people and organizations have made exceptions. One notable one is the class path except...
The distinction between the GPL with the Class Path Exception (CPE) and the LGPL (Lesser General Public License) primarily comes down to the conditions regarding the modification and redistribution of the library itself, as well as the intent behind the two licenses. 1. **General Purpose and Intent**: - The **GPL**...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "As far as I understand, the GPL is a license with an incredibly strong copyleft trait. That is, anything that even links to it, let alone modify it, needs to be released under the GPL. Due to this 'viral' nature of the license, some people and organizations have made exceptions....
I've decided to license some code I have yet to release under the GPL v3. However, OpenSSL is used quite a bit in the software and I know that the two licenses are explicitly cited as being incompatible. I wanted to stay with my decision to go GPL but without having to refactor years of work to use something like GNU T...
Adding an exception to the GPL v3 license that allows linking with OpenSSL can be a pragmatic approach if you want to maintain your software under the GPL while still utilizing OpenSSL. Here’s a detailed look at the implications of this practice and whether it "works": ### Understanding License Compatibility 1. **GPL...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I've decided to license some code I have yet to release under the GPL v3. However, OpenSSL is used quite a bit in the software and I know that the two licenses are explicitly cited as being incompatible.\nI wanted to stay with my decision to go GPL but without having to refactor...
I always see these tags in the issues and pull requests on Github but do not know the meaning and find it hard to search for. For example, in this famous Caffe project.
In GitHub projects like Caffe, tags (also known as labels) are used to categorize and organize issues and pull requests. Here’s a breakdown of common tags you might encounter and their typical meanings: 1. **Bug**: Indicates that there is a problem or error in the code that needs to be fixed. 2. **Feature**: Suggests...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I always see these tags in the issues and pull requests on Github but do not know the meaning and find it hard to search for.\nFor example, in this famous Caffe project.\n" }, { "from": "gpt", "value": "In GitHub projects like Caffe, tags (also known as labels) are u...
Suppose you are a land owner. You own a large piece of land containing lots of amazing fossils and other important pieces of history. To share this with the world you decide you want to allow ANYONE to come and discover the history on your property. My question: EDIT Could you apply an open source license such as CC-BY...
Applying an open-source license like Creative Commons (CC-BY) to physical artifacts, such as fossils and historical items found on your property, is not straightforward. Here are a few key points to consider: 1. **Ownership and Legal Rights**: As the landowner, you have ownership rights over the physical land and any ...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "Suppose you are a land owner. You own a large piece of land containing lots of amazing fossils and other important pieces of history. To share this with the world you decide you want to allow ANYONE to come and discover the history on your property.\nMy question:\nEDIT\nCould yo...
I'm thinking about an example of a popular piece of software to illustrate the difference between Free Software and Open Source Software. ANTLRv4 is an Open Source project and provides an online documentation sufficient to get started with the project, but mastering it requires to read the ANTLR 4 Definitive Reference....
Your interpretation raises an interesting point about the distinction between Free Software and Open Source Software, especially in relation to documentation. The Free Software Foundation (FSF) defines Free Software as software that gives users the freedom to run, modify, and share it. One of the key aspects of Free S...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I'm thinking about an example of a popular piece of software to illustrate the difference between Free Software and Open Source Software.\nANTLRv4 is an Open Source project and provides an online documentation sufficient to get started with the project, but mastering it requires...
Teaching materials like textbooks or work sheets can be opened up to free redistribution and free change for everyone. What risks does the publisher face, then deciding to do so? Are there legal consequences?
When a publisher decides to release teaching materials, such as textbooks or worksheets, with an open license that allows for free redistribution and modification, they may encounter several risks and potential legal consequences: 1. **Loss of Revenue**: One of the most immediate risks is the potential loss of revenue...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "Teaching materials like textbooks or work sheets can be opened up to free redistribution and free change for everyone. What risks does the publisher face, then deciding to do so? Are there legal consequences?\n" }, { "from": "gpt", "value": "When a publisher decides ...
I am creating an open source project and I want to use an MIT license for that. I have found this page: http://choosealicense.com/licenses/mit/ What should I write under "full name"? Should the group of people, that I am working with be registered as a company? If I am the head developer, and other people are freelance...
When using the MIT License for your open-source project, here are the key points to consider for filling out the license template: 1. **Full Name**: You can write your own name if you are the primary developer and responsible for the project. If your team is not a registered company, it's perfectly acceptable to use y...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I am creating an open source project and I want to use an MIT license for that. I have found this page: http://choosealicense.com/licenses/mit/\nWhat should I write under \"full name\"? Should the group of people, that I am working with be registered as a company? If I am the he...
What issues are involved when taking code from (for example) MIT licensed code and including it in a Apache 2.0/GPLv3 licensed project. Does that mean that there is simply no patent license granted? Is that situation any different from going from LGPLv2.1/GPLv2+ to GPLv3?
When combining code from different open source licenses, it’s important to understand the terms and compatibility of those licenses. Here’s a breakdown of the issues involved with MIT licensed code and Apache 2.0/GPLv3 licensed projects, as well as a comparison between LGPLv2.1/GPLv2+ to GPLv3. ### Combining MIT Licen...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "What issues are involved when taking code from (for example) MIT licensed code and including it in a Apache 2.0/GPLv3 licensed project.\nDoes that mean that there is simply no patent license granted?\nIs that situation any different from going from LGPLv2.1/GPLv2+ to GPLv3?\n" ...
If I contribute some code to an open source project, ought I to continue to work on that project? If I don't have the time to continue as a regular contributor, should I avoid starting? As an analogy, charities seeking funding often state that one off donations are not useful and they prefer a fixed ongoing regular pay...
Contributing to open source projects can be a rewarding experience, both for personal growth and for the community. However, whether or not to continue contributing after an initial contribution depends on a few factors: 1. **Project Needs**: Open source projects often thrive on ongoing contributions, but they also we...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "If I contribute some code to an open source project, ought I to continue to work on that project? If I don't have the time to continue as a regular contributor, should I avoid starting?\nAs an analogy, charities seeking funding often state that one off donations are not useful a...
I'm extending an open source library written in Java released under the BSD License. That library has a class, let's call it Utils, that exposes a lot of static methods. The common use case is to import all the exposed methods in a static import, i.e. import static org.acme.Utils.*; Now, I'm creating new functions in ...
In this situation, you need to consider a few important aspects regarding the licensing and Java's class inheritance model. ### Licensing Since the library from acme is released under the BSD License, you are allowed to extend it and create a new library. The BSD License is quite permissive, allowing modification and...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I'm extending an open source library written in Java released under the BSD License. That library has a class, let's call it Utils, that exposes a lot of static methods. The common use case is to import all the exposed methods in a static import, i.e.\nimport static org.acme.Uti...
When contributing to an open source project that uses pull requests exclusively for contributions, I'm left wondering when a good time is for me to send a pull request. I'm especially in doubt when it come to implementing rather major features, should I implement the entire feature on my fork and only push upstream whe...
When contributing to an open-source project that utilizes pull requests (PRs) for contributions, finding the right balance for when to submit your PR can indeed be challenging. Here are some guidelines and considerations to help you make that decision: ### General Guidelines: 1. **Start Small**: If you're uncertain a...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "When contributing to an open source project that uses pull requests exclusively for contributions, I'm left wondering when a good time is for me to send a pull request.\nI'm especially in doubt when it come to implementing rather major features, should I implement the entire fea...
I'm a scientist that's a self-taught programmer. I've worked on several open source projects before, but the developers gave me a better idea on what to work on. This guy just sent me a link to github and told me to go for it. There's no README and most of the bugs are front-end (which I don't have much experience with...
It's great to hear that you're excited about contributing to an open source project! Here are some steps you can take to get started effectively and make a meaningful contribution, even with limited front-end experience: ### 1. **Familiarize Yourself with the Project** - **Explore the Repository:** Spend some time na...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I'm a scientist that's a self-taught programmer. I've worked on several open source projects before, but the developers gave me a better idea on what to work on. This guy just sent me a link to github and told me to go for it. There's no README and most of the bugs are front-end...
The Open Source Initiative has created the Open Source Definition to define what open source is. Also it has set up a formal process to approve licenses to be open source. Now, does a license need this formal approval to be an open source license or is conforming with the definition enough?
A license does not need formal approval from the Open Source Initiative (OSI) to be considered an open source license, but it must conform to the Open Source Definition (OSD) to be recognized as such. The OSI's approval process serves as a way to provide a stamp of approval for licenses that meet their criteria and to ...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "The Open Source Initiative has created the Open Source Definition to define what open source is. Also it has set up a formal process to approve licenses to be open source. Now, does a license need this formal approval to be an open source license or is conforming with the defini...
What are the shortcomings of CC0 in comparison with Public Domain? for author of work? for users? for those who modify/extend/change license of original work?
CC0, or Creative Commons Zero, is a public domain dedication tool that allows creators to waive all their rights and place their work in the public domain. While it provides many benefits, it also has shortcomings when compared to traditional public domain status. Here are the shortcomings of CC0 from different perspec...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "What are the shortcomings of CC0 in comparison with Public Domain?\n\nfor author of work? \nfor users? \nfor those who modify/extend/change license of original work? \n\n" }, { "from": "gpt", "value": "CC0, or Creative Commons Zero, is a public domain dedica...
I have a 3d printer that I use to print some models. There is a model I like that is licensed in Creative Commons under the Attribution - Non-Commercial - Share Alike license. I am not sure what "Commercial purposes" are. My questions are: Can I sell it? (I guess the answer is no) If someone wants me to print a model...
You're right to consider the implications of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike (CC BY-NC-SA) license for the model you want to print. Here are answers to your questions based on the terms of that license: 1. **Can I sell it?** No, you cannot sell the model or any prints made from it, as th...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I have a 3d printer that I use to print some models. There is a model I like that is licensed in Creative Commons under the Attribution - Non-Commercial - Share Alike license.\nI am not sure what \"Commercial purposes\" are.\nMy questions are:\n\nCan I sell it? (I guess the answ...
The authors of a free/libre work can change the license of their work any time, and they can even make it non-free again. This does not affect copies that were made before that change (and any further copies from that "branch"), so I may still use/modify/distribute it according the original license. Let’s assume the a...
Proving that a work was originally published under a specific license can be challenging if the authors later remove all references to that license and prevent access to archived versions of their website. However, there are several strategies you can employ to document and safeguard your evidence: 1. **Maintain Copie...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "The authors of a free/libre work can change the license of their work any time, and they can even make it non-free again. \nThis does not affect copies that were made before that change (and any further copies from that \"branch\"), so I may still use/modify/distribute it accord...
I recently modified software code licensed under EPL v1.0. Can I remove the original copyright and add my own copyright ?
No, you cannot remove the original copyright from software licensed under the Eclipse Public License (EPL) v1.0. When you modify software that is licensed under this license, you must retain the original copyright notice and provide appropriate attribution to the original authors. EPL v1.0 allows you to modify the co...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I recently modified software code licensed under EPL v1.0. Can I remove the original copyright and add my own copyright ?\n" }, { "from": "gpt", "value": "No, you cannot remove the original copyright from software licensed under the Eclipse Public License (EPL) v1.0....
Does open source clothing exists? With that I mean, do sewing patterns, tutorials or steering files for sewing and weaving machines, that are licensed as open source exist? Meaning these patterns, tutorials and steering files can be freely changed and redistributed? Is it even possible to open source clothing?
Yes, open source clothing does exist, and there is a growing movement around it. Open source clothing typically involves the sharing of sewing patterns, tutorials, and other resources under licenses that allow them to be freely modified and redistributed. Here are some key aspects of open source clothing: 1. **Sewing ...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "Does open source clothing exists? With that I mean, do sewing patterns, tutorials or steering files for sewing and weaving machines, that are licensed as open source exist? Meaning these patterns, tutorials and steering files can be freely changed and redistributed? Is it even p...
The GNU GPL is very long. If I have to include a copy of it with my program, can I drop the preamble to save space?
The GNU General Public License (GPL) is designed to ensure that users have the freedom to use, modify, and distribute software. When it comes to including a copy of the GPL with your program, it is important to adhere to the license's requirements. According to the terms of the GPL, you are required to provide a full ...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "The GNU GPL is very long. If I have to include a copy of it with my program, can I drop the preamble to save space?\n" }, { "from": "gpt", "value": "The GNU General Public License (GPL) is designed to ensure that users have the freedom to use, modify, and distribute ...
If I compose a piece of music using instruments and sound effects that I don't own the copyright to (but am licensed to use), can I release my composition under a free/open license that allows derivatives, without violating one of the two: The free license that allows derivations, or My license to the instruments / so...
This is a complex legal issue involving copyright law and licensing agreements. Here are some key points to consider regarding your situation: ### 1. Ownership of Composition vs. Sound Samples: - When you create a musical composition using sound samples or instruments that you are licensed to use, you typically own th...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "If I compose a piece of music using instruments and sound effects that I don't own the copyright to (but am licensed to use), can I release my composition under a free/open license that allows derivatives, without violating one of the two:\n\nThe free license that allows derivat...
Can a project be licensed as "open source", yet place a restriction on who can utilize the software? For example, if my software falls under software export controls, can I continue to license it as "open"?
Yes, a project can be licensed as "open source" while placing certain restrictions on its use, including compliance with export control laws. However, it's important to note that doing so can complicate the classification of the software as "open source" under the definitions provided by organizations like the Open Sou...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "Can a project be licensed as \"open source\", yet place a restriction on who can utilize the software?\nFor example, if my software falls under software export controls, can I continue to license it as \"open\"?\n" }, { "from": "gpt", "value": "Yes, a project can be ...
Codehaus shut down earlier this year. Many projects that were hosted there, including JIRA pages like this one, are now broken. What can I do to access all the lost content of projects that were hosted in Codehaus, such as bug reports? Was it uploaded/dumped somewhere? Further, since Google Code is also shutting down, ...
The shutdown of platforms like Codehaus and Google Code can indeed lead to the loss of valuable content, including bug reports, documentation, and project history. Here's how you can potentially access lost content and prevent further data loss: ### Accessing Lost Content from Codehaus 1. **Internet Archive (Wayback ...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "Codehaus shut down earlier this year. Many projects that were hosted there, including JIRA pages like this one, are now broken.\nWhat can I do to access all the lost content of projects that were hosted in Codehaus, such as bug reports? Was it uploaded/dumped somewhere?\nFurther...
As a follow up from GPL V3 with OpenSSL Exception, I'm curious about linking an LGPLv3 project with a GPLv3 project that has a special exception for OpenSSL. In the answer to the aforementioned question, it was stated: Note, however, that you can only add exceptions to work for which you have copyright control. If y...
Linking an LGPLv3-licensed library with a GPLv3-licensed project (even one with OpenSSL exceptions) involves a few important considerations regarding license compatibility and obligations: 1. **Understanding LGPLv3 and GPLv3**: The GNU Lesser General Public License (LGPL) is designed to allow developers to link to lib...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "As a follow up from GPL V3 with OpenSSL Exception, I'm curious about linking an LGPLv3 project with a GPLv3 project that has a special exception for OpenSSL. In the answer to the aforementioned question, it was stated:\n\nNote, however, that you can only add exceptions to work f...
Suppose I am finishing an open source software. I am about to publish it but I just have to choose the license. I want it to be a CC-BY license but I don't want anyone to republish it under ANY other license. My question: How do I stop future users from just publishing it under any other license? I've also just found ...
If you want to prevent users from republishing your open-source software under any other license, a Creative Commons (CC) license, including CC BY, would not be suitable. Creative Commons licenses are primarily designed for creative works like text, art, and music, not software, and they generally allow for more flexib...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "Suppose I am finishing an open source software. I am about to publish it but I just have to choose the license. I want it to be a CC-BY license but I don't want anyone to republish it under ANY other license.\nMy question:\nHow do I stop future users from just publishing it unde...
I was looking to override a class in rt.jar with my own version (to guarantee that existing legacy code remains unbroken). With Oracle's JDK, it says the following for the -Xbootclasspath/p:path option: Do not deploy applications that use this option to override a class in rt.jar, because this violates the JRE binary ...
Yes, if you switch to OpenJDK, you will still face similar limitations regarding the use of boot classpath options to override classes in the Java runtime environment (JRE), including those in `rt.jar`. While OpenJDK is an open-source implementation of the Java Platform, it still adheres to the same fundamental princip...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I was looking to override a class in rt.jar with my own version (to guarantee that existing legacy code remains unbroken).\nWith Oracle's JDK, it says the following for the -Xbootclasspath/p:path option:\n\nDo not deploy applications that use this option to override a class in r...
Throughout the development of programming itself which came first: open sourced or closed source? Which was more popular? Or did one come after the other?
The development of programming and software can be traced back to the early days of computing in the 1950s and 1960s. In this early era, the concept of software as a commercial product was not well established, and most software was developed for specific systems and shared freely among users. The notion of "closed sou...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "Throughout the development of programming itself which came first: open sourced or closed source? Which was more popular? Or did one come after the other?\n" }, { "from": "gpt", "value": "The development of programming and software can be traced back to the early day...
GPL 3 allows adding additional clauses, such as exceptions, as long as such exceptions grant additional privileges. But if I distribute software under GPL 3 with exceptions, are those exceptions required to be preserved, or are downstream distributors free to remove those exceptions, leaving the license as GPL 3 only? ...
When you distribute software under GPL version 3 with additional exceptions, those exceptions are part of the licensing terms that you provide. Here are key points regarding the exceptions: 1. **Nature of Exceptions**: Exceptions you add to the GPL 3 license are meant to provide additional permissions or clarify certa...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "GPL 3 allows adding additional clauses, such as exceptions, as long as such exceptions grant additional privileges. But if I distribute software under GPL 3 with exceptions, are those exceptions required to be preserved, or are downstream distributors free to remove those except...
I was wondering if there was a software license that has the same requirements as the Creative Commons BY-NC-SA 4.0 since they do not recommend its use for software. I looked on choosealicense.com but it seems no license fit these requirements : I know some people do not consider this as open-source, but I personally c...
If you're looking for a software license that aligns with the conditions of the Creative Commons BY-NC-SA 4.0 (Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike) but is more tailored for software, you might consider a few alternatives: 1. **GNU General Public License v3.0 (GPL-3.0) with a NonCommercial Clause**: While the GPL itse...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I was wondering if there was a software license that has the same requirements as the Creative Commons BY-NC-SA 4.0 since they do not recommend its use for software.\nI looked on choosealicense.com but it seems no license fit these requirements :\nI know some people do not consi...
While most operating systems have a closed source nature, from the beginning Linux / Ubuntu has remain open sourced. This has allowed it to become quite popular. My question: How has it used open source to its advantage? And what has keeping it open sourced allowed it to do, that it otherwise wouldn't?
Linux and distributions like Ubuntu have leveraged their open-source nature to gain several significant advantages. Here are some key aspects of how being open source has benefitted Linux and Ubuntu: 1. **Community Collaboration**: Open source allows developers from all over the world to contribute to the Linux kernel...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "While most operating systems have a closed source nature, from the beginning Linux / Ubuntu has remain open sourced. This has allowed it to become quite popular. \nMy question:\nHow has it used open source to its advantage? And what has keeping it open sourced allowed it to do, ...
When using an R package, for example in a commercial application, it seems to me that it is not sufficient to check the licenses of the package's imports, but also the licenses of the imports' imports (and so on). For example, dplyr imports assertthat. dplyr has an MIT license, whereas assertthat is GPL-3. If I underst...
Yes, you are correct in your understanding. When you use an R package, you need to be mindful of the licenses not just of the package you are using, but also of its dependencies (including both direct dependencies and transitive dependencies). Here’s a breakdown of how licensing works in this context: 1. **Direct Depe...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "When using an R package, for example in a commercial application, it seems to me that it is not sufficient to check the licenses of the package's imports, but also the licenses of the imports' imports (and so on). For example, dplyr imports assertthat. dplyr has an MIT license, ...
Dalvik was licensed under the ASL on the premise that it was reverse engineered: Licensing and patents Main article: Oracle v. Google Dalvik is published under the terms of the Apache License 2.0.[18] Google says that Dalvik is a clean-room implementation rather than a development on top of a standard Java runtime...
As of now, the Android Runtime (ART) is also licensed under the Apache License 2.0, similar to Dalvik. When ART was introduced in Android 4.4 (KitKat) as a replacement for Dalvik, it continued to follow an open-source licensing model, allowing developers to use, modify, and distribute the software under the same terms....
[ { "from": "human", "value": "Dalvik was licensed under the ASL on the premise that it was reverse engineered:\n\nLicensing and patents Main article: Oracle v. Google\nDalvik is published under the terms of the Apache License 2.0.[18]\n Google says that Dalvik is a clean-room implementation rather than a\n ...
I want to publish a lot of documentation on programming and other similar topics I have been writing over the years. The documentation consist of explanations, diagrams, exercises and code examples. At this moment most of the content is my own, with some contributions from people who I personally know. My requirements ...
Given your requirements, the **Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike (CC BY-SA)** license could be a suitable choice for your documentation. Here’s how it aligns with your needs: 1. **Free License**: CC BY-SA is a free license, allowing anyone to use, share, and adapt your work. 2. **Copyleft**: The ShareAlike aspe...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I want to publish a lot of documentation on programming and other similar topics I have been writing over the years.\nThe documentation consist of explanations, diagrams, exercises and code examples.\nAt this moment most of the content is my own, with some contributions from peo...
I would like to use an image in the cover page of a paid book. The image is first published in Wikimedia and it is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 Unported license. I would like to self-publish the book. Should I change the license of the whole book to the same as the image or just put a...
When using an image licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 Unported license in your book, you need to adhere to the terms of that license. Here are the key points to consider: 1. **Attribution**: You must give appropriate credit to the original creator of the image. This typically includes the...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I would like to use an image in the cover page of a paid book.\nThe image is first published in Wikimedia and it is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 Unported license.\nI would like to self-publish the book. Should I change the license of the whole ...
While reading through the GPL FAQ I found some relevant points to the question, however it is still unclear to me if this fully applies to a public gameserver. I'll try to keep it short: There is a gameserver A, fully available, including source code, published under the GPL. There is a modified gameserver B, based on ...
Your question touches on a nuanced aspect of the GPL (GNU General Public License) and its implications for modified software running on a public game server. ### Key Points: 1. **Definition of "Release":** The GPL considers a modification to be "released" when it is made available to the public, which includes mak...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "While reading through the GPL FAQ I found some relevant points to the question, however it is still unclear to me if this fully applies to a public gameserver.\nI'll try to keep it short:\nThere is a gameserver A, fully available, including source code, published under the GPL.\...
I've written my first app, to process images (user photos) on the phone. It writes to the jpegs on the phone, and maybe I'll add functionality to delete selected images. Do I need to protect myself somehow against any liability, if someone experiences unintentional loss of data, say due to some software bug/error? If...
Congratulations on developing your first app! It's an exciting achievement, and you're right to consider the implications of liability when it comes to data processing applications. ### Liability Considerations 1. **Data Loss and Liability**: If your app processes images and has the potential to overwrite or delete u...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I've written my first app, to process images (user photos) on the phone. It writes to the jpegs on the phone, and maybe I'll add functionality to delete selected images. \nDo I need to protect myself somehow against any liability, if someone experiences unintentional loss of dat...
If you notice the following scaffold starter kit source code is licensed under MIT throughout the code base. Even the configuration file contain a header of MIT licensed by the creator. Assuming, I have already written my application code and did some changes on the application config. How should I properly create a LI...
When you create an application based on a scaffold starter kit that is licensed under the MIT license, you can certainly retain your own copyright and license terms for the original application code that you have written, but you must also adhere to the terms of the MIT license for the portions of the code that you did...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "If you notice the following scaffold starter kit source code is licensed under MIT throughout the code base. Even the configuration file contain a header of MIT licensed by the creator.\nAssuming, I have already written my application code and did some changes on the application...
I'm interested in a license that says something like "After the 1st of January 2020, you may distribute this work under the terms of the GPL v3" (or some other open source license). I'm interested in developing software products and keeping a limited period of monopoly for commercial exploitation, but granting people o...
What you're describing is a form of license that grants limited rights to users during a certain time frame, after which the work would be open-sourced under specific terms, such as the GPL v3. While there isn't a widely recognized existing license that fits this exact model, you can consider a few approaches to achiev...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I'm interested in a license that says something like \"After the 1st of January 2020, you may distribute this work under the terms of the GPL v3\" (or some other open source license). I'm interested in developing software products and keeping a limited period of monopoly for com...
The well-known MIT (or "X11/MIT" license reads): Permission is hereby granted, free of charge, to any person obtaining a copy of this software and associated documentation files (the "Software"), to deal in the Software without restriction, including without limitation the rights to use, copy, modify, merge, publish, ...
The warranty disclaimer and limitations of liability in the MIT License serve specific legal purposes, helping to protect the authors and copyright holders from potential liability arising from the use of the software. Here's a breakdown of your questions regarding modifying the license text: 1. **Do you really need t...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "The well-known MIT (or \"X11/MIT\" license reads):\n\nPermission is hereby granted, free of charge, to any person obtaining a copy of this software and associated documentation files (the \"Software\"), to deal in the Software without restriction, including without limitation th...
I searched all over the Internet but I was not able to find if anyone has raised this issue. I want to edit some files in an open source sample project provided by Google (change some methods and the package name of all the files), and then deploy the app on the Play Store. I have the following questions: Can I do thi...
Yes, you can edit the files in the open source sample project provided by Google and deploy the app on the Play Store, as long as you comply with the terms of the Apache License 2.0. Here are answers to your specific questions: 1. **Can I do this?** - Yes, you can modify the code, change methods, and alter the pac...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I searched all over the Internet but I was not able to find if anyone has raised this issue. I want to edit some files in an open source sample project provided by Google (change some methods and the package name of all the files), and then deploy the app on the Play Store.\nI h...
I use closed-source scientific software for my work. I also use GPL licensed tools and libraries. It would save me a lot of time to be able to call a GPL library directly from the closed-source software. The closed-source program can be extended with "plugins" that are written in C, run as a separate process, but ne...
Your questions about using GPL-licensed libraries in a closed-source environment touch on several important aspects of the GPL (General Public License) and how it interacts with closed-source software. Here's a breakdown of your queries: ### 1. Can I write a plugin to interface the closed-source software with the GPL ...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I use closed-source scientific software for my work. I also use GPL licensed tools and libraries. It would save me a lot of time to be able to call a GPL library directly from the closed-source software. The closed-source program can be extended with \"plugins\" that are writ...
I'm thinking about an example of a popular piece of software to illustrate the difference between Free Software and Open Source Software. ANTLRv4 is an Open Source project and provides an online documentation sufficient to get started with the project, but mastering it requires to read the ANTLR 4 Definitive Reference....
You raise an interesting point about the distinction between Free Software and Open Source Software, particularly in relation to documentation. The Free Software Definition, as maintained by the Free Software Foundation (FSF), emphasizes not just the freedom to use, modify, and redistribute the software itself, but als...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I'm thinking about an example of a popular piece of software to illustrate the difference between Free Software and Open Source Software.\nANTLRv4 is an Open Source project and provides an online documentation sufficient to get started with the project, but mastering it requires...
For my OSS project, is it a good idea to release the "brand assets" under a CC license? I want to make it easy for people to use the logo for blogs/articles talking about the product and derivatives for forks of the project, but I also want to keep some restriction on it so it doesn't look like the official project is ...
Releasing brand assets, such as logos, under a Creative Commons (CC) license can be a nuanced decision, especially if you want to maintain some control over how those assets are used. Here are some considerations and suggestions based on your situation: ### Using a Creative Commons License: 1. **CC Attribution (BY)**:...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "For my OSS project, is it a good idea to release the \"brand assets\" under a CC license?\nI want to make it easy for people to use the logo for blogs/articles talking about the product and derivatives for forks of the project, but I also want to keep some restriction on it so i...
I'm writing a library and a tool on top of it, and I would like to release both under MPL-2. However, the library has an optional dependency, another library which is released under GPL (not LGPL). I understand that the result of this combination will be under GPL, but I want to allow using my library and tool under co...
When combining code licensed under different licenses such as MPL-2 (Mozilla Public License 2.0) and GPL (GNU General Public License), it's important to clearly understand how these licenses interact and the implications for your library and tool. ### Key Points to Consider 1. **MPL-2 and GPL Compatibility**: MPL-2 i...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I'm writing a library and a tool on top of it, and I would like to release both under MPL-2. However, the library has an optional dependency, another library which is released under GPL (not LGPL).\nI understand that the result of this combination will be under GPL, but I want t...
I'm developing an application using iText. iText, unless a commercial license is purchased, forces you to abide by the AGPL. My plan is to sell commercial pre-compiled copies of my software at a small cost, while leaving the source code on github for those technically adept to compile it themselves. Is this legal? Also...
Using iText under the AGPL (GNU Affero General Public License) entails some specific obligations, particularly when it comes to distribution of software that incorporates iText. Here’s a breakdown of your situation: 1. **AGPL Requirements**: The AGPL requires that if you distribute a modified version of the software (...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I'm developing an application using iText. iText, unless a commercial license is purchased, forces you to abide by the AGPL. My plan is to sell commercial pre-compiled copies of my software at a small cost, while leaving the source code on github for those technically adept to c...
Does anyone know what the license is for Mondor's MS Captcha? The only information that I could find on their site was: "License MS Captcha is free to use in any kind of projects. The software is licensed, not sold." What would be the equivalent of this statement in terms of the existing Open Source licenses out th...
Based on the statement "MS Captcha is free to use in any kind of projects. The software is licensed, not sold," it suggests that the software can be freely used, which is a common feature of open-source licenses. However, the phrase "the software is licensed, not sold" implies that there may be some restrictions or ter...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "Does anyone know what the license is for Mondor's MS Captcha? The only information that I could find on their site was:\n\n\"License\n MS Captcha is free to use in any kind of projects. The software is licensed, not sold.\"\n\nWhat would be the equivalent of this statement in t...
Is there any point in complying with the licence which comes with a project published anonymously (like the initial Bitcoin source code)? If so, in case of breaking the rules of your license, who has the right to enforce the aspects of a license if nobody takes the ownership of the project? So basically, can you do wha...
When it comes to software licenses, including those associated with projects published anonymously, there are several important points to consider: 1. **Licensing Compliance**: Even if a project is published anonymously, the license that accompanies it still carries legal weight. Compliance with the terms of the licen...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "Is there any point in complying with the licence which comes with a project published anonymously (like the initial Bitcoin source code)?\nIf so, in case of breaking the rules of your license, who has the right to enforce the aspects of a license if nobody takes the ownership of...
While I'm searching for a new project to start contributing to, I often check the daily email I get from GitHub that lists the most popular repositories of the day and also the repositories starred by the people I follow. So, should I star my own repositories once I create them so it would appear in the daily digest f...
Starring your own repositories on GitHub can be seen as a gray area in terms of ethics and community norms. Here are some considerations to keep in mind: 1. **Authenticity**: The purpose of starring a repository is to signify that you find it useful, interesting, or worthy of attention. By starring your own project, y...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "While I'm searching for a new project to start contributing to, I often check the daily email I get from GitHub that lists the most popular repositories of the day and also the repositories starred by the people I follow. \nSo, should I star my own repositories once I create the...
Can an open source project undergo a hostile takeover? That is, the current project has an active community and an active BDFL, but some individual or group wants to take over the project. Also, does the BDFL being female or non-white or another discriminated against group affect the likelihood of such a thing happenin...
The concept of a "hostile takeover" in open source projects can be complex, and while it might not fit the traditional corporate model of hostile takeovers, the dynamics of community-driven projects can lead to situations where an individual or group attempts to take control or influence a project against the will of i...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "Can an open source project undergo a hostile takeover? That is, the current project has an active community and an active BDFL, but some individual or group wants to take over the project.\nAlso, does the BDFL being female or non-white or another discriminated against group affe...
The text of the GPLv3 starts with the following disclaimer: Everyone is permitted to copy and distribute verbatim copies of this license document, but changing it is not allowed. What does this mean? The text of the GPL itself isn't open source? Will the FSF sue me in court if I change the text of the GPL and relea...
The disclaimer at the beginning of the GNU General Public License version 3 (GPLv3) is specifically stating that while you are free to copy and distribute the license itself, you are not allowed to modify the text of the license. This means that the GPLv3 is not open to alterations; it must remain in its original form....
[ { "from": "human", "value": "The text of the GPLv3 starts with the following disclaimer:\n\nEveryone is permitted to copy and distribute verbatim copies of this\n license document, but changing it is not allowed.\n\nWhat does this mean? The text of the GPL itself isn't open source? Will the FSF sue me in c...
I want to write a plugin for an open-source software which is not GPL, but has a GPL-compatible license (MIT/BSD). I would like the plugin to use a GPL library. Can I do this? My rationale: Since the plugin links with a GPL library, the plugin is of course also GPL, which is fine. In order to comply with GPL, all the ...
Your reasoning is generally on the right track, but there are some important nuances to consider regarding the licensing of your plugin. 1. **GPL Compatibility**: Since the plugin depends on a GPL library, the GPL license will impose restrictions on your plugin. When you link against a GPL library, your plugin must al...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I want to write a plugin for an open-source software which is not GPL, but has a GPL-compatible license (MIT/BSD). I would like the plugin to use a GPL library.\nCan I do this?\nMy rationale:\n\nSince the plugin links with a GPL library, the plugin is of course also GPL, which i...
I want to release my WPF Media Element based on FFmpeg on GitHub. I want to be as permissive as possible. I believe that this control could be of great help to a ton of people. Here are the links to the licenses. Hopefully someone can help me out. FFmpeg build by Zeranoe Says all builds on this page are licensed as ...
When it comes to licensing your WPF Media Element that utilizes FFmpeg and other libraries, you need to carefully consider the licenses of the dependencies and how they affect your own code. Here's a breakdown of the licenses involved and how they might impact your release: 1. **FFmpeg (GPL 3.0)**: If you are using a ...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I want to release my WPF Media Element based on FFmpeg on GitHub. I want to be as permissive as possible. I believe that this control could be of great help to a ton of people. Here are the links to the licenses. Hopefully someone can help me out. \n\nFFmpeg build by Zeranoe\n\n...
Are there any rough estimates of the total number of person-hours that have been spent on writing FLOSS software? (paid and volunteer)
Estimating the total number of person-hours spent on Free/Libre and Open Source Software (FLOSS) development is challenging due to the decentralized and often informal nature of contributions. However, several studies and analyses have attempted to provide rough estimates. 1. **Studies and Reports**: Some research pap...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "Are there any rough estimates of the total number of person-hours that have been spent on writing FLOSS software? (paid and volunteer)\n" }, { "from": "gpt", "value": "Estimating the total number of person-hours spent on Free/Libre and Open Source Software (FLOSS) de...
My question is: where lies the border for a programmer to copyright new software when in GNU/linux basically everything is released on very restrictive licences that force you to copyleft your work? The thing i need to know the most right now is: Bash is licensed under GNU GPL v3+, if I write a software with it do i ho...
The copyright landscape for software developed using components licensed under the GNU General Public License (GPL), like Bash, can be complex. Here are the key points to help you understand your rights and obligations: 1. **Copyright Basics**: As the author of a piece of software, you hold the copyright to your origi...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "My question is: where lies the border for a programmer to copyright new software when in GNU/linux basically everything is released on very restrictive licences that force you to copyleft your work?\nThe thing i need to know the most right now is:\nBash is licensed under GNU GPL...
As I understood in this wonderful answer, GPLv3 and GPLv2 code can't be used simultanously in the same product. Why?
The reason GPLv3 and GPLv2 code generally cannot be used simultaneously in the same product lies in the fundamental differences in the licensing terms and conditions of the two versions of the GNU General Public License. 1. **Compatibility**: GPLv2 and GPLv3 have different requirements regarding things like patent rig...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "As I understood in this wonderful answer, GPLv3 and GPLv2 code can't be used simultanously in the same product.\nWhy?\n" }, { "from": "gpt", "value": "The reason GPLv3 and GPLv2 code generally cannot be used simultaneously in the same product lies in the fundamental ...
My employer has given me to permission to open source a component of a project that I have been working on, allowing me to retain ownership and control, with the condition that they be acknowledged in some way. This open source tool would be hosted on GitHub, as part of a larger collection of tools in an existing coll...
Acknowledging your employer in an open source project is a thoughtful gesture, and it can indeed be done in a few different ways. Here are some common practices and options for acknowledgment that you can consider: ### 1. License Text While most open source licenses (like MIT, GPL, etc.) have standard language that do...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "My employer has given me to permission to open source a component of a project that I have been working on, allowing me to retain ownership and control, with the condition that they be acknowledged in some way. This open source tool would be hosted on GitHub, as part of a large...
I have some small projects under different open source licenses (I like BSD and GPLv2). I would like to license some new projects under an OSI approved license but make sure any other OSI-approved license can use too. Assume all the code is owned by me (or I can get the consent of all the copyright owners). Does it su...
What you're looking for is a licensing approach that allows others to choose their own OSI-approved licenses while ensuring that your code remains compatible with a broad spectrum of other open source projects. While your suggestion of using the BSD license and stating that the code can be used under any OSI-approved l...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I have some small projects under different open source licenses (I like BSD and GPLv2). \nI would like to license some new projects under an OSI approved license but make sure any other OSI-approved license can use too. Assume all the code is owned by me (or I can get the consen...
Sourceforge was once the number one in project hosting for open source projects. But things have changed. And some things Sourceforge does are worrying. The adware injected into binaries of Open-Source-projects is indeed not worthy of an OSS-hoster. Now github or Google Code seem like good alternatives. The question I ...
Your concerns about project hosting platforms are valid, especially given the evolution of Sourceforge and its approach to monetization over the years. When it comes to alternative platforms like GitHub and Google Code (which has since been archived and is no longer active), there are several factors to consider in ter...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "Sourceforge was once the number one in project hosting for open source projects. But things have changed. And some things Sourceforge does are worrying. The adware injected into binaries of Open-Source-projects is indeed not worthy of an OSS-hoster.\nNow github or Google Code se...
By a quick count, wikipedia lists almost fifty different open source / free software licenses. Assuming (and this may not be valid) that many of these licenses were created in the early days of the movement, when it was trying to settle on common conventions, why do they all persist? Given the seeming ideological split...
The persistence of a wide variety of open source and free software licenses can be attributed to several factors: 1. **Historical Context and Evolution**: Many licenses were developed in response to specific projects, philosophies, or legal contexts. As the software movement evolved, different communities and projects...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "By a quick count, wikipedia lists almost fifty different open source / free software licenses.\nAssuming (and this may not be valid) that many of these licenses were created in the early days of the movement, when it was trying to settle on common conventions, why do they all pe...
The scenario is the following: a proprietary software can save files in its own file format. I want to build a free/open-source software capable of decoding those files for further processing. Given that there is no documentation for the file format, I create a few files and reverse engineer them. After experimenting w...
Your scenario raises several important legal considerations regarding software development and reverse engineering. Here's a breakdown of the key factors: 1. **Reverse Engineering and Copyright**: In many jurisdictions, reverse engineering for interoperability purposes can be allowed under certain conditions. If you a...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "The scenario is the following: a proprietary software can save files in its own file format. I want to build a free/open-source software capable of decoding those files for further processing.\nGiven that there is no documentation for the file format, I create a few files and re...
It seems that GPL is not compatible with the Apple App Store due to the differences regarding Apple's ability to impose further restrictions. Does this also affect fonts bundled with the app? In other words - can one use fonts that are licensed under GPL-FE (font exception) with an iOS app? (both from the GPL and Apple...
When dealing with the use of GPL-FE (Font Exception) licensed fonts in an iOS app distributed through the Apple App Store, there are several factors to consider: 1. **GPL-FE License**: The GPL-FE license allows you to use, modify, and distribute the font files without having to release your entire app under the GPL. T...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "It seems that GPL is not compatible with the Apple App Store due to the differences regarding Apple's ability to impose further restrictions.\nDoes this also affect fonts bundled with the app?\nIn other words - can one use fonts that are licensed under GPL-FE (font exception) wi...
According to recent news the US FCC has targeted the network devices enforcing manufacturers to lock down firmwares to prevent installation custom firmwares like OpenWRT. You can read the whole article here: New FCC Rules May Prevent Installing OpenWRT on WiFi Routers Below is an important part of the article. The n...
As of my last knowledge update in October 2023, many manufacturers have indeed complied with the FCC regulations requiring firmware locks on Wi-Fi devices to ensure compliance with U.S. laws regarding wireless communication. However, the landscape of networking hardware and open-source firmware support is dynamic, and ...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "According to recent news the US FCC has targeted the network devices enforcing manufacturers to lock down firmwares to prevent installation custom firmwares like OpenWRT. \nYou can read the whole article here: New FCC Rules May Prevent Installing OpenWRT on WiFi Routers\nBelow ...
As I know, Linux intentionally avoids the switch from GPLv2 to GPLv3. It has the unfortunate side-effect, that it doesn't take part in the defense of the opensource world from the most recent danger, the patent manipulation by different "patent broker" companies or large software producers. What was the reason behind t...
Yes, the decision for the Linux kernel to remain under the GNU General Public License version 2 (GPLv2) and not transition to version 3 (GPLv3) primarily stemmed from Linus Torvalds' philosophy and his concerns regarding the implications of GPLv3. Here are some key points regarding this decision: 1. **Simplicity and ...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "As I know, Linux intentionally avoids the switch from GPLv2 to GPLv3. It has the unfortunate side-effect, that it doesn't take part in the defense of the opensource world from the most recent danger, the patent manipulation by different \"patent broker\" companies or large softw...
This branched out from my previous question: Can I select who can contribute to my Open Source Project? Having never worked on open source software before, and developing my own mini applications that I hope to release to the App Store sometimes this summer, I'm quite unfamiliar with the way most open source developmen...
Absolutely, you can select who can contribute to your open-source project, but the way you manage contributions is influenced by the project's governance model and the specific licensing terms you choose. ### Key Concepts in Open Source Development: 1. **Repository**: This is where your project code is stored. It can...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "This branched out from my previous question: Can I select who can contribute to my Open Source Project?\nHaving never worked on open source software before, and developing my own mini applications that I hope to release to the App Store sometimes this summer, I'm quite unfamilia...
What is the copyright status of the source code of “Adventure” (also known as Colossal Cave Adventure)? There is a good record today of the history of Adventure. Specifically: The 1975–1976 Crowther and Woods “350-point version” for PDP-10 Fortran is available. What is the copyright status of this work? Not just who ho...
The copyright status of "Adventure" (also known as "Colossal Cave Adventure") is quite complex due to its age and the various versions that exist. The original version, developed by Will Crowther in the mid-1970s, was later modified by Don Woods. As of my last knowledge update in October 2023, the following points can ...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "What is the copyright status of the source code of “Adventure” (also known as Colossal Cave Adventure)?\nThere is a good record today of the history of Adventure. Specifically: The 1975–1976 Crowther and Woods “350-point version” for PDP-10 Fortran is available.\nWhat is the cop...
I would like to use a dynamically linked library with GPL V2 license for adding remote support to my existing C++ application. I use the library without modifications of the library code. Do I need to use GPL license for my program or do I need only to give access to the library license and code? Is there a possibility...
Using a dynamically linked library licensed under the GPL version 2 (GPLv2) in your C++ application involves several important considerations regarding licensing. 1. **GPL Compatibility**: The GPLv2 is a copyleft license, which means that if you link your application with a GPLv2 library, your entire application would...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I would like to use a dynamically linked library with GPL V2 license for adding remote support to my existing C++ application. I use the library without modifications of the library code.\nDo I need to use GPL license for my program or do I need only to give access to the librar...
The GNU project has a list of free GNU/Linux distributions. But it lists only a few Linux distros, although hundreds do exist. Even more, very common distributions like Debian, Linux Mint or Gentoo aren’t listed. Why is the list so restricted?
The GNU Project's list of free GNU/Linux distributions is intentionally restricted to focus on distributions that adhere closely to the principles of free software as defined by the Free Software Foundation (FSF). The criteria for inclusion often include: 1. **Free Software Philosophy**: The GNU Project prioritizes di...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "The GNU project has a list of free GNU/Linux distributions. But it lists only a few Linux distros, although hundreds do exist. Even more, very common distributions like Debian, Linux Mint or Gentoo aren’t listed.\nWhy is the list so restricted?\n" }, { "from": "gpt", ...
I have a 3d printer that I use to print some models. There is a model I like that is licensed in Creative Commons under the Attribution - Non-Commercial - Share Alike license. I am not sure what "Commercial purposes" are. My questions are: Can I sell it? (I guess the answer is no) If someone wants me to print a model...
You're correct in your understanding that the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike (CC BY-NC-SA) license has specific restrictions. Here's a breakdown of your questions: 1. **Can I sell it?** No, you cannot sell the model itself or any printed copies of it under the terms of the CC BY-NC-SA licen...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I have a 3d printer that I use to print some models. There is a model I like that is licensed in Creative Commons under the Attribution - Non-Commercial - Share Alike license.\nI am not sure what \"Commercial purposes\" are.\nMy questions are:\n\nCan I sell it? (I guess the answ...
Given that we should already check the patches which we distribute, does hosting the source tree of an OSS component obligate us to check it for copyright infringement, license compliance and/or security issues?
Hosting the source tree of an open-source software (OSS) component does carry certain responsibilities, although the specifics can vary based on legal jurisdiction, the nature of the licenses involved, and the policies of your organization. Here are a few key considerations: 1. **Copyright Infringement**: While you ma...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "Given that we should already check the patches which we distribute, does hosting the source tree of an OSS component obligate us to check it for copyright infringement, license compliance and/or security issues?\n" }, { "from": "gpt", "value": "Hosting the source tre...