instruction stringlengths 57 20.2k | completion stringlengths 4 5.16k | conversations listlengths 2 2 |
|---|---|---|
How far I can go in order to open source the project which is based on closed/commercial project where the whole source code (assuming the access is there) has been converted into different state or programming language (either manually or automatically by transcompiling)? So for example no single line (or resource) ma... | Creating an open-source project based on a closed or commercial project raises significant legal and ethical questions. Here are some considerations you should take into account:
### 1. **Copyright Law:**
- **Original Code:** If you convert closed-source software into a different programming language or state, you ... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "How far I can go in order to open source the project which is based on closed/commercial project where the whole source code (assuming the access is there) has been converted into different state or programming language (either manually or automatically by transcompiling)? So fo... |
I have a question about licensing, and because my legal English isn't really strong, I was hoping for a simple answer...
My idea is to create a set of services, that uses command line programs which are licensed under LGPL and LGPLv3 and distribute amazon AMI for a fee. The question is should my code be also LGPL, and ... | Under the LGPL (Lesser General Public License), you are allowed to use LGPL-licensed libraries in your software and distribute your application, even for a fee, without the need to release your own source code under the LGPL. However, there are a few important points to consider:
1. **Using LGPL Libraries**: You can l... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "I have a question about licensing, and because my legal English isn't really strong, I was hoping for a simple answer...\nMy idea is to create a set of services, that uses command line programs which are licensed under LGPL and LGPLv3 and distribute amazon AMI for a fee. The que... |
I'm working on one npm package based on another one but with another approach, this package is licenced under Apache v2 and I want to use MIT. After some use of my package I've noticed I need to use the feature that the licenced code provides, but this package is not mantained since midyear of 2014 and a PR to this pac... | When dealing with open-source licenses, it’s essential to understand the legal implications of modifying and redistributing code. Since you mentioned that the original package is licensed under the Apache License 2.0 and you wish to use parts of it in your own package that is licensed under the MIT License, here are so... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "I'm working on one npm package based on another one but with another approach, this package is licenced under Apache v2 and I want to use MIT. After some use of my package I've noticed I need to use the feature that the licenced code provides, but this package is not mantained s... |
I want to use FFmpeg in commercial software using its LGPL licence without enabling the GPL add-on. However, the libavformat library allows decoding for a lot of codecs straight out of the box. These are third party codecs so probably won't be the same LGPL licence. Are these embedded codecs ok to use in my application... | Using FFmpeg in your commercial software under the LGPL (Lesser General Public License) while avoiding the GPL (General Public License) can be tricky, especially when it comes to third-party codecs that are included in the libavformat library.
1. **FFmpeg License**: FFmpeg is primarily licensed under the LGPL, but it ... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "I want to use FFmpeg in commercial software using its LGPL licence without enabling the GPL add-on. However, the libavformat library allows decoding for a lot of codecs straight out of the box. These are third party codecs so probably won't be the same LGPL licence. Are these em... |
Does the Python Software Foundation License permit relicensing to the GNU GPLv3 (or v2)?
| The Python Software Foundation License (PSF License) is a permissive open-source license. It allows for modification and redistribution of the software. However, when it comes to relicensing, the specifics can vary depending on the version of the license and the context of the relicensing.
Generally speaking, since th... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "Does the Python Software Foundation License permit relicensing to the GNU GPLv3 (or v2)?\n"
},
{
"from": "gpt",
"value": "The Python Software Foundation License (PSF License) is a permissive open-source license. It allows for modification and redistribution of the so... |
Some points I know:
Contributors own copyright over their contributions, which means the author (= the owner of the repo and original author) cannot re-license the code (= change the license of the code) without asking every contributor.
That's why some companies require you to sign a Contributor License Agreement whi... | This is an important area of software licensing, especially in open source projects. Let's break it down step by step, addressing your questions and providing clarity on forking, contributing, and licensing.
### Step-by-Step Explanation
#### 1. **Forking the Repository**
When you fork a repository:
- You create a per... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "Some points I know:\n\nContributors own copyright over their contributions, which means the author (= the owner of the repo and original author) cannot re-license the code (= change the license of the code) without asking every contributor.\nThat's why some companies require you... |
Is it a GPL-only thing or can I use this formulation with any license, like "MPL 2 or later"?
Does it mean that in case versions 1, 2 & 3 of license are available, "version 1 or later" effectively licenses the project under all 3 of them?
Can I formulate it so only the latest version of license would apply at any give... | The formulation "GPL or later" or "MPL 2.0 or later" is a way to specify the licensing terms under which a work is distributed. Here’s a breakdown of your questions regarding this concept:
### 1. Is it a GPL-only thing or can I use this formulation with any license, like "MPL 2 or later"?
You can use a similar formul... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "\nIs it a GPL-only thing or can I use this formulation with any license, like \"MPL 2 or later\"?\nDoes it mean that in case versions 1, 2 & 3 of license are available, \"version 1 or later\" effectively licenses the project under all 3 of them?\nCan I formulate it so only the l... |
I come across a JavaScript library which is licensed under the CC BY 3.0 (US) license.
The only restrictions of the license is
Attribution — You must give appropriate credit, provide a link to the license, and indicate if changes were made. You may do so in any reasonable manner, but not in any way that suggests the l... | When using a JavaScript library licensed under the CC BY 3.0 (US) license, it's important to provide appropriate attribution in a way that meets the requirements of the license. Here's a breakdown of how you can do that effectively:
### Attribution Requirements
1. **Credit the Author**: You need to give appropriate c... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "I come across a JavaScript library which is licensed under the CC BY 3.0 (US) license.\nThe only restrictions of the license is\n\nAttribution — You must give appropriate credit, provide a link to the license, and indicate if changes were made. You may do so in any reasonable ma... |
I have been using MS VS Code since a while now and I am I really loving it.
Although the other day I was having a discussion regarding editors with my mentor where he pointed to me this.
It's mentioned in the product license.
SCOPE OF LICENSE. The software is licensed, not sold. This agreement only gives you some rig... | Your observations about Visual Studio Code (VS Code) and the differences in licensing between the binary product and the source code are astute, and you've touched on some important aspects of software licensing and open source principles. Let’s address your specific questions:
### 1. Business Reason for Different Lic... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "I have been using MS VS Code since a while now and I am I really loving it.\nAlthough the other day I was having a discussion regarding editors with my mentor where he pointed to me this. \nIt's mentioned in the product license.\n\nSCOPE OF LICENSE. The software is licensed, not... |
Is it legal to install an old version of a software that was free but not anymore?
Version 1 was free, I use it for a year. Version 2 is not free anymore. Can I install (into a new environment) the version 1 or is it illegal?
Example:
Firefox is free, but tomorrow (not true) they change to software with commercial lice... | The legality of installing an old version of software that was previously free, but is no longer available for free, depends on several factors, including the licensing terms that were in place at the time of the software's release.
1. **License Terms:** When you download and use software, you're typically agreeing to... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "Is it legal to install an old version of a software that was free but not anymore?\nVersion 1 was free, I use it for a year. Version 2 is not free anymore. Can I install (into a new environment) the version 1 or is it illegal?\nExample:\nFirefox is free, but tomorrow (not true) ... |
Is the development of Free Download Manager halted? The last code committed was in 2014 :/
Here is a link to the repository.
| As of my last knowledge update in October 2023, I cannot access external links or repositories in real time. However, if a project's last code commit was in 2014, it may indicate that development has halted, but it's not definitive. Many projects can still be in use even if they haven't been actively developed or updat... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "Is the development of Free Download Manager halted? The last code committed was in 2014 :/\nHere is a link to the repository.\n\n"
},
{
"from": "gpt",
"value": "As of my last knowledge update in October 2023, I cannot access external links or repositories in real tim... |
In relationship to my other question What if anything is wrong with the Apache License 2.0?
and following on from How can a "crayon" license be a problem?
Is a license certified to by copyfree (i.e. listed on copyfree.org) sufficient weight to consider it more than a "crayon" license?
I think an important point of a co... | When discussing open source licenses, there are several facets to consider, especially when distinguishing between permissive licenses (like Apache License 2.0 and various copyfree licenses) and copyleft licenses (like the GPL).
### Issues with Apache License 2.0
While the Apache License 2.0 is a well-regarded license... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "In relationship to my other question What if anything is wrong with the Apache License 2.0?\nand following on from How can a \"crayon\" license be a problem?\nIs a license certified to by copyfree (i.e. listed on copyfree.org) sufficient weight to consider it more than a \"crayo... |
In the document “How to use GNU licenses for your own software”, the FSF says:
For software with several releases over multiple years, it's okay to use a range (“2008-2010”) instead of listing individual years (“2008, 2009, 2010”) if and only if every year in the range, inclusive, really is a “copyrightable” year that... | The requirement to include an explicit statement in your documentation when using a range of years for copyright is largely a precautionary measure rather than a strict legal requirement. The reasoning behind this guidance can be attributed to a few key points:
1. **Clarity**: Specifying that a range of years is being... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "In the document “How to use GNU licenses for your own software”, the FSF says:\n\nFor software with several releases over multiple years, it's okay to use a range (“2008-2010”) instead of listing individual years (“2008, 2009, 2010”) if and only if every year in the range, inclu... |
Here's the scenario. Alice crafted a compression library and published it under GPL. Bob crafted a font processing library which uses pieces of code from Alice's library and ... let's call it overly optimistically ... published his combined work under MIT license. This is a problem for people who want to use Bob's libr... | Yes, if Carol successfully rewrites Bob's code to remove any pieces of Alice's GPL-licensed code and creates a new version that does not depend on it, then she can publish her reworked code under the MIT license without any GPL publication requirements.
The key points to consider in this scenario are:
1. **Original L... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "Here's the scenario. Alice crafted a compression library and published it under GPL. Bob crafted a font processing library which uses pieces of code from Alice's library and ... let's call it overly optimistically ... published his combined work under MIT license. This is a prob... |
I have several open source projects and now I really got to a question of choosing a license. They all are somewhat licensed, but in a noob way.
I don't think I'll find something meeting all of the criteria, but maybe I can find something extensible (unlike CC, for example), so I can separately state my conditions.
I w... | Choosing the right open-source license for your projects while maintaining the flexibility you desire can be challenging, especially given your specific requirements. Let's break down your criteria and see how they can be addressed, then suggest some licenses or approaches you can consider.
### Your Requirements Break... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "I have several open source projects and now I really got to a question of choosing a license. They all are somewhat licensed, but in a noob way.\nI don't think I'll find something meeting all of the criteria, but maybe I can find something extensible (unlike CC, for example), so... |
I have a question regarding the enforcing of the GPL license.
Let us suppose I am creating an IoT device using custom software linking/modifying GPL software. We assume that the software running in the IoT device is not accessible via conventional ways.
Case 1:
The client loans the IoT device. In that case, should I di... | Your understanding of the GPL (GNU General Public License) and its implications in both cases you've presented is largely correct, but let's clarify the details further to ensure full comprehension.
### Case 1: Loaning the IoT Device
In this scenario, if you **loan** the IoT device to a client, you are not transferri... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "I have a question regarding the enforcing of the GPL license.\nLet us suppose I am creating an IoT device using custom software linking/modifying GPL software. We assume that the software running in the IoT device is not accessible via conventional ways.\nCase 1:\nThe client loa... |
In the linux kernel, several symbols are exported with EXPORT_GPL_ONLY, and as a result are only available if your kernel module contains MODULE_LICENSE("GPL"). Do either of those have any legal meaning? Can I create a proprietary kernel module that uses gpl-only symbols?
| In the context of the Linux kernel and its licensing, the `EXPORT_GPL_ONLY` mechanism is indeed tied to the GPL (GNU General Public License) licensing model. When a symbol is marked with `EXPORT_GPL_ONLY`, it indicates that the symbol should only be used by modules that are licensed under the GPL.
### Legal Meaning:
... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "In the linux kernel, several symbols are exported with EXPORT_GPL_ONLY, and as a result are only available if your kernel module contains MODULE_LICENSE(\"GPL\"). Do either of those have any legal meaning? Can I create a proprietary kernel module that uses gpl-only symbols?\n"... |
Is it possible to use as optional dependency a GPL dependency in a commercial product?
My idea is to ask the user when installing my product if he wants to install a GPL dependency. Is it possible to do that?
| Using a GPL (General Public License) dependency in a commercial product, even as an optional dependency, can be complex and requires careful consideration of the licensing terms. Here are the main points to consider:
1. **GPL License Terms**: The GPL is a strong copyleft license, which means that if you incorporate GP... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "Is it possible to use as optional dependency a GPL dependency in a commercial product?\nMy idea is to ask the user when installing my product if he wants to install a GPL dependency. Is it possible to do that?\n"
},
{
"from": "gpt",
"value": "Using a GPL (General Pub... |
I'm writing a userspace driver which requires some modifications to the Linux kernel to function. The modifications expose new functionality by the sysfs interface. I understand that the modifications to the Linux kernel have to be licensed under the GPLv2, but is the userspace software (which relies on the modified ... | In the context of software licensing and the specifics of the GPL, the distinction between derivative works and independent works is crucial. According to the GNU General Public License version 2 (GPLv2), derivative works are typically considered to be those that are based on or incorporate the original work in such a ... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "I'm writing a userspace driver which requires some modifications to the Linux kernel to function. The modifications expose new functionality by the sysfs interface. I understand that the modifications to the Linux kernel have to be licensed under the GPLv2, but is the userspac... |
I am soon launching an Android app that uses some code and APIss from other developers or public domain etc, I believe they all have a public domain or similar public license.
SimpleNLG License
http://icon.shef.ac.uk/Moby/mwords.html (dead link, verified on 31.12.2020).
License and Commercial Use of WordNet
All of th... | When using software or APIs that are licensed under terms like the one you've quoted, it's essential to comply with the licensing requirements. Here’s a breakdown of what you need to do regarding citation and attribution:
1. **Attribution**: The license you described indicates that you must provide appropriate credit.... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "I am soon launching an Android app that uses some code and APIss from other developers or public domain etc, I believe they all have a public domain or similar public license.\n\nSimpleNLG License\nhttp://icon.shef.ac.uk/Moby/mwords.html (dead link, verified on 31.12.2020).\nLic... |
It has always bothered me that the MIT license uses the word “conditions” but only seems to list one condition:
Permission is hereby granted […] to any person obtaining a copy of this software […] to deal in the Software without restriction […] subject to the following conditions:
The above copyright notice and this p... | The confusion arises from the language and structure of the MIT License. The MIT License is indeed straightforward and primarily lists one explicit condition regarding the inclusion of the copyright and permission notice in copies or substantial portions of the software.
The phrase "subject to the following conditions... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "It has always bothered me that the MIT license uses the word “conditions” but only seems to list one condition:\n\nPermission is hereby granted […] to any person obtaining a copy of this software […] to deal in the Software without restriction […] subject to the following condit... |
I'm creating the documentation for a small FOSS project of mine. I intend to release such documentation under GNU FDL version 1.3. I have one question, though.
Someone else has made a graphic art that I intend to put on the cover of the user's manual and also use as a logo for the project. This image doesn't yet have a... | Yes, you can publish your documentation under the GNU Free Documentation License (FDL) version 1.3 while attaching a different license to the graphic art. The licenses for different parts of your project do not have to be the same. This is a common practice in open source projects where various components may have diff... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "I'm creating the documentation for a small FOSS project of mine. I intend to release such documentation under GNU FDL version 1.3. I have one question, though.\nSomeone else has made a graphic art that I intend to put on the cover of the user's manual and also use as a logo for ... |
I want to use the Apache 2.0 License on one of my projects. Apache 2.0 recommends putting a boilerplate header in each code file right before module level documentation in it's Appendix section (bottom)
This is all well and good, but I can't find an answer on whether I should include the Appendix within the LICENSE fil... | When using the Apache License 2.0 for your project, you should include the entire license text as specified in the LICENSE file at the root of your project. This includes the main body of the license, but you should **not** include the Appendix section (which contains the boilerplate header) in the LICENSE file.
Here'... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "I want to use the Apache 2.0 License on one of my projects. Apache 2.0 recommends putting a boilerplate header in each code file right before module level documentation in it's Appendix section (bottom)\nThis is all well and good, but I can't find an answer on whether I should i... |
This is a hypothetical question, that has not happened, so please no advice. If I publish some code on GitHub with the GPLv3 license, then want to use that code in proprietary software that I will also own. Do I have the rights to use it for monetary purposes?
| Under the GPLv3 license, when you publish code, you grant users the rights to use, modify, and distribute that code, but any derivative works must also be licensed under the GPLv3. If you want to use that code in proprietary software, you cannot do so without violating the license terms.
You can use the GPLv3 license... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "This is a hypothetical question, that has not happened, so please no advice. If I publish some code on GitHub with the GPLv3 license, then want to use that code in proprietary software that I will also own. Do I have the rights to use it for monetary purposes?\n"
},
{
"f... |
OK, Zizouz212 I will try to reformulate my question making it as clear as I can. I have a tool that is not open source but allows you to define plugins that have to follow a set of interfaces, all of them on a DLL. I also want to offer the source code for a plugin I developed as an example of how to implement those int... | Your question is quite clear! It seems you want to release both the source code for the interfaces and an example plugin while maintaining certain restrictions due to your main tool not being open source. Here’s a suggestion on how to approach licensing for both components:
### For the Interfaces
Since you want the i... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "OK, Zizouz212 I will try to reformulate my question making it as clear as I can. I have a tool that is not open source but allows you to define plugins that have to follow a set of interfaces, all of them on a DLL. I also want to offer the source code for a plugin I developed as... |
I have been developing an open-source software under the GNU GPLv3 license for 3 years (as part of my PhD thesis) and I am releasing the source code to the public. Now I am planning to write a plug-in for that software and distribute the plugin commercially without disclosing the plugin's source code. I was wondering i... | The scenario you're describing involves creating a plugin for a piece of software that is licensed under the GNU GPLv3. The key issue here revolves around the concept of "derivative works" as defined by the GPLv3.
Under the GPLv3, if you create a plugin that interacts with the GPL-licensed software, whether it constit... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "I have been developing an open-source software under the GNU GPLv3 license for 3 years (as part of my PhD thesis) and I am releasing the source code to the public. Now I am planning to write a plug-in for that software and distribute the plugin commercially without disclosing th... |
I'm using portlet-api.jar within my maven project, but I can't find any hint on an applicable license. Is it public domain? And if so, is it written down somewhere?
<dependency>
<groupId>javax.portlet</groupId>
<artifactId>portlet-api</artifactId>
<version>1.0</version>
</dependency>
| The `portlet-api` is part of the Java Portlet Specification, which is managed by the Java Community Process (JCP). The API itself, as part of the Java EE (now Jakarta EE) specifications, is generally subject to the licensing terms laid out by the JCP.
While the specific `portlet-api.jar` does not have a single public ... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "I'm using portlet-api.jar within my maven project, but I can't find any hint on an applicable license. Is it public domain? And if so, is it written down somewhere?\n<dependency>\n <groupId>javax.portlet</groupId>\n <artifactId>portlet-api</artifactId>\n <version>1.0</v... |
I want to copy a file from a project licensed under a New BSD license. My own project is licensed under an MIT license. The file is simple batch script for locating build tools and starting the build. The file itself does not contain copyright notices.
How can copy the file without breaking the license? Should I includ... | When dealing with licensing issues, it’s important to respect the terms of the original license while also maintaining clarity in your own project. Here’s a breakdown of your options:
1. **Attribution**: Under the New BSD License, you are allowed to use and modify the code as long as you include the original copyright... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "I want to copy a file from a project licensed under a New BSD license. My own project is licensed under an MIT license. The file is simple batch script for locating build tools and starting the build. The file itself does not contain copyright notices.\nHow can copy the file wit... |
Assuming the following situation:
I am having a GitHub open-source repository, licensed under the MIT license
I want to document the software on a website with a logo and usage examples, hosted open-source on GitHub
I want to prevent others from re-publishing the website or use my logo anyhwere else, but want to allow... | To achieve your goals while being clear about the usage rights and restrictions related to your GitHub open-source project and its documentation website, you will indeed need to carefully craft both the footer of the website and the LICENSE file in the website's repository.
Here’s how you could structure each:
### 1.... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "Assuming the following situation:\n\nI am having a GitHub open-source repository, licensed under the MIT license\nI want to document the software on a website with a logo and usage examples, hosted open-source on GitHub\nI want to prevent others from re-publishing the website or... |
For games like minecraft it is released under "LGPL 2.1 or later", does this mean that if you record Minecraft the video must also be released under the LGPL 2.1 or later?
Is a separate license needed or are you allowed to record and publish any game?
| No, you do not need to release your recorded gameplay of Minecraft under the LGPL 2.1 or later license. The LGPL (Lesser General Public License) pertains to the software itself and its source code. When you record gameplay, you are creating a new work that does not fall under the restrictions of the LGPL in the same wa... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "For games like minecraft it is released under \"LGPL 2.1 or later\", does this mean that if you record Minecraft the video must also be released under the LGPL 2.1 or later? \nIs a separate license needed or are you allowed to record and publish any game?\n"
},
{
"from":... |
We're trying to raise some fund for our Open Source project.
There's a lot of companies out there selling t-shirts and stickers with Open Source projects, but they don't give a share of the profits to those projects.
I was wondering if there was any initiative out there selling merchandise who're giving a part of the p... | Yes, there are several initiatives and platforms that focus on selling merchandise while giving a share of the profits back to open source projects. Here are a few options you might consider:
1. **Open Collective**: This platform allows open source projects to raise funds through contributions, and they offer merchand... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "We're trying to raise some fund for our Open Source project.\nThere's a lot of companies out there selling t-shirts and stickers with Open Source projects, but they don't give a share of the profits to those projects.\nI was wondering if there was any initiative out there sellin... |
According to Wikipedia's Copyright Formalities and Copyright notice, dating or even putting the author copyright notice in unnecessary.
And then explanations such as this Stack Overflow Post make me wonder about how redundant dating is.
Except maybe to show when the work was start or published, what is the point of the... | The topic of copyright notices and dates can be a bit complex, as it involves legal considerations and conventions that can vary by jurisdiction and specific licenses. Here's a breakdown of your questions:
### 1. The Role of Dates in Copyright Notices
- **Historical Context**: While it's true that copyright protectio... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "According to Wikipedia's Copyright Formalities and Copyright notice, dating or even putting the author copyright notice in unnecessary.\nAnd then explanations such as this Stack Overflow Post make me wonder about how redundant dating is.\nExcept maybe to show when the work was s... |
Straight up: I've never heard of the term 'copyleft' before. The fact that I get that little red squiggle under it tells me it's not really a word. Concisely, my question is, what does it mean to you?
I saw it tagged on a few questions so I read the tag description:
For questions about the copyleft concept (also kno... | The term "copyleft" refers to a licensing approach that allows creators to grant others the freedom to use, modify, and distribute their works while ensuring that all derivative works remain under the same or similar licensing terms. Essentially, it flips the traditional notion of copyright on its head, allowing for mo... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "Straight up: I've never heard of the term 'copyleft' before. The fact that I get that little red squiggle under it tells me it's not really a word. Concisely, my question is, what does it mean to you? \n\nI saw it tagged on a few questions so I read the tag description:\n\nFor q... |
Say there is a multiplayer game (or radio station, BitTorrent tracker, etc) that would (at least threaten to) ban users if they are using a modified client. And the official client is released using GPL. Does it work?
Intuitively it isn't that free as the GPL intended. But some problems are:
The software could be rele... | Your question touches on the nuances of the GNU General Public License (GPL) and its implications when software is used in conjunction with online services like games, radio stations, or BitTorrent trackers. Here's a breakdown of the main points involved:
### 1. **GPL Overview**
The GPL is designed to ensure that soft... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "Say there is a multiplayer game (or radio station, BitTorrent tracker, etc) that would (at least threaten to) ban users if they are using a modified client. And the official client is released using GPL. Does it work?\nIntuitively it isn't that free as the GPL intended. But some... |
This is somewhat inspired by this: Does a GPL image “infect” my blog post? and the Google Material Design Icons. The latter is a very well known project.
The first question deals with a picture licensed under the GPL. The material design icons hosts a series of icons licensed under the Apache 2.0 license - this was cha... | You've raised some insightful points about the use of software licenses, like Apache 2.0, for media assets, such as icons and images. Here are some additional arguments and considerations for why some projects might choose software licenses over media-specific licenses like those from Creative Commons:
### Arguments f... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "This is somewhat inspired by this: Does a GPL image “infect” my blog post? and the Google Material Design Icons. The latter is a very well known project.\nThe first question deals with a picture licensed under the GPL. The material design icons hosts a series of icons licensed u... |
Can I recode WordPress or another CMS and then sell it as my own?
Can I encrypt the source code?
| When it comes to recoding a CMS like WordPress and selling it as your own, several important factors must be considered:
### 1. Licensing
WordPress is released under the **GNU General Public License (GPL)**, which allows you to modify and redistribute the software, but there are conditions:
- You must keep the GPL l... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "Can I recode WordPress or another CMS and then sell it as my own? \nCan I encrypt the source code?\n"
},
{
"from": "gpt",
"value": "When it comes to recoding a CMS like WordPress and selling it as your own, several important factors must be considered:\n\n### 1. Lice... |
Assuming a copyright license (I'll reference Apache 2.0, but that's an example only) that allows derivations, at what point are those derivations so extensive that the Apache license no longer applies? If every line of code is replaced, classes refactored, packages renamed, moved, merged, and split, to the point that e... | The question of when a derivative work becomes sufficiently transformative to no longer be considered a derivative of the original work is complex and doesn't have a one-size-fits-all answer. This concept plays into copyright law but also intersects with licensing terms, including permissive licenses like Apache 2.0 an... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "Assuming a copyright license (I'll reference Apache 2.0, but that's an example only) that allows derivations, at what point are those derivations so extensive that the Apache license no longer applies? If every line of code is replaced, classes refactored, packages renamed, move... |
I have an commercial embedded device which uses linux as OS and I would like to add remote support to my commercial application on the device.
I would like to use a dynamically linked library with GPL V2 license for adding the remote support.
Can I create an application under GPL, which uses the library and acts as se... | To determine whether you can create an application under the GPL that uses a GPL-licensed library and acts as a server communicating with your commercial program, it's important to understand the implications of the GPL license.
1. **Using a GPL-licensed Library**: When you use a library licensed under the GPL (includ... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "I have an commercial embedded device which uses linux as OS and I would like to add remote support to my commercial application on the device.\nI would like to use a dynamically linked library with GPL V2 license for adding the remote support. \nCan I create an application under... |
There are two libraries under MIT, that do the same thing, each with some pros and cons. I'd like to merge them, effectively reworking the public API, but keeping the underlying logic (code). The resulting library should be part of my framework that is currently licensed under apache 2.0.
Can I license the resulting l... | When it comes to merging two libraries that are licensed under the MIT License into a new library that will be part of your framework licensed under Apache 2.0, there are several considerations to keep in mind:
1. **Licensing the New Library**:
- You can license your resulting library under Apache 2.0. The MIT Lice... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "There are two libraries under MIT, that do the same thing, each with some pros and cons. I'd like to merge them, effectively reworking the public API, but keeping the underlying logic (code). The resulting library should be part of my framework that is currently licensed under a... |
I have an open source software project licensed under MIT.
The MIT License (MIT)
Copyright (c) 2016 Håvard Fossli
Permission is hereby granted, free of charge, to any ....
I found some code on another repo also licensed under MIT and I want to use bits and pieces of that. The MIT license has a copyright notice on t... | When incorporating code from another MIT-licensed project into your own, it's important to properly attribute the original authors. You can indeed retain the copyright notice of the original authors. However, your overall license should still clearly reflect the contributions and authorship related to your project.
He... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "I have an open source software project licensed under MIT. \n\nThe MIT License (MIT) \nCopyright (c) 2016 Håvard Fossli\nPermission is hereby granted, free of charge, to any ....\n\nI found some code on another repo also licensed under MIT and I want to use bits and pieces of th... |
I am currently planning to launch an alpha version of the software as a representative of an unregistered company. We (currently I'm the only person on the team) do not have any patents and are not planning to apply for it until we are cash-flow positive. Open-source licenses like that of Open Source Foundation and Fre... | You're navigating a complex landscape of software licensing, especially if you're aiming to balance commercial control and open collaboration. Here are some points to consider in relation to your goals:
### Licensing Options
1. **Custom License**:
- You could create a custom license that clearly outlines your term... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "I am currently planning to launch an alpha version of the software as a representative of an unregistered company. We (currently I'm the only person on the team) do not have any patents and are not planning to apply for it until we are cash-flow positive. Open-source licenses li... |
As far as I understand, choosing GPL licence for library does not permits use of it in proprietary programs as opposed to LGPL.
So releasing my library (or code classes), I'm forcing people to use them only in free programs, is that right? Is it including myself?
In other words, as owner of the libraries, can I break t... | You're correct that the General Public License (GPL) and the Lesser General Public License (LGPL) have different implications for the use of libraries in proprietary programs. Let me clarify the key points regarding GPL licensing and your specific questions:
### GPL vs. LGPL
1. **GPL License**: If you release your li... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "As far as I understand, choosing GPL licence for library does not permits use of it in proprietary programs as opposed to LGPL.\nSo releasing my library (or code classes), I'm forcing people to use them only in free programs, is that right? Is it including myself?\nIn other word... |
Suppose we have this scenario:
there are 4 Free softwares (under GPL version 2);
a man puts them in a Stack and codes some glue-tools and a GUI to wrap them all together;
now the stack is a Platform, provided in a bundle;
If the man writes a program, which uses other softwares under GPLv2, he must release his code,... | You have a good understanding of how the GNU General Public License version 2 (GPLv2) operates in relation to derivative works and the obligations that come with using GPL software. Let’s break down your scenario and address some key points.
1. **Derivative Works**: According to the GPLv2, any modifications or works t... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "Suppose we have this scenario:\n\nthere are 4 Free softwares (under GPL version 2); \na man puts them in a Stack and codes some glue-tools and a GUI to wrap them all together;\nnow the stack is a Platform, provided in a bundle; \n\nIf the man writes a program, which uses other s... |
I am confused about choosing a license for my project. I have read some resources like Open Source Initiative and Choosealicense.com, though.
My project is a mobile application for Android. Now, it's already on public repository. Details of technology (software or plug-in) I used on this project are:
Mobile applicatio... | When selecting a license for your project, especially when it interacts with components under different licenses, it's essential to understand the implications of those licenses.
### Key Points to Consider:
1. **GPL v3 License**:
- If you use GPL v3 licensed code (even if you don't modify it), your project can onl... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "I am confused about choosing a license for my project. I have read some resources like Open Source Initiative and Choosealicense.com, though.\nMy project is a mobile application for Android. Now, it's already on public repository. Details of technology (software or plug-in) I us... |
I'm building a program which gets certain info off the net, makes calculations, then sends the info to the net again. I don't program the 'taking off the net' and 'sending to the net' parts though; instead I use a script to issue commands via a CLI that someone else built. Now here's my question:
Is this application a ... | Determining whether your application is a derivative work of another software project can be complex and often depends on specific legal interpretations and the particular details of how you use the software. Let's break down your scenario.
1. **Derivative Work Definition**: A derivative work is typically defined as a... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "I'm building a program which gets certain info off the net, makes calculations, then sends the info to the net again. I don't program the 'taking off the net' and 'sending to the net' parts though; instead I use a script to issue commands via a CLI that someone else built. Now h... |
I am using Javassist within my free open-source project (Javassist is included as pre-built .jar file which has been downloaded from the Releases section on their page, no source code). I'm now wondering if I need to include something beside the used .jar (e.g., some Javassist.license.html or similar) when publishing m... | When using a library like Javassist, which is distributed under a triple license (MPL, LGPL, and Apache License), it is important to comply with the terms of the licenses.
Here's a breakdown of the requirements for each license:
1. **Mozilla Public License (MPL)**: If you include any MPL-licensed code in your project... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "I am using Javassist within my free open-source project (Javassist is included as pre-built .jar file which has been downloaded from the Releases section on their page, no source code). I'm now wondering if I need to include something beside the used .jar (e.g., some Javassist.l... |
Me and several collegues of mine are working on open sourced framework (licensed under GPL) in the mobile field. Our code depends on the Android SDK.
Looking into the license of the SDK itself you can read the following license.
On the other hand Android is open sourced with most of classes licensed under Apache 2 (few... | The situation you're describing involves navigating the licensing terms of both the Android SDK and the Android operating system itself. Here’s a breakdown of key points to consider regarding your project and its licensing implications:
1. **Android SDK License**: The Android SDK is licensed under a specific license (... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "Me and several collegues of mine are working on open sourced framework (licensed under GPL) in the mobile field. Our code depends on the Android SDK.\nLooking into the license of the SDK itself you can read the following license.\nOn the other hand Android is open sourced with m... |
I implemented a little console application in C# (tool) that can go through the web pages on the site and get information, links, files from them. I used Selenium for this purpose. Two nuget packages WebDriver and ChromeDriver (the last is unlicensed). But WebDriver has Apache 2.0 license.
I don't actually understand ... | The Apache License 2.0 is a permissive open-source license, which allows you to use, modify, and distribute software under certain conditions. Since you're using the WebDriver library, which is licensed under the Apache 2.0 License, here are the key points to keep in mind to ensure compliance with the license:
1. **Li... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "I implemented a little console application in C# (tool) that can go through the web pages on the site and get information, links, files from them. I used Selenium for this purpose. Two nuget packages WebDriver and ChromeDriver (the last is unlicensed). But WebDriver has Apache 2... |
I have a project, a big portion of which can be released as LGPL, but there are still some portions that must keep a more restrictive license. I'm not sure what exactly is allowed. The intent is distributing the whole package with source code, but allow redistribution and modification beyond personal use only for the L... | Your questions touch on several important aspects of the GNU Lesser General Public License (LGPL) and its interaction with other licensing models. Here's a breakdown of your inquiries:
1. **Can a proprietary program link to an LGPL library?**
- Yes, a proprietary program can link to an LGPL library. The LGPL allows... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "I have a project, a big portion of which can be released as LGPL, but there are still some portions that must keep a more restrictive license. I'm not sure what exactly is allowed. The intent is distributing the whole package with source code, but allow redistribution and modifi... |
I like the jQuery Isotope plugin and I want to use it on my website. I was wondering if it was OK to use it without a licence.
It's licensed under either GPLv3 as an open-source license, or there's a commercial license available if you want to keep your code proprietary.
I am not gonna sell the plugin or claim its mine... | Using the jQuery Isotope plugin under the GPLv3 license is generally permissible for your intended use, as long as you comply with the terms of the license. The GPLv3 license allows you to use, modify, and distribute the software, provided that you adhere to its conditions. This means you can use Isotope on your websit... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "I like the jQuery Isotope plugin and I want to use it on my website. I was wondering if it was OK to use it without a licence.\nIt's licensed under either GPLv3 as an open-source license, or there's a commercial license available if you want to keep your code proprietary.\nI am ... |
I'm the only developer working on an open source project (MPL v2.0 license, not sure if it does matter) and I have a single-person LLC I use for some consulting works.
What are the pros and cons of copyrighting the code under my own name vs the name of the company?
| When deciding whether to copyright your open-source project under your own name or your single-person LLC, there are several pros and cons to consider:
### Copyrighting Under Your Own Name
**Pros:**
1. **Simplicity**: As an individual, it may be simpler to manage copyright, especially if you’re the only developer. It... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "I'm the only developer working on an open source project (MPL v2.0 license, not sure if it does matter) and I have a single-person LLC I use for some consulting works.\nWhat are the pros and cons of copyrighting the code under my own name vs the name of the company?\n"
},
{
... |
Is it possible to release software under GPL license but not publish one small part of it which contains data that really shouldn't be available publicly (I mean private API keys, etc.) If not, which FOSS license should I use to do so?
| The GNU General Public License (GPL) is designed to promote software freedom and requires that all modified versions of the software also be distributed under the same license. This means that if you release software under the GPL, you must make the entire source code available to the recipients, including all componen... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "Is it possible to release software under GPL license but not publish one small part of it which contains data that really shouldn't be available publicly (I mean private API keys, etc.) If not, which FOSS license should I use to do so? \n"
},
{
"from": "gpt",
"value"... |
Some time ago I published the source code for a web application under the GNU AFFERO license, some people forked it and modified it in different ways.
Now I would like to modify the original version of the software, the one I published initially which only includes my own work, but I don't want to share the modificatio... | The GNU Affero General Public License (AGPL) is a copyleft license, which means that any derivative work you create based on the original code must also be released under the same license if you distribute it. However, there are some nuances to consider.
1. **Modifying Your Own Code**: If you are working on your origi... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "Some time ago I published the source code for a web application under the GNU AFFERO license, some people forked it and modified it in different ways.\nNow I would like to modify the original version of the software, the one I published initially which only includes my own work,... |
Circa 2006, blogs.sun.com/chandan/entry/copyrights_licenses_and_cddl_illustrated says, in comparing EULA, GPL, CDDL and BSD, that one must "use CDDL for things already under CDDL".
But what does it mean? Aren't you must always use BSD licence for things already under BSD, too? As well as any other licence, as well?
| The statement "you must use CDDL for things already under CDDL" refers specifically to the compatibility and requirements of the Common Development and Distribution License (CDDL) when dealing with software that is already licensed under the CDDL.
In general, licensing works as follows:
1. **Same License for Derived ... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "Circa 2006, blogs.sun.com/chandan/entry/copyrights_licenses_and_cddl_illustrated says, in comparing EULA, GPL, CDDL and BSD, that one must \"use CDDL for things already under CDDL\".\nBut what does it mean? Aren't you must always use BSD licence for things already under BSD, to... |
In source code for a project released by Amazon.com Inc., awslabs/amazon-redshift-utils, an "Open Source"-like license is found with questionable stipulations, particularly section 3.3:
3.3 Use Limitation. The Work and any derivative works thereof only may be used or intended for use with the web services, computing p... | The scenario you describe raises interesting legal and ethical questions about the nature of open-source licenses and their enforceability.
1. **Legal Validity**: Generally, software licenses are legal contracts, and their terms can be enforced in court, provided that they meet certain legal requirements. The specifi... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "In source code for a project released by Amazon.com Inc., awslabs/amazon-redshift-utils, an \"Open Source\"-like license is found with questionable stipulations, particularly section 3.3:\n\n3.3 Use Limitation. The Work and any derivative works thereof only may be used or intend... |
I'm working on a commercial closed-source app and I need to use a library under the Cecill-B licence.
I read the licence terms here
and it desn't say it is mandatory to distribute the source code of the software that uses the library, or to use it only for open-source apps. So I conclude I can use the library for my ap... | Your understanding is mostly correct. The CeCILL-B license allows you to use, modify, and distribute the software, including in proprietary applications, without the obligation to release the source code of your own application.
Here's a summary of the key points regarding your scenario:
1. **Use in Closed-Source Ap... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "I'm working on a commercial closed-source app and I need to use a library under the Cecill-B licence.\nI read the licence terms here\nand it desn't say it is mandatory to distribute the source code of the software that uses the library, or to use it only for open-source apps. So... |
It seems that GPL is not compatible with the Apple App Store due to the differences regarding Apple's ability to impose further restrictions.
Does this also affect fonts bundled with the app?
In other words - can one use fonts that are licensed under GPL-FE (font exception) with an iOS app? (both from the GPL and Apple... | When it comes to using fonts licensed under the GPL with Font Exception (GPL-FE) in an iOS app intended for the Apple App Store, several factors need to be considered:
1. **GPL and Apple's Policies**: The GNU General Public License (GPL) is a copyleft license that requires derivative works to also be licensed under th... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "It seems that GPL is not compatible with the Apple App Store due to the differences regarding Apple's ability to impose further restrictions.\nDoes this also affect fonts bundled with the app?\nIn other words - can one use fonts that are licensed under GPL-FE (font exception) wi... |
GNU Classpath exception says I can link this library with independent modules to produce an executable, regardless of the license terms of these independent modules, and to copy and distribute the resulting executable under terms of your choice.
Note this library wording. It sounds like I can take the library code as a... | The GNU Classpath exception, as you noted, allows you to link the library with independent modules and distribute the resulting executable under terms of your choice. However, your question about using only parts of the library raises some important points about licensing and copyright.
1. **Using Parts of the Library... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "GNU Classpath exception says I can link this library with independent modules to produce an executable, regardless of the license terms of these independent modules, and to copy and distribute the resulting executable under terms of your choice.\nNote this library wording. It so... |
I am currently developing an online service that allows to share and download music from different source on the internet, this is a free service without subscription or registration, I found a perfect flag icons I will like to integrate into the website countries section, but it comes with Creative Commons license: At... | Based on the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported license, you cannot use the flag icons for your website because of the following reasons:
1. **NonCommercial Restriction**: The license specifically states that you may not use the material for commercial purposes. Since you are... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "I am currently developing an online service that allows to share and download music from different source on the internet, this is a free service without subscription or registration, I found a perfect flag icons I will like to integrate into the website countries section, but i... |
I am permitted to mix not open-source code with GPL code on my computer if I don't distribute it.
Is deploying it to a VM on a remote server considered distribution?
| The GNU General Public License (GPL) has specific terms regarding the use and distribution of software. According to the GPL, you can indeed mix proprietary (not open-source) code with GPL code on your computer for personal use, as long as you do not distribute that combined work.
However, when it comes to deploying y... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "I am permitted to mix not open-source code with GPL code on my computer if I don't distribute it.\nIs deploying it to a VM on a remote server considered distribution?\n"
},
{
"from": "gpt",
"value": "The GNU General Public License (GPL) has specific terms regarding t... |
Specifically, the GPLv2. The creator of a work can allow people to upgrade to a higher GPL version:
(emphasis mine)
This program is free software; you can redistribute it and/or modify it under
the terms of the GNU General Public License as published by the Free
Software Foundation; either version 2 of the License... | Under the terms of the GNU General Public License version 2 (GPLv2), you have the option to allow others to use your modified version under the same license terms as the original work, including the possibility of upgrading to a later version of the GPL if you included that option.
If you modify a work that allows up... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "Specifically, the GPLv2. The creator of a work can allow people to upgrade to a higher GPL version:\n(emphasis mine)\n\nThis program is free software; you can redistribute it and/or modify it under\n the terms of the GNU General Public License as published by the Free\n Softwa... |
A friend and I developed a software which we would like to be free as in freedom.
We would like our software to be available to anyone for no money, but we would like to sell the source code to those interested in.
My goal then is :
Anyone has access to binary gratis
Anyone who wants the source from our version pays a... | Your approach raises some interesting points about the nature of Free and Open Source Software (FOSS) and how you can maintain control while still aiming for a model that provides access and potential monetization.
### Understanding FOSS
FOSS typically refers to software that can be freely used, modified, and distri... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "A friend and I developed a software which we would like to be free as in freedom.\nWe would like our software to be available to anyone for no money, but we would like to sell the source code to those interested in.\nMy goal then is :\n\nAnyone has access to binary gratis\nAnyon... |
The infamous "DRM clause" of the GFDL reads:
You may not use
technical measures to obstruct or control the reading or further
copying of the copies you make or distribute.
From Wikipedia:
A criticism of this language is that it is too broad, because it applies to private copies made but not distributed. This means t... | The language in both the GNU Free Documentation License (GFDL) and the GNU General Public License (GPL) regarding technical measures highlights an important philosophical stance taken by the Free Software Foundation (FSF) against the use of Digital Rights Management (DRM) and other restrictions that limit users' freedo... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "The infamous \"DRM clause\" of the GFDL reads:\n\nYou may not use\ntechnical measures to obstruct or control the reading or further\ncopying of the copies you make or distribute.\n\nFrom Wikipedia:\n\nA criticism of this language is that it is too broad, because it applies to pr... |
Are there any rough estimates of the total number of person-hours that have been spent on writing FLOSS software? (paid and volunteer)
| Estimating the total number of person-hours spent on writing Free/Libre and Open Source Software (FLOSS) is quite challenging due to the decentralized and volunteer-driven nature of many projects. However, researchers and organizations have made attempts to quantify contributions to FLOSS.
One common method involves a... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "Are there any rough estimates of the total number of person-hours that have been spent on writing FLOSS software? (paid and volunteer)\n"
},
{
"from": "gpt",
"value": "Estimating the total number of person-hours spent on writing Free/Libre and Open Source Software (F... |
From the FFmpeg's Encode/AAC page:
The licenses of libaacplus, libfaac, and libfdk_aac are not compatible
with the GPL, so the GPL does not permit distribution of binaries
containing code licensed under these licenses when GPL-licensed code
is also included. Therefore these encoders have been designated as
"no... | The situation you're describing revolves around the complexities of software licensing, particularly when it involves the GNU General Public License (GPL) and other licenses that are not compatible with it. Here's a breakdown of what's happening:
1. **Licensing Compatibility**:
- The GPL, particularly GPLv2 and GP... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "From the FFmpeg's Encode/AAC page:\n\nThe licenses of libaacplus, libfaac, and libfdk_aac are not compatible\n with the GPL, so the GPL does not permit distribution of binaries\n containing code licensed under these licenses when GPL-licensed code\n is also included. Therefor... |
Suppose I write a server-based application that I wish to release under the AGPL and expose publicly. What concrete steps do I need to take in order to satisfy clause 13? Is it enough to add a valid link to a public git repository on an "About" page? Does the link have to appear on every page of the application? Does i... | When you release a server-based application under the GNU Affero General Public License (AGPL), satisfying the requirements of Clause 13, which pertains to offering the source code, involves several important considerations. Here are the concrete steps you should take to comply with the AGPL requirements:
### 1. **Pro... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "Suppose I write a server-based application that I wish to release under the AGPL and expose publicly. What concrete steps do I need to take in order to satisfy clause 13? Is it enough to add a valid link to a public git repository on an \"About\" page? Does the link have to appe... |
All I want to know is what licensing allows me, the program author, to keep "author credits"(so no one can rip me off), and make all software created from this program to remain free (like Ruby License)
| If you're looking to maintain author credits and ensure that all derivative works of your software remain free, you might consider the following licenses:
1. **GNU General Public License (GPL)**: The GPL requires that any derivative work be licensed under the same terms (i.e., remain free). It also has provisions that... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "All I want to know is what licensing allows me, the program author, to keep \"author credits\"(so no one can rip me off), and make all software created from this program to remain free (like Ruby License)\n"
},
{
"from": "gpt",
"value": "If you're looking to maintain... |
In open source the term "free" is often used, sometimes with a qualifier, "free as in beer" or "free as in speech". What is meant with these qualifications?
| The terms "free as in beer" and "free as in speech" are commonly used in the context of open source and free software to distinguish between different meanings of the word "free."
1. **Free as in Beer**: This phrase refers to something being free of charge, similar to how a beer might be given away without cost. In th... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "In open source the term \"free\" is often used, sometimes with a qualifier, \"free as in beer\" or \"free as in speech\". What is meant with these qualifications?\n"
},
{
"from": "gpt",
"value": "The terms \"free as in beer\" and \"free as in speech\" are commonly us... |
A repository owner on GitHub transferred me ownership of a project he abandoned some time ago. I noticed the year in the license file is outdated (2014), and the original author's name is still included.
The license is MIT, but I know I can't reattribute the work to myself. Should I:
Keep the year updated and continue... | When a project is transferred to you and you become the new owner while maintaining the original license (in this case, the MIT License), the general approach is to maintain proper attribution and respect the original author's rights. Here’s what you can consider:
1. **Keep the Year Updated and Continue Credit**: It’s... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "A repository owner on GitHub transferred me ownership of a project he abandoned some time ago. I noticed the year in the license file is outdated (2014), and the original author's name is still included.\nThe license is MIT, but I know I can't reattribute the work to myself. Sho... |
I have noticed that some groups or organizations convey the GPL software without the source code. Such examples are:
https://sourceforge.net/projects/serbian2014/files/Download/ as Serbian GNU/Linux
https://gitlab.com/trios-linux/trios/tree/master (pure, if any source), again as some kind of Serbian GNU based on Linu... | You are correct in your understanding of the GNU General Public License (GPL). The GPL is a copyleft license that stipulates that if you distribute software that is licensed under the GPL, you must also make the source code available to the recipients. This includes any modifications you make to the software, as well a... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "I have noticed that some groups or organizations convey the GPL software without the source code. Such examples are:\n\nhttps://sourceforge.net/projects/serbian2014/files/Download/ as Serbian GNU/Linux \nhttps://gitlab.com/trios-linux/trios/tree/master (pure, if any source), aga... |
I downloaded few source codes for android from here.
From what I see this website doesn't state the license of these source codes anywhere, although the title say free code game and it says open source in the url, I can't find a txt file in the apps or a line in the website stating the license for these projects.
I wan... | When dealing with source code that does not explicitly state a license, it's important to proceed with caution. Here are the key points to consider:
1. **Lack of License**: If the source code does not include a license file or any other form of explicit licensing terms, it is generally considered that you do not have ... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "I downloaded few source codes for android from here.\nFrom what I see this website doesn't state the license of these source codes anywhere, although the title say free code game and it says open source in the url, I can't find a txt file in the apps or a line in the website sta... |
I have a graduation project based on an open source system. As my university is more leaned towards the market instead of the academia, I wanted to know who else (if ever) is going to take my project from the campus library to read or create new work based on it.
Is it possible to attach some type of creative-commons-... | Yes, it is possible to attach a Creative Commons license to your graduation project document, but there are some limitations to the specific request you have regarding a clause requiring users to contact you about their work.
Creative Commons licenses generally allow you to specify certain permissions and restrictions... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "I have a graduation project based on an open source system. As my university is more leaned towards the market instead of the academia, I wanted to know who else (if ever) is going to take my project from the campus library to read or create new work based on it. \nIs it possibl... |
This is a follow up question from here.
Since I'm allowed to delay the distribution of the binary and source code as long as I provide the source code eventually. This makes me wonder if that does not defeat the purpose of the GPLV2 completely. If that is true, I could choose an arbitrary time when I release the sourc... | Your concern about the timing of source code release in relation to binary distribution under the GPLv2 is valid. The GPLv2 does allow for the binary to be distributed before the source code, but it mandates that the source code must be made available at some point. This is intended to preserve the rights of users to a... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "This is a follow up question from here. \nSince I'm allowed to delay the distribution of the binary and source code as long as I provide the source code eventually. This makes me wonder if that does not defeat the purpose of the GPLV2 completely. If that is true, I could choose ... |
I am using the Volley library, provided by Google, to do some http requests on android app. The Volley library is under the "Creative Commons Attribution 2.5".
If I want to publish my app later on the Play Store, do i have something special to do to be able to use this library ? I read the license but i don't really un... | The Volley library is under the Creative Commons Attribution 2.5 license, which is primarily focused on the attribution requirements for any reused content. However, it's important to clarify that the license is not typically applied to software libraries. Instead, libraries are usually covered under more traditional l... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "I am using the Volley library, provided by Google, to do some http requests on android app. The Volley library is under the \"Creative Commons Attribution 2.5\".\nIf I want to publish my app later on the Play Store, do i have something special to do to be able to use this librar... |
I am integrating an LGPL application to my iOS application. I am modifying the LGPL application in such a way that, I am integrating a new library to it. So the flow is like this:
Appl Code >> LGPL Library >> New Library
Do I need to make the New Library opensource?
This is what I am planning to do to meet the license... | The LGPL (Lesser General Public License) has specific requirements and conditions that need to be followed, especially when it comes to modifications and linking. Here's how your situation plays out with the LGPL:
1. **Making the Modified LGPL Application Open Source**: If you modify the LGPL library and distribute th... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "I am integrating an LGPL application to my iOS application. I am modifying the LGPL application in such a way that, I am integrating a new library to it. So the flow is like this:\nAppl Code >> LGPL Library >> New Library\nDo I need to make the New Library opensource? \nThis is ... |
I'm working on porting a very old program (1994) that was released under the GPL. However, the only reference to that license is this text in the header of the C files:
This program is free software; you can redistribute it and/or modify it under the terms of the GNU General Public License as published by the Free Sof... | The text you provided indicates that the program is licensed under the GNU General Public License (GPL), but it does not specify a version number. The GNU GPL has undergone multiple versions since its inception, with the most notable ones being GPLv1, GPLv2, and GPLv3.
Since the license text from 1994 doesn't specify... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "I'm working on porting a very old program (1994) that was released under the GPL. However, the only reference to that license is this text in the header of the C files:\n\nThis program is free software; you can redistribute it and/or modify it under the terms of the GNU General ... |
Say an android app is hosted on Github, it has beautiful UI elements that I introduced within copied into an app of my own. Now I am getting requests from users/customers to show them how to implement those UI elements in their apps.
The Github project's license is General Public License Version 2 1991.
Edit (adding so... | Given that the Android app you are referring to is hosted on GitHub and licensed under the General Public License Version 2 (GPLv2), there are important legal considerations to keep in mind regarding the use and distribution of the UI elements from that project.
### Key Points of GPLv2:
1. **Copyleft Principle**: The... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "Say an android app is hosted on Github, it has beautiful UI elements that I introduced within copied into an app of my own. Now I am getting requests from users/customers to show them how to implement those UI elements in their apps.\nThe Github project's license is General Publ... |
As a person who wants to allow other people to use my code, I want to use a standard, proper license. But sometimes my code ends up being smaller than the LICENSE file that comes with it. This can especially annoying if I write a code snippet and want people to actually use it. I don't especially like the idea of copyi... | Yes, you can definitely mention that your code is licensed under the MIT License (or any other license) and provide a link to the full text of the license instead of including the entire license text in your repository or alongside your code snippet. This approach is quite common, especially for smaller code snippets.
... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "As a person who wants to allow other people to use my code, I want to use a standard, proper license. But sometimes my code ends up being smaller than the LICENSE file that comes with it. This can especially annoying if I write a code snippet and want people to actually use it. ... |
I was quite surprised to see the following in an answer: (emphasis mine)
For new projects, you should avoid the MPL as it has issues with the European law system. For this reason, the CDDL can be seen as the successor of the MPL.
Given that both licenses disallow to change the license but limit their scopt to files, y... | The concerns regarding the Mozilla Public License (MPL) and its compatibility with European law often stem from specific legal interpretations and practices that vary between jurisdictions. The issues may relate to how certain provisions are structured or how they interact with European concepts of copyright and contra... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "I was quite surprised to see the following in an answer: (emphasis mine)\n\nFor new projects, you should avoid the MPL as it has issues with the European law system. For this reason, the CDDL can be seen as the successor of the MPL.\nGiven that both licenses disallow to change t... |
I'm working for a company that stores millions of newspapers articles. Subscribers can log on our site and make queries. Our search engine returns articles that match the queries.
I know that in general, a company can use GPL Stanford software commercially as long as all their source code is available and the GPL is pr... | The Stanford Named Entity Recognizer (NER) is distributed under the GNU General Public License (GPL), which allows you to use the software freely under certain conditions. You are correct that one of the core requirements of the GPL is that if you distribute software that includes GPL-licensed components, you must also... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "I'm working for a company that stores millions of newspapers articles. Subscribers can log on our site and make queries. Our search engine returns articles that match the queries.\nI know that in general, a company can use GPL Stanford software commercially as long as all their ... |
The source for the Linux kernel v0.01 can easily be found online, however it does not seem to contain a license or any redistribution rules. Is it, therefore, safe to assume that this code is in the public domain? Or have I missed something, and in fact it is licensed under some kind of license?
| The Linux kernel version 0.01, which was released by Linus Torvalds in 1991, does not include an explicit license file, and at that time, the notion of open source licenses was not as well defined as it is today. However, it is widely accepted that the kernel was originally released with the intention of being open for... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "The source for the Linux kernel v0.01 can easily be found online, however it does not seem to contain a license or any redistribution rules. Is it, therefore, safe to assume that this code is in the public domain? Or have I missed something, and in fact it is licensed under some... |
Some friends and I started up a very small business venue a while back, to make a card game. Properly registered as a partnership and all that. It was nothing serious though, just something we worked on in our spare time.
We've all gotten busy, and so are likely to drop it (technically I exitted 3 months ago). No one i... | When considering open sourcing your card game and the artwork created for it, there are several important legal and ethical aspects to consider:
1. **Ownership of Copyright**: Since you mentioned that you and your friends purchased the artwork outright and own the copyright, you have the right to use, modify, and dist... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "Some friends and I started up a very small business venue a while back, to make a card game. Properly registered as a partnership and all that. It was nothing serious though, just something we worked on in our spare time.\nWe've all gotten busy, and so are likely to drop it (tec... |
Is there any software licence (GNU, MIT Apache etc.) that could be readily used or modified to allow to impose limitations of the specific use/modification of parts of a source code that otherwise is being distributed as open source?
Specifically, for example, in a collaboratively developed software package (like scien... | Open source licenses, such as GNU GPL, MIT, and Apache, are designed to promote freedom of use, modification, and redistribution of software. As such, they generally do not provide mechanisms for imposing limitations on specific parts of the code while allowing other parts to be open source. This is a fundamental chara... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "Is there any software licence (GNU, MIT Apache etc.) that could be readily used or modified to allow to impose limitations of the specific use/modification of parts of a source code that otherwise is being distributed as open source?\nSpecifically, for example, in a collaborativ... |
I want to release a program under the CeCILL version 2. It permits relicensing to the GPL, and I'm okay with that. However, version 2.1 permits relicensing to the European Union Public License, and I don't want to allow that, because (as the FSF notes) it permits relicensing to licenses with weaker copylefts.
The issue... | You are grappling with a nuanced aspect of the CeCILL licensing, particularly with the implications of its versioning and relicensing provisions. Let's break this down to clarify your concerns.
1. **CeCILL Versioning**: According to Article 12.3 of the CeCILL license, a program distributed under a specific version may... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "I want to release a program under the CeCILL version 2. It permits relicensing to the GPL, and I'm okay with that. However, version 2.1 permits relicensing to the European Union Public License, and I don't want to allow that, because (as the FSF notes) it permits relicensing to ... |
GNU Unifont is a fontface licensed under the GNU GPLv2 or later with this exception:
The license for the compiled fonts is covered by the above GPL terms
with the GNU font embedding exception, as follows:
As a special exception, if you create a document which uses this font, and embed this font or unaltered portions... | Based on the licensing terms you've provided for GNU Unifont, here are some key points to consider regarding your usage of the font in your game:
1. **Definition of "Document"**: The term "document" in the context of the GNU font embedding exception typically refers to any material that you create that uses the font, ... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "GNU Unifont is a fontface licensed under the GNU GPLv2 or later with this exception:\n\nThe license for the compiled fonts is covered by the above GPL terms\n with the GNU font embedding exception, as follows:\nAs a special exception, if you create a document which uses this fo... |
I am developing a software for commercial release which is developed ahead on a sample code provided by MSDN
This is mentioned in the beginning
// THIS CODE AND INFORMATION IS PROVIDED "AS IS" WITHOUT WARRANTY OF
// ANY KIND, EITHER EXPRESSED OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO
// THE IMPLIED WARRANTIES OF MERC... | You can use the sample code provided by Microsoft under the Microsoft Limited Public License version 1.1, but there are important considerations to keep in mind.
### Key Points from the License:
1. **Non-Exclusive, Royalty-Free License**: You are granted the right to reproduce, prepare derivative works, and distribut... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "I am developing a software for commercial release which is developed ahead on a sample code provided by MSDN \nThis is mentioned in the beginning\n// THIS CODE AND INFORMATION IS PROVIDED \"AS IS\" WITHOUT WARRANTY OF \n// ANY KIND, EITHER EXPRESSED OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT... |
I really like a specific open source project and would like to contribute to it. Unfortunately I don't know anything about programming. What are meaningful ways in which a non-programmer can contribute in a meaningful way to an open source project?
| Contributing to an open source project as a non-programmer can be very rewarding, and there are several meaningful ways to get involved. Here are some suggestions:
1. **Documentation**: Many open source projects need help with their documentation. This can include improving existing documentation, writing new guides, ... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "I really like a specific open source project and would like to contribute to it. Unfortunately I don't know anything about programming. What are meaningful ways in which a non-programmer can contribute in a meaningful way to an open source project?\n"
},
{
"from": "gpt",... |
Reading this question caused me to wonder: Is it even possible to keep a GPL-licensed software internal to one company?
Am I correct in thinking that any employee who has access to it, would be free to distribute it, either during his employment or after leaving? And also, that GPL specifically forbids stopping such di... | You're correct in your understanding of the GNU General Public License (GPL) and its implications for software distribution. Let's break down the points you raised:
1. **Internal Use of GPL Software**:
- The GPL allows you to use the software internally within your organization without any obligation to distribute... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "Reading this question caused me to wonder: Is it even possible to keep a GPL-licensed software internal to one company?\nAm I correct in thinking that any employee who has access to it, would be free to distribute it, either during his employment or after leaving? And also, that... |
I want to write a plugin for an open-source software which is not GPL, but has a GPL-compatible license (MIT/BSD). I would like the plugin to use a GPL library.
Can I do this?
My rationale:
Since the plugin links with a GPL library, the plugin is of course also GPL, which is fine.
In order to comply with GPL, all the ... | Your reasoning is mostly correct, but it's important to clarify a few points regarding the licensing implications of using a GPL library in your plugin for an open-source software that is licensed under a GPL-compatible license like MIT or BSD.
1. **Linking with GPL Libraries**: When you link your plugin with a GPL li... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "I want to write a plugin for an open-source software which is not GPL, but has a GPL-compatible license (MIT/BSD). I would like the plugin to use a GPL library.\nCan I do this?\nMy rationale:\n\nSince the plugin links with a GPL library, the plugin is of course also GPL, which i... |
With the rise of much licensing debate around here on Stack Exchange, there's been a lot of arguments about having a license closest to the status quo. Initially, I would've thought that the closest license would be the GPL, but I'm struck between the major copyleft victims: The GPL, LGPL, and the MPL.
I'm not so sure ... | You are correct in noting that the Mozilla Public License (MPL) and the Creative Commons ShareAlike (CC BY-SA) license share some similarities, particularly in how they handle licensing on a file or component basis.
### Key Similarities:
1. **File-Level Copyleft**: The MPL applies to individual files within a project... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "With the rise of much licensing debate around here on Stack Exchange, there's been a lot of arguments about having a license closest to the status quo. Initially, I would've thought that the closest license would be the GPL, but I'm struck between the major copyleft victims: The... |
I wrote a C++ library (that compiles to a dll that can be called in C#).
I would like it so that the library itself can never become proprietary but can be used in proprietary applications. If the proprietor makes any changes to the library code they have to publish only the code for the modified library and nothing el... | To achieve your goal of allowing the library to be used in proprietary applications while ensuring that any modifications to the library itself are shared, you might consider using a license that fits the following criteria:
1. **Permits proprietary use of the library**.
2. **Requires modifications to the library to b... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "I wrote a C++ library (that compiles to a dll that can be called in C#).\nI would like it so that the library itself can never become proprietary but can be used in proprietary applications. If the proprietor makes any changes to the library code they have to publish only the co... |
We use XPCOM technology to create XPCOM components for our Firefox add-on.
For creating any XPCOM component, Mozilla's XULRunner tool is needed as a development tool. XULRunner is under the Mozilla Public License.
My question is that will XULRunner's license affect the XPCOM component I created?
If yes, how?
If no ,... | The Mozilla Public License (MPL) under which XULRunner is licensed is a permissive open-source license. Here’s a breakdown of how this affects your development and the XPCOM components you create:
### 1. **Independence of Your Code**:
Your XPCOM components are separate pieces of software that you develop. If you are n... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "We use XPCOM technology to create XPCOM components for our Firefox add-on. \nFor creating any XPCOM component, Mozilla's XULRunner tool is needed as a development tool. XULRunner is under the Mozilla Public License. \nMy question is that will XULRunner's license affect the XPCOM... |
I have been researching the GNU and GPL licenses and I can't find a straight answer to a question I have. If you are going to use a Programming IDE that is distributed under a GNU GPL does the software made have to be covered under the the GNU GPL licenses or can it be sold?
Please note that this is not an improved v... | The GNU General Public License (GPL) is a copyleft license that ensures that any derivative works based on the licensed software also remain open and free under the same license. However, the situation with using a GPL-licensed IDE to develop new software is different.
If you use a programming IDE that is distributed ... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "I have been researching the GNU and GPL licenses and I can't find a straight answer to a question I have. If you are going to use a Programming IDE that is distributed under a GNU GPL does the software made have to be covered under the the GNU GPL licenses or can it be sold? \n... |
This website: https://html5up.net/ offers lots of HTML 5 themes using CC BY licenses. Can I create my own Wordpress theme based on these HTML 5 templates and sell on a theme market like https://themeforest.net/ ?
| Using HTML5 templates from HTML5 UP, which are licensed under the Creative Commons BY license, allows you to modify and distribute the templates as long as you provide appropriate credit to the original creator. However, there are some important considerations if you plan to create a WordPress theme based on these temp... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "This website: https://html5up.net/ offers lots of HTML 5 themes using CC BY licenses. Can I create my own Wordpress theme based on these HTML 5 templates and sell on a theme market like https://themeforest.net/ ?\n"
},
{
"from": "gpt",
"value": "Using HTML5 templates... |
In a project that I am working on, I would like to use the GNU GPL software license, but I also don't want to have any possible problems distributing my software.
For instance, there were some reports that GNU GPL apps were removed from the Apple App Store because the GNU GPL is not consistent with their terms of distr... | Your thought process regarding dual licensing under the GNU GPL and CC-BY-ND is an interesting approach, but there are some important considerations you should keep in mind.
### 1. **Compatibility of Licenses:**
The GNU General Public License (GPL) and Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivatives (CC-BY-ND) serve differ... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "In a project that I am working on, I would like to use the GNU GPL software license, but I also don't want to have any possible problems distributing my software.\nFor instance, there were some reports that GNU GPL apps were removed from the Apple App Store because the GNU GPL i... |
Memtest86 was originally licensed under the GPL, but its entire code was rewritten so its owners decided to remove the GPL license on newer versions of the program. Free Download Manager is another program that was originally licensed under the GPL but then had its code rewritten so that it can become closed-source.
It... | The question of whether it is ethical for developers to relicense software that was originally open-source under a proprietary license after rewriting the code is a nuanced one. Here are a few points to consider:
### Ownership and Copyright
1. **Legal Rights**: As you mentioned, the developers hold the copyright to t... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "Memtest86 was originally licensed under the GPL, but its entire code was rewritten so its owners decided to remove the GPL license on newer versions of the program. Free Download Manager is another program that was originally licensed under the GPL but then had its code rewritte... |
I understand that, generally speaking, you may not issue a license on a copyrighted work if you do not own the copyright to that work. Licensing is an exclusive right of the copyright holder. Instead, you may prepare a derivative your other people's work, and license your own changes under some license. Recipients of y... | Your understanding of copyright and licensing is largely correct, but there are some important clarifications to make regarding the MIT License and sublicensing.
The MIT License is a permissive free software license that allows you to do almost anything with the software, provided that the original copyright notice an... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "I understand that, generally speaking, you may not issue a license on a copyrighted work if you do not own the copyright to that work. Licensing is an exclusive right of the copyright holder. Instead, you may prepare a derivative your other people's work, and license your own ch... |
A development package I'd like to use is provided as Linux binaries for a single platform. I'd like to build and run it on another platform.
The manual, available on the developer's site but not included in the package, contains the following text (product/project names redacted):
Warranty and Copying
* This document i... | If you believe that the developer's approach to changing the licensing of their software is inappropriate, there are a few steps you can consider taking to communicate your concerns effectively:
1. **Understand the Situation**: Before approaching the developer, ensure you fully understand the implications of the licen... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "A development package I'd like to use is provided as Linux binaries for a single platform. I'd like to build and run it on another platform.\nThe manual, available on the developer's site but not included in the package, contains the following text (product/project names redacte... |
To license a project in GitHub, can I do it like this:
There are many files like src->Java, res, etc for my Android app
So I want to use Apache license v 2.0 for open sourcing it
So will the license apply if I use it in the header of one of my files(not all files) will it be open sourced or only that one file is open s... | To properly license your entire project on GitHub under the Apache License 2.0, you should follow a few key steps:
1. **Add a LICENSE file**: Create a file named `LICENSE` in the root directory of your repository. This file should contain the full text of the Apache License 2.0. This is the most common and clear way t... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "To license a project in GitHub, can I do it like this:\nThere are many files like src->Java, res, etc for my Android app\nSo I want to use Apache license v 2.0 for open sourcing it\nSo will the license apply if I use it in the header of one of my files(not all files) will it be ... |
We started to use an open source library in one of our projects, and now we need to do some custom modifications to this library. The source of this library is distributed under LGPL and I need some help in identifying whether we would violate LGPL terms/conditions if we follow an approach detailed below.
Facts:
The ... | Your proposed approach for modifying and using the open source library licensed under the LGPL generally aligns with the requirements of the LGPL (Lesser General Public License). However, there are several important considerations to ensure compliance:
1. **Modifications and Distribution**: The LGPL allows you to modi... | [
{
"from": "human",
"value": "We started to use an open source library in one of our projects, and now we need to do some custom modifications to this library. The source of this library is distributed under LGPL and I need some help in identifying whether we would violate LGPL terms/conditions if we follow ... |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.