instruction
stringlengths
57
20.2k
completion
stringlengths
4
5.16k
conversations
listlengths
2
2
MIT license says: The above copyright notice and this permission notice shall be included in all copies or substantial portions of the Software. How much is that substantial portion? For example: is using half of some helper function defined in that software substantial or not?
The term "substantial portion" in the context of the MIT License is not explicitly defined, and its interpretation can vary depending on the context of the use and the specific software involved. In general, "substantial" is often understood in terms of significance, rather than a strict quantitative measure like a spe...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "MIT license says:\n\nThe above copyright notice and this permission notice shall be included in\n all copies or substantial portions of the Software.\n\nHow much is that substantial portion?\nFor example: is using half of some helper function defined in that software substantia...
I am planning on selling software which is licensed under GPL 3. I have gone through the terms and conditions listed in the GPL 3 license. However, I would like to know if any of the following scenarios will violate the GPL 3 license: Can I charge the customer for software? This includes selling the software as well a...
The GNU General Public License (GPL) v3 is designed to ensure freedom for users of software licensed under it. Here's how it applies to your scenarios: 1. **Charging for Software and Support**: You can charge for software licensed under the GPL v3. This includes selling the software itself and charging for technical s...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I am planning on selling software which is licensed under GPL 3. I have gone through the terms and conditions listed in the GPL 3 license. However, I would like to know if any of the following scenarios will violate the GPL 3 license:\n\nCan I charge the customer for software? T...
I'm using LGPL binaries, as well as EPL binaries for my open source project. Is this OK? And if yes, does that mean I should license my project under LGPL? The binaries are being used as dependencies for the project i.e. I'm just using them as-is without making changes to them.
Using LGPL (Lesser General Public License) and EPL (Eclipse Public License) binaries in your open-source project is generally permissible, but there are important considerations to keep in mind regarding licensing and compliance: 1. **LGPL Binaries**: - The LGPL allows you to link to the library without requiring y...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I'm using LGPL binaries, as well as EPL binaries for my open source project. Is this OK? And if yes, does that mean I should license my project under LGPL?\nThe binaries are being used as dependencies for the project i.e. I'm just using them as-is without making changes to them....
I apologize in advance for what is probably a dumb question, but I'm trying to do this the right way from the beginning. I'm putting together a coding tutorial site, and my main question boils down to this: how do I allow "good guys" to use my code for whatever they want, but prevent "bad guys" from copying my entire s...
Your concerns about balancing openness with protection against misuse are valid and reflect a common dilemma faced by educators and content creators. Here are some strategies and considerations to help you navigate this situation: ### 1. Licensing Options: - **Creative Commons (CC) Licenses**: If you want to share tex...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I apologize in advance for what is probably a dumb question, but I'm trying to do this the right way from the beginning.\nI'm putting together a coding tutorial site, and my main question boils down to this: how do I allow \"good guys\" to use my code for whatever they want, but...
I have recently created a small project and pushed it to GitHub. I now plan on applying an open-source license. Once I choose a license and commit it to the project, are the older versions subjected to that license?
Yes, once you choose an open-source license and commit it to your project, that license applies to all versions of the project, including older versions. When you add a license file (like `LICENSE` or `LICENSE.txt`) to your repository and commit it, that license retroactively applies to all previous commits. However, ...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I have recently created a small project and pushed it to GitHub. I now plan on applying an open-source license. Once I choose a license and commit it to the project, are the older versions subjected to that license?\n" }, { "from": "gpt", "value": "Yes, once you choo...
In some documents or blogs about development in open source projects, you can read stuff like 'upstream developer' or 'upstream fix'. What does that mean?
In the context of open source development, the terms "upstream" and "upstream developer" refer to the primary or original source of a project, repository, or codebase from which other forks or distributions are derived. Here’s a breakdown of the terms: 1. **Upstream**: This term typically indicates the original projec...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "In some documents or blogs about development in open source projects, you can read stuff like 'upstream developer' or 'upstream fix'. What does that mean?\n" }, { "from": "gpt", "value": "In the context of open source development, the terms \"upstream\" and \"upstrea...
I've a proprietary program which is using OOP classes which I want to publish as FOSS (only the classes). Which FOSS compatible license I can choose for the classes which will work with my proprietary program which I'm selling? I was thinking about GNU GPL, but if I understand correctly, I've to distribute my entire pr...
You're correct in your understanding that the GNU General Public License (GPL) has strong copyleft provisions, meaning that if you distribute software that incorporates GPL-licensed components, you are generally required to release the entire combined work under the GPL as well. If you want to publish your OOP classes...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I've a proprietary program which is using OOP classes which I want to publish as FOSS (only the classes).\nWhich FOSS compatible license I can choose for the classes which will work with my proprietary program which I'm selling?\nI was thinking about GNU GPL, but if I understand...
When a creator posts content to any Stack Exchange site, they grant Stack Exchange a Creative Commons Attribute Share-Alike license to use (and display and share) the content. This is irrevocable - even if you choose to delete your post, or a moderator deletes your post, Stack Exchange still has a license to use it. St...
Linking to a deleted post while providing the required attribution information can be a bit complex in terms of Creative Commons (CC) rules, especially considering the accessibility of the content. According to the CC BY-SA license, proper attribution must include a link to the material. However, since the post is dele...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "When a creator posts content to any Stack Exchange site, they grant Stack Exchange a Creative Commons Attribute Share-Alike license to use (and display and share) the content. This is irrevocable - even if you choose to delete your post, or a moderator deletes your post, Stack E...
I was looking to override a class in rt.jar with my own version (to guarantee that existing legacy code remains unbroken). With Oracle's JDK, it says the following for the -Xbootclasspath/p:path option: Do not deploy applications that use this option to override a class in rt.jar, because this violates the JRE binary ...
Using the `-Xbootclasspath/p:path` option to override classes in the JRE (such as those in `rt.jar`) can be a useful technique in some scenarios, but you need to be aware of the licensing implications. **Oracle JDK:** As you mentioned, Oracle's JDK explicitly states that using this option to override classes in `rt.ja...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I was looking to override a class in rt.jar with my own version (to guarantee that existing legacy code remains unbroken).\nWith Oracle's JDK, it says the following for the -Xbootclasspath/p:path option:\n\nDo not deploy applications that use this option to override a class in r...
In its anatomy browser BioDigital has a feature where the website displays text that it doesn't license under CC BY-SA. At the end of that text the user can click on "Read more". If he does an inline popup appears showing information from Wikipedia mobile. This popup refers at it's end to being licensed CC-BY-SA. Is it...
The use of content under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike (CC BY-SA) license alongside content that is not licensed under the same terms can be complex, but here's a general overview: 1. **Attribution Requirement**: The CC BY-SA license requires that proper attribution is given to the original source of the...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "In its anatomy browser BioDigital has a feature where the website displays text that it doesn't license under CC BY-SA. At the end of that text the user can click on \"Read more\". If he does an inline popup appears showing information from Wikipedia mobile. This popup refers at...
I have a web app that I sell. It is a Java REST service with an AngularJS front end. I want to use a Javascript library that is licensed under the AGPL but I don't understand the implications or if it is OK for me to use it. Specifically, I don't understand the modifying/linking/usage parts and how it applies and what...
The GNU Affero General Public License (AGPL) has specific requirements that can significantly impact how you can distribute your software if it incorporates code licensed under the AGPL. Here’s a breakdown based on your questions: ### 1. **Does the AGPL mean I have to distribute my source code that is using this libra...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I have a web app that I sell.\nIt is a Java REST service with an AngularJS front end.\nI want to use a Javascript library that is licensed under the AGPL but I don't understand the implications or if it is OK for me to use it. \nSpecifically, I don't understand the modifying/lin...
EDIT: It should be noted that this question appears to have only historical relevance now that LinkedIn has discontinued the requirement to indicate how you know a contact when adding them a while ago. While I have a day-to-day job, I consider my open source contributions to be a part of my professional life. I highli...
It sounds like you're navigating the nuances of professional networking on LinkedIn, especially in the context of open source contributions. Since LinkedIn has updated its policies, removing the requirement to indicate how you know a contact, you might find it easier to connect without feeling constrained by those opti...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "EDIT: It should be noted that this question appears to have only historical relevance now that LinkedIn has discontinued the requirement to indicate how you know a contact when adding them a while ago.\n\nWhile I have a day-to-day job, I consider my open source contributions to ...
In October 2015, Red Hat acquired Ansible, the developer of the famous configuration management software Ansible, apparently for a price of about $100M. Ansible, the software, AFAIK is licensed fully under the GPL. Ansible, the company, does however also develop an extension to the software called Tower that, as I unde...
Red Hat's acquisition of Ansible in 2015 for around $100 million can be understood through several strategic and business considerations: 1. **Access to Talent**: Acquiring Ansible also meant gaining access to the talent and expertise of its developers and engineers. This team was instrumental in building and enhancin...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "In October 2015, Red Hat acquired Ansible, the developer of the famous configuration management software Ansible, apparently for a price of about $100M.\nAnsible, the software, AFAIK is licensed fully under the GPL. Ansible, the company, does however also develop an extension to...
Many IP cores especially from Xilinx have an AXI interface from ARM. The AXI interface standard is free for download (after registration), but I don't think it's free for implementation. So I assume Xilinx has bought an AMBA license to equip its IP cores with AXI interfaces. I don't have such license. Can I offer AXI i...
The use of AXI (Advanced eXtensible Interface) and other AMBA (Advanced Microcontroller Bus Architecture) protocols is indeed subject to licensing by ARM. As you noted, many companies, including Xilinx, have licenses to use these protocols in their IP cores. The licenses typically cover the use of the specification and...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "Many IP cores especially from Xilinx have an AXI interface from ARM.\nThe AXI interface standard is free for download (after registration), but I don't think it's free for implementation. So I assume Xilinx has bought an AMBA license to equip its IP cores with AXI interfaces.\nI...
My project is a fork of a project that comes with the MIT license and nobody wants to change the license that applies to the software. However, some of the content that is also stored on GitHub is not freely available. We have permission to use some of the photos for this project only. If they were to show up in a fork...
Yes, it's a good idea to add a clarification regarding the specific rights and restrictions associated with the photographic content, especially since it is not freely available and you have permission to use it only for your project. You could include an additional line in your README or license file that specifies ...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "My project is a fork of a project that comes with the MIT license and nobody wants to change the license that applies to the software. However, some of the content that is also stored on GitHub is not freely available. We have permission to use some of the photos for this projec...
If you go to the Google search site:https://themeforest.net/item/ This item is licensed 100% GPL, you will find a lot of GPL themes. Is it legal to use a theme which I buy once in multiple sites? (Please use "Yes" or "No" and simple English.)
Yes.
[ { "from": "human", "value": "If you go to the Google search site:https://themeforest.net/item/ This item is licensed 100% GPL, you will find a lot of GPL themes. \nIs it legal to use a theme which I buy once in multiple sites?\n(Please use \"Yes\" or \"No\" and simple English.)\n" }, { "from": "gpt"...
As I said in the title I have created a software that contains a library that has FOSS license.. 1) can I distribute my project with proprietary license (either sell it or give it for free) ? 2) If not, what should I do? This is the software license.
When dealing with Free and Open Source Software (FOSS) licenses, the ability to distribute your project under a proprietary license depends largely on the specifics of the FOSS license that applies to the library you're using. Here’s a general breakdown: 1. **Can you distribute your project with a proprietary license?...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "As I said in the title I have created a software that contains a library that has FOSS license..\n1) can I distribute my project with proprietary license (either sell it or give it for free) ?\n2) If not, what should I do?\nThis is the software license.\n" }, { "from": "...
Until now, we have not had an application version strategy or version-ed our application. We are considering doing so with our next release. What are the minimum tasks necessary to transition to a version-ed application? Answers in the form of bullet points, not necessarily in chronological order would be sufficient. I...
Transitioning to a versioned application involves several key tasks to ensure a smooth implementation. Here’s a high-level list of minimum tasks to consider: - **Establish Versioning Scheme**: Determine a version control naming convention (e.g., Major.Minor.Build.Revision) and define what constitutes a major, minor, a...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "Until now, we have not had an application version strategy or version-ed our application. We are considering doing so with our next release. What are the minimum tasks necessary to transition to a version-ed application? Answers in the form of bullet points, not necessarily in c...
Currently, all user submitted content is licensed under "cc by-sa 3.0 with attribution required". This shows up at the bottom of each page: user contributions licensed under cc by-sa 3.0 with attribution required Is material that is submitted to Stack Exchange under this license compatible with the GPL? The reason t...
The compatibility of licenses is an important consideration when dealing with content, especially when it comes to the combination of different licenses in software and documentation. The Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 (CC BY-SA 3.0) license, under which user contributions to Stack Exchange are licensed, ...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "Currently, all user submitted content is licensed under \"cc by-sa 3.0 with attribution required\". This shows up at the bottom of each page:\n\nuser contributions licensed under cc by-sa 3.0 with attribution required\n\nIs material that is submitted to Stack Exchange under thi...
I have an open source project on GitHub that is currently under the MIT license. The "project" is actually a README file containing information on a variety of new language and library features, complete with examples, on C++. Think of it as a cheatsheet or a small book on C++. With this in mind, I have a few question...
When it comes to open source licenses like the MIT License, there are a few important
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I have an open source project on GitHub that is currently under the MIT license. The \"project\" is actually a README file containing information on a variety of new language and library features, complete with examples, on C++. Think of it as a cheatsheet or a small book on C++...
If you go to the Google search site:https://themeforest.net/item/ This item is licensed 100% GPL, you will find a lot of GPL themes. Is it legal to use a theme which I buy once in multiple sites? (Please use "Yes" or "No" and simple English.)
Yes.
[ { "from": "human", "value": "If you go to the Google search site:https://themeforest.net/item/ This item is licensed 100% GPL, you will find a lot of GPL themes. \nIs it legal to use a theme which I buy once in multiple sites?\n(Please use \"Yes\" or \"No\" and simple English.)\n" }, { "from": "gpt"...
If you go to the Google search site:https://themeforest.net/item/ This item is licensed 100% GPL, you will find a lot of GPL themes. Is it legal to use a theme which I buy once in multiple sites? (Please use "Yes" or "No" and simple English.)
Yes.
[ { "from": "human", "value": "If you go to the Google search site:https://themeforest.net/item/ This item is licensed 100% GPL, you will find a lot of GPL themes. \nIs it legal to use a theme which I buy once in multiple sites?\n(Please use \"Yes\" or \"No\" and simple English.)\n" }, { "from": "gpt"...
I've read lots of discussion on shipping commercial products that link against GPLv2/3 libraries, and products that include code from GPLv2/3 software. But I haven't been able to satisfactorily answer my question about shipping a commercial product that uses GPLv2/3 binaries. Specifically, I'd like to bundle a modified...
Your situation revolves around the use of GPL-licensed binaries in a commercial product. Here's a breakdown of the key points regarding the GPL and your scenario: 1. **Execution of GPL Binaries**: The GPL permits you to use GPL-licensed binaries by executing them and reading their output. This usage does not constitut...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I've read lots of discussion on shipping commercial products that link against GPLv2/3 libraries, and products that include code from GPLv2/3 software. But I haven't been able to satisfactorily answer my question about shipping a commercial product that uses GPLv2/3 binaries.\nS...
From the Wikipedia article on Linux: The Linux kernel is licensed explicitly only under version 2 of the GPL, without offering the licensee the option to choose "any later version", which is a common GPL extension. There was a debate over how easily it could be changed to use later GPL versions such as version 3 and w...
The statement in the COPYING file you referenced indicates that the Linux kernel is licensed under "version 2 of the License, or (at your option) any later version," which means that, while the original authors of the Linux kernel chose to license it under GPL version 2 specifically, they allow licensees to use any lat...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "From the Wikipedia article on Linux:\n\nThe Linux kernel is licensed explicitly only under version 2 of the GPL, without offering the licensee the option to choose \"any later version\", which is a common GPL extension. There was a debate over how easily it could be changed to u...
Say I create an Open Source project on Github licensed under e.g. LGPL like Qt. As I understand ownership of code, if I wrote a piece of code, I am free to change the license at a later point, as long as I keep a LGPL version of the old code. This could be because I want to further develop it into a solution I want to ...
When you create an open-source project and license it under the LGPL (or any other open-source license), you retain ownership of the code you originally wrote. However, the situation becomes more complex when others contribute to your project, such as through pull requests. Here's how it generally works: 1. **Ownersh...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "Say I create an Open Source project on Github licensed under e.g. LGPL like Qt. As I understand ownership of code, if I wrote a piece of code, I am free to change the license at a later point, as long as I keep a LGPL version of the old code. This could be because I want to furt...
I came across a library on GitHub (now Zlib/Libpng licensed) that is a fork of a library that was originally released under the Boost software license. Is it legitimate/legal to relicense boost software under the zlib license? I guess the Boost license doesn't explicitly deny nor explicitly allow relicensing as far a...
The Boost Software License is a permissive license, which generally allows users to do almost anything with the code as long as certain conditions are met. It typically allows for modification, redistribution, and even commercial use without requiring the original license to be preserved. Here are a few points to cons...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I came across a library on GitHub (now Zlib/Libpng licensed) that is a fork of a library that was originally released under the Boost software license. \nIs it legitimate/legal to relicense boost software under the zlib license? \nI guess the Boost license doesn't explicitly den...
I have an algorithm. I'd like to publish this in an open access journal under the creative commons license. But I'm also considering a patent. How do these processes sit together? Does publishing in this way, or in any way for that matter, essentially preclude the chance of holding on to commercial rights, however thes...
When considering both publishing your algorithm in an open access journal and filing for a patent, it's important to understand the implications of each action on your intellectual property rights. 1. **Patentability and Prior Disclosure**: Most jurisdictions require that the invention must be novel to qualify for a p...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I have an algorithm. I'd like to publish this in an open access journal under the creative commons license. But I'm also considering a patent. How do these processes sit together? Does publishing in this way, or in any way for that matter, essentially preclude the chance of hold...
A few years ago I started working on an open-source project, but things continued and now--years later--I currently maintain my own branch of the project. The project currently resides on GitHub. The project has the boilerplate MIT license and copyright on every file in the project. I have simply been copy/pasting this...
When it comes to copyright and licensing in open-source projects, here are some considerations based on your situation: ### 1. Including Yourself in the Copyright If you have contributed significant original code or modifications to the project, you may want to include yourself in the copyright notice. Generally, the...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "A few years ago I started working on an open-source project, but things continued and now--years later--I currently maintain my own branch of the project. The project currently resides on GitHub.\nThe project has the boilerplate MIT license and copyright on every file in the pro...
I am wondering if forking a repo of software I use in case the owner ever decides to remove it is a silly thing to do or whether it actually makes sense. It seems like the repo could just disappear if the author decides to delete it and if I don't have it cloned locally, I would lose access unless I had previously made...
Forking a repository can be a sensible precaution, especially for software that you rely on. Here are some reasons why it can make sense to fork: 1. **Preservation**: If the original repository is deleted or made private, having a fork ensures you still have access to the codebase. This is particularly important for p...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I am wondering if forking a repo of software I use in case the owner ever decides to remove it is a silly thing to do or whether it actually makes sense.\nIt seems like the repo could just disappear if the author decides to delete it and if I don't have it cloned locally, I woul...
We are using Qt(5.3.2 - opensource) for one of our applications that we are going to be distributing (closed-source). We dynamically link to Qt and have made no modifications to Qt. At Qt's Legal FAQ, they list the necessary obligations for using Qt under the LGPL. We understand and agree with their interpretation of ...
Your question touches on some nuanced aspects of the LGPLv3 and how it pertains to the distribution of libraries like Qt. Here are some clarifications regarding your points: 1. **Self-Hosting the Source Code**: According to the LGPLv3, if you dynamically link against a library, you are required to provide the source c...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "We are using Qt(5.3.2 - opensource) for one of our applications that we are going to be distributing (closed-source). We dynamically link to Qt and have made no modifications to Qt. \nAt Qt's Legal FAQ, they list the necessary obligations for using Qt under the LGPL. We understa...
In a recent question on programmers.SE†, it was asked whether a project is open source if it provides some source code but doesn't make it clear how to actually compile it. Consensus is that it's not required for compilation to be easy, but that raises the question where to draw the line between non-obvious and impossi...
The question of whether the company is violating the GPL revolves around the obligations that come with distributing GPL-licensed code. The GPL requires that when a binary is distributed, the corresponding source code must also be made available. However, it does not specify that the source code must be provided in a f...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "In a recent question on programmers.SE†, it was asked whether a project is open source if it provides some source code but doesn't make it clear how to actually compile it. Consensus is that it's not required for compilation to be easy, but that raises the question where to draw...
I wonder whether Open Source libraries used within firmware burnt (in flash or ROM) in an IC that is sold to customers building products with it requires the final manufacturer to give credits (attribution) to the OSS project. Perhaps this is better described with an example: IC Manufacturer A builds a new chip that co...
In the scenario you've described, whether Manufacturer B is obliged to credit the open-source project depends primarily on the licensing terms of the specific open-source software used and how it is distributed. ### 3-Clause BSD License The 3-Clause BSD license is a permissive open-source license. Its main requiremen...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I wonder whether Open Source libraries used within firmware burnt (in flash or ROM) in an IC that is sold to customers building products with it requires the final manufacturer to give credits (attribution) to the OSS project.\nPerhaps this is better described with an example:\n...
I've been playing around with my own router and found DD-WRT as an open source firmware alternative for this kind of device but I can't find something equivalent for modems. Can you recommend something?
While there are several open-source firmware options for routers, the landscape for modems is quite different. Most consumer modems do not have the same level of support for open-source firmware as routers do. This is primarily because modems often require certification from your Internet Service Provider (ISP) and are...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I've been playing around with my own router and found DD-WRT as an open source firmware alternative for this kind of device but I can't find something equivalent for modems. Can you recommend something?\n" }, { "from": "gpt", "value": "While there are several open-so...
This question stems from discussion of a question on programmers.stackexchange.com. In the LGPL 3.0 section 4 "Combined Works" it states: You may convey a Combined Work under terms of your choice that, taken together, effectively do not restrict modification of the portions of the Library contained in the Combined...
To clarify the relationship between "combined works" and "derivative works" in the context of the LGPL (Lesser General Public License) and software licensing in general: 1. **Definitions**: - **Derivative Work**: This is typically a work that is based upon one or more existing works and includes modifications, adap...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "This question stems from discussion of a question on programmers.stackexchange.com.\nIn the LGPL 3.0 section 4 \"Combined Works\" it states:\n\nYou may convey a Combined Work under terms of your choice that,\n taken together, effectively do not restrict modification of the\n p...
In trying to deal with a codebase that was originally proprietary and then open sourced, new contributors are coming along. Each file has names on it (though usually the main author's). At this point, the codebase is drifting considerably. Maintaining a list of names in each file seems to clutter it, and introduces a...
You're considering some valid points regarding how to manage author attribution in an open-source codebase, especially one that has shifted from proprietary to open-source. The approach you're thinking about—removing individual names from the files and moving that information to a separate CONTRIBUTORS or CREDITS file—...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "In trying to deal with a codebase that was originally proprietary and then open sourced, new contributors are coming along. Each file has names on it (though usually the main author's).\nAt this point, the codebase is drifting considerably. Maintaining a list of names in each ...
I would like to fork a repository on GitHub (let's call this A) so that I can modify a few things. If I were to try and make a pull request, I don't think it would be merged as they changed the focus of that project, and it's not active. A is registered under the Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 license. If I create a ...
Yes, you can create a new repository (B) based on a repository (A) that is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 license, but there are some important considerations to keep in mind: 1. **License Compliance**: The Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 license requires that you give appropriate credit to the o...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I would like to fork a repository on GitHub (let's call this A) so that I can modify a few things. If I were to try and make a pull request, I don't think it would be merged as they changed the focus of that project, and it's not active.\nA is registered under the Creative Commo...
We're living in freedom of speech community. However when writing controversial books, are there any topics which are not allowed to write about in First World countries (even for educational purposes)? How do you know when you cross the line? One example could be Uncle Fester books or WikiLeaks which are the borderlin...
In First World countries, the principle of freedom of speech allows for a wide range of topics to be explored in literature, including controversial subjects. However, there are still certain boundaries and legal considerations that authors should be aware of: 1. **Hate Speech**: While individuals have the right to ex...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "We're living in freedom of speech community.\nHowever when writing controversial books, are there any topics which are not allowed to write about in First World countries (even for educational purposes)? How do you know when you cross the line?\nOne example could be Uncle Fester...
Example GPL v3 Project, MIT (ExPat) file/directory. myproject ├── LICENSE (GPL v3) ├── ... ├── gpl_licensed_file ├── mit_licensed_directory │   └── mit_file1 └── mit_licensed_file So If I were looking at this project, I would have on way to know that mit_licensed_directory and mit_licensed_file were not under the pri...
To clearly denote that certain files or directories within a project are licensed under different licenses from the primary license declared in the LICENSE file, you can follow these best practices: 1. **Add a Notice in Each File/Directory**: For files or directories that are licensed differently, include a comment at...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "Example\nGPL v3 Project, MIT (ExPat) file/directory.\nmyproject\n├── LICENSE (GPL v3)\n├── ...\n├── gpl_licensed_file\n├── mit_licensed_directory\n│   └── mit_file1\n└── mit_licensed_file\n\n\nSo If I were looking at this project, I would have on way to know that mit_licensed_di...
Are there any licenses considered free by the OSI and not by the FSF and Vice Versa? They both seem to further the same point, and all the licenses I saw they both agreed that it was either free or not. Do they ever disagree?
Yes, there are indeed instances where the Open Source Initiative (OSI) and the Free Software Foundation (FSF) have differing opinions on certain licenses, leading to some licenses being considered "free" by one organization but not by the other. ### OSI vs. FSF Perspectives 1. **Definition of Freedom**: - The FSF'...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "Are there any licenses considered free by the OSI and not by the FSF and Vice Versa?\nThey both seem to further the same point, and all the licenses I saw they both agreed that it was either free or not.\nDo they ever disagree? \n" }, { "from": "gpt", "value": "Yes,...
I've found a few open-source software projects and I'd like to run my own websites regarding them, but not claiming to own them; just make a place where information and such can be found. I believe I can do this and nobody can stop me for the following of reasons, among possibly others: It's open-source, so I can host...
While your intentions may be rooted in a desire to create a community and provide resources around open-source projects, there are several important legal and ethical considerations to keep in mind when doing so: 1. **Open Source Licensing**: Even if a project is open source, it is essential to comply with the specifi...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I've found a few open-source software projects and I'd like to run my own websites regarding them, but not claiming to own them; just make a place where information and such can be found. I believe I can do this and nobody can stop me for the following of reasons, among possibly...
I have just wrote a program and would like to release it dual-license (probably AGPL and proprietary, but I also would like to retain the ability to release it under other licenses in the future). I want to welcome patches from the future community, but merging should not compromise the goal above, so if I understand c...
The two options you’re encountering in the Harmony Agreement Selector—Copyright License Agreement (CLA) and Copyright Assignment Agreement (CAA)—are distinct approaches to managing contributions from external developers. Here’s a breakdown of the differences between them: ### 1. Copyright License Agreement (CLA) - **W...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I have just wrote a program and would like to release it dual-license (probably AGPL and proprietary, but I also would like to retain the ability to release it under other licenses in the future).\nI want to welcome patches from the future community, but merging should not compr...
The Json license has an appendix where it says: The Software shall be used for Good, not Evil. If I want to use a library with the Json license am I forced to add this quote to my license? Update: Changed the title so that its question and text ask the same question
The phrase "The Software shall be used for Good, not Evil" is a part of the JSON license, which is a permissive license. This phrase is intended to be more of a guiding principle or a philosophical statement rather than a strict legal requirement. When you use a library that is licensed under the JSON license, you are...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "The Json license has an appendix where it says: \n\nThe Software shall be used for Good, not Evil.\n\nIf I want to use a library with the Json license am I forced to add this quote to my license? \nUpdate: Changed the title so that its question and text ask the same question\...
I'm planning on open-sourcing an application soon, and I've settled on either GPLv3 or the Mozilla Public License 2.0, as this application has a massive community surrounding it, and I still want other people to have to disclose source code for modified versions. The application is a standalone executable, but I can se...
It sounds like you have a complex situation to navigate with your open-source application, especially considering the licensing implications and the potential distribution methods. Let’s break down some of your concerns: 1. **GPLv3 and the App Store**: You're correct that the GPLv3 has specific terms that can conflict...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I'm planning on open-sourcing an application soon, and I've settled on either GPLv3 or the Mozilla Public License 2.0, as this application has a massive community surrounding it, and I still want other people to have to disclose source code for modified versions.\nThe applicatio...
I recently started using an open source library for a project I'm working on. Let's call it Dasypus. It's an established library that's been around for a number of years. As I got to know Dasypus better, I found some missing features from the API. These features would be easy to implement and wouldn't upset the existin...
To effectively communicate your ideas for new features in the Dasypus library and convince the author that these changes are worthwhile, you can take the following steps: 1. **Research and Prepare**: Make sure you fully understand the library and its existing API. Clearly outline the features you believe are missing, ...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I recently started using an open source library for a project I'm working on. Let's call it Dasypus. It's an established library that's been around for a number of years.\nAs I got to know Dasypus better, I found some missing features from the API. These features would be easy t...
Just noticed this in the linux's kernel code main.c: * Copyright (C) 1991, 1992 Linus Torvalds * Copyright 2007 rPath, Inc. - All Rights Reserved * Copyright 2009 Intel Corporation; author H. Peter Anvin How do they apply to the kernel? It seems really strange to me, also because the next line is: * This f...
The copyright notices and licensing terms you see in the Linux kernel code serve to establish ownership of the code and set the rules under which the code can be used, modified, and distributed. 1. **Copyright Notices**: - The copyright notices indicate who holds the rights to the code in the file. In your example...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "Just noticed this in the linux's kernel code main.c:\n * Copyright (C) 1991, 1992 Linus Torvalds\n * Copyright 2007 rPath, Inc. - All Rights Reserved\n * Copyright 2009 Intel Corporation; author H. Peter Anvin\n\nHow do they apply to the kernel? It seems really strange to ...
I'm a bit confused on how CDDL interfaces with other licences. If I want to modify an existing CDDL project, by introducing an extension — implementing a certain feature in a new file — can I affix my copyright statement in such a new file on top of a BSD licence, instead of a CDDL header? Can I publish the result as a...
The Common Development and Distribution License (CDDL) is a copyleft license, meaning that any modifications to CDDL-licensed code must also be distributed under the same license. When you introduce an extension to an existing CDDL project, there are several important considerations regarding licensing: 1. **New File ...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I'm a bit confused on how CDDL interfaces with other licences.\nIf I want to modify an existing CDDL project, by introducing an extension — implementing a certain feature in a new file — can I affix my copyright statement in such a new file on top of a BSD licence, instead of a ...
In a recent question on programmers.SE†, it was asked whether a project is open source if it provides some source code but doesn't make it clear how to actually compile it. Consensus is that it's not required for compilation to be easy, but that raises the question where to draw the line between non-obvious and impossi...
The question of whether the company is violating the GPL in your scenario hinges on the GPL's requirements regarding source code availability and the ability to build the binary. The GNU General Public License (GPL) mandates that when a program is distributed in binary form, the corresponding source code must also be ...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "In a recent question on programmers.SE†, it was asked whether a project is open source if it provides some source code but doesn't make it clear how to actually compile it. Consensus is that it's not required for compilation to be easy, but that raises the question where to draw...
I have a repository (a website) available on Github which contains code, media and texts. Everything is freely available (either on the website or via the code on Github). I want to let the code available under an open source license (MIT, for example), but I don't want the license to apply on media and texts. These ar...
Yes, you can specify different licensing terms for different parts of your repository on GitHub. Here’s how you can do it: ### 1. Use the MIT License (or other open-source licenses) for the Code You can include an `LICENSE` file in your repository to specify that the code is licensed under the MIT License (or another...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I have a repository (a website) available on Github which contains code, media and texts.\nEverything is freely available (either on the website or via the code on Github). I want to let the code available under an open source license (MIT, for example), but I don't want the lic...
In a comment on my question What if anything is wrong with the Apache License 2.0? someone (Zimm) reminded me that its considered bad practice to use a less widely known license. How wildly known is the COIL license? How wildly used are copyfree licenses in general? Jeff Atwood's recommendation of the WTFPL license in ...
Determining how widely known a license is, as well as assessing the popularity and use of specific licensing categories (like copyfree licenses), involves several approaches. Here are some pointers you can use to gather this information: ### 1. **Research Existing Data Sources** - **License Popularity Metrics**: We...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "In a comment on my question What if anything is wrong with the Apache License 2.0?\nsomeone (Zimm) reminded me that its considered bad practice to use a less widely known license.\nHow wildly known is the COIL license?\nHow wildly used are copyfree licenses in general?\nJeff Atw...
I want to release a pre-alpha software for preview. I do not want to put the code in an open repository like GitHub yet because it is just a prototype and I intend to re-design parts. The package I am releasing contains the HTML/JS source which is bundled in a single file and is not uglified/minified. However, I defin...
Given your project's characteristics and objectives, it's important to choose a license that aligns with your desire to keep your core code open-source while allowing for flexible use and modification by others. Here's a breakdown of your situation and recommendations: ### License Recommendations 1. **Mozilla Public ...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I want to release a pre-alpha software for preview. I do not want to put the code in an open repository like GitHub yet because it is just a prototype and I intend to re-design parts. The package I am releasing contains the HTML/JS source which is bundled in a single file and is...
How do Open Source projects audit code to ensure it comes from ethical sources. For example, if a hacker hacks into IBM, steals some code and contributes it to the kernel, how does the kernel team ensure that it doesn't get into the kernel?
Auditing code in open-source projects to ensure it comes from ethical sources is a significant challenge, but many open-source communities, including the Linux kernel community, implement various practices and tools to mitigate the risks of incorporating malicious or compromised code. Here are some key approaches: ###...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "How do Open Source projects audit code to ensure it comes from ethical sources. For example, if a hacker hacks into IBM, steals some code and contributes it to the kernel, how does the kernel team ensure that it doesn't get into the kernel?\n" }, { "from": "gpt", "va...
I found that FSF considers proprietary software to be unethical (bold emphasis mine): Proprietary Software Is Often Malware Proprietary software, also called nonfree software, means software that doesn't respect users' freedom and community. This means that its developer or owner has power over its users. This power i...
The Open Source Initiative (OSI) has a different perspective on software licensing and the distinctions between open source and proprietary software compared to the Free Software Foundation (FSF). While the FSF emphasizes the ethical implications of software freedom, the OSI focuses primarily on the practical aspects o...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I found that FSF considers proprietary software to be unethical (bold emphasis mine):\n\nProprietary Software Is Often Malware\nProprietary software, also called nonfree software, means software that doesn't respect users' freedom and community. This means that its developer or ...
I recently saw something like this: Copyright (c) Some Corporation All rights reserved. MIT License ... And then the MIT license follows. Now, from what I know the MIT license is one of the most permissive licenses. Is it correct to add All rights reserved. in this context?
Yes, it is technically possible to include the phrase "All rights reserved" in a document that also contains the MIT License. However, doing so can lead to confusion about the intent of the licensing terms. The MIT License is indeed a permissive license that allows for wide use, modification, and distribution of the s...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I recently saw something like this:\nCopyright (c) Some Corporation\n\nAll rights reserved.\n\nMIT License\n\n...\n\nAnd then the MIT license follows. Now, from what I know the MIT license is one of the most permissive licenses. Is it correct to add All rights reserved. in this ...
The UIUC license contains the clauses Redistributions of source code must retain the above copyright notice, this list of conditions and the following disclaimers. Redistributions in binary form must reproduce the above copyright notice, this list of conditions and the following disclaimers in the documentation a...
The UIUC (University of Illinois/NCSA) license, as you've noted, contains specific clauses regarding the redistribution of source code and binary forms. In the context of your question about compiling a project that includes code licensed under UIUC using Emscripten, we need to differentiate between source code and bin...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "The UIUC license contains the clauses\n\n\nRedistributions of source code must retain the above copyright notice,\n this list of conditions and the following disclaimers.\nRedistributions in binary form must reproduce the above copyright notice, this list of\n conditions and t...
So what I'm planning to do is to create a script which one part calls (via Python's subprocess) external open source script licensed under GPL-2. To make it easier for users I'd like to distribute the GPL-2'ed script with with my own so that call could be easily done on the correct version of software. (I want to use ...
The scenario you're describing involves the interaction between your script and an external script licensed under GPL-2. Here are some important points to consider regarding GPL licensing: 1. **Calling the GPL-2 Script**: If your script merely calls the GPL-2 script through a subprocess and does not include any GPL-2 ...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "So what I'm planning to do is to create a script which one part calls (via Python's subprocess) external open source script licensed under GPL-2. To make it easier for users I'd like to distribute the GPL-2'ed script with with my own so that call could be easily done on the cor...
I am currently working on an EPUB project in which I'll embed a font licensed under OFL. According to the second point in the PERMISSION & CONDITIONS section, the font "may be bundled (...) provided that each copy contains the above copyright notice and this license". There is no problem to include the "copyright notic...
Including the license file for a font licensed under the Open Font License (OFL) within an EPUB is straightforward. Here are the steps and best practices you can follow: 1. **Create the License File**: Make sure you have the OFL license text saved in a plain text file, commonly named `OFL.txt` or something similar, th...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I am currently working on an EPUB project in which I'll embed a font licensed under OFL.\nAccording to the second point in the PERMISSION & CONDITIONS section, the font \"may be bundled (...) provided that each copy contains the above copyright notice and this license\".\nThere ...
I have an audio library that optionally uses a GPL sub-library for computing the FFT (FFTW3). At compile time, I can disable FFTW3 and use another FFT implementation (which is slower than FFTW3, but with a more permissive license). If I release this audio library under GPL, everything would be very easy. Nevertheless, ...
Your approach of dual licensing your audio library under Apache 2.0 and GPLv3 is a reasonable strategy to achieve your goals. However, there are some nuances and implications that you need to consider, especially regarding the licensing of the FFTW3 library and how it interacts with your library. Here are some key poin...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I have an audio library that optionally uses a GPL sub-library for computing the FFT (FFTW3). At compile time, I can disable FFTW3 and use another FFT implementation (which is slower than FFTW3, but with a more permissive license).\nIf I release this audio library under GPL, eve...
I'm building my first Android app and I imported two external GitHub libraries into my project. Both of these libraries use Apache License v2.0 and the LICENSE file says: If the Work includes a "NOTICE" text file as part of its distribution, then any Derivative Works that You distribute must in...
Yes, you are required to include the LICENSE file in your Android app project if you are using libraries that are licensed under the Apache License 2.0. This is part of complying with the terms of the license. ### Where to Place the LICENSE File A common practice is to include the LICENSE file in a dedicated folder w...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I'm building my first Android app and I imported two external GitHub libraries into my project. Both of these libraries use Apache License v2.0 and the LICENSE file says:\n\nIf the Work includes a \"NOTICE\" text file as part of its\n distribution, then any Derivative...
For my GPL open source software I use LGPL-based libraries. I recently found a very useful NVIDIA SDK which I would like to use for my software. NVIDIA is using its own license, and I have difficulty understanding if it is OK to use the license with my GPL project. Could someone tell me if I can use the license for my...
Using a software library or SDK licensed under terms that differ from your own project's license can be complex, especially when it comes to the GPL (General Public License) and its requirements for derivative works and distribution. Let's break down the key points regarding the NVIDIA license you provided and the impl...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "For my GPL open source software I use LGPL-based libraries. I recently found a very useful NVIDIA SDK which I would like to use for my software. NVIDIA is using its own license, and I have difficulty understanding if it is OK to use the license with my GPL project. \nCould someo...
I have a software I would like to release for free. It will be published on the AppStore at first and at the same time, the source code will be released on GitHub for those who would like to build the software by themselves, or have concern about privacy issues. But, I don't want to allow these people using the code ...
The MIT License is indeed a permissive open-source license, allowing others to use, modify, and distribute your code, even for commercial purposes. If you want to prevent others from redistributing or selling modified versions of your software, the MIT License may not be suitable for your needs. If you're looking to r...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I have a software I would like to release for free. \nIt will be published on the AppStore at first and at the same time, the source code will be released on GitHub for those who would like to build the software by themselves, or have concern about privacy issues. \nBut, I don't...
Maven allows several licenses in its license block e.g. <licenses> <license> <name>GPL-3.0</name> </license> <license> <name> Beerware</name> </license> </licenses> Does mean : the user can choose ? (or) has to follow both licenses ? (and) it is not defined by maven ? Update: The answers so ...
Your observations are quite insightful. The Maven `<licenses>` block indeed does not define a specific semantic meaning for multiple licenses; it simply allows the inclusion of several licenses. However, the interpretation of those licenses can vary widely among developers and projects. 1. **User Choice (Logical 'Or')...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "Maven allows several licenses in its license block e.g.\n<licenses>\n <license>\n <name>GPL-3.0</name>\n </license>\n <license>\n <name> Beerware</name>\n </license>\n</licenses>\n\nDoes mean :\n\nthe user can choose ? (or)\nhas to follow both licenses ? (and)\ni...
I'm making a game in that requires the CSFML libraries. I've downloaded the libraries from: http://dsfml.com/downloads.html I can't understand these things, the license doesn't explain much: I only want to distribute the files in the lib folder, can I? Not the whole package. If I can, where do I put the license.txt? ...
When using libraries like CSFML, it's important to understand the licensing terms associated with them to ensure compliance when distributing your game. CSFML is licensed under the zlib license, which is a permissive license. Here’s what it generally allows: 1. **Distributing the Libraries**: You can distribute the co...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I'm making a game in that requires the CSFML libraries. I've downloaded the libraries from: http://dsfml.com/downloads.html \nI can't understand these things, the license doesn't explain much:\n\nI only want to distribute the files in the lib folder, can I? Not the whole package...
I am looking at some highy geometric flags used by the the extended LGBT community. Many of these are not able to be copyrighted (according to wikimedia) Because the consist only of: Choice of Color Geometric Shapes and these factors do not contribute to the creation of an original work. Several of the flags I am loo...
Your inquiry raises several important points about copyright and licensing, particularly in the context of flags associated with the LGBT community. 1. **Copyrightability of Flags**: It's true that simple designs consisting solely of colors and geometric shapes can be challenging to copyright, especially if they lack ...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I am looking at some highy geometric flags used by the the extended LGBT community.\nMany of these are not able to be copyrighted (according to wikimedia)\nBecause the consist only of:\n\nChoice of Color\nGeometric Shapes\n\nand these factors do not contribute to the creation of...
Let's say I need a piece of functionality and there is a library on GitHub, licensed under Apache 2.0, that provides that funcionality. There are a couple of use cases that can occur that I would prefer to just copy-paste a certain part of the library instead of the whole thing: It is written for Eclipse, and I am usin...
When dealing with an Apache 2.0 licensed library, you are granted a broad set of rights, including the ability to copy, modify, and distribute the code. However, there are specific obligations and best practices you should follow to ensure compliance with the license and to give credit to the original authors. Here’s a...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "Let's say I need a piece of functionality and there is a library on GitHub, licensed under Apache 2.0, that provides that funcionality.\nThere are a couple of use cases that can occur that I would prefer to just copy-paste a certain part of the library instead of the whole thing...
Is there a licensing model, or common ethic agreement, prohibiting the leaking of solutions to questions contained in a textbook? I was searching for solutions to a question in a very popular and internationally used textbook, and found that a solution guide is available to teaching staff whom approach the publisher an...
Creating your own solution guide for a textbook involves several legal and ethical considerations, particularly with respect to copyright and intellectual property. Here are some key points to consider: 1. **Copyright**: Textbooks are generally protected by copyright law. This includes not only the text but also the s...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "Is there a licensing model, or common ethic agreement, prohibiting the leaking of solutions to questions contained in a textbook?\nI was searching for solutions to a question in a very popular and internationally used textbook, and found that a solution guide is available to tea...
As a follow up from GPL V3 with OpenSSL Exception, I'm curious about linking an LGPLv3 project with a GPLv3 project that has a special exception for OpenSSL. In the answer to the aforementioned question, it was stated: Note, however, that you can only add exceptions to work for which you have copyright control. If y...
Linking a project licensed under the LGPLv3 with a project licensed under GPLv3 (even with an OpenSSL exception) can be tricky, and it's essential to understand the implications of these licenses. 1. **Compatibility of Licenses**: The LGPL (Lesser General Public License) is designed to allow for more permissive linkin...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "As a follow up from GPL V3 with OpenSSL Exception, I'm curious about linking an LGPLv3 project with a GPLv3 project that has a special exception for OpenSSL. In the answer to the aforementioned question, it was stated:\n\nNote, however, that you can only add exceptions to work f...
Scenario I plan to share the source code of a larger software that depends on external libraries. The directory structure of the project is as follows src/ ... my source code ext/ ... external source code The external libraries only have few modifications and contain the original license headers. The external ...
Yes, you can license your source code in the `src/` directory under a different license than the external libraries in the `ext/` directory, as long as you comply with the terms of the licenses of those external libraries. Here's a breakdown of your situation: 1. **Your Code vs. External Libraries**: Since your code ...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "Scenario\nI plan to share the source code of a larger software that depends on external libraries. The directory structure of the project is as follows\nsrc/\n ... my source code\next/\n ... external source code\n\nThe external libraries only have few modifications and con...
I have recently started my first open source project. I want people to contribute their ideas and to help grow this project. I don't know how I should spread it. I have a guide on how to contribute, a todo list and I even offer to vouch for them in the future if they contribute. It has a guide on what needs to be done ...
Congratulations on starting your open source project! Here’s a guide to help you promote your project, attract contributors, and ensure your repository is set up for success. ### 1. Posting About Your Project **Online Communities:** - **Social Media:** Share your project on platforms like Twitter, LinkedIn, or Reddit...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I have recently started my first open source project. I want people to contribute their ideas and to help grow this project. I don't know how I should spread it. I have a guide on how to contribute, a todo list and I even offer to vouch for them in the future if they contribute....
I have a D-Link DIR-816 router that runs a 'trimmed-down' version of BusyBox v1.12.1 running a linux kernel version 2.6.36 (linsongdeng@gj222d.gj.com) (gcc version 3.4.2) #35 Wed Sep 23 17:23:58 CST 2015 I say 'un-modifyable' and 'trimmed-down' because amongst other that aren't present, there is no way (that I can see)...
The General Public License (GPL) is a free software license that requires derivative works to also be licensed under the GPL. The key provisions concerning modifications, distribution, and source code apply similarly across both GPLv2 and GPLv3, though GPLv3 has additional requirements. ### GPLv2 Compliance 1. **Sourc...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I have a D-Link DIR-816 router that runs a 'trimmed-down' version of BusyBox v1.12.1 running a linux kernel version 2.6.36 (linsongdeng@gj222d.gj.com) (gcc version 3.4.2) #35 Wed Sep 23 17:23:58 CST 2015\nI say 'un-modifyable' and 'trimmed-down' because amongst other that aren't...
If I took the linux kernel, rewrite it and changed the order and file names and some other stuff, and destroy the original linux kernel, will the new kernel be subject to the terms of the GPL? tl;dr: If I rewrite the linux kernel, change almost every line while keeping the same computation and delete the original kerne...
The key issue in your question revolves around copyright law, particularly how it applies to software licensed under the GNU General Public License (GPL). The GPL requires that any derivative works based on the licensed software also be licensed under the GPL. A derivative work is generally defined as a work that is b...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "If I took the linux kernel, rewrite it and changed the order and file names and some other stuff, and destroy the original linux kernel, will the new kernel be subject to the terms of the GPL?\ntl;dr: If I rewrite the linux kernel, change almost every line while keeping the same...
If I want to put a song licensed under a Creative Commons license that does not allow derivatives (such as CC BY-NC-ND 3.0), am I allowed to programmatically loop (or apply effects) to the song when it is being played in my game? This is a tricky question because things like ROM hacking are technically legal because th...
Using a song licensed under a Creative Commons license that does not allow derivatives, such as CC BY-NC-ND 3.0, raises important legal considerations. The key element of this license is that it explicitly prohibits the creation of derivative works. When it comes to audio content, looping a song or applying effects can...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "If I want to put a song licensed under a Creative Commons license that does not allow derivatives (such as CC BY-NC-ND 3.0), am I allowed to programmatically loop (or apply effects) to the song when it is being played in my game?\nThis is a tricky question because things like RO...
I have recently created a small project and pushed it to GitHub. I now plan on applying an open-source license. Once I choose a license and commit it to the project, are the older versions subjected to that license?
Yes, once you apply an open-source license to your project and commit it to the repository, the license applies to all versions of the project, including older versions. By choosing an open-source license and including it in your repository, you are specifying the terms under which your project can be used, modified, a...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I have recently created a small project and pushed it to GitHub. I now plan on applying an open-source license. Once I choose a license and commit it to the project, are the older versions subjected to that license?\n" }, { "from": "gpt", "value": "Yes, once you appl...
If I'm getting this whole thing right, each time I'm changing something in a published licensed project, I'm licensing it independently from any other edition of it. Each version/commit from legal perspective is an independent set of data licensed on it's own conditions. Each new version gets its own license and each p...
Your understanding of licensing, particularly in software and creative works, contains several key points that are worth unpacking. Let's go through your questions and ideas step by step. ### Licensing Versions Independently 1. **Independent Licensing**: You're correct that each version or commit of a project can be ...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "If I'm getting this whole thing right, each time I'm changing something in a published licensed project, I'm licensing it independently from any other edition of it. Each version/commit from legal perspective is an independent set of data licensed on it's own conditions. Each ne...
I wish to develop a computer game and the engine I have chosen is ioquake3. This engine is licensed under GPLv2. Needless to say the game's source code will itself will, in turn, be licensed under GPLv2. The game data/assets on the other hand will be proprietary. I intend to release this game as a free-to-play app acro...
When using a GPLv2-licensed engine like ioquake3 for your game, it's important to understand how the GPL license affects your project, especially regarding proprietary elements and in-app billing logic. 1. **Source Code Requirements**: The GPLv2 license requires that any derivative works must also be licensed under th...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I wish to develop a computer game and the engine I have chosen is ioquake3. This engine is licensed under GPLv2. Needless to say the game's source code will itself will, in turn, be licensed under GPLv2. The game data/assets on the other hand will be proprietary. I intend to rel...
The accepted answer on How can large open source projects be monetized? mentions open source SaaS. Once you are successful enough in one of the above, you can afford giving away your software for free (as in free beer). So how can a startup whos core product is SaaS safely grow until youre "successful enough" if yo...
This is a valid concern when it comes to building a startup around open-source software, especially in the SaaS space. Here are some strategies to help mitigate the risks associated with open-source projects while still fostering growth: 1. **Offer Value-Added Services**: While the core product is
[ { "from": "human", "value": "The accepted answer on How can large open source projects be monetized? mentions open source SaaS. \n\nOnce you are successful enough in one of the above, you can afford giving away your software for free (as in free beer). \n\nSo how can a startup whos core product is SaaS safe...
This question is related to Copyleft Multi-Licenced Copyright Notice. I upload pictures on commons.wikimedia.org and I want to facilitate the reuse but I want derivatives stay "libre". Therefore I provide the wikicode {{self|cc-by-sa-all|cc-sa|GFDL|FAL}} to multi-license them under some copyleft licenses: Any version ...
Your approach to multi-licensing and providing a clear copyright notice is commendable, and it's great that you're thinking about facilitating reuse while ensuring derivatives remain "libre." Here are some considerations and suggestions based on your questions: ### 1. Multi-Licensing Practices - **Is it a good practic...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "This question is related to Copyleft Multi-Licenced Copyright Notice.\nI upload pictures on commons.wikimedia.org and I want to facilitate the reuse but I want derivatives stay \"libre\". Therefore I provide the wikicode {{self|cc-by-sa-all|cc-sa|GFDL|FAL}} to multi-license them...
I have cloned a repo under the Apache 2.0 licence and am changing content. under section 4 of the licence: a. You must cause any modified files to carry prominent notices stating that You changed the files; and b. You must retain, in the Source form of any Derivative Works that You distribute, all copyright, patent, t...
Your understanding of the requirements of the Apache 2.0 License is mostly correct, and your modified file notice provides a good basis. However, let's clarify the details and answer your questions: 1. **Is this correct?** - Your modified file notice is largely correct in terms of fulfilling the requirements. You i...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I have cloned a repo under the Apache 2.0 licence and am changing content.\nunder section 4 of the licence:\n\na. You must cause any modified files to carry prominent notices stating that You changed the files; and\nb. You must retain, in the Source form of any Derivative Works ...
Up to now, I've mainly been programming for fun projects on a small scale. Now I am planning the release of a larger iOS application in which I use BSD licensed code. I've know this is one of the simplest licenses and should be easy to implement, but the restrictions still leave me puzzled on how I should implement the...
Your question is perfectly valid and it's great that you're being diligent about licensing, especially as you prepare for a larger application. The BSD license is indeed one of the simpler open-source licenses, but there are a few important steps you need to follow to comply with its terms. ### Key Requirements of the...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "Up to now, I've mainly been programming for fun projects on a small scale. Now I am planning the release of a larger iOS application in which I use BSD licensed code. I've know this is one of the simplest licenses and should be easy to implement, but the restrictions still leave...
I have just a couple years of experience in software development and in the past few months have been dipping my toes in the water of making open source contributions. It was very exciting when my first patch was accepted! Recently I've opened pull requests to a couple projects and have gotten no response from maintain...
It's great to hear that you've started contributing to open source! Your experience with getting a patch accepted is a significant achievement. It's not uncommon to face delays in response from maintainers, especially for projects that may not have a large team or resources dedicated to managing contributions. Here are...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I have just a couple years of experience in software development and in the past few months have been dipping my toes in the water of making open source contributions. It was very exciting when my first patch was accepted! Recently I've opened pull requests to a couple projects ...
I would submit a pull request updating a library or a language. I would do so even if there are breaking changes (ex. Python 2 -> Python 3). I would submit a pull request that adds a new library if it is relevant to the functionality. However, I am struggling with the acceptability changing the implementation languag...
Changing the implementation language of a library or project via a pull request is a nuanced topic, and its acceptability largely depends on several factors, including community norms, the project's goals, and the maintainers' preferences. Here are some considerations to help you evaluate whether submitting a PR that c...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I would submit a pull request updating a library or a language. I would do so even if there are breaking changes (ex. Python 2 -> Python 3). I would submit a pull request that adds a new library if it is relevant to the functionality.\nHowever, I am struggling with the accepta...
I am developing a web application which streams videos. For the frontend I intend to use the richfaces framework for jsf. That framework is licensed under the LGPL v2. Does that mean that I have to make it possible to use different version of this framework by the user as the license indicates? I actually want to unde...
The LGPL (Lesser General Public License) v2 has specific implications for how you can use and distribute software that is licensed under it, particularly in the context of libraries and frameworks like RichFaces. ### Key Points Regarding LGPL v2: 1. **Linking and Modification**: The LGPL allows you to use the library...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I am developing a web application which streams videos. For the frontend I intend to use the richfaces framework for jsf. That framework is licensed under the LGPL v2. Does that mean that I have to make it possible to use different version of this framework by the user as the li...
I've been searching around a little bit for statistics on how many projects are licensed with a licence file in their repository. I found this article with a graph: The spike between 2013 and 2014 can largely be attributed to the unveiling of choosealicense.com by GitHub. Quoting from the article: The new Licenses AP...
You're right to note that the presence of a dedicated `LICENSE` file in a repository is a common practice, but it is not the only way to indicate the licensing of a project. A license can indeed be specified in other locations, such as in the `README` file or even in the comments of source code files. The statistics de...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I've been searching around a little bit for statistics on how many projects are licensed with a licence file in their repository. I found this article with a graph:\n\nThe spike between 2013 and 2014 can largely be attributed to the unveiling of choosealicense.com by GitHub.\nQu...
I'm curious about the definition of "System Libraries" The “System Libraries” of an executable work include anything, other than the work as a whole, that (a) is included in the normal form of packaging a Major Component, but which is not part of that Major Component Why is it necessary, in order to protect the user...
The term "System Libraries" in the context of software, particularly in the realm of open source and software freedom, is an important concept that helps to delineate the boundaries between what constitutes a software work and what is considered ancillary support for that work. Here’s a detailed breakdown of why it’s e...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I'm curious about the definition of \"System Libraries\" \n\nThe “System Libraries” of an executable work include anything, other than the work as a whole, that (a) is included in the normal form of packaging a Major Component, but which is not part of that Major Component\n\nWh...
I'm working on a project where BSD, Apache v2 and MPL1.1 libraries were used. Basically propietary code will link to these libraries to run the Program. Libraries were only used in binary form, though. No code combination. When further distributing the Program, do i need to make the source code of those OSS libraries a...
When distributing software that links to open-source libraries, the obligations under the respective licenses of those libraries need to be followed. Here's how it works for the licenses you've mentioned: ### BSD License - **Obligation**: The BSD license is quite permissive. You don't need to provide the source code o...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I'm working on a project where BSD, Apache v2 and MPL1.1 libraries were used.\nBasically propietary code will link to these libraries to run the Program. Libraries were only used in binary form, though. No code combination.\nWhen further distributing the Program, do i need to ma...
I am writing an R package that uses data from other authors (UN Voting). Is there any licensing issue in adding the data directly to the package? I am not sure whether I can just add this data to the package (surely quote it), or if this is not allowed and I should include an extra command that downloads the data every...
When incorporating data from other authors into your R package, it's essential to consider the
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I am writing an R package that uses data from other authors (UN Voting). Is there any licensing issue in adding the data directly to the package?\nI am not sure whether I can just add this data to the package (surely quote it), or if this is not allowed and I should include an e...
The Json license has an appendix where it says: The Software shall be used for Good, not Evil. If I want to use a library with the Json license am I forced to add this quote to my license? Update: Changed the title so that its question and text ask the same question
The JSON license's phrase "The Software shall be used for Good, not Evil" is a humorous and informal statement rather than a legally enforceable clause. It is part of the license's lighthearted nature, and while it conveys the intention that the software should be used ethically, it does not impose legal obligations on...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "The Json license has an appendix where it says: \n\nThe Software shall be used for Good, not Evil.\n\nIf I want to use a library with the Json license am I forced to add this quote to my license? \nUpdate: Changed the title so that its question and text ask the same question\...
The traditional expectation for contributions to a free software project are "inbound=outbound" [1] [2]. That is, if the project is under license X, contributions are made under license X. However, I'd like to make a simple statement about this in my README, just for clarity. I don't want to say "inbound=outbound" beca...
A clear and user-friendly way to express the concept of "inbound=outbound" in your README could be: "Contributions to this project must be made under the same license as the project." This phrase conveys the essential idea without relying on jargon or prior knowledge, making it accessible to all readers. If you want ...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "The traditional expectation for contributions to a free software project are \"inbound=outbound\" [1] [2]. That is, if the project is under license X, contributions are made under license X.\nHowever, I'd like to make a simple statement about this in my README, just for clarity....
In an open source project, such as one typically found on GitHub, there are users who can submit pull requests and users who can merge them. It is my understanding that "contributor" is the term for the former group. What is the term for the latter group?
In the context of open source projects on platforms like GitHub, the users who can merge pull requests are often referred to as **"maintainers"** or **"owners."** Maintainers typically have the responsibility of reviewing contributions from other users (contributors) and deciding whether to merge them into the main cod...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "In an open source project, such as one typically found on GitHub, there are users who can submit pull requests and users who can merge them. It is my understanding that \"contributor\" is the term for the former group. What is the term for the latter group?\n" }, { "from...
as the title implies, I've installed some npm packages - all of which I've knowingly installed and requested are published under MIT, ISC, Apache 2, or other permissive license. However, some of these packages, which I require in the package.json, require other packages with less permissive licenses, such as CC-BY-3.0 ...
When you use npm packages in your project, you are effectively creating a dependency tree where your project depends on those packages and, by extension, their dependencies. Your obligations regarding licenses arise from the licenses of the packages you are directly using, as well as the licenses of any sub-dependencie...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "as the title implies, I've installed some npm packages - all of which I've knowingly installed and requested are published under MIT, ISC, Apache 2, or other permissive license.\nHowever, some of these packages, which I require in the package.json, require other packages with le...
I'm working with a formerly closed-source project whose official first release under that product name was in 1997. Development on it slowed and was abandoned, then released as Apache 2.0 in 2012. The copyright dates in the file headers of that open source publication said: Copyright 2012 PROJECT Corp. PROJECT is a ...
Your situation is quite nuanced, and there are a few important factors to consider regarding copyright and the correct way to attribute contributions to the codebase. 1. **Copyright Ownership**: The copyright in the headers refers specifically to the rights held by PROJECT Corp. as the original author of the codebase ...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I'm working with a formerly closed-source project whose official first release under that product name was in 1997. Development on it slowed and was abandoned, then released as Apache 2.0 in 2012. The copyright dates in the file headers of that open source publication said:\nC...
I wish to install my first add-on to my newly acquired Bitbucket open source project. Should it be setup and developed on its on branch and then imported in when approved and working OR Edit the files locally and then add a 1.1 tag? In the past before using git I have used Version 1.1 (My first add-on) Version 1.2 (Sma...
Welcome to the world of version control with Git! Setting up your workflow properly will help you maintain a clean project history and make collaboration easier. Let's look at the options you've mentioned and how they relate to GitFlow and versioning. ### Two Approaches: 1. **Develop on a Separate Branch**: - Crea...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I wish to install my first add-on to my newly acquired Bitbucket open source project.\nShould it be setup and developed on its on branch and then imported in when approved and working\nOR\nEdit the files locally and then add a 1.1 tag?\nIn the past before using git I have used\n...
I was looking for a library implementing a specific protocol for my favorite programming language. I found one, but noticed that it started out as a straight port of another project. However, in each code file the author have replaced the original copyright with his own. I opened an issue and pointed out that the copyr...
In cases where one project is derived from another, proper handling of copyright is essential to respect the original authors' rights and comply with licensing requirements. Here are some guidelines for handling copyright in such scenarios: 1. **Acknowledge the Original Work**: The author should retain proper attribut...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I was looking for a library implementing a specific protocol for my favorite programming language.\nI found one, but noticed that it started out as a straight port of another project. However, in each code file the author have replaced the original copyright with his own.\nI ope...
Is it useful to have a CLA when you e.g. use an MIT license for your project? I am just asking this, because when you use the MIT license you are already granted to sublicense it, so is a CLA necessary and/or useful in this case? Is not a CLA only useful when you use copyleft licenses such as the GPL, because the MIT l...
In the context of an MIT-licensed project, a Contributor License Agreement (CLA) can still be useful, but its necessity may depend on your specific goals and the nature of contributions you expect. 1. **Clarification of Rights**: A CLA can clarify the rights being granted by contributors, which might be useful for leg...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "Is it useful to have a CLA when you e.g. use an MIT license for your project?\nI am just asking this, because when you use the MIT license you are already granted to sublicense it, so is a CLA necessary and/or useful in this case?\nIs not a CLA only useful when you use copyleft ...
Hacking and cheating in online multiplayer games (that use the typical client-server model) is not uncommon. For example, in some first-person shooters there are "aimbots" that allow the player's character to hit a target every time, "triggerbots" that fire whenever a player's cursor passes over an enemy, and "wallhack...
The challenge of maintaining fair play in an online multiplayer game that is released as free and open-source software (FOSS) while using a client-server model is indeed complex. Here are several strategies that could be employed to mitigate cheating and maintain a fair environment for players, as well as consideration...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "Hacking and cheating in online multiplayer games (that use the typical client-server model) is not uncommon. For example, in some first-person shooters there are \"aimbots\" that allow the player's character to hit a target every time, \"triggerbots\" that fire whenever a player...
Background: Suppose I am developing an open source project. I am at the stage where I need to license my software. After doing research I find out that I live in a place where there is no ported CC license. My question: What do I do if the CC license I want to use has not yet been ported in my country?
If you wish to use a Creative Commons (CC) license that has not been ported to your country, you have a few options to consider: 1. **Use the International Version**: Most Creative Commons licenses have an international version that is designed to be applicable across jurisdictions. You can choose to use this internat...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "Background:\nSuppose I am developing an open source project. I am at the stage where I need to license my software. After doing research I find out that I live in a place where there is no ported CC license. \nMy question:\nWhat do I do if the CC license I want to use has not y...
I am starting a web API for my school and I was wondering what licence would be most appropriate? The goal is to have an open source application that can be freely shared with other school but prohibits it's use for commercial applications (basically to protect from companies who make software for schools). The applica...
For your web API aimed at schools, where you want it to be open source, freely shareable, and prohibiting commercial use, here are some licensing options you might consider: 1. **GNU General Public License (GPL)**: This is a strong copyleft license. It allows anyone to use, modify, and distribute the software, but req...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I am starting a web API for my school and I was wondering what licence would be most appropriate?\nThe goal is to have an open source application that can be freely shared with other school but prohibits it's use for commercial applications (basically to protect from companies w...
I am working on open source tool for which I want users to not remove or change product logo. Is this possible? I had originally asked my question here at Stack Overflow but it was recommended that I ask here as well.
In the context of open source software, it's generally challenging to enforce restrictions like preventing users from removing or changing a logo. Open source licenses typically grant users certain freedoms, including the ability to modify the software, which would extend to any assets bundled with it, such as logos an...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I am working on open source tool for which I want users to not remove or change product logo. Is this possible?\nI had originally asked my question here at Stack Overflow but it was recommended that I ask here as well.\n" }, { "from": "gpt", "value": "In the context...
I've been working on a side project for fun that I originally wanted to release and commercialize. I've realized recently that while I think my work is great and would be fun to share I am not ready to commit to working on it full-time. I'm afraid that the work I've done is going to be for naught if I don't do anythi...
It's great to hear that you've been working on a side project and are considering open-sourcing it! It’s understandable to be concerned about the potential for others to commercialize your work without your permission. ### Non-Commercial Open Source Licenses To address your concerns, you can consider the following o...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "I've been working on a side project for fun that I originally wanted to release and commercialize. I've realized recently that while I think my work is great and would be fun to share I am not ready to commit to working on it full-time. I'm afraid that the work I've done is go...
According to Apache Trademark Policy page, I can use Apache feather logo in my slides without asking permissions. You needn't ask us for permission to use the Apache feather logo (the version published by us here ) on your own website solely as a hyperlink to www.apache.org or to an appropriate Apache project, or in o...
Yes, you should contact them to use the logos in your presentation. While the Apache feather logo can be used freely in presentations, the specific logo for Apache Foo software has restrictions that require you to obtain written approval for any use beyond a hyperlink on a website. Since your use case involves a presen...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "According to Apache Trademark Policy page, I can use Apache feather logo in my slides without asking permissions.\n\nYou needn't ask us for permission to use the Apache feather logo (the version published by us here ) on your own website solely as a hyperlink to www.apache.org o...
Sections 3.1 and 3.2 of the CeCILL, edited and with emphasis added: 3.1 The Licensee shall be deemed as having accepted the terms and conditions of this Agreement upon the occurrence of the first of the following events: (i) loading the Software by any or all means, notably, by downloading from a remote server, or by...
Based on Sections 3.1 and 3.2 of the CeCILL license you provided, the Licensee accepts the terms of the Agreement upon loading the software. However, Section 3.2 clearly states that a copy of the Agreement must be provided to the Licensee prior to acceptance, and the Licensee must acknowledge that they have read and un...
[ { "from": "human", "value": "Sections 3.1 and 3.2 of the CeCILL, edited and with emphasis added:\n\n3.1 The Licensee shall be deemed as having accepted the terms and conditions of this Agreement upon the occurrence of the first of the following events:\n\n(i) loading the Software by any or all means, notabl...