AtlasOpenCoder / validation /paper1 /APPENDIX_B1_checks.md
piotrwilam's picture
AtlasOpenCoder v1: the battery, the artefacts and both papers' manifests
9b7bd53
|
Raw History Blame Contribute Delete
2.87 kB
# Appendix B.1 — the licence suite, check by check
*One row per check. Reference `pretrain_iter_0484865`. The suite has **nine** checks, not eight: `check8_nulls__suite_7` in the stored artefact holds **two** — 7a scrambled and 7b split-half — which is the whole of the §4.1 / §2.6 discrepancy. Eight stored keys, nine checks.*
| # | check | pass criterion | outcome | ran on |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | twin agreement | none — a characterisation | the two batteries' profiles agree: median cosine 0.995 for `For` | all 188 (188 of 188) |
| 2 | convergence | none — a characterisation | the profile reaches cosine 0.99 with its full set by a median 56 of 720 prompts | 31 per-prompt (31 of 188) |
| 3 | length | none — a characterisation | three padding levels; min pair cosine and the length index | 31 per-prompt (31 of 188) |
| 4 | re-weighting (ν) | none — a characterisation | a second generator menu against the twin floor | all 188 (188 of 188) |
| 5 | calibration | none — reported as inflation | do the stated intervals cover the twin difference at the nominal 95% | all 188 (188 of 188) |
| 6 | companion | none — a measured cap | the measured version of the pre-run companion cap | 8 with companions (8 of 188) |
| 7a | scrambled null | **PASS: the real norm must exceed the null's 95th percentile** | median 10.7× the null p95, minimum 7.2×; 0 of 31 at or below | 31 per-prompt (31 of 188) |
| 7b | split-half null | **PASS: the real norm must exceed the null's 95th percentile** | median 12.8× the null p95, minimum 6.0×; 0 of 31 at or below | 31 per-prompt (31 of 188) |
| 8 | σ₀ floor | none — a sensitivity | how far the smooth floor's open parameter moves the reading, in twin units | all 188 (188 of 188) |
**Only two checks have a pass criterion** — the two nulls — and both pass for every construct they ran on. The other seven are characterisations or sensitivities: they are reported, and there is nothing for them to fail.
**Four checks were re-run** after the per-prompt join fault of 19 October: 2 convergence, 3 length, 7a null_scrambled, 7b null_split_half. Table B.2 gives published against corrected per construct.
**Understated for calibration.** Check 5 reports an inflation factor rather than a pass: the stated intervals cover the twin difference at below their nominal 95% rate, so the intervals are optimistic and the inflation is the amount by which. It ran on all 188 constructs.
**Why four checks ran on 31 and one on 8.** Checks 2, 3, 7a and 7b need per-prompt vectors, and the record keeps those for 31 constructs; the other 157 are `profile_source: accumulators`. Check 6 applies only to the eight constructs that can have a companion (`ClassDef`, `For`, `FunctionDef`, `If`, `Match`, `Try`, `While`, `With`). Neither is a gap in the run; both are properties of what the record holds.