The Dataset Viewer has been disabled on this dataset.

Wrong with Confidence: hallucination, overconfidence and identity-conditioned behaviour

GitHub Kaggle Website OSF

When a question is missing information, do models ask, or guess? And if they guess, can the user tell? Five open-weight models from four organisations answered 142 factual questions in a fully specified form and with the key referent removed, plus three identity probes. Registered on OSF before any response was scored (10.17605/OSF.IO/CS967). Study C of the thesis MRI of a Mad Machine.

Result

Error rises, tone does not
Finding Number
Referent removed: models ask for clarification 33.7% of prompts
Error among attempted answers, intact → referent removed 39.1% → 52.0% (mixed-effects OR 4.12, 95% CI 2.76–6.14)
Wrong answers that carry no hedge 75.3%
How well hedging separates right from wrong (0.5 = chance) AUROC 0.56
Same 50 questions, the user claims an identity mean answer length 188 words (anonymous) vs 259–268 (patient, physician, researcher)

When information is missing, models usually guess, and the wording barely changes. Hedging is not a usable warning sign.

Two sets of figures, one conclusion. The scoring sheets carry the original correctness labels; code/run_analysis.py reproduces the figures they support (error 39.9% intact and 66.7% referent removed; 77.4% unhedged), reported in the thesis as a robustness check. The headline figures above come from the final registered analysis, which treats a pure clarification request as an abstention, as the rubric specifies.

What is inside

Path Contents
data/prompts/ Prompt set and question sources
data/probes/ Pronoun, authority and safety probes
data/raw_outputs/ Every model response
data/scoring/ Both raters' sheets, the blind key and the 600-response overlap list
code/ Sampling, collection, agreement and analysis scripts
results/ Inter-rater agreement report
STUDY_README.md The full study page

Reproduce

from huggingface_hub import snapshot_download
path = snapshot_download("rejaulkorimsadi/wrong-with-confidence-llm", repo_type="dataset")
cd <the path printed above>
pip install -r requirements.txt
python code/compute_kappa.py
python code/run_analysis.py

Citation

@misc{sadi2026wrongconfidence,
  title  = {Wrong with Confidence: Measuring Hallucination, Overconfidence and Identity-Conditioned Behaviour in Large Language Models},
  author = {Sadi, Md. Rejaul Korim and Tasin, Toufiqur Rahman and Naeem, Golam Mostofa and Chowdhury, Dewan Fahad and Chowdhury, Hatim Al Amin},
  year   = {2026},
  note   = {Pre-registered at OSF, doi:10.17605/OSF.IO/CS967}
}

Part of a research collection

Authors' affiliation: Department of Computer Science and Engineering, Metropolitan University, Sylhet, Bangladesh. Questions and feedback: open a discussion on this page.

Downloads last month
-

Space using rejaulkorimsadi/wrong-with-confidence-llm 1

Collection including rejaulkorimsadi/wrong-with-confidence-llm