Datasets:
CALVIN-MAX: human feasibility audit
A human audit of 400 cases from CALVIN-MAX, a benchmark of mid-execution changes on CALVIN's five-instruction chains. For each case, one annotator judged whether a competent robot could still complete the instruction from the state just after the change.
Result
No case was judged infeasible.
| Change | n | Feasible | Infeasible | Unclear | Feasible share (%), 95% Wilson interval |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Target relocation | 80 | 79 | 0 | 1 | 100 [95.4, 100] |
| Receptacle relocation | 80 | 79 | 0 | 1 | 100 [95.4, 100] |
| Obstacle insertion | 80 | 80 | 0 | 0 | 100 [95.4, 100] |
| Arm push | 54 | 54 | 0 | 0 | 100 [93.4, 100] |
| Grasp loss | 26 | 26 | 0 | 0 | 100 [87.1, 100] |
| Perceptual (five changes) | 80 | 80 | 0 | 0 | 100 [95.4, 100] |
| All | 400 | 398 | 0 | 2 | 100 [99.0, 100] |
The share is computed over cases judged feasible or infeasible. The two unclear cases come from CALVIN's
instructions not saying what contact between objects is allowed: a block moved deep onto the slider inside
the cabinet (core-target_relocation-A-k3-E0247), and the drawer partly closed while a block was carried to it
(core-receptacle_relocation-B-k4-E0106).
Cases
400 realized held-out cases from Max-A, using FLOWER's runs, drawn with a fixed seed (20261108). The draw favours changes that can make a task infeasible: 80 each for target relocation, receptacle relocation and obstacle insertion, 54 arm pushes, all 26 realized grasp losses, and 16 for each of the five perceptual changes (camera shift, sensor noise, illumination switch, visual-theme switch, distractor burst).
Each image shows the static camera (top) and the gripper camera (bottom), just before (left) and just after (right) the change. The frames were re-rendered from FLOWER's stored Base actions, with no policy in the loop. The annotator saw the instruction and a description of the change, never the rollout outcome.
Scope: the audit covers FLOWER's onset states, and only cases already accepted by the benchmark's automated checks.
Note: for one case (core-illumination_switch-A-k5-E0247, a lighting change during "open drawer"), a bug in
the page shown during the audit left the instruction text empty; it was judged feasible from the frames and the
change description. The released index.html and frames/tasks.json include the instruction.
Files
| Path | Content |
|---|---|
index.html |
The labeling page. Open it in a browser next to frames/; answers are kept in the browser and exported as audit_answers.json. |
frames/<case_id>.jpg |
Before and after frames for each case |
frames/tasks.json |
The instruction (CALVIN subtask) of each case |
audit_selection.json |
The 400 cases: change, variant, chain, instruction index, onset step, change parameters |
audit_answers.json |
The annotator's answers (feasible, infeasible or unclear) with notes and timestamps |
audit_summary.json |
Counts and Wilson intervals per change |
audit_traces.tar.gz |
FLOWER's Base traces for the 236 chains, needed to re-render the frames |
Reproduce
From the root of the CALVIN-MAX repository, with CALVIN installed and
this dataset downloaded to <data>:
mkdir -p results/audit && cp <data>/audit_selection.json results/audit/
tar xzf <data>/audit_traces.tar.gz # -> results/base/flower_abc/traces/
python scripts/render_qual.py audit-render # before and after frames -> results/audit/frames/
python scripts/build_audit_page.py # -> results/audit/index.html
python scripts/analyze_audit.py results/audit/audit_answers.json
render_qual.py audit-select draws the cases again; it needs FLOWER's per-case Max-A results, which are not
released.
To audit again with a new annotator, open index.html, answer every case and export.
- Downloads last month
- 496