|
Download analysis/README.md from sciminds/same-words-different-judgements: direct link, hf CLI and curl.
- Browser
- Download file 13.7 kB
-
https://huggingface.co/datasets/sciminds/same-words-different-judgements/resolve/main/analysis/README.md
- Command line
-
hf download hf://datasets/sciminds/same-words-different-judgements/analysis/README.md
-
curl -L -o README.md https://huggingface.co/datasets/sciminds/same-words-different-judgements/resolve/main/analysis/README.md
13.7 kB
| # Analysis | |
| Every number and table in the paper is produced by a script in this | |
| folder, reading only the data shipped in `data/` and `stimuli/`. Run | |
| everything from the repository root. | |
| ``` | |
| analysis/ | |
| ├── common/ shared helpers (imported, never run directly) | |
| ├── 01_data_prep/ raw exports → analysis tables (only for new collections) | |
| ├── 02_main_study/ the human study (Tables 1, 2, 5, 21) | |
| ├── 03_synthetic_raters/ AI-rater alignment (Tables 3, 4, 6–8) | |
| ├── 04_annotation_budget/ using AI ratings to allocate human raters (Table 20) | |
| ├── 05_prompt_analyses/ which prompts swing across modality (Table 19, Appendix J) | |
| ├── 06_voice_study/ Ablation A: four TTS voices (Tables 9, 10, 12; Appendix G) | |
| ├── 07_audio_context_study/ Ablation B: conversation history heard as audio (Table 13; Appendix H) | |
| ├── 08_cross_study/ contrasts across arms of both ablations (Tables 11, 14–18) | |
| ├── run_all.sh runs every script below in order | |
| └── Stimuli_Sampling.pdf stimulus-screening worksheet (reference only) | |
| ``` | |
| Scripts write tables to `results/<folder>/` and figures to `figures/`. | |
| Inputs in `data/` are never overwritten. | |
| ## Setup | |
| The analyses need Python and R together, so the simplest setup is | |
| [pixi](https://pixi.sh), which installs both from `pixi.toml` and `pixi.lock`: | |
| ```bash | |
| pixi install | |
| pixi run python analysis/02_main_study/01_omnibus_bias_model.py | |
| ``` | |
| To use `pip` instead, install R (≥ 4.2) yourself along with the R packages | |
| that `pymer4` and the analyses load: | |
| ```bash | |
| python3.11 -m venv .venv && source .venv/bin/activate | |
| pip install -r requirements.txt | |
| brew install r # or your platform's R installer | |
| R -e 'install.packages(c("lme4","lmerTest","emmeans","broom","broom.mixed","report","parameters","performance","insight","tidyverse","arrow","boot"), repos="https://cloud.r-project.org")' | |
| ``` | |
| Results were verified with Python 3.11.7, R 4.5.2, lme4 1.1-38, | |
| lmerTest 3.1-3 and emmeans 2.0.0. `08_cross_study/09_validate_lme4_substitution.py` | |
| checks that the direct `lme4` bridge used by the follow-up analyses | |
| reproduces the paper's Table 1 before you rely on it. | |
| ## Where each result comes from | |
| The synthetic-rater scripts take `--model gpt4o | gemini_36_flash | | |
| qwen35_omni_flash`. The default, `gpt4o`, gives the main-text Tables 3–4; | |
| running all three gives the cross-family Tables 6–8. The voice study is | |
| **Ablation A** (arms A1 am_michael, A2 Chatterbox, A3 Serena) and the | |
| audio-context study is **Ablation B** (B1 one-voice history, B2 two-voice | |
| history). In Tables 10–18 the text and audio reference rows are the main | |
| study's conditions recomputed on each ablation's 30 prompts. | |
| ### Human study and main-text AI comparisons | |
| | Result | Script | | |
| |---|---| | |
| | Table 1: omnibus bias model; per-modality length effects | `02_main_study/01_omnibus_bias_model.py` | | |
| | Table 2: ICC and Krippendorff's α, bootstrap CIs, permutation tests | `02_main_study/02_reliability_icc_alpha.py` (slow, see below) | | |
| | ICC(2,k) by number of raters (figure) | `02_main_study/03_icc_by_k_curve.py` | | |
| | Decision threshold (audio M = 27.9, text M = 41.7); cross-modality winner agreement (53/100, p = .31); agreement-by-decisiveness figures | `02_main_study/04_cross_modality_agreement.py` | | |
| | Prompt-specific modality effects (random-slope model, χ²(2) = 22.1) | `02_main_study/05_prompt_modality_effects.py` | | |
| | Practice effects on trial duration | `02_main_study/06_practice_effects.py` | | |
| | Table 5: session and trial characteristics by condition | `02_main_study/07_session_characteristics.py` | | |
| | Table 21: participant demographics by condition | `02_main_study/08_participant_demographics.py` | | |
| | Qualitative TF-IDF analysis of justifications | `02_main_study/09_qualitative_tfidf.py` | | |
| | Robustness: education covariate | `02_main_study/10_robust_education.py` | | |
| | Robustness: audio-quality covariate | `02_main_study/11_robust_audio_quality.py` | | |
| | Robustness: relistening to the first clip | `02_main_study/12_robust_relisten.py` | | |
| | Robustness: ceiling compression | `02_main_study/13_robust_ceiling.py` | | |
| | Table 3: AI–human alignment; PRISM vs. external raters | `03_synthetic_raters/01_ai_human_alignment.py` | | |
| | Table 4: AI differentiation predicts human agreement | `03_synthetic_raters/02_ai_predicts_agreement.py` | | |
| `04_cross_modality_agreement.py` is the authoritative source for the | |
| 53/100 winner-agreement figure. `05_prompt_modality_effects.py` | |
| deliberately prints no winner-agreement number, because its | |
| sign-of-mean rule differs from `04` in edge cases. | |
| ### Additional synthetic raters, triage and prompt analyses (Appendices F, J, K) | |
| | Result | Script | | |
| |---|---| | |
| | Table 6: AI–human agreement and rating error, three rater families | `03_synthetic_raters/01_ai_human_alignment.py --model <m>` | | |
| | Table 6 follow-up: calibration offset vs. rank agreement (centered MAE) | `03_synthetic_raters/05_mae_bias_decomposition.py` | | |
| | Table 7: AI differentiation predicts human agreement, three families | `03_synthetic_raters/02_ai_predicts_agreement.py --model <m>` | | |
| | Table 8: PRISM vs. AI annotators across raters | `03_synthetic_raters/01_ai_human_alignment.py --model <m>` (writes `h2_prism_comparisons*.csv`) | | |
| | Cross-family judge agreement, text vs. audio | `03_synthetic_raters/03_cross_model_agreement.py --models gpt4o gemini_36_flash qwen35_omni_flash` | | |
| | Do AI judges reproduce the human order and length biases? | `03_synthetic_raters/04_synth_bias_effects.py` | | |
| | Triage experiment: gap-threshold sweep, budget-matched allocation | `04_annotation_budget/01_triage_experiment.py --model <m>` | | |
| | Human raters needed per AI-gap band | `04_annotation_budget/02_human_sample_size_by_ai_gap.py --model <m>` | | |
| | Table 20: first-hit vs. stable ratings by gap band | `04_annotation_budget/03_raters_to_gold_by_gap.py --model <m>` | | |
| | Tiered vs. uniform allocation at matched budget | `04_annotation_budget/04_triage_allocation_table.py` | | |
| | Cost per trial behind the triage savings ($0.26 text, $0.46 audio) | `04_annotation_budget/05_annotation_cost_per_trial.py` | | |
| | Length and conversation-structure predictors of the modality effect (Appendix J) | `05_prompt_analyses/01_modality_effect_features.py` | | |
| | Table 19: modality effect by induced prompt type; inter-coder κ = .699 | `05_prompt_analyses/05_topic_code_stimuli.py --reuse` | | |
| | Context-dependent prompts flip winners more often (68% vs. 35%; Section 5.2) | `05_prompt_analyses/06_context_dependence_flips.py` | | |
| | Qualitative fail cases: prompts ranked by human cross-modal gap, with justifications | `05_prompt_analyses/02_qual_rating_disagreement.py`, `03_qual_raw_rating_diff.py`, `04_qual_pair_diff_table.py` | | |
| `05_topic_code_stimuli.py --reuse` rebuilds Table 19 from the shipped | |
| topic codes (`data/main_study/stimulus_topic_codes*.csv`) and makes no | |
| network calls. Without `--reuse` it re-runs the topic induction and | |
| coding through the Gemini and OpenAI APIs, which needs API keys, costs | |
| money, and will not return exactly the same codes. | |
| ### Voice and audio-context ablations (Appendices G–I) | |
| | Result | Script | | |
| |---|---| | |
| | Table 9: acoustic characterization (WPM, f0, loudness) | `06_voice_study/03_acoustics.py` (needs the WAVs) | | |
| | Voice f0 level and self-consistency (drift 0.27–0.98 st) | `06_voice_study/04_f0_drift.py` (needs the WAVs) | | |
| | Table 10: modality signatures by voice. Threshold and ICC columns come from the threshold summary; recency and length come from the replication script | `08_cross_study/01_threshold_summary.py`, `06_voice_study/05_replication.py` | | |
| | Tables 11 and 14: equivalence tests (TOST) between arms | `08_cross_study/03_equivalence_tost.py` (run `02` first) | | |
| | Table 12: synthetic-rating alignment by voice | `06_voice_study/06_synth_alignment.py` | | |
| | Table 12 follow-up: prompt-clustered bootstrap CIs | `06_voice_study/07_synth_alignment_bootstrap.py` (5,000 reps) | | |
| | Table 13: audio-context modality signatures | `08_cross_study/01_threshold_summary.py`, `07_audio_context_study/02_replication.py` | | |
| | Table 15: winner agreement with a split-half noise floor | `08_cross_study/04_winner_floor.py` | | |
| | Table 16: rating-scale usage by condition | `08_cross_study/05_scale_usage.py` | | |
| | Tie probability by condition (companion to Table 16) | `08_cross_study/06_tie_probability.py` | | |
| | Table 17: estimated marginal means for the decision threshold | `08_cross_study/02_condition_contrasts.py` | | |
| | Table 18: pairwise contrasts between conditions | `08_cross_study/02_condition_contrasts.py` | | |
| | Arm × position and arm × length interactions (p = .15, p = .003) | `08_cross_study/07_bias_interactions.py` | | |
| | History depth, trial position, session duration, completion rates | `08_cross_study/08_feasibility_covariates.py` | | |
| | B1 split at median trial duration (slower half threshold 19.6) | `07_audio_context_study/03_duration_split.py` | | |
| | Audio-quality ratings and transcript divergence by voice (Serena −18.5) | `06_voice_study/09_quality_by_voice.py` | | |
| | AI-judge winner agreement across voices | `06_voice_study/08_judge_winner_agreement.py --model <m>` | | |
| | Transcript consistency of each voice against the baseline | `06_voice_study/02_transcript_consistency.py` | | |
| | Prompt selection for each study | `06_voice_study/01_select_prompts.py`, `07_audio_context_study/01_select_prompts.py` | | |
| The prompt-selection scripts write their reselection to `results/` and | |
| never overwrite the fielded prompt lists in `stimuli/*/prompts.csv`. | |
| Two values print slightly differently from the paper, which was rounded | |
| from an earlier pass: the f0 drift script prints .694/.973 st for Serena | |
| and Chatterbox (paper: 0.70/0.98), and the Table 15 split-half floors | |
| print .544/.565/.547/.557 (paper: .543/.564/.548/.555). Conclusions are | |
| unchanged. | |
| ## Running everything | |
| `pixi run bash analysis/run_all.sh` runs the commands below in order: | |
| ```bash | |
| M="gpt4o gemini_36_flash qwen35_omni_flash" | |
| for s in 01 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 12 13; do python analysis/02_main_study/${s}_*.py; done | |
| python analysis/02_main_study/02_reliability_icc_alpha.py # ~3 hours | |
| for m in $M; do | |
| python analysis/03_synthetic_raters/01_ai_human_alignment.py --model $m | |
| python analysis/03_synthetic_raters/02_ai_predicts_agreement.py --model $m | |
| for s in 01 02 03; do python analysis/04_annotation_budget/${s}_*.py --model $m; done | |
| done | |
| python analysis/03_synthetic_raters/03_cross_model_agreement.py --models $M | |
| for s in 04 05; do python analysis/03_synthetic_raters/${s}_*.py; done | |
| for s in 04 05; do python analysis/04_annotation_budget/${s}_*.py; done | |
| for s in 01 02 03 04 06; do python analysis/05_prompt_analyses/${s}_*.py; done | |
| python analysis/05_prompt_analyses/05_topic_code_stimuli.py --reuse | |
| for s in 01 02 05 06 07 09; do python analysis/06_voice_study/${s}_*.py; done | |
| for m in gemini_36_flash qwen35_omni_flash; do | |
| python analysis/06_voice_study/08_judge_winner_agreement.py --model $m | |
| done | |
| for s in 01 02 03; do python analysis/07_audio_context_study/${s}_*.py; done | |
| for s in 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09; do python analysis/08_cross_study/${s}_*.py; done | |
| ``` | |
| Runtime and dependencies: | |
| - **Reliability (`02_main_study/02`)** takes about three hours, from the | |
| bootstrap and permutation tests. It checkpoints to | |
| `_internal/run_outputs/` and resumes after an interruption. Delete that | |
| folder to recompute from scratch. | |
| - **Replication scripts (`06/05`, `07/02`)** accept `--skip-models` for a | |
| fast descriptive pass. | |
| - **Acoustics (`06_voice_study/03`, about 30 minutes) and f0 drift (`04`)** | |
| read the rendered WAVs in `stimuli/voice_study/audio/` (see | |
| `stimuli/voice_study/README.md`). Their outputs ship in | |
| `stimuli/voice_study/`, so you can skip them. `03_acoustics.py --out <path>` | |
| writes elsewhere instead of overwriting the shipped table. | |
| ## Running on your own data | |
| The main-study scripts (`02_main_study/*`, `03_synthetic_raters/01`, `02`) | |
| read from `data/main_study/` by default. Point them at another folder | |
| with an environment variable or a flag: | |
| ```bash | |
| ANALYSIS_DATA_DIR=data/your_study python analysis/02_main_study/01_omnibus_bias_model.py | |
| ``` | |
| To build that folder from a new collection: | |
| ```bash | |
| node tools/export-firestore.js # → data/your_study/raw/firebase_export.json | |
| ANALYSIS_DATA_DIR=data/your_study python analysis/01_data_prep/01_build_stim_tables.py | |
| ANALYSIS_DATA_DIR=data/your_study python analysis/01_data_prep/02_convert_main_json_to_csv.py | |
| ``` | |
| The convert script refuses to run against `data/main_study/`. The | |
| remaining folders (`03`–`08`) read the shipped follow-up and | |
| synthetic-rating tables directly, so they don't take a data folder. | |
| The data-prep scripts are only needed for new collections; the shipped | |
| tables are their outputs: | |
| | Script | Produces | | |
| |---|---| | |
| | `01_data_prep/01_build_stim_tables.py` | `prompt_stim_table.csv`, `survey_long_format.csv` from a `survey_data.json` | | |
| | `01_data_prep/02_convert_main_json_to_csv.py` | main-study long, wide and participant tables from a Firestore export | | |
| | `01_data_prep/03_synth_to_long_csv_multi.py` | `synth_long_*` tables from a wide synthetic-ratings file (`--model`, `--input`) | | |
| | `01_data_prep/04_convert_followup_json_to_csv.py` | follow-up long tables from `data/<study>/raw/` exports (see `tools/export-firestore-followup.js`) | | |
| ## Stimulus-screening worksheet | |
| `Stimuli_Sampling.pdf` is a 39-page export of the sheet used to screen | |
| candidate PRISM turns before the 200 study clips were chosen: yellow = | |
| poor audio, orange = other language, green = empty output, red = | |
| harmful. It is reference material only. The machine-readable provenance | |
| is `stimuli/main_study/study_stimuli_mapping.csv`. | |