|
Download data/voice_study/README.md from sciminds/same-words-different-judgements: direct link, hf CLI and curl.
- Browser
- Download file 5.68 kB
-
https://huggingface.co/datasets/sciminds/same-words-different-judgements/resolve/main/data/voice_study/README.md
- Command line
-
hf download hf://datasets/sciminds/same-words-different-judgements/data/voice_study/README.md
-
curl -L -o README.md https://huggingface.co/datasets/sciminds/same-words-different-judgements/resolve/main/data/voice_study/README.md
5.68 kB
| # Data dictionary: `data/voice_study/` | |
| Follow-up study: does the audio–text difference survive a change of TTS | |
| voice? The response text is held fixed and only the voice changes. | |
| Participants were assigned to one voice arm and heard it on every trial. | |
| The main study's audio condition (Kokoro `af_heart`) is the baseline and | |
| was not re-run. | |
| | Arm | Engine / voice | Analyzed raters | Label in the paper | | |
| |---|---|---:|---| | |
| | `kokoro_am_michael` | Kokoro-82M, `am_michael` | 15 | A1 | | |
| | `chatterbox` | Chatterbox, default voice | 16 | A2 | | |
| | `qwen3tts_serena` | Qwen3-TTS-12Hz-1.7B-CustomVoice, `Serena` | 17 | A3 | | |
| - **Stimuli:** 30 of the main study's 100 prompts | |
| (`stimuli/voice_study/prompts.csv`), presented in six fixed blocks of | |
| five. | |
| - **Session:** each participant rated four blocks (20 trials) plus one | |
| attention check. | |
| - **Coverage:** 8–12 raters per clip. | |
| - **Ethics and pay:** same IRB protocol, Prolific recruitment (US | |
| residents), consent flow and pay rate as the main study. | |
| - **Pseudonyms:** `V001..V066`, numbered in assignment order. These are | |
| different people from the main study's `P001..P094`. | |
| Results built from this folder: the voice ablation in Appendix G and | |
| Tables 9–12 and 15–18 (see `analysis/README.md`). | |
| ## Human ratings | |
| ### `long_voice_raw.csv` | |
| One row per (participant × rated clip), every arm, including attention | |
| checks and participants who later failed them. | |
| | column | type | description | | |
| |---|---|---| | |
| | PromptID | str | `<conv_id>_<turn_no>`, same ids as the main study; `attention_0` for the attention check | | |
| | ParticipantID | str | `V001`..`V066` | | |
| | AudioClip | str | `<PromptID>_<0|1>.mp3`; the same clip id names the same response text in every arm and in the main study | | |
| | TrialNumber | int | 0 = attention check, 1–20 = real trials | | |
| | IsAttentionCheck | bool | | | |
| | PresentedFirst | bool | this clip was played first on the trial | | |
| | Rating | int | 1–100 response-quality rating | | |
| | qualityRating | int | 1–100 audio-quality rating | | |
| | overallPreference | str | A / Tie / B, where A is the first-played clip | | |
| | Arm | str | voice arm (table above) | | |
| ### `long_voice_normalized.csv` | |
| The analysis input: real trials only, with participants who failed the | |
| attention check removed. It adds the main study's normalization columns, | |
| computed within each arm: | |
| | column | description | | |
| |---|---| | |
| | L | shrunk logit of Rating, `log(p / (1 − p))` with `p = (Rating + 0.5) / 101` | | |
| | L_adjusted | L with the arm's mean position bias removed from second-played clips | | |
| | position_bias | that arm's mean position bias (second-played minus first-played L) | | |
| | user_mean, user_sd | participant's mean and SD of L_adjusted | | |
| | L_centered | L_adjusted − user_mean | | |
| | z | L_centered / user_sd (0 when user_sd is 0) | | |
| | Pref_Num | 1 = this clip preferred, 0.5 = tie, 0 = the other clip | | |
| ### `participants_voice.csv` | |
| One row per participant record, including people who started and never | |
| finished. Demographic columns (Age through Education) are blank for | |
| records with `Analyzed` = False; their status and session columns are | |
| kept so completion rates can be reproduced. | |
| | column | description | | |
| |---|---| | |
| | ParticipantID, Arm | pseudonym and assigned voice. Arm is blank for 6 records that signed in but were never assigned | | |
| | Started, Completed | reached the first trial / finished the session | | |
| | PassedAttention | True / False, or blank if the participant never reached the attention check | | |
| | Analyzed | contributes rows to `long_voice_normalized.csv`. Five partial sessions that passed the attention check are included, as in the main study | | |
| | TotalSessionDuration | ms | | |
| | Age, Gender, Race, Ethnicity, EnglishProficiency, Country, Education | self-reported, same categories as the main study | | |
| | postSurveyDifficulty | 1–5 | | |
| | assignedTrialIDs | comma-separated `<arm>__<PromptID>` trial ids | | |
| ### `justifications_voice.csv` | |
| Optional free-text justifications (183): `PromptID`, `ParticipantID`, | |
| `Arm`, `TrialNumber`, `overallPreference`, `Justification`. Each was | |
| manually reviewed before release. | |
| ### `trial_durations_voice.csv` | |
| `ParticipantID`, `PromptID`, `TaskDurationMs`: time on each trial, used | |
| for the feasibility and cost analyses. | |
| ## Synthetic (AI) ratings: `synth/` | |
| Gemini 3.6 Flash and Qwen 3.5 Omni Flash rated every one of the 100 main | |
| study prompts rendered in each new voice, with the main study's audio | |
| protocol: 10 generations per pair, order counterbalanced, waveform in | |
| directly. The judges were not run on text here, since the text is | |
| unchanged from the main study. The baseline voice's ratings are the main | |
| study's own (`data/main_study/synth_long_audio_table_<model>.csv`). | |
| - `synthetic_ratings_<arm>_<model>.csv`: raw wide output, one row per | |
| prompt. Same columns as `data/main_study/synthetic_ratings_10x*.csv`, | |
| plus `arm`. The audio blocks are `response_rating_{a,b}_<i>`, | |
| `audio_quality_rating_{a,b}_<i>`, `justification_<i>` and | |
| `audio_order_a_first_<i>`. The `text_*` columns are empty. | |
| - `synth_long_audio_table_<arm>_<model>.csv`: the long form (`PromptID`, | |
| `AudioClip`, `PresentedFirst`, `Rating`, `qualityRating`, `synthNo`, | |
| `model`), produced by `analysis/01_data_prep/03_synth_to_long_csv_multi.py`. | |
| The judges' inputs (the prompt rows sent per voice) are in | |
| `stimuli/voice_study/synth_inputs/`. | |
| ## Provenance | |
| Built from the study's Firestore export with | |
| `analysis/01_data_prep/04_convert_followup_json_to_csv.py`, then | |
| anonymized. Dropped fields: Firebase UIDs, Prolific IDs, every | |
| timestamp, post-survey free-text feedback, and demographics the main | |
| release doesn't carry (birth country, timezone, employment, languages, | |
| "Other" free text). | |