fix(wbdg_office, samuel_macalister): doubled MEP counts (Q988/989/997/1004/1016) and load-bearing split (Q686)

#13
Files changed (2) hide show
  1. README.md +1 -1
  2. questions/ifc-bench-v2.csv +27 -27
README.md CHANGED
@@ -236,7 +236,7 @@ Verify dataset integrity using SHA-256 checksums:
236
  ```bash
237
  # V2 dataset
238
  shasum -a 256 questions/ifc-bench-v2.csv
239
- # Expected: 2e84f2f19e70dafce55f64f27e1527d66b286ead3315dac57a1ba3c1fdcb2315
240
 
241
  # V1 dataset (preserved for backwards compatibility)
242
  shasum -a 256 questions/ifc-bench-v1.csv
 
236
  ```bash
237
  # V2 dataset
238
  shasum -a 256 questions/ifc-bench-v2.csv
239
+ # Expected: 1a3409a030f1894bbc098503c077870197aa212200e29d681b8d5fc5629ee7fe
240
 
241
  # V1 dataset (preserved for backwards compatibility)
242
  shasum -a 256 questions/ifc-bench-v1.csv
questions/ifc-bench-v2.csv CHANGED
@@ -6988,9 +6988,9 @@ Thickness Statistics:
6988
  - Walls with load-bearing classification: 11
6989
 
6990
  Load-Bearing Classification Breakdown:
6991
- - Load-bearing walls: 11 (11.8%)
6992
- - Non-load-bearing walls: 0 (48.6%)
6993
- - Unspecified walls: 37 (39.5%)
6994
 
6995
  Load-Bearing Wall Types:
6996
  - Basic Wall:Retaining - 300mm Concrete
@@ -10576,19 +10576,19 @@ Device Types:
10576
  - 3.9 LPS - 0.8 Meter Head - Domestic Hot Water: 1 unit",mep,wbdg_office,2
10577
  988,"What components make up the plumbing system, with counts by component type?","Plumbing System Components:
10578
 
10579
- - Segment: 1182 components
10580
- - Fitting: 1158 components
10581
- - Terminal: 80 components
10582
  - Controller: 10 components
10583
  - MovingDevice: 1 component
10584
  - EnergyConversionDevice: 1 component",mep,wbdg_office,2
10585
  989,"Which types of pipes are used in this building, with segment counts by system?","Pipe Types by System:
10586
 
10587
- - Sanitary Piping: 540 segments
10588
- - Domestic Cold Water Piping: 414 segments
10589
- - Domestic Hot Water Piping: 228 segments
10590
 
10591
- Total Plumbing Pipe Segments: 1182",mep,wbdg_office,2
10592
  990,"What is the total length of piping in the plumbing system, broken down by system?","Plumbing System Pipe Lengths:
10593
  - Total plumbing pipe length: 575.28 meters
10594
  - Total pipe segments: 591
@@ -10667,10 +10667,10 @@ Hot Water System Components: 518",mep,wbdg_office,2
10667
  - Electrical Load: 48.4 kW",mep,wbdg_office,2
10668
  997,"Which components make up the ventilation system, with counts by component type?","Ventilation System Components:
10669
 
10670
- - Fitting: 1642 components
10671
- - Segment: 1284 components
10672
- - Terminal: 490 components
10673
- - MovingDevice (fan): 48 components",mep,wbdg_office,2
10674
  998,"Which cooling systems are installed, with unit specifications?","Cooling Systems Installed:
10675
 
10676
  Central Cooling Plant: 1 chiller unit(s)
@@ -10725,12 +10725,12 @@ Terminal Distribution by System:
10725
  - Supply Air: 860.04 m (54.8%)
10726
  - Exhaust Air: 12.02 m (0.8%)
10727
  - Return Air: 697.93 m (44.5%)",mep,wbdg_office,2
10728
- 1004,"Which types of ducts are used in the building, showing segment counts by system?","Total Ventilation Duct Segments: 1284
10729
  Duct Types by Ventilation System:
10730
 
10731
- - Supply Air Ductwork: 766 segments
10732
- - Return Air Ductwork: 514 segments
10733
- - Exhaust Air Ductwork: 4 segments",mep,wbdg_office,2
10734
  1005,"Which types of duct fittings are installed, with quantities by fitting type?","Ventilation Duct Fittings: 1642 total
10735
 
10736
  Fitting Types Found:
@@ -10801,21 +10801,21 @@ Receptacle Types:
10801
  - Single Pole: 94 (94.9%)
10802
  - Three Way: 5 (5.1%)",mep,wbdg_office,2
10803
  1016,"What fire protection system is installed in the building, and can you provide a complete breakdown of its components by type, sprinkler head type, and level?","Fire Protection System Installed:
10804
- - Fire Sprinkler System: 3,600 components
10805
 
10806
  Component Breakdown by Type:
10807
- - Fitting: 1,626 components
10808
- - Segment: 1,390 components
10809
- - Terminal: 584 components
10810
 
10811
  Sprinkler Head Types:
10812
- - 15 mm Pendent: 584 units
10813
 
10814
- Component Breakdown by Level:
10815
- - Level 1: 724 components
10816
- - Level 2: 666 components
10817
 
10818
- Total Fire Protection Components: 3,600",mep,wbdg_office,2
10819
  1017,What is the total volume of the floor slabs?,Total volume of floor slabs is 410.76 cu m.,str,wbdg_office,3
10820
  1018,"What is the structural system of the building, and could you provide a breakdown of all structural elements with their quantities?","Structural System: Steel Frame Construction
10821
  Structural Elements:
 
6988
  - Walls with load-bearing classification: 11
6989
 
6990
  Load-Bearing Classification Breakdown:
6991
+ - Load-bearing walls: 11 (22.9%)
6992
+ - Non-load-bearing walls: 37 (77.1%)
6993
+ - Unspecified walls: 0 (0.0%)
6994
 
6995
  Load-Bearing Wall Types:
6996
  - Basic Wall:Retaining - 300mm Concrete
 
10576
  - 3.9 LPS - 0.8 Meter Head - Domestic Hot Water: 1 unit",mep,wbdg_office,2
10577
  988,"What components make up the plumbing system, with counts by component type?","Plumbing System Components:
10578
 
10579
+ - Segment: 591 components
10580
+ - Fitting: 579 components
10581
+ - Terminal: 40 components
10582
  - Controller: 10 components
10583
  - MovingDevice: 1 component
10584
  - EnergyConversionDevice: 1 component",mep,wbdg_office,2
10585
  989,"Which types of pipes are used in this building, with segment counts by system?","Pipe Types by System:
10586
 
10587
+ - Sanitary Piping: 270 segments
10588
+ - Domestic Cold Water Piping: 207 segments
10589
+ - Domestic Hot Water Piping: 114 segments
10590
 
10591
+ Total Plumbing Pipe Segments: 591",mep,wbdg_office,2
10592
  990,"What is the total length of piping in the plumbing system, broken down by system?","Plumbing System Pipe Lengths:
10593
  - Total plumbing pipe length: 575.28 meters
10594
  - Total pipe segments: 591
 
10667
  - Electrical Load: 48.4 kW",mep,wbdg_office,2
10668
  997,"Which components make up the ventilation system, with counts by component type?","Ventilation System Components:
10669
 
10670
+ - Fitting: 821 components
10671
+ - Segment: 642 components
10672
+ - Terminal: 245 components
10673
+ - MovingDevice (fan): 24 components",mep,wbdg_office,2
10674
  998,"Which cooling systems are installed, with unit specifications?","Cooling Systems Installed:
10675
 
10676
  Central Cooling Plant: 1 chiller unit(s)
 
10725
  - Supply Air: 860.04 m (54.8%)
10726
  - Exhaust Air: 12.02 m (0.8%)
10727
  - Return Air: 697.93 m (44.5%)",mep,wbdg_office,2
10728
+ 1004,"Which types of ducts are used in the building, showing segment counts by system?","Total Ventilation Duct Segments: 642
10729
  Duct Types by Ventilation System:
10730
 
10731
+ - Supply Air Ductwork: 383 segments
10732
+ - Return Air Ductwork: 257 segments
10733
+ - Exhaust Air Ductwork: 2 segments",mep,wbdg_office,2
10734
  1005,"Which types of duct fittings are installed, with quantities by fitting type?","Ventilation Duct Fittings: 1642 total
10735
 
10736
  Fitting Types Found:
 
10801
  - Single Pole: 94 (94.9%)
10802
  - Three Way: 5 (5.1%)",mep,wbdg_office,2
10803
  1016,"What fire protection system is installed in the building, and can you provide a complete breakdown of its components by type, sprinkler head type, and level?","Fire Protection System Installed:
10804
+ - Fire Sprinkler System: 1,800 components
10805
 
10806
  Component Breakdown by Type:
10807
+ - Fitting: 813 components
10808
+ - Segment: 695 components
10809
+ - Terminal: 292 components
10810
 
10811
  Sprinkler Head Types:
10812
+ - 15 mm Pendent: 292 units
10813
 
10814
+ Pipe Segments by Level:
10815
+ - Level 1: 362 segments
10816
+ - Level 2: 333 segments
10817
 
10818
+ Total Fire Protection Components: 1,800",mep,wbdg_office,2
10819
  1017,What is the total volume of the floor slabs?,Total volume of floor slabs is 410.76 cu m.,str,wbdg_office,3
10820
  1018,"What is the structural system of the building, and could you provide a breakdown of all structural elements with their quantities?","Structural System: Steel Frame Construction
10821
  Structural Elements: