Dataset Viewer
Auto-converted to Parquet Duplicate
variant
large_stringclasses
2 values
model_key
large_stringclasses
7 values
model_name
large_stringclasses
7 values
benchmark
large_stringclasses
6 values
benchmark_name
large_stringclasses
6 values
axis
large_stringclasses
6 values
metric
large_stringclasses
3 values
n
int64
500
2.91k
score
float64
2.4
78.1
ci95_low
float64
1.38
75.6
ci95_high
float64
4.15
80.3
macro_f1
float64
13.6
78.1
⌀
mc2
float64
38.9
47.2
⌀
mc2_ci95_low
float64
37.3
45.3
⌀
mc2_ci95_high
float64
40.5
49.2
⌀
f1
float64
1.95
73.2
⌀
precision
float64
50
73.1
⌀
recall
float64
1
99.8
⌀
published
cosmos_gemma_9b
CosmosGemma-9B
mmlu
MMLU-TR
knowledge
accuracy
2,905
50.981067
49.163108
52.796435
50.768179
null
null
null
null
null
null
published
trendyol_7b_chat
Trendyol-7B-Chat v0.1
mmlu
MMLU-TR
knowledge
accuracy
2,905
23.442341
21.937502
25.017324
13.618427
null
null
null
null
null
null
published
trendyol_7b_chat_v4
Trendyol-7B-Chat v4.1
mmlu
MMLU-TR
knowledge
accuracy
2,905
40.309811
38.539999
42.105217
38.460185
null
null
null
null
null
null
published
wiroai_9b
WiroAI-9B
mmlu
MMLU-TR
knowledge
accuracy
2,905
45.197935
43.395651
47.012901
43.324974
null
null
null
null
null
null
published
wiroai_8b
WiroAI-8B
mmlu
MMLU-TR
knowledge
accuracy
2,905
42.822719
41.033977
44.630418
42.633683
null
null
null
null
null
null
published
kocdigital_8b
KoçDigital-8B v0.1
mmlu
MMLU-TR
knowledge
accuracy
2,905
37.693632
35.948691
39.471076
34.472287
null
null
null
null
null
null
published
kumru_2b_base
Kumru-2B-Base
mmlu
MMLU-TR
knowledge
accuracy
2,905
24.096386
22.57606
25.685129
22.976364
null
null
null
null
null
null
published
cosmos_gemma_9b
CosmosGemma-9B
arc
ARC-TR
scientific reasoning
accuracy
1,167
78.06341
75.599226
80.343446
78.107765
null
null
null
null
null
null
published
trendyol_7b_chat
Trendyol-7B-Chat v0.1
arc
ARC-TR
scientific reasoning
accuracy
1,167
23.479006
21.13657
25.99547
13.862933
null
null
null
null
null
null
published
trendyol_7b_chat_v4
Trendyol-7B-Chat v4.1
arc
ARC-TR
scientific reasoning
accuracy
1,167
68.894602
66.180276
71.484943
68.839817
null
null
null
null
null
null
published
wiroai_9b
WiroAI-9B
arc
ARC-TR
scientific reasoning
accuracy
1,167
73.86461
71.268392
76.304231
73.718257
null
null
null
null
null
null
published
wiroai_8b
WiroAI-8B
arc
ARC-TR
scientific reasoning
accuracy
1,167
63.496144
60.69384
66.209888
63.498322
null
null
null
null
null
null
published
kocdigital_8b
KoçDigital-8B v0.1
arc
ARC-TR
scientific reasoning
accuracy
1,167
54.241645
51.374045
57.081412
53.460937
null
null
null
null
null
null
published
kumru_2b_base
Kumru-2B-Base
arc
ARC-TR
scientific reasoning
accuracy
1,167
23.393316
21.054227
25.906995
22.040241
null
null
null
null
null
null
published
cosmos_gemma_9b
CosmosGemma-9B
hellaswag
HellaSwag-TR
commonsense
accuracy
1,000
54.7
51.602617
57.761411
54.62979
null
null
null
null
null
null
published
trendyol_7b_chat
Trendyol-7B-Chat v0.1
hellaswag
HellaSwag-TR
commonsense
accuracy
1,000
34.8
31.91094
37.805393
34.748327
null
null
null
null
null
null
published
trendyol_7b_chat_v4
Trendyol-7B-Chat v4.1
hellaswag
HellaSwag-TR
commonsense
accuracy
1,000
50
46.90696
53.09304
49.88323
null
null
null
null
null
null
published
wiroai_9b
WiroAI-9B
hellaswag
HellaSwag-TR
commonsense
accuracy
1,000
51.9
48.801915
54.983544
51.886589
null
null
null
null
null
null
published
wiroai_8b
WiroAI-8B
hellaswag
HellaSwag-TR
commonsense
accuracy
1,000
48.8
45.71244
51.896745
48.732369
null
null
null
null
null
null
published
kocdigital_8b
KoçDigital-8B v0.1
hellaswag
HellaSwag-TR
commonsense
accuracy
1,000
44.5
41.446705
47.595389
44.423942
null
null
null
null
null
null
published
kumru_2b_base
Kumru-2B-Base
hellaswag
HellaSwag-TR
commonsense
accuracy
1,000
41.4
38.385788
44.480032
41.384679
null
null
null
null
null
null
published
cosmos_gemma_9b
CosmosGemma-9B
gsm8k
GSM8K-TR
math reasoning
exact_match
500
72.8
68.736739
76.515591
null
null
null
null
null
null
null
published
trendyol_7b_chat
Trendyol-7B-Chat v0.1
gsm8k
GSM8K-TR
math reasoning
exact_match
500
3.2
1.979151
5.134487
null
null
null
null
null
null
null
published
trendyol_7b_chat_v4
Trendyol-7B-Chat v4.1
gsm8k
GSM8K-TR
math reasoning
exact_match
500
61.6
57.263883
65.759233
null
null
null
null
null
null
null
published
wiroai_9b
WiroAI-9B
gsm8k
GSM8K-TR
math reasoning
exact_match
500
40.6
36.383044
44.960293
null
null
null
null
null
null
null
published
wiroai_8b
WiroAI-8B
gsm8k
GSM8K-TR
math reasoning
exact_match
500
40.6
36.383044
44.960293
null
null
null
null
null
null
null
published
kocdigital_8b
KoçDigital-8B v0.1
gsm8k
GSM8K-TR
math reasoning
exact_match
500
43.6
39.31856
47.979031
null
null
null
null
null
null
null
published
kumru_2b_base
Kumru-2B-Base
gsm8k
GSM8K-TR
math reasoning
exact_match
500
2.4
1.378131
4.147706
null
null
null
null
null
null
null
published
cosmos_gemma_9b
CosmosGemma-9B
truthfulqa
TruthfulQA-TR
reliability
mc1
500
52.4
48.020822
56.742581
null
47.243709
45.269032
49.20461
null
null
null
published
trendyol_7b_chat
Trendyol-7B-Chat v0.1
truthfulqa
TruthfulQA-TR
reliability
mc1
500
45.4
41.087573
49.782571
null
44.797089
42.603685
47.016958
null
null
null
published
trendyol_7b_chat_v4
Trendyol-7B-Chat v4.1
truthfulqa
TruthfulQA-TR
reliability
mc1
500
48.2
43.850659
52.576789
null
43.582116
41.974501
45.19786
null
null
null
published
wiroai_9b
WiroAI-9B
truthfulqa
TruthfulQA-TR
reliability
mc1
500
49.4
45.039013
53.770136
null
43.952041
42.033863
45.863605
null
null
null
published
wiroai_8b
WiroAI-8B
truthfulqa
TruthfulQA-TR
reliability
mc1
500
47.4
43.059811
51.779835
null
44.639554
42.738785
46.458707
null
null
null
published
kocdigital_8b
KoçDigital-8B v0.1
truthfulqa
TruthfulQA-TR
reliability
mc1
500
47.4
43.059811
51.779835
null
44.761867
42.887308
46.586126
null
null
null
published
kumru_2b_base
Kumru-2B-Base
truthfulqa
TruthfulQA-TR
reliability
mc1
500
36.8
32.688455
41.112828
null
38.873878
37.250474
40.536653
null
null
null
published
cosmos_gemma_9b
CosmosGemma-9B
hallucination
HalluVerse-M3
hallucination detection
accuracy
800
67
63.667191
70.170327
null
null
null
null
73.170732
61.85567
89.552239
published
trendyol_7b_chat
Trendyol-7B-Chat v0.1
hallucination
HalluVerse-M3
hallucination detection
accuracy
800
49.75
46.294767
53.207623
null
null
null
null
1.95122
50
0.995025
published
trendyol_7b_chat_v4
Trendyol-7B-Chat v4.1
hallucination
HalluVerse-M3
hallucination detection
accuracy
800
52.5
49.035885
55.940221
null
null
null
null
67.8511
51.410256
99.751244
published
wiroai_9b
WiroAI-9B
hallucination
HalluVerse-M3
hallucination detection
accuracy
800
58.625
55.178876
61.988688
null
null
null
null
70.629991
54.896552
99.004975
published
wiroai_8b
WiroAI-8B
hallucination
HalluVerse-M3
hallucination detection
accuracy
800
64.25
60.868079
67.495723
null
null
null
null
66.510539
62.831858
70.646766
published
kocdigital_8b
KoçDigital-8B v0.1
hallucination
HalluVerse-M3
hallucination detection
accuracy
800
67.625
64.30507
70.776475
null
null
null
null
63.572433
73.139159
56.218905
published
kumru_2b_base
Kumru-2B-Base
hallucination
HalluVerse-M3
hallucination detection
accuracy
800
50.125
46.667943
53.580863
null
null
null
null
15.64482
52.112676
9.20398
arc_corrected
trendyol_7b_chat_v4
Trendyol-7B-Chat v4.1
arc
ARC-TR
scientific reasoning
accuracy
1,167
70.094259
67.40499
72.651672
null
null
null
null
null
null
null
arc_corrected
wiroai_9b
WiroAI-9B
arc
ARC-TR
scientific reasoning
accuracy
1,167
75.321337
72.767306
77.709212
null
null
null
null
null
null
null
arc_corrected
wiroai_8b
WiroAI-8B
arc
ARC-TR
scientific reasoning
accuracy
1,167
64.695801
61.909685
67.385485
null
null
null
null
null
null
null
arc_corrected
kocdigital_8b
KoçDigital-8B v0.1
arc
ARC-TR
scientific reasoning
accuracy
1,167
55.441302
52.57643
58.27047
null
null
null
null
null
null
null

Turkish LLM Multi-Axis Evaluation — Per-Item Results

These are the evaluation results behind the following paper. The release has per-item outcomes for every model, so the scores, confidence intervals and significance tests can all be recomputed without running a model.

M. T. Yılmaz, M. A. Pala, Y. Çakır, "A Multi-Axis Comparative Evaluation of Turkish Large Language Models across Knowledge, Reasoning, and Reliability," 2026 Innovations in Intelligent Systems and Applications Conference (ASYU), IEEE, 2026. doi:10.1109/ASYU71790.2026.11772376

Seven open-weight Turkish LLMs were evaluated on six benchmarks:

  • Shared protocol. Every model uses the same scoring rules and the same fixed inference settings.
  • Scoring. Multiple-choice tasks are scored by log-likelihood. Generation tasks use greedy decoding with seed 42.
  • Quantization. All models are loaded in 4-bit NF4.
  • Statistics. Scores carry 95% Wilson confidence intervals. Pairwise differences are tested with paired McNemar tests.

No benchmark text is included. Items are identified by SHA-256 hashes. The underlying datasets belong to their authors.

Main results

Primary metric per benchmark, in %. All models were evaluated on the same items.

Model MMLU-TR
(Acc)
ARC-TR
(Acc)
HellaSwag-TR
(Acc)
GSM8K-TR
(EM)
TruthfulQA-TR
(MC1)
HalluVerse-M3
(F1)
CosmosGemma-9B 51.0 78.1 54.7 72.8 52.4 73.2
Trendyol-7B-Chat v0.1 23.4 23.5 34.8 3.2 45.4 2.0
Trendyol-7B-Chat v4.1 40.3 68.9 50.0 61.6 48.2 67.9
WiroAI-9B 45.2 73.9 51.9 40.6 49.4 70.6
WiroAI-8B 42.8 63.5 48.8 40.6 47.4 66.5
KoçDigital-8B v0.1 37.7 54.2 44.5 43.6 47.4 63.6
Kumru-2B-Base 24.1 23.4 41.4 2.4 36.8 15.6
Significant pairs (McNemar, p<0.05) 20/21 20/21 18/21 17/21 9/21 15/21

Kumru-2B-Base is a base model and was evaluated with a raw prompt. On GSM8K-TR it used a 3-shot context. Treat its scores as a base-model reference, not a direct comparison with the instruction-tuned models.

Configurations

Config Rows Contents
scores (default) model × benchmark Primary metric with its 95% Wilson CI. Also macro-F1 (multiple-choice tasks); MC2 with a bootstrap CI (TruthfulQA); F1, precision and recall (HalluVerse). variant is published or arc_corrected (see Known issue).
item_results 48104 One row per model × scored item: correct (0/1), pred/gold (option index, number or 0/1 label, where stored), mc2 (TruthfulQA), correct_arc_fixed, item_sha256.
pairwise_mcnemar 6 × 21 All model pairs per benchmark: scores, discordant counts, McNemar p-value, significant_05.
models 7 Hugging Face ID, size, base model, training strategy, prompting, and whether predictions were stored.
subset_manifest 6874 Every item in the evaluated subsets. Includes evaluated, eval_index, source, subset, flag, text_sha256 and item_sha256.

item_results.eval_index matches subset_manifest.eval_index within each benchmark. Every model has exactly the same rows, so paired tests can be run directly.

Benchmarks

Axis Benchmark Source Items Scoring
Knowledge MMLU-TR (12 subjects) malhajar/mmlu-tr 2905 log-likelihood of option letter
Scientific reasoning ARC-TR (Challenge) malhajar/arc-tr 1167 log-likelihood of option letter
Commonsense HellaSwag-TR malhajar/hellaswag-tr 1000 length-normalized log-likelihood of the ending
Math reasoning GSM8K-TR malhajar/gsm8k_tr-v0.2 500 greedy generation (≤300 tokens), exact match on the final number
Reliability TruthfulQA-TR malhajar/truthfull_qa-tr 500 MC1 / MC2 with length-normalized log-likelihood
Hallucination HalluVerse-M3 (Turkish QA) sabdalja/HalluVerse-M3 800 (402 / 398) greedy generation (≤8 tokens), DOĞRU/YANLIŞ; accuracy and F1

Each subset was drawn by shuffling with random.seed(42) and keeping the first N items. The positive class for HalluVerse-M3 is "hallucinated".

Usage

from datasets import load_dataset

scores = load_dataset("tarikk/turkish-llm-eval-results", "scores", split="train").to_pandas()
items  = load_dataset("tarikk/turkish-llm-eval-results", "item_results", split="train").to_pandas()

# Example: paired comparison of two models on ARC-TR
arc = items[items.benchmark == "arc"].pivot(index="eval_index", columns="model_key", values="correct")
a, b = arc["cosmos_gemma_9b"], arc["wiroai_9b"]
print("A only:", ((a == 1) & (b == 0)).sum(), " B only:", ((a == 0) & (b == 1)).sum())

Known issue: ARC-TR answer keys given as digits

In the ARC-TR subset, 22 answer keys are digits ("1"–"4"). These keys are 1-based, but the evaluation code read them as 0-based. As a result:

  • 20 scored items were compared against the wrong option;
  • 2 items were skipped, which is why 1167 of the 1169 items are scored.

The affected items carry flag = arc_digit_key in subset_manifest. The column correct_arc_fixed re-scores them from the stored predictions. Where no predictions were stored, it is null.

Model Published Corrected
CosmosGemma-9B 78.1 78.0 – 79.6 (no stored predictions)
Trendyol-7B-Chat v0.1 23.5 23.4 – 25.0 (no stored predictions)
Trendyol-7B-Chat v4.1 68.9 70.1
WiroAI-9B 73.9 75.3
WiroAI-8B 63.5 64.7
KoçDigital-8B v0.1 54.2 55.4
Kumru-2B-Base 23.4 22.9 – 24.1 (no stored predictions)

ARC-TR scores change by at most about 1.5 percentage points. The number of significant ARC-TR pairs stays at 20/21 at both ends of the ranges, and the paper's conclusions are unaffected. Published scores are kept as variant = published.

Limitations

  • Translated benchmarks. Five of the six benchmarks are Turkish translations of English sources. Contamination from pre-training cannot be ruled out.
  • Quantization. All results are relative performance under shared 4-bit NF4 inference, not full-precision capability.
  • Not bit-exact across runs. 4-bit GPU inference is not bit-exact across runs or environments. A repeated WiroAI-9B run with identical code differed on 4 of the 500 GSM8K-TR items.
  • Observational comparison. The models differ in base family, size and training strategy all at once, so differences are comparative and not causal.

Citation

@inproceedings{yilmaz2026multiaxis,
  author    = {Yılmaz, Muhammet Tarık and Pala, Muhammed Ali and Çakır, Yusuf},
  title     = {A Multi-Axis Comparative Evaluation of Turkish Large Language Models across Knowledge, Reasoning, and Reliability},
  booktitle = {2026 Innovations in Intelligent Systems and Applications Conference (ASYU)},
  publisher = {IEEE},
  year      = {2026},
  doi       = {10.1109/ASYU71790.2026.11772376}
}

License

The results and this card are released under the MIT License, the same as the code. The benchmark datasets and the evaluated models are subject to their own licenses.

Downloads last month
-

Space using tarikk/turkish-llm-eval-results 1