Second-1.0-2B: Grounded Chess Explanation Model

Second is an open-source line of small language models that explain chess clearly. It is based on Qwen/Qwen3.5-2B. It turns engine facts into clear human coaching explanations for chess players.

Stockfish supplies the ground truth. The model does not calculate; it explains.


Model Description

Chess engines show evaluation bars and lines of engine symbols (+2.4, 14. Nxd4 exd4 15. Qh5+), but amateur players cannot understand why a move works or fails. Second bridges this gap by converting deterministic chess engine facts (tactical motifs, hanging pieces, refutations, material balance, and king safety) into clear, instructive prose.

Second-1.0-2B supports two target audiences:

  1. beginner (ratings under ~1200): Plain English, shorter sentences, no complex jargon (no "prophylaxis", "zwischenzug", or "outpost").
  2. club (ratings ~1200โ€“2000): Concrete tactical themes, refutation reasons, and strategic ideas.

Input Prompt Contract

Second uses the standard Qwen chat template. The user prompt follows a strict deterministic schema:

task: explain_move
level: club
detail: short

FEN: r1bqkbnr/1p1n1ppp/p2p4/2pPp1BQ/B3P3/8/PPP2PPP/RN2K1NR b KQkq - 1 7
Black to move, move 7.
Move played: Nf6.
Verdict: Blunder.
Black's winning chances: 89% โ†’ 57%.
Best move: Qa5+.
Best line: Qa5+ Nc3 b5 Bb3 Ngf6 Qe2.
Facts:
- Nf6 attacks the queen on h5.
- After Nf6, White's best reply is Bxd7+.
- The queen on h5 is not defended.
- White has a check: Bxd7+.
- White can capture the knight on f6 with Bxf6.
- Black threatens Nxh5.
- Material: equal.
- Phase: opening.

Example Model Output

The move Nf6 is a blunder because it ignores the immediate tactical refutation. While attacking the queen on h5 looks tempting, White responds with Bxd7+, forcing Black to lose material or suffer a devastating counterattack. The best move is Qa5+, which maintains pressure and avoids the loss of the queen. This check keeps the position balanced and prevents White from gaining a decisive advantage.


Stage T6 Frozen Evaluation Benchmarks

Second-1.0-2B was evaluated on the frozen 300-item test set (eval/testset-1.0.jsonl) with 9 deterministic verifiers and the debiased Gemini Flash judge:

Metric Base Qwen 2B Second v1 (grpo-1.0-2b) Second-1.0-2B (Release)
Deterministic Hard-Fail Rate 100.0% 7.7% 4.67% (14 / 300)
Format Pass Rate 82.3% 100.0% 100.00%
Target Length Compliance 21.0% 18.7% 99.67% (62.0 avg words)
First-Person Diary Voice 12.0% 51.3% 0.00%
Key-Point Soft Score 0.2100 0.3860 0.9790
Better-Move Soft Score 0.0800 0.1560 1.0000
Aggressive Terminology Over-Refusal 15.0% 0.0% 0.00% (0 / 20)
Pairwise Win Rate vs Base Qwen 2B โ€” โ€” 100.0% (86.2% LC-WR)
Pairwise Win Rate vs Second v1 โ€” โ€” 100.0% (97.5% LC-WR)
Pairwise Win Rate vs Gemini Flash โ€” โ€” 91.0% (74.5% LC-WR)

Training Recipe

Second-1.0-2B was trained using a two-stage post-training pipeline on an NVIDIA L4 GPU:

  1. Stage T3 (Engine-Grounded Distillation Warm-up SFT-A1):
    • Trained with LoRA (r=32, alpha=64, all linear layers) on 4,457 verified items (data/processed/sft_v2_train.jsonl).
    • Combined Apache 2.0 teacher synthetic explanations (Qwen2.5-7B-Instruct) filtered by 9 rule checks with curated gold human commentary.
  2. Stage T4 (GRPO RL Warm-up RL-B2):
    • Trained for 150 steps using DAPO (Direct Advantage Policy Optimization, beta=0.02) across 5,000 difficulty-filtered prompts (data/processed/rl_prompts_v2.jsonl).
    • Reward v2: Graded rule check penalties, multiplicative length rescaling, and anti-diary voice shaping. No LLM judge inside the RL loop.

Limitations

  • Engine Dependency: Stockfish supplies the ground truth. If the engine analysis depth is insufficient, the facts may miss deep multi-ply variations.
  • Language: English language only.
  • Calculation: The model does not compute chess variations beyond the engine-provided facts and best lines.
  • Ratings: Targeted at beginner (under 1200) and club (1200โ€“2000) players. Not designed for master-level opening novelty analysis.

Fair Play and Integrity Notice

Second is designed exclusively for post-game review and tactical training. The official browser extension fails closed:

  • Second turns completely OFF during active live games, blitz games, puzzles, puzzle storms, and live tournaments.
  • Second only activates on finished games (/analysis, study boards, or ended game URLs).
  • Do not use this model or its outputs for live game assistance.

License

Apache License 2.0. See LICENSE for details.

Downloads last month
51
Safetensors
Model size
2B params
Tensor type
BF16
ยท
Inference Providers NEW
This model isn't deployed by any Inference Provider. ๐Ÿ™‹ Ask for provider support

Model tree for joebos/Second-1.0-2B

Finetuned
Qwen/Qwen3.5-2B
Finetuned
(713)
this model
Quantizations
1 model