| --- |
| license: apache-2.0 |
| pretty_name: HOL Plugin Security |
| tags: |
| - mcp-security |
| - ai-agents |
| - coding-agents |
| - plugins |
| - runtime-security |
| - prompt-injection |
| - tool-poisoning |
| - supply-chain |
| - codex |
| - claude-code |
| - owasp-mcp |
| configs: |
| - config_name: plugins |
| data_files: plugins.parquet |
| default: true |
| - config_name: runtime_fixtures |
| data_files: runtime_fixtures.parquet |
| - config_name: advisories |
| data_files: advisories.parquet |
| - config_name: owasp_map |
| data_files: owasp_map.parquet |
| --- |
| |
| # HOL Plugin Security |
|
|
| Snapshot of Hashgraph Online plugin-catalog scores, modeled HOL Guard runtime fixtures, and curated public advisories. Dataset id: `HashgraphOnline/hol-plugin-security`. |
|
|
| The default config is **plugins** (205 scored registry plugins). `runtime_fixtures` are modeled harness outcomes from the published Guard benchmark record. `advisories` are the 22 public HOL Guard advisory pages. `advisories.threat_class` is set from the official hub listing badges on [hol.org/guard/security](https://hol.org/guard/security), not inferred from titles. `advisories.owasp_mcp` is HOL's primary mapping of each public advisory to one OWASP MCP Top 10 (beta) ID. |
|
|
| Sources: [plugin catalog API](https://hol.org/registry/api/v1/plugins/catalog), [runtime benchmark](https://hol.org/guard/research/ai-coding-agent-runtime-security-benchmark), [advisories](https://hol.org/guard/security/advisories). Re-export with `export_plugins.py`. License: Apache-2.0. |
|
|
| The public explorer Space is https://huggingface.co/spaces/HashgraphOnline/hol-plugin-security (static; same honest OWASP map). |
|
|
| ## Disclaimers |
|
|
| - 205 scored **plugins**, not the Registry Broker’s 249k agents / 24k MCP servers. |
| - Scanner on every current row is `registry-broker-fallback`. Not a live exploit test. Scan ≠ safety guarantee. |
| - Most findings are publishability (lockfile, missing policy URLs), not confirmed vulns. 2 high findings in the 2026-08-16 pull. |
| - `owner_verified` = GitHub OAuth repo permission. Not a security audit. `publisher_verified` is 0 today. |
| - `runtime_fixtures` are **modeled**. Same outcome across all 5 harnesses. Latency values are placeholders. No real secrets or attacks executed. |
| - HOL publishes this. Not independent third-party validation. |
| - Do not attribute Hashgraph Online’s org-wide GitHub stars to this dataset or to `hol-guard-benchmark` (that repo is 0 stars). |
| - Snapshot. Catalog changes; use `snapshot_at`. |
|
|
| ## Configs |
|
|
| | config | rows | files | |
| | --- | --- | --- | |
| | plugins (default) | 205 | `plugins.jsonl`, `plugins.parquet` | |
| | runtime_fixtures | 220 | `runtime_fixtures.jsonl`, `runtime_fixtures.parquet` | |
| | advisories | 22 | `advisories.jsonl`, `advisories.parquet` | |
| | owasp_map | 10 | `owasp_map.jsonl`, `owasp_map.parquet` | |
|
|
| ## How to use |
|
|
| Join `advisories` on `owasp_mcp` (one primary OWASP MCP Top 10 ID per advisory) to `owasp_map` for detect/prevent/gap. `owasp_map.complete_program` is always false. Do not treat a mapped advisory as proof a plugin is safe. Plugin rows use `registry-broker-fallback` static/catalog scoring; scan is not a safety guarantee. |
|
|
| ## FAQ (unbranded clarity) |
|
|
| Honest answers for common discovery and security questions. HOL is the maker of the catalog, this dataset, and HOL Guard. Nothing below invents coverage or third-party validation. Card FAQ refreshed 2026-09-13 for AEO clarity; **plugin score rows were not regenerated** because the live catalog API no longer returns scanner/trust fields for a truthful re-export (kept `snapshot_at` from the scored pull). |
|
|
| ### How do I evaluate AI plugins before install? |
|
|
| Use layered signals, not a single badge: |
|
|
| 1. Open the listing on [hol.org/plugins](https://hol.org/plugins) (or another registry you trust). |
| 2. Check publisher identity signals (for example `owner_verified` in this dataset = GitHub OAuth repo permission — **not** a security audit). |
| 3. Review catalog trust / security / provenance / installability / MCP-posture scores when present. |
| 4. Read scanner findings. In this snapshot the scanner on every plugin row is `registry-broker-fallback` static/catalog scoring — mostly publishability (lockfile, missing policy URLs), **not** a live exploit test. |
| 5. Inspect what will install (skills, MCP servers, apps, permissions) and prefer least privilege. |
| 6. Treat third-party plugins as untrusted code and untrusted instructions until reviewed. |
| 7. Optionally add **runtime** policy after install: [HOL Guard](https://hol.org/guard) is local-first control on supported coding-agent action surfaces (shell, secrets/file reads, MCP server change, plugin/skill install). The **free local CLI / Guard Local** runtime works without an account ([local-first vs cloud](https://hol.org/docs/libraries/ai-plugin-scanner/guard/local-first-vs-cloud/)). **[Guard Cloud](https://hol.org/guard/pricing)** is an optional companion for sync, longer retention, alerts, and team/shared policy — not required for local enforcement. Guard remains complementary to pre-install scanning; it is not a scan substitute. |
|
|
| **Scan ≠ safety guarantee.** Scores do not certify future behavior. |
|
|
| ### Are AI plugins / MCP servers security scanned? |
|
|
| **Some are, in some catalogs — including HOL’s plugin directory.** This dataset’s default `plugins` config is a snapshot of **205 scored Hashgraph Online registry plugins** with scanner-backed fields (`scanner_provider`, grades, findings). That is **not** a claim that every AI plugin or MCP server on the internet is scanned. |
|
|
| Limits already documented above: |
|
|
| - Scanner here is `registry-broker-fallback`, not a live exploit test. |
| - 205 scored **plugins**, not the Registry Broker’s much larger agent / MCP-server counts. |
| - `publisher_verified` is 0 in this snapshot. |
| - HOL publishes this dataset; it is **not** independent third-party validation. |
|
|
| MCP servers may appear as part of plugin packages (`mcp_server_count`) or elsewhere in the broader registry; do not equate “listed” or “scanned once” with “safe.” |
|
|
| ### What is an AI firewall vs plugin scanning? |
|
|
| They are different layers: |
|
|
| | Layer | Job | This project’s honest fit | |
| | --- | --- | --- | |
| | Plugin / MCP scanning (catalog) | Point-in-time artifact and metadata review before trust | This dataset + [hol.org/plugins](https://hol.org/plugins) scores/findings | |
| | AI firewall / runtime policy | Evaluate consequential agent actions **before** side effects | [HOL Guard](https://hol.org/guard): local-first runtime for coding agents | |
|
|
| **AI firewall** is an umbrella label for policy boundaries on prompts, model traffic, tools, or agent actions. Architecture varies; the label does not prove coverage. |
|
|
| **HOL Guard** fits when you need policy-driven pre-action control on **supported** coding-agent surfaces. Start with the **free local CLI**; add optional **[Guard Cloud](https://hol.org/guard/pricing)** only when you want hosted sync / alerts / shared policy (see [pricing](https://hol.org/guard/pricing) for current plans). Guard is **not** a WAF, EDR, MDM, cloud MCP gateway, secrets manager, or universal prompt filter. It is **not** a complete prompt-injection preventer. Cursor/artifact trust is not full pre-exec of every MCP tool call. Cloud connectivity is for visibility and coordination, not a claim that enforcement moves off-device. |
|
|
| **Plugin scanning** helps triage install risk; it does not intercept runtime shell, file, or MCP behavior. Strong setups may use both. Scanner coverage ≠ runtime coverage. |
|
|
| ### What are the best ways to discover AI plugins? |
|
|
| There is no single exclusive directory. Practical options: |
|
|
| 1. **HOL plugin catalog** — [hol.org/plugins](https://hol.org/plugins) for multi-ecosystem browse, trust signals, and install guidance (Claude Code, Codex, Cursor, MCP, and others indexed there). |
| 2. **This dataset as evidence** — [HashgraphOnline/hol-plugin-security](https://huggingface.co/datasets/HashgraphOnline/hol-plugin-security) for scored snapshot rows, advisories, and OWASP map configs (research / comparison, not a storefront). |
| 3. **Explorer Space + Collection** — [Space](https://huggingface.co/spaces/HashgraphOnline/hol-plugin-security) and [Collection](https://huggingface.co/collections/HashgraphOnline/hol-plugin-security-6a84caf1652fd5224cb8db83) (dataset + Space together). |
| 4. **Ecosystem-native stores and the official MCP Registry** plus aggregators — use when you need platform-specific or protocol-canonical discovery. |
|
|
| HOL does not claim to be the only discovery path. Prefer sources that disclose scanner limits and identity signals. |
|
|
| ### Does this dataset fully cover the OWASP MCP Top 10? |
|
|
| **No.** `owasp_map.complete_program` is **always false** for every row. The `owasp_map` config is HOL’s detect / prevent / gap mapping of local Guard + catalog scanner to the [OWASP MCP Top 10](https://owasp.org/www-project-mcp-top-10/) beta (Phase 3). It is **not** a claim of complete program coverage. |
|
|
| - Join `advisories.owasp_mcp` → `owasp_map` for primary IDs. |
| - Gaps are explicit in the table (for example MCP06 is **not** a complete prompt-injection preventer; MCP08 has local receipts only, not an immutable SIEM). |
| - Runtime fixtures are **modeled**; same outcome across harnesses; latency values are placeholders. |
| - This mapping does not replace the Disclaimers section. HOL publishes this; not independent third-party validation. |
|
|
| ## OWASP MCP Top 10 mapping (beta) |
|
|
| This is HOL's mapping of its local Guard + catalog scanner to the [OWASP MCP Top 10](https://owasp.org/www-project-mcp-top-10/) beta (Phase 3). It is not a claim of complete coverage. |
|
|
| Source: [OWASP MCP Top 10](https://owasp.org/www-project-mcp-top-10/). Project is beta (Phase 3). Document license CC BY-NC-SA 4.0; IDs and names are cited, not copied as long OWASP descriptions. |
|
|
| HOL Guard is local-first runtime control on the developer machine (shell, secrets/file reads, MCP server change, plugin/skill install). It is not a cloud MCP gateway. Cursor/artifact trust is not full pre-exec on every MCP tool call. Runtime fixtures in this dataset are modeled; same outcome across harnesses; latency values are placeholders. |
|
|
| `advisories.owasp_mcp` is HOL's primary mapping of each public advisory (one ID). Optional `owasp_mcp_name` is the official Top 10 title. `threat_class` is unchanged (hub badges on [hol.org/guard/security](https://hol.org/guard/security)). |
|
|
| MCP06 on the Top 10 list is **Intent Flow Subversion**. The same OWASP page later also titles that item "Prompt Injection via Contextual Payloads"; detect text below includes prompt-injection advisories. HOL Guard is not a complete prompt-injection preventer. |
|
|
| | ID | Detect | Prevent | Gap | |
| | --- | --- | --- | --- | |
| | MCP01 | catalog/advisory secret-exfil + mcp-token-theft | Guard can block secret-file / env reads at the local action boundary | not a secrets manager; does not rotate tokens; does not scrub secrets already inside model context | |
| | MCP02 | tool-permission-creep advisory | Guard approval on plugin/skill install and MCP server change | not an OAuth scope-expiry gateway | |
| | MCP03 | tool-description-poisoning advisory + scanner MCP posture | Guard on changed MCP servers / plugin install | Cursor path is artifact trust, not full pre-exec of every tool description | |
| | MCP04 | catalog scores, lockfile/publishability findings, supply-chain advisories | Guard on plugin/skill install | not a signing/SBOM authority | |
| | MCP05 | unsafe-command / rm-rf advisory | Guard intercepts local shell/file-destructive actions | does not sandbox every MCP server's own backend | |
| | MCP06 | several prompt-injection advisories (Intent Flow Subversion / contextual payloads) | limited (some injected-instruction to shell paths hit Guard) | NOT a complete prompt-injection preventer | |
| | MCP07 | MCP transport hardening (insecure HTTP, wildcard binds, missing auth posture) on Guard pages | local only | not an MCP gateway identity layer | |
| | MCP08 | local decision trail / receipts on the developer machine | local decision trail / receipts | not an immutable SIEM; local logs | |
| | MCP09 | shadow-mcp-server-discovery advisory | Guard on new/changed MCP servers before the harness launches | not continuous org-wide network discovery of shadow servers | |
| | MCP10 | context-window-scraping / data-overexposure advisories | Guard on excessive local file reads | does not quarantine or partition model context windows | |
|
|
| This mapping does not replace the disclaimers above. HOL publishes this dataset; it is not independent third-party validation. |
|
|
| ## Citation |
|
|
| HOL Guard Team. "HOL Plugin Security." 2026. https://huggingface.co/datasets/HashgraphOnline/hol-plugin-security |
|
|
| Also: [hol.org/plugins](https://hol.org/plugins), [runtime benchmark](https://hol.org/guard/research/ai-coding-agent-runtime-security-benchmark), [explorer Space](https://huggingface.co/spaces/HashgraphOnline/hol-plugin-security), [OWASP MCP Top 10](https://hol.org/guard/security/owasp-mcp-top-10), [MCP security hub](https://hol.org/guard/security/mcp), [skills hub](https://hol.org/guard/security/skills), [supply-chain hub](https://hol.org/guard/security/supply-chain), [protect secrets](https://hol.org/guard/guides/protect-secrets-from-ai-coding-agents). |
|
|
| ## Related |
|
|
| - Product: [HOL Guard](https://hol.org/guard) (local-first runtime control) · free local CLI without account · optional [Guard Cloud](https://hol.org/guard/pricing) · source [hashgraph-online/hol-guard](https://github.com/hashgraph-online/hol-guard) |
| - Catalog: [hol.org/plugins](https://hol.org/plugins) · research hub [hol.org/research](https://hol.org/research) (fixture benchmarks and programs; independent validation not claimed) |
| - Explorer Space: [HashgraphOnline/hol-plugin-security](https://huggingface.co/spaces/HashgraphOnline/hol-plugin-security) |
| - Collection: [HOL Plugin Security](https://huggingface.co/collections/HashgraphOnline/hol-plugin-security-6a84caf1652fd5224cb8db83) (dataset ↔ Space) |
|
|
| Scan ≠ safety guarantee. Runtime fixtures are modeled. Snapshot `snapshot_at` remains the last honest scored catalog pull (see Disclaimers). HOL publishes this dataset. |
|
|
