Caesarrr commited on
Commit
229c343
·
verified ·
1 Parent(s): 58157c5

Add task-level fine-tuning-scope catalogue and preserve historical comparison limits

Browse files
README.md CHANGED
@@ -710,6 +710,14 @@ configs:
710
  path: latency-aware/intercept-grab-fast/mean_rtx3090_h1_s123_275ep_v1/demonstrations/conversion/expected/lerobot/meta/episodes/**/*.parquet
711
  - split: validation
712
  path: latency-aware/intercept-grab-fast/mean_rtx3090_h1_s123_275ep_v1/demonstrations/conversion/expected/lerobot__val/meta/episodes/**/*.parquet
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
713
  dataset_info:
714
  - config_name: humanoidbench_balance_simple
715
  features:
@@ -2735,6 +2743,37 @@ dataset_info:
2735
  - name: deterministic
2736
  dtype: bool
2737
  download_size: 1211318389
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
2738
  ---
2739
 
2740
  # LAGEN benchmark-datasets
@@ -2746,6 +2785,7 @@ Training data, episode-level evaluations and paper experiment manifests.
2746
  | Visual history | [Visual history](https://huggingface.co/datasets/latency-sensitive-bench/benchmark-datasets/tree/main/experiments/visual-history) |
2747
  | Latency in prompt | [Latency in prompt](https://huggingface.co/datasets/latency-sensitive-bench/benchmark-datasets/tree/main/experiments/latency-in-prompt) |
2748
  | Latency transfer | [Latency transfer](https://huggingface.co/datasets/latency-sensitive-bench/benchmark-datasets/tree/main/experiments/latency-transfer) |
 
2749
  | Mean vs. profile training | [Mean vs. profile training](https://huggingface.co/datasets/latency-sensitive-bench/benchmark-datasets/tree/main/experiments/mean-vs-profile) |
2750
 
2751
  | Resource | Repository |
 
710
  path: latency-aware/intercept-grab-fast/mean_rtx3090_h1_s123_275ep_v1/demonstrations/conversion/expected/lerobot/meta/episodes/**/*.parquet
711
  - split: validation
712
  path: latency-aware/intercept-grab-fast/mean_rtx3090_h1_s123_275ep_v1/demonstrations/conversion/expected/lerobot__val/meta/episodes/**/*.parquet
713
+ - config_name: flappy_fixed_l2_fs4
714
+ data_files:
715
+ - split: train
716
+ path:
717
+ - latency-aware/flappy/flappy_fixed_l2_fs4/train.parquet
718
+ - split: val
719
+ path:
720
+ - latency-aware/flappy/flappy_fixed_l2_fs4/val.parquet
721
  dataset_info:
722
  - config_name: humanoidbench_balance_simple
723
  features:
 
2743
  - name: deterministic
2744
  dtype: bool
2745
  download_size: 1211318389
2746
+ - config_name: flappy_fixed_l2_fs4
2747
+ features:
2748
+ - name: action
2749
+ list: float32
2750
+ - name: action_id
2751
+ dtype: int64
2752
+ - name: action_text
2753
+ dtype: string
2754
+ - name: deterministic
2755
+ dtype: bool
2756
+ - name: done
2757
+ dtype: bool
2758
+ - name: episode_idx
2759
+ dtype: int64
2760
+ - name: image_stack
2761
+ list: image
2762
+ - name: latency_ms
2763
+ dtype: float64
2764
+ - name: latency_raw_frames
2765
+ dtype: int64
2766
+ - name: prompt
2767
+ dtype: string
2768
+ - name: reward
2769
+ dtype: float64
2770
+ - name: seed
2771
+ dtype: int64
2772
+ - name: split
2773
+ dtype: string
2774
+ - name: t
2775
+ dtype: int64
2776
+ download_size: 11243675137
2777
  ---
2778
 
2779
  # LAGEN benchmark-datasets
 
2785
  | Visual history | [Visual history](https://huggingface.co/datasets/latency-sensitive-bench/benchmark-datasets/tree/main/experiments/visual-history) |
2786
  | Latency in prompt | [Latency in prompt](https://huggingface.co/datasets/latency-sensitive-bench/benchmark-datasets/tree/main/experiments/latency-in-prompt) |
2787
  | Latency transfer | [Latency transfer](https://huggingface.co/datasets/latency-sensitive-bench/benchmark-datasets/tree/main/experiments/latency-transfer) |
2788
+ | VLA fine-tuning scope | [VLA fine-tuning scope](https://huggingface.co/datasets/latency-sensitive-bench/benchmark-datasets/tree/main/experiments/vla-finetuning-scope) |
2789
  | Mean vs. profile training | [Mean vs. profile training](https://huggingface.co/datasets/latency-sensitive-bench/benchmark-datasets/tree/main/experiments/mean-vs-profile) |
2790
 
2791
  | Resource | Repository |
experiments/README.md CHANGED
@@ -5,6 +5,7 @@
5
  | Visual history | Flappy Bird, Demon Attack, Deadly Corridor | 17 selected/source checkpoint entries | [Visual history](visual-history/README.md) |
6
  | Latency in prompt | Flappy Bird, Demon Attack | 2 selected/source checkpoint entries; Demon links pending | [Latency in prompt](latency-in-prompt/README.md) |
7
  | Latency transfer | Flappy Bird, Demon Attack | 17 selected/source checkpoint entries | [Latency transfer](latency-transfer/README.md) |
 
8
  | Mean vs. profile training | Flappy Bird, Deadly Corridor, Ant, InterceptGrabFast | 8 selected/source checkpoint entries | [Mean vs. profile training](mean-vs-profile/README.md) |
9
 
10
  Each task page provides settings, fixed asset references and evaluation evidence. Shared assets have one current location.
 
5
  | Visual history | Flappy Bird, Demon Attack, Deadly Corridor | 17 selected/source checkpoint entries | [Visual history](visual-history/README.md) |
6
  | Latency in prompt | Flappy Bird, Demon Attack | 2 selected/source checkpoint entries; Demon links pending | [Latency in prompt](latency-in-prompt/README.md) |
7
  | Latency transfer | Flappy Bird, Demon Attack | 17 selected/source checkpoint entries | [Latency transfer](latency-transfer/README.md) |
8
+ | VLA fine-tuning scope | Flappy Bird | 7 scope runs; 2 historical trials | [Details](vla-finetuning-scope/README.md) |
9
  | Mean vs. profile training | Flappy Bird, Deadly Corridor, Ant, InterceptGrabFast | 8 selected/source checkpoint entries | [Mean vs. profile training](mean-vs-profile/README.md) |
10
 
11
  Each task page provides settings, fixed asset references and evaluation evidence. Shared assets have one current location.
experiments/vla-finetuning-scope/README.md ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,8 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ # VLA fine-tuning scope
2
+
3
+ Compare trainable model components.
4
+
5
+ | Task | Settings and assets |
6
+ |---|---|
7
+ | Flappy Bird | [Final scope comparison](flappy/README.md) |
8
+ | Historical LoRA/full | [Separate source records](archive/flappy/README.md) |
experiments/vla-finetuning-scope/archive/flappy/README.md ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,5 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ # Historical LoRA/full — Flappy Bird
2
+
3
+ The retained HF evaluation has 50 episodes: Full mean 18.5180, LoRA mean 3.8620. The old paper has a separate 100-episode aggregate: Full 22.3080, LoRA 3.4820. The original 100-episode source and exact weight binding remain unrecovered. Both records are preserved without substitution.
4
+
5
+ `manifest.json` identifies the separate model, adapter, action head, data and evaluation sources.
experiments/vla-finetuning-scope/archive/flappy/manifest.json ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,178 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ {
2
+ "experiment": "vla-finetuning-scope",
3
+ "archived": true,
4
+ "runs": [
5
+ {
6
+ "run": "openvla_flappy_l2_full",
7
+ "source": {
8
+ "repo": "latency-sensitive-bench/vla-finetuning-scope-models",
9
+ "revision": "1ab96924e691cbe8924ac4671466723bdb5ec3af",
10
+ "path": "historical/openvla_flappy_l2_full"
11
+ },
12
+ "metadata": {
13
+ "repo": "latency-sensitive-bench/benchmark-models",
14
+ "revision": "f99bd515da2a2a364198848b7f3c2dcaaf9566dd",
15
+ "path": "latency-aware/flappy/vla/starvla-qwenoft-h1/openvla_flappy_l2_full"
16
+ },
17
+ "checkpoints": [
18
+ {
19
+ "repo": "latency-sensitive-bench/benchmark-models",
20
+ "revision": "f99bd515da2a2a364198848b7f3c2dcaaf9566dd",
21
+ "path": "latency-aware/flappy/vla/starvla-qwenoft-h1/openvla_flappy_l2_full/final_model/pytorch_model.pt"
22
+ }
23
+ ],
24
+ "source_bindings": [
25
+ {
26
+ "source_repo": "latency-sensitive-bench/openvla_flappy_l2_full",
27
+ "source_revision": "2e8e58c6af1ee6f8a3701388b2552a4fa65a041c",
28
+ "target_repo": "latency-sensitive-bench/vla-finetuning-scope-models",
29
+ "target_run": "historical/openvla_flappy_l2_full",
30
+ "artifact_state": "complete_checkpoint_bundle",
31
+ "framework": "QwenOFT",
32
+ "run_id": "openvla_flappy_l2_full",
33
+ "training_step": 2000,
34
+ "seed": 42,
35
+ "training_data_root": "/root/latency-sensitive-bench/playground/Datasets/rl_games",
36
+ "training_data_mix": "flappy_fixed_l2_fs4",
37
+ "dataset_reference": null,
38
+ "original_dataset_config": null,
39
+ "weights": [
40
+ {
41
+ "path": "historical/openvla_flappy_l2_full/final_model/pytorch_model.pt",
42
+ "identity": "f6be353e457ac9cf6dbda6cd2e93692d797016100b69ecea4bcab0ececb9a076",
43
+ "source_path": "final_model/pytorch_model.pt",
44
+ "size": 9805972271
45
+ }
46
+ ],
47
+ "paper_locations": [
48
+ "paper/legacy/figures/sft_comparisons/lora_vs_full"
49
+ ],
50
+ "paper_identity_confirmed": false,
51
+ "interpretation": "The legacy experiment and training models are documented. The paper 100-episode raw evaluation and its exact weight binding were not recovered. The separate HF 50-episode record is preserved unchanged.",
52
+ "unpublished_training_data": "The recorded local training directory has no recovered exact HF source. No replacement dataset is assumed.",
53
+ "paper_evaluation_record_difference": [
54
+ {
55
+ "method": "full",
56
+ "hf_episode_count": 50,
57
+ "hf_mean_return": 18.518000243455173,
58
+ "paper_episode_count": 100,
59
+ "paper_mean_return": 22.308000287115576,
60
+ "same_evaluation_record": false,
61
+ "hf_timestamp": "2026-06-02T23:20:12.557796+00:00",
62
+ "note": "The HF 50-episode record and paper 100-episode aggregate are retained separately. The paper local per-episode source files were not recovered."
63
+ },
64
+ {
65
+ "method": "lora",
66
+ "hf_episode_count": 50,
67
+ "hf_mean_return": 3.8620000724494457,
68
+ "paper_episode_count": 100,
69
+ "paper_mean_return": 3.4820000667870046,
70
+ "same_evaluation_record": false,
71
+ "hf_timestamp": "2026-06-02T22:57:10.859128+00:00",
72
+ "note": "The HF 50-episode record and paper 100-episode aggregate are retained separately. The paper local per-episode source files were not recovered."
73
+ }
74
+ ]
75
+ }
76
+ ],
77
+ "evaluation": {
78
+ "repo": "latency-sensitive-bench/benchmark-datasets",
79
+ "revision": "58157c572dbd2e0e5036ce197c42db975e56ae4e",
80
+ "path": "evaluations/flappy/openvla_flappy_l2_full"
81
+ }
82
+ },
83
+ {
84
+ "run": "openvla_flappy_l2_lora",
85
+ "source": {
86
+ "repo": "latency-sensitive-bench/vla-finetuning-scope-models",
87
+ "revision": "1ab96924e691cbe8924ac4671466723bdb5ec3af",
88
+ "path": "historical/openvla_flappy_l2_lora"
89
+ },
90
+ "metadata": {
91
+ "repo": "latency-sensitive-bench/benchmark-models",
92
+ "revision": "f99bd515da2a2a364198848b7f3c2dcaaf9566dd",
93
+ "path": "latency-aware/flappy/vla/starvla-qwenoft-h1/openvla_flappy_l2_lora"
94
+ },
95
+ "checkpoints": [
96
+ {
97
+ "repo": "latency-sensitive-bench/benchmark-models",
98
+ "revision": "f99bd515da2a2a364198848b7f3c2dcaaf9566dd",
99
+ "path": "latency-aware/flappy/vla/starvla-qwenoft-h1/openvla_flappy_l2_lora/final_model/action_model.pt"
100
+ },
101
+ {
102
+ "repo": "latency-sensitive-bench/benchmark-models",
103
+ "revision": "f99bd515da2a2a364198848b7f3c2dcaaf9566dd",
104
+ "path": "latency-aware/flappy/vla/starvla-qwenoft-h1/openvla_flappy_l2_lora/final_model/adapter_model.safetensors"
105
+ }
106
+ ],
107
+ "source_bindings": [
108
+ {
109
+ "source_repo": "latency-sensitive-bench/openvla_flappy_l2_lora",
110
+ "source_revision": "427f4c0582d6eb9419fa39f5942db1d59585993c",
111
+ "target_repo": "latency-sensitive-bench/vla-finetuning-scope-models",
112
+ "target_run": "historical/openvla_flappy_l2_lora",
113
+ "artifact_state": "complete_checkpoint_bundle",
114
+ "framework": "QwenOFT",
115
+ "run_id": "openvla_flappy_l2_lora",
116
+ "training_step": 2000,
117
+ "seed": 42,
118
+ "training_data_root": "/mnt/data/latency_data/playground/Datasets/rl_games",
119
+ "training_data_mix": "flappy_fixed_l2_fs4",
120
+ "dataset_reference": null,
121
+ "original_dataset_config": null,
122
+ "weights": [
123
+ {
124
+ "path": "historical/openvla_flappy_l2_lora/final_model/action_model.pt",
125
+ "identity": "e8bc83aaf046d0b6c2045cd38c06875ccc60c808701d6eba10fc491e2b016ffb",
126
+ "source_path": "final_model/action_model.pt",
127
+ "size": 131200330
128
+ },
129
+ {
130
+ "path": "historical/openvla_flappy_l2_lora/final_model/adapter_model.safetensors",
131
+ "identity": "551bd2362cc9548b9d97f3a4f77fcfbe2b28f2725b2897ab42b996485962b8bb",
132
+ "source_path": "final_model/adapter_model.safetensors",
133
+ "size": 161192096
134
+ }
135
+ ],
136
+ "paper_locations": [
137
+ "paper/legacy/figures/sft_comparisons/lora_vs_full"
138
+ ],
139
+ "paper_identity_confirmed": false,
140
+ "interpretation": "The legacy experiment and training models are documented. The paper 100-episode raw evaluation and its exact weight binding were not recovered. The separate HF 50-episode record is preserved unchanged.",
141
+ "unpublished_training_data": "The recorded local training directory has no recovered exact HF source. No replacement dataset is assumed.",
142
+ "paper_evaluation_record_difference": [
143
+ {
144
+ "method": "full",
145
+ "hf_episode_count": 50,
146
+ "hf_mean_return": 18.518000243455173,
147
+ "paper_episode_count": 100,
148
+ "paper_mean_return": 22.308000287115576,
149
+ "same_evaluation_record": false,
150
+ "hf_timestamp": "2026-06-02T23:20:12.557796+00:00",
151
+ "note": "The HF 50-episode record and paper 100-episode aggregate are retained separately. The paper local per-episode source files were not recovered."
152
+ },
153
+ {
154
+ "method": "lora",
155
+ "hf_episode_count": 50,
156
+ "hf_mean_return": 3.8620000724494457,
157
+ "paper_episode_count": 100,
158
+ "paper_mean_return": 3.4820000667870046,
159
+ "same_evaluation_record": false,
160
+ "hf_timestamp": "2026-06-02T22:57:10.859128+00:00",
161
+ "note": "The HF 50-episode record and paper 100-episode aggregate are retained separately. The paper local per-episode source files were not recovered."
162
+ }
163
+ ]
164
+ }
165
+ ],
166
+ "evaluation": {
167
+ "repo": "latency-sensitive-bench/benchmark-datasets",
168
+ "revision": "58157c572dbd2e0e5036ce197c42db975e56ae4e",
169
+ "path": "evaluations/flappy/openvla_flappy_l2_lora"
170
+ }
171
+ }
172
+ ],
173
+ "training_data": {
174
+ "repo": "latency-sensitive-bench/benchmark-datasets",
175
+ "revision": "58157c572dbd2e0e5036ce197c42db975e56ae4e",
176
+ "path": "latency-aware/flappy/flappy_fixed_l2_fs4"
177
+ }
178
+ }
experiments/vla-finetuning-scope/flappy/README.md ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,53 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ # VLA fine-tuning scope — Flappy Bird
2
+
3
+ # VLA fine-tuning scope
4
+
5
+ This experiment asks how much of OpenVLA must be fine-tuned for latency-aware
6
+ control. The initial hypothesis was that preserving the pretrained visual
7
+ representation and adapting only the upper language-model layers plus the
8
+ action head would be sufficient. The final comparison does not support that
9
+ hypothesis: full-model fine-tuning achieves the highest evaluation return.
10
+
11
+ The result shows no evidence that full-model fine-tuning harms downstream
12
+ control in this setting. It does **not** establish that the pretrained visual
13
+ representation remains unchanged or that perception itself improves, because
14
+ the experiment contains no perception-specific metric.
15
+
16
+ ## Reported comparison
17
+
18
+ The figure reports the final checkpoint for each of three fine-tuning scopes:
19
+
20
+ | Figure label | Trainable scope |
21
+ | --- | --- |
22
+ | `Top-8 + vision` | Vision tower and connector, tied embeddings/language-model head, decoder layers 28--35, and action head |
23
+ | `Top-8 only` | Decoder layers 28--35 and action head; vision tower, connector, and tied embeddings/language-model head are frozen |
24
+ | `Full model` | All model parameters |
25
+
26
+ Qwen3-VL-4B has 36 decoder layers, so layers 28--35 are the upper eight
27
+ layers. `data.csv` contains only these three final checkpoints. The runs use an
28
+ effective batch size of 128 examples (64 x 2 accumulation for the partial
29
+ scopes and 32 x 4 for full-model tuning). Their module-specific learning rates
30
+ are also matched: `2e-5` base, `1e-5` VLA interface, and `1e-4` action head.
31
+
32
+ ## Setting
33
+
34
+ - Model: OpenVLA initialized from the Qwen3-VL-4B Bridge checkpoint.
35
+ - Environment: Flappy Bird.
36
+ - Training data: 200 episodes collected with fixed two-tick latency.
37
+ - Input: one observation frame.
38
+ - Training duration: 5,000 optimizer steps.
39
+ - Evaluation latency: fixed at two environment ticks.
40
+ - Evaluation: one final checkpoint per scope, 50 episodes, evaluation seed 42,
41
+ and a 3,600-step episode limit.
42
+ - Metric: episode return.
43
+
44
+ The bars show mean return. Error bars are episode-level normal-approximation
45
+ 95% confidence intervals,
46
+ `1.96 * std_return / sqrt(50)`. They measure variation across evaluation
47
+ episodes from one checkpoint, not variation across independent training
48
+ seeds.
49
+
50
+
51
+ ## Assets
52
+
53
+ `manifest.json` records the seven retained scope runs. Only the three final sources in the paper CSV form the plotted comparison. Shared Flappy L2 data remain in `latency-aware/flappy/flappy_200ep/flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep`.
experiments/vla-finetuning-scope/flappy/manifest.json ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,443 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ {
2
+ "experiment": "vla-finetuning-scope",
3
+ "task": "flappy",
4
+ "runs": [
5
+ {
6
+ "run": "flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep_full_tuning_corrected_bs32_4k_steps",
7
+ "source": {
8
+ "repo": "latency-sensitive-bench/vla-finetuning-scope-models",
9
+ "revision": "1ab96924e691cbe8924ac4671466723bdb5ec3af",
10
+ "path": "flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep_full_tuning_corrected_bs32_4k_steps"
11
+ },
12
+ "metadata": {
13
+ "repo": "latency-sensitive-bench/benchmark-models",
14
+ "revision": "f99bd515da2a2a364198848b7f3c2dcaaf9566dd",
15
+ "path": "latency-aware/flappy/vla/starvla-qwenoft-h1/flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep_full_tuning_corrected_bs32_4k_steps"
16
+ },
17
+ "checkpoints": [
18
+ {
19
+ "repo": "latency-sensitive-bench/benchmark-models",
20
+ "revision": "f99bd515da2a2a364198848b7f3c2dcaaf9566dd",
21
+ "path": "latency-aware/flappy/vla/starvla-qwenoft-h1/flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep_full_tuning_corrected_bs32_4k_steps/checkpoints/steps_4000_model.safetensors"
22
+ }
23
+ ],
24
+ "source_bindings": [
25
+ {
26
+ "run": "flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep_full_tuning_corrected_bs32_4k_steps",
27
+ "module": "vla-finetuning-scope",
28
+ "train_latency_raw_frames": 2,
29
+ "training_step": 4000,
30
+ "training_started_at_utc": "2026-06-24T11:59:06.297366Z",
31
+ "git_commit": "7b77b87cb564e33377cc2a4f17fc513677849877",
32
+ "wandb_run_id": "w9uahhsz",
33
+ "checkpoint": "flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep_full_tuning_corrected_bs32_4k_steps/checkpoints/steps_4000_model.safetensors",
34
+ "checkpoint_identity": "074a513f33ae5b81499478f5b7cd258757d271ce29077b30e299b49f5ba81bdb",
35
+ "source_path": "flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep_full_tuning_corrected_bs32_4k_steps/checkpoints/steps_4000_state/model.safetensors",
36
+ "source_model_revision": "946358fcf7850d259d33e1b822b80cf5aed15577",
37
+ "freeze_config": {
38
+ "freeze_modules": "",
39
+ "freeze_vit": false,
40
+ "freeze_tied_embedding": false,
41
+ "freeze_llm_layers": []
42
+ },
43
+ "dataset": {
44
+ "repo": "latency-sensitive-bench/benchmark-datasets",
45
+ "revision": "e0f4007f504978f93c32557ea4e9b97fdf62fcf5",
46
+ "path": "latency-aware/flappy/flappy_200ep/flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep",
47
+ "source_repo": "latency-sensitive-bench/flappy_200ep",
48
+ "source_revision": "5df5688a961dc2c91090155c719bff4a5b248235",
49
+ "train_rows": 330734,
50
+ "train_episodes": 180,
51
+ "original_source": {
52
+ "repo": "latency-sensitive-bench/flappy_200ep",
53
+ "revision": "5df5688a961dc2c91090155c719bff4a5b248235",
54
+ "path": "flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep"
55
+ }
56
+ },
57
+ "paper_consumers": []
58
+ }
59
+ ],
60
+ "evaluation": {
61
+ "repo": "latency-sensitive-bench/benchmark-datasets",
62
+ "revision": "58157c572dbd2e0e5036ce197c42db975e56ae4e",
63
+ "path": "evaluations/flappy/flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep_full_tuning_corrected_bs32_4k_steps"
64
+ }
65
+ },
66
+ {
67
+ "run": "flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep_full_tuning_corrected_bs32_3k_steps",
68
+ "source": {
69
+ "repo": "latency-sensitive-bench/vla-finetuning-scope-models",
70
+ "revision": "1ab96924e691cbe8924ac4671466723bdb5ec3af",
71
+ "path": "flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep_full_tuning_corrected_bs32_3k_steps"
72
+ },
73
+ "metadata": {
74
+ "repo": "latency-sensitive-bench/benchmark-models",
75
+ "revision": "f99bd515da2a2a364198848b7f3c2dcaaf9566dd",
76
+ "path": "latency-aware/flappy/vla/starvla-qwenoft-h1/flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep_full_tuning_corrected_bs32_3k_steps"
77
+ },
78
+ "checkpoints": [
79
+ {
80
+ "repo": "latency-sensitive-bench/benchmark-models",
81
+ "revision": "f99bd515da2a2a364198848b7f3c2dcaaf9566dd",
82
+ "path": "latency-aware/flappy/vla/starvla-qwenoft-h1/flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep_full_tuning_corrected_bs32_3k_steps/checkpoints/steps_3000_model.safetensors"
83
+ }
84
+ ],
85
+ "source_bindings": [
86
+ {
87
+ "run": "flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep_full_tuning_corrected_bs32_3k_steps",
88
+ "module": "vla-finetuning-scope",
89
+ "train_latency_raw_frames": 2,
90
+ "training_step": 3000,
91
+ "training_started_at_utc": "2026-06-24T09:52:32.813741Z",
92
+ "git_commit": "68f11e4545a2ad73d3783fd50c14ab886749d0fd",
93
+ "wandb_run_id": "pllmo179",
94
+ "checkpoint": "flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep_full_tuning_corrected_bs32_3k_steps/checkpoints/steps_3000_model.safetensors",
95
+ "checkpoint_identity": "dee60fc99cf35e2e6d5908129093c8c66c2cafb62d3b87a236d45acd86522d59",
96
+ "source_path": "flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep_full_tuning_corrected_bs32_3k_steps/checkpoints/steps_3000_state/model.safetensors",
97
+ "source_model_revision": "946358fcf7850d259d33e1b822b80cf5aed15577",
98
+ "freeze_config": {
99
+ "freeze_modules": "",
100
+ "freeze_vit": false,
101
+ "freeze_tied_embedding": false,
102
+ "freeze_llm_layers": []
103
+ },
104
+ "dataset": {
105
+ "repo": "latency-sensitive-bench/benchmark-datasets",
106
+ "revision": "e0f4007f504978f93c32557ea4e9b97fdf62fcf5",
107
+ "path": "latency-aware/flappy/flappy_200ep/flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep",
108
+ "source_repo": "latency-sensitive-bench/flappy_200ep",
109
+ "source_revision": "5df5688a961dc2c91090155c719bff4a5b248235",
110
+ "train_rows": 330734,
111
+ "train_episodes": 180,
112
+ "original_source": {
113
+ "repo": "latency-sensitive-bench/flappy_200ep",
114
+ "revision": "5df5688a961dc2c91090155c719bff4a5b248235",
115
+ "path": "flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep"
116
+ }
117
+ },
118
+ "paper_consumers": []
119
+ }
120
+ ],
121
+ "evaluation": {
122
+ "repo": "latency-sensitive-bench/benchmark-datasets",
123
+ "revision": "58157c572dbd2e0e5036ce197c42db975e56ae4e",
124
+ "path": "evaluations/flappy/flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep_full_tuning_corrected_bs32_3k_steps"
125
+ }
126
+ },
127
+ {
128
+ "run": "flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep_last_8_layers_corrected_v2",
129
+ "source": {
130
+ "repo": "latency-sensitive-bench/vla-finetuning-scope-models",
131
+ "revision": "1ab96924e691cbe8924ac4671466723bdb5ec3af",
132
+ "path": "flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep_last_8_layers_corrected_v2"
133
+ },
134
+ "metadata": {
135
+ "repo": "latency-sensitive-bench/benchmark-models",
136
+ "revision": "f99bd515da2a2a364198848b7f3c2dcaaf9566dd",
137
+ "path": "latency-aware/flappy/vla/starvla-qwenoft-h1/flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep_last_8_layers_corrected_v2"
138
+ },
139
+ "checkpoints": [
140
+ {
141
+ "repo": "latency-sensitive-bench/benchmark-models",
142
+ "revision": "f99bd515da2a2a364198848b7f3c2dcaaf9566dd",
143
+ "path": "latency-aware/flappy/vla/starvla-qwenoft-h1/flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep_last_8_layers_corrected_v2/checkpoints/steps_5000_model.safetensors"
144
+ }
145
+ ],
146
+ "source_bindings": [
147
+ {
148
+ "run": "flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep_last_8_layers_corrected_v2",
149
+ "module": "vla-finetuning-scope",
150
+ "train_latency_raw_frames": 2,
151
+ "training_step": 5000,
152
+ "training_started_at_utc": "2026-06-23T16:43:48.375941Z",
153
+ "git_commit": "fcb51e2694288bdcf8dc8f558e9973cdaaafb944",
154
+ "wandb_run_id": "z0dfovtb",
155
+ "checkpoint": "flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep_last_8_layers_corrected_v2/checkpoints/steps_5000_model.safetensors",
156
+ "checkpoint_identity": "b2375e35dca20389af04508aba967acffda126a63d3daa8344629d271bdcac3d",
157
+ "source_path": "flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep_last_8_layers_corrected_v2/checkpoints/steps_5000_state/model.safetensors",
158
+ "source_model_revision": "946358fcf7850d259d33e1b822b80cf5aed15577",
159
+ "freeze_config": {
160
+ "freeze_modules": "",
161
+ "freeze_vit": true,
162
+ "freeze_tied_embedding": true,
163
+ "freeze_llm_layers": [
164
+ 0,
165
+ 27
166
+ ]
167
+ },
168
+ "dataset": {
169
+ "repo": "latency-sensitive-bench/benchmark-datasets",
170
+ "revision": "e0f4007f504978f93c32557ea4e9b97fdf62fcf5",
171
+ "path": "latency-aware/flappy/flappy_200ep/flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep",
172
+ "source_repo": "latency-sensitive-bench/flappy_200ep",
173
+ "source_revision": "5df5688a961dc2c91090155c719bff4a5b248235",
174
+ "train_rows": 330734,
175
+ "train_episodes": 180,
176
+ "original_source": {
177
+ "repo": "latency-sensitive-bench/flappy_200ep",
178
+ "revision": "5df5688a961dc2c91090155c719bff4a5b248235",
179
+ "path": "flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep"
180
+ }
181
+ },
182
+ "paper_consumers": [
183
+ "exps/vla_finetuning_scope"
184
+ ]
185
+ }
186
+ ],
187
+ "evaluation": {
188
+ "repo": "latency-sensitive-bench/benchmark-datasets",
189
+ "revision": "58157c572dbd2e0e5036ce197c42db975e56ae4e",
190
+ "path": "evaluations/flappy/flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep_last_8_layers_corrected_v2"
191
+ }
192
+ },
193
+ {
194
+ "run": "flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep_last_8_layers_corrected",
195
+ "source": {
196
+ "repo": "latency-sensitive-bench/vla-finetuning-scope-models",
197
+ "revision": "1ab96924e691cbe8924ac4671466723bdb5ec3af",
198
+ "path": "flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep_last_8_layers_corrected"
199
+ },
200
+ "metadata": {
201
+ "repo": "latency-sensitive-bench/benchmark-models",
202
+ "revision": "f99bd515da2a2a364198848b7f3c2dcaaf9566dd",
203
+ "path": "latency-aware/flappy/vla/starvla-qwenoft-h1/flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep_last_8_layers_corrected"
204
+ },
205
+ "checkpoints": [
206
+ {
207
+ "repo": "latency-sensitive-bench/benchmark-models",
208
+ "revision": "f99bd515da2a2a364198848b7f3c2dcaaf9566dd",
209
+ "path": "latency-aware/flappy/vla/starvla-qwenoft-h1/flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep_last_8_layers_corrected/checkpoints/steps_5000_model.safetensors"
210
+ }
211
+ ],
212
+ "source_bindings": [
213
+ {
214
+ "run": "flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep_last_8_layers_corrected",
215
+ "module": "vla-finetuning-scope",
216
+ "train_latency_raw_frames": 2,
217
+ "training_step": 5000,
218
+ "training_started_at_utc": "2026-06-23T10:13:20.354969Z",
219
+ "git_commit": "b6f4f971098c0bc5e340ef616b823a4ca769c7e4",
220
+ "wandb_run_id": "fomfbmpo",
221
+ "checkpoint": "flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep_last_8_layers_corrected/checkpoints/steps_5000_model.safetensors",
222
+ "checkpoint_identity": "750786e2eac8b455ab6e8232416d692e8ad1d5b7a56d386b40bf53a9462ba436",
223
+ "source_path": "flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep_last_8_layers_corrected/checkpoints/steps_5000_state/model.safetensors",
224
+ "source_model_revision": "946358fcf7850d259d33e1b822b80cf5aed15577",
225
+ "freeze_config": {
226
+ "freeze_modules": "",
227
+ "freeze_llm_bottom_ratio": 0.7778
228
+ },
229
+ "dataset": {
230
+ "repo": "latency-sensitive-bench/benchmark-datasets",
231
+ "revision": "e0f4007f504978f93c32557ea4e9b97fdf62fcf5",
232
+ "path": "latency-aware/flappy/flappy_200ep/flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep",
233
+ "source_repo": "latency-sensitive-bench/flappy_200ep",
234
+ "source_revision": "5df5688a961dc2c91090155c719bff4a5b248235",
235
+ "train_rows": 330734,
236
+ "train_episodes": 180,
237
+ "original_source": {
238
+ "repo": "latency-sensitive-bench/flappy_200ep",
239
+ "revision": "5df5688a961dc2c91090155c719bff4a5b248235",
240
+ "path": "flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep"
241
+ }
242
+ },
243
+ "paper_consumers": [
244
+ "exps/vla_finetuning_scope"
245
+ ]
246
+ }
247
+ ],
248
+ "evaluation": {
249
+ "repo": "latency-sensitive-bench/benchmark-datasets",
250
+ "revision": "58157c572dbd2e0e5036ce197c42db975e56ae4e",
251
+ "path": "evaluations/flappy/flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep_last_8_layers_corrected"
252
+ }
253
+ },
254
+ {
255
+ "run": "flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep_full_tuning_corrected",
256
+ "source": {
257
+ "repo": "latency-sensitive-bench/vla-finetuning-scope-models",
258
+ "revision": "1ab96924e691cbe8924ac4671466723bdb5ec3af",
259
+ "path": "flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep_full_tuning_corrected"
260
+ },
261
+ "metadata": {
262
+ "repo": "latency-sensitive-bench/benchmark-models",
263
+ "revision": "f99bd515da2a2a364198848b7f3c2dcaaf9566dd",
264
+ "path": "latency-aware/flappy/vla/starvla-qwenoft-h1/flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep_full_tuning_corrected"
265
+ },
266
+ "checkpoints": [
267
+ {
268
+ "repo": "latency-sensitive-bench/benchmark-models",
269
+ "revision": "f99bd515da2a2a364198848b7f3c2dcaaf9566dd",
270
+ "path": "latency-aware/flappy/vla/starvla-qwenoft-h1/flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep_full_tuning_corrected/checkpoints/steps_5000_model.safetensors"
271
+ }
272
+ ],
273
+ "source_bindings": [
274
+ {
275
+ "run": "flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep_full_tuning_corrected",
276
+ "module": "vla-finetuning-scope",
277
+ "train_latency_raw_frames": 2,
278
+ "training_step": 5000,
279
+ "training_started_at_utc": "2026-06-23T20:08:09.389236Z",
280
+ "git_commit": "b6f4f971098c0bc5e340ef616b823a4ca769c7e4",
281
+ "wandb_run_id": "jd1xm599",
282
+ "checkpoint": "flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep_full_tuning_corrected/checkpoints/steps_5000_model.safetensors",
283
+ "checkpoint_identity": "ff343b81e73667493a90c8c0696872ab7f3ed1bf55fae59cf8b57f9785b040eb",
284
+ "source_path": "flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep_full_tuning_corrected/checkpoints/steps_5000_state/model.safetensors",
285
+ "source_model_revision": "946358fcf7850d259d33e1b822b80cf5aed15577",
286
+ "freeze_config": {
287
+ "freeze_modules": "",
288
+ "freeze_llm_bottom_ratio": 0.0
289
+ },
290
+ "dataset": {
291
+ "repo": "latency-sensitive-bench/benchmark-datasets",
292
+ "revision": "e0f4007f504978f93c32557ea4e9b97fdf62fcf5",
293
+ "path": "latency-aware/flappy/flappy_200ep/flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep",
294
+ "source_repo": "latency-sensitive-bench/flappy_200ep",
295
+ "source_revision": "5df5688a961dc2c91090155c719bff4a5b248235",
296
+ "train_rows": 330734,
297
+ "train_episodes": 180,
298
+ "original_source": {
299
+ "repo": "latency-sensitive-bench/flappy_200ep",
300
+ "revision": "5df5688a961dc2c91090155c719bff4a5b248235",
301
+ "path": "flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep"
302
+ }
303
+ },
304
+ "paper_consumers": [
305
+ "exps/vla_finetuning_scope"
306
+ ]
307
+ }
308
+ ],
309
+ "evaluation": {
310
+ "repo": "latency-sensitive-bench/benchmark-datasets",
311
+ "revision": "58157c572dbd2e0e5036ce197c42db975e56ae4e",
312
+ "path": "evaluations/flappy/flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep_full_tuning_corrected"
313
+ }
314
+ },
315
+ {
316
+ "run": "flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep_last_8_layers",
317
+ "source": {
318
+ "repo": "latency-sensitive-bench/vla-finetuning-scope-models",
319
+ "revision": "1ab96924e691cbe8924ac4671466723bdb5ec3af",
320
+ "path": "flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep_last_8_layers"
321
+ },
322
+ "metadata": {
323
+ "repo": "latency-sensitive-bench/benchmark-models",
324
+ "revision": "f99bd515da2a2a364198848b7f3c2dcaaf9566dd",
325
+ "path": "latency-aware/flappy/vla/starvla-qwenoft-h1/flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep_last_8_layers"
326
+ },
327
+ "checkpoints": [
328
+ {
329
+ "repo": "latency-sensitive-bench/benchmark-models",
330
+ "revision": "f99bd515da2a2a364198848b7f3c2dcaaf9566dd",
331
+ "path": "latency-aware/flappy/vla/starvla-qwenoft-h1/flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep_last_8_layers/checkpoints/steps_5000_model.safetensors"
332
+ }
333
+ ],
334
+ "source_bindings": [
335
+ {
336
+ "run": "flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep_last_8_layers",
337
+ "module": "vla-finetuning-scope",
338
+ "train_latency_raw_frames": 2,
339
+ "training_step": 5000,
340
+ "training_started_at_utc": "2026-06-23T03:14:55.765555Z",
341
+ "git_commit": "daeb076ebed09fb21a1a1b3ce6ab124c64018212",
342
+ "wandb_run_id": "kbm7xajn",
343
+ "checkpoint": "flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep_last_8_layers/checkpoints/steps_5000_model.safetensors",
344
+ "checkpoint_identity": "8afaa32fca8bd02a62fd251a0457e809370c64803c90166b0962241a2089519a",
345
+ "source_path": "flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep_last_8_layers/checkpoints/steps_5000_state/model.safetensors",
346
+ "source_model_revision": "946358fcf7850d259d33e1b822b80cf5aed15577",
347
+ "freeze_config": {
348
+ "freeze_modules": "",
349
+ "freeze_llm_bottom_ratio": 0.7778
350
+ },
351
+ "dataset": {
352
+ "repo": "latency-sensitive-bench/benchmark-datasets",
353
+ "revision": "e0f4007f504978f93c32557ea4e9b97fdf62fcf5",
354
+ "path": "latency-aware/flappy/flappy_200ep/flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep",
355
+ "source_repo": "latency-sensitive-bench/flappy_200ep",
356
+ "source_revision": "5df5688a961dc2c91090155c719bff4a5b248235",
357
+ "train_rows": 330734,
358
+ "train_episodes": 180,
359
+ "original_source": {
360
+ "repo": "latency-sensitive-bench/flappy_200ep",
361
+ "revision": "5df5688a961dc2c91090155c719bff4a5b248235",
362
+ "path": "flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep"
363
+ }
364
+ },
365
+ "paper_consumers": [
366
+ "legacy/vla_hyper"
367
+ ]
368
+ }
369
+ ],
370
+ "evaluation": {
371
+ "repo": "latency-sensitive-bench/benchmark-datasets",
372
+ "revision": "58157c572dbd2e0e5036ce197c42db975e56ae4e",
373
+ "path": "evaluations/flappy/flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep_last_8_layers"
374
+ }
375
+ },
376
+ {
377
+ "run": "flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep_full_tuning",
378
+ "source": {
379
+ "repo": "latency-sensitive-bench/vla-finetuning-scope-models",
380
+ "revision": "1ab96924e691cbe8924ac4671466723bdb5ec3af",
381
+ "path": "flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep_full_tuning"
382
+ },
383
+ "metadata": {
384
+ "repo": "latency-sensitive-bench/benchmark-models",
385
+ "revision": "f99bd515da2a2a364198848b7f3c2dcaaf9566dd",
386
+ "path": "latency-aware/flappy/vla/starvla-qwenoft-h1/flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep_full_tuning"
387
+ },
388
+ "checkpoints": [
389
+ {
390
+ "repo": "latency-sensitive-bench/benchmark-models",
391
+ "revision": "f99bd515da2a2a364198848b7f3c2dcaaf9566dd",
392
+ "path": "latency-aware/flappy/vla/starvla-qwenoft-h1/flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep_full_tuning/checkpoints/steps_5000_model.safetensors"
393
+ }
394
+ ],
395
+ "source_bindings": [
396
+ {
397
+ "run": "flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep_full_tuning",
398
+ "module": "vla-finetuning-scope",
399
+ "train_latency_raw_frames": 2,
400
+ "training_step": 5000,
401
+ "training_started_at_utc": "2026-06-23T16:41:09.236188Z",
402
+ "git_commit": "daeb076ebed09fb21a1a1b3ce6ab124c64018212",
403
+ "wandb_run_id": "hfsfeb3f",
404
+ "checkpoint": "flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep_full_tuning/checkpoints/steps_5000_model.safetensors",
405
+ "checkpoint_identity": "2ad30759d93084b8a8c6e03129e3239fac9a644b4c17c638deb76d82aa8610d5",
406
+ "source_path": "flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep_full_tuning/checkpoints/steps_5000_state/model.safetensors",
407
+ "source_model_revision": "946358fcf7850d259d33e1b822b80cf5aed15577",
408
+ "freeze_config": {
409
+ "freeze_modules": "",
410
+ "freeze_llm_bottom_ratio": 0.0
411
+ },
412
+ "dataset": {
413
+ "repo": "latency-sensitive-bench/benchmark-datasets",
414
+ "revision": "e0f4007f504978f93c32557ea4e9b97fdf62fcf5",
415
+ "path": "latency-aware/flappy/flappy_200ep/flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep",
416
+ "source_repo": "latency-sensitive-bench/flappy_200ep",
417
+ "source_revision": "5df5688a961dc2c91090155c719bff4a5b248235",
418
+ "train_rows": 330734,
419
+ "train_episodes": 180,
420
+ "original_source": {
421
+ "repo": "latency-sensitive-bench/flappy_200ep",
422
+ "revision": "5df5688a961dc2c91090155c719bff4a5b248235",
423
+ "path": "flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep"
424
+ }
425
+ },
426
+ "paper_consumers": [
427
+ "legacy/vla_hyper"
428
+ ]
429
+ }
430
+ ],
431
+ "evaluation": {
432
+ "repo": "latency-sensitive-bench/benchmark-datasets",
433
+ "revision": "58157c572dbd2e0e5036ce197c42db975e56ae4e",
434
+ "path": "evaluations/flappy/flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep_full_tuning"
435
+ }
436
+ }
437
+ ],
438
+ "shared_training_data": {
439
+ "repo": "latency-sensitive-bench/benchmark-datasets",
440
+ "revision": "58157c572dbd2e0e5036ce197c42db975e56ae4e",
441
+ "path": "latency-aware/flappy/flappy_200ep/flappy_fix_latency_2_200ep"
442
+ }
443
+ }