Iyeumiru-R-Rayo-RSI / docs /REVIEW_GUIDE.md
PureOne's picture
Upload Iyeumiru-R research dataset release
cbb30a8 verified
|
Raw History Blame Contribute Delete
1.69 kB

Scientific review guide

Read the PDF for the argument and the LaTeX source for exact mathematics. This guide points to existing manuscript sections; it adds no scientific results.

Review question Entry point
What does the Rayo connection actually supply? Sections 1–2
Does the old grammar include the incumbent's real capabilities, sharing, and installed modules? Section 3; operational adequacy condition
Does an extension preserve the same meaning and contract? Section 4
Are a valid old lower bound and a complete new upper bound compared? Section 5; productive boundary escape theorem
Are actual work and allocated budgets distinguished? Section 6
Which assumptions permit repeated savings, and which remain unproved? Section 7
What is the proposed bounded implementation loop? Section 8
What is preserved through architectural change? Section 9
Which baselines and causal ablations distinguish the proposal from prior approaches? Section 10
What finite optimization model, counterexamples, ledger, and dependencies are supplied? Appendices A–E

The key open question is whether class-wide obstruction certificates and useful extensions can be discovered cheaply enough, and transferred widely enough, to repay their complete cost in later improvement episodes.

The proposed multi-generation evaluation is a future protocol. No executed experiments, benchmark scores, autonomous system, or mechanized certificate artifacts accompany this release. JSONL records preserve supplied arguments and stated status; their successful parsing or reconstruction does not establish mathematical correctness.