instruction
stringlengths
31
24.5k
There seems to be a great disparity when it comes to the definition of Consciousness in the western and eastern schools. Now, in India, according to Advaita Vedanta(non-dualistic school of philosophy which says everyone is one and the same not in terms of body, mind and all, but in terms of who we are), we use the ter...
Since every living being has a metabolism, we all live in non-equilibrium state. We keep on exchanging molecules and atoms with our environment. I assume that our brain is affected by this as well as the rest of our body. So while my atoms keep on changing while I'm writing this, why am I still the same person, or be...
After reading The Groundwork of the Metaphysics of Morals, I'm still unsure why human beings have a duty to obey the Categorical Imperative. I understand Kant's argument why a rational will necessarily obeys it, but I do not see how it carries the force of an "ought", and thus why beings not bound by perfect rationalit...
In Abrahamic religions, God is often believed to be wholly omnipotent. People also seem to believe that humans have "free will", especially insofar that they feel they are in control of their own actions. Regardless of whether these beliefs are true or not, are these claims contradictory with one another? It seems the...
Roughly, Gödel demonstrated that in a logical system, that contains a model or arithmetic, there are statements which may be true, but are unprovable within the system. If a statement is not provable an inconsistency or self-contradiction may or will develop that invalidates the system. Arrival at this point then demo...
Does a kid, which learns the meaning of the term "distance" (or any other expressions which might be thought of as physical quantities) automatically also develope a concept of numbers? If I know that my desk is longer than my pen, does that imply I know that the one can be thought of as being multiple times as long a...
Consider the following definition of set given by Cantor in a letter to Dedekind: If on the other hand the totality of the elements of a multiplicity can be thought of without contradiction as 'being together', so that they can be gathered together into 'one thing' I call it a consistent multiplicity or a 'set'. ("Let...
Intuitionistic logic is the same as the usual boolean one apart from excluding the excluded middle, that is not(p) or p is not neccessarily true, so that boolean logic is a specialisation of the intuitionistic one. I take it evident that some parts of everyday reasoning uses classical boolean logic. Are there any every...
In Nyaya-Vaisesika atomic theory atoms are both considered to be both without magnitude and round. How is this possible? For anything to be round, it must have at least a non-zero radius which contradicts its extensionless. Is my conflation of extensionless with without magnitude the problem?
What is the post-structuralist approach to natural sciences, especially physics? Maybe post stucturalism is a bit too scattered to ask for a specific clear position, but what are the common ideas of the people associated with this line of thought? The question is mainly motivated by me wondering about the role of obj...
In 1804, poet Robert Southey said of Coleridge: His mind is in a perpetual St. Vitus dance—eternal activity without action. In The Inconvenience of Being Born, the Romanian philosopher Emil Cioran mistakenly reported these words as said by Wordsworth, and added: It seems to me that everything one does is pernicio...
I'm asking as a relative novice, but have come across the debate in the field of information architecture and classification (and technology studies too). In this field, Aristotle is often quoted as believing in an overarching, objective classification of knowledge and is set against Foucault who (in my understanding) ...
I really liked GEB a few years ago, and have been following up with "I am a Strange Loop" recently. In the book, Douglas Hofstadter tries to better explain his concept of symbols and in particular the strangely loopy symbol of "I" or self. In the earlier parts of the book (with his careenium analogy), he describes sym...
Can someone please advise as to the meaning of the symbol here? Please note that this is a symbol utilized in logic or possible calculations utilizing triangles (though still logical). Its not the euro...
Historically, many civilizations have contained in their culture, in one way or another, the concept of the "axis mundi" or world axis. Examples of this include Yggdrasil from Norse culture and Mount Meru in Hinduism, of which Angkor Wat is a representation. In fact, a brief perusal of the linked wikipedia entry on the...
I want to learn logic better, I know a few fallacies but I've read no books mostly just stuff on the Internet. I see them everywhere, but sometimes I don't know what the fallacy is called. I am a pretty decent logician, but I want to learn the terminology well. Where do I start? What books do you recommend?
“To be born to create, to love, to win at games is to be born to live in time of peace. But war teaches us to lose everything and become what we were not. it all becomes a question of style.” — Albert Camus, Notebooks, 1935–1942 Can someone explain the above quote from Albert Camus? Especially the last part abo...
Some are pointing out that democracy with equal vote is not optimal and they propose that people should have variable numbers of votes based on their education, usefulness or other social factors. What is the name of this idea? What other variants does it have?
In most systems of government one has various "duties and discretions" in relation to the state he was born to even though he did not signed any agreement with the state - nor was he asked whether he agrees or not. On the other hand there are hypothesised systems of government (example: Starship Troopers) where one has...
My question motivated by a part of this page from Saul Kripke's book Naming and Necessity, which is also viewable on google books. In the middle of the page he say something, which seems unnatural to me: Namely he implies that one mathematical theorem can be proved in two different formal systems. Later, in a slightly ...
Cody Gray recently asked "Why should philosophers feel any different about the existence of emotions than they do about the color of the sky?" as a rhetoric question. But both physics and psychology were once subject matters of philosophy, so there was a time when philosophy actually cared about these questions. But to...
I am a student of econometrics and I'm studying the philosophy of economics. This week I have exams, and I was reviewing last year's exam to practice. I ran into this question: One of the arguments for a 'flat tax' system instead of the current Dutch progressive system is that such a tax contributes to the welfare of ...
In §85 of Ideas I, Husserl classifies all mental processes into intentional and non-intentional mental processes. The class of non-intentional mental processes contains all sensuous mental processes. Among the former [class of non-intentional mental processes] belong certain "sensuous" mental processes which are unita...
In software development, there is an activity called domain modeling, by which the developer creates a representation of the problem domain using some language (ultimately a programming language). When modeling a particular domain, developers have to make some "metaphysical decisions", so to speak*. In particular, one ...
In an answer here, the following was stated: The essence of his [Descartes] argument is that you can doubt almost everything about the world, but you can't doubt that you're doubting. Because if you doubt that you're doubting, you're still doubting... What is the analogous mathematical/logical expression to the last ...
According to the abstract of this article1, ... Descartes' God acts by a single immutable will for all eternity, and there is no sense in which it is possible for Him to will or to have willed anything other than what He in fact wills. ... The description here offered suggests that God Himself can not change His will...
I am just going to give an example of what I mean using Skolem's Paradox. I DO NOT want to get into Skolem's Paradox itself or its "resolution." Skolem's showed that countability is relative in models of first-order formulations of ZFC (assuming ZFC has a model). For example, take a model of ZFC. Let satisfy the stat...
I just read Atlas Shrugged and was wondering if the kind of moral objectivism suggested in there is even practical in real life. For example, I have an IT assignment to do for high school, and we have been assigned groups. My partners are all incredibly lazy—they do nothing and always have new excuses for why they coul...
Is saying that P is very unlikely, the same as saying that you believe ~P? Does it follow rationally, that if P is very unlikely, one should believe ~P? And would the evidence for P being very unlikely, be the same as the evidence for ~P?
My question is based on the Cave of Plato. In this myth I see two types of learning. The first type of learning is the person that is released from the cave and climbs up to the light. The second type of learning is when the same person is coming back to the cave, and now sits again in the previous locked position and...
This is not a direct quote, but what I can remember of the general idea: Humans have the sense of sight to see things around us, so we would of the presence of some larger being as such. However, plants don't have the sense to detect our presence, so cannot sense our being there. What if we lack a sense that det...
J. S. Mill is well known as an intellectual father of both Utilitarianism and Liberalism, but I was thinking recently about a tension between these lines of thought and wondered if he ever addressed it. The tension is this, Utilitarianism leaves no boundary between ethics and politics. An action is good if it maximizes...
Intuitively, it seems pretty obvious that, for a given proposition p, we know whether or not we know p. I am not sure how to express this more formally (e.g. as a property of the relevant epistemic accessibility relation). I remember that belief, as opposed to knowledge, corresponds to a transitive accessibility relati...
I came across a story about a kid who committed suicide after carefully calculating the benefits of life and deciding it was not worth living. I am wondering if any philosopher has considered the rationality of suicide and wrote in great detail about it. I understand Albert Camus said that, Suicide was the only true ph...
I recently had a discussion with somebody who had read the book "Children of Mother Earth" by the Dutch author Thea Beckman. She claimed that in the book, the idea was proposed to no longer lock up criminals, but mark them in the face instead so that people would recognize their crimes while looking it them. The story ...
Is it possible for Nothing to exist in Something ? e.g. if something is the whole set can nothing be an element of it ? If you take Nothing from something something remains. If nothing cannot exist in something. how can you take nothing from something. In set Theory null set means an empty set a collection of 0 element...
The only porpose of life that I see is to feel good. Some try to achieve it by earning money, some try to achieve it by earning fame and respect, and there are still others who try to achieve it by helping others and doing things which promote humanity. But the motive behind doing anything we do is to ultimately feel g...
Can the "love of wisdom" be turned into something bad? Were there evil philosophers in the past? I was recently reading a book about the dark side of psychology, how people use psychological tricks to manipulate others. Does philosophy have a "dark side"?
In Descartes's Meditations, in order to establish a firm foundation upon which he could build a framework to determine philosophical and material truths, he begins by removing all of his then-current beliefs and examining what could be admitted as indubitable. In effect, he begins by doubting everything, including, und...
I'm reading this book and I'm stuck trying to understand what's the difference between these kinds of perceiving, when I read the example in italic I tend to think they're the same thing, what's wrong? Can someone help me? The last two cases—perceiving that, and perceiving to be—are different from the first—perceiv...
Can anyone explain to me what jouissance mean in Slavoj Zizek's philosophy? I understand Lacan's term, but I am having a hard time understanding Slavoj Zizek's jouissance. More specifically, how does jouissance relate to political power?
I'm a computer science PhD student which does some work in Knowledge Representation, and I have studied a lot of (mathematical) logic. As far as I remember from my high school philosophy classes, Wittgenstein has some prominent works concerning languages/human languages and their effects on philosophy, so I felt like i...
On todays wikipedia front page, in the did you know... section, it says Did you know... ... that Niels Kaas was the chancellor of Denmark during the late 1500s? Now I find this to be somewhat amusing, since I'm fairly sure not too many people know anything about Niels Kaas. This is basically a new name to me. So afte...
We know that we can see distant galaxies only billions years before now. We can observe the nearest stars just several years before the present. Something on the Moon can be observed only some seconds in the past. Continuing this scale, is there an object in the universe that can be observed just now, at present, or at...
I'm about to start graduate studies with an AI philosopher, and I'm hoping he's considered a leading researcher. Apart from trying to gauge his reputation, I'm trying to become familiar with the research landscape. I am acquainted with only classical work - Searle, Dreyfus and so on. These people are very old now, and ...
In §111 of his Philosophical Investigation, Ludwig Wittgenstein writes (my hopefully not-too-inept translation1): Let’s ask ourselves: why do we perceive a grammatical joke as deep? (And that is what philosophical depth is.) I would have guessed that a "grammatical joke" (ein grammatischer Witz) was something like "...
I was reading about Epicureanism on Wikipedia, and there I saw that, apparently, Epicureanism was in conflict with Stoicism and Platonism. I then read up on those two philosophies, and well, they do not seem mutually exclusive at all! They are different, yes, but I don't see why would they be in conflict in any way. Pl...
[CRUCIAL CLARIFICATION: unless I explicitly say otherwise, all references to Wittgenstein, or W, below should be read as "the post-Tractatus Wittgenstein." I am not interested in those who could be described as followers of the author of the Tractatus. In fact, I would actively avoid reading such philosophers, if the...
I guess there are two questions here. QUESTION 1: Skolem's Paradox shows that countability is relative in first-order logic, but where is the relativity? In this first question, I will do the following: (A) I will give an example here of the relativity of countability and then (B) talk about why I don't see the relat...
Philosophers such as Susanne Bobzien have provided work that provides a basis for axiomatising Stoic logic, however, the treatments I have seen focus on exposition of ancient works, with little emphasis on formal tractability, by contrast to the wealth of tractable formulations of Aristotelian syllogistic. What exists ...
What sort of models might be untestable? For instance, the model only concerns events in the past, or the model is too ambiguously specified for the experimenter to know what to measure, or we do not have the technology to make the necessary measurements, or demonstrating the model is false would require an infinitely...
I've just finished reading Twilight of the Idols/The Anti-Christ, and I was struck by his sincere admiration for Christ. He calls him 'the only Christian'. Is it fair then to describe him as a reformer of Christianity in its long tradition of reformers, rather than a destroyer as one may take from his famous 'God is ...
I've just come across the writings of Fritjof Schuon and they appear to be impressive. There is a hint of new-ageism about him, and having never heard of him before I have no idea of his general reputation apart from his wikipedia page. What exactly is his reputation within academic circles?
The obvious problem of illegalization is that it can never be enforced perfectly. Moreover, it addresses only the symptoms and not the reasons underlying a certain behavior. What alternatives are there for a government?
I've been reading a conversation between two individuals - A claiming to be atheist and B asking him to prove it, since B does not believe that A is saying the truth and can't be sure if A is really an atheist as A claims. So I was wondering - is this even a valid argument B has there - to say that B does not believe w...
By actual possibility I mean the possibility which is implied by ability or power. By logical possibility I mean whether concepts of reality contradict each other or not. I believe that knowledge and reason are accurate reflections of the nature of reality. Therefore I am not inclined to believe that something which is...
Alfred North Whitehead said 'The safest general characterization of the European philosophical tradition is that it consists of a series of footnotes to Plato'. I'm not interested (in this question) as to what Whitehead meant by this, but simply that he points towards Plato as the pre-eminent ancient philosopher in the...
Spinoza presented his work in a proposition/theorem format following Euclid, presumably to varnish his work in the seemingly eternal verities of mathematics. Is there any significance as to why Plato presented his work mainly as dialogues? Or does it simply reflect that the pre-eminant artform of the time was the theat...
I said this to a friend once, but told her to keep it quiet as I couldn't back it up as I haven't read any of her works, nor even a solid introduction. I formed my snap judgement on the basis of a synopsis of 'Atlas Shrugged', one of her novels. Is my judgement a fair characterisation or am I making a philosophical fau...
I found the following statement on this Creationist site. If a fair maiden kisses a frog which instantly changes into a handsome prince we would call it a fairy tale. But if the frog takes 40 million years to turn into a prince we call it evolution. Time is the evolutionist's magic wand. Fairy tales come in many f...
I could be wrong, but it sounds like ontology is the study of what things exist. But I wonder what is the name for the study of what changes happen? The study of action, change, motion, etc.
The fragmentary pre-socratic record abounds in aphorisms, Nietszche wrote poetic & prophetic prose, the continental tradition is highly literary - to the point where it is incomprehensible to the uninitiated (I would even suggest Badious use of Set Theory (a rational mode of thinking par-excellance) is being used in a ...
I've read (probably in wikipedia but can't track down the reference now) that the Asharite strand in Islamic theology couldn't accept that substance necessarily exists pre-eternally as the Quoran revealed Allah as the creator of this universe, and if something existed pre-eternally then there is no need for a creator. ...
The three laws are: First law: The velocity of a body remains constant unless the body is acted upon by an external force. Second law: The acceleration a of a body is parallel[disambiguation needed ] and directly proportional to the net force F and inversely proportional to the mass m, i.e., F = ma. Third law: The mutu...
Having only the a very cursory knowledge of Structuralism, there does appear to be some points of coincidence: Structuralism: Individual elements of culture must be placed within a System/Structure. The individual elements of culture must be understood by their inter-relationships within this System, and not by their ...
We have a theory (the standard model) that explains a great deal of the physical phenomena that we perceive. Let us grant Physicists their dream, and say we have a theory that explains all physical phenomena. Surely this theory then allows evolution (which is non-teleological), but the choice of theory has to be put in...
Visual hallucinations present a unique problem for ontology. On the one hand they are clearly not sense data, meaning they are not the phenomenal product of a transduced pattern of photons. On the other their emergence into awareness may create the subjective sense that this is the case. Hallucinations therefore are su...
Why do we (including other living organisms) reproduce? Why is it necessary that our race keeps flourishing and multiplying? I couldn't find any useful articles on google except for some yahoo and wiki answers which I don't like much. I would like if someone could suggest me some books or redirect me to some useful art...
Language, even when taking into Chomsky's hypothesis of the biological ground of 'Deep Grammar', is primarily public: The English language is not built into our minds, it is 'out there'. I come into the world, find language and the use of language and 'learn' this. But is language an extension of the mind? Isn't it bet...
I come into the world where other beings are using language. I learn this. Those beings have come into the world where other beings are using language. They learn it. Those other beings come into the world, etc. This is not an infinite regress, as we go down the chain of being, we come down to plants and they commonly...
That is, if good is done, then evil will be done in proportion to rebalance the moral universe; like wise for evil. I should be clear, that I'm not advocating this as a moral philosophy, or the seed of one; but am simply looking for reference to someone who has.
In ethics, autonomy is the right of an individual to make an un-coerced decision. While studying this, I often find myself thinking of free will. If free will does not exist, how would this affect the practice of medical ethics in situations that currently involve the consideration of autonomy?
Frantz Fanon, also known as Ibrahim Frantz Fanon wrote in his book, The Wretched of the Earth: Not long ago Nazism transformed the whole of Europe into a veritable colony meaning that the techniques pioneered in the colonies of Europe were turned upon Europe itself, culminating in the horrors of the holocaust, mirror...
The famous Cogito ergo sum opens with "I" can think, therefore "I" am. How does "I" establish "I" before "I" can "think"? in other words how did "I" establish "I" before it could think in the first place I believe that this was due to bad articulation even though the quote is still valid, it seems that Cogito ergo sum ...
To begin with, consider Chomsky famous construction: "Colorless green ideas sleep furiously". All the words respect a grammatical construction. But "colorless green" seems like a contradiction. If someone says "beautify the beauty" or "value the value"(the first term as verb, the second as a noun, in the sense of "maki...
Presently reading Pierre Klossowski's Nietzsche and the Vicious Circle, and help in clarifying the following would be greatly appreciated The translator's introduction notes (4) Phantasme (‘phantasm’) and simulacrum (‘simulacrum’) are perhaps the most important terms in Klossowski’s vocabulary. The former comes ...
According to Wittgenstein, language is an essentially public activity between minds; and language is structured by a grammar so that this communication can indeed occur. I think, the notion of language is equivalent to grammar (a structuring); as grammar stipulates the range and form of the expression of the language....
I'm having a hard time to find good learning material for the structuralist school of thought. I try to understand what it is "all" about and how it relates to other schools of thought and scientific terms (i.e.: postmodernism, poststructuralism, …). What I've found (on the web) so far is not very much. I found the Int...
One of the things that seems the most bizarre about philosophy as discipline is its horrible record at producing an income. As people deeply knowledgable and interested in the big problems surrounding ethics, how humans ought to behave, and the meaning of life and the universe, you would think there would be a monetary...
Given that there are many many aspects of our understandings that can seem unexplainable in our limited extent of knowledge, is it possible that trees can communicate on some sort of level that we may not understand yet? Many other creatures have strange ways of communicating. Is it possible/probable that trees can als...
Given that an extensional definition is one that defines the definienda by enumerating (partially or exhaustively) examples that belong to it (i.e. the list defines the concept), and intensional is a definition if it focuses on the principles behind the definienda, i.e. necessary and sufficient conditions, and therefir...
I found the following story on this site An atheist professor of philosophy speaks to his class on the problem science has with God, The Almighty. He asks one of his new students to stand and..... Prof: So you believe in God? Student: Absolutely, sir. Prof : Is God good? Student: Sure. Prof: Is God all-powerful? Stu...
I was wondering why the definition of life has always been so abstract and so I was thinking It's because there is so many things that are considered to be alive. (Although not much is sentient) Example: Humans are alive and a virus is alive and germs are alive and so on. And in the future there will be living machines...
I am a mathematician by training. Category theory has become a major subfield of mathematics --- major enough that some have tried to recast the logical foundations of mathematics in terms of categories. A category consists of a collection of objects, and then for each pair of objects, a set of morphisms between the ...
The higgs mechanism is a mechanism by which gives gauge bosons their mass, by absorbing the goldstone bosons appearing in the goldstone theorem. I found this mechanism very mathematically beautiful, but what philosophical implications can you draw from this mechanism, as this mechanism seems a very deep physical princi...
Can anyone explain what an "objective" statement or argument really is? How can we decide that one statement is more objective than another?
There are two arithmetics of infinity, ordinal & cardinal. I'm going to focus on the cardinal arithmetic as it requires less structure, that is they need less (i.e., ordinals require the idea of ordering whereas cardinals do not). Cardinal arithmatic recognises that counting can be characterised in two ways, by using n...
A recent Hugo Schwyzer article laid out the following explanation of "Strong Objectivity": We can never adopt a true “view from nowhere.” We can defy gravity in outer space, but we can never slip the surly bonds of our human imperfection. Our experiences impact us each day of our lives, and our experiences are shaped ...
Aristotle's Posterior Analytics is the basis of the modern scientific method of arguing from effects to the causes of things ("demonstration quia" or "a posteriori"). The ideal [of a unified science with a "progressive Aristotelianism" philosophy] is that perhaps best set by Thomas Aquinas and his teacher Albertus...
Is the "New Essentialism" simply a return to Aristotelianism masked in new terminology, or is it a novel contribution to modern philosophy? See: Brian Ellis's Philosophy of Nature: A Guide to the New Essentialism David S. Oderberg's Real Essentialism Thanks in advance for any insight on this question
They seem very similar to me, but I judge that they were given two distinct Wikipedia pages for a reason. Is the difference that a "first principle" is a predicated statement while a "primitive notion" can only serve as the subject of such a statement? The Wikipedia page for primitive notion states that a primitive n...
Generally philosophical traditions seem to be associated with literate cultures. But a philosopher is someone who has a philosophical problem and so not necessarily tied to literacy. Obviously literacy allows discussion over time & space, expands ways of thinking and allows a documentary record. Is there any indicatio...
Hume shows that experience, when looked at rigorously, gives us no information about cause & effect. At most he permits only that two events are simultaneous. Is this reflected in our best scientific theories? Does his argument apply to all possible scientific theories, i.e. any empirical procedure? Does he go further ...
One of the arguments marshaled against traditional cultures' invocation of spirits is that they're simply projecting their own fears onto the world. That they're anthropomorphizing the world. It is notable that individuals have a telos. It would be bizarre for us to come across someone who did things arbitrarily. Even ...
or of our mental representation of it? Edit: Michael Dorfman raises the point, "why would it be amazing that "extremely complicated mathematics" would model the physical world? ... In fact, it would seem that given mathematics of sufficient complexity, one should be able to model anything; if one finds an object or sy...
In many traditions (eg Stoicism) philosophy is not a field of knowledge but of endeavour and spiritual exercise, or in other terms a way of life and seeing life. In that light, what value has any single answer to a given question? Should we close this website and remain silent (à la Zen)? Would it depend on the nature ...
What is the difference between the statements "I believe x is true" and "I suspect x is true"? To my mind they are both statements about what is known. However, the former seems to rely on faith to bridge the gap between our limited certainty and the complete certainty we often think is required to know something, whil...
In monadology, Liebniz describes monads as the true atoms, that which cannot be broken into parts, and enters into compounds. They are simple substances. Nor can they have shape, extension or divisibility. Now take spacetime itself; this obviously has extension & shape, so cannot be a monad: it must be a compound of th...
Capitalism is predicated on desire, and on maintaining that desire. Buddhism turns away from desire. Has anyone written anything that takes Buddhism seriously enough to make it the centre of their economic philosophy?
Is there a name for the following false syllogism? A implies B and B implies A therefore A For example: If unicorns exist then they have horns, by the definition of a unicorn. But in order for them to have horns they must surely exist. We must therefore conclude that unicorns do in fact exist.