instruction stringlengths 31 24.5k |
|---|
A real-world circle is not a true circle which, as far as Platos concerned, lives in the World of Forms. But isn't a fractal a mathematical form, so that does live in the the World of Forms; and as Mandelbrot pointed out, the coast of England, the shape of a cloud and the shape of a fern are fractals so they too live i... |
For those who don't know, the "preface paradox" is an epistemic paradox wherein an author painstakingly researches every single fact he asserts in a new book he's releasing. As a result, he believes each assertion made in the book with a high degree of certainty. However, he also takes care to write in the book's pre... |
Here he says that:
If you have A is sufficient for B it means that every time you have A
you will have B, without exception:
A -> B
If you have A is necessary for B it means that every time you
have B you will have A, without exception
A <- B
But I'm in doubt on what truth tables does each one holds. Can so... |
I have just read Angelika Kratzer's paper "Conditionals". In this paper Kratzer rejects the traditional account of the "if-then" construction in English as a two-place material implication operator, in favor of a new interpretation of "if" as a modal scope modifier.
It seems to me that this account might provide an alt... |
I am trying to search for literature that describes the various types of judgements people make based on their content. Most of the well-known works like that of Kant talk about two types of judgements: analytic and synthetic. I found a resource (http://www.rbjones.com/rbjpub/philos/epistem/rbj019.htm) that talks about... |
I'm reading critique of pure reason, from Immanuel Kant:
Now, in the first place, if we have a proposition which contains the
idea of necessity in its very conception, it is a¹ if, moreover, it is
not derived from any other proposition, unless from one equally
involving the idea of necessity, it is absolutely pr... |
Let's start with what is the universe: the universe is everything that exists - galaxies, stars, planets, matter, energies, etc. So the universe is composed of atomic components and the energies between them. That means that our universe is composed entities "positioned" relatively to each other in some space.
Even if... |
I was discussing with my friend about Star Wars. He told me that the emperor just wanted to create new political system and democracy, that was there, was totality, because it was only existing political system.
I think he's wrong, but i couldn't explain it to him. So what arguments are important to prove that democrac... |
I am working on a web site that has products information. Products, let's say consumer electronics, are represented by classes which describe different properties or groups of properties. Some classes can be same as categories, e.g. "smartphones".
Now let's say we have "Samsung Galaxy S II" as one of the items under "... |
How does/did cognitive science influence philosophy of mathematics? I saw somewhere (Wikipedia, "Cognitive science") that it helped to create new perspective on philosophy of mathematics, but it did not mention how it influenced.
|
If we begin with a notion of number N that we denote F(N) as a function of time, can a decidable procedure exist on definability of the growth of numbers? Inspired by Tipler's Omega point and Thomson's lamp, what would be the bound when definability cease to have meaning?
Prologue: It all started after reading The Uni... |
How long is present? When does present become past? Present exists as well it doesn't? How many seconds, miliseconds or whatever separates now from past?
|
I am having trouble understanding what defines Entailment operator. On Mathoverflow I posted this question on what I perceive to be paradox of entailment.
Consider:
Modus Ponens:
P therefore Q P
Therefore, Q
My question is could we have arbitrarily defined it such as:
P therefore Q P
Therefore, P
However, if an... |
In a great answer, a community member gave the following proof sketch that the halting problem is undecidable:
Proof that the halting problem is undecidable. If there were a computable procedure to reliably determine whether a given program/input halts, then design a new program q that on input p first asks whether p ... |
I'm looking for contemporary philosophers other than those typically labeled as part of the New Atheism movement (i.e., Richard Dawkins, Daniel Dennett, Sam Harris, Christopher Hitchens, and Victor J. Stenger) who have responded to some of Alvin Plantinga's works.
Could you recommend any?
|
I remember a few years ago I came across a description of a framework of argument that disallowed the use of the current (or any other) state in the argument given that the state is independent of how good the reasoning is. I can't find any reference to it any longer, can someone point me in the right direction?
|
I have to admit, that I don't know this:
I know that before Kant there were two groups of people that saw the world differently and Kant somehow synthesized the two positions and afterwords Hegel had something to criticized about his work and this is known as the "linguistic turn".
As you can see I don't know anything ... |
The title says it all. I looking into studying abroad in South Korea (I'm from Germany) in a year or so and I want to have at least a working knowledge of the philosophical workings of Asia and specifically of Korean philosophy. What would be a good starting point to familiarize myself with these philosophical viewpoin... |
I recently read 'Man's search for Meaning' by Viktor Frankl. It was a very moving book and in it the author describes three ways in which a man may find meaning in his life.
1.Through some creative act
2.Through an experience of beauty/art
3.Through suffering
Are there any other books that deal with the 'meaning of lif... |
I'm intending to read Anthony's Kenny's 4 volume History of Philosopy. I notice though it stops in 1975 which is fair enough I think. You can't have the history of yesterday. However I'm curious to know what of significance would be missing.
I appreciate there are a lot of academic philosophers so a lot must have been ... |
If you ask someone to describe someone else, or just tell him who is that person? what is the natural answer? of course he will respond which person?, because he never saw him before. And it's clear that we can't think in vacuum (thinking about nothing) because thinking is a prove of our existence. So now the trivial q... |
A plane is defined by being 2-dimensional. But if it is curved (like a hyperbolic plane), it requires an extra dimension, that is, it is curved in a 3-dimensional space.
So it seems, 2-D coordinates wouldn't be enough to describe this plane.
What is it's dimension? Should it be considered as 2 < D < 3 (some sort of fra... |
I see this in The God Delusion by Richard Dawkins:
If God is omniscient, he must already know how he is going to intervene to change the course of history using his omnipotence. But
that means he can't change his mind about his intervention, which
means he is not omnipotent.
Is this argument sound?
|
I've read this here:
Empiricists see empiricism as a pragmatic compromise between
philosophical skepticism and nomothetic science; philosophical
skepticism is in turn sometimes referred to as "radical empiricism."]
And this here:
But if we can distinguish pragmatic, moral or legal reasons from
epistemic reason... |
(Since there is no Psychology.SE, Ph.SE seemed like the best place to ask this question.)
I have noticed that when a person is presented with an unfamiliar idea, the default reaction is often to regard it as ridiculous.
Why is that?
Random example #1: If Obama claimed that he had seen a "Bigfoot", most people would th... |
Law of Excluded Middle:
In logic, the law of excluded middle (or the principle of excluded
middle) is the third of the so-called three classic laws of thought.
It states that for any proposition, either that proposition is true,
or its negation is. The principle should not be confused with the
principle of bivalence, ... |
I mean, is there a thought experiment that shows its ontological validity?
Could it concievably, based on the data that we have, be merely an epiphenomenon of syntax and semantics?
|
Strictly speaking, is it inappropriate to make a truth-claim?
I am seeking an answer from Philosophy (Epistemology), and feel free to use logic
I am speaking "theoretically", not "practically"
I am defining "truth" as "an objective truth" (e.g. "there is a car in my driveway")
I am excluding divine revelation (miracu... |
I was reading Russel's "Human Knowledge". He started with principle of inference. I'm not getting a hang of it though.(I'm just curious reader, not a philosopher in any means).
So a "easily conceivable" description will be very helpful for me.
|
The proper study of mankind is man. How, then, can philosophers be objective?
This is a question I ask myself every time I think of philosophical questions. We have no choice but to view the world and its mysteries from a human perspective, but that may be one that is quite irrelevant or mistaken from some other hypot... |
We know that today society does not approve of racism (atleast in public it has a negative sound). But I asked myself - why did it even come to racism - why was it needed?
Did it bring any benefit to a certain community to hate people of different race/belief/sexuality, even if they were not doing any harm to them?
Fo... |
Is there a philosophical explanation behind the following statement:
All fear is ultimately the ego's fear of death.
I heard this phrase in Eckhart Tolle's A New Earth. I am having difficulty understanding or accepting the idea, although I feel like it's true. What kind of explanation does philosophy have to offer he... |
My question is a follow-up from reading this answer;
"Roughly speaking, Socrates believed truth could not be discovered with certainty, Plato believed that truth could only be known via recollection, and Aristotle believed that truth could be obtained via observation and logic. The latter two, of course, began the tw... |
An overwhelming amount of evidence points to indirect realism being true. This means that all perceptions are spatio-temporally located throughout brain processes. Therefore the body you perceive is an illusory homunculus which actually exists throughout processing in your 'real' brain. There is no problem of infinite ... |
I am wondering about traditions of ethics which might incorporate naturalism or skepticism.
As far as I understand, the Academic Skeptics, in particular Carneades and Cicero, held that there was no way to know anything for certain, but also held that you could draw conclusions about good and evil from available evidenc... |
I found Internet resources a bit confusing, so I ask this question:
What are Wittgenstein's arguments on algorithm decidability and Godel's Incompleteness Theorem?
|
Many - if not all - sports seem to be only about winning. The rules of any particular sport determine what counts as permissible, and what counts as winning, and individuals and teams can "win ugly". In fact, winning is all that counts.
But it's possible to argue that this isn't the case at all. Anyone who has watched... |
Once logic has been formalised, it's an easy move to ask whether certain axioms can be altered. One of these is that logic is two-valued. This has been done and we have formal multi-valued logic.
Ordinary language sustains an idea of truth & falsity which fits in with the usual logic. Is there some way of understanding... |
I find somewhat odd to find out that there does not seem to exist concise summary or review of Callicles and Thrasymachus's arguments for supporting injustice, so I ask this question: what would be concise summary of Callicles and Thrasymachus's arguments regarding injustice, and what would be the summary of Socrates/P... |
I'm far from being an expert in the field of mathematical logic, but I've been reading about the academic work invested in the foundations of mathematics, both in a historical and objetive sense; and I learned that it all seems to reduce to a proper -axiomatic- formulation of set theory.
It also seems that all set theo... |
I am having a hard time understanding this section in Wikipedia's article on Logical biconditionals:
Colloquial usage
One unambiguous way of stating a biconditional in plain English is of the form "b if a and a if b". Another is "a if and only if b". Slightly more formally, one could say "b implies a and a implies b". ... |
A good few years ago I read The Emperor's New Mind by Roger Penrose. Having recently read some philosopy primers I was wondering about the links between this book and the question of free will.
From what i remember the final (speculative) argument went
(Roger thinks) there is free will
Where might free will be located... |
The trolley problem is a thought experiment in ethics that goes like this:
Suppose that a judge or magistrate is faced with rioters demanding
that a culprit be found for a certain crime and threatening otherwise
to take their own bloody revenge on a particular section of the
community. The real culprit being unk... |
I found the following passage in The Age of Reason by Thomas Paine
When Samson ran off with the gate-posts of Gaza, if he ever did so,
(and whether he did or not is nothing to us,) or when he visited his
Delilah, or caught his foxes, or did anything else, what has
revelation to do with these things? If they were... |
The description of Product systems in the SEP entry on Many-Valued Logic uses Dunn/Belnap's 4-valued system as an example of a product system:
In this way, the truth degrees of Dunn/Belnap's 4-valued system can be considered as evaluating two aspects of a state of affairs (SOA) related to a database:
whether there is... |
If what I know about Kant is correct- watching the Harvard Justice series on Kant and some summaries of his work- then Kant believes in an absolute morality where everything is either right or wrong in every situation. The act of morality is not dependent on the consequence of the action, but rather the action itself. ... |
One direct way of stating the heart of the question might be: is there sufficient textual evidence and support for the assertion that Plato's Republic contains meritocratic elements?
A second and larger concern here would be if so, because of this meritocracy, and not to mention the absence of slavery, the Republic cou... |
Lao Tsu's Tao Te Ching is full of paradoxes. Is paraconsistent logic sufficient to translate Tao Te Ching to formal logic?
To be specific, how can I get started with the following passage from J.Legge translation using ω-consistentcy theory?
The Tao that can be trodden is not the enduring and unchanging Tao.
The nam... |
If "I think, therefore I am" is correct wouldn't thinking you are "cool" imply that you are because you think therefore your are? And since that is the case, you would have to be "cool", right?
For Example
David: John just thinks he's cool.
|
I am currently in the process of enrolling for a Philosophy major. I would like to balance the amount of western philosophy with eastern philosophy. However, I can only choose Chinese or Japanese studies or even "Southeast Asian" studies, whatever that means.
At the moment I have no clue what the major differences in p... |
According to Wikipedia, Aristotle lived in the fourth century BC and is one of the most influential figures in Western philosophy.
The famous philosophers that deal with Aristotelianism that I am familiar with are from the Middle Ages. Avicenna, Maimonides, Averroes, Thomas Aquinas. It seems that Aristotelianism was po... |
What is the difference between propositional and acquaintance knowledge? It seems that acquaintance knowledge deals with sets of propositional knowledge - both known and unknown sets of propositional knowledge:
(Example from the unknown set) - "I may know the president of Japan,
but I may not know in what position he ... |
I've been thinking about this lately and I cannot come to a consistent conclusion.
Do animals deserve any rights? If so which rights and to which animals?
For example: testing medicine on chimps
Is it possible to come to any conclusion without using arbitrary qualifying attributes for such rights?
Furthermore, if we... |
I have read somewhere that Epicurus introduced (English author, I can provide the full details), among others:
A moral code of values of integrity, serenity and peaceful acceptance to life
Acceptance of the existence of other forms of life, like extra-terrestrial
Notions of DNA, evolution theory, atom theory
Acceptanc... |
Frequently, utilitarian ethics are presented from the point of view of individual decision-making, that is, the maximization of the "pleasure less suffering" function which underlyies rational choice in the context of personal self-interest; and the argument goes on by defining collective utility as a direct (botttom-u... |
What standards are used to evaluate and validate the potential enlightenment one may have achieved in Buddhism?
Do these vary between Theravada and Mahayana traditions, or vary in even more granularity?
Lastly, are these tests/evaluations only generally available to ordained members of the community, or is the knowle... |
As we all know until late XIX century, only offical logic was the Aristotelian logic. Also it's known fact that many scholars were aware of existance of propositional logic and disregarded it ex catedra. I'm looking for some reference regarding examples of irrational resistance against some new ideas in logic. In parti... |
I'm no philosopher and haven't extensively read or studied any philosophers.
I've recently been reading up a little on relativism and what it means and I'm a little confused about to what it is supposed to apply.
From my reading relativism is that truth belongs to the observer and there is no underlying truth.
Is thi... |
Who are the contemporary -not necessarily living- philosophers whose view of the world is similar to Schopenhauer's?
|
I'm reading a book on the history of philosophy and the author makes use of the word real-reality-really in such a way that is a bit confusing for me.
For example:
Aristotle's knowledge theory searches the instruments that allow the knowledge of particular things, because they are the only and true reality.
Only the p... |
I was a Philosophy major as an undergrad and became obsessed with the beauty of rigorous argumentation. There I didn't take a single class listed under the Mathematics department and was almost exclusively interested in Ethics.
Now, two years later, I have quit my job to pursue a Masters Degree in Pure Mathematics (af... |
Certainly your past experiences will affect how you perceive the world, process events, think about things, and behave but do you think the high level thinking required for the conception of self needs time or can it be instantaneous? Imagine someone who literally not remember more than 30 seconds ago, so as it were, ... |
The feeling that it's "sad" if a species dies out seems to be coming from an aesthetic point of view how the world should be. But is there a rationality behind it?
The only rational reason I was able to come up with is that more variety gives more possibilities for study. But this is only a weak argument I think and I... |
My oldest child is nearly six years old and will be starting his first level of formal schooling in a few weeks. I don't believe he will be taught philosophy and logic in the classroom, so I would like to suppliment his education.
Are there any resources for teaching young children philosophy and logic?
|
If Nietzsche is writing about humans, is he really writing about men or doesn't he make the distinction?
The way I came up with the question is complicated, but specifically I was thinking about the motivations for him writing Will To Power. In the sense of "What would be the intention anyway, did he want to make peopl... |
Could there be a possibility that everyone has a destiny pre-written and their desires are just driven by that destiny? And the concept of free will is just a blindfold with limited options. No matter which option we choose, we always move one step further in fulfilling our destiny.
In Astrology, it is said that the... |
I am planning to live with Buddhist monks. But I am hesitant. I am not sure whether I shall be able to live with them without leaving my current religion.
I think, if Buddhism is a religion, I am bound to face hard times. Because, it will clash with my current religion.
If it is a philosophy, then I dare to attempt.
I... |
Material things change every second (through natural (atomic) "decay"). However. things in the mind seem to not change at all. For example, 1+1=2 never varies.
What is the difference between 'Material things' and 'things in the mind'?
No; I do not want to talk about the differences; I want to talk about CHANGE. What do... |
I'd like to know all of the definitions of intention in philosophy.
Where can I find them?
I've found just this article which I couldn't understand much of it.
P.S. Cause I'm a computer science student and have done almost nothing before about philosophy, I'd be glad if the sources or answers are in simple words.
Thank... |
I have noticed recently that my mental experiences seem to posses the appearance of temporal continuity even when I cease to be aware of them. For example, if I'm running through a song in my head, I will cease to be conscious of doing so and then become aware of it again a minute later, by which time my inner monologu... |
This states 'act only in accordance with that maxim through which you can at the same time will that it become a universal law'.
How can I will a maxim to become a universal law, surely that kind of power can only be wielded by a god? Does he mean that I apply it universally and consistently myself?
|
If the universe is infinite, by virtue of chance it means that every possible configuration of matter must exist somewhere (according to this documentary).
Therefore, if the universe is infinite and it's possible to travel through time and space instantaneously, by sheer chance there must be a version of me out there ... |
I would like to hear some opinions on a question I am asking myself due to contradictions in the references of my term paper.
The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy article on "The Natural Law Tradition in Ethics" states:
Aquinas was not the only historically important paradigmatic natural law theorist. Thomas Hobbes... |
According to a paper titled Nietzsche's Reception of Buddhist Psychology With Constant Reference to Christianity by McDonald (2012), given at a conference in Copenhagen, Nietzsche's work contains 158 references to Buddhismus and its cognates within 137 textual units in the collected Digitale Kritische Gesamtausgabe of... |
In the novel (I think, could be another in the trilogy) "Beetle in the Anthill" one of the protagonists states that it is wrong to do acts that are irreversible, in the context of a grand decision possibly affecting the fate of humankind.
Thermodynamics and common sense tell us that this is strictly speaking impossible... |
There are various forms of the Anthropic Principle, and the Weak Anthropic Principle in the version stated by Barrow and Tipler roughly says that the observed values of the physical and cosmological constants are not all equally probable, and this is partially due to only a certain range of these various constants bein... |
I'm reading Latour's book We have never been modern, but I can't imagine a single example of a hybrid thing. Can you name one?
|
According to Whitehead’s theory of cosmic epochs and extensive continuum, there are material conditions that drive the more general metaphysical descriptions and principles. We only can account for the factors which characterize our cosmic epoch without overstretching these results to the cosmos in toto.
Unlike many p... |
Possible Duplicate:
What is the difference between free-will and randomness and or non-determinism?
Is free will reconcilable with a purely physical world?
As asked in the title, can a Universe which is deterministic at its fundamental level still allow free will?
|
Background: I am taking a philosophy of ethics class at a local college for the summer and my teacher brought up this prompt for discussion. The class discussion came down to the question if we have a responsibility to accommodate for the less "tech-savy" internet users so they don't get stuck in a "bubble."
My teacher... |
What is the difference in the role and in the notion that representation had in the middle age epistemologies vs the modern ones?
|
I think the answer is yes but I know a lot of people disagree. So, I would like to ask these people when exactly does it stop being me.
Let's say I want to upload my brain into a computer using the following procedure:
I have each of my neurons replaced by electronic neurons. By electronic neurons I mean chips with the... |
Without a clear answer to the infinite regress problem, can we justify anything without resorting to 'a priori' truths? And if not, how is there a reliable standard for testing the validity of a priori reasoning?
|
I recently answered this question on the ethical duty to help educate others, where I wrote:
I feel like if a person increases "happiness" more in his life then he
decreases the "happiness" then a person is moral. If a person helps
only 1 person in his life but doesn't harm anybody then he is moral.
He is not required... |
F.W.J. Schelling (1775-1854) seems to be a seriously overlooked figure of modern philosophy: is there a good reason (beyond the merely historical) for his diminished relative importance compared, for instance, to Hegel?
Heidegger admitted that Schelling's Freedom Essay (1809) was the "acme" of German Idealism — he brou... |
I never bought into the razor.
For example, if I have two hypotheses A and B with equal evidence, the razor would have me pick the simpler one. But personally in my mind, I create a sort of credence-distribution over the two hypotheses and hold the resulting distribution as my belief.
This can put us into some really ... |
I was thinking — if we didn't have words our experiences would be different somehow.
It seems to me that perhaps words are limiting our experiences because as soon as we relate an experience to a word it becomes entrenched, explored, all the mysteries given up, all the options explored — meaning that there are now so ... |
We've all heard of the Gospel of John and "In the beginning was the logos and the logos was with God." Many commentators and scholars have etymologically traced the term back to the notion of Word or revelation, whether in the sense of creation itself or scripture. Others have suggested this actually means the "gathe... |
One of the most appealing parts of Karl Popper's philosophy for me is the idea of theory-laden observation. To provide an unjust summary: whenever you are making an observation-statement to question some theory, you are relying on some background theory which shapes your observation. Any observation, no matter how basi... |
Kant argues in his Third Critique (sec. 59) that moral uprightness and decency brings us pleasure as in a reflective, judgment of taste:
Now I say that the beautiful is the symbol of the morally good, and
also that only in this respect (that of a relation that is natural to
everyone, and that is also expected of... |
Several research groups around the world are attempting to perfect techniques for growing animal flesh for human consumption, without requiring the killing of a complete intelligent organism. This is known as in vitro meat. Vegetarian groups are reportedly generally in favour of this development, deeming that this fles... |
Once in high school, a philosophy professor asked us the following question, as homework:
Is it possible for something perfect to be created by humans?
We were to discuss this question in the next class but for some reason the professor never came back to school, so we were never able to learn the answer (or the fact t... |
Can we say that no matter what philosophy a person holds, ultimately, all humans use double standards to live? The reason is: all continuously living human beings, will prefer to eat other living things, and not want to be eaten by other living things. Because if there is any human that is not using this way of think... |
A medical ethicist recently proposed that selecting (and possibly engineering) certain traits into our children is not just morally permissible but desirable:
Professor Julian Savulescu said that creating so-called designer babies could be considered a "moral obligation" as it makes them grow up into "ethically better... |
I know that several different philosophy currents touch the subject of what we are as humans, what does it mean to be alive, and if we are something transcendent to the mere bodily representation that we have. I am aware that there are great differences in what these philosophies proclaim.
Some of these currents conclu... |
The most appropriate statement of monotheism is surely the Shema which, as is widely known, is highly related to the Abrahamic faiths. In Chapter 1 of the book "against the gods: the remarkable story of risk", by Peter Bernstein, the author discusses the most intriguing topic of why probability theory was not developed... |
In the Introduction to Metaphysics, metaphysics is defined as "that science which claims to dispense with symbols." Bergson contends that the human mind operates discursively, or by taking snapshots of reality as frozen instances of time. The continuing flow and rhythm of duration can only be grasped intuitively, not... |
The special relativity theory teaches us that simultaneity is relative to the motion of our reference frame. This seems to contradict the intuitive notion of the present to be instantaneous. Some additional paradoxes from quantum mechanics and general relativity seem to question our intuitive notion of time and present... |
An occurrence such as bumping into a friend at a bus terminal bring to fore the role of Chance in the happenings of events. In this example, would Chance be exhaustively identified as the cause of the event? If so would it be, in a similar line of thought, be posited that the universe arose from an action of Chance?
|
Many theories of speech describe speech acts as being phenomena with both a sign and signified aspect. ( http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/meaning/ etc.)
In another perspective, which is exemplified in Iwenhe Tyerrtye by Margaret Turner who is an Australian Aboriginal elder, there exists only a fundamental identity bet... |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.