instruction stringlengths 31 24.5k |
|---|
http://gettingstronger.org/2010/05/opponent-process-theory/
One basic tenet of the opponent process theory is that there is a gradual unbalancing of the relation between an emotion and its own counter agent. For example holding a bucket of bricks with a wire handle, the intensity of the pain which is generated also pro... |
If the structures which enable the emergence of meaning in awareness behave according to principles which do not require meaning to function, this means meaning is inextricably tied to silence or non-meaning.
if meaning is the product of processes which are silent, does this mean that this silence is more ontologicall... |
Are modern proponents of formalism associated with an ontoglogical opinion regarding numbers?
If they view mathematics as the process of manipulating string according to agreed upon rules, there is no initial need for semantics. In a way you don't need the notion of the number three to do some work, which involved ... |
I am puzzled by compatibilism and am trying to understand what it means using a test example. Given that a typical chess program generates several choices, evaluates them with a goal of winning and chooses a specific option, would this imply that it has free will as defined by the compatibilists?
If not, is the reason ... |
Possible Duplicate:
How to get started with philosophy without getting overwhelmed quickly?
What is a good book (Or online resource) that introduces Philosophy and the methods of Philosophers, not by example only, but also with clear statements of what is being done?
I am reading a book on Philosophy of Science, and... |
“CHILDHOOD’S END”
From what is presently known, Homo sapiens—the modern form of man—has
existed on earth for approximately a hundred thousand years in numbers
large enough to constitute a population. Barring catastrophic
accidents, it can be expected that man will continue living on earth
for many millions of ... |
Although not an expert, I do see many similarities on both these currents' focus on man himself, aboloshing all idols and taking control of his fate. Are there any real differences between these two philosophies?
|
I don't know if this goes under philosophy, but I made an account here because I got really curious about this. I feel like the more materialistic society gets, we get less and less happy, but I am really not too sure how to explain that, just a guess. What do you think?
|
Nietzsche in what can be considered a critique of Cartesian reasoning at one point uses the identity of a flash with the lightning that 'produced it as a metaphor for famously saying that there's no doer behind the doing:
For, in just the same way as people separate lightning from its flash
and take the latter as a... |
Consider the claim that we knew that Earth was flat. The aforementioned claim seems counter-intuitive, at first glance; and false in accordance with the definition of "knowledge" as "justified true belief", since, presumably, it has never—at least since the existence of humankind upto the present—been a justified true ... |
Science typically refers people to Philosophy when such subjects are brought up. But yet they know that there are profound metaphysical implications of the physics of the last century, and since the spiritual interpretations don't conflict with the science, it doesn't quite seem in harmony with their otherwise neutral... |
I am quite confused how Fichte's ideas (and Schelling's ideas) and Hegel's ideas differ. There seem to be some common elements, but I am unsure how to pinpoint the difference between Hegel's and Fichte's.
|
I'm sure that there is a philosopher that tells about anger, but I don't know his/her name. Could you help me? I'm studying about the anger in many cultural fields: arts, history, religion.
Now I am interested in anger in philosophy.
What would you advise to me?
|
In terms of science, this claim has a pretty straightforward answer. Evidence is the base of all scientific claims, and without sufficient evidence any knowledge claim is meaningless. However, what are the implications of this idea for other subjects like art, history, ethics, etc.? Do these subjects require the same t... |
I was thinking about the topic of emotions, and their reliability in different areas of study(science, history, math etc.). The question I have is: Can we know when our emotions are credible in the pursuit of knowledge? For example, pseudoscience is caused when emotions trump rational thinking; so, is there ever a time... |
Consider this dialogue:
John: If I bet you a dollar this quarter would land heads, would you accept?
Jane: Yes.
John: If I bet you a dollar this nickel would land heads, would you accept?
Jane: No.
John: Do you believe that the probabilities of the coins landing heads are different?
Jane: No.
I seek the name of the f... |
Epicurus famously asserted that death should not be feared, with roughly the following argument:
When we die, we no longer exist;
Since we no longer exist, we can feel neither pain nor pleasure. Rather, we simple "are not";
Therefore, there is nothing to fear in death, as death literally is nothing from our perspectiv... |
Consider this text:
Researchers conducted two different types of test on a large group of people. After that, the researchers subjected the people to situations like Z and noted their response R. Those with high scores on test T2 had a good response. Likewise, those with low scores on test T2 had a bad response. There... |
You tell a person to try something. On the 1st & 2nd attempts, they succeed. On the 3rd attempt, they fail. They give up, saying "I failed, so I will always fail." From only 1 data point (of 3) they imagine a larger general trend that is false.
I am thinking it's Composition, with a larger set of actions being composed... |
Diogenes Laërtius says of Diogenes of Sinope ‘others, of whom Cercidas, a Megalopolitan or Cretan, is one, say that he died of holding his breath for several days’ in the midst of a bundle of accounts another almost right after tells of his sudden closing of his teeth and holding of his breath and so then death.
http:/... |
I am looking for a visual organization format that can help group logical conclusions. Basically, If people are given 3 options, and I am looking to interpret their vote, what is a clean manner of cataloging these items?
Basically,
- Option A can entail the numbers 1,2,3
- Option B can entail the numbers 1
- Option... |
Can you recommend a good reference to answer the critiques in Popper's "The Open Society and Its Enemies"? I am especially interested in responses to the Marx section of the book.
|
Is this a real quote from Kant?
“Someone’s intelligence can be measured by the quantity of uncertainties that he can bear”
If so, what is the origin? In what context does he say it?
|
Are the laws of mathematics and logic, such as if a=b, and b=c, then a=c just constructs of the human mind, or does the universe hold an innate logical structure to it, which the physical part of the universe must abide by?
|
What does it mean, strictly, for one event to "cause" another? If I throw a ball, does the movement of my arm cause the ball to move, or are they simply correlated events? If you say the arm caused the ball to move, how can you be sure?
|
Consider the following proof:
(1) Let the Universe be defined as the set of all things.
(2) It is impossible for a thing to come from itself. (You can't be your own parent)
(3) 2 implies a set of things cannot contain its own source.
(4) For all things X:
(5) Assume the Universe came from X.
(6) 1 implie... |
This question is inspired from news that several Lukoil franchisees in New Jersey had radically increased prices in protest of unfair pricing practices, in order to gain the attention of customers and force the company to respond.
This is only one example of the use of coercion in an attempt to generate a particular re... |
I did not ask such for pretentiousness, but for the reason that I may be characterized along with my arguments distinct of other scholars for nobody will know of my endeavor unless I tell them. I would like to do such as well for useful entitlement so as to prove that philosophers are not only those with academic crede... |
What are the most significant contributions Slavoj Žižek has made to the field of philosophy, perhaps in particular to political philosophy?
|
A major concern in epistemology is just what we can know about existential claims, that is, claims about the existence (or lack of) something.
Suppose for example that I assert the following:
The cake is a lie. No physical cake exists.
This is a negative existential claim, meaning that I am making a claim that some t... |
I know that the strict translation of ad hominem is against the person, but still I wonder if the logical fallacy named ad hominem is equally applicable when used against organizations. For example, it is a common argument tactic these days to dismiss a premise because its source was (take your choice) Fox News or the... |
I realize that the person I am as I type these letters and the person I am at the end of this sentence is slightly different. Change occurs all the time and infact change within my brain is the reason there is a "me" to begin with.
However from there is a continuity, as I started this question and until I'm done typing... |
We all will die one day.
We all know the life is difficult. We may live long lives, but death will come sooner or later for everyone. It is inevitable. Why should we bother living at all, facing the difficulties that it offers, if it is simply going to end one day.
What's the point?
|
I saw this on Wallerstein's writing, and I am not sure how one leads to this conclusion.
What is the source of this quote, "Globalization directly resuscitates local traditions", and how does one lead to this conclusion?
(The quote seems to be made by Slavoj Zizek, though I am not sure.)
|
Lately I´ve been reading Poppers "Logic of Scientific Discovery" and I am especially interested in his critics of induction as a scientific method. When he trys to show that a principle of induction can´t be formulated, he writes:
Kant tried to force his way out of this difficulty by taking the principle of induction ... |
I'm very interested in psychoanalysis ontologization of the "self"-concept meaning: The idea that there is a self - a continuous entity with some inner dynamic, that we must fight (defense mechanism) to preserve, and that the disintegration of such a self would be horrible, which is in contrast to accepting Buddhist be... |
A moments thought shows there can be no centre of an infinite expanse of space, it has no geometrical sense. When Aristotle places the Earth at the centre, he can surely only mean that its the meaningful centre, the place where anything of any importance can take place. Is this right?
|
Occams razor states that given a choice between differing explanations one should always choose the simplest. Of course this begs the question as to what one could mean by simplest.
I'm interested in situations in which the opposite principle has been found correct. That the more complex explanation wins out.
A possibl... |
Kants copernican revolution placed the observer squarely back into universe. The universe wasn't just an objective reality out there, but also entangled up in our own ways of knowing and perceiving at a fundamental level, that is our understanding of what is space and what is time.
Did his thought have an impact on the... |
Whenever I come across the words "authentic", "authenticity", etc. in (modern) philosophy texts, the manner and context in which they are used often give me the impression that the author intended them in a sense (a "technical" sense?) that differs significantly from the one I am familiar with.
I would like to understa... |
The functioning of cinema and other artistic and informational mediums within capitalism have been problematised by Zizek from a number of perspectives. within the huge volume of content which Zizek has produced the role of critique or critical theory is also given much attention (see for eg.).
how would Zizek explain... |
It seems Mathematical theories/Laws/Formulas are the least questioned in all of the sciences. Is mathematics that good at being closest to the laws of universe, or is it just a logical tool of our own perception of the universe (that being the reason it always works)?
I'll elaborate second part of question above, I tho... |
Aristotle claimed that the continuum, that is say a line, is not solely composed of points. Modern mathematics would agree, they additionally impose a topology to achieve cohesion.
Have their been any other philosophers who have discussed the continuum?
|
I would like to point out that I am not knowledgeable in the Christian religion (or any religion for that matter), so excuse me if I say anything that reveals my ignorance.
Of course, Nietzsche was not entirely fond of altruism. Despite this, I remember he said that the idea of altruism that is currently held is not ac... |
Nowhere is this fetishist logic more evident than apropos of Tibet, one of the central references of the post-Christian "spiritual" imaginary. Today, Tibet more and more plays the role of such a fantasmatic Thing, of a jewel which, when one approaches it too much, turns into the excremental object. It is a commonplace... |
I am curious why Hegel became more important than Schelling.
First of all, how would Schelling's ideas differ from Hegel's? I read that there are some supernatural elements in Schelling's, but do not know specifically.
Next, are Schelling's later ideas basically the reason for Schelling's under-appreciated status?
|
In this essay by Phil Shields, Wittgenstein & Silence he relates the following story:
Wittgenstein was invited to a meeting of the Vienna circle:
“When he finally came, instead of answering their questions about his book, he sat facing away from them reading Tagore, the Indian poet, for over an hour and then got up an... |
Zeno famously stated a number of paradoxes of space, time & motion to argue for parmenides unity & changelessness of being.
Infinite divisiblity of space & time seemed to be a commonly held view then (Aristotle distinguishes between infinite extent and infinite divisiblity), did anyone propose resolving his paradoxes ... |
Is there a fallacy in the argument, "Don't blame me; I voted for ..."? Or is a voter's entire responsibility for their contribution to whatever current state of political affairs they experience entirely waived because they voted for a candidate(s) other than the most recently elected official(s)?
Please note: This qu... |
Logic sprouted of different branches and now there is for computers, but as it grows the symbols tend to deal with problems not in accordance with what central philosophy tackles. It should therefore be specific to philosophy if the study is philosophical reasoning which is philosophical logic. Philosophical logic is a... |
In the sense of why the Barber in the Barber Paradox doesn't go mad or enter an infinite decision loop. What makes our minds paradox proof?
Can an artificial intelligence be made paradox proof?
I know that the exact functioning of mind is not known yet, but I'd appreciate any insight scratching the surface.
|
Is it ever morally ethical to override the majority in a democracy if you feel morally obliged to do so?
For example, a recent 'yougov' poll stated that a majority (I think somewhere in the mid-sixties) suppourted the death sentence. However, if I feel strongly morally against this, despite it being a majority, is it r... |
One of the interpretations of quantum mechanics is the Many Worlds Interpretation which basically states that the universe as a whole develops like an unobserved quantum system, and any observation effects ("collapse of the wave function") are illusions which are caused by the observer getting entangled with the observ... |
While this collapse of metaphysics into ethics is increasingly evident as nihilism, contemporary thought has yet to escape from this condition. Agamben seeks to understand and ultimately escape this collapse through a rigorous philosophy of the experience of language suggested in Infancy and History. In his analysis o... |
Is it possible to always act according to ones moral standards while tolerating hierarchy in society?
In other words: If you leave to somebody else the act of making the rules, including immoral ones, then how does this leave room to always act in accordance to your own (or even the current society's) moral standards?
... |
How is Shakespeare's work superior to Twilight? How is String Theory superior to some random dude's "theory of everything"? How is a Van Gogh better than what is termed 'kitsch'.
An answer that I do not want is something like "color choice, form, texture" or "abstraction, truth, falsifiability". I'm no stranger to the... |
Positivism (as formulated by Mills & Comte) advocated an epistemology based solely around the 'scientific method'. No doubt due to the stunning successes it had already achieved by then.
Marx said that he took Hegel and turned him down: that is from spirit over matter to matter over spirit. Did he do this at the behes... |
In 'Nagurjana, the limits of thought', Graham Priest defines essence to be
'For something to have an essence (Tibetan: rang bzhin; Sanskrit: svabhava) is for it to be what it is, in and of itself, independently of all other things.'
Who in the European tradition defines essence in this way? Or is the notion of substanc... |
To know something correctly requires describing a context that places that something, but to describe that context we would need to describe a wider context that places it and so on.
We have an infinite regression. So to obtain knowledge we must truncate this at some point, but then we do not have real knowledge of th... |
In his essay entitled My teacher Gilles Deleuze characterises the "central obsession" of Sartre as being "lakes of non-being and the viscosity of matter".
Is this a fair characterisation of Sartre's work ?
|
I got it into my head some years ago that a constructivist epistemology is one that requires the foundations of new knowledge to be consistent with the existing corpus. I figured 'constructivist', since it builds on what is already there. I've since learnt, also some time ago, that constructivism is something entirely ... |
1) If a distinction is made between scientific inquiry that proceeds via induction and scientific inquiry that proceeds via deduction, what are the core activities and disciplines of each?
My attempt, which may serve as guide to what I'm after, is below.
Inductive fields of science:
data collection
database manageme... |
Possible Duplicate:
Is Knowledge Fallible?
My question is about the definition of knowledge as used by philosophers in the area of epistemology.
I am wondering if knowledge implies certainty. In other words, if you are not certain of something, can you know that thing, or must you be certain in order to know it?
If ... |
Is Nagarjuna by affirming the Sunyata of being, that is nothingness, commenting on the lack of object essences, that this sofa that I'm sitting on has no essence in and of itself; thus it's being is interdependent on other beings. (I shouldn't use the word being here at all, but I cannot think of the appropriate termin... |
To be more clearer with the question let us compare for this instance sociology to philosophy, both being a broad subject. Sociology has many branches including political science, psychology, anthropology, etc., yet political science can be discussed without the participation of anthropology in other words it can exist... |
From the definition from Wikipedia:
Philosophy is the study of general and fundamental problems, such as
those connected with reality, existence, knowledge, values, reason,
mind, and language. Philosophy is distinguished from other ways of
addressing such problems by its critical, generally systematic
approach... |
In Nietzsche's The Gay Science, §8 deals with that he calls "unconscious virtues":
Unconscious virtues. — All qualities of a person of which he is conscious — and especially those he supposes to be visible and plain to others also — are subject to laws of development entirely different from those qualities which are u... |
What did Jean-Paul Sartre mean when he said that because there is no creator, humans are "Condemned to be Free"?
|
Imagine a rock has become dislodged, rolling down a hill just on the outskirts of town. As it's rolling, it picks up an amount of money, which sticks to it. The rock has just enough momentum to roll into a pie shop. The money falls on the counter, a pie is given to the rock, along with the change, and the rock and the ... |
The physical substance of a computer can deteriorate and eventually stop functioning, but the immaterial program & its state can be transferred to
another computer. Its conciousness is effectively continuous with its prior existence,
Does this mean if a concious computer is possible then it can reincarnate itself?
|
Hubert Dreyfus among others have risen to prominence in philosophy of AI by emphasising (among other things) the directive primacy of unconscious or automatic, habit-driven processes. Dreyfus came to recognise this as a problem for AI developers working with formal symbol manipulation matrices through his readings in t... |
What are philosophical reasons for approving of freedom of speech but not of freedom of deeds? If teasing the others by speech is allowed, why not by deeds? If freedom of deeds is wrong, then why approving of freedom of speech? If both can cause disasters, then why distinguish between them? To me being teased by words ... |
There are many mathematicians who talk about the particular beauty of a subject. They may say a particular result is pretty. It may be beautiful.
It seems to me play a fundamental role in the composition of new mathematics. I know that there are theories of aesthetics, I imagine they refer either to music or to art, b... |
How does he relate hubris to his notion of the superman. For example in the greek play Oedipus Rex, hubris directly leads to destruction. It's seen as a vice, a flaw in character. But it seems that a superman must have hubris as a virtue. How does he reconcile these two contraries, if at all. Is he consistent on it.
Se... |
There are some notable persons who criticized formal logic in favor of informal logic for various reasons, like Schiller. So what is the school of thought or tradition that incorporates or adheres to the maxims asserting the much importance of informal logic or practical logic.
|
Suppose you have to choose between:
a. getting 1$
b. getting a ticket of the lottery L(p) which gives you 1'000'000'000$ with probability p and 0 with probability (1-p), with p such that the expected gain is less than 1$
could it be rational to play?
One could think that the 1$ you get by choosing a doesn't actually ... |
Consider the following multiple choice question:
If you randomly chose and answer to this question, what is the probability that you are right?
a) 17%
b) 0%
Note that when I heard about this question, there where more, and more plausible answers compared to how the question is formulated here. However, I'm only in... |
I am new to the philosophy stack exchange, so please let me know if I need to clarify this question further. I am curious if there is a distinction made in philosophical fields between a typical step-by-step accretion of knowledge and what might be called an epiphany or an epiphanic event.
For example, I feel that thi... |
Logic is broad and concerns different fields, so to be more specific with the purpose of logic what is the most important form of which required for practical philosophy?
|
The US Supreme Court has ruled that the act of spending money (buying political ads) is a form of speech, or, a speech act (political speech). The implication being, of course, that political spending, under the aegis of free speech, cannot be restricted. The notion that spending is a form of speech does not seem strai... |
The most important element for expression of truth is trough an argument, with premises and conclusion. Argumentation requires to avoid fallacies and adhere to the truth. However logic if treated as a subject itself and not a part of something else grows bigger and deeper, that it leads to symbols which I find unnecess... |
Recently listening to my thoughts I think that it's reasonable to affirm that thoughts are randomly generated. It is correct to say so because you can't think an infinite pattern of thoughts at once, truly, you can only be thinking one thing at once, which leads to the question,
Did I choose to think this or this thoug... |
Logic, which I mean as the system or subject not the adjective; like modal propositional logic, etc., and not an adjective stating rationality, sense of thinking, common sense, etc.
Perhaps we all know who Nietzsche is. For me he is the most unique philosopher for he knows how to conceal his notions with clever play o... |
I have this question haunting me for a while now.
I always appreciate Feynman's saying about Nobel prize most: "I appreciate the work that I did, and all the people who appreciated it, and I noticed other physicists use my work, I don't need anything else, I don't think there's any sense to anything else, I don't see t... |
I am trying to understand emptiness (Buddhism). As I understand it, nothing that can be changed, or broken down into smaller parts is inherently real. If my worldly perceptions of emptiness are not inherently real, but created out of some interaction between emptiness and my own mind, how does that explain that so many... |
In a very interesting talk Graham Harman speaks of a woman doing a PhD thesis on Actor-Network theory and Volcanoes. This is almost syncronistically in line with ideas I have been considering for my present honours thesis. The seamless crossover between philosophy and real-world phenomena in Latour is fascinating, and ... |
I'm a junior researcher in Computer Science field and I've had some difficulties with some scientific terms like the one on the title "classical logic" which is used to represent and identify some other things. Could any one explain the meaning of that term?
|
I considered asking this on math.SE, but I realized this question wasn't really about mathematics.
Suppose I have 4 pens sitting on my desk. So I have a set S = {pen, pen, pen, pen} = {pen}. That's not quite what I wanted: I can't tell the pens apart.
How do I distinguish the pens? Well, I might consider the color of t... |
Most of out time-measuring instruments are based on repetitive physical phenomenon. These phenomenon repeat and every time their state matches the one in our recent memory, we tend to acknowledge, that a unit of time has passed.
on the other hand, Our mind's states never repeat exactly the same. The only blurred idea ... |
Is it true in logic that "a is b" but "b is not a"? Does it work one way or both ways?
For example:
a is b
Therefore, b is not a
If this is valid, how can you prove that it is valid?
|
Many people talk about the demarcation problem, which is supposed to be about finding a criterion that would distinguish between "scientific" and "non-scientific" theories.
Yet any such criterion is ultimately just a convention. If we wanted to, we could call anything science - there is nothing special about the word "... |
It is well known that there exists self-referential statements which are neither true or false, such as "I am lying".
Is it possible to have statements neither true or false which are not self-referential?
Consider the statement, "Alice likes berries". If Alice likes some berries (say grapes), and dislikes other berri... |
Physics and biology have no answer why or how we personally experience the color red and we say that the experience of the color red is a quale.
Physics also has no answer why or how we experience the flow of time. So is the experience of the flow of time also a quale?
Since the flow of time is so closely related t... |
I would like to know how Derrida-Searle debate went on (Wikipedia is lacking, and Searle's response is somehow difficult to find.).
Can anyone provide me some summary and some crucial details?
|
I am much interested in discussions such as Wigner's "The Unreasonable Effectiveness of Mathematics in the Natural Sciences". It's quite amazing that mathematics so well applies to our universe, and this raises many interesting questions which have been discussed here already, but I am interested in the converse as we... |
What are some new, unique and interesting ethical/philosophical/sociological issues that are starting to present themselves as Information & Communication Technologies (ICT) advance?
Are there any intriguing issues related directly to a specific ICT?
|
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1ZjMKGTYfK4
I don't get this guy, from where does he justify his point? Can anyone give facts about this, principally I would be interested in some facts here, as they are soaringly lacking, and this accounts for the shabby nature of my understanding about this important matter.
Why is a ... |
According to OED, noumenon is
An object knowable only by the mind or intellect, not by the senses
But I'm a little confused at considering about numbers, they seem to be objects knowable only by the mind or intellect; but when we see 2 apples on a table, we seem to can know 2 by our sense of sight. But I'm not sure... |
For Latour all things from people, trees, minerals, all the way to atomic phenomena are able to be seen as actors and actants, with no actor or actant being reducible or irreducible to anything else. A tree cannot ultimately be reduced without arbitrariness to bark, wood and chlorophyll systems any more than it can be ... |
Is it acceptable to say that a specific language is more logical than another language? To give an example, I always see the argument, that Latin (and also Japanese) is more logical than English.
|
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.