instruction
stringlengths
31
24.5k
While reading Incognito by David Eagleman, there was a chapter about justice and the neural plasticity of the brain. The ability (or in some cases inability) to regulate "moral" functioning. The legal implications of this are boggling in some cases - someone who has a brain tumour removed stops acting like a total jerk...
I'm looking for references on population ethics, preferably those with a mathematical bent. Broome's Weighing Lives is a good example of what I'm looking for.
My new term brings new questions, this time concerning Kant's "Perpetual Peace" (you can read most of it here). The preliminary articles can be differentiated: All of them are prohibitive rules, but some (1,5 and 6) are "strictly valid without regard to circumstances". The other ones are permissive laws. It is these t...
Russell was active in philosophy (although no longer in math) for many years after the Gödel's 1931 publication. Gödel's paper were not obscure, and Russell would have been aware of their effect on the Principia and his logicism (and Hilbert's formalism). Logicomix (a partially fictionalized accounts of Russell's life)...
If so, does it mean we should always use quantificational logic since it combines both syllogistic and proportional logic? Also, Is there any other logic which further builds on quantificational logic?
Possible Duplicate: How can we reason about “if P then Q” or “P only if Q” statements in propositional logic? Here's the table for If-then _____ ___________ | A B | (A ⊃ B) | | 0 0 | 1 | | 0 1 | 1 | | 1 0 | 0 | | 1 1 | 1 | |_____|___________| Let A = There's a God. and B = There...
If zero is the representation of nothing, then nothing must me something because it is being represented, correct? Now, if the above is incorrect, and zero is actually nothing, then why is it that after every 9 numbers when we count we use zero to increment to the next set of 1-9 IE: [1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10<-,11,12,13,...
I have a problem with the distinction between induction and deduction. To me it does not make sense to talk about induction at all. People argue that the following is induction: A_1 is x A_2 is x ... A_n is x -- All A are x; The question whether induction is a valid way to conclude this, from my point of view, boils d...
Some people argue that we can not verify hypothesis but we can falsify them? I believe we can usually negate statements. So, if we can falsify statements, why cant we verify statements by falsifying their negation? I do not ask if it is practicable to do so, but rather about the general possibility. Why does the distin...
“I am utterly amazed, utterly enchanted! I have a precursor, and what a precursor! I hardly knew Spinoza: that I should have turned to him just now, was inspired by “instinct.” Not only is his overtendency like mine—namely to make all knowledge the most powerful affect—but in five main points of his doctrine I...
The works of Marshall McLuhan (and others) explore the way meaning comes to be conditioned by the nature of the medium through which it is conveyed. The key emphasis for McLuhan, however, centred upon systems of information dissemination, namely those utilised by the media. The question of how a philosophical tract's c...
Peirce, James, & Dewey are generally regarded as the three originators of American pragmatism. Personally, I have noticed each of them for different reasons. James is interesting because of his radical empiricism, Dewey because of his understanding of inquiry as both cognitive and action-oriented, and Peirce because o...
Consider the following scientific hypothesis, "One is more likely to observe a kangaroo at night than during the day". In other words, "the conditional probability of observing a kangaroo given it is night is greater than the conditional probability of observing a kangaroo given it is daytime". Do you think there are a...
You can imagine the perfect chair in your mind but you cannot build the perfect chair. Or something very similar. I believe that is Kant but I cannot find any reference to the quote anywhere. Any one have some ideas?
Positivism tells us that only what is verifiable exists. Therefore scientists should study only what they can observe and measure, through which they can explain natural or social phenomena. Interpretivists focus on the experience that people are having, hence scientists should conduct qualitative interviews to underst...
According to Conjunctive syllogism, We accept one part of the statement as true and reject the other part as false. Truth table for AND _____________ | P Q | (P.Q)| | 1 0 | 0 | | 0 1 | 0 | | 1 1 | 1 | | 0 0 | 0 | |_____|______| For example: Suppose, we have, Premise 1: ~(P.Q) Premise 2: P There...
I had a midterm question where this was relevant, essentially it was: "Assuming you're an atheist, how would you prove to Descartes that your last vacation wasn't a dream?" I put that since Descartes believes in God, your beliefs are irrelevant and since God is not a deceiver (according to Descartes), he would not d...
I have 3 statements I want to convert into symbolic logic (P, Q, etc.) All men are people. Some men are clever. Therefore, all people are clever. First of all, I know this is illogical, but I'm trying to figure out how to show this using symbolic logic. Can I say: P = men Q = people R = clever (All) P -> Q (...
I'm curious if anyone has any suggestions for finding contemporary philosophy essays/books (i.e., not Aristotle) which deal with the connection between virtue and well-being.
Wikipedia defines knowledge as "familiarity with someone or something" and Plato defined knowledge as "justified true belief". Belief and familiarity is something that only a sentient being can have, or at least an agent with some level of intelligence. This implies, that knowledge can't exist in outside of the conscio...
I was reading Wikipedia through materialism and physicalism article and was unable to find, whether modern scientists largely subscribe to physicalism in natural sciences. What is the scientific consensus on the metaphysical stances? To particularize: Does physicalism holds for mathematics and what is the mathematicia...
Something about my translation has bothered me since I originally posted my question (which follows below). It concerns what Bertrand Russell wrote in "On Denoting". Ryno indicated a circularity with the way I originally reformulated Cogito ergo sum. But upon rereading Russell I'm wondering if the following isn't a mor...
I guess everyone knows about Cervantes's character "Don Quixote" and the metaphor within it's lifestyle. Even though every single individual understands it differently, in my opinion Don Quixote is the image of the visionary, the true free spirit living it's own dream beyond ignorance and the convention we call life, ...
Everyone on this world wants to be happy. It's in human nature to be satisfied, pleasured,... happy. Happiness usually means painless state of mind when we enjoy beautiful present. In this desire for the happiness we often make a lot of pain to ourselves and people around us, why is that? I've often caught myself and o...
You think that you will die just because everyone dies. And you would like to know if you are immortal. How can you know if you are immortal or not?
If I am infinitely old , can I have a father ? And can I have a brother that is infinitely older than me but younger than my dad ?
I'm engaged in a discussion with somebody about the nature of belief. I've been arguing that belief is an attitude toward a proposition, and that in order to believe something, you necessarily have to have some concept of the proposition in mind(whether consciously or not). He disagrees(!), however, and believes that i...
When you look at the world, I think it's a rather non-controversial statement that a good percentage, if not a majority, of social problems are caused by people making choices based solely on short-term outcomes--"if X then Y, and Y is desirable, therefore I will do X"--without taking long term consequences into accoun...
I was thinking about the question How can I know that I am not immortal? and started wondering about the relation between induction and falsifiability. Regarding the cited question, one thinks: well, so far every one of the 100 billion human beings that ever existed died (supposedly, since we didn't verify every and ea...
Let's take that person's subjective experience of the universe is given. If we take for example one particular person - lets say the person that is reasoning about this question (denoted with I in the rest of the text), we could say that: "because I'm having various kind of experiences about the universe, I would say f...
Possible Duplicate: How can we reason about “if P then Q” or “P only if Q” statements in propositional logic? I have read in quite a few books that the proposition 'p->q' can be read as either 'if p then q' and 'p only if q'. Let p = it rains, and q = take an umbrella. Then with according to the first form the argum...
Reading some philosophy articles, I keep coming across the phrases "it is the case that X" and "it is not the case that Y". I get the impression that this phrase has a somewhat different nuance than "X is true" (or X is reality) and "Y is false". But when I search for definitions, I can't find any. ("Case" obviously is...
This question has bothered me for a long time but I decided not to share it with anyone because I find that someone else might actually live by it. Personally I subscribe to some form of utilitarianism as my moral Philosophy and its been quite obvious to me that moral behavior should be the default position anyone shou...
Heraclitus proposed that everything was in flux always: The Greeks before Heraclitus focused on the essence of things, its nature and being, which they deemed unchangeable. In contrast, Heraclitus said: "You cannot step into the same river twice, for fresh waters are ever flowing in upon you." This simple sentence exp...
In a recent paper, Steve Fuller lambasts the analytic social epistemologist as having little understanding of how knowledge making actually works in the real world. The criticism is that the analytic approach has not made any significant progress compared to studies of knowledge in the wild. What counterarguments are t...
Suppose John asks Mary to show him a piece of art, and she shows him the Mona Lisa. In doing so, Mary seems to be claiming that the Mona Lisa is a piece of art—i.e., that the Mona Lisa has (or instantiates) some property denoted by the word "art". But does it? It seems to me that the word "art" denotes a class of thing...
Possible Duplicate: How can we reason about “if P then Q” or “P only if Q” statements in propositional logic? Are both forms of arguments correct? If not then why? To me both seem correct because If John had a gun then he shot James and if he shot James then he must had a gun. First form: If John shot James, then J...
Is or was there a philosophy which examines a hypothesis that in fact nothing "exists" except maybe questions? I know there are philosophies that state that reality is a simulation etc. but I mean that not even a simulation exists. The only "things" that exist are the questions we ask.
I'm a physicist, but I do like philosophy, so I was arguing with a friend about what comes first: Ideas or the language/symbolism? More Precisely: If we define thinking process as: a kind of abstract process that enables some object to deduct results or solve problems, but not as specific usual biological/machine proc...
Possible Duplicate: How can we reason about “if P then Q” or “P only if Q” statements in propositional logic? In a logic exercise, suppose this argument is given: P1: If there's a God, then there's a world. P2: If there's a God. C : There's a world. This argument is valid. But if we put the first premise this ...
When you have a propositional sentence of the form P ⊃ Q  — which we might read as "if P, then Q" — how can you tell when it is true, or false, based on the truth-values of P and Q in classical logic? When is this different from Q ⊃ P? And what is the connection to 'necessary' conditions, or sufficient conditions? Also...
Disclaimer: I haven't seen any other posts about this anywhere and one night, I was just thinking and scribbled this down, so I don't know where this could be found otherwise. What if, there is no true meaning to death? Many scientist believe that death is simply death, and when you die, there is nothing left but the ...
I am currently studying some aspects of Spinoza's philosophy, mainly in contrast to Kant. It seems to me that Spinoza is just the kind of "dogmatic metaphysician" Kant criticises. I know that Kant tried to "proof" God's existence in his pre-critical phase, but later changed his mind (I refrain from going into details)....
I have been trying to solve some propositional proofs, E.g. (A ⊃ B) (~A ⊃ B) Therefore, B And I know that this is valid argument. Can we ever know the real values of A and B from the truth table or is it just that we assume some values which we can use to prove the argument to be valid or invalid?
So far, I've only been able to dig up a partial footnote by Kripke in his essay "Wittgenstein on Rules and Private Language" where he tantalizingly writes that "... Wittgenstein would regard his remarks on machines as applicable to 'functionalism' as well." (p. 37) I can't imagine that Ludwig would've accepted fun...
Recently had a dream where I was in a situation I have never been before in "real life" - (no real experience prior to the dream of this situation). After waking, all the feelings, thoughts, memories of what I did in the dream were still there, and could now do this activity through the skills and experience I learned...
What branch of philosophy or what philosopher(s) study the classification of different types and processes of thinking (thought)? Mortimer J. Adler in his 1972 book "How to read a book" defines 3 types of so-called analytical reading: Structural - when reader divides the text hierarchically until atomic parts (the pro...
First, I understand the argument that "you don't need heaven or hell to be moral". That's not the question. Second, this question is about atheists and non-religious people. You see many of these people doing good things in their lives continuously with no promise of heaven or any self-benefit. Someone might spend thei...
We have, not all represented by ~(x) and some represented (∃x) For example if I say, Not all are animals. Some are animals. Because we aren't considering all the animal nor we are disregarding all the animal. What would be difference between the two statements and how do we use them?
In logic we say, "All A are B" to mean (x)(Ax ⊃ Bx) "Some A is B" to mean (∃x)(Ax . Bx) I can see how (x)(Ax ⊃ Bx) makes sense, By looking the table if we had A = 1, B = 0 then this statement wouldn't hold. My question is how do we know that (∃x)(Ax . Bx) means "Some A is B"? What if I had (∃x)(Ax ⊃ Bx) instead? Can it...
What subset of Hegel should a person know to understand Marxist philosophy? In political alignment i'm a Marxist, and mostly subscribe to social and political positions of the kinds like Slavoj Žižek or István Mészáros. However in philosophy i was always a logical positivist and was never interested in continental trad...
I have come across an inference rule that if I had statements like: Not all are birds which translates to ~(x)Bx, is equivalent to, Some are not birds which translates to (∃x)~Bx. According to this answer, For example: Not all are birds can mean zero or no birds at all and Some are not birds should mean that at least...
Philosopher John G. Bennett proposed the idea that there are actually three time-like dimensions, in addition to the usual three spatial dimensions. I would be curious to learn what the philosophical implications of such ideas might be, and whether there are any new advances or ideas in this area. I would be most inte...
I'm having some doubt if this proof is valid or invalid, especially regarding the line 4 derived from line 2. Do I need to change the letter in there? 1. (z)~Fz ∴ ~(z)Fz Using Indirect proof strategy we assume the opposite i.e., 2. (z)Fz 3. ∴ ~Fa [from 1; Dropping universal] 4. ∴ Fa [from 2; Dropping universal] 5. ∴ ...
Simply include 2-3 main points about the theory.
Does anyone know if the idea that something can't be proved, only disproved has a specific origin? I often hear it and would like to make a reference to it in a term paper I'm writing. Is it from the null hypothesis? I also take it that it applies to pretty much any belief, whether it's an untested hypothesis or a theo...
What's the difference between "universal" and "existential" when used in the context of wff (well-formed formulas)? We have a universal quantifier, which can be written as (x), and an existential quantifier, which can be written as (∃x). Now, let's take ~(∃x)Fx as an example. Would you call it a universal or existentia...
I recently discovered Marion Levy's laws. And Princeton's news article on his life claims his laws grew to eleven, but only adds the eleventh. What is Marion J. Levy's tenth Law? My apologies if this question does not belong here. I looked through the different Stack Exchange sites, and this one seemed to be the best ...
John Lane Bell, is his paper "Abstract and Variable Sets in Category Theory" (go to Bell's Homepage to download it), defines an abstract set as follows: "An abstract set is then an image of pure discreteness, an embodiment of raw plurality; in short, it is an assemblage of featureless but nevertheless distinct 'dots' o...
As asked here about the difference between "some" and "not all". I'm looking for a practical example in real world where these two can be applied. Do we have a situation where we can use either of them? Are these two merely based on how we infer things? I came up with this example: Suppose, we enter a hall where we fin...
I'm looking for a book that isn't too dense and that is usually recommended for someone who wants to learn of the mind/consciousness but doesn't know where to start.
Predicate logic is somewhat like propositional logic, except that where propositional logic only works on the level of whole sentences (e.g. A = "Socrates is mortal", B = "All Scottish people eat their porridge plain"), it allows you to talk about individual objects (e.g. "Socrates", "porridge") and consider properties...
I am not a philosopher but I would like to ask this question. I know that there are philosophers like Hobbes, Locke or Foucault, who excel in the areas of ethics, political philosophy and aesthetics. However they rather use informal logic than formal/symbolic logic in dealing with practical problems posed by the respec...
Can the above words be used interchangeably? The phrase "circular reasoning" is mentioned under "paradox" in wikipedia, which led me to think about "tautology". I understand "dialectical" to mean (a relationship) characterised by opposites, which, is synonymous with contradictory and therefore similar to "paradox"? Wha...
If most people in population report the same negative experience relative to others - what is the source of that experience? For example, the majority of a student body reported feelings of exclusion and loneliness - but how can that really exist? Especially the exclusion - wouldn't that require another population to f...
I know we have accepted Cantor's ideas a long time ago and many mathematicians use sets and infinities without ever realizing that thinking about sets and infinities intuitively fails, because there are many paradoxes associated with naive set theory. However, why did mathematicians such as Kronecker regarded Cantor's ...
Possible Duplicate: Does a philosopher need much knowledge of mathematical/formal logic? That's right, I am weak in all subjects dealing with symbols and structures. My specialty lies with critical thinking. I found my talent useful in philosophy especially to moral philosophy. I am lucky that I have established my ...
Reading Russell's Why I Am Not a Christian I stumbled upon a passage (The Moral Arguments for Deity) I don't seem to understand. Kant, as I say, invented a new moral argument for the existence of God, and that in varying forms was extremely popular during the nineteenth century. It has all sorts of forms. One form is...
Possible Duplicate: What does “to cause” mean? Take an example, It is reported that short-circuit caused fire in city bakery. In this case short-circuit and fire was in a causality, short-circuit is cause and fire is effect. But what is causality? Is cause a necessary or sufficient condition of effect? In this case ...
I have been reading a bit of Dawkins and the like and they all seem to hold a very strong viewpoint on atheism and its associated ideology. I have not found a direct citation for this but he frequently makes a very close connection, e.g.: An atheist before Darwin could have said, following Hume: "I have no explanation...
I posted this question on english.se, and there have been a few interesting points, but I'm not sure the audience has the domain knowledge needed to fully appreciate what I'm asking. I restate below: In the philosophy of science, there are three terms which are used to describe three different related notions. In bot...
I know Russell and Wittgenstein argued about negative truths. It is easy to prove the existence of some property provided there is considerable empirical evidence for its existence, but what if we are concerned with negative properties? Although we could provide some evidence for absence of a particular properties, we ...
What is virginity in philosophers perspective? How do philosophers see virginity while its being a value and as part of a practicing religious belief? How do philosophers see this from their perspective? Most people in certain cultures, e.g. Islam and Hinduism, want their partner to be a virgin. The Indian community ...
Which philosopher has stated "This is not the beginning of a crisis. This is the end of an illusion"? (approximate quote) And if you remember the philosopher: from which context or book comes this quote?
Can constraints against goodness maximizing actions be defended on grounds which suggests that such actions might illegitimately involve one using others without treating them as ends? What is the difference between treating someone as an end and merely using that person?
I was recently introduced to categorical arguments and, since the square of opposition is merely a mnemonic, it doesn't seem completely unreasonable to me that there could be a 3-dimensional analogue (also a mnemonic) that allows the inferences for three categorical propositions to be carried out by geometric means, li...
Kant's theoretical work Perpetual Peace could be seen as limited insofar as he didn't really provide any detailed thoughts on the legislative and executive institutions that would make international law reality. Could it be said that he relies on the enlightened and moral republican public to make up for this? Explain ...
A distinction I have come across in some of Zizek's informal lectures, as well as in my own ponderings, is that which describes those beliefs which, although we know formally to be true, we do not experience the world as if they were true. As an example, I believe the threat posed by man-made climate change to be both ...
In the Summa, Aquinas, working from an Aristotelian philosophical position, argues that the rationality of the universe points to a creator. If I am correct in interpreting his work, he says that the rationality of the intellect (per tabula rasa) is merely a reflection of the rationality of the universe, that is, that ...
On the one hand, Dawkins is a rather vocal exponent of evolution. Evolution, to me, appears to hold that greater complexity can arise form lesser complexity (unless we want to argue that the causes conspiring to increase the complexity of a particular part of the universe are summa summarum greater in some sense than t...
Let there be two hypothetical, irreducible objects A and B, both possess a changeable property P. If A and B interact, their property P is effected. How do I distinguish between entities and interaction in logical sense, when someone asks what was the cause of change in P ? Which is correct cause : A ?, B ?, both ?, o...
Consider a piece of information. I know it and so do you. Moreover, I know that you know it, and you know that I know it. Further, I know that you know that I know it, you know that I know that you know it, and so on. Each stage entails a further degree of knowledge because it is quite possible in principle, for exampl...
I've been searching the questions posed here, and don't seem to find one that gives the answers I am looking for. I've proposed to start a list on meta but no one proposed anything, so I feel I must ask this question: What are some books generally regarded as good for a general introduction on philosophy? By this I mea...
Consider the 'set' behind Russell's Paradox: R = { x | x is a set and x ∉ x } in light of Cantor's definition of set ("aggregate"/Menge) in his CONTRIBUTIONS TO THE FOUNDING OF THE THEORY OF TRANSFINITE NUMBERS (Dover edition), By an 'aggregate'...we are to understand any collection into a whole... M of definite and s...
In Cresswell and Hughes: "A new introduction to Modal Logic" they in question 2.4 ask to show that $L(M(\alpha))$ isn't a theorem of $K$ system (where L is the necessary operator and M the possible operator). Here's what I thought, I can substitute $\alpha$ for p&~p So I get: L(M(p&~p)) assumption ad absurdum. L(Mp &...
It appears to me that no two things can ever be identical, yet the notion that they can has been deployed rather without pause about a billion times in theoretical literature in philosophy and mathematics. FYI: I'm trained in Science and Technology Studies in case that helps to clarify my confusion. Question: What sor...
Are there any theories of moral responsibility that don't require free will? Sam Harris rejects the notion of free will and attempts to construct some form of moral calculus, but "The Moral Landscape" didn't sound very convincing to me exactly because the notion of responsibility wasn't there, it was all about optimiza...
Whether you ultimately agree with it or not, I feel that a study of modal logic, including David Lewis's (and others') notion of possible words is a valuable facet of a proper understanding of logic and metaphysics. However when I attempt to explain necessary truths (where one cannot imagine a world in which they woul...
Provided that humanity has addressed this issue with rationality and assuming it's been given enough time, there should be an answer to the following questions: Why do most people choose to believe in unnatural powers and divinity? Are spiritual people rising or decreasing in number with time? Is this explained by some...
Does the revolution of the earth bother us in our day-to-day activities? If yes, how? If not, then why do we teach and study these thing? Isn't it right that we have to study only those things that are relevant for our survival?
There's been much ado about the divisiveness between Heidegger and Husserl fans on the one side, with Frege and Russell stalwarts on the other. I'm mostly amused by accounts of name-calling between Derrida and Searle. With regards to the C/A divide itself, there remains all too much disagreement about what the disagree...
Probably the most cliche question ever, but I never got a good answer so I'll ask it anyway: How can science and theism co-exist? Even if we forget that the two have entirely different ideas about how the universe was created, theism says that everything is determined by god, while science claims that everything can be...
Everyone seems to think that everything was better back when they were doing it, and now everything is much worse. It's mostly not true, when it comes down to facts, yet people never say that things are better now then they where before (unless they come from poverty or were in a war), why? PS I am generalizing when sa...
After mentioning Kierkegaard's leveling and mathematical equality concepts, this passage is quoted: The individual no longer belongs to God, to himself, to his beloved, to his art or to his science; he is conscious of belonging in all things to an abstraction to which he is subjected by reflection. (emphasis mine) Wh...
Is there a good survey article for lay readers (imagine an intelligent secondary-school pupil who may later do graduate work in philosophy but doesn't yet know much) of the philosophical difficulties attending the problem of induction, and the positions that philosophers have taken on it?
Is there a particular reason why Nietzsche chose the word genealogy as opposed to history for his book 'the genealogy of morality'? Is it simply Nietsche literary style or is their a deeper reason?
I do not mean that there are philosophical positions on the theory of mind (as there most certainly are), but that philosophising must be part of the theory of mind, with a natural 'osmotic' unwilled component (which would have a genealogical willed process), and a willed component. How far one takes that willed compon...
Agrippas trilemma states that formal systems are either self-circular, infinitely regressive or axiomatic. Its commonly taken that mathematics is axiomatic. However just as mathematicians can build ever more elaborate structures, they can painstakingly dig-down into foundations. Does this mean that mathematics is actu...
After Cantor, mathematicians realised that infinities can be graded by size (cardinalities). But just as we view the naive infinite as bigger than any finite number, is there an 'infinite' greater than any infinite? But then the same pattern can carry on, in which case we are actually no nearer the absolute infinite t...
My knowledge of philosophy is probably only a bit greater than an average person's. I am a trained mathematician so I have the basic knowledge of mathematical logic. I know more or less what modal logic is, but I definitely don't know much about it. I find these interesting. I think I also understand what ethics, esthe...